Document no.

: 0004-6605 Date: 2012-01-17

Issued by: VQM
Non Destructive Testing of Primary Steel Class: 2
Components, Tower Sections and
Type: Quality Specification Page 1 of 6
Embedment’s for Vestas Wind Turbines

VT / MT Report
VT examination Date Technician (Init.) Certificate No. Examination organization / Inspection authority
2020 Nov 27 T.N.ANH II-152 CS Wind VietNam Co., Ltd.
MT examination Date Technician (Init.) Certificate No. Client
2020 Nov 27 T.D.T.SINH II-199 Vestas Tower
Contractor Location
CS Wind VietNam Co., Ltd. Road 2B, Phu My I Industrial Zone, Phu My Ward, Phu My Town, BaRia -
VungTau Province, Vietnam
Description in text Section ID. No. Drawing No. / Rev. No.
Bottom ø6300 /15710/ ø6033 weld 328452 75933130/R0
Visual examination
Examination procedure Acceptance criteria
VN-QI-803-10-VT VN-QI-803-10-VT
Aids
Ruler Tape measure Calliper gauge Feeler gauge Weld gauge Contour gauge
Time of examination
After welding Repairs
Extent of examination Surface condition
100 % Ground Smooth Coarse Primer Coated
Remarks
All welds has been inspection 100% visual and found out accepted

Page Technician (Date (YYYY-MM-DD)/Signature)

VT acceptable 1 of 1 2020 Nov 30

Magnetic particle examination
Examination procedure Acceptance criteria
VN-QI-803-11-VT VN-QI-803-11-VT
Surface condition Reinforcement
Ground Smooth General Primer As welded Ground
AC Yoke coated

Type MY-2

S max.=150 mm
S
Reg. No. 1904093
Water/black Kerosine/black Background

Water/fluocent Kerosine//fluocent White Ground Non-treated

Field strength minimum 2 kA/m Other Lighting
Oerstedm. Value Oe 4.5kg White UV-lamp No.
Magnetized for
Indications in any direction Extent of examination100%
Remarks
1. MT 100% for the welded bracket
2. MT 100% for SAW welding start/stop, and if any, where temporary attachments have been welded on and removed again , weld
repair of surface defects has been performed, and where stray arc has been removed by grinding, and areas where non-
specified welding have been applied on to primary steel.
3. MT 100% on the welded repair other than SAW area were inspected and found acceptable.

Page Technician (Date (YYYY-MM-DD)/Signature)

MT of surface repair acceptable

MT acceptable 1 of 1 2020 Nov 30

Vestas Towers A/S · Engdraget 20 · 6800 Varde · Denmark · www.vestas.com

Document no.: 0004-6605 Date: 2012-01-17
Issued by: VQM
Non Destructive Testing of Primary Steel Class: 2
Components, Tower Sections and
Type: Quality Specification Page 2 of 6
Embedment’s for Vestas Wind Turbines

UT Report
Examination Date Technician (Init.) Certificate No. Examination organization / Inspection authority
2020 Nov 27 N.H.THO II-120 CS Wind VietNam Co., Ltd.
Contractor Location
CS Wind VietNam Co., Ltd. Road 2B, Phu My I Industrial Zone, Phu My Ward, Phu My Town, BaRia -
VungTau Province, Vietnam
Description in text Section ID. No. Drawing No./Rev. No.
Bottom ø6300 /15710/ ø6033 weld 328452 75933130/R0
Examination procedure Acceptance criteria Equipment type / Reg. No.
VN-QI-803-13-VT VN-QI-803-13-VT KrautkramerUSM36/ 17027552
Compression transducers Angle transducers
A: B4S B: SEB4 C: SWB70-2E D: SWB60-2E E: F:
Transducer type (Dia. 24) (Dia. 6 * 20) (Dia. 14 * 14) (Dia. 14 * 14)
Reg. No. / True angle 12650 / 4 MHz 5278 / 4 MHz 52647 / 70 ° 52481 / 60 ° / ° / °
Sensitivity setting LW CW LW CW
Basic sett.~ref.curve 38 dB 32 dB 48 44 dB 40 39.5 dB dB dB
Transfer Correction 2.8 dB 2.8 dB 2.8 2.8 dB 2.8 2.8 dB dB dB
Extra when scanning 14 dB dB 14 14 dB 14 14 dB dB dB
Total 54.8 dB 34.8 dB 64.8 60.8 dB 56.8 56.3 dB dB dB
Sensitivity: Diam.= 3 mm, range = 400-150 mm DGS (AVG): Disc diam. = range = 300-250 mm
mm, Other
V1 No. 80297 V2. No. TIF-block No. DAC (VN-NDT-DAC-TMCP-50-L/T-003-1)
Transducer check Parent metal Couplant
Operator check of ultrasonic transducers carried out Scanning area tested for lamination CMC
Scanning position for longitudinal defects

