Professional Documents
Culture Documents
*Department of Industrial Engineering, University of Parma, Parco Area delle Scienze 181/A, 43124 - Parma –
Italy (giovanni.romagnoli@unipr.it)
Abstract: The paper performs a review of the literature of RFID deployments in the fashion and apparel retail
sector: 95 papers from different sources were carefully analyzed and organized in a proper data base, and the
contents of these papers were used to build a data base of RFID projects in the mentioned sector. The information
stored in the data base were then organised in descriptive statistics that depict the situation of RFID projects: the
statistics describe the papers we used to build our data base and, more important, the overview of RFID projects
that we reviewed, such as the types of products where item-level tags are employed the most (apparel, footwear or
accessories), the partition of projects and stores per geographic area and per type of projects (feasibility studies, pilot
projects or full deployments). Also, the use cases of RFID pursued were reported, together with respective number
of deployments and percentage values, and the same was done with results achieved, categorized in 6 main different
clusters.
Eventually, a statistics was reported to try to link the RFID use case investigated by a project to its possibility to
evolve into a full deployment, and the results of this statistics could greatly help managers to choose the best use
cases of RFID to be pursued for achieving competitive advantage.
Keywords: fashion and apparel retailing; RFID deployment; use cases; in the field analysis.
7
XX Summer School "Francesco Turco" - Industrial Systems Engineering
8
XX Summer School "Francesco Turco" - Industrial Systems Engineering
45,7% (min = 15,0% max = 70,0%). However, it is worth in these projects, although the single country that
noting that, since the use cases investigated by each experiences the higher value of RFID projects are the
project are records of our data base, a value of filled in United States, as it can be seen in Table 5, followed by
fields of 100% is only possible when a project pursued all Germany and Italy.
18 the use cases illustrated in (Esposito, Romagnoli,
Also, Table 5 reports that the most RFID projects were
Sandri, & Villani, 2015). Since the maximum number of
pilots, followed by feasibility studies and full deployments.
use cases investigated by a single project equals 10, the
This caught our attention, because a possible explanation
maximum value of filled in fields is 80%.
of these numbers is that (i) only a few number of firms
3.1 Descriptive statistics reported their feasibility studies before implementing
RFID and (ii) the number of pilot projects reported is
We distinguished the different products in apparel, more than double to the number of full deployments.
footwear, accessories and some combinations of them: This could mean that either the feasibility studies were not
this was done to see which categories experience the wider given so much academic importance, or that several
use of item-level RFID tags. Table 3 shows that apparel is companies felt so sure to implement RFID they jumped
the single most RFID-friendly category, while Accessories directly to piloting it. On the other one hand, the number
is the least of them. of pilots can outnumber the full deployments because of a
time lag (i.e. some of the today pilot’s will eventually
Table 3. Types of products where item level tags are become full deployments) or because of unsatisfactory
employed. results achieved by RFID pilots. Most probably, a
Product type # % combination of these issues come to play in each case;
however, to better understand the results achieved by
Apparel 33 42,9% RFID projects of our data base, we continued with some
Apparel/ Footwear / Accessories 17 22,1% other statistics as reported in the following paragraph.
9
XX Summer School "Francesco Turco" - Industrial Systems Engineering
Table 6. Use cases of RFID pursued and respective number of deployments and percentage values.
Level 2 UCs N. of deployments % of projects % of total deployments
1.1-Locating items 7 9,1% 2,2%
1.2-Loss prevention 35 45,5% 10,9%
1.3-POS Transaction / Faster checkout 15 19,5% 4,7%
1.4-Stock visibility / Replenishment from the backroom 39 50,6% 12,1%
2.1-Social shopping 2 2,6% 0,6%
2.2-Store associate availability / Customer knowledge 11 14,3% 3,4%
3.1-Customer experience 19 24,7% 5,9%
3.2-Cross-selling / cross-promotions 14 18,2% 4,4%
3.3-Store associate empowerment 5 6,5% 1,6%
4.1-Process automation 50 64,9% 15,6%
4.2-Process accuracy 34 44,2% 10,6%
4.3-After sales / Returns 9 11,7% 2,8%
5.1-Out of Stock / Inventory accuracy 46 59,7% 14,3%
5.2-Omnichanneling 7 9,1% 2,2%
5.3-Supply chain visibility 17 22,1% 5,3%
6.1-Grey market 3 3,9% 0,9%
6.2-Counterfeiting 4 5,2% 1,2%
6.3-Traceability 4 5,2% 1,2%
Total 321 100,0%
Table 7. Results achieved and relative frequency, average and maximum values.
