!

"#$%

&'()*+, &')#-
«!" #"$ %&'()*$ + ,-./012 *1 3/)45,
4. '.*$ 6 *1 %&'()*$ +.'3&2»:
31"3 %. 7-89: ' :";$<*35"&6 4;$%)0&<
(%. /.34$*.'") /;.9-12))

! "#$%&'()#*+ ,$%-./*+'*+ #"0),"$* (12$3"4%0.(5 -4* $*6'* *,

5# 4.-%7,)(5, 46%7324.#089'* :$2;$%3. «:$%4.0)'2&» -2<08='2&
(,%,>42& :24>-*'#. -*49%, (?02:/*4 /* 4.32;. ,%# #%,>;2$.9'2 '>
,2$#%0.(5). @ 2-'2;2 =2#", -*49.'" 4.?24"8,) 4 :%,$*%$?%0)'23"
-"(*, 4.3%;%8,) :2#*$'2(,*, (#$23'2(,*, 6=>$>A>''5 /'2,., B2
6%64.9%+ :>$>-%7,)(5 3>,%12$%3. «9.(,2,.», «'>6%+3%'2(,*», «'>-
:29%,2(,*», «#$%(2,.». @ *'<2;2 A =2#" – =%,)#%3. :*-,$.3"7,)(5
* 6%2?29"7,)(5 (:*0)'> -*49%, 6 :%$"=#%3. (:%''5 * -2:"(#%7,)(5
(%32(,*+'*(,) " 4.=2$* :%$,'>$% -05 (:*0)'2& '29*40*.
C20*6*5 29>4.-'%. D 4>(*0)'23" 2=$5-* «#232$.» /'2,% -*49.'.
="0% 2=’7#,23 :$.(#*:0.42& :>$>4*$#.. E# 4*-232, :*- 9%( <08='2&
'29*, 5#B2 3202-.+ 6 5#.?2() :$.9.' '> (:$%4054(5 6 6%-%9>8,
(«9>$>6 B2-'>="-) '> 4,'> «6$2=.,. #%0.'.» 3202-*+»), (:$%4%
2-'%#242 -242-.0%(5 -2 #*'/5 – %=2 -$FA#23, %=2, 4 :*6'*<.? 4%-
$*%',%?, ->102$%/*8 6-*+('84%0% (4%<#% [G.,4.'24%-H%$,2<
1900:93], – 1%#, «9>('2(,*» 9. «'>9>('2(,*» -*49.'. 3%4 =",.
2=24’56#242 :>$>4*$>'.3 (:$2 «9>('*(,)» :%$"=#% 324% '> +<0%).
I0*-. «'>4.''2(,*» '> :$2(,2 2=24’56#242 3%0. =",. :"=0*9'2
6%(4*-9>'*, %0> ,%#2A %'%0*6"4%0.(5 (:>/*%0*(,#%3. '% :$>-3>,
'>:*-$2=0>'2(,*: =$%0.(5 -2 "4%;. #20*$ (9. '> ="$5#24.+ (*#?),
#*0)#*(,) (*'#20. 9>$>6 '>6'%''5 -*49.'%, :*-$2=0589. (0*-., 4.-
0.4%0% '% (2$29#" '%-3*$ #"$592& #$24*), 3*(/> :053 ,2B2.
J%623 6 ,%#.3 4*-:24*-%0)'.3, $>,>0)'.3 (,%40>''53 -2 /'2-
,., 4 ,.? (%3.? 02#%0)'.? ,$%-./*5? ,2;2 A :>$*2-" *('"4%02 +

73
 «., -,' /#0*+1' 2 345678" 18 $6+%9, %5 051' : 18 /#0*+1' 250$#"»

