Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Abstract
Background: Poisoning is a common medical emergency needing prompt medical interventions. The study focuses on pattern of toxic agents, drug
utilization, management and outcome in poisonings reported.
Methods: The cross sectional study was carried out on patients admitted to two urban hospitals in Pune, Maharashtra from January 2014 - March 2016.
Results: Total 1078 cases of poisoning were reported with male (57.1%) predominance. The cases reported ranged from 8 months to 72 years old in
age with a mean (± SD) 37.8 ± 27.3. Intentional poisoning was more common (53%). Route of exposure was mostly Ingestion (72.5%) followed by Bite/
Sting (26.4%), Inhalational (0.8%), Injection (0.1%) and Eye (0.1%). Household and agricultural agents (56.4%) were associated with most poisoning followed
by Animal Bites and Stings (26.4%). The mortality reported was 9.7%. The management included Supportive treatment, Antidotes, and Enhanced Elimination
Techniques. Supportive treatment was mainly with Gastro protective (94.3%) and Anti-Microbial (77.9%) agents. The antidote was used in 70.9% cases and
mostly included Anti-Snake Venom (24.4%) followed by Atropine (21%) and Pralidoxime (18.1%). Enhanced Elimination Techniques included Gastric Lavage
(76.3%), Nasogastric Aspiration (7.2%), Hemodialysis (0.1%), Activated Charcoal (4.5%) and Eye wash (0.1%).
Conclusion: The treatment approaches were based on parameters such as route of exposure, Toxic agent involved and age of the patient. The pharmacist
can play a vital role in the recommendation of the rational management plan in Poisonings.
Cite this article: Raut A, Pawar A, Shaj K, Dave P (2017) Treatment Approaches for Management of Poisonings in India. Ann Public Health Res 4(4): 1068.
Raut et al. (2017)
Email:
Central
The Pune city resides many multi specialty hospitals. The Table 1: Characteristics of Poisoning cases observed.
Government hospital, a 380 bedded multi specialty hospital, Characteristics Number of cases
is located in Pimpri – Chinchwad which engulfs a wide area of Demographic
surrounding suburban and industrial areas like Aundh, Bhosri, Male 616
Nigdi and villages like Moshi, Chikli, Dehu, etc. The private Female 462
teaching hospital is a 900 bedded hospital with hi-tech super Age (Mean ± SD) 37.8 ± 27.3
specialties. It is located in inner suburbs of Pune which includes Route
areas like Katraj, Ambegaon, Vadgaon, Parvati Hill, etc. These
Ingestion 782
are the industrial and agricultural areas where a high number of
Injection 1
chemical or pesticide poisoning can be observed.
Inhalational 9
Population and sampling Bite/Sting 285
Eye 1
The study was cross-sectional and made use of retrospective
Reason
and prospective extraction of data from records available at the
Intentional 571
government and private teaching hospitals respectively. All cases
Accidental 475
of poisoning available in the medical record departments were
Unknown 32
included in the study.
Length of Hospital Stay (Mean ± SD) 2.5 ± 1.6
Data collection and extraction Outcome
Symptoms improved 836
The records were collected from Medical Record Department
DAMA 137
of the respective hospitals. The data collection period was from
Death 105
January 2014 to March 2016. The cases were reviewed for gender,
age, route, and reason of poisoning and agents, management, and Agents
drug utilization. Household and Agricultural 608
Animal Bites and Stings 285
RESULT Drugs 116
Miscellaneous 39
Demography of poisoning cases
Unknown 30
During the study period of 28 months, 1078 cases of poisoning
were reported to the emergency department of the hospitals, out used as an adjunct for eliminating toxins and diazepam for
of which 616 (57.1%) were male and 463 (42.9%) were Female. alcohol withdrawal symptoms. Oxygen Inhalation was given
The cases reported ranged from 8 months to 72 years old in age to patients with Inhalational poisoning with insecticides and
with a mean (± SD) 37.8 ± 27.3. This suggestive that on an average petroleum. Antidotes were used in 70.9% cases and included
38 cases was reported per month which demands attention to Anti-Snake Venom (24.4%), Atropine (21%), Pralidoxime
the situation. The reason for poisoning was primarily Intentional (18.1%), Rabipur (3%), N-Acetylcysteine (1.4%), Neostigmine
(53%) than Accidental (44.1%) and Unknown (3%) and Route of (3.2%). Other Enhanced Elimination Techniques were also used.