Results # % of the % of the Avg. increase / Max increase /
projects total decrease decrease
R5 - Inventory accuracy 30 39,0% 24,2% 98,6% 99,9%
R4 - Inventory time reduction 27 35,1% 21,8% 88,5% 98,0%
R3 - Increased turnover/sales 23 29,9% 18,5% 7,0% 21,0%
R6 - Shrinkage reduction 17 22,1% 13,7% 40,0% 55,0%
R1 - Process time reduction 17 22,1% 13,7% 70,4% 95,0%
R2 - Increased process accuracy 10 13,0% 8,1% 8,0% 9,0%
Total 124 100,0%
Finally, all use cases presented in (Esposito, Romagnoli, result is achieved whenever, say, process accuracy is
Sandri, & Villani, 2015), together with the number of increased and process time is decreased by x and y%,
deployments registered for each use case, the percentage respectively).
of projects that pursued each one of them and the
As we can see in Table 7, the mostly achieved benefit is
percentage of total deployments allotted to each use case
inventory accuracy (around 39%). Also for inventory time
are reported in Table 6. The table shows that consistent
reduction (35,1%) and increased turnover/ sales (29,9%)
percentage of projects in our data base pursued 4.1-
big values have been recorded, while other performance
Process automation (almost 65% of projects), 5.1-Out of
indexes appeared a bit less.
Stock / Inventory accuracy (roughly 60% of projects), 1.4-
Stock visibility / Replenishment from the backroom About the percentage of increase/decrease the scenario is:
(50,6%), 1.2-Loss prevention (45,5%) and 4.2-Process on top of the classification we have inventory accuracy
accuracy (44,2%). and inventory time reduction where the maximum of
increase is almost 100% for the first one and 98% of
4. Results and discussion
decrease for the second one, while average values are
around 99% and 88%.
The average results achieved are shown in Table 7. The
2nd column reports the number of projects where each The first two are followed by process time reduction with
single result was documented: since more than one single a maximum value of 95% of decrease and an average of
result can be achieved by every single RFID project, the 70%. The results of other three performance indexes are
total of this column is higher than the total number of lower.
projects. The 3rd and 4th column calculates the
percentage over the number of projects and over the total Important though it is, Table 7 allows to understand
number of results achieved, while last two columns show which kind of results were more frequently found out, but
it cannot help specialists to understand which use cases
average and maximum value achieved of percent
could be pursued to “ensure” the higher probability of
increase/decrease for each performance index (e.g. a good
10
XX Summer School "Francesco Turco" - Industrial Systems Engineering
achieving results and, therefore, rolling out full RFID • use cases that most probably evolved pilot
deployments. We believe this point is very important for projects into full deployments:
practitioners because it can help to choose which use
cases to pursue when planning new RFID o 1.2-Loss prevention;
implementations. o 1.3-POS Transaction / Faster checkout;
To do so, we operated in the following way: first of all, we o 1.4-Stock visibility / Replenishment
considered only pilot projects and full deployment, from the backroom;
scratching out feasibility studies or unknown projects.
Afterwards, we tried to link projects, therefore achieving o 2.2-Store associate availability /
(i) which companies performed only pilot projects and did Customer knowledge;
not follow up with full deployments pursuing similar use o 4.2-Process accuracy;
cases; (ii) which companies, on the other hand, performed
directly full deployments, without anticipating them with o 4.3-After sales / Returns;
pilot projects; finally, we listed (iii) which companies o 5.1-Out of Stock / Inventory accuracy;
performed first a pilot and then, pursuing similar use
cases, continued with full RFID deployments. o 5.3-Supply chain visibility;
Eventually, we linked these three categories to the results • use cases that most probably started directly
achieved, only considering which kind of results were from full RFID deployments:
attained from the qualitative point of view and not taking
o 5.2-Omnichanneling;
into account the numerical values of results.