9 10
1 2 5 6

8 7

11
3 4

Weld No. / Thickness / Transducer type / Transducer position / Inspection area Weld No. / Thickness / Transducer type / Transducer position / Inspection area
CW04 / 41-27.8 mm / B-C-D / 1-2-3-4 / 100 % LW04 / 27.8 mm / B-C-D / 3-4 / 10 %
CW05 / 27.8-27.5 mm / B-C-D / 3-4 / 100 % LW05 / 27.5 mm / B-C-D / 3-4 / 10 %
CW06 / 27.5-27.4 mm / B-C-D / 3-4 / 100 % LW06 / 27.4 mm / B-C-D / 3-4 / 10 %
CW07 / 27.4-33 mm / A-B-C-D / 5-6-7-8 / 100 % / mm / - - - - / - - - / %
/ mm / - - - - / - - - / % / mm / - - - - / - - - / %
/ mm / - - - - / - - - / % / mm / - - - - / - - - / %
/ mm / - - - - / - - - / % / mm / - - - - / - - - / %
/ mm / - - - - / - - - / % / mm / - - - - / - - - / %
/ mm / - - - - / - - - / % / mm / - - - - / - - - / %
/ mm / - - - - / - - - / % / mm / - - - - / - - - / %
/ mm / - - - - / - - - / % / mm / - - - - / - - - / %
/ mm / - - - - / - - - / % / mm / - - - - / - - - / %
/ mm / - - - - / - - - / % / mm / - - - - / - - - / %
Remarks
Welds with defects: CW04~CW06
Accepted welds: CW07, LW04~LW06
Acceptable Page Technician (Date (YYYY-MM-DD)/Signature)

Not acceptable (reported on UT repair report) 1 of 5 2020 Nov 27

Vestas Towers A/S · Engdraget 20 · 6800 Varde · Denmark · www.vestas.com

Document no.: 0004-6605 Date: 2012-01-17
Issued by: VQM
Non Destructive Testing of Primary Steel Class: 2
Components, Tower Sections and
Type: Quality Specification Page 3 of 6
Embedment’s for Vestas Wind Turbines

UT Report
Examination Date Technician (Init.) Certificate No. Examination organization / Inspection authority
2020 Nov 27 V.D.NAM II-131 CS Wind VietNam Co., Ltd.
Contractor Location
CS Wind VietNam Co., Ltd. Road 2B, Phu My I Industrial Zone, Phu My Ward, Phu My Town, BaRia -
VungTau Province, Vietnam
Description in text Section ID. No. Drawing No./Rev. No.
Bottom ø6300 /15710/ ø6033 weld 328452 75933130/R0
Examination procedure Acceptance criteria Equipment type / Reg. No.
VN-QI-803-13-VT VN-QI-803-13-VT Epoch 650/ 150048406
Compression transducers Angle transducers
A: B4S B: SEB4 C: SWB70-2E D: SWB60-2E E: F:
Transducer type (Dia. 24) (Dia. 6 * 20) (Dia. 14 * 14) (Dia. 14 * 14)
Reg. No. / True angle 12650 / 4 MHz 5278 / 4 MHz 52647 / 70 ° 51428 / 60 ° / ° / °
Sensitivity setting LW CW LW CW
Basic sett.~ref.curve 51 dB 31 dB 39 34 dB 35 35 dB dB dB
Transfer Correction 2.8 dB 2.8 dB 2.8 2.8 dB 2.8 2.8 dB dB dB
Extra when scanning 14 dB dB 14 14 dB 14 14 dB dB dB
Total 67.8 dB 33.8 dB 55.8 50.8 dB 51.8 51.8 dB dB dB
Sensitivity: Diam.= 3 mm, range = 400-150 mm DGS (AVG): Disc diam. = mm, range = 300-250 mm
Other
V1 No. 80297 V2. No. TIF-block No. DAC (VN-NDT-DAC-TMCP-50-L/T-003-1)
Transducer check Parent metal Couplant
Operator check of ultrasonic transducers carried out Scanning area tested for lamination CMC
Scanning position for longitudinal defects