exposure was mostly Ingestion (72.5%) followed by Bite/Sting These Included Gastric Lavage (76.3%), Nasogastric Aspiration
(26.4%), Inhalational (0.8%), Injection (0.1%) and Eye (0.1%). (7.2%), Hemodialysis (0.1%), Activated Charcoal (4.5%) and Eye
The agents responsible were categorized as Household and wash (0.1%) [Table 2].
Agricultural Agents (56.4%), Animal Bites and Stings (26.4%),
Drugs (10.8%), Miscellaneous (3.6 %) and Unknown (2.8%). Management in different patient population
Few Intentional poisonings were a mix of above agents and some The usage pattern of Antidote and the Enhanced Elimination
with alcohol as well. Length of Hospital Stay ranged from 1-15 Techniques were observed in different patient population;
days with a mean (± SD) 2.5 ± 1.2. Mortality reported was 9.7% Pediatric, Adult, and Geriatric for different toxic agents. In 276
and Symptoms Improved in most (77.6%) cases but 12.7% were cases of Pediatrics aged 0-18 years, Antidotes were given in 135
DAMA (Discharged against Medical Advice) or Absconded [Table (48.9%), Gastric Lavage in 156 (56.5%), Nasogastric Aspiration
1]. in 12 (4.3%), Activated Charcoal in 24 (8.7%) and Eye Wash in 1
Treatment approaches in poisonings (0.4%). In 760 cases of Adults aged 19-55 years, Antidotes were
given in 600 (78.9%), Gastric Lavage in 648 (85.3%), Nasogastric
The Management of admitted poisoning cases was done Aspiration in 66 (8.7%), Hemodialysis in 1 (0.1%), Activated
by Symptomatic treatment, Antidote, and Other Enhanced Charcoal in 24 (3.2%). Finally, in 42 cases of Geriatric above age
Elimination Techniques. Symptomatic Treatment were done 55 years, Antidotes were given in 30 (71.4%) and Gastric Lavage
with following drugs: Anti-Microbial (77.9%), Gastro protective in 18 (42.9%) [Table 3, Figure 2].
(94.3%), Anti-allergic (52.7), Anti-Inflammatory (39.3), Anti-
Hypertensive (54%), Antipsychotics (44.1%), Supplements Treatment approach according to toxic agents
(5.6%), Anticonvulsants (3.5%), and Hormones (2.2%). In The treatment was recorded toxic agent wise. For Household
Antibiotics, mostly administered were Cephalosporin’s (29%), and Agricultural agents, Atropine or Pralidoxime along with
Amoxicillin+Clavulanic Acid (25.7%) followed by Metronidazole gastric lavage and/or nasogastric aspiration and/or activated
(14.4%) (Figure 1). Other drugs Mannitol and Perinorm were
Central
35
Amoxicillin+Clavulanic
30 Ampicillin
Figure 1 Usage Pattern of Anti microbial agent used for poison Management.