o 6.1-Grey market;
Table 8 reports what we achieved. As the table shows, the
number of projects that only undertook pilot projects o 6.3-Traceability;
equals 35, while 11 projects went directly for full
deployments and 22 projects performed first a pilot and • use cases that most probably stopped to pilot
then a closely related full deployments. projects without evolving into full deployments:
11
XX Summer School "Francesco Turco" - Industrial Systems Engineering
12
XX Summer School "Francesco Turco" - Industrial Systems Engineering
13
XX Summer School "Francesco Turco" - Industrial Systems Engineering
7.com/2012/09/20/mammoth-sporting-gods-deploys- RFID 24-7, 2013. Marks & Spencer to tag all apparel
item-level-tagging/ [Ac-cessed July 6, 2014]. items at 700-plus stores. RFID 24-7, Jan 15. Available at:
www.rfid24-7.com/2013/01/15/marks-spencer-to-tag-
RFID 24-7, 2012. Monnalisa tags 50 percent of apparel
all-apparel-items-at-700-plus-stores/ [Accessed June 2,
inventory. RFID 24-7, Oct, 24. Available at: www.rfid24-
2014].
7.com/2012/10/24/monnalisa-tags-50-percent-of-
apparel-inventory/ [Accessed July 6, 2014]. RFID 24-7, 2013. Retailer Gerry Weber enhances
customer experience with RFID, RFID 24-7, Dec 16.
RFID 24-7, 2012. Report: JC Penney will rely on RFID to
Available at: www.rfid24-7.com/video/retailer-gerry-
automate checkout lines. RFID 24-7, Jul 18. Available at: weber-enhances-customer-experience-with-rfid/
www.rfid24-7.com/2012/07/18/report-jc-penney-will-
[Accessed June 2, 2014].
rely-on-rfid-to-automate-check-out-lines/ [Accessed May
29, 2014]. RFID 24-7, 2013. White paper: Lord & Taylor boosts
shoe sales with RFID. RFID 24-7, Nov 11. Available at:
RFID 24-7, 2012. RFID will play a crucial role in JC
www.rfid24-7.com/2013/11/11/white-paper-lord-taylor-
Penney’s customer-centric sales strate-gy. RFID 24-7, Jul
boosts-shoe-sales-with-rfid/ [Accessed June 2, 2014].
25. Available at: www.rfid24-7.com/article/rfid-will-play-
a-crucial-role-in-jc-penney%E2%80%99s-customer- RFID 24-7, 2014. Footwear manufacturer to source tag
centric-sales-strategy/ [Accessed May 29, 2014]. entire inventory. RFID 24-7, Jan 9. Available at:
www.rfid24-7.com/2014/01/09/footwear-manufacturer-
RFID 24-7, 2013. American apparel deploys fixed reader
to-source-tag-entire-inventory/ [Accessed July 9, 2014].
system; solution eliminates need for handheld readers.
RFID 24-7, Aug 12. Available at: www.rfid24- RFID 24-7, 2014. Kohl’s Completes Chain-Wide RFID
7.com/article/american-apparel-deploys-fixed-reader- Deployment. RFID 24- 7, Jan 17. Available at:
system-solution-eliminates-need-for-handheld-readers/ www.rfid24-7.com/article/kohl%E2%80%99s-deploys-
[Ac-cessed June 2, 2014]. rfid-chain-wide-launches-consumer-engagement-apps/
[Accessed June 9, 2014].
RFID 24-7, 2013. C&A expands RFID program to 25
stores in Germany. RFID 24-7, Mar 20. Available at: RFID 24-7, 2014. Ll bean deploys RFID-based consumer
www.rfid24-7.com/2013/03/20/ca-expands-rfid- engagement tool. RFID 24-7, Jan 14. Available at:
program-to-25-stores-in-germany/ [Accessed June 22, www.rfid24-7.com/2014/01/14/ll-bean-deploys-rfid-
2014]. based-consumer-engagement-tool/ [Accessed July 6,
2014].