*'<> "540>''5 :$2 :$.:"(,.3* -2<08='* 46%73.'.. !*-:24*--

'2 -2 '.? -*49.'% 32;0% * '%4*,) :24.''% ="0% (:%,. 6 :%$"=-
#23: «K2$2<% -*49.'%, 42'% *6 ?02:/53. (:.,. C20.(), 5# *6
?02:/53. '> (:%0% -*49.'%, ,2 + '> (9.,%02(5, B2 ,2 42'% + -*4-
9.'%», – ,%# (12$3"084%0% 6%#2'. (427& 3202-2(,* (5#.? " (4*+
9%( -2,$.3"4%0%(5) '%<% 90-$*9'% $>(:2'->',#% 6 L20,%4B.'.
[L0J><LB].
M", 3. $26;05'>32 :$%4.0%, 5#* $>;"084%0. -2<08='* *',.3'*
46%73.'. 4 "#$%&'()#23" (>0* '% $"=>A* KNK–KK (,20*,).
@4.9%74* '2$3. :$%#,.9'2 "(*? %$>%0*4 D#$%&'. -2:"(#%0.
:>4'.+ *',.3'.+ -2(4*- -2 <08=". @ :>4'2;2 4*#" 3202-) 4?2-.0%
4 -*429* + :%$"=29* ;$23%-.. !(,": " ,%#" ;$23%-" 6%;%023 26'%9%4
* -264*0 '% (:*0)'> (:%''5, «4 ->5#.? (>0%? :%$"=2# 6 :>$<.? A>
-'*4 (42;2 :$.+23" 4 «;$23%-"» (,24%$.(,42 :%$"=#*4) 6%42-.4
(2=* «;"05#"» %=2 «'29"4%#"» [E(,$>=24 1896:120].
!6.3#" 3202-* 08-. (:%0. 4 ?%,*, -> 4*-="4%0.(5 4>92$'./*:
O2-.' -2 ->(5,., -2 -4%'%-/5,. :2:$5-",). M2-* 4'2(5,)
(2023. 4 ?%,". P-*50 ,2-* '> ="02, % $5-'% ,#%'*. L$2(,>058,)
$5-'2. L2#2,23 (,>05,)(5 + 05;%8,) 2-'> #202 2-'2;2, ?02:>/)
6 -*49.'28. K,2 #23" :2'$%4.,)(5. L2(.0%8,), B2= (:.,%4, 9.
(2;0%('% 42'%, B2= :$.+,. :>$>'29"4%,.. Q '> (?2,*0% 42'%, ,2 +
'*92;2 [L0R.#H0].
R*49%, :$.+-",) (*3-4*(*3..., <.8,)-4.<.4%8,), % :%$"=#.
,%3 (2=* ,2-()2. S.8,) -2 -4%'%-/5,.. M2-* 05;%8,) (:%,. " /*+
?%,* – (2023. '%(,>0.0., B2() :$2(,>0.0. * :2#2,23 4(* (:05,).
T> 5# ?,2, ,2 6 :%$"=#23 -2(:.,)(5. U> ="02 (2$23" – 5#.+ (2$23.
M%# ="02 6%4>->'2 [L0R.#U0=].
L2-*='* :%$"4%''5 '> 62=24’56"4%0. -2 <08="; 5# (,4>$-A"7
E(,$>=24, :%$. 0>;#2 $26?2-.0.(5, «:*(05 92;2 * :%$"=2#, * -*49.'%
6%42-.0. '242;2 -$";% (>$/5, ... -*49.'* -242-.02() -"A> 9%(,2
4.(0"?24"4%,. :$2?%''5 :%$"=#*4 '29"4%,. 6 '>8» [E(,$>=24
1896:120].
D 20-,* $2#. KK (,20*,,5 :$%#,.#% -2<08='2;2 (:%''5 :29%0%
6'.#%,. ($%623 6 *'(,.,",23 4>92$'./)). V #*0)#% :2<.$>'.? ?.=-
'.? "540>') :$2 &? :$%4.0% * 63*(,.
=.2)-"$ 1. I:*0)'> (:%''5 3202-* ="02 4.3"<>'.3, (.,"%,.4-
'.3 (=2 4'29*, :*(05 :$5-*''5, 4%A#2 ="02 -*(,%,.(5 -23*42#), %
'%(:$%4-* -*49%,% 4(*05#2 "'.#%0. /)2;2.
74
 &'()*+, &')#-

