Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Sriramesh Et Al. - 2013 - The Grunig Legacy To Academic Studies and Professi
Sriramesh Et Al. - 2013 - The Grunig Legacy To Academic Studies and Professi
Abstract
This chapter outlines the introduction and trajectory of the theories developed by
James Grunig and Larissa Grunig in Latin America and describes the reception and
incorporation of those innovative ideas by the researchers in the region. Today, it
is an indisputable fact that these authors have left a deep and lasting footprint on
the region’s academic sphere and professional market. From the first days of their
introduction to this part of the world, the models of practice of public relations
and the Excellence Theory have become an essential component of the research
and studies conducted in Latin American countries. The chapter details the phases
of transposition of the theoretical legacy and the personal engagement of both
authors in the process, and demonstrates that, notwithstanding the cultural dif-
ferences, their teachings have succeeded in changing the public relations approach
in this vibrant part of the world.
Key Words
environmental scanning, Excellence Theory, James Grunig, Larissa Grunig, Latin
America, public relations
Introduction
A significant part of the public relations academic world recognizes James E.
Grunig and Larissa A. Grunig as renowned scholars whose work constitutes a
reference in the practice of modern public relations.
Latin America did not “discover” James Grunig and Larissa Grunig until the
1990s; since then, however, their research and theories have boosted and renewed
The Grunigs’ Legacy in Latin America 325
FIGURE 19.1 Maria Aparecida Ferrari and Larissa A. Grunig, During the 1st Brazilian
Congress of Researchers on Organizational Communication and Public Relations—
ABRAPCORP, April, 2007
326 Maria Aparecida Ferrari
personal contact with two very considerate and always available friends, or the
countless hours of professional guidance and collaboration with the two scholars.
Perhaps the most accurate would be to accept the impossibility of dissociating the
human and the professional dimensions, as they are mutually nourishing and
complementary. The following is my personal testimonial on the legacy of James
E. Grunig and Larissa Grunig to Latin America.
This process culminated with the creation in Mexico City of the Federación
Interamericana de Asociaciones de Relaciones Públicas (FIARP) on September 26, 1960,
whose purpose was to assemble all of the national organizations “to foster the
image of the profession and to promote education in public relations through the
advancement and standardization of public relations education and practice,” as
stated in Article 5 of the institution’s bylaws.
Finally, two pioneer publications in the 1960s in the area of public relations, at
a time when the field was under the influence of American and then European
authors, are worthy of note: in 1963, Cândido Theobaldo de Souza Andrade
published Para Entender Relações Públicas (1968), and in the same year Relaciones
Públicas: fundamentos científicos y aplicaciones prácticas, by Fernando Fernández
Escalante, reached the shelves in Argentina. Additionally, in Colombia, Samper
Gnecco published Las Relaciones Públicas: ¿qué son y para qué sirven? Un análisis de
treinta casos reales, in 1963. Later on, other titles begin to appear: Francisco Flores
Bao’s Relaciones Públicas: Ciencias de la integración humana (1978) in Peru; Semillas
del Éxito, Técnicas de Relaciones Humanas y Relaciones Públicas (1985) by Jaime
Humerez Estrada in Bolivia; in Chile, Las Relaciones Públicas en Chile (1989) by
Bárbara J. Délano A.; and in Venezuela, Manual de Teorías y Técnicas Magistrales de
las Relaciones Públicas (1979) by Juan Merchán López.
plan, writing speeches, flyers or yearly activity reports, thus fulfilling their role as
“technicians” rather than “strategists.”
Starting in the 1980s, the School of Communication and Arts at the
Universidade de São Paulo, Brazil, became the pioneer in Latin America in
offering both master’s and doctoral programs in public relations. In fact, it is still
the only institution in the entire region offering the doctoral degree. This has had
a bearing on the development of a critical mass, as both programs required the
production of research and scientific projects in the area. It was only natural,
therefore, that the bibliographic production in Brazil soon developed more than
that of other countries in the region.
A review of the public relations literature in the whole of Latin America,
however, shows that only a few local authors have developed their own theories,
independent of the American and/or the European influence.