1 10 100 1000
Antidote
Gastric lavage
Nasogastric Aspiration
Hemodialysis
Charcoal hemoperfusion
Eye wash
Charcoal Nasogastric
Eye wash Hemodialysis Gastric lavage Antidote
hemoperfusion Aspiration
Pediatric 1 24 0 12 156 135
Adult 0 24 1 66 648 600
Geriatric 0 0 0 0 18 30
charcoal was done. Atropine was given IV with doses ranging common in India and the study shows that on an average 38
from 0.1mg-2g, STAT or 1 to maximum 4 hourly in 24 hours. A cases are reported per month and this is due to easy availability
close monitoring Heart Rate with target to keep below 100 beats/ of toxic agents, occupational exposures mainly ones involved in
minute. Pralidoxime was given IV, Dose ranging from 500mg-2g agriculture and no awareness particularly in rural areas [10]. In
with Normal Saline STAT or 2-8 hourly for 24 hours. Maintenance this study, a male predominance was observed which the similar
given in some cases was 500mg-1g with Normal Saline as Slow pattern is observed by other studies in India [11-13]. This trend
Infusion. For Animal Bites and Stings especially snake bite, ASV, may be due to increased occupational hazard and exposure of
and Rabipur for Dog bite were given. ASV was given as Test dose, men to stress being the earning members compared to women.
2-10 vials and in some cases as IV Infusion with Normal Saline In this study, most of the cases were between 19-55 years of age
or Dextrose Saline. Tetanus toxoid was given in unknown bites. similar to the trend in other Indian studies and may be due to
For drugs, especially acetaminophen, N-Acetyl cysteine and/or domestic, educational and employment related stress [12-14].
gastric lavage were given. N-acetylcysteine effervescent tablets The most common reason behind poisoning was intentional
were given 500mg with water. For some Miscellaneous and
which was observed in 57.1% of cases [15].
unknown, Atropine was given. Oxygen Inhalation was given for
inhalational exposure by insecticides and petroleum. Eye wash Household and agricultural agents were associated with most
was done in eye exposure of household agent. All poisonings intentional poisoning due to easy availability of these agents and
were also provided supportive treatment [Table 4, Table 5]. inadequate knowledge to support their safe residential use [16].
Studies have shown that pesticide is the most common toxic
DISCUSSION
agent involved in poisoning [15,17,18]. Animal bites and stings
Poisoning cases brought to Emergency Departments are very were the most common cause of accidental poisoning which
Central
was contrary to findings of the studies conducted in South India length of stay might also be indicative of better management
where most accidental poisonings was due to household poisons strategies which were observed in this study [Table 6].
[19-20]. This may be due to the difference in geography and
The management strategies in the present study included
occupation. The Length of Stay recorded in this study was 2.4 ± Symptomatic Treatment, Antidote, and other Enhanced
1.2 days which is much lesser than an Indian study which showed Elimination Techniques. Symptomatic Treatment with Supportive
5.4 ± 3.8 days [21]. Moreover, in the present study the mortality care played a vital role in managing acute poisonings. The
was 9.7% of patients which is lesser than other studies in India Symptomatic Treatment mainly involved usage of gastroprotective
which showed in range of 10-20% [21,22]. This may be due to agents like PPIs, H2 Blockers, Antacids, Antiemetic as well as
number of factors such as nature of poison, dose consumed, level laxatives which were observed in other studies too [21,22].
of available medical facilities and time interval between intake of Antimicrobials were prescribed to 77.9% patients and most used
poison and provision of medical help. The lesser mortality and were cephalosporins, followed by penicillin and Metronidazole.
Central
Insect Sting
Unknown Bite
Anti-allergic, Anti-inflammatory,
Drugs N Acetyl cysteine Gastric Lavage
Gastroprotective agents
Gastroprotective agents, Anti-allergic,
Miscellaneous and Unknown Atropine Gastric Lavage
Anti-microbial, Anti-inflammatory
Similar Usage was found in other Indian studies [21,22]. Though subjects was compliant with dosing recommendation given in drug
there is no evidence of anti microbial therapy benefit in poisoning databases [25,26]. The study found the considerably good use of
trials [23,24], improvement in symptoms were observed in Enhanced elimination techniques along with pharmacotherapy
patients with Cellulitis post-Snake Bite in the study. Anti allergic which was not the case in Indian studies. Gastric Lavage was
agents like Avil, Phenergan, and Hydrocortisone were preferred considered in 76.3% and Nasogastric Aspiration in 7.2% cases.
in 52.7% patients. Anti Inflammatory and Anti Spasmodic Even lesser popular Hemodialysis (0.1%) and Activated Charcoal
Buscopan and Dexamethasone were given in 39.3% patients, (4.5%) was attempted in our study settings.