9 10
1 2 5 6

8 7

11
3 4

Weld No. / Thickness / Transducer type / Transducer position / Inspection area Weld No. / Thickness / Transducer type / Transducer position / Inspection area
CW01 / 41-41 mm / A-B-C-D / 9-10-11 / 100 % LW01 / 41 mm / B-C-D / 1-2-3-4 / 10 % 50%
CW02 / 41-41 mm / B-C-D / 1-2-3-4 / 100 % LW02A / 41-70 mm / B-C-D / 1-2-3-4 / 10 %
CW02A / 41-70 mm / B-C-D / 1-2-3-4 / 100 % LW02B / 70-41 mm / B-C-D / 1-2-3-4 / 10 %
CW03 / 41-41 mm / B-C-D / 1-2-3-4 / 100 % LW03 / 41 mm / B-C-D / 1-2-3-4 / 10 % 50%
CW03A / 70-41 mm / B-C-D / 1-2-3-4 / 100 % / mm / - - - - / - - - / %
/ mm / - - - - / - - - / % / mm / - - - - / - - - / %
/ mm / - - - - / - - - / % / mm / - - - - / - - - / %
/ mm / - - - - / - - - / % / mm / - - - - / - - - / %
/ mm / - - - - / - - - / % / mm / - - - - / - - - / %
/ mm / - - - - / - - - / % / mm / - - - - / - - - / %
/ mm / - - - - / - - - / % / mm / - - - - / - - - / %
/ mm / - - - - / - - - / % / mm / - - - - / - - - / %
/ mm / - - - - / - - - / % / mm / - - - - / - - - / %
Remarks
CW01~CW02, CW03~CW03A, LW01, LW03
Welds with defects:
Accepted welds: CW02A, LW02A~LW02B
Acceptable Page Technician (Date (YYYY-MM-DD)/Signature)

Not acceptable (reported on UT repair report) 2 of 5 2020 Nov 27

Vestas Towers A/S · Engdraget 20 · 6800 Varde · Denmark · www.vestas.com

Document no.: 0004-6605 Date: 2012-01-17
Issued by: VQM
Non Destructive Testing of Primary Steel Class: 2
Components, Tower Sections and
Type: Quality Specification Page 4 of 6
Embedment’s for Vestas Wind Turbines

UT Repair Report
Examination Date Technician (init.) Certificate No. Examination organization / Inspection authority
2020 Nov 27 N.H.THO II-120 CS Wind Vietnam Co., Ltd.
V.D.NAM II-131
Client
Vestas Tower
Contractor Location
Road 2B, Phu My I Industrial Zone, Phu My Ward, Phu My Town,
CS Wind Vietnam Co., Ltd. BaRia - VungTau Province, Vietnam
Description in text Section ID No. Drawing No. / Rev. No.
Bottom ø6300 /15710/ ø6033 weld 328452 75933130/R0
Type of
Scanning details Location of indication Result Remarks
indication
Depth from

EN - Exceeds acceptance
Plate thickness
Indication No.

Beam angle (true)*

Scanning Position

Acceptance level

Defect Length

Not acceptable
Coordinates

Level with: dB
External side
(db/disk dia.)

Internal side

Longitudinal

Transverse

Acceptable
Weld No.