An analysis of all the titles published in all the Latin American countries in the
field reveals that most works consist simply of a re-examination of foreign litera-
ture. Most titles are actually “primers” that deal with communication techniques—
the how to do, while others are translations of works that introduce public relations
from a foreign perspective. In the latter case, a frequent practice is the introduction
of “cases” from other countries. One of the most frequently cited “cases” discussed
by the Latin American students in their courses has been and still is the crisis
experienced by Johnson & Johnson in 1982 as a result of the Tylenol incident.
This is an indication that even the examples were transposed from the foreign
reality, in the absence of research on local cases.
One of the authors who published specialized literature in the field is Roberto
Porto Simões, from Brazil, who introduced innovative public relations concepts
(1995) and defined public relations as “conflict management,” and for whom
conflict was an ever-present element in the organization, where the public relations
professional played a management role to ensure the legitimacy of the organiza-
tion’s decisions. This was quite a revolutionary concept at the time, considering
that, without exception, all literature between 1960 and 1970 had adopted the
definition formulated in the Mexico Agreement, according to which
FIGURE 19.2 James E. Grunig, Maria Aparecida Ferrari and Fábio França at the
Launch of Their Book in Portuguese. São Paulo, August 1, 2009
The Grunigs’ Legacy in Latin America 333
In Barranquilla, Colombia, in 2011, James Grunig took part in the 1st Congress
for Strategic Communication and Public Relations organized by the Universidad
del Norte. Grunig was once again the keynote speaker and was eagerly received
by all the professionals and academics attending the event.
The value of Public Relations at the societal level results from the cumu-
lative impact of what it does at the program, functional, and organizational
levels. The value of Public Relations at the societal level is the long-term
impact of good relationships identified at the organizational level and culti-
vated at the program level. As a result, research on the quality of relationships
also can be used to establish the contribution of Public Relations to society.
(Grunig, 2010, p. 96)
The Grunig legacy has without any doubt changed the course of public
relations in the region. His work has provided us with the compass that helped
orient us, professionals and academics alike, in the right direction, and his theories
have helped pave the way to achieving the organization’s objectives with sym-
metry, coherence and ethics.
Acknowledgments
In closing, I would like to express my personal gratitude for James Grunig’s
disposition to become my mentor and inspiration since the early moments of our
professional contact, and for the privilege of enjoying the friendship and
comradeship of both James and Larissa despite the geographical distance!
References
Andrade, C. R. S. (1993). Para entender Relações Públicas. São Paulo, Loyola.
Ferrari, M. A. (2000). A influência dos valores organizacionais na determinação da prática
e do papel dos profissionais de relações públicas: estudo comparativo entre organizações
do Brasil e do Chile. Doctoral thesis, São Paulo, ECA-USP.
Grunig, J. E., & Hunt, T. (1984). Managing Public Relations. New York: Holt, Rinehart &
Winston.
Grunig, J. E. (1992). Excellence in Public Relations and Communication Management. Hillsdale,
NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum.
Grunig, J. E. (2010). La investigación en las relaciones públicas: estado actual y nuevas
perspectivas. In Las nuevas Relaciones Públicas (pp. 69–111). Lima, Peru: Universidad San
Martín de Porres.
Grunig, J. E., Ferrari, M. A., & França, F. (2009). Relações Públicas: teoria, contexto e
relacionamentos. São Caetano do Sul: Difusão.
Grunig, J. E., Ferrari, M. A., & França, F. (2011), Relações Públicas: teoria, contexto e
relacionamentos. 2ª. edição revisada e ampliada. São Caetano do Sul: Difusão.
Grunig, J. E., Gorpe, S., Noguero, A., & Solórzano, E. H. (2010). Las nuevas Relaciones
Públicas. Universidad San Martín de Porres, Editorial USMP.
Grunig, J. E., & Hunt T. (1984). Managing public relations. New York: Holt, Rinehart &
Winston.
Kunsch, M. N. K. (1997). Relações Públicas e Modernidade. São Paulo: Summus.
Kunsch, M. N. K. (2011). Comunicação Organizacional e Relações Públicas: perspectivas dos
estudos Latino-Americanos. São Paulo: Revista ALAIC.
Penteado, R. (1996). Effects of public relations roles and models on Brazilian organizations
committed to quality. Master’s dissertation, University of Florida.
Simões, R. P. (1995). Relações Públicas: Função política. 3rd edn. São Paulo: Summus.