! ,>:0* :2$. $2#", #20. '% 4>92$'./* + -2(4*,#. '> 6=.$%0.(5

(/> 6.324* 6*=$%''5), -*49%,% :$2-24A"4%0. (:%,. 6 ?02:/53., -05
/)2;2 42'. (,%$%0%(5 '29"4%,. '> 4 ?%,*, % '%-42$*, %=. ="02 6$"9'2
«:$.+3%,.» ?02:/5:
M*0)#. ;$*3 6%;$.3*4 4>('28 – 4A> #2A'% '% -42$* (:.,).
U> '% -42$*, % 4 (%$%& 9.... N ?02:/* :$.?2-.0., &3 ;"05,., B2
5#% &3 $*6'./5. E ;%6>," 9%(23 -.408(5 – (,*0)#. ?42$2= ,>:>$!
[L0R.#H0].
Q -*49%,% – 9. 4 :2;$*='.#", 9. 4 (%$%+9.#" :$.32(,#"
6$2=.,). ... Q $%')<> ="02 ;"050. ?02:/*, (:%0. 6 -*49%,%3., '2 '>
6%+3%0.. E# =%,)#. '> $26$*<%, -*49.'* 6 ?02:/53. (:%,., ,2 42'%
4 ?%,* (:.,) [L0J><LB].
H"0% ,%#2A ,$%-./*5 '29"4%,. «4 ?202-'*+ ?%,*», 9%(,2 :2
#*0)#% :%$ $%623 :$.?2-.0. '% '29*408 4 2-'" :2$2A'8 ('>A.0",
?202-'") ?%,". M%#.+ 4.- '29*40* $*6#2 :*-4.B"4%4 32A0.4* $.6.#.,
2-'%9> ,%#2A '> 6%=2$2'54(5 =%,)#%3.:
K202-'% ?%,% 7. D 32&? =%,)#*4 ="0% ?%,%. ! 2-'*+ 42'. A.0.,
% 4 -$";*+ 5. I:%0% 6 ?02:/53., ;"050%, -"A> ;"050% 6 ?02:/>3
4*- (42&? =%,)#*4. R"A>, '" :29.,"4%0. * =%,)#. 3>'>, * 5 (42&?
=%,)#*4. W> ,%# ="02 #20.(). Q ,>:>$, 32& -*,#., 5#=. -*49.'%
05;0%... H"4%02 ,%#>, 2-'% -*49.'#% A.0% -23%, '" '*5# 6 ?02:/>3
(:%,.. M2 -2 3>'> +->, ,2 B> -2 5#2&() :2-$";., * ?02:/5 [4>->].
P-'*+ -*49.'/* ="02 ,%#>: '" '*5# 6 ?02:/>3 :>$>(:%,.. Q 3>'>
64",) X%$1%, ,2 42'% * #%A>:
– X%$1%, 4 ,>=> '*-> 6 ?02:/>3 05;,.?
– Q 92;2 A ,%3, – #%A", – '*->! D 3>'> 4A> 2-'% (:.,) ->(5,)
3*(5/*4. N 5 (:08, * 42'% (:.,).
N ,$>,5 :$.+<0% -2 3>'> (:%,. 6 (42&3 ?02:/>3. Q 5# '> (:.,)
*6 ?02:/>3, ,2 + '> B.,%0., B2 42'% * -*49.'%. C%A",), '> 08=>
'*?,2 [L0J><LB].
!,*3, '> " 4(*? 4.:%-#%? (:*0)'> (:%''5 ="02 -2=$24*0)'.3.
M%#, ?02:/* 3%0. :$%42 «";2B%,.» -*49%,%3. (42&? ,24%$.<*4 6
("(*-'*? (*0. W> 4?2-.02 4 :$%4.0% 44*90.42(,* * 4.$%6" :$.56'* -2
:%$"=292& ;$23%-. ("(*-')2;2 (>0%:
E# '%-"3%0. 5#2;2() ?02:/5 2(,%4.,. [6 *'<2;2 (>0%] – 2/>
05;%+ *6 '.3. Y. ,. 08=.< +2;2, ?2,) '> 08=.<, % 05;%+ (:%,..

75
 «., -,' /#0*+1' 2 345678" 18 $6+%9, %5 051' : 18 /#0*+1' 250$#"»

– Q 2,#%6%,)(5 '> 32A'% ="02?

– U> 32A'%, ?02:/* 6%(,%4058,), (42&» [L0R.#Q'-].
=.2)-"$ 2. W> ="0. ,%73'*, '>-26420>'* (,2("'#. ?02:/*4
* -*49%,. H%,)#. 6%=2$2'50. (:*0)'> (:%''5, :>$>(0*-"4%0. 3202-.?
08->+.
R2(0*-'.#., B2 6%+3%0.(5 4.49>''53 *'(,.,"," -2<08='2;2
(:%''5 (!. E(,$>=24, X. I"3/24, !. H2$A#24()#.+), 5# :$%4.02,
6%6'%9%0., B2 -2$2(0* :*-,$.3"8,) * 6%2?29"8,) :2-*='* 6"(,$*9*.
W> '> ="02 ,%73'./>8 -05 =%,)#*4:
– Q =%,)#. '> 0%50.(5?
– H2A> (2?$%'.! X2-% ,%#% ="0%, 92;2 = A> 42'. 0%50.()!
[L0J><LB].
T> 4 KNK (,20*,,* H2$A#24()#.+ 64>$'"4 "4%;", B2 «(>05'. '>
3%8,) '*92;2 :$2,. [4>92$'./) * 4"0./*], *'#20. =%,)#2 -%7 (.'"
-05 4>92$'./) ;$2<*, % 3%,. -2')/* -05 /)2;2 A (.$, 5+/5, 3"#"
,2B2» [H2$A#24()#.+ 1887:775]. Q !. E(,$>=24 6%"4%A"4%4, B2
«6%64.9%+ =%,)#. '> =2$2'5,) (42&3 -29#%3 (:%,. 6 ?02:/53.: 42'.
$26;05-%8,) /> 5# 64.9%+'" $*9, 5#% A2-'.3 9.'23 '> ;%')=.,)
-*49.'"...» [E(,$>=24 1997 (1896):124].
! ,>#(,%? :$2:24*->+ -05 (*0)()#.? :%(,.$*4 #*'/5 KNK (,20*,,5
7 64>$'>''5 -2 =%,)#*4 6 6%#0.#23 6%=2$2'5,. (:*0)'> (:%''5;
29>4.-'2, B> 4 KNK (,20*,,* =%,)#. (,%4.0.(5 -2 /)2;2 '> ,%#, %=2
'> ,%# #%,>;2$.9'2, 5# 4.3%;%4 />$#24'.+ #%'2':
U2 2,#"-% '29'Z5 (=2$.B% '%<>+ 3202->A.? P,#"-% :*('.
:2 '29%3 . $%6'Z5 ;$*?24'Z5 =>69.'(,4%? [ 4(> \,2 =Z4%>, '>
,20)#2 4 2=Z#'24>''2> 4$>35 ;2-%, '2 -%A> 42 (45,2+ !>0.#*+
:2(,! <...> P,/Z . 3%,>$.! !Z 2,4>,(,4>''Z :>$>- H2;23 6% -*,>+
4%<.?, . 6% 3%0Z?, . 6% 46$2(0Z?, % :2,23" (0>-*,> 6% ->,)3. .
'> :264205+,> .3 :262$.,) (>=5 $%6'Z3. '29'Z3. =>69.'(,4%3.
;$>?24'Z3.» [L$2:24>-. 1897:10].

