You are on page 1of 12

C H A P T E R

38
Human Neurophysiology: EEG and
Quantitative EEG in Addiction Research
Rebecca J. Houston*, Natalie A. Ceballos$
*
Research Institute on Addictions, University at Buffalo, The State University of New York, NY, USA
$
Texas State University, San Marcos, TX, USA

O U T L I N E

Electroencephalography 379 Opiates and ERPs 387


Hallucinogens 387
Quantitative Electroencephalography 380
3,4-Methylenedioxymethamphetamine
Event-Related Brain Potentials 380 and Quantitative EEG 387
3,4-Methylenedioxymethamphetamine and Event-
EEG and ERP Findings by Addictive Substance 382
Related Potentials 387
Nicotine 382
Marijuana and Quantitative EEG 388
Nicotine and qEEG 382
Marijuana and Event-Related Potentials 388
Nicotine and ERPs 382
Other Addictions and EEG/ERP 388
Alcohol 383
Disordered Eating 388
Alcohol and qEEG 383
Pathological Gambling 388
Alcohol and ERPs 384
Illicit Stimulants 385 Treatment Implications 389
Illicit Stimulants and qEEG 385
Summary 389
Illicit Stimulants and ERPs 386
Opiates 386
Opiates and qEEG 386

ELECTROENCEPHALOGRAPHY thought to represent summated postsynaptic potential


activity (changes in the membrane potential in relation
The first report on measurement of the human to neuronal firing). As a result, the EEG provides
brain’s electrical activity was published by Hans a continuous time-sensitive index of neural activation.
Berger in 1929. Since then, electroencephalography Accordingly, a prime advantage of EEG as compared
(EEG) methodology has evolved substantially. EEG to many other measures of functional brain activity
involves noninvasive measurement of neural activity (i.e. functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI)
from scalp surface electrodes. This electrical signal and positron emission tomography (PET)) is the high
reflects the summation of synchronous activity of temporal resolution. Changes in neural activity are
a large group of neurons with similar spatial orienta- measured on the order of milliseconds as opposed to
tion. More specifically, these voltage fluctuations are minutes that are required for some functional brain

Biological Research on Addiction, Volume 2


http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/B978-0-12-398335-0.00038-8 379 Copyright Ó 2013 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
380 38. HUMAN NEUROPHYSIOLOGY: EEG AND QUANTITATIVE EEG IN ADDICTION RESEARCH

measurement approaches. Thus, the EEG provides an QUANTITATIVE


index of brain activity that is particularly sensitive for ELECTROENCEPHALOGRAPHY
reflecting moment-to-moment changes in neural acti-
vation (up to a thousand times faster), whereas other qEEG measures consist of frequency analyses in
methods may rely on slower processes such as cerebral which the signal is deconstructed into its sub-band
blood flow. frequencies or a power spectrum is obtained. Perhaps
Although the EEG has high temporal resolution, the the most commonly used spectral estimation method
spatial resolution (ability to detect the source of a given is the fast Fourier transformation (FFT); this method
EEG signal in the brain) can be quite low and the uses an algorithm to decompose the signal into compo-
signal from subcortical structures is diminished nent frequencies so that changes or levels of different
considerably, if detectable at all. In an attempt to over- frequencies can be observed. Power spectral analysis
come this shortcoming, specialized techniques have focuses on the study of the EEG in several nonoverlap-
been applied, some of which involve the combination ping frequency bands, typically defined as delta waves
of EEG/ERP with structural (e.g. magnetic resonance (1–4 Hz; deep sleep), theta waves (5–7 Hz; drowsiness),
imaging (MRI)) information. For instance, source local- alpha waves (8–13 Hz; relaxed wakefulness), and beta
ization involves the application of mathematical waves (>13 Hz; alert wakefulness). Some researchers
parameters in an attempt to identify the location, have partitioned frequency bands further, for instance,
orientation, and strength of a given source of the elec- alpha 1 (8–10 Hz), alpha 2 (10–12 Hz), beta 1 (12.5–
trical information recorded at the scalp. These para- 16 Hz), beta 2 (16–20 Hz), and beta 3 (20.5–28 Hz) bands.
metrics must be applied to human head models Power is typically expressed in either absolute or rela-
which can vary from generic multilayer nested concen- tive units. Relative power, a proportion of power in
tric spheres to individualized computed tomography the entire spectrum, minimizes the individual differ-
(CT) or MRI scans. The combination of two methods ences across subjects in absolute power magnitude and
(i.e. EEG plus MRI) provides both the temporal resolu- may obscure group differences.
tion of the EEG and the superior spatial resolution of Variance in EEG pattern is heritable and typically
the MRI. stable throughout the lifetime. Current models suggest
Given the noninvasive and cost-effective nature of that genetic predisposition to alcohol dependence, in
EEG (it is fairly inexpensive compared to other particular, is linked to central nervous system (CNS)
approaches), it has developed its own niche as a useful homeostatic imbalance, which may be observed using
tool for increasing our understanding of brain function qEEG methods. In fact, the Collaborative Study on the
and dysfunction. Moreover, the use of EEG and its deriv- Genetics of Alcoholism (COGA) has identified a signifi-
atives has been particularly valuable for examining the cant linkage for beta EEG power and the gamma-amino-
neurobiological precursors and consequences of butyric acid A (GABAA) receptor a2 subunit gene
a number of addictive disorders. (GABRA2). Subsequent work has shown that GABRA2
Although more recent assessment methodologies alleles affect subjective responses to alcohol and may
with high spatial resolution have decreased the clinical play a role in the risk of alcohol use disorders. Predis-
use of the traditional EEG, quantitative EEG (qEEG) posed individuals tend to have higher than typical levels
remains a popular tool in research studies. qEEG of disinhibition or CNS hyperexcitability, for which
reflects ongoing functional brain activation during alcohol consumption may provide temporary normali-
a given time period or task. Differences in qEEG char- zation. This initial state of hyperexcitability may facili-
acteristics such as frequency and amplitude have been tate the neuroadaptive changes associated with chronic
reliably associated with distinct behavioral and mental alcohol use, and may lead to a more rapid development
states (e.g. relaxed wakefulness, changes in mental of physical dependence.
activity/processing) and thus provide an excellent
basis for comparison when abnormal activity is sus-
pected. Event-related potentials (ERPs), a derivative of
the EEG signal, are used to assess sensory and cognitive EVENT-RELATED BRAIN POTENTIALS
processing. Typically, the EEG signal is time-locked to
a discrete event (e.g. a stimulus or response) and aver- ERPs are derived from the ongoing EEG signal and
aged over several trials to eliminate noise and identify are time-locked to a specific event. For example, contin-
a specific pattern in the change in electrocortical uous electrocortical activity is collected while individ-
activity with regard to that event. A number of ERPs uals are attending to and/or performing a given task.
have been identified and each represents a different The EEG is then epoched, which means that a window
means for assessing various aspects of specific psycho- of time is marked around each stimulus presentation.
logical processes. The activity is then examined for a change in voltage