[mm] [mm] [mm] [mm] [mm]

CW01 1 10 70 3 41-41 104 240 22 X -4.9 X
CW01 2 10 70 3 41-41 2,210 269 20 X -2 X
CW01 3 10 70 3 41-41 4,521 40 16 X -1.4 X
CW01 4 10 70 3 41-41 9,430 236 19 X 1.8 X
CW01 5 10 70 3 41-41 9,763 85 18 X 2.4 X
CW01 6 10 70 3 41-41 17,319 75 26 X -5.8 X
CW02 1 4 70 3 41-41 2,630 205 35 X 3.2 X
CW02 2 3 70 3 41-41 4,215 48 16 X 5.6 X
CW03 1 4 70 3 41-41 4,523 51 30 X 1.8 X
CW03 2 4 70 3 41-41 11,254 84 34 X 2.4 X
CW03A 1 3 70 3 70-41 14,446 74 18 X -3.4 X
CW04 1 3 70 3 41-27.8 4,210 43 22 X 2.2 X
CW05 1 3 70 3 27.8-27.5 8,864 105 23 X 1.2 X
CW05 2 3 70 3 27.8-27.5 10,054 395 18 X -4.4 X
CW05 3 4 70 3 27.8-27.5 12,646 435 16 X -1.4 X

Repairs marked Page Technician (Date (YYYY-MM-DD)/Signature)

On object 3 of 5 2020 Nov 27

A general description of the coordinate

system to be used when defects are reported.

The 0 point for all

longitudinal welds is
located at the
X circular weld below.

X
The 0 point for all circular welds
X
(except from the one at the top)
is located at the longitudinal weld
above.

X X

Vestas Towers A/S · Engdraget 20 · 6800 Varde · Denmark · www.vestas.com

Document no.: 0004-6605 Date: 2012-01-17
Issued by: VQM
Non Destructive Testing of Primary Steel Class: 2
Components, Tower Sections and
Type: Quality Specification Page 5 of 6
Embedment’s for Vestas Wind Turbines

UT Repair Report
Examination Date Technician (init.) Certificate No. Examination organization / Inspection authority
2020 Nov 27 N.H.THO II-120 CS Wind Vietnam Co., Ltd.
V.D.NAM II-131
Client
Vestas Tower
Contractor Location
Road 2B, Phu My I Industrial Zone, Phu My Ward, Phu My Town,
CS Wind Vietnam Co., Ltd. BaRia - VungTau Province, Vietnam
Description in text Section ID No. Drawing No. / Rev. No.
Bottom ø6300 /15710/ ø6033 weld 328452 75933130/R0
Type of
Scanning details Location of indication Result Remarks
indication
Depth from

EN - Exceeds acceptance
Plate thickness
Indication No.

Beam angle (true)*

Scanning Position

Acceptance level

Defect Length

Not acceptable
Coordinates

Level with: dB
External side
(db/disk dia.)

Internal side

Longitudinal

Transverse

Acceptable
Weld No.

[mm] [mm] [mm] [mm] [mm]

CW06 1 3 70 3 27.5-27.4 1,406 722 16 X -1.6 X
CW06 2 3 70 3 27.5-27.4 6,303 432 15 X -1 X
CW06 3 4 70 3 27.5-27.4 8,364 80 15 X -8.8 X
CW06 4 3 70 3 27.5-27.4 11,824 398 19 X -5.4 X
CW06 5 3 70 3 27.5-27.4 16,219 80 16 X -4.4 X
LW01 1 3 70 3 41 0 122 14 X -2.8 X
LW03 1 4 70 3 41 1,004 213 24 X -3.4 X

Repairs marked Page Technician (Date (YYYY-MM-DD)/Signature)

On object 4 of 5 2020 Nov 27

A general description of the coordinate

system to be used when defects are reported.

The 0 point for all

longitudinal welds is
located at the
X circular weld below.

X
The 0 point for all circular welds
X
(except from the one at the top)
is located at the longitudinal weld
above.

