Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Maria Ressa
A publication of the Center for Global Peace Journalism at Park University Vol. 11, No. 2 Oct. 2022
April 2022 October 2022
Contents I’ve been privileged to work on dozens of peace journalism
projects in 28 countries face-to-face, and another 15 or so
stories of mutual interest on the environment, agriculture,
health, and business. They’ll be publishing these jointly
4 Hawaii 18 Pakistan-India via Zoom. Of all these projects, none has been as gratify-
ing to me as my work on a cross border reporting project
reported stories this fall in media across South Asia and,
we hope, worldwide.
EWC international media conf. Films unite auteurs, viewers that brought together Pakistani and Indian journalists. We
Cover Photo by East-West Center
7 Nepal recently met in Nepal for a work- Cross border, boundary-busting collaborations are the very
Editor’s
The Peace Journalist is a semi- shop. (See pg. 7). essence of peace journalism. PJ, after all, seeks to reduce
annual publication of the Center Indian, Pakistani journalists gather tensions through eliminating inflammatory and demoniz-
for Global Peace Journalism at Park It was inspiring to see these sup- ing language, and rejecting “us vs. them” narratives. I have
University in Parkville, Missouri. The 9 Twitter Notebook posed enemies working together
as professional journalists while
been inspired to continue developing projects with a cross
boundary reporting theme. There is no better way to plant
Peace Journalist is dedicated to dis- Study on peace discourse
seminating news and information developing friendships in the pro- the seeds of peace than through this type of people-to-
for teachers, students, and
practitioners of PJ.
10 Ukraine cess. The Indians and Pakistanis are teaming up to report people contact and collaboration. -Steven Youngblood
missions about peace projects, but Journalism in conflicted societies Peace Journalism for re-
Pratyush Ranjan (pg. 6) is participatory arts at Cardiff
search to facilitate conflict
are instead focused only on articles
with a strong media angle. 14 Italy 24 Cameroon a digital journalist who has
18 years in different digital
transformation. Contact Gi-
uliana at giulianatiripelli@
University, in
the school of
Theater for Peace Female journalists voice concerns newsrooms handling edito- gmail.com and @iulikravitz. Journalism, Jake Lynch (pg. 22) teaches
Deadlines: March 3 (April edition);
September 3 (October edition). 16 Kenya 26 War, Peace Stories rial and product related
responsibilities. Pratyush is a Emma Lygnerud Boberg
Media, and
Culture.
on the new Master of Social
Justice degree at the Uni-
Covering the 2022 election with PJ WSPS launches new website certified fact (pg. 10) works as a Gender versity of Sydney. He won
Editor: Steven Youngblood, Director, Advisor at International Me- Wanja Gathu (pg. 16) is a
Center for Global Peace Journalism,
Park University
What is Peace Journalism? checker with
Google News dia Support (IMS). Emma Kenyan Journalist with over
15 years multi-media expe-
the Luxembourg Peace Prize
in 2017 for his
Initiative In- has previous experience
Peace Journalism is when editors and reporters make choices that improve the contributions
dia Training working on gender equality rience, working in both local
Proofreading: Dr. Tom Patterson prospects for peace. These choices, including how to frame stories and care- and international media. to peace
Network. and inclusion in Kyrgyzstan
fully choosing which words are used, create an atmosphere conducive to peace She aspires to world where journism.
and Belarus.
Contact/Social Media: and supportive of peace initiatives and peacemakers, without compromising Faiz Paracha (pg. 7) is a sea- people’s Rosaline Obah Akah (pg.
steve.youngblood@park.edu the basic principles of good journalism. (Adapted from Lynch/McGoldrick, Peace soned broadcast journalist rights are 24) is the national coordina-
Twitter-@Peace Journ Journalism). Peace Journalism gives peacemakers a voice while making peace with over 15 years’ experi- respected tor for the Cameroon Com-
initiatives and non-violent solutions more visible and viable. ence in reporting and edito- and pro- munity Media
Facebook-Peace Journalism group
A number of valuable peace journalism resources, including back issues of rial positions in Pakistan tected. Network, and a
Center for Global Peace
The Peace Journalist can be found at www.park.edu/peacecenter. and abroad. He is a current trainer and spe-
Journalism, Park University Urmi Chanda (pg. 18) is a
Fellow of East West Chema Sarri pg. 12) is a cialist in peace
Parkville, Missouri Harmony Scholar at the Uni-
8700 NW River Park Dr Center for Global Peace Journalism Center’s Cross Border Re- Spanish journalist who
porting Program on Environ- works as a communications
versity of Wales Trinity Saint
David, a culture journalist,
journalism.
The Center for Global Peace Journalism works with journalists, academics, and Faith McClure (pg. 26) is a
ment. He can manager at ICIP (Interna- and a peacebuilder in the
students worldwide to improve reporting about conflicts, societal unrest, rec- multimedia editor, producer,
be reached at tional Catalan Institute making. She moonlights as
onciliation, solutions, and peace. Through its courses, workshops, lectures, this writer, and artist. She studied
fparacha@ for Peace). He has been
magazine, blog, and other resources, the Center encourages media to reject a voice-over religion and ethics at Harvard
gmail.com. a project
sensational and inflammatory reporting, and produce counter-narratives that artist. She University and is
coordinator is based in Operations Manag-
offer a more nuanced view of those who are marginalized—ethnic/racial/ Giuliana Tiripelli (pg. 8) is for different Mumbai, er at War Stories-
A Park University Publication religious minorities, women, youth, LGBTQ individuals, and migrants. Senior Lecturer in Digital organiza- India. Peace Stories.
tions, pub-
pg 2 www.park.edu/peacecenter pg 3
October 2022 October 2022
EWC conference spotlights media trust a little of both. She said it makes her a bigger target league (left) and No-
backgrounds, there were a lot of simi- bel Peace Prize winner
larities as well. (as evidenced by the 7 charges currently filed against
her in the Philippines), but that the prize gives her a Maria Ressa.