II. NEUROSCIENCE
EVENT-RELATED BRAIN POTENTIALS 381
in response to the stimulus in question (the “event” in ERP, the modality and characteristics of the external
this example). The primary ERP characteristics that event (if applicable), and the elicitation method. Below
are examined in response to specific “events” are ampli- is a brief description of ERPs that have significantly
tude, the change in voltage, and latency, the point in contributed to addiction research.
time where this change occurs. The topographic distri- One of the movement-related potentials, the contin-
bution of a given ERP is another important character- gent negative variation (CNV), is a slow negative wave
istic and thus careful attention to electrode locations is that occurs between a warning stimulus and target stim-
required for proper interpretation. ERPs are frequently ulus that requires a rapid motor response. It consists of
labeled based on polarity, whether the change two distinct components: an early negativity which
in voltage is positive or negative in relation to a pre- peaks about 1 s after the warning stimulus (the orienting
stimulus baseline, and latency (e.g. N100 reflects a nega- wave or O-wave) and a late negativity which increases
tive change in polarity peaking approximately 100 ms up to the point at which the imperative stimulus appears
after stimulus onset). Other naming conventions may (expectancy wave or E-wave). The late CNV is thought
incorporate topographical characteristics (e.g. frontal to reflect both anticipation of the imperative stimulus
P300) or functional interpretation (e.g. error-related and movement preparation. Thus, the CNV has been
negativity (ERN)). described as reflecting expectancy, attentional prepara-
There is a distinction between those ERPs whose tion, and motivation/intention to act.
characteristics depend largely on the physical features The ERN occurs approximately 100 ms after an incor-
of an external stimulus or event (exogenous) and those rect response, regardless of whether or not the partici-
whose characteristics are thought to be determined by pant is consciously aware of committing an error, and
internal processes related to the event (endogenous). is hypothesized to reflect error detection or conflict
Exogenous ERPs, such as the P100 or N100, are elicited monitoring processes. Often observed in conjunction
in response to the presentation of a stimulus and with the ERN are the error positivity (Pe), a positive
changes in the physical features of this stimulus can deflection occurring slightly later than the ERN after
result in changes in the exogenous ERP. For example, an error and thought to reflect conscious processing of
the presentation of an auditory tone will elicit the P100 an error, and the feedback negativity (sometimes called
and N100, but an increase in the loudness (i.e. intensity) the fERN), which is strongly associated with negative
of the tone can result in changes in P100 and N100 feedback outcomes (particularly in reward contexts),
amplitude. These ERPs are also termed evoked poten- and typically occurs 250–300 ms after feedback
tials as they are elicited (or evoked) simply by the presentation.
presentation of a stimulus. Endogenous ERPs, on the The MMN is an auditory ERP that is elicited during
other hand, are linked to internal processes surrounding a passive attention task in which infrequent stimuli are
a given event, such as decision making and error moni- embedded within a sequence of frequent standard
toring. Changes in endogenous ERP characteristics such stimuli while the individual’s attention is typically
as amplitude or latency are dependent on these internal engaged in another task (e.g. watching a silent video).
mechanisms (e.g. the amount of time the individual The MMN is thought to reflect involuntary attention to
spends in evaluating a stimulus to meet task demands). the change in stimuli (i.e. deviance or “mismatch” detec-
There are, however, some ERPs that may exhibit both tion) and/or may be a marker of early pre-attentive
exogenous and endogenous properties. In addition, sensory memory processes.
some studies have suggested links between particular Mid-latency ERPs reflect the segue from exogenous to
ERP components and specific neurochemical processes, endogenous ERPs depending on the stimuli and task
such as neurotransmitter function. For instance, ampli- demands used to elicit these components. The visual
tude increases in the mid-latency ERPs in response to P100 occurs approximately 100 ms after stimulus onset
increases in auditory stimulus intensity have been and is thought to represent sensitivity to an attended
repeatedly linked to low serotonin function and favor- stimulus. The N100 or N1 is hypothesized to indicate
able response to selective serontonin reuptake inhibitors the allocation and orienting of attention. The N200 or
(SSRIs). Dopamine function has also been associated N2 refers to a group of related components that occur
with conflict processing (P300, ERN) and attention around 200 ms poststimulus, although the latency range
(N100, mismatch negativity (MMN)). Given the complex and topography can vary depending on task demands
electrical and neurochemical processes involved in and modality. Early work on the N2 hypothesized that
neural communication, our extant understanding of this component reflected the detection of deviant stimuli
how these electrocortical measures are directly related or a mismatch between a stimulus and some previous
to neurochemical transmission remains an area of mentally stored expectation (the N2a is similar to the
debate. More is known about the anatomical basis for MMN, but other N2 components differ from the MMN
specific ERPs, although this varies considerably by in that the individual’s attention is consciously

