Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Mortgage Instruments
Jing Li
October 8, 2023
Mortgage Instruments
To facilitate the flow of credit from lenders to borrowers, various mortgage instruments
have been developed.
I Fixed-rate mortgage (FRM)
I A fixed-rate mortgage has the same interest rate and monthly payment throughout
the term of the mortgage. The payment is calculated to pay off the mortgage
balance at the end of the term. The most common terms are 15 years and 30 years.
I Adjustable-rate mortgage (ARM)
I The monthly payment is calculated to pay off the entire mortgage balance at the
end of the term. The term is typically 30 years. After any fixed interest rate period
has passed, the interest rate and payment adjust at the frequency specified.
Definition:
I Money has the capacity to earn interest rate over time. Therefore, money
available at the present time is worth more than the same amount in the future.
Example
I Assuming a 5% interest rate, $100 invested today will be worth $105 in one year
($100 multiplied by 1.05). Conversely, $100 received one year from now is only
worth $95.24 today ($100 divided by 1.05), assuming a 5% interest rate.
1
PVIFi,n =
(1 + i)n
(1 + i)n − 1
PVIFAi,n =
i(1 + i)n
Suppose You Borrow $100, 000 @ 7.50% for 30 Years, what is your Monthly Payment?
Ans:
The maturity n and yield to maturity i can be adjusted for any length compounding
period by measuring time in compounding periods and i as a periodic rate.
I If the mortgage is compounded monthly, then n = number of years times twelve,
and the monthly period rate im is the annual periodic rate ia divided by 12.
I Example
Calculate the required monthly payment Calculate the maximum loan size you can
if maturity is 30 years, annual interest rate borrow if you can pay $1000 per month,
is 8% and principal is $ 150,000 the annual interest rate is 7.5%, and the
maturity is 25 years.
Calculate the maturity of a loan Calculate the interest rate of a loan if the
if the monthly payment is $ 843.86, principal amount of the loan is $ 175,000, the
the principal balance is $ 100,000 monthly payment is $ 1,367.36 and the matu-
and the interest rate is 6% rity of the loan is 30 years.
In real estate, we frequently need to know what the remaining unpaid balance of the
loan will be at some future date.
I A borrower is thinking about selling their home (and paying off their mortgage) or
refinancing
I A borrower is considering whether to default
I The lender applies a new interest rate to the outstanding balance on an
adjustable-rate mortgage
I Interest charges in a given year depend on the outstanding balance on the loan
Example:
I Calculate the remaining balance after 12 payments for a mortgage loan with an
original balance of $100,000, loan rate of 8%, and original term of 30 years.
Divide PV into two groups of payments, from the first 12 months and the remaining
348 months . . .
12 360
X PMT X PMT
PV = t
+
(1 + i) (1 + i)t
t=1 t=13
Calculate the remaining balance after 12 payments for a mortgage loan with an original
balance of $100,000, loan rate of 8%, and original term of 30 years.
Key Point
I The unpaid principal balance on a loan is equal to the present value of all
remaining payments discounted using the contractual interest rate.
Step 3: Calculate the principal paid in the first month as the change in balance upon
making the first payment
I Principal paid in first month = 100,000 – 99,900.45 = 99.55
Jing Li (SMU) Mortgage Instruments 15/70
Loan Amortization
Calculate the interest paid in the first month for the same loan.
Step 1: Determine the total monthly payment and the principal paid in the first
month, as before
I Monthly payment = 599.55
I Principal paid in the first month = 99.55
Step 2: Calculate interest paid in the first month as the difference between the total
payment and principal paid
I Interest paid in first month = 599.55 – 99.55 = 500.00
Alternative Method
I Interest paid in month k is equal to im ∗ PVk (where PVk is the value of PV at
the beginning of period k before any payments are made)
I Interest paid in the first month = 500.00
Jing Li (SMU) Mortgage Instruments 16/70
Loan Amortization
Decomposing payments: Payment = Principal (PPk) + Interest (Ik). From our
previous calculations
(1 + i)n − 1 PMT
PVn = PMT ( )=
i(1 + i)n MCi,n
Principal payment in period k equals the difference in balance in period k and period k-1
(1 + i)k − 1 (1 + i)k−1 − 1 1 + i 1
PPk = PMT ( k
) − PMT ( )· = PMT ( )
i(1 + i) i(1 + i)k−1 1+i (1 + i)k
Interest payment in k equals the difference between PMT and PPk. This also equals the
periodic loan rate times the outstanding balance
1 (1 + i)k − 1 PMT
Ik = PMT − PMT ( k
) = PMT ( )=i· = i · PVi,k
(1 + i) (1 + i)k MCi,k
Lenders frequently charge fees for originating a new loan. These cover the cost of
underwriting the loan, appraising the property, and the lender’s time and effort in
making the loan.