R%0* 4 ,>#(,* '%;202<"7,)(5, B2 =%,)#. 4*-:24*-%8,) :>$>-

H2;23 * 6% -2$2(0.? -*,>+, 5#* 4*-4*-"8,) 4>92$'./*.
W*#%4.3. 7 :24*-230>''5 08->+, 8'*(,) 5#.? :$.:%0% '% 20-,*
$2#., '% $%''*+ $%-5'()#.+ :>$*2-, #20. ,$%-./*+'% 32$%0) 42-'29%(
* -2642050% (:*0)'> (:%''5, * :29%(,. 2("-A"4%0%. X2A0.42, ,2-*
4.$2=.4(5 :>4'.+ «3*1», 5#.+ 3%4 :27-'%,., "6;2-.,. -264*0 * 6%-

76
 &'()*+, &')#-

=2$2'". ]*'#%, 5#% 4 8'2(,* =0.6)#2 $2#" '29"4%0% 4 «?202-'*+

?%,*» 6* (42&3 :%$"=#23, 2:24*-%7:
V, B2 =%,)#. ->$A%,), 5# #2'5#", '% 4*A#%?. X>'> '> ->$A%0.
'*5#. P, (#%6%0. 3>'* ,%,2 + 3%3%, 5# ?%$2<% ,. ="-><, ,2 ->$A%,)
,>=> '% 4*A#%? '> '%-%, % 5# ;*3'2, ,2 ;*3'2 ?2,) * '% 4*A#%? ->$A.,
;*3'23 * 2(,%'>,)(5 [L0J><LB].
N'<.+ 4.:%-2#:
! 2-'2;2 ="0% /5 -*49.'% [:2#$.,#%]. M2 =%,)#2 & ->$A%4, 5#
'% 4*$)24/*, '*#"-. '> :"(#%4, 2/> ->$A%4. M2 42'% 5# :$.4>0% /8
-.,.'"... P =2A>!... S2 ,*0)#. '> $2=.02()... O2(:2-., :$2(,.
3>'> ;$*<'"!... S2 6;%-%0%... H.0. * <2 ?29... M2 ,%3 =%,)#2
->$A%4 5# '% 4*$)24/*. Q 3. [6 (>(,$28] ?2-.0. 5# :$20*,%$’5,..
U*92;2... E# 3%3% '% '%( #$.9.,), % =%,)#2 #%A>: «S2, ,. &+ $"#28
6%,"0.<? E# 42'% '> 43*7 (>=> 4>(,., ,%# 42'% 6$2=.,)». M%# * 4()2
[R2'I04M%,].
=.2)-"$ 3. L*- 9%( (:*0)'2;2 (:%''5 (,%,>42;2 %#," '> ="02.
W> 2-'> 6 '%+-.(#",.4'*<.? :.,%'). @%64.9%+ 49>'*, B2
4*-(,288,) ;*:2,>6" :$2 4*-(",'*(,) (,%,>42;2 -2(4*-" 4 3202-*
"#$%&'()#2;2 ,$%-./*+'2;2 (>0%, :2;2-A"8,)(5, B2 3202-) ,%#.
«$%623 (:.,)», %0> '> =*0)<>, «:$2(,2 (:.,)». U%4$5- 9. /> (4*-9.,)
:$2 «'>>$2,.9'*(,)» (:*0)'.? '29*4>0), 4*-(",'*(,) (>#("%0)'2&
#23:2'>',. '%4*,) 6% 4*-(",'2(,* (%32;2 (,%,>42;2 %#,". I%3%
0>#(.#%, '%$2-'% 3>,%12$.#% :>$>-%4%0% (>#("%0)'*(,) :2-*='2&
:24>-*'#.. U%:$.#0%-: «E#B2 -*49.'% :$.+'50% :$2:26./*8,
,2 :$2 :%$"=#% ;242$.0., B2 «+23" 4*- '>& ="0% 32#$%», % 5#B2
4*-324.0%, ,2 «("?%», '%:$.#0%-: «G>4#24* ="0% 2- O2$:.'. ("?%»
[E(,$>=24 1896:120].
M*0)#. 5#B2 (:>#,$ 08-()#2& (>#("%0)'2(,* 642-.,)(5 -2
$>:$2-"#,.4'.? ,>?'*#, :2-*='% (:*0)'% '29*405 44%A%7,)(5
«=>6'>4.''28».
U>64%A%89. '% 9.(0>''* ,4>$-A>''5, B2 3202-* 08-. ,*0)#.
:2$5- 0>A%,), *('"7 ,%#2A #2$:"( ,>#(,*4, B2 (4*-9%,) :$2 *'<>.
M$.4%0* 46%73.'. :$.42-.0. -2 =*0)<2;2 1*6.9'2;2 6=0.A>''5
3202-.? 08->+. «C2$.(,"89.() :23*9>'28 :$.4’56%'*(,8 -*49.'.,
:%$"=2# -2=.4%7,)(5 B> =*0)<2;2 6=0.A>''5, 2B":"7 && ;$"-. *
(,%,>4.+ 2$;%' * '%$><,* «:2087»: ,%# '%6.4%7,)(5 2(2=0.4.+
(:2(*= (,%,>42;2 %#," =>6 :26=%40>''5 '>4.''2(,*» [E(,$>=24
1997 (1896):121] (32A0.42 (0242 «654;(» :24’56%'> 6 0%,. polluo
«3.324*0)'> 4.#.-%''5 (*3’5»).
77
 «., -,' /#0*+1' 2 345678" 18 $6+%9, %5 051' : 18 /#0*+1' 250$#"»