II. NEUROSCIENCE
382 38. HUMAN NEUROPHYSIOLOGY: EEG AND QUANTITATIVE EEG IN ADDICTION RESEARCH

engaged). Continued research on the N2 has indicated that a family history of addiction may influence acute
the versatility of this component and the identification response to various substances.
of the N2b and N2c. The N2b is thought to be related Studies of the chronic effects of substances on EEG/
to cognitive control and response inhibition, and is the ERP indices also encounter a host of confounding
most popular N2 component for the study of psycholog- factors. For instance, certain EEG/ERP patterns may
ical processes. The N2c is more common in visual serve as an endophenotype for risk of substance depen-
perception research and is related to visual attention dence and may be associated with a family history of
processes. alcohol/drug use or a predisposition for disinhibited
The P300 or P3 is probably the most frequently or externalizing behavior. Because few studies follow
studied ERP component in addiction research. The participants from birth to their entry into substance
“classic” P3 or P3b is elicited via an oddball paradigm abuse treatment it is difficult to definitively determine
(e.g. presentation of stimuli requiring discrimination whether or not EEG/ERP deficits among substance-
between target and nontarget events) and is usually dependent individuals reflect predisposing CNS factors
maximal at posterior sites; its amplitude provides an or merely the toxic effects of chronic substance use.
index of cognitive efficiency within the context of atten-
tion and memory updating whereas its latency reflects
stimulus evaluation time or task complexity. The P3a Nicotine
(i.e. frontal P3 or novelty P3) is elicited in response to
Nicotine and qEEG
infrequent and/or novel stimuli, has a more anterior
topographic distribution, and provides an index of Most studies of nicotine’s effects on qEEG have
attention to novelty. focused on acute administration, which results in a stim-
Other ERP components, such as the P50, N400, or ulant-like EEG profile, including reduction in ampli-
negative slow wave (NSW), have been explored in rela- tude/power in slow wave delta and theta frequency
tion to addictive disorders. The findings related to these bands, and increases in amplitude/power in fast wave
components are relatively recent and/or less consistent, alpha and beta frequency bands. When alpha is parti-
but are also described where relevant. tioned into slow (alpha 1: 8–10 Hz) and fast (alpha 2:
10–12 Hz) varieties, acute nicotine results in decreases
in slow alpha and fast alpha amplitude/power. EEG
activation is widespread; however, low nicotine-yield
EEG AND ERP FINDINGS BY cigarettes tend to produce more localized posterior acti-
ADDICTIVE SUBSTANCE vation, which spreads to central and frontal regions with
increasing nicotine concentration. Administration
Important issues for research on addictive substances methods may also influence the EEG profile (e.g. ciga-
include the distinction between acute versus chronic rette smoking is a more efficient activator of the EEG
effects, the route of administration, and the differentia- versus nicotine nasal spray).
tion and/or control of facilitation/inhibition versus Chronic smoking increases the risk of attention and
withdrawal effects on cognition. Chronicity, extent of working memory deficits; however, the literature is
dependence, and family history are also crucial factors. contentious concerning the question of whether or not
The double-blind, placebo-controlled design presents chronic smoking results in cognitive deficits that may
the “best practice” method of measuring the effects of be reflected via qEEG. This work is typically
a drug; however, this technique has not consistently confounded by lingering effects of overnight abstinence
been applied to studies assessing the effects of addictive from nicotine and/or acute abstinence occurring
substances on EEG/ERPs. Lack of methodological conti- throughout the testing session itself. As such, the acute
nuity may be a contributing factor to inconsistent find- facilitative effects of nicotine may partially mask cogni-
ings in this field. tive deficits associated with long-term use, particularly
In terms of acute effects, the EEG/ERP findings asso- in the frontal brain regions. However, longitudinal
ciated with a given class of addictive substances may be studies of EEG changes during smoking cessation have
predicted based on their CNS-activating or -inhibiting revealed an overall slowing of the EEG, which persists
effects. For instance, administration of a stimulant has for up to a month following cessation.
an excitatory effect on the CNS, resulting in an “alert”
Nicotine and ERPs
EEG pattern (typically most evident frontally) and
increased amplitude with decreased latency of atten- • CNV: CNV amplitude tends to increase in response to
tion-related ERPs. Conversely, administration of a seda- higher doses of nicotine, suggesting an increased
tive drug typically results in the opposite pattern of orienting response reflected at frontal scalp electrodes
findings. As noted above, it is important to acknowledge and readiness for movement reflected at central scalp

II. NEUROSCIENCE
EEG AND ERP FINDINGS BY ADDICTIVE SUBSTANCE 383
electrodes. Further, studies suggest that personality research such as acute versus chronic effects, length
traits may also influence smokers’ CNVs with an and severity of use/dependence, as well as effects of
increase in amplitude for extroverts and a decrease for abstinence/recovery. Research on the effects of alcohol,
introverts. Overall, these findings tend to apply to the particularly chronic effects, on neurophysiological
global CNV waveform or to the E-wave component. measures is often rife with confounds related to a history
• MMN: Nicotine administration tends to be associated of head injury, seizure disorder, antisocial behavior, and
with MMN amplitude increase and latency decrease, family history of alcoholism. Early work may not have
reflecting an enhancement of deviance detection in accounted for many of these issues, assuming that defi-
a string of otherwise common stimuli. Other work has cits were a consequence of the neurotoxic effects of
focused on patients treated or not treated with alcohol. Studies in recent years have tended to take
acetylcholinesterase inhibitors; nicotine increased a more rigorous and balanced approach. It is also imper-
MMN amplitude among untreated patients and ative to note that the neurophysiology of alcoholism is
decreased latency among patients in both groups. inextricably linked to one’s genetic propensity to develop
• Mid-latency ERPs: Acute improvements in task such disorders or behavior patterns. To date, hundreds of
performance are thought to be related to nicotine’s studies have been conducted; below is a summary of the
facilitative effects on identification and encoding of most consistent and notable findings in humans.
rare deviant stimuli at early sensory levels. Nicotine
enhances P100 and P200 amplitudes; however, Alcohol and qEEG
findings for the N100 waveform have been less Studies of acute alcohol administration on qEEG
consistent. indices have demonstrated increases in slow alpha
activity at low doses, although these results are not
Chronic smoking is thought to reduce amplitude and
always consistent. Moderate doses of alcohol tend to
increase latency of early ERP components. N100 find-
result in increased slow alpha, increased theta, and
ings among smokers might reflect delayed information
decreased beta activity. Several studies of acute alcohol
processing and perhaps short-term memory distur-
effects on qEEG have been specifically conducted on
bances, both related to prefrontal cognitive dysfunction.
offspring of alcohol-dependent individuals (family
However, it is possible that preexisting frontal dysfunc-
history positive or FHP) in an effort to explore whether
tion could have contributed to the initiation of partici-
these offspring may possess an underlying neurological
pants’ tobacco use.
vulnerability that may be revealed via alcohol exposure.
• P300: Acutely, nicotine/cigarette smoking shortens P3 In general, FHP individuals do not exhibit any differ-
latency and/or increases P3 amplitude, reflecting ences from those without such a history in terms of the
enhanced efficiency of attentional allocation to target uptake and clearance of alcohol in the bloodstream.
stimuli. Evidence of a P3 endophenotype for tobacco However, qEEG studies have demonstrated greater
dependence has also been noted in studies of chronic increases in slow alpha and beta activity as well as
smokers, who exhibit lower P3 amplitude compared greater decreases in fast alpha in response to alcohol
to nonsmokers. Other research indicates diminished consumption in FHP males as compared to non-FHP
P3 amplitudes in both current smokers and former males. In addition, non-FHP individuals classified as
smokers, as compared to never smokers. Although at least moderate drinkers also exhibit more beta power
some researchers attribute these findings to than lighter drinkers after alcohol consumption. Finally,
neurotoxicity, one could also argue that these data studies of FHP individuals have also indicated that
reflect a trait or risk factor contributing to tobacco a diminished alpha response to alcohol administration
dependence. in these individuals may be related to later development
of severe alcohol use problems.
Studies examining the chronic effects of alcohol
consumption on qEEG have largely focused on patient
Alcohol populations. Studies of resting EEG studies have tradi-
EEG/ERPs have long played an integral role in the tionally indicated increased levels of slow wave activity
understanding of the vulnerability for and neurocogni- (e.g. theta) in alcoholic individuals as compared to
tive consequences of addictive disorders. Published nonalcoholic controls. This effect appears to be more
studies date back to the 1940s indicating EEG abnormal- robust in men and independent of length of abstinence.
ities as a result of both acute and chronic alcohol use. Elevated theta during a normal waking EEG is abnormal
When the study of evoked and ERPs increased in popu- and this type of finding is consistent with increased EEG
larity, research on how these neural mechanisms relate to slow wave patterns reported in other psychiatric disor-
alcohol consumption also grew steadily. Important ders such as depression and psychotic disorders. In
issues are similar to some of those noted for nicotine addition to theta differences, a series of early studies