Iron and Calcium supplementation were also given in 5.6%
Toxic Agent wise approach was also studied. The first class of
patients. Anti Psychotics (44.1%) were introduced or continued
Household and Agricultural agents could be further categorized
in patients who attempted self-poisoning. Adrenaline and Anti-
into two; Pesticides and Corrosives. In cases of Pesticides and
Hypertensive’s were used on patients with cardiac co morbidities.
Insecticides, Antidotes Atropine and Pralidoxime were used
Anticonvulsants Carbazepine and Phenytoin were given to ones
and Gastric lavage was done with Potassium Permanganate or
with k/c/o seizure disorders. Mannitol and Perinorm were
Normal Saline or Plain Water. Activated Charcoal alone or with
also given in poisonings to enhance the elimination to avoid
Gastric Lavage was also considered. Nasogastric Aspiration
neurotoxicity. Dopamine was used in patients who were severe
was also included with or without Gastric Lavage. Whereas in
and progressed to Cardiogenic Shock. As many cases had mixed
case of Corrosive substances, Antidote given was Atropine and
the toxins with alcohol and some were a chronic alcoholic,
for acute poisonings, gastric lavage with or without nasogastric
Diazepam was given to manage the withdrawal symptoms.
aspiration was also done. Some poisonings were a mixture of
In the study, Antidotes ASV (dose range1-10vial), Atropine both insecticides and Corrosives. As such cases were acute,
(dose range: 0.1mg-2mg), Pralidoxime (dose range: 500mg- above approaches were considered. In our study, there were 9
2g) were used widely. Rabipur was preferred in dog bites and cases of inhalational poisonings by insecticides and petroleum.
unknown bites sometimes. The dosing of Antidotes given in study These were managed by Atropine and Oxygen Inhalation along
Central
Table 6: Classification of toxic agents according to ICD-10 2017. Bites, Insect Stings and Unknown Bites. Snake Bite Treatment
Type of Poison ICD-10 CODE No. of cases approach was according to The Snake Bite Treatment Guideline
Household & Agricultural Agents by AIIMS, Delhi with Anti-Snake Venom for mild to severe
OPP and Carbamate T60.0 162 envenomation. Neostigmine was given along with ASV for
Other Insecticides T60.2 34 neurotoxic snake bites. ASV related anaphylaxis reaction was also
Rodenticides T60.4 35
seen in 15 patients who were treated with epinephrine. Scorpion
Bite Management was Symptomatic with Gastroprotective, Anti
Other pesticides T60.8,9 3
inflammatory and sometimes cardio protective agents. Dog
Kerosene T52.0 24
Bite was treated with Rabipur Vaccination. Insect Stings and
Phenol and Related Agents T54.0 42
Unknown Bites were treated symptomatically. Unknown Bites
Corrosives Acids and Alkali T54.1/2/3/9 13
which were Severe and showed similar symptoms to Snake Bites
Classify based on
Antiseptics and Disinfectants 50 were administered ASV. The Third class of Drug poisonings was
composition
mainly due to Antibiotics, NSAIDs, Acetaminophen, and mix of
Specific inorganic substance T57.8 1
various medications. The treatment was mainly Symptomatic.
Other organic solvents T52.8 2
N-Acetylcysteine was used for Acetaminophen toxicity. Gastric
Alcohol T51 36
Lavage is also considered along with symptomatic treatment. In
Soap and detergent T55 1
our study, Hemodialysis was performed on a patient with severe
Aluminium Phosphide T57.1 2
Carbamazepine overdose. For other classes of Miscellaneous and
Organochlorine T53 6 Unknown poisonings, the approach was mainly symptomatic.
Herbicides-Paraquat T60.3 35 Gastric lavage was also done.