U% C.&4B.'* ,%#.+ -2<08='.+ (>#( '%6.4%4(5 *'%#<>,

«:$.,"0%»:
!*' 4.0%6.,) '% '>& * (,"088,) ,2-* 42'. A.42,. 6 A.42,%3.
* -"A9> = B2 $2=.0., ,% + ,>, + -$";>, =25,)(5 (0%4.. <...>
=*0)< '*92;2 * '> $2=05,), % ,*#2 ;$%8,)(5, "(> 4*' 6->$A"7,)(5,
B2= '> :$2=.,) ,%#., % ,*#2 ,$2<>9#. ,%# (2=* 4329.,) " '>&, *
:02,) 5# (?2-.,) 6 +2;2, '> 4:"(#%,) " '>&, =2 * /> "A> 6'%8,)»
[X$. O<$"<>4()#.+> 1906:97].
X%$#2 O$"<>4()#.+ ,%#2A 6%6'%9.4, B2 «:$.,"0% $*6'.?
(2$,*4 7», * 2:.("7, 5# «:$.,"0% -%4%0%(5» [X$. O<$"<>4()#.+>
1906:100–101]. L26./*5 63*'84%0%(5 '% =*0)< 6$"9'" -05 :%$"=#%
* '>=>6:>9'" -05 -*49.'., 6%0>A'2 4*- ,$.4%02(,* 64’56#" * -24*$.
3*A 3202-.3. 08-)3..
@%;%023, :.<> X%$#2 O$"<>4()#.+, 4*-32405,. 4 :$.,"0* :%-
$"=#. 44%A%0. «:2;%'.3 ,2'23»: «Q :$.,"0% ,%# 5# -*02 2=.#'2-
4>''> * '%+:$2(,*<>. N ,2 4A> 5# =. '> ="02, ,2 :$.,"0. :24.''%
-*4#% =>6 32$2#. -%4%,) <...> H2 5# ,%# ?2-.,) '29"4%,), B2= * :$.-
,"0. '> -%4%,), ,2 ?02:/* ="-",) /"$%,)(5» [X$. O<$"<>4()#.+>
1906:100–101].
K29 6%4%;*,'*,. -*49.'28 ="02 4>0.#28 ,$%;>-*78, ,%#* 4.:%-#.
,$%:050.(5, * /> ,%#2A :*-,4>$-A"7 '%54'*(,) (>#("%0)'.? :$%#,.#
:*- 9%( (:*0)'2;2 (:%''5: «I#*0)#2 ?29 ="02, <2 -*49.'% (2=* '%
-2(4*,#%? -.,.'#" '%;"050%» [L0S.<C4]; «N -*,2#, ="4%02, '%
-2(4*,#%? -2="4%0.. ... L$.,"0.4() ->() $%6292#, * 42'2 + :$.,"-
0.02()» [L0X.$@C]1.
P=$5- «#232$.», (?2A>, (0*- $26;05-%,. 5# (:2(*= :>$>4*$#.,
'%(#*0)#. -*49.'% (:$%4.0%(5 6 /.3. :$2,.$*9'.3. (2/*%0)'.3.
:$2;$%3%3..
=.2)-"$ 4. !4%A%7,)(5, B2 :2-*='* ,$%-./*& ="0. ?%$%#,>$'*
-05 2#$>3.? $>;*2'*4 D#$%&'..
U%(:$%4-* ,$%-./*5 (.(,>3'2 '> -2(0*-A"4%0%(5 [I%49>'#2
1926]. H*0)<> 6%:.(*4 7 6 W>',$%0)'2& * I?*-'2& D#$%&'., $*-<>
* =*0)< 0%#2'*9'* 6 L$%42=>$>AA5, 5# 2,: «U29*405 :%$"=#*4 6 -*4-
9%,%3. *('"7. U% 4>92$'./5? 9. -2(4*,#%? 6 -$";.? (*0 ="4%8,)
,>A :%$"=#. '% '29*408» [@-.?*4()#.+ 1930:81]. !,*3, 6%?*-'2-
"#$%&'()#%, #%$:%,()#% ,$%-./*5 -2<08='2;2 (:*0#"4%''5 3202-*
3%=",) ,%#. 4*-$*6'50%(5. @%:.(., '%:$.#0%-, 1*#("8,) *'<", '*A
32A'% (:2-*4%,.(5, :24>-*'#":
78
 &'()*+, &')#-