II. NEUROSCIENCE
384 38. HUMAN NEUROPHYSIOLOGY: EEG AND QUANTITATIVE EEG IN ADDICTION RESEARCH

reported low alpha activity in alcoholics, but later work frontal lobe functioning, which is consistent with
has reported opposite or null effects. Another series of findings from neuropsychological and structural
studies has shown that men with a paternal history of imaging studies (see Neuropsychological Precursors
alcoholism (FHP) exhibit increased alpha power and Consequences of Addiction, Addiction and the
compared to men without such a paternal history. Inter- Human Adolescent Brain, Alcohol Neuroimaging in
estingly, alcohol-dependent patients in recovery (as long Humans).
as 12 weeks abstinent) do not exhibit the same increases • MMN: Decreases in MMN amplitude in response to
in alpha activity in response to increases in photic stim- acute alcohol suggest that consumption can impair
ulation intensity as control individuals; this suggests auditory detection processes for unexpected events. A
impaired sensory/attentional processing. Also related visual analog of the MMN called the rareness-related
to alpha activity is the notion that individuals who negativity (RRN) is also adversely affected by acute
exhibit low voltage alpha activity (LVA), an EEG pheno- alcohol. These findings speak to the extent that acute
type, may be at higher risk for alcoholism. It has been alcohol can diminish attentional processes during
demonstrated that alcohol-dependent individuals are everyday activities such as driving. Studies of the
three to four times more likely to exhibit LVA, and MMN in recently detoxified alcohol-dependent
LVA is related to low P3 amplitude, a “classic” character- patients report larger MMN amplitudes, suggestive of
istic of alcohol-dependent individuals. greater attentional distraction and impaired
Increased beta power in alcohol-dependent individ- reorienting, although this effect has not always been
uals has been consistently reported and there is evidence consistent. Further, the MMN appears to reduce with
of elevated beta in those with a family history of alco- increased abstinence, and alcoholics who have
holism as well. Moreover, increased qEEG fast beta maintained abstinence for a minimum of 6 months
activity has also been demonstrated as a valuable exhibit no differences in MMN when compared to
predictor for relapse in alcohol-dependent (and other nonalcoholic controls. Thus, the MMN seems to be
substance-dependent) patients over and above a number more sensitive to state factors, such as recent alcohol
of other comorbid factors, such as severity of illness, use, and less determined by factors which may persist
depression level, and childhood conduct problems. throughout long-term recovery.
This association appears stronger for men than women. • Mid-latency ERPs: Consistent with acute alcohol
Related to these findings is research demonstrating that effects on the MMN, alcohol administration results in
the beta frequency band of the EEG is genetically linked smaller N1 amplitude and increased N2b latencies,
to a GABRA2 receptor gene, which has been associated suggesting attentional impairment. Findings are
with alcohol dependence. The current hypothesis is somewhat similar in terms of chronic alcohol
that variations in this gene can influence neural excit- consumption with reduced visual N1 amplitude and
ability which can then implicate a predisposition to alco- a phenomenon termed “auditory N1 amplitude
holism. These studies on beta power in alcoholic patients suppression” (reduced amplitude with repetitive
and nonalcohol-dependent individuals with a family stimuli) being demonstrated in alcohol-dependent
history of alcoholism suggest that these effects are likely patients compared to controls. There is also evidence
related to a premorbid vulnerability for alcoholism as of amplitude decrements in P100, N170, and N200.
opposed to the consequences of alcohol consumption. Studies published in 2012 on binge drinkers have
demonstrated increased P100 and N200 latency over
the course of 9 months compared to nonbinge
Alcohol and ERPs
drinkers, supporting the idea that binge drinking may
• CNV: The acute effects of alcohol administration on be on a continuum with other alcohol use disorders,
the CNV include decreases in CNV amplitude, and and thus result in neurotoxic effects. Taken together,
thus a dampening of preparatory processes under the studies of mid-latency ERPs indicate impaired
influence of alcohol. However, some studies report no sensory and attentional processing which is also likely
difference in CNV amplitudes or latencies between to contribute to deficits in later stages of cognitive
abstinent alcohol-dependent patients and controls, processing.
and others demonstrate reduced CNV amplitudes in • P300: Acutely, alcohol has been found to reduce both
heavy and/or chronic drinkers compared to controls. P3a and P3b amplitudes, even at low doses.
These disparate findings may be related to the Decrements in P3b amplitude and prolonged P3b
severity of alcohol consumption history as well as the latency, in response to both visual and auditory
effects of abstinence. Studies reporting reduced CNV stimuli, have been repeatedly demonstrated in
amplitudes in drinkers interpret this as evidence of alcohol-dependent patients as compared to controls
deficient cognitive and motor preparation (i.e. reflecting inefficient attention and/or cognitive
reduced CNV amplitudes), and hence impaired processing. This is consistent with findings in