Drugs
Antibiotic T36 2 The overall treatment strategy focused on lesser absorption
Anti infectives and and faster elimination of toxins. Also, the treatment approaches
T37 10 were based on parameters such as route of exposure, Toxic agent
antiparasitic
Hormones and Synthetic involved and age of the patient. This demands the need for a
T38 1 proper guideline for the management of poisonings in all tertiary
substitutes
Non opioid analgesics and care settings in India. Well equipped settings can not only reduce
T39 20
antipyretics hospital stay but can play a vital role in lowering mortality. Expert
Anti epileptic, Sedative training is needed for managing particularly poisoning patients
T42 8
Hypnotics in the country with such huge population and poison exposure
Psychotropic T43 5 rates. As poisoning management can be described as the use
Hematological, Antiallergic T45 3 of chemicals to tackle harmful chemical effects, choice of drugs
Cardiac Stimulant glycoside T46.0 2 plays a vital role. Pharmacists can help in the recommendation of
Gastroprotective agents T47 2 the treatment plan and rational drug use in these cases which can
Vaccines and unknown help in effective management with economic benefits to patients
T50 10
medication [17]. Apart from this, the pharmacist can assist in history taking
Topical lotion T49 1 and assessment as well patient and community education.
Respiratory T48.5 3
The limitation was that Poor maintenance of records was
Animal Bite & Stings
frequently observed in the government setting and Cases referred
Snake T63.0 126 from other hospitals lacked detailed patient history. Very few
Scorpion T63.2 7 studies on poisoning targeted cases have been done in the
Bee/Wasp T63.4 39 country with over 1.2 billion population. More studies should be
Unknown bite T63.9 33 encouraged in different hospital settings and geographical areas
Dog bite, Rat bite 52 to study the pattern of poisoning, its morbidity, and mortality. A
Miscellaneous long term prospective study is needed in case of poisoning for
Food Poisoning Fish T64 4 understanding the clinical pattern and management techniques
Lizard in Food T62.8 5 which can help in intervention for a better outcome. An urgent
Stale food contaminated T64 19 need to implement preventative and intervention strategies
Parts of plants T62.2 6 to combat suicide needs national emphasis and awareness
Poisoning by antidote, measures.
T50.6 9
Chelating agent
Fumes/Gases Vapors T65 4 REFERENCES
Unknown T65.9 18 1. World Health Organization. Poisoning Prevention and Management.
2. National Crime Records Bureau, Ministry of Home Affairs. Accidental
with Symptomatic Treatment. A pediatric case of accidental eye Deaths and Suicides in India - New Delhi, 2012.
exposure to insecticide was managed by eye wash.
3. Satar S, Seydaoglu G, Akpinar A, Sebe A, Karakoc E, Gumusay U, et al.
The second class of Animal Bite and Stings type of Poisonings Trends in acute adult poisoning in a ten-year period in Turkey: factors
could be further classified as Snake Bites, Scorpion Bites, Dog affecting the hazardous outcome. Bratisl Lek Listy. 2009; 110: 404-
411.
Central
4. Davies JO, Eddleston M, Buckley NA. Predicting outcome in acute 15. Pathan Amanulla Khan, Dileep Chary M, Manoj Kumar M, BB Sarah
Organophosphorus poisoning with a poison severity score or the Nousheen. A study on treatment pattern and outcomes of poisoning
Glasgow coma scale. QJM. 2008; 101: 371-379. cases in a tertiary care and government district hospital. Int J Pharm
Pharm Sci. 2017; 9: 193-197.
5. Boyle JS, Bechtel LK, Holstege CP. Management of the critically
poisoned patient. Scandinavian J Trauma, Resuscitation Emerg Med. 16. John NA, John J. Prolonged use of mosquito coil, mats, and liquidators:
2009; 17-29. A review of its health implications. Int J Clin Exp Physiol. 2015; 2: 209-
213.
6. WHO International Working Group for Drug Statistics Methodology,
WHO Collaborating Centre for Drug Statistics Methodology, WHO 17. Amit Sharma, Vinay Pandit. Importance of Poison Information Center
Collaborating Centre for Drug Utilization Research and Clinical and Role of a Pharmacist in Management of Poisoning. Int J Pharm
Pharmacological Services. Introduction to drug utilization research. Teaching Practices. 2014; 5: 905-909.