M%3, -> 7 -*4#., % <> -2 ,.? -*42# :$.?2-7 ("(*-#.--*4#. (6'%8,,

<2 ,%3 3%8, 4>9>$'./* =",.). U% :$5-*'* :$.+-",, 6 #"->053....
Q :2,23" :2:$7-", ,% + ?02:/* =>$", -*42# :>$>4>$,%8,. M%
+ ;$%8, (. '% :2(,>0.. @%;2078, -*42#. L>$(,>'* 4*-=.$%8,.
C2,$.+ '. 32A>, <2 ,";2 – 4.' +3> :%0>/ " $2, – ,%#. (,7;'>.
M%+ <#*$" (,7;'>, 7# (?29>, % 3"(., :>$(,>') 4.-2+3.,.. M%+ ,%#.
-*4#" :>$>4>$'> (,$"(*4 '. ="02 ,2;-.), #%A>: «E ?29" 4 ,>=> 2–3
4202(#. 43.#%,....» K02:/* 4?2:’7 -*42# 4.- ,2& #"->0* – #"->0* (.
:2:%$<.4.,... !>$A> [-*4#"] '% :2(,*0), '%#29%7(., '%#"(%7(. 7+,
'%/*087(. ,% + :"(,.,...M% + -%0* :$*-> [C*() 1970:%$#.15].

***
! 1929 $2/* 4 J%-5'()#*+ D#$%&'* ="02 6-*+('>'> (2/*202;*9'>
2:.,"4%''5, 5#> 4.49%02 :$%#,.#. * '2$3. (,%,>42;2 A.,,5
"#$%&'()#.? (>05'. P:.,"4%''5 :$242-.02(5 4 30-,. $%+2'%?
(?0*=2$2=()#.? #20;2(:'.? 2#$";%?) J%-5'()#2& D#$%&'.. @;*-'2 6
2,$.3%'.3. $>6"0),%,%3., 27,1% 2:.,%'.? A*'2#, 5#* 2-$"A.0.(5
" 4*/* 15–19 $2#*4, :29%0. (427 (,%,>4> A.,,5 -2 2-$"A>''5, % (>$>-
,.?, ?,2 2-$"A.4(5 4 25–33 $2#., />+ 4*-(2,2# (5;%7 :2#%6'.#%
42,6% (4*-(2,2# 2:.,%'.? -*49%,, B2 A.0. 4A> (,%,>4.3 A.,,53
'% 9%( 2:.,"4%''5, '%=%;%,2 4.B.+ – 71,2% – :25('87,)(5 ,.3,
B2 %'#>,"4%''5 :$242-.02(5 (*0)()#.3. 0*#%$53., * 4.=*$#%, 4*--
,%#, 12$3"4%0%(5 '% 2('24* :%/*7',*4 ;*'>#202;*9'2;2 4*--*0>'-
'5) [O"$>4.9, !2$2A=., 1931:38]. M%#.3 9.'23, <08= * :2-
9%,2# (,%,>42;2 A.,,5 '> 6=*;%0.(5. Q'#>,% ,%#2A '%/*0>'% ="0%
'% 4.540>''5 6%0>A'2(,* -2<08='2;2 (,%,>42;2 -2(4*-" 4*-
4*-4*-"4%''5 4>92$'./) ,% -2(4*,2#. E# :2#%6%0. $>6"0),%,., (>$>-
,.?, ?,2 ?2-.4 '% -2(4*,#., :29.'%0. (,%,>4> A.,,5 -2 <08="
45,6%, % (>$>- ,.?, ?,2 '> ?2-.0. '% -2(4*,#. – ,*0)#. 23,8%, (>=,2
3%+A> "-4*9* 3>'<> [O"$>4.9, !2$2A=., 1931:46]. M%#.3 9.'23,
4.?2-.,), B2 :$.'%+3'* " 20-,* $2#. -2(4*,#. * 4>92$'./* ="0. "
:>4'23" (>'(* «:$242#"89.3» 1%#,2$23 -05 :29%,#" (,%,>42;2
A.,,5, % -2,$.3%''5 ,$%-./*+'2;2 "#0%-" :*-42-.02 -2 -2<08='2;2
(>#("%0)'2;2 ->=8,". J%623 6 ,.3 (%3* '2(*& #"0),"$. '> =%9.0.
6%0>A'2(,* 3*A 4>92$'./53. * '%54'*(,8 -2<08='.? -*,>+: «U%
6=*0)<>''5 2(,%''*3 9%(23 #*0)#2(,* '>6%#2''2'%$2-A>'.? -*,>+
4:0.4%8,) =%;%,2 *'<.? :$.9.', (>05'. A 624(*3 '> (,%405,) &?
4 6%0>A'*(,) 4*- 4>92$'./). U% 327 :.,%''5 :$2 /> 2-.' (>05'.'
4*-:24*4: «N -%4'2 ,> ="02, 5# * ,>:>$; 6%42-. * 4>9>$'./* 5#=. '* :$.
923"» [H2$A#24()#.+ 1887:775].
79
 «., -,' /#0*+1' 2 345678" 18 $6+%9, %5 051' : 18 /#0*+1' 250$#"»

!>92$'./* ="0. :*- =>6:>$>$4'.3 :$./*023 />$#4., 6 ,29#.