Sometimes, lenders also allow borrowers to purchase points upfront in order to reduce
the contractual interest rate (will not discuss this in detail).
How do these fees affect the borrower’s true cost of borrowing?
A lender offers a $100,000 FRM loan to a borrower with the following terms:
I Maturity: 30 years
I Interest rate: 8%
I Total loan fees: $3,000
Because we are accustomed to thinking in terms of annual rates, the accepted custom
is to multiply this monthly rate by 12:
I 0.69364*12 = 8.32%
We call this annualized rate the true annual nominal (mortgage) rate or the Annual
Percentage Rate (APR).
A lender offers a $100,000 FRM loan to a borrower with the following terms:
I Maturity: 30 years
I Interest rate: 8%
I Total loan fees: $3,000
In calculating the APR of 8.32% for the loan with $3,000 of fees of the earlier
example, we assumed that the borrower paid the loan over 30 years.
A lender offers a $100,000 FRM loan to a borrower with the following terms:
I Maturity: 30 years
I Interest rate: 8%
I Total loan fees: $3,000
In calculating the APR of 8.32% for the loan with $3,000 of fees of the earlier
example, we assumed that the borrower paid the loan over 30 years.
I Is this normally what happens? No!
I People often move or refinance their original loan when the interest rate drops.
What if you take out the loan described in the example where you pay the $3,000 in
fees but move after five years? What is your effective borrowing cost?
To calculate the effective cost of your loan, we need to calculate the discounted value
of the payments you actually make.
I You will make 60 payments
I You then pay the remaining balance of your loan
If the loan was held to maturity, there would be 360 periodic payments and no balance
due at the end of the loan (FV = 0)
Now we need to determine the outstanding balance after 60 payments have been made
in order to be able to solve for the i = r/12 that equates the RHS of the TVM
expression with the LHS.
t=60
X 733.76 UPB60
97, 000 = r t + r 60
(1 + 12 ) (1 + 12 )
t=1
PV = 95,069.26
Recall that if the borrower had held the loan to maturity, the effective cost = 8.32%
Is prepayment a bad thing for the borrower and a good thing for the banker?
I Not necessary!
A borrower took out an FRM with a loan amount of $200,000 (compounds annually)
and the following terms:
I Maturity: 25 yrs
I Interest rate: 4%
I A prepayment penalty of 1.5% of outstanding balance and transaction costs of
$1500 (assume both can be financed with the new mortgage)
I A maturity of any remortgage deal equal to the number of years remaining for
prepayment of the original loan
Under these assumptions, show only if the interest rate falls below percent,
remortgaging at the end of the 7th year will make economic sense.
Cash-out refinancing often occurs when the underlying housing asset appreciates in
value.
It involves both substituting a new loan for an existing loan and getting some extra
cash on the strength of one’s remaining equity in the property.
Take a borrower who still owes $50,000 on a $150,000 property as an example.
I In a typical refinancing, he or she would substitute a new loan equal to $50,000
for the balance owed.
I In cash-out refinancing, he or she might go for an $80,000 loan.
I The $80,000 loan would repay the old balance outstanding, and the remainder will
be cash left at the borrower’s disposal.
I The new $80,000 loan results in a loan-to-value ratio of about 53%, which is still
considered a safe deal for the bank.
I Other ways of tapping into one’s home equity
I Home equity loan (HELOAN)
I Home equity line of credit (HELOC)
Five years ago a borrower incurred a mortgage for $80,000 at 10% for 30 years,
monthly payments. Currently, the market rate is 8% on 25-year mortgages. The
existing mortgage has a prepayment penalty of 5% of the outstanding balance at
prepayment for the first 10 years of the mortgage and the lender will charge 4%
financing cost on the new loan. The borrower’s opportunity investment rate is 8%.
The borrower is considering refinancing the payoff of the loan (remaining balance +
prepayment penalty)
(a) If the borrower plans to hold either mortgage (existing mortgage or the new
mortgage) for the next 25 years, should she refinance?
(b) If the borrower plans to hold the mortgage for 8 more years, should she refinance
under the conditions in part a?
(c) Assume everything in part (a) except that, instead of refinancing the outstanding
balance, the borrower borrows $100,000 (cash-out refinancing), should she refinance?
(a) If the borrower plans to hold either mortgage (existing mortgage or the new
mortgage) for the next 25 years, should she refinance?
Existing Loan PMT = 80,000 (MC10,30) = $702.06
Balance EOY5 = $77,259m
Payoff of Existing Mortgage = $77,259 (1.05) = $81,122
New Loan PMT = $81,122 (MC8,25 ) = $626.11
Financing Costs of New Loan = $81,122 (0.04) = $3,245
NPV = (702.06 – 626.11) (PVIFA8,25 ) – 3,245 = 9,840 – 3,245 = $6,595
(b) If the borrower plans to hold the mortgage for 8 more years, should she refinance
under the conditions in part a?