The 2022 East-West Center (EWC) interesting topics. My colleague Praty- good listeners, but they are even bet- Ressa’s intellect, insightfulness, and humility that was evident during our chat
this website (journalistsforchange.
International Media Conference ‘Con- ush Rajan (from India) and I (from Pak- ter storytellers. It was mesmerizing to was on display the next day at her keynote address to the conference.
org). They also created a WhatsApp
necting in a Zero Trust World’ was istan) were also speakers on different group which has kept them connected hear their stories of how the media in The keynote’s headline was Ressa’s announcement that Rappler had just re-
held in Honolulu, Hawaii June 26-30. It panels including the East-West Center for the past two years. their country or region face pressure ceived a shut down order from the government. She said Rappler will appeal,
featured 40 speakers from throughout media program “Reporting on Cross- and fend off attacks. noting that the order demonstrates that “the rule of law has been bent to
the Asia-Pacific region, including six Border Issues of Mutual Concern” for The panelists agreed that the cross
Some of the stories hit home about the point that it’s breaking” in the Philippines.
journalists from India and Pakistan Indian and Pakistani journalists. border reporting fellowship helped
who have been participating in a cross them to grow as journalists and what journalists do to push back Ressa went on to detail the avalanche of online hate directed at her because
border reporting project (see pg. 7) Other panelists included Khuldune understand concerns from colleagues against forces trying to silence them. of Rappler’s critical reporting of the Duterte regime and because of her
sponsored by the East West Center. Shahid, Pakistan Correspondent, The from across the border. It was a cultural déjà vu. Journal- elevated profile. At its peak, 90 hate messages per hour were directed at
Participants from 35 Asia-Pacific Diplomat from Lahore, Pakistan; Disha ists from Asia, the Pacific Islands, Ressa, including threats of bodily harm. She defiantly said, “You don’t want
countries attended. Below are reflec- Shetty, Staff Reporter, The Fuller Proj- The best part of this fellowship was the Americas, Australia, Africa, and the threat to rule (your) world…Embrace your fear!”
tions about the conference from two ect from Pune, India; and an indepen- that it allowed journalists a peek into Europe all seemed to live similar lives.
participants. dent multimedia journalist from India their neighboring country and learn- It was clear we are in a world where She noted that her online experience is not atypical since 73% of female jour-
whose name is withheld for security ing how to write balanced pieces on free space is fast shrinking but there nalists experience online hate.
Reflections: reasons . The panel was moderated by mutual topics in a region where emo- are people pushing back.
Lubna Jerar Naqvi, Pakistan Steven Youngblood, Founding Direc- tions run high. So, what can be done to combat what Ressa calls the “toxic sludge” of online
tor, Center for Global Peace Journal- As if there weren’t enough issues, hate and misinformation?
Meeting people from other countries ism, Park University (Missouri, USA). Apart from the Cross-border panel, the digital and social media platforms
helps you to understand their cultures these fellows were also on other pan- have only added another layer for She recommends a “whole society” approach to address social media toxic-
– not only the differences but also The panel spoke about the similarities els including ‘Global Challenges Facing journalists to worry about. On one ity. This approach involves education, establishing legal frameworks, fact
the similarities with your culture and between Pakistan and India - neigh- Women Journalists’; ‘Combating hand, the cyber world has connected checking, and facilitating collaboration on the topic among media, academic,
country. boring countries and ‘traditional Misinformation’; ‘Does America Still people, it has amplified the frequency civil society, religious institutions, and businesses.
rivals’ in Asia. Journalists from both Matter for Asia?; Views on US Influ- and impact of the content shared Ressa concluded her keynote with the
The 2022 East-West Center Interna- countries spoke about the Reporting ence from Senior Regional Journal- online. Journalists know the cyber question, “What will you sacrifice for
tional Media Conference ‘Connecting on Cross-Border Issues of Mutual Con- ists’; ‘Journalism in a State of Emer- world is another frontier to struggle the truth?” It’s a vital question for ev-
in a Zero Trust World’ was a congrega- cern fellowship and the collaborations gency’ and ‘Best Practices in Climate to preserve one’s right to speech and eryone, but especially for journalists.
tion of journalists, scholars, activists, they did with colleagues from across Reporting’. free media.
authors, digital experts, and policy- the border. I’m old and possibly jaded (or, possi-
makers who interacted with each The main event was amazing. But And more and more journalists are bly old and definitely jaded). Even so,
other for almost a week. They also spoke about the website events held on the sidelines of the encountering problems like cyber Ressa quickly won me over. I hope our
they helped create for this fellowship. conference allowed people to meet harassment, cyberbullying, doxing, paths cross again.
Several panel discussions were orga- Cross-border stories by fellows from --Steven Youngblood
nized that covered some extremely Continued on next page
Pakistan and India are uploaded on Continued on next page
pg 4 www.park.edu/peacecenter Vol 11 No 2 pg 5
EWC from Pg 5
October 2022
The East West Center (EWC) spon-
Cross border October 2022
The first plenary session on the “Im-
project meets
sored project “Reporting on Cross- portance and Challenges of Cross-
sexual harassment, and fake content. Border Media Collaboration in South
Border Issues of Mutual Concern”
This has increased their responsibil- Asia” was presented by Nepal’s Himal
brought together over 60 Pakistani
ity to produce authentic and verified
content.
and Indian journalists for a workshop
in Kathmandu, Nepal in September. in Kathmandu Media cofounder, Kanak Mani Dixit.
