You are on page 1of 27

`2C;54D 2= #A:2;:>174D *2D1>17< N[YN_a Ob^] ,269;1@A> !

cQQc &4@: *CBD174>125<


QO]NbPOcZdcQQceQNfN[aN\ Ob^]\ QcQ^ON /25H25E #A2C<45H -4M<E ,! 45H ":L V:DA1

!"#$%&'&#() *!+#$(&

! ,-",(*#.!/ +(!&&(&&)("#

01234551 ,4627714

!8&#+!,#
)459 9:4;< 4=>:; 1>< :?:;@:57: 15 >A: 3274BCD4;9 2= 72?64;4>13: 62D1>17<E >A:
D4B:D 2= F45>1%<9<>:?G 1< <>1DD 25: 2= >A: ?2<> C<:H >2 H:<7;1B: 4 64;>9 2; @;2C6
>A4> :I:;>< 4 ;4H174D =2;? 2= 2662<1>125J K2L:3:;E >A: >:;? A4< B::5 C<:H 15 45
157;:4<15@D9 1H12<957;4>17 ?455:;E LA17A ?4M:< 1> 15466;26;14>: =2; 72?64;4%
>13: ;:<:4;7AJ #A: 2;1@15< 2= >A: 7257:6> ;:<1H: 15 >A: L;1>15@< 2= &4;>2;1 25
64;>9 <9<>:?< 15 >A: NOPQ< 45H NORQ<E LA:;: 1> ?415D9 ;:=:;;:H >2 >A: >2>4D1>4;%
145 64;>1:< 2= >A: 15>:;%L4; 45H 62<>%L4; H:74H:<J &157: 1>< 157:6>125E A2L:3:;E
>A: 7257:6> 2= 45 45>1%<9<>:? 64;>9 A4< 52> 25D9 B::5 C<:H 15 64;>9 <9<>:?
454D9<1<E BC> 4D<2 15 >A: 725>:I> 2= :?61;174D <>CH1:< 2= 34;12C< 4<6:7>< 2= >A:
D1=: 2= H:?27;4>17 ;:@1?:<E >2 15H174>: 7A4DD:5@:< >2 1>< <>4B1D1>9E D:@1>1?479
2;E ?2;: ;:7:5>D9E 725<2D1H4>125J #A1< 4;>17D: ;:725<>;C7>< >A: 7257:6> 2=
F45>1%<9<>:?5:<<G B9 H1<:5>45@D15@ 1>< H1==:;:5> :?61;174D ;:=:;:5>< 15 64;>9
<9<>:? >A:2;9 45H 15 >A: :?61;174D 454D9<1< 2= H:?27;479E 45H 6;262<:< 4
?2;: ;:S5:H >962D2@9 2= F45>1%<9<>:? 64;>1:<GJ
T(' U-+V& ! 45>1%<9<>:? 64;>1:< ! 7257:6>C4D 454D9<1< ! H:?27;479 ! 64;>9
<9<>:?<

!"#$%&'(#)%"

#A1< 4;>17D: <::M< >2 7D4;1=9 >A: 7257:6> 2= >A: 45>1%<9<>:? 64;>9 45H >2
4HH;:<< >A: WC:<>125 2= LA:>A:; 45H A2L 1> 745 B: C<:=CDD9 :?6D29:H =2;
>A: 72?64;4>13: 454D9<1< 2= 64;>9 <9<>:?< 45H H:?27;4>17 ;:@1?:<J !D>A2C@A
>A: 7257:6>E B9 1>< 3:;9 54>C;:E H2:< 52> D:5H 1><:D= >2 7D:4;%7C> 26:;4>1254D1%
X4>125E $ 4;@C: >A4> 1>< C>1D1>9 1< :31H:5>J #A: 74>:@2;9 2= F45>1%<9<>:?5:<<G L1DD
B: 454D9X:H 15 >A: D1@A> 2= >A: D2@174D ;CD:< =2; 7257:6>C4D =2;?4>125 45H
;:725<>;C7>125E L1>A >A: 41? 2= 7D4;1=915@ 1>< ?:4515@ 45H 6;:71<125E 45H <2
:5A45715@ 1>< 466D174B1D1>9 L1>A15 72?64;4>13: 454D9<:< Y&4;>2;1E NORQ4E
NOZ[4E NOON\ &4;>2;1 :> 4DJE NOR]\ ,2DD1:; 45H )4A25E NOO^_J !5>1%<9<>:?5:<<E