62$" 5#2&, :$.$2-'2, /* 6*=$%''5 3202-* 44%A%0.(5 2(>$>-#23 '>?$.-
(,.5'()#2& 32$%0*. ! -$";*+ :2024.'* KNK (,20*,,5 4 #'.;26=*$'*
2-'2& 6 (*0)()#.? />$#24 L20,%4()#2& ;"=>$'*& ="4 6'%+->'.+
"#%6 C.&4()#2& -"?24'2& #2'(.(,2$*& 1719 $2#". ! ')23", 62#$>3%,
+<02(5 :$2 6%=2$2'" 4>92$'./), =2 ,%3 «-.,Z :2 '29%3 #":%3.
(2=.$%89.(5, '>.(:24>-.3Z5 =>69.'.5 . 3>$6#.5 =>66%#2'.5
,42$5,, (:$%4"89. (>=> .;$Z, ,%'/Z . 4(5#.> :.5,.?. (#4>$'%5...,
' 1':6'*88 65/ *'$ %',+3 18*8$%+0<3 $=5)50 )'21<8 /84';%$-
8,$78$$', -,5 %5 =4>/+8 ?)83+, /80$%0' )'$%481+8, =822',51158
/8%8: 6)+@+%+8» (4.-*0>''5 327 – &. &.) [X%$#>4.9 1885:178].
L.,%''5, 923" 4 ,$%-./*& ,%# -24;2, 4:$.,"0 -2 20-.? $2#*4,
% :2->#"-. + -24<>, *('"4%0% ,%#% :$242#%,.4'% 12$3% -2<08='.?
(,2("'#*4 3*A 3202--8, -2,>:>$ '> $264’56%'>. R>5#* ;*:2,>6.
="-"4%0.(5 '%4#202 :.,%''5, 64*-#. 4.'.# />+ *'(,.,",. X. I"3-
/24 44%A%4, B2 -2(4*,#. 7 12$328 :$2='2;2 <08=" [I"3/24
1886], ^. !24# 4 4>92$'./5? 4=%9%4 :>$>A.,2# #23"'%0)'2;2
((>=,2 #20>#,.4'2;2) <08=", 5#23" '% 63*'" :$.+<24 <08= *'-.-
4*-"%0)'.+. P=.-4% :$.:"B>''5 '> 2,$.3%0. 6;2-23 %'* $264.,#",
%'* :*-,4>$-A>''5. !. H%0"<2# 44%A%7 (:*0)'> (:%''5 «:>$>A.,#23
4*0)'2;2 (,%,>42;2 (:*0#"4%''5 3202-*» [H%0"<2# 1998:104]. M$>=%
;%-%,., 4 %$?%&9'*+ #"0),"$* (>#("%0)'% (1>$% ="0% 2$;%'*624%'% 4
(:2(*= *'<.+, '*A ("9%('%, *, (?2A>, *'(,.,", -2<08='2;2 (:%''5
="4 4*-;202(#23 /.? *'<.? :$.:.(*4 * '2$3. R2(0*-A>''5 :2-*='.?
$>%0*+ 7 4%A0.4.3 -05 $26"3*''5 2$;%'*6%/*& ,$%-./*+'2;2 ("(-
:*0)(,4% ,% *'<.? %(:>#,*4 +2;2 1"'#/*2'"4%''5.
>".;.(1**#
(/.-5.'& +$/)3) $'4.;")
1997–2004 ;."&'):
R2'I04P0 – R2'>/)#% 2=0%(,), I024’5'()#.+ $%+2', (>02 P0>#(%'--
$*4#%.
R2'I04M%, – R2'>/)#% 2=0., I024’5'()#.+ $-'., (>02 M%,)5'*4#%.
L0R.#Q'- – L20,%4()#% 2=0%(,), R.#%')()#.+ $%+2', (>02 Q'-$.#..
L0R.#H0 – L20,%4()#% 2=0%(,), R.#%')()#.+ $%+2', (>02 H%05('>.
L0R.#U0= – L20,%4()#% 2=0%(,), R.#%')()#.+ $%+2', (>02 U>08-
=*4#%.
L0J><LB – L20,%4()#% 2=0%(,), J><>,.0*4()#.+ $%+2', (>02 L*B%'>.
L0S.<C4 – L20,%4()#% 2=0%(,), S.<%/)#.+ $%+2', (>02 C24%0*4#%.
80
 &'()*+, &')#-