Oslo, Norway: WHO Press; 2003.
18. Banerjee I, Tripathi SK, Sinha R, Sengupta P. Pesticide use pattern
7. Nair PK, Revi NG. One-Year Study on Pattern of Acute Pharmaceutical among farmers in a rural district of West Bengal, India. J Nat Sci Biol
and Chemical Poisoning Cases Admitted to a Tertiary Care Hospital in Med. 2014; 15: 313-316.
Thrissur, India. Asia Pac J Med Toxicol. 2015; 4: 79-82.
19. Jesslin J, Adepu R, Churi S. Assesment of Prevalence and Mortality
8. Wickramasinghe K, Steele P, Dawson A, Dharmaratne D, Gunawardena Incidence due to poisoning in South Indian Tertiary Care Teaching
A, Senarathna L, et al. Cost to government health-care services of Hospital. Indian J Pharm Sci. 2010; 72: 587-591.
treating acute self-poisonings in a rural district in Sri Lanka. Bull
20. Shakuntala, Yogesh G. Analysis of Organophosphorus Poisoning, at
World Health Organ. 2009; 87: 180-185.
tertiary care Hospital: A Report. J Evidence based Med Healthc. 2015;
9. Collector Office, Pune. District at a Glance. 2: 421-430.
10. Singh NP, Kaur G. Poisoning: Basic Considerations and Epidemiology. 21. Pratik D, Asari, Shreya M, Shah, Anand J, Amin, et al. Drug Utilization
In: Munjal YP, Sharma SK, Agarwal AK, Gupta P, Kamath SA, Nadkar Study on Acute Poisoning Cases Treated at a Tertiary Care Hospital in
MY, et al, editors. API Textbook of Medicine. 9th Ed. New Delhi, India: Western Part of India. Asia Pacific J Med Toxicol. 2016; 5: 20-24.
Jaypee Brothers Medical Pub; 2012.
22. Aiswarya Aravind, Mohandas Rai. The pattern of Acute Poisoning
11. Mittal N, Shafiq N, Malhotra S, Bhalla A, Pandhi P. A prospective Admissions in the Medical Intensive Care Unit of a Tertiary Care
observational study on different poisoning cases and their outcomes Hospital. Int J Pharm Sci Drug Res. 2014; 6: 239-242.
in a tertiary care hospital. SAGE Open Med. 2013; 1.
23. Kularatne SA, Kumarasiri PV, Pushpakumara SK, Dissanayaka WP,
12. Gupta P, Kumar A, Singh SP, Prakash M, Gupta M, Kumar P. Pattern of Ariyasena H, Gawarammana IB, et al. Routine antibiotic therapy in the
Cases of Acute Poisoning in a Rural Tertiary Care Center in Northern management of the local inflammatory swelling in venomous snake
India. National J Commun Med. 2016; 7: 307-310. bites: results of a placebo-controlled study. Ceylon Med J. 2005; 50:
151-155.
13. Ramesh V, Chavan VR, Arshad M, Raghunandan M, Faizuddin. A Study
on Pattern of Acute Poisoning in an Emergency Department of a 24. Priyendu A, Vandana KE, Varma M, Prabhu N, Rahim AA, Nagappa
Tertiary Care Hospital. Asian J Pharm Clin Res. 2016; 9: 361-363. AN. Antibiotic prophylaxis in organophosphorus poisoning: A study
of health and economic outcomes. Saudi Pharm J. 2017; 25: 332-336.
14. Naresh DTV, Shailendra D, Subbaratnam Y, Prasuna G, Rajashekar
K, Mary Rohini. Profile of Poisoning Cases in Tertiary Care Hospital, 25. Medscape.
Telangana, India. J Evidence Based Med Hlthcare. 2015; 2: 3032-3038.
26. Micromedex Solutions.