Dixot highlighted the importance of
In such a situation it was interesting peace in South Asia as both India and
that the conference participants got a
The selected journalists from both Indian, Pakistani Pakistan continue to face tremendous
countries were divided in four the- problems because of poverty and
chance to interact with Nathaniel Glei-
cher, Head of Security Policy for Meta.
matic groups : environment, agricul- journalists convene for economic issues.
ture and water management, health,
This was a very interesting session
and business/economy. The workshop workshop, planning “India and Pakistan are part of two
especially since Facebook is a popular
social media platform among journal- started on 5th September with great enthusiasm among great civilizations, Indus and Ganga Jumna, have a shared
ists, media personnel, and content participants. The first day at Hotel Himalaya in Kathmandu history and can have a shared future, and the journalists,
creators. But with the benefits comes was bustling with energy. At the opening session, Susan who are the gatekeepers have the responsibility to make
the downside – increased attacks. Kreifels, EWC Media Program Manager, welcomed the par- this happen,” opined Dixit. He said the Taj Mahal and Mo-
ticipants to the workshop. She discussed the importance henjo Daro should be the common heritage of both Indian
Overall, the conference was a learn- of the program which aims to highlight commonalities and and Pakistanis as it has never been a Hindu or a Muslim
ing experience for me and helped me Indian journalist Disha Shetty discusses her experience collaborating with Paki- issues concerning both nations. heritage.
broaden my experience and added to stani colleagues during a panel at the EWC International Media Conference in
my skills as a journalist. Honolulu. (Photo by East-West Center) One participant, Sukrut Karandikar from Pune, Maharash- He said that media can play a positive role in bringing the
tra, India, said, “I was eager to take part in the workshop two states closer. He said the region can only achieve eco-
Reflections: ment, agriculture, and health. of peace journalism and focus on in Nepal only because Pakistani journalists were going to nomic growth and social justice if ultra-nationalism and
Pratyush Ranjan, India finding peaceful solutions to the meet there. Pakistanis are no different from us in terms of state power diverts its resources for human development
I attended the conference as the pan- fundamental problems of the people color, food, lifestyle, culture, language (and even religion by both nations.
The International Media Conference elist/speaker with my fellow journal- living in the border areas. Focusing on until a few centuries ago).”
2022 in Honolulu, Hawai’i was a great ists from India and Pakistan in the first real issues and helping the needy with Trainer Steve Rice then held a class on multimedia, and
get-together of journalists from across session titled “Connecting through the correct information can only help Workshop leaders introduced themselves and the groups taught participating journalists regarding basic principles
the world. What a beautiful place! Cross-Border Collaboration.” The ses- them be empowered citizens. they were leading, including Sara Shipley Hiles, Associate of multimedia stories, camera techniques, and how to edit
During my stay here from June 25 sion was moderated by peace jour- Professor, Missouri School of Journalism (environment); shots.
to July 1, I felt very close to nature, nalism project mentor Steven Young- Another session I attended as the Erin Jordan, Investigative Journalist, The Gazette, Iowa
which is in its purest form here. All blood. It was a fantastic experience as panelist speaker was on the important (agriculture and water management); Steve Rice, Profes- The next day, trainer Steven Youngblood lead a discussion
thanks to the East-West Center for in- all the panelists opened their hearts topic Combating Misinformation with sor Emiritus, Missouri School of Journalism, (multimedia), about how peace journalism principles can be applied to
viting me as a panelist to the Interna- and discussed such an important topic journalists from the USA, Fiji, Paki- Randy Smith, Donald W. Reynolds Endowed Chair in Busi- the four reporting subject areas. Ashwini Shrivastava,
tional Media Conference (IMC). with a great sense of urgency and of stan, Taiwan, and Indonesia. Philippa ness Journalism, Missouri School of Journalism, (economy working with Press Trust of India as Assistant Editor, said,
responsibility towards society. The McDonald (Former Senior News and trade); Laura Ungar, Global Health Reporter, The As- “The program has been a very wonderful event. Steven’s
I got a lifetime opportunity to attend lively audience also participated in the Reporter, Australian Broadcasting workshop on peace journalism was a learning experience.
sociated Press (health); and Steven Youngblood, Founding
the IMC 2022 and meet journalists panel discussion with many questions, Corporation) was the session modera- It guided me how peace journalism can be used in day
Director, Center for Global Peace Journalism, Park Univer-
from the US, Asia, and Pacific, to listen tor. The panelists took many questions
and all the panelists answered all the sity, Missouri (peace journalism). Continued on next page
to their expert views on the critical from the audience on how to identify
questions with their in-depth exper-
issues in the region and common chal- and debunk misinformation. I talked
tise and experience.
lenges and trends in media. All the about my exclusive talk show in which
sessions had a series of exceptional To me, as a participant in the project more than 25 top medical experts
keynote speakers and panelists with since 2019, it has been beneficial to from India took part, shared verified
in-depth subject knowledge. The best change my mindset while speaking information, and answered all the
part of the conference was that it also with journalists from Pakistan on dif- questions on social media platforms
offered workshops and the opportu- ferent issues related to the common on Covid-19.
nities to network with international man. As I said during the session, we
journalists and media professionals. need to focus on the topics related Participating in the IMC 2022 became
to the life and economy of a common special because of one more reason
At the IMC 2022, I was part of the when I met Maria Ressa (Nobel Peace
family and empower them with the
EWC program “Reporting on Cross- Prize winner 2021). Overall, it was an
information they need to live good,
Border Issues of Mutual Concern.” excellent opportunity to meet many
safe, and healthy lives with great op-
It’s an ongoing project started by the friends in-person for the first time,
portunities to learn and grow person-
East-West Center to cover topics like and grow a professional network with
ally and professionally. The journalism (L)-Cross border reporters visit a school impacted by climate-change fueled urban flooding. (R)-Nepali journalist Kunda
economy/trade, water and environ- brilliant journalism minds worldwide.