A'4>B5, 1998 – H%0"<2# !. P=$5-. *'*/*%/*+ "#$%&'/*4 ,% -%4'*? (02-

4’5'. – G)4*4 – U)8–_2$#, 1998. – 215 (.
A5)@,50$,+: 1887 – H2$A#24(#.+ !. «L%$"=2/,42» #%# 2(2=%5 ;$"::%
4 3%02$"((#23 (>0)(#23 2=B>(,4> // C.>4(#%5 I,%$.'%. – 1887. – Q4;"(,. –
M. KVNNN. – I. 765–776.
C>)80+*, D5)5@=+% 1931 – O"$>4.9 O. Q., !2$2A=., Q. N. I,%,>4> A.,,5
(>05'#.. – K%$#*4: X>-4.-%4, 1931. – 106 (.
E+,')#0 1900 – R.#%$*4 X. L$2;$%3% -2 6=.$%''5 4*-232(,>+ :$2 ;$2-
3%-. * 6=*$#. (*0)()#2& 3202-* (4"0./8, 4>9>$'./*, -2(4*,#. * (#0%-#.) //
X%,>$.50. -2 "#$%&'()#2-$"()#2& >,'20)2;*&. – G)4*4: UMS *3. S>49>'#%,
1900. – M. NNN. – I. 1–27.
!/+3#0$9,+: 1930 – Q$?*4 NX^`. ^. 1–7. P-. 6=. 691. @-.?*4()#.+ P. P.
!>(*005, 4*$"4%''5, ;2(:2-%$9% -*50)'*(,), :*('*, #%6#., '%$2-'.+ #%0>'-%$,
6>30>3*$(,42. @%:.(%'2 '% !*''.99.'*. – 1930.
F#$9 1970 – Q$?*4 N'(,.,"," '%$2-26'%4(,4% UQU D#$%&'.. ^2'- 1.
P:.( 2. P-. 6=. a 202–Q. Q$#. 15. `,'2;$%1*9'* 3%,>$*%0. 6 O"/"0)B.'..
@%:.(%4 J23%' C*() :*- 9%( >#(:>-./*+ 1970–1972 $2#*4. L*,.05# L%$%(#%
R3.,$*4'%. I. J*9#% (#",2# L*-=$"('.+), N4%'2-^$%'#*4()#% 2=0.
G+%0+150'-A')%5B 1900 – G.,4.'24%–H%$,2< L. E. !>(&0)'* 2=$5-. *
64.9%& " (>0& @>305'/& O0"?*4()#2;2 :24*," " Y>$'.;*4B.'* // X%,>$.50. -2
"#$%&'()#2-$"()#2& >,'20)2;*&. – G)4*4, 1900. – M. 3. – I. 70–172.
&'),80+* 1885 – X%$#>4.9 Q. X>$Z :$2,.4 4>9>$'./ . #"0%9'Z? =2>4 4
X%02$2((.. // C*>4(#%5 I,%$.'%. – 1885. – I>',5=$). – M. K. – I. 177–180.
&). C<)>B80$9,+:> 1906–1907 – X$. O. R.,.'% " 64.9%5? * 4*$"4%''5?
"#$%&'()#2;2 '%$2-". X%,>$*%0. 6 :20"-'>42& C.&4B.'.. P=$2=.4 @. C"6>05 //
X%,>$*50. -2 "#$%&'()#2-$"()#2& >,'20)2;*&. – M. VIII. – 1906. – I. 60–220;
M. IX. – 1907. – 144 (.
H)56508/+ 1897 – L$2:24>-.. L$.02A>'*> # $"#242-(,4" (>0)(#.? :%(-
,Z$>+. E'4%$), 1897. – C.>4, 1896. – 794 (.
I'0*81,5 1926 – I%49>'#2 ^. L%$"=29* ,% -*42/)#* ;$23%-. '% D#$%&'* //
L>$4*('> O$23%-5'(,42. – 1926. – !.:. 3. – I. 85–93.
I>"750 1886 – I"3/24 U. R2(4>,#. . :2(.->0#. // C.>4(#%5 I,%$.'%. –
X%$,. – a 3. – 1886. – I. 421–445.
.$%)8=50 1896 – E(,$>=24 !. U24Z> -%''Z> 2 (286%? '>A>'%,2+ 3202-
->A. '% 8;> J2((.. // C.>4(#%5 I,%$.'%. – 1896. – P#,5=$). – M. LV. – I. 110–
128.
.$%)8=50 1997 (1896) – C%$:24>/) U. G.(,"4%''5 !. E(,$>=24% *
^. !24#% // H>$>;.'5. – 1997. – Y. 1–2. – I. 110–126.
1
K29 X. I"3/24 $2=.,) '>(:2-*4%'> (:2(,>$>A>''5, B2 «" X>6>'()#23"
:24*,* '>4.''*(,) -*49.'. 624(*3 '> /*'.,)(5; '%4:%#., -*49.'%, B2 '%$2-.0%
-.,.'", <4.-<> 6'%?2-.,) (2=* 92024*#%, '*A ,%, B2 6=>$>;0% -*42/,42»
[/.,. 6%: O"$>4.9, !2$2A=., 1931:42], /> 2-'%# '> :*-4>$-A"7,)(5 3%(.423
3%,>$*%0" :$2 A2$(,2#" :2#%$" :2#$.,#..

81