II. NEUROSCIENCE
EEG AND ERP FINDINGS BY ADDICTIVE SUBSTANCE 385
individuals with other psychiatric disorders and on both unconscious and conscious error detection. In
likely reflects generalized impairment of attentional terms of alcohol dependence, ERN amplitude
allocation, as opposed to deficits directly due to findings have been mixed, although it is suggested
alcohol. Interestingly, these findings appear to be that psychiatric comorbidity may be an important
more robust for male as opposed to female alcoholics. factor (i.e. comorbid anxiety disorders are related to
Studies of P3a have also demonstrated smaller P3a larger ERN). In addition, the feedback negativity does
amplitude in alcohol-dependent individuals as not appear to be affected in alcoholic participants, but
compared to controls in both visual and auditory it is smaller in those participants with a greater family
modalities, although contradictory reports do exist. In density of alcohol problems, consistent with a genetic
general, these findings of smaller P3b and P3a are vulnerability theory of addictions.
hypothesized to be due to reduced inhibition of the
CNS, and although the majority of studies have been
conducted in alcohol-dependent patients, research in
Illicit Stimulants
the past 20 years has also demonstrated similar Studies of the acute effects of illegal stimulant admin-
findings in heavy versus light social drinkers. In istration typically have focused on participants who are
addition, research with alcohol-dependent patients already dependent on these substances. Given the
has also demonstrated that P3 amplitude decrements similar dopaminergic mechanisms of cocaine, amphet-
do not fully recover with prolonged abstinence. amine, and methamphetamine, it is not surprising that
acute administration studies tend to report a similar
A line of research initiated in the early 1980s also
pattern of CNS activation. In addition, as for other
demonstrated that nonalcohol-dependent offspring of
substances, study results may vary based on partici-
alcoholics also exhibit P3b amplitude decrements. This
pants’ severity of dependence, length of chronicity,
work along with other research examining family
time since last use of an illicit stimulant, and comorbid-
history of substance use disorders has lead to a growing
ity in terms of other addictions and psychiatric
series of twin studies, suggesting that P3b amplitude to
conditions.
visual stimuli may be an endophenotype or biomarker
for the development of externalizing behavior disorders Illicit Stimulants and qEEG
including substance use disorders. However, not all P3
Acutely, cocaine produces rapid increases in absolute
studies examining family history have found consistent
theta, alpha, and beta power over the prefrontal cortex,
effects; some have suggested that these effects may be
persisting up to approximately 25 min, although level
better accounted for by other common comorbid factors
of experience with cocaine may influence the extent of
such as conduct disorder/antisocial personality, and
drug action (e.g. tolerance or reverse tolerance effects).
other related features (i.e. impulsivity). Again, most of
In particular, cocaine-related increases in theta power
these studies have been conducted with male partici-
have been correlated with the subjectively positive
pants, thus the picture for females is less clear.
effects of cocaine. Overall, research suggests that the
An interesting development in recent years is the use
prefrontal cortex is activated by both acute cocaine
of EEG/ERP measures in studies of cue reactivity; the
administration and the pleasurable effects of cocaine
P3 has played a significant role in this area. Research
on the brain’s reward pathways (i.e. ventral
has demonstrated enhanced P3 amplitudes to alcohol-
tegmental–nucleus accumbens–prefrontal cortex).
related stimuli in individuals with a history of alcohol
Chronic cocaine use tends to be associated with
use disorders, indicating an attentional bias for
decreased absolute and relative power in the delta
alcohol-related cues. Further, individuals low in
band and increased relative alpha power. Although
alcohol sensitivity, who report needing more alcohol
causation cannot be inferred from such studies, it is
to experience subjective alcohol-related effects versus
interesting to note that these abnormalities may persist
those high in sensitivity, tend to exhibit larger P3
even after 6 months of abstinence, suggesting a persis-
amplitudes to alcohol cues. This sensitivity effect may
tent neurobiological alteration resulting from chronic
be specific to alcohol cues versus other arousing cues.
cocaine exposure. Of course, because pre-addiction
The P3 has been used to explore alcohol expectancies
measures are not possible in quasi-experimental studies
as well. In general, the higher the individual’s self-
of this nature, it is unknown whether or not these alter-
reported positive/arousing expectancies, the larger
ations resulted from cocaine use or if preexisting qEEG
the P3 amplitude in response to negative alcohol expec-
abnormalities might have predisposed these patients
tancy stimuli.
to addiction.
• ERN: Acutely, alcohol reduces ERN and Pe Although EEG/ERP studies of chronic methamphet-
amplitudes during a cognitive control task, amine abusers have increased in recent years, the litera-
suggesting that alcohol may have an attenuating effect ture remains relatively sparse with regard to this issue.