fraternity should follow the principles Dixit discusses the impact of war on everyday citizens and his book, “A People War.” (Photo by Steve Rice)
pg 6 www.park.edu/peacecenter Vol 11 No 2 pg 7
October 2022 October 2022
Nepal from Pg 7
Study: What does ‘peace’ mean on Twitter?
to day reporting. The peace journalism principles are so
timely and necessary for journalists across the globe. I in- “At least, the word peace is not forbid- The aim of this new study is to start ses interactions between journalists,
tend to encourage my fellow journalists back home to use den yet,” said a British correspondent measuring the evolution of the peace activists, and members of the public
peace journalism principles in their daily work.” covering the war in Ukraine at the discourse in the 30 years following the discussing peace in Israel/Palestine
beginning of March 2022, to end their Israeli-Palestinian peace agreement, on Twitter, from a dataset collected
The workshop also featured a presentation by Nepalese coverage of the new conflict at the and consider how the role of journal- in 2019. We focus our attention on
journalism legend Kunda Dixit, brother of Kanak Dixit. He heart of Europe. Who could possibly ism in shaping peace discourses may the way each of these actors frame
discussed his peace journalism project, which consisted claim to be against peace? Even politi- have changed in the digital context. the meaning of peace, and the lack
of three books and a documentary film chronicling the cians who advocate occupation and thereof, and on who they consider to
Nepalese civil war (1996-2006). The project was centered fight wars of aggression nevertheless The social media era has brought soci- be responsible for this lack of peace.
around a photo book, “A People War,” that featured most use the word “peace.” ety into a fully developed postmodern
prominently the impact of the war on everyday citizens—a dimension, marked by the crumbling Our initial findings have confirmed
hallmark of peace journalism. Dixit said the book was nec- Indian and Pakistani journalists interview local climate Once again, the word “peace” has of traditional ideological structures that the two main approaches to the
essary since “the media has an important role, especially change expert Madhukar Upadhya at an elementary a variety of undefined meanings. and the rise of new ideas that, unlike meaning of peace, namely the two-
when the State tries to bury the conflict.” school near the Kathmandu airport during the cross border Advancing peace journalism entails 30 years ago, anyone could express state and the one-state solutions, are
workshop. unpacking the role of journalism in without mediation. While this greater still debated. However, most of the
Sri Lankan journalist Dilrukshi Handunnetti also made a said, “The program presented an amazing opportunity shaping such ambiguous meanings circulation of free viewpoints could be meanings of peace we examined were
fascinating presentation at the workshop on disinforma- to share ideas and deep-dive on issues that matter in our across multiple platforms. seen as a precursor to better chances either generic ideas of peace, or even
tion. Her discussion featured a peace journalism-oriented world today. Cross-border collaborations help break preju- for conflict transformation, digital rejections of peace. In other words,
presentation on story framing, and the tendency to tell dices, allow deeper understanding of people and cultures, Elsewhere I have claimed that concep- postmodernity has manifested itself a considerable part of Twitter users
stories in the region only through the frame, or lens, of the and also bring people closer in a divided world.” tions of peace based on diplomacy as an ongoing effort to affirm what involved in the debate consider peace
India-Pakistan conflict. and covered by traditional media may is true and what is false. Too often to be impossible, and sometimes
The workshop also turned out to be a platform for the provide a favourable environment for online social life is a collective exer- also unwelcome. This provides new
The aim of the workshop was well-achieved, as the cross- reporters to collaborate on reporting projects, which are the rejection of constructive peace. cise in which individuals defend their evidence for the claim that, over the
border workshop brought together journalists from vari- instrumental for both countries. By interacting and report- This tends to happen when diploma- views against each other, while at the past 30 years, it has been much more
ous backgrounds, groomed their reporting skills, taught ing such stories on multiple platforms, they can pave the cy-led ideas of peace are not followed macro level these views still converge difficult to understand peace as a just
about solutions and peace journalism. The thematic way for peace-building efforts to have an impact. by improvements in the prospects of into two opposite discourses. The op- outcome that could safeguard the
workshop groups analyzed problems/issues and resolved those experiencing violence. timistic analyses of the digital society rights of both Israelis and Palestinians.
to report with an aim to seek resolution and improve the Indian journalist Athar Parvaiz noted, “The workshop pro- from the early 2000s predicted the
situation for citizens of both India and Pakistan. vided a very good platform for teaming up with journalists In the Israeli-Palestinian case, the Finally, our analysis shows that the
beginning of an era of unstructured
on either side of the border to work on issues facing both diplomatic peace discourses of the diversity, citizen journalism, and a con- journalistic field has changed signifi-
Pakistani journalist Attiq Ahmad Sadozai said, “It was an countries. I have no doubt in my mind that the workshop early 1990s paved the way for the rise vergent multiplicity of voices (Bruns, cantly. It is now acceptable for some
amazing experience to attend the cross-border event. has laid a foundation for effective and meaningful cross- of long-term exclusionary views. This Jenkins, or Shirky), but this has shown media watchdog organisations and
Through this week-long series of workshops, I learned border journalistic collaboration.” was due to a variety of factors, but by to be an era of polarisation, based on journalists to have a strong political
many things about working in collaboration, cross-border avoiding clarity regarding the ultimate anti-social ideologies. bias against inclusive ideas of peace,
story ideas, peace journalism, agriculture and water The trainers were also impressed with the workshop. meaning of peace and emphasizing and to support exclusionary views
management, and many other things, but the best part of Israeli expectations, some mainstream This twisted manifestation of the about Israelis or Palestinians. Hence
this event was to meet journalist fellows from India and Randy Smith said, “The most important legacy of the news media also played a significant age of multiple perspectives further it appears that alternative journalism,
Indian-administered Kashmir. I hope this event will bring gathering is the lifelong relationships formed by journalists role. The mechanisms of this journal- nurtures exclusionary views, limit- which was born to counter dominant
closer both countries and will help the peace process on from Pakistan and India. Those relationships will translate istic role are explained in my previous ing opportunities for the transfor- narratives of the powerful, can be a
the sub-continent.” into fact based reporting on issues important to the future research, in particular the book about mation of intractable conflicts but new means to maintain unjust rela-
of both countries. Good journalism can and should play a the role of mainstream journalism in
One independent multimedia journalist who will remain also for peaceful progress and fairer tions in the fluid digital space.