X X

Vestas Towers A/S · Engdraget 20 · 6800 Varde · Denmark · www.vestas.com

Document no.: 0004-6605 Date: 2012-01-17
Issued by: VQM
Non Destructive Testing of Primary Steel Class: 2
Components, Tower Sections and
Type: Quality Specification Page 6 of 6
Embedment’s for Vestas Wind Turbines

UT Report
Examination Date Technician (Init.) Certificate No. Examination organization / Inspection authority
2020 Nov 30 N.Q.CONG II-183 CS Wind VietNam Co., Ltd.
Contractor Location
CS Wind VietNam Co., Ltd. Road 2B, Phu My I Industrial Zone, Phu My Ward, Phu My Town, BaRia -
VungTau Province, Vietnam
Description in text Section ID. No. Drawing No./Rev. No.
Bottom ø6300 /15710/ ø6033 weld 328452 75933130/R0
Examination procedure Acceptance criteria Equipment type / Reg. No.
VN-QI-803-13-VT VN-QI-803-13-VT KrautkramerUSM35/ 7031a
Compression transducers Angle transducers
A: B4S B: DL4R C: SWB70-2E D: SWB60-2E E: F:
Transducer type (Dia. 24) (Dia. 6 * 20) (Dia. 14 * 14) (Dia. 14 * 14)
Reg. No. / True angle 12650 / 4 MHz 886135 / 4 MHz 52641 / 70 ° 51428 / 60 ° / ° / °
Sensitivity setting LW CW LW CW
Basic sett.~ref.curve 42 dB 33 dB 54 50 dB 48 47 dB dB dB
Transfer Correction 2.8 dB 2.8 dB 2.8 2.8 dB 2.8 2.8 dB dB dB
Extra when scanning 14 dB dB 14 14 dB 14 14 dB dB dB
Total 58.8 dB 35.8 dB 70.8 66.8 dB 64.8 63.8 dB dB dB
Sensitivity: Diam.= 3 mm, range = 300-200 mm DGS (AVG): Disc diam. = range = 300-250 mm
mm, Other
V1 No. 80297 V2. No. TIF-block No. DAC (VN-NDT-DAC-TMCP-50-L/T-003-1)
Transducer check Parent metal Couplant
Operator check of ultrasonic transducers carried out Scanning area tested for lamination CMC
Scanning position for longitudinal defects

9 10
1 2 5 6

8 7

11
3 4

Weld No. / Thickness / Transducer type / Transducer position / Inspection area Weld No. / Thickness / Transducer type / Transducer position / Inspection area
CW01 R1/ 41-41 mm / A-B-C-D / 9-10-11 / Defected area LW01 R1/ 41 mm / B-C-D / 1-2-3-4 / Defected area
CW02 R1/ 41-41 mm / B-C-D / 1-2-3-4 / Defected area LW03 R1/ 41 mm / B-C-D / 1-2-3-4 / Defected area
CW03 R1/ 41-41 mm / B-C-D / 1-2-3-4 / Defected area / mm / - - - - / - - - / %
CW03A R1/ 70-41 mm / B-C-D / 1-2-3-4 / Defected area / mm / - - - - / - - - / %
CW04 R1/ 41-27.8 mm / B-C-D / 1-2-3-4 / Defected area / mm / - - - - / - - - / %
CW05 R1/ 27.8-27.5 mm / B-C-D / 3-4 / Defected area / mm / - - - - / - - - / %
CW06 R1/ 27.5-27.4 mm / B-C-D / 3-4 / Defected area / mm / - - - - / - - - / %
/ mm / - - - - / - - - / % / mm / - - - - / - - - / %
/ mm / - - - - / - - - / % / mm / - - - - / - - - / %
/ mm / - - - - / - - - / % / mm / - - - - / - - - / %
/ mm / - - - - / - - - / % / mm / - - - - / - - - / %
/ mm / - - - - / - - - / % / mm / - - - - / - - - / %
Remarks
Welds with defects: N/A
Accepted welds: CW01~CW02, CW03~CW06, LW01, LW03
Acceptable Page Technician (Date (YYYY-MM-DD)/Signature)

Not acceptable (reported on UT repair report) 5 of 5 2020 Nov 30

Vestas Towers A/S · Engdraget 20 · 6800 Varde · Denmark · www.vestas.com