II. NEUROSCIENCE
386 38. HUMAN NEUROPHYSIOLOGY: EEG AND QUANTITATIVE EEG IN ADDICTION RESEARCH

However, existing research suggests that increased theta (EPN) relevant to cue reactivity. Among individuals
power may be associated with poorer performance on with cocaine use disorders, LPP amplitude generally
working memory tests among recently abstinent meth- appears to be enhanced following presentation of
amphetamine abusers. Overall, the neuroelectric profile cocaine-related versus neutral stimuli. Level of self-
of recently abstinent methamphetamine-dependent reported cocaine craving has also been positively
participants is consistent with generalized encephalop- associated with LPP amplitudes. However, these
athy. The issue of persistent neurobiological alterations effects may be modulated by recency of cocaine use.
among chronic abusers is particularly relevant to studies A 2011 study reported that while early LPP (400–
of methamphetamine, which by nature of its enhanced 1000 ms poststimulus) amplitude to cocaine pictures
lipid solubility, might be expected to create lasting was enhanced in both “abstinent” and “currently
neuronal changes. using” participants versus controls, late LPP
amplitude (1000–2000 ms poststimulus) was
Illicit Stimulants and ERPs enhanced for abstinent participants but attenuated
among current users.
Currently, most of the work in this area appears to
have focused on cocaine use; however, studies of meth-
amphetamine’s effects are on the rise.
• N200: Decrements of frontal lobe (i.e. executive)
Opiates
function are frequently noted among chronic cocaine The available research on human neurophysiology
abusers. Electrophysiological correlates of these associated with opiate-related drug disorders has
deficits are often elicited using flanker tasks with Go/ largely been conducted on heroin users, although recent
NoGo features. Described in simple terms, these are work has begun to expand beyond this type of sample.
tasks in which one class of stimulus requires A significant proportion of the patient samples in these
a behavioral response, whereas another requires the studies also tend to abuse other substances, particularly
participant to refrain from responding. Such tasks alcohol, nicotine, cocaine, and prescription drugs. Thus,
require a variety of executive functions, including separating the individual effects of opiate use is one of
cortical inhibition, selection of appropriate responses the biggest challenges in this area. However, several
from among several competing ones, withholding studies have demonstrated consistent results and have
inappropriate responses, and the ability to detect error focused, in particular, on the effects of withdrawal.
and exercise corrective control. Within this context,
the N200 ERP is considered to reflect inhibitory Opiates and qEEG
executive functions in Go/NoGo tasks and conflict Few studies that have examined the acute effects of
monitoring in tasks that elicit incompatible response opioids on qEEG have primarily used morphine-like
tendencies. Decreased N200 amplitude and delayed drugs and report increases in theta and delta power
latency are often noted among chronic cocaine and decreases in alpha and beta power in both opioid
abusers and may reflect an inability to override users and surgical patients. Alpha slowing also appears
automatic addiction-related cognitions and behaviors. to be highly dependent on dosage. One placebo-
• P300: Cocaine-dependent individuals often exhibit controlled study of self- versus passive-administration
decreased amplitude and delayed latency of the P3, of fentanyl, a synthetic mu-opioid agonist, in heroin-
elicited by the classic oddball paradigm. Such dependent, methadone-maintained individuals, reported
decrements are thought to reflect a generalized deficit increased delta power with fentanyl administration.
of attentional functions in chronic cocaine abusers. However, when fentanyl was self-administered, the
Other studies have noted a negative correlation increase in delta was doubled, highlighting the reinforc-
between P3 amplitude and impulsivity, and this ing nature of the drug.
finding appears to be independent of childhood Early qEEG studies of individuals with chronic opiate
conduct disorder symptoms. use tend to report increased slow wave activity
compared to nondrug using controls, even after
Similarly, methamphetamine-dependent individuals
extended periods of abstinence (up to 6 months in
also exhibit P3 decrements, which appear to be indepen-
many cases). Increased relative beta 2 power has been
dent of methamphetamine psychosis. These persistent
demonstrated in abstinent heroin users, as well. Recent
decrements support the notion of long-term neurophys-
work has utilized rigorous methodological approaches
iological alterations of the cortex in chronic metham-
to explore functional cortical connectivity in the alpha
phetamine abusers.
and beta frequencies in relation to opiate withdrawal.
• Cue reactivity: Much of this work has revealed a late Functional connectivity refers to the temporal correla-
positive potential (LPP) and early positive negativity tion between spatially distanced events (e.g. separate

II. NEUROSCIENCE
EEG AND ERP FINDINGS BY ADDICTIVE SUBSTANCE 387
groups of neurons firing synchronously), and thus is performed worse than controls. Although not
thought to reflect coordination of neuronal areas or statistically significant, a similar pattern was
systems. The basic theory underlying this approach is demonstrated for the auditory P3 in which the opioid-
that chronic opiate use results in disrupted or rear- dependent men exhibited the smallest P3 amplitude
ranged neuronal assemblies, which in turn, affects and longest P3 latencies, and the brothers exhibited
neuronal communication (i.e. produces a different smaller P3 amplitudes and longer latencies compared
pattern of neural synchrony between brain regions) to the controls. Taken together, these findings are
and subsequently disrupts neurocognitive processing consistent with P3 findings with other substances,
and behavior. Most of this work suggests that individ- particularly alcohol, indicating deficits in attentional
uals with a history of opiate use exhibit a different resource allocation in opioid-dependent individuals
pattern of functional connectivity that is directly related (in withdrawal) as well as some attentional bias
to the severity of their withdrawal symptoms and that toward rewarding cues. This work also supports the
this facilitates drug-seeking behavior and reduces the aforementioned alcohol research on the P300 as
efficiency of rehabilitation. In addition, individuals in a potential endophenotype for substance use risk.
opiate withdrawal exhibit a slowing of the EEG which
can be restored via methadone treatment.
Opiates and ERPs Hallucinogens
• MMN: In the only published study examining MMN Neurophysiological correlates of hallucinogenic drugs
in abstinent opioid-dependent men and women, the are not well studied, although a growing body of work
MMN latency to novel sounds was delayed now exists primarily for two hallucinogenic substances:
suggesting deficits in pre-attentive auditory 3,4-methylenedioxymethamphetamine (MDMA or
processing. The MMN is thought to be modulated by ecstasy) and marijuana (MJ). An important consideration
changes in dopamine such as attenuated MMN for these studies is that ecstasy users, and often MJ users
responses after acute administration of a dopamine D2 as well, tend to be polydrug abusers, thus it is difficult to
antagonist. Thus this finding in opioid-dependent completely isolate the effects of these specific drugs in
individuals is hypothesized to be related to the studies of chronic use.
important role of dopamine in neural mechanisms of
3,4-Methylenedioxymethamphetamine
reward; additional study is needed to further identify
and Quantitative EEG
how the MMN is connected to dopamine function in
the context of attentional processing. In healthy volunteers, acute MDMA administration
• P300: Several studies have described P3 amplitude results in a decrease in slow and medium wave activity,
decrements and prolonged P3 latency among opioid- particularly decreased frontal delta, a global decrease in
dependent individuals in withdrawal. Interestingly, theta activity, and decreased alpha activity in fronto-
active heroin users tend to exhibit normalized P3 parietal regions. Acute MDMA also results in increased
amplitude, thus emphasizing the severe impact of beta activity, most prominent in the orbitofrontal cortex
opiate withdrawal on cognitive and attentional and anterior temporal lobes, which is hypothesized to
processes. Another study demonstrated reduced play an important role in the enhanced mood effects of
auditory P3 amplitude in heroin and/or cocaine MDMA.
addicts, but those addicts with a history of A study of resting EEG in recreational ecstasy users
dysregulated aggression exhibited even smaller P3 revealed a positive correlation between chronic MDMA
amplitudes than those without. Studies of emotional use and both alpha and beta powers. A negative correla-
processing in abstinent heroin addicts report small P3 tion between MDMA use and delta power was also
amplitudes in response to unpleasant and neutral demonstrated. MDMA use was also inversely correlated
emotional stimuli, but not to pleasant stimuli with performance on a test of frontal lobe function. The
suggesting a bias toward positive emotional cues. authors interpreted these results as evidence that
This is further supported by evidence of enhanced P3 MDMA produces mild frontal lobe impairment related
amplitudes in response to opiate-related images as to impulsivity; however, this study did not include
compared to the P3 response to emotional and neutral a nondrug using comparison group.
images in recently detoxified heroin addicts, some of
3,4-Methylenedioxymethamphetamine
which were methadone maintained. A study in
and Event-Related Potentials
opioid-dependent men and their full brothers found
that the opioid-dependent men performed worst on • Mid-latency ERPs: Auditory intensity dependence
a battery of neurocognitive measures compared to paradigms examine mid-latency ERPs (P1, N1, and
their brothers and control men, and the brothers P2) in response to increasing stimulus intensities,