RFID 24-7, 2013. Five ways that retailer Faconnable will
benefit from RFID. RFID 24-7, Apr 10. Available at: RFID 24-7, 2014. Macy’s continues RFID rollout in 2014.
www.rfid24-7.com/article/five-ways-that-retailer- RFID 24-7, Jan 22. Available at: www.rfid24-
faconnable-will-benefit-from-rfid/ [Accessed July 6, 7.com/2014/01/22/macys-continues-rfid-rollout-in-
2014]. 2014/ [Accessed July 13, 2014].
RFID 24-7, 2013. French retailer deploys RFID for loss RFID 24-7, 2014. Marks & Spencer expands RFID
prevention. RFID 24-7, Aug 21. Available at: www.rfid24- rollout; will tag 400m items in 2014. RFID 24-7, Feb 27.
7.com/2013/08/21/french-retailer-deploys-rfid-for-loss- Available at: www.rfid24-7.com/2014/02/27/marks-will-
prevention/ [Accessed July 6, 2014]. tag-400m-items-in-2014/ [Accessed June 2, 2014].
RFID 24-7, 2013. German retailer Adler deploys RFID at RFID 24-7, 2014. RFID allows Coccinelle to use stores to
170 stores. RFID 24-7, Nov 29. Available at: www.rfid24- fulfill online orders. RFID 24-7, Feb 12. Available at:
7.com/2013/11/29/german-retailer-adler-deploys-rfid-at- www.rfid24-7.com/2014/02/12/apparel-retailer-
170-stores/ [Accessed July 9, 2014]. coccinelle-deploys-rfid-chain-wide/ [Accessed June 2,
2014].
RFID 24-7, 2013. German retailer Mersmann turns to
RFID for loss prevention. RFID 24-7, Jun 10. Available RIS News, 2010. Walmart and RFID, it's deja vu all over
at: www.rfid24-7.com/2013/06/10/german-retailer- again. Retail Information System, Jul 27. Available at:
mersmann-turns-to-rfid-for-loss-prevention/ [Accessed www.risnews.edgl.com/retail-news/Walmart-and-RFID,-
July 6, 2014]. It-s-Deja-Vu-All-Over-Again38027 [Accessed June 22,
2014].
RFID 24-7, 2013. Macy’s stellar q3 traced to RFID and
omnichannel. RFID 24-7, Nov 13. Available at: Roberti, M. 2010. Wal-Mart relaunches EPC RFID effort,
www.rfid24-7.com/2013/11/13/macy%E2%80%99s- starting with men's jeans and basics. RFID Journal, Jul 25.
stellar-q3-traced-to-rfid-and-omnichannel/ [Accessed July Available at: www.rfidjournal.com/articles/view?7753
13, 2014]. [Accessed July 13, 2014].
RFID 24-7, 2013. Macy’s updates RFID and omnichannel Roberti, M., 2011. Gerry Weber shows how retailers
strategy; DC’s might be a thing of the past. RFID 24-7, benefit from RFID. RFID Journal, Jul 25. Available at:
Jun 18. Available at: www.rfid24- www.rfidjournal.com/articles/view?8624 [Accessed June
7.com/article/macy%E2%80%99s-updates-rfid-and- 2, 2014].
omni-channel-strategy-dcs-might-be-a-thing-of-the-past/
[Accessed July 13, 2014].
14
XX Summer School "Francesco Turco" - Industrial Systems Engineering
Roberti, M., 2013. Marks & Spencer leads the way. RFID Swedberg, C., 2014. Kohl's rolls out RFID for select
Journal, Oct 21. Available at: product categories at its stores. RFID Journal, Jan 14.
www.rfidjournal.com/articles/view?11106/ [Accessed Available at: www.rfidjournal.com/articles/view?11341
June 2, 2014]. [Accessed June 9, 2014].
SCDigest Editorial Staff, 2010. RFID news: will WalMart TAGSYS RFID, 2010. Serge Blanco extends item-level
get RFID right this time? Supply Chain Digest, Jul 28. visibility to retail store with Tagsys RFID solution.