positive and constructive role as everyone wrestles with the Israeli/Palestinian Oslo peace pro-
anonymous to protect their own safety observed, “It communities. New narratives have
the complexities of climate, health, trade and food.” cess (Tiripelli 2016), and my newest All this is not completely new. Peace
was an overwhelming and surreal feeling to be part of a merged the aspirations for freedom
publication about the representation and justice of one community with has always been exploited politically,
diverse group from India and Pakistan. The one biggest Sara Shipley Hiles, who led the environment group, stated,
of the Oslo peace agreement in The the oppression of another, making it and some journalism – especially war
realization is that we had more similarities than differenc- “Environmental issues don’t stop at borders. Air, water,
New York Times (Tiripelli 2022). more difficult for alternative views to journalism - has always supported the
es especially in facing challenges, be it the climate emer- pollution, and animals move freely. Journalists need to
become visible and legitimised. For status quo. What is new, and worry-
gency, gender equity, or the economic crisis. I was also know how to cover issues as big as the world, and the best In a new research project that I am example, the view that criticism of ing, is the elusive nature of the mean-
amazed by how people from both the countries hope we way to do that is by collaborating. I really enjoyed work- developing in collaboration with Dr. Israeli measures against the Palestin- ing of peace in public debate, and
should resolve the political problems for the greater cause ing with my team of Indian and Pakistani journalists. I’m Simon Goodman at De Montfort ians is a threat to the Jewish people the dangerous lack of deontological
of common people.” impressed with their talent and dedication and can’t wait University, I am examining the under- has gained more legitimacy. anchoring of new journalism forms.
to see what stories they create together.” lying meanings of “peace” on Twitter.
Priyadarshini Sen, an independent journalist from India, -Faiz Paracha Our current research project analy- -Giuliana Tiripelli
pg 8 www.park.edu/peacecenter Vol 11 No 2 pg 9
October 2022 October 2022
Men are also victims of hypermasculine stereotypes der women being stopped at the borders, not being able
to leave Ukraine. Other amplified gendered dynamics stem
created to amplify the voices of women and the region’s
most deeply affected communities: members of civil soci-
“The Unwomenly Face of War” is the title of the book by When women are portrayed, they are often portrayed only from the loss of access to healthcare, education, food, wa- ety, especially women and other vulnerable populations.
Belarusian Svetlana Alexievich, published in 1985, a prod- as victims or bystanders and rarely speak for themselves. ter and sanitation. This is one of many aspects which will be critical in the
uct of thousands of hours
of interviews with women
The image of a bloody pregnant woman from Ukraine and
her unborn child is only one of many examples of viral
“ The international media
have...promoted hyper-
While the data, brief
testimonials and UN
long-term for any prospects of peace for Ukraine.
who served in the Soviet news stories dictating an overall narrative of women’s reports are pub- Originally printed at mediasupport.org-
Army during World War II. victimization. While these stories are critical and deserve masculine war narratives lished, the stories https://www.mediasupport.org/blogpost/everything-
Svetlana Alexievich spoke
to women who worked
to be heard as they ultimately are documentation of hu-
man rights abuses, it is important to consider how they are
“
and gender stereotypes. from the individuals
behind the statistics
we-know-about-war-we-know-with-a-mans-voice-and-
ukraine-is-no-exception/
in every possible role in being told, the involvement of the subject and the angle. are seldom heard.
the war including snipers, The stories about women fleeing with their families are Journalists must actively reach out to individuals and care- Recommendations: More responsible
nurses, pilots, tank drivers, not necessarily only stories about victims, but also about fully craft these stories. gender-based Ukraine war coverage
foot soldiers, surgeons and women being active agents of their families, their commu-
Women of colour have been giving testimonies of rac- • Engage in gender media monitoring to keep track
partisans. nities and their nations, bringing them from fragility to sta-
ism and hostility from the Ukrainian military when trying of who is represented in your content and in what
bility. And women are not only seeking refuge. As a matter
She said, “Everything we to flee, and at the border people have been divided into capacity.
of fact, women form around 15 percent of total military
know about war we know two groups: those who were white and those who were
personnel in Ukraine, many of whom are serving on the
with a man’s voice,” and, “I not. The international news coverage is also often, simply • Be careful not to replicate stereotyping in which
frontlines. Not to mention the courageous women report-
wanted to write a history of stated, racist. One example is the quote in international you simply view women as passive victims and suf-
ers who choose to stay in Ukraine to provide vital informa-
that war. A women’s his- media, from CBS News senior foreign correspondent Char-
tion from the hotspots. Their stories are rarely heard. ferers. We also need to report stories that reflect
tory.” lie D’Agata, that Ukraine “isn’t a place, with all due respect,
like Iraq or Afghanistan, that has seen conflict raging for women’s courage, leadership, resilience and heal-
Men are also victims of the war and hypermasculine ing and their roles as agents of change and peace
While it may come as no surprise that women’s stories and stereotypes they are supposed to live up to. The majority decades. This is a relatively civilised, relatively European – I
perspectives from this time were neglected, one would have to choose those words carefully, too – city, one where building.