II. NEUROSCIENCE
388 38. HUMAN NEUROPHYSIOLOGY: EEG AND QUANTITATIVE EEG IN ADDICTION RESEARCH

which has been linked to serotonergic functioning. In Other Addictions and EEG/ERP
general, MDMA users exhibit greater intensity
dependence (i.e. increased N1–P2 amplitudes with In addition to drugs, which may be thought to hijack
increasing stimulus intensity), which is indicative of the brain’s natural reward processes, other substances
serotonergic dysfunction. These findings also appear and activities may also appropriate these dopaminergic
to be independent of MJ use and related to the level of pathways, leading to addictive preoccupations that
MDMA consumption. However, a longitudinal study affect daily activities. Recent research has focused on
applied this paradigm to a small sample of polydrug disordered eating, ranging from anorexia to binge eating
ecstasy users and reported no significant and obesity, as well as gambling behaviors.
neurophysiological changes between the two time
points (18 months apart). Disordered Eating
• N200: Slower N200 latencies have been reported in Individuals with eating disorders (e.g. anorexia and
MDMA users compared to controls during a facial bulimia) may exhibit facilitated processing of food-related
emotion discrimination task. This has been images versus standard emotional and neutral pictures, as
interpreted as evidence of a delayed attention deficit indexed by early posterior negativity (220–310 ms) in the
as a result of MDMA use. ERP. In contrast, controls may demonstrate facilitated
• P300: Studies of P3 in ecstasy users have yielded mixed processing only for high-calorie food images. Further,
results with some studies reporting P3b findings food availability manipulations may modulate ERPs
consistent with most substance use disorders, namely, to food cues among restrained eaters. Similarities between
reduced P3b amplitude and longer P3b latency. food cue reactivity among eating disordered individuals
However, most of these studies included polydrug and substance cue reactivity among addicted populations
ecstasy abusers and these effects do not appear to be highlight the common mechanisms for behaviors utilizing
differentiated from those found in MJ users. the reward pathway (see Common Neural Mechanisms in
Obesity and Drug Addiction).
On the other side of the spectrum, women with binge
eating disorder appear to differ from overweight control
Marijuana and Quantitative EEG participants in terms of their long latency ERPs to
Studies of acute MJ exposure report global decreases in pictures of high- versus low-calorie foods. In this case,
theta power and frontal beta power in conjunction with high-calorie foods may have high motivation properties
lower accuracy and slowed reaction times on behavioral and consume significant attentional resources. This
tasks. MJ exposure has also been associated with “alpha pattern is similar to what is seen in other addictions
hyperfrontality” (increased power over the frontal where binging occurs.
cortex) in daily MJ users. Given the controversy, both in To further substantiate the parallel between addiction
the research literature and societal perception regarding and preoccupation with food, one might predict that the
neurotoxic effects of MJ, these findings do suggest that responses of obese or food-addicted individuals to food-
MJ is associated with subtle, but adverse effects. related stimuli would be similar to cue-related activation
within substance-dependent individuals. In fact,
research has demonstrated a P200 ERP bias to food-
related words among obese participants, suggesting
Marijuana and Event-Related Potentials a heightened automaticity that may contribute to exces-
Acute MJ exposure results in reduced P3 amplitude sive eating behaviors. However, it is important to
during working memory tasks as well as smaller ampli- acknowledge that only a portion of those with obesity
tudes for attentional components (e.g. N200). The N400 show characteristics of addiction (see Common Neural
ERP (detection of novelty in language processing) is Mechanisms in Obesity and Drug Addiction).
also adversely affected. It is not clear, however, whether
these results are the direct result of MJ’s neurochemical Pathological Gambling
effects or are indirectly related to the reduced motiva- Much of the work on EEG/ERP correlates of gambling
tional capacity experienced during MJ intoxication. In behaviors has taken place at a more basic level, focusing
terms of chronic effects, Native Americans meeting on neurophysiological indices of reward sensitivity
criteria for MJ dependence alone and those with MJ and evoked by “gambling” tasks among controls. Although
other drug dependence both exhibit prolonged P350 it is believed that individuals who develop problematic
and P450 latencies in response to a facial discrimination gambling behaviors may exhibit pathological levels of
task as compared to nondrug users. These results support reward sensitivity, little work has been done in terms of
the notion that MJ dependence is associated with delays EEG/ERPs among groups of pathological gamblers.
in processing and identifying emotional stimuli. Existing data suggest that the feedback negativity ERP