$ >A45M &>:=452 84;>2D151E $5@;1H 345 81:X:5E )4>>A1g< 82@44;H<E +17A4;H 8;::5E 8:66:
V1 *4D?4E &1?25 KC@E *:>:; )41;E *A1D166: &7A?1>>:;E 4< L:DD 4< >A: :H1>2; 2= >A: !"#$%&' "(
)*+"$+,-.&' /"'-,-.0 45H >A;:: 45259?2C< ;:31:L:;< =2; >A:1; C<:=CD 72??:5>< 45H <C@@:<>125<
25 6;:312C< 3:;<125< 2= >A1< 4;>17D:J #A: C<C4D H1<7D41?:; 466D1:<J

Downloaded from http://jtp.sagepub.com at SWETS WISE ONLINE CONTENT on July 26, 2009
NQ `-.+"!/ -h #K(-+(#$,!/ *-/$#$,& N[YN_

15 =47>E 1< 4 7257:6> >A4> A4< <C==:;:H =;2? 725<1H:;4BD: F<>;:>7A15@G Y&4;>2;1E
NORQ4_E 52> D:4<> B:74C<: 2= 1>< C5H1==:;:5>14>:H 466D174>125 47;2<< >L2 H1<%
>157> S:DH< 2= 454D9<1<a >A: <>CH9 2= 64;>9 <9<>:?<E 25 >A: 25: A45HE 45H
>A: :?61;174D 454D9<1< 2= B;24H:; 4<6:7>< 2= >A: D1=: 2= H:?27;4>17 ;:@1?:<E
25 >A: 2>A:;J $ 4;@C: >A4> >A: 7257:6> 2= 45>1%<9<>:?5:<< LA:5 466D1:H >2 64;%
>1:< ;:=:;< >2 H1==:;:5> 1= 64;>14DD9 23:;D46615@ ;:4D1>1:< 15 B2>A S:DH<J $5 64;>9
<9<>:? 454D9<1<E >A: 7257:6> 6215>< >2 >A: 1H:2D2@174D 1-((+$+%.+ 2= 25: 2;
?2;: 64;>1:< =;2? >A: 2>A:;< 15 >A: <9<>:?E LA1D: L1>A15 >A: ?2;: @:5:;4D
454D9<1< 2= H:?27;4>17 ;:@1?:< >A: 6;1?4;9 ;:=:;:57: 1< >2 4 64;>9G< 15A:;:5>
1H:2D2@174D .*&$&.,+$JN
#A: 7257:6> 2= 45 45>1%<9<>:? 64;>9 1< 45 :<<:5>14D :D:?:5> 2= &4;>2;1G<
>A:2;9 2= 64;>9 <9<>:?< Y&4;>2;1E NOPPE NORQBE NORPE NOZc\ <:: 4D<2 &4;>2;1E
NOORa PR_J *;1?4 =471:E >A: H:S51>125< 2= F45>1%<9<>:?5:<<G @13:5 B9
&4;>2;1 4D<2 157DCH:H >A: 2Bg:7>13: :D:?:5> 2= 4 64;>9G< 1H:2D2@174D .*&$&.,+$2
K2L:3:;E 15 >A: 725>:I> 2= &4;>2;1G< >A:2;9E >A: H:S51>1254D 4>>;1BC>: 2= 45>1%