of the military force are men, and if you are a man in the
have thought that by 2022 we would have reached a cer- age range of 18–60, you are not able to leave Ukraine, ac- you wouldn’t expect that, or hope that it’s going to hap-
tain level of gender equality where we would document pen.” • When covering gender-based violence, utilise best
cording to the law during wartime. The point of this text is
events in a more inclusive way. That does not seem to be practices, ethical standards and resources that sup-
not that women are more affected than men. The point is
the case, at least not in international media’s coverage of that women are affected differently because of gendered
A former deputy prosecutor general of Ukraine said in a port a survivor-centred approach.
conflicts. In February, Russia invaded Ukraine, and interna- BBC interview, “It’s very emotional for me because I see
dynamics and other grounds of discrimination.
tional media have taken on the unfortunate role in promot- European people with blue eyes and blond hair…being • Focus on underreported, misreported and unre-
ing hyper masculine war narratives, gender stereotypes The latest reports of rape highlight women and girls killed every day,” the BBC host simply replied, “I under- ported forms and targets of violence, including with
and manifestations of racism. in conflicts being particularly vulnerable to sexual and stand and respect the emotion,” instead of questioning marginalised communities.
gender-based violence. The United Nations has now de- the comment. International media allow this narrative to
The current war in Ukraine has three key leaders, each of manded an independent investigation into rape and sexual spread, and few or no efforts are being made to create • Make use of databases of women experts on vari-
whom uses a different approach to the current situation. violence in Ukraine, after allegations Russian troops com- counternarratives. ous topics — or create your own.
But what do Zelensky, Putin, and Biden all have in com- mitted such crimes during the continuing invasion of the
mon? They are men – political leaders who represent very The issue of lack of inclusive coverage is not only princi- • Revise your editorial guidelines to make sure that
neighbouring country. The discrimination is also intersec-
different versions of masculinity. pally wrong and against international standards but also a gender perspective and inclusivity are included.
tional in its nature with reports of discrimination against
lays the foundation for other unintended, negative con-
people from the LGBTQIA+ community, such as transgen-
Women, on the other hand, are not represented among the sequences. In the short term, independent media cover- • Consider introducing an equality editor. This is a
top political leaders and constitute only 23 percent of the Continued on next page age helps inform policy-makers decisions on military and self-regulatory mechanism created specifically to
total experts, protagonists or sources quoted in global digi- humanitarian aid to Ukraine. When reporting is framed by tackle gender inequality in media content. The New
tal news about the war in Ukraine, according to an analy- a male perspective, it can magnify the bias that already York Times (USA) and El País (Spain) are examples of
sis of the GDELT news exists within government and multilateral institutions that
pioneers of this tool.
monitoring database. This are dominated by male leadership.
does not diverge much • Conduct a gender audit of your internal work to
from the Global Media Svetlana Alexievich’s observation that everything we know
about war we know with“a man’s voice” unfortunately make sure that you have a diverse workforce and
Monitoring Project (GMMP) data, which has shown that
still holds true – and from a longer-term perspective, the identify the gender gaps in your organisation — a
news paints a picture of a world in which women are virtu-
ally invisible. Women are dramatically under-represented participation of women in public debate during and post- diverse workforce is more likely to produce
in the news, with only 24 percent of them serving as news conflict is proven to be crucial for peace negotiations and pluralistic content.
subjects and sources. to contributes to long-lasting peace. Platforms must be --Emma Boberg
UTexas Maps
pg 10 www.park.edu/peacecenter Vol 11 No 2 pg 11
October 2022 October 2022
There is also concern about the impunity that usually charac- Mexican journalist Marcela Turati highlighted the value of journalism that tells “stories of life in
terizes attacks against journalists. According to official data, times of death; narrates how victims organize and resist, and that inspires others in forms of resis-
more than 90% of the murders of journalists go unpunished. tance.” She said, “Journalism, in short, builds a bridge between indignation and hope.” A journal-
The country has a Special Prosecutor’s Office for the Attention ist from Colombia, Cindy Morales, spoke about her experience and the work of Colombia +20 of
of Crimes Committed against Freedom of Expression, but many El Espectador about the contribution that journalism can make in the processes of memory and
journalists complain about how it works. recognition.
Also, public discrediting by government representatives encour- Professor Xavier Giró, a specialist in peace journalism, insisted on the advisability of not staying
ages social discredit and makes journalists more vulnerable to with those stories that seek to punish those responsible for serious human rights violations but also
attacks and harassment. looking at the other side of justice, the truth, reparations, and non-repetition.
“For Mexican journalists, coverage in the territory is especially complicated because different actors One of the fundamental tools in constructing peace is the creation of alliances and platforms that
are involved. It is not as simple as saying ‘it is organized crime, one cartel against another or the propose transformations from a collective point of view. Establishing strong networks was one
state against a cartel’. There are business people who favour forced displacement in areas that are of the recurrent demands throughout the forum. “The lack of a union organization is one of the
rich in natural resources. It is a huge challenge for those covering corruption cases,” said another of factors that make it difficult to reduce the situation of vulnerability in which many journalists find
the participants, journalist Patricia Mayorga. themselves in Mexico,” added journalist Daniela Pastrana.