II. NEUROSCIENCE
SUMMARY 389
appears to be sensitive to reward versus nonreward feed- As mentioned previously, EEG/ERP measures have
back and outcome expectation. Compared to low-risk been increasingly used in studies of cue reactivity or atten-
conditions, high-risk conditions evoke a more negative tional bias. Substance-dependent individuals exhibit
ERP deflection in areas overlying frontocentral brain enhancements of some ERPs, such as the LPP, elicited by
regions. This is thought to occur because high-risk condi- stimuli related to their drug of choice (versus neutral
tions lead to higher conflict between participants’ moti- images), and this enhancement is related to drug-taking
vationally based tendencies and task instructions. From characteristics such as recency of use and level of craving
a qEEG perspective, both theta and delta activities have for the drug. Such responses closely parallel cue-reactivity
also been correlated to various aspects of the decision- data obtained using other techniques, such as behavioral
making process. Perhaps the most consistent finding is and eye-tracking measures. Using behavioral techniques
a change in theta activity (e.g. greater increase in theta (i.e. reaction time to visual probe tasks), researchers
power negative feedback/losses), occurring 150–350 ms have implemented attentional bias modification (ABM)
post-feedback, which appears to be related to the valence training among groups of substance-dependent partici-
(e.g. positive or negative psychological value) that the pants with the goal of changing attentional biases and
participant assigns to his or her performance. influencing subjective craving and drug-seeking behav-
In an exception to the trend toward “basic” iors. Although this growing body of research suggests
approaches, ERPs have been compared in problem that a single session is not sufficient to affect long-term
gamblers and controls using a computerized Black Jack changes in behavior, ABM training does appear to be
game. Problem gamblers tend to perseverate in making a promising target for future research. Given the amena-
high-risk decisions, even though such decisions have bility of EEG/ERPs to the study of cue reactivity/atten-
led to failures in the past (i.e. the “gambler’s fallacy”). tional bias, it is possible that this methodology could
This pattern is not apparent among controls, who are provide a more complete picture of the psychophysiolog-
more likely to make conservative decisions and to learn ical correlates of successful ABM training.
from their mistakes. When compared to controls,
problem gamblers show more frontocentrally distributed
reward-related positive amplitudes 270–320 ms after
SUMMARY
presentation of the card which leads to a “bust” (e.g.
Taken together, the body of research on EEG/ERPs
failure) or “no bust” result. The level of risk taking has
and related techniques in addictions is vast, innovative,
been positively correlated with amplitude differences
informative, and shows no signs of stopping. Although
between task conditions (“bust” versus “no bust”).
human neurophysiology may be considered one of the
Such findings suggest that high-risk-taking behavior in
older techniques in addictions research, it is clear that
problem gamblers is associated with an increased
recent advancements in methodology and theory will
reward-related neural response to infrequent successes.
pave the way for an even more comprehensive body of
research in this area. Neurophysiological measures
posses several advantages for assessing neural function
TREATMENT IMPLICATIONS
in terms of risk for and effects of addictive substances
and behaviors. These include technical features such as
Although EEG/ERPs have been applied to addic-
high temporal resolution during assessment, but also
tion research primarily with regard to determining
practical points such as the ability to identify subtle
neurophysiological effects of, or risk for, addictive
changes or features that may not always manifest them-
disorders, the past decade has produced research sug-
selves behaviorally. The extant literature provides
gesting that it may also prove useful in treatment
evidence for possible neurotoxic effects of various
contexts. The use of brain wave biofeedback, a process
substance of abuse, opportunities for exploring new treat-
that allows an individual to learn how to change phys-
ment avenues, and potential tools to help identify those
iological activity to improve health and/or perfor-
most at risk. The future of human neurophysiology in
mance, has been examined in addictive disordered
addictions lies in the combination of these measures
samples. Although initial studies were mixed with
with other techniques and study disciplines, including
regard to success, biofeedback has received more
behavioral, neuroimaging, and genetic approaches.
recent attention and systematic study with regard to
addictions. Essentially the EEG provides a measure
of ongoing electrocortical activity which the individual SEE ALSO
uses as a guide for inducing physiological changes
such as a more relaxed state. These studies have Neuropsychological Precursors and Consequences of
been applied to a wide range of addictions including Addiction, Common Neural Mechanisms in Obesity and
alcohol, cocaine, heroin, and MJ. Drug Addiction, Addiction and the Human Adolescent

II. NEUROSCIENCE
390 38. HUMAN NEUROPHYSIOLOGY: EEG AND QUANTITATIVE EEG IN ADDICTION RESEARCH

Brain, Intermediate Phenotypes/Endophenotypes and Abuse: Research, Clinical, and Forensic Applications. Humana
Pathways to Addiction, Alcohol Neuroimaging in Press, Totowa, NJ, pp. 77–112.
Campanella, S., Noël, X., Tomberg, C., 2010. Cognitive event-related
Humans potentials and alcoholism. Journal of Psychophysiology 24, 231–
239.
Ceballos, N.A., Bauer, L.O., Houston, R.J., 2009. EEG/ERP and
List of Abbreviations substance use disorders. Clinical EEG and Neuroscience 40, 122–
ABM attentional bias modification 128.
CNS central nervous system Fabianai, M., Gratton, G., Federmeier, K., 2007. Event-related brain
CNV contingent negative variation potentials: methods, theory and applications. In: Cacioppo, J.T.,
EEG electroencephalography Tassinary, L.G., Berntson, G.G. (Eds.), Handbook of Psycho-
ERN error-related negativity physiology, third ed. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge,
ERP event-related brain potential U.K., pp. 85–119.
FHP family history positive Knott, V.J., 2001. Electroencephalographic characterization of cigarette
fMRI functional magnetic resonance imaging smoking behavior. Alcohol 24, 95–97.
LPP late positive potential Pizzagalli, D., 2007. Electroencephalography and high density elec-
LVA low voltage alpha activity trophysiological source localization. In: Cacioppo, J.T.,
MDMA 3,4-methylenedioxymethamphetamine Tassinary, L.G., Berntson, G.G. (Eds.), Handbook of Psychophys-
MJ marijuana iology, third ed. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK,
MMN mismatch negativity pp. 56–84.
Pe error positivity Porjesz, B., Begleiter, H., 2003. Alcoholism and human electrophysi-
qEEG quantitative electroencephalography ology. Alcohol Research and Health 27, 153–160.
RRN rareness-related negativity Porjesz, B., Rangaswamy, M., Kamarajan, C., Jones, K.A.,
Padmanabhapillai, A., Begleiter, H., 2005. The utility of neuro-
physiological markers in the study of alcoholism. Clinical Neuro-
Further Reading physiology 116, 993–1018.
Pritchard, W., Sokhadze, E., Houlihan, M., 2004. Effects of nicotine and
Bauer, L.O., 2001. Electroencephalographic studies of substance use smoking on event-related potentials: a review. Nicotine and
and abuse. In: Kaufman, M.J. (Ed.), Brain Imaging in Substance Tobacco Research 6, 961–984.

II. NEUROSCIENCE

You might also like