Available at: www.scdigest.com/assets/On_Target/10-07- Available at: www.tagsysrfid.com/Company/News-
28-1.php?cid=3609 [Accessed June 20, 2014]. events/Thursday-08-April-2010-SERGE-BLANCO-
EXTENDS-ITEM-LEVEL-VISIBILITY-TO-RETAIL-
SCDigest Editorial Staff, 2012. RFID News: JC Penney
STORE-WITH-TAGSYS-RFID-SOLUTION [Accessed
CEO says retailer going all in on RFID, perhaps with
June 19, 2014].
significant impact on the industry. Supply Chain Digest,
Aug 15. Available at: www.scdigest.com/ontarget/12-08- The Economist, 2012. Burberry goes digital. The
15-1.php?cid=6106&ctype=content [Accessed June 28, Economist, Sep 22. Available at:
2014]. www.economist.com/node/21563353. [Accessed July 20,
2014].
SCDigest Editorial Staff, 2013. RFID News: JC Penney’s
sudden retreat from RFID led to rash of store thefts. The Retail Bullettin, 2014. Special NRF report: Decathlon
Supply Chain Digest, Dec 3. Available at: develops RFID to revolutionise stores and back of house.
www.scdigest.com/ontarget/13-12-03-1.php?cid=7637 Available at:
[Accessed June 28, 2014]. http://www.theretailbulletin.com/news/special_nrf_repo
rtdecathlon_develops_rfid_to_revolutionise_stores_and_
Soudagar, R., 2013. How fashion retailer Burberry keeps
back_of_house_17-01-14/ [Accessed June 22, 2014].
customers coming back for more. Forbes, Oct 28.
Available at: VDC Research, 2012. The New Balance Experience Store
www.forbes.com/sites/sap/2013/10/28/how-fashion- in Boston runs away with RFID. Available at:
retailer-burberry-keeps-customers-coming-back-for- blog.vdcresearch.com/autoid/2012/05/the-new-balance-
more/ [Accessed July 20, 2014]. experience-store-in-boston-runs-away-with-rfid.html
[Accessed July 13, 2014].
Swedberg, C., 2009. Charles Vogele group finds RFID
helps it stay competitive. RFID Journal, Apr 29. Available Wessel, R., 2007. Metro Group's Galeria Kaufhof
at: www.rfidjournal.com/articles/view?4836 [Accessed launches UHF item-level pilot. RFID Journal, Sep 20.
June 2, 2014]. Available at: www.rfidjournal.com/articles/view?3624
[Accessed June 2, 2014].
Swedberg, C., 2011. RFID brings intelligence to Billabong
store in Brazil. RFID Journal, Aug 22. Available at: Wilding, R.D. & Delgardo, T., 2004. RFID demystified:
www.rfidjournal.com/articles/view?8722 [Accessed June Part 3 - Company case studies. Logistics and Transport
22, 2014]. Focus, 6(5), pp.32-42.
Swedberg, C., 2012. American Apparel adopting RFID at Zaino, J., 2011. RFID Journal Award winner: best RFID
every store. RFID Journal, Feb 8. Available at: implementation - Gerry Weber's pain-free RFID
www.rfidjournal.com/articles/view?9202 [Accessed June revolution. RFID Journal, Jul 25. Available at:
2, 2014]. www.rfidjournal.com/purchaseaccess?type=Article&id=8
622&r=%2Farticles%2Fview%3F8622 [Accessed June 2,
Swedberg, C., 2013. American Apparel deploys real-time,
2014].
storewide RFID inventory-management solution. RFID
Journal, Aug 13. Available at: Zanotti, L., 2012. Showroom and store: Patrizia Pepe
www.rfidjournal.com/articles/view?10906 [Accessed June changes the experience using RFID and touch screen. The
2, 2014]. biz loft - Digital news, Oct 12. Available at:
thebizloft.com/showroom-rfid-patrizia-
Swedberg, C., 2013. Italian purse company finds a discreet
pepe/#.U5gY_HJ_sts [Accessed July 13, 2014].
way to prevent gray market. RFID Journal, May 28.
Available at: www.rfidjournal.com/articles/view?10711
[Accessed June 22, 2014].
Swedberg, C., 2014. Hong Kong leather goods company
uses RFID to track inventory, fight diversion. RFID
Journal, Jan 27. Available at:
www.rfidjournal.com/articles/view?11379 [Accessed July
6, 2014].
Swedberg, C., 2014. Intersport expects RFID to boost its
sales, decrease its costs. RFID Journal, Feb 7. Available
at:www.rfidjournal.com/articles/view?11417 [Accessed
May 28, 2014].
15