At the Forum, many journalists highlighted forced displacement as one of the worst consequences The forum was highly valued by all the journalists who participated. The forum’s formal and infor-
of the pressure and violence experienced by many in the country. This victimization has multiple mal spaces generated connections between professionals, especially journalists at risk, and human
impacts in the personal but also professional sphere. More structural elements also hinder journal- rights and psychosocial support organizations. It was clear to everyone attending that it is necessary
to continue establishing alliances to face the complex reality that Mexico is living in.
Continued on next page --Chema Sarri
pg 12 www.park.edu/peacecenter Vol 11 No 2 pg 13
October 2022 October 2022
Films from Pg 18
been produced in the program were launched at simulta- imaginary (border) lines over human dignity; “Beltoon” (a
neous events in India and Pakistan. In July, the participants Pashto word meaning ‘separation’), a documentary explor-
finally got together in Dubai – a politically neutral location ing the lives of communities that had migrated to India
– for a workshop and closed-door screening. during the time of partition; “Viral,” the story of an unlikely
friendship between social media stars from India and Paki-
The films include “Small Time Cinema,” a documentary stan; “Nani” (maternal grandmother), a tender tale that
about two groups of Youtube filmmakers—one in Hazara highlights the impossible hurdles people from one side
Town in Quetta, Pakistan and the other in Sipajhar in As- of the border face to visit the homes they were forced to
sam, India. Other films included, “Eik Tha Kabootar” (There abandon during the partition; and “Assi Nabbe Puray Sou”
was once a pigeon), based on a real-life incident that ques- (Eighty, Ninety, Hundred), a comedy of errors at the centre
tions the absurdity of the act of protecting the integrity of of which is an honest friendship between protagonists
from either side of the border. Rounding out the films was
“When Jay met Ammar,” a dramatic film about unearthing
Pakistanis, Indians collaborate on films a buried treasure with a little help from the ‘enemy’; and
I Shall Not Hear Love,” an artsy film on intergenerational
trauma, love and healing. Of these, “Viral” and “Small Time
Introduction intentions, young people from both sides of the border Cinem”’ have been selected for the International Docu-
In 2021, Indian prime minister Narendra Modi had tweeted have initiated programs and missions to foster solidarity mentary and Short Film Festival of Kerela (IDFSSK) 2022. All
what some would call an ominous intention. The leader among Indians and Pakistanis despite contrary political the films were picked up by the Indian OTT platform Zee5.
of the Hindutva-espousing Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) propaganda and fulminating diplomatic tensions. Examples
had said that BJP would observe August 14 as Vibhajan like Project Dastaan and The Pind Collective are just a 30-year-old Shreyas Dashrathe is visibly elated. The co-
Vibhishika Diwas, translated as Partition Horrors Remem- couple of the numerous projects where art is being used director, writer and editor of “Viral” said, “I’m very happy
brance Day. This year, they made it happen. While there art to bridge a gap that is made to look insurmountable. about our film’s selection at IDSFFK. Filmmakers and en-
may be nothing wrong with such a remembrance, choosing thusiasts from all over the country will be there and I can’t
neighbour-country Pakistan’s Independence Day to do so Creativity despite the odds wait to for everyone to see the film. I hope it will start a
is certainly problematic. Naturally, Pakistan is not amused, Kitnay Duur Kitnay Paas was officially kicked off in October positive conversation.”
and this jingoistic move might further stress an already 2020, but the call for applications was made in January
2021. Within just four weeks, the program had received an To see and be seen
tenuous relationship between the two nations. Blood and These eight films take different approaches – from the
tears were, after all, shed on both sides of the border. overwhelming 295 applications, of which 125 were from
Pakistan, and 170 from India. By March, 42 filmmakers comic to dramatic treatments, from documentary to
So Far, So Close were selected to collaboratively make cross-border films, fictional forms – but underscoring them all is the fact that
But as some bridges were being burnt, some others were under the mentorship of three experts: national award- Indians and Pakistanis are more alike than different. They
being built. In 2021, Seeds of Peace, a US-based non-profit, winning veteran filmmaker Sankalp Meshram from India; show images of the self, reflected easily in the other, melt-
with the sponsorship support of the US Consulate Karachi, Academy Award-winning documentary filmmaker Haya ing away all imagined borders and boundaries. After all,
launched Kitnay Duur Kitnay Paas (So Far, So Close) – an Fatima Iqbal from Pakistan; and filmmaker and cinematog- centuries worth of shared history and culture can hardly
India-Pakistan film collaboration project. The inspiration for rapher Marcus Goldbas from the US. be erased by a colonial travesty. Just as the filmmaking
the project was to bring to light the rich legacy of shared teams from India and Pakistan bonded over the trials and
history, culture, and traditions between the two historical Even as this young cohort of filmmakers, all aged between triumphs of the creative process, the viewers of the films
adversaries that makes them starkly similar to each other 21 to 35, were set to start the program, the second wave will find plenty of things to tug at their heartstrings.
despite their conflict. Qasim Aslam, project lead, comment- of the pandemic hit the Indian subcontinent, shutting
down all logistical doors. As with most things in the world Goldbas, who has a long-standing relationship with Seeds
ed, “My hope has always been that people are able to see of Peace, said, “This program is exactly the kind of thing
that, at the end of the day, we are all humans. Whichever in 2021, the program moved online and the participants
went through the motions of workshops and script writ- we need to bring the two countries together. There is no
part of the world one comes from, we all think and worry better way, in my opinion, to talk about these relationships
about the same things – whether it’s about putting food ing via Zoom and other platforms. From October 2021
onwards, as things began to open up again, the film crews than to have people who actually live in these communi-
on the table, where life is going, mid-life crises, etc. There ties do it, and to create something with it. Such a project
is just so much in common among humans from every part got to the shooting and production stage. It would serve to
remind readers here that given the current political hostili- can also expand in other regions of the world, because the
of the world. When people connect, that is a celebration of medium of film is so powerful...”