Balance of Existing Loan at end of year 13 = $68,748
Balance of New Loan at end of year 8 = $69,703
NPV = 75.95(PVIFA8,8 ) − (69, 703 − 68, 748)(PVIFA8,8 ) − 3, 245 = $1, 623
(c) Assume everything in part (a) except that, instead of refinancing the outstanding
balance, the borrower borrows $100,000 (cash-out refinancing), should she refinance?
Financing Costs of New Loan = $100, 000(0.04) = $4, 000
New Loan PMT = 100, 000(MC8,25 ) = $771.82
NPV = −(771.82 − 702.06)(PVIFA8,25 ) + 18, 878 − 4, 000
NPV = −9, 038 + 18, 878 − 4, 000 = $5, 840
Recall that Mian and Sufi (2011)’s argument for direct home-equity-based borrowing
channel:
The mortgage contract describes the promised future cash flows associated with a
mortgage.
I Cash flows depend on maturity, coupon rate, timing of payments
I Treating these cash flows as certain, we can calculate the present value for
different discount rates.
The same is true for all financial products with future cash flows.
N
X CFt
PV (d) =
(1 + d)t
t=1
There has been a dramatic increase in the level and volatility of inflation in the 1970s.
I → Inflation: 6% in 1970; 3.4% in 1972; and 13.3% in 1979
Alternative mortgage instruments were designed in the 1980s to reduce the impact of
interest rate risk and mitigate the “tilt” problem, including ARMs – adjustable rate
mortgage.
An ARM is a loan on which the periodic contractual interest rate can change over the
life of the mortgage.
The rate is reset periodically to a fixed spread (called the margin) over a benchmark or
reference rate.
I The Most common reference rate is the short-term treasury rate as determined by
current market conditions.
I Margin: the amount, in basis points, added to the index to arrive at the contract
rate for the loan
I Ranges from 150 to 275 basis points
I Once stated in the mortgage contract, the margin cannot change for that loan.
I Example: if the index is 6% and the margin is 150 basis points, the rate on the loan
will be 7.5%.
I Interest rate caps: periodic adjustment rate cap and life-of-loan rate cap
I The periodic adjustment rate cap places a limit on how much the contract rate can
change at each date of adjustment.
I The life-of-loan rate cap establishes a ceiling that the contract rate can never exceed.
ARM rates are generally lower than 15-year or 30-year FRM rates.
ARM helps the lender to reduce interest rate risk, hence the lender is willing to accept
a lower rate of return.
Rate varies over time and across loan types mainly due to differences in index.
Jing Li (SMU) Mortgage Instruments 53/70
Index
The periodic rate on an ARM is typically set as a fixed spread over an index or a
benchmark rate.
For example, the contract rate on an ARM can be set at 275 basis points over the
one-year Treasury rate.
I To find the rate on the loan, we look up the one-year Treasury rate (say 1.5% in
2004) and add 275 basis points to it to get the annual contract rate of 4.25%.
I The monthly periodic rate is set to 4.25/12 for 12 months.
I At the end of the 12 months, the contract rate is “reset” to 275 basis points
above the then-current one-year Treasury rate.
I If the Treasury rate rises to 4.5% (as in 2006) the mortgage contract rate could
rise to 7.25%.
In order to provide some protection for borrowers, ARMs provide limits on how much
the loan rate and/or payment can change.
I Lifetime limits or caps on how high the interest rate can rise are common
I Life caps are often in the 5% to 6% (500 to 600 basis points) range
I Periodic rate caps limit how much the rate can change at any one time
I Periodic caps are often in the 1% to 2% (100 to 200 basis points) range
Caps allow for a sharing of interest rate risk between lenders and borrowers.
When an ARM has rate caps, you can think of the rate adjustment process as having
three steps:
Step 1: Calculate the rate as if there were no caps: Index + Margin.
Step 2: See if the rate calculated in Step 1 exceeds the lifetime cap on the loan. If it
does, reduce the rate obtained in Step 1 to the maximum rate allowed by the lifetime
cap.
Step 3: See if the change from the current rate to the rate calculated in Step 2
exceeds the periodic limit. If it does, set the rate equal to the old rate plus (or minus)
the periodic limit.
ARM rates adjust over the life of the loan based on a formula of index + margin,
subject to caps. However, the initial loan rate is not constrained by any specific
formula.
I In one earlier example, we have set the initial rate to the current index rate plus
the margin.
I In fact, it is often the case that lenders offer initial rates below the index +
margin.
I These lower initial rates are typically called “Teaser Rates.”
I Lower the borrower’s initial monthly payment
I Lower the lifetime cap if it is specified as the initial rate plus a maximum % increase
in the loan rate
I Cause future payments to increase at the first reset of the loan even if index values
do not change