<9<>:?5:<< 1< ;:D4>1254DE B:15@ @13:5 B9 >A: 1H:2D2@174D 1-((+$+%.+ B:>L::5 25:
2; ?2;: 64;>1:< 45H >A: 2>A:; 64;>1:< 2= >A: <9<>:?J #AC<E 15 64;>9 <9<>:?
>A:2;9E >A: H1?:5<125 2= 72?64;1<25 2= F64;>9 45>1%<9<>:?5:<<G 1< >A: -1+"3
'"4-.&' 1-0,&%.+ 2= 25: 64;>9 =;2? >A: 2>A:;< 15 ;:<6:7> >2 1<<C:< 2= 7;C714D
1?62;>457: =2; >A: ;:@1?: 15 LA17A >A:<: 64;>1:< 26:;4>:J $5 >A: D1>:;4>C;:E
A2L:3:;E >A: 6;26:;>9 2= F45>1%<9<>:?5:<<G A4< 2=>:5 B::5 4<<1@5:H >2 4
64;>9 Y2; @;2C6_ 25 >A: :I7DC<13: B4<1< 2= >A: 2Bg:7>13: 725>:5> 2= 1>< 1H:2D2@9E
L1>A2C> ;:=:;;15@ >2 :1>A:; 1>< FH1<>457:G =;2? >A: 2>A:; 64;>1:< 15 >A: <9<>:?
2; >2 >A: :==:7>< 25 >A: ?:7A4517< 2= >A4> 64;>9 <9<>:? >A4> >A: 6;:<:57: 2=
<C7A 4 64;>9 1< D1M:D9 >2 :I:;>J $5 >A:<: 74<:<E 45 F45>1%<9<>:? 64;>9G 1<
<1?6D9 <::5 4< 4 >A;:4> >2 >A4> ;:@1?:E 45H 2=>:5 4< 4 >A;:4> >2 H:?27;479
>2C> 72C;> Y:J@J ":>>DE NOPZa ]RN_J
$5 >A1< 4;>17D:E $ >A:;:=2;: :D4B2;4>: 4 <:64;4>: 7257:6>C4D ;:725<>;C7>125 2=
F45>1%<9<>:?5:<<G 15 64;>9 <9<>:? >A:2;9 45H 15 :?61;174D H:?27;4>17 >A:2;9E
H1<:5>45@D15@ >A: >L2 H1==:;:5> ?:4515@< 45H :?61;174D ;:=:;:5>< >A4> 4;:
1532D3:HJ 89 454D9X15@ >A: FD1>:;4>C;:G 2= >A: 7257:6> Y&4;>2;1E NOZ[4a [P_E
>A4> 1<E 1>< 2;1@15< 15 &4;>2;1G< L2;M 25 64;>9 <9<>:?<E 45H 1>< <CB<:WC:5>
C<: B9 2>A:; 4C>A2;<E $ H1<>15@C1<A B:>L::5 F;:D4>1254DG 45>1%<9<>:?5:<<E
LA17A 1< ;:D:345> =2; 64;>9 <9<>:? 454D9<1<E 45H F1H:2D2@174DG 45>1%<9<>:?5:<<E
LA17A 1< ;:D:345> =2; >A: :?61;174D 454D9<1< 2= H:?27;471:<E LA:>A:; >A1<

NJ #A: 454D9<1< =27C<:< 25 45>1%<9<>:?5:<< 15 H:?27;4>17 <9<>:?<E :3:5 >A2C@A >A: 7257:6>E
6:; <:E 72CDH B: 466D1:H >2 4DD ;:@1?:< Y&4;>2;1E NOZc\ <:: 4D<2E :J@J &417AE NOOQ\ /:L1<E NOOR_J
)2;:23:;E LA1D<> 15 64;>9 <9<>:? >A:2;9 >A: 4>>;1BC>: 5:7:<<4;1D9 ;:=:;< >2 4 64;>9E 15 B;24H:;
454D9<:< 2= H:?27;479 1> 745 157DCH: 525%64;>9 47>2;<J $5 >A1< D4>>:; ;:<6:7>E >A: ;:=:;:57: >2
64;>1:< 15 >A: >:I> 1< =2; >A: <4M: 2= <1?6D171>9J

Downloaded from http://jtp.sagepub.com at SWETS WISE ONLINE CONTENT on July 26, 2009
,!*-,,$!a !"#$%&'&#() *!+#$(& NN

1532D3:< >A: 454D9<1< 2= H:?27;4>17 D:@1>1?479E <>4B1D1>9E 725<2D1H4>125 2;


LA4>:3:;J $> 1< 1?62;>45> >2 :?6A4<1X: >A4>E LA:5 466D1:H >2 64;>1:<E >A:<:
>L2 =2;?< 2= 45>1%<9<>:?5:<< 5::H 52> B: 6;:<:5> 4> >A: <4?: >1?:E LA17A
A4< 4 @;:4> 1?62;>457: =2; 72?64;4>13: <>CH1:< 15 >A: S:DHJ $5 =47>E 4D>A2C@A
>A: 72?B154>125 2= ?:4515@< L4< 7A4;47>:;1<>17 2= >A: F>2>4D1>4;145 64;>1:<G 2=
>A: NOcQ< 45H NO^Q<E >A: L4515@ 2= 45>1%H:?27;4>17 1H:2D2@1:< 15 >A: 725>:?%
62;4;9 L2;DH A4< :==:7>:H 4 ?C7A <A4;6:; <:64;4>125 B:>L::5 >A: >L2J !<
L1DD B: <A2L5 D4>:;E >A1< H1<>157>125 1< >A:;:=2;: 2= 64;>17CD4; 1?62;>457:
=2; >A: 454D9<1< 2= 725>:?62;4;9 :I>;:?1<> 64;>1:<J

*+, -%"(,.#'/0 1,(%"2#$'(#)%" %3 45"#)6272#,8",229:


;,",$/0 <=2,$>/#)%"2

#A: >:;? F45>1%<9<>:? 64;>9G 466:4;:H 15 >A: ?2H:;5 62D1>174D <71:57: D1>:;4%
>C;: 15 >A: :4;D9 NOPQ<Jc $> L4< >A:5 C<:HE 4> >A: <4?: >1?: 4< 2>A:; 454D2@2C<
D4B:D<E^ 15 2;H:; >2 ;:=:; >2 64;>17CD4; M15H< 2= 64;>1:< Y6;1?4;1D9 =4<71<>E 54X1
45H 72??C51<>_ LA17AE 15 V44DH:;G< YNOPPBa P[_ >:DD15@ 6A;4<:E F64;>17164>:H
15 2;H:; >2 H:<>;29GE >A:;:B9 =2;715@ >A: 72DD46<: 2= 4 5C?B:; 2= (C;26:45
H:?27;471:< HC;15@ >A: 15>:;%L4; 6:;12H 45H :5H45@:;15@ 9:> 2>A:;< HC;15@
>A: 62<>%L4; 9:4;<J )2;: ;:7:5>D9E L1>A >A: 62D1>174D :32DC>125 2= L:<>:;5
H:?27;471:<E 45H L1>A >A: <6;:4H 2= H:?27;4>17 ;:@1?:< 15 >A: 525%L:<>:;5
L2;DHE L: A43: L1>5:<<:H 4 6;2D1=:;4>125 2= F45>1G D4B:D< 15 >A: D1>:;4>C;:[ 45HE
4> >A: <4?: >1?:E 4 725<1H:;4BD: <>;:>7A15@ 2= >A: 7257:6> 2= >A: 45>1%<9<>:?

cJ #A: S;<> =2;?CD4>125 2= >A: 7257:6> 745 B: =2C5HE >2 >A: B:<> 2= ?9 M52LD:H@:E 15 4 7A46>:;
B9 &4;>2;1 15 45 :H1>:H 32DC?: 6CBD1<A:H 15 NOP^ Y&4;>2;1E NOP^_J $>< S;<> C<: 4< 4 >22D =2; 72?%
64;4>13: 454D9<1<E A2L:3:;E 1< H4>:H NOPPE 45H 745 B: =2C5H 15 45 :<<49 4B2C> 62D4;1X:H ?CD>1%
64;>9 <9<>:?< Y&4;>2;1E NOPP_J !< K45< V44DH:; Y6:;<254D 72??C5174>125_ ;:62;><E A2L:3:;E
>A: >:;? 5::H 52> B: 45 153:5>125 2= &4;>2;1E 4< 1> L4< 4D;:4H9 2= 72??25 C<4@: 4?25@ >A:
<7A2D4;< YLA2 157DCH