humanity, and it should happen as often as possible, and ties, getting visas to travel between India and Pakistan is
Kitnay Duur Kitnay Paas is but one such manifestation.” nearly impossible. The filmmakers, after receiving mentor- All 8 films are available to watch for free on the Kitnay
ing, collaborated digitally and conceived, shot, and edited Duur Kitnay Paas website and Seeds of Peace’s Youtube
Aslam’s remark may be seen as a reference to many such eight films remotely from their respective locations in India channel.
initiatives that have been taking shape in the subcontinent and Pakistan. In June 2022, the eight short films that had
-Urmi Chanda
over the last few years. Armed with digital tools and great Continued on next page
pg 18 www.park.edu/peacecenter Vol 11 No 2 pg 19
October 2022 October 2022
THISAM from Pg 20
ing research into journalism/commu-
- New Trends in Media, Journalism,
nication combined with the expertise
THISAM in Numbers
and News
- Constructive Journalism of pioneering media professionals. 46 participants
- Media & News Literacy The program is structured around key- 16 countries
- Photojournalism note presentations by distinguished 78% women
- Cybersecurity experts, interactive small group work,
and roundtable discussions. Lectures 25 lecture sessions
- Public Diplomacy
and workshops were conducted with 12 workshops
The Summer Academy is a major a mix-method teaching style that 32 hours of lecture
forum where current issues and re- included lectures, discussion, small 18 different organizations
search developments will be present- group work, policy lab and hands-on
ed. For this purpose, distinguished practicum. Sessions are led by experts better and more sustainable future
international scholars are invited and from across communication fields, for all. THISAM aims to promote them
share their expertise through lectures, including research, policy making, and with a special emphasis in goal 4,
collaborative study designs, digital media industries. quality education, in order to ensure
content development, and theoretical that all learners acquire the knowl-
models. THISAM’s success is evi- THISAM is part of the United Nations
Impact Network (UNAI) initiative that edge and skills needed to promote
denced by the increasing number of sustainable development, including,
partners and participants. aligns institutions of higher education
with the United Nations in supporting among others, through education for
and contributing to the realization of sustainable development and sustain-
It is the interactive nature of THISAM
United Nations goals and mandates, able lifestyles, human rights, gender
that makes it such an exciting op-
equality, promotion of a culture of
THISAM from Pg 21
responding to address them, and what are the impacts on
it, along with its modes of interaction and dissemination?
meeting point where participants Macedonia and Thrace. Kathimerini, Don’t miss the chance to be part of an
have the opportunity to share, create international event that will take place Peace journalism has enjoyed traction precisely as a re-
Greek Public Television, Athens Voice,
and generate change. It is an event between 14-22 of July 2023. sponse to such challenges in the field of conflict reporting,
and Inside Story.
that actively promotes the goal of having acted as the organising principle for initiatives in
peace and constructive journalism. THISAM 2023 is sure to be an excit- --Nikos Panagiotou and both scholarly research and media development aid in the
ing opportunity for all in attendance. Christos Fragkonikolopoulos form of journalism training. Yet how should it now evolve,
Thessaloniki International Media amid a rapidly changing mediascape? Contributors to this
Summer Academy is organized by book peer into the future to examine the exigencies of ap-
the Peace Journalism Lab, School of plying its insights and distinctions in real-world settings. Journalism community – my co-editor Dr. Charis Rice, of
Journalism and Mass Communications Coventry University (and her colleague Maureen Turner),
Aristotle University of Thessaloniki A strong theme of the volume is the local turn in news, interrogate it to consider what we mean when we say
and the Jean Monet Chair for Public with journalism now served in smaller and more spe- journalism is, or can be trusted.
Diplomacy between 15-22 July 2022, cialised portions, to real communities – where everyone
knows each other, or at least how to find and contact each Navigating through the minefield of commercial con-
in collaboration with well-known Or- straints, political pressure, audience feedback, social me-
ganizations and Universities Deutsche other – as distinct from the imagined community of state
or nation. Much of this reporting is a labour of love, ac- dia, fake news and government censorship, journalism is
Welle, Beijing University, University alive and well, the book concludes, imbued with a strong
of Zagreb, University of Novi-Sad, Na- cording to dozens of interviews – conducted by writers in
the book – with small-time but highly skilled and dedicated sense of responsibility and public service. It is seeking out
tional and Kapodistrian University of new ways and new venues, which in many cases involves
Athens, Jiaotong-Liverpool University, practitioners. Their sense of responsibility to their audi-
ence comes across loud and clear. struggle: but its exponents are aware it is a righteous one,
Temple University, Hallyn University of and they are meeting it with creativity and flair.
Korea, Panteion University, University
Another topic is the scope presented by today’s interactive
of Maribor, Slovenia, VII Academy, Contributors bring perspectives to bear on these issues
media to compile news feeds and access diverse materi-
ImedD Niarchos Foundation and DCN from ten countries, and across four continents, making
als to one’s own specification – arguably decentring and
Global. the book a valuable addition to journalism scholarship and
spreading responsibility for news content from journalists
to audiences, in new and potentially creative relationships. reflective practice alike.
This international initiative is support-
ed from Konrad Adenauer Stiftung, -Jake Lynch
A key concept in such relationships is trust, and – in a
World Learning, European Federation Professor Shin Dong Kim, Professor, The Media School, Hallym University Korea, chapter that carries particular resonance for the Peace
of Journalists, Journalistic Union of presents at the Summer Academy on July 18.
pg 22 www.park.edu/peacecenter Vol 11 No 2 pg 23
October 2022 October 2022
pg 26 www.park.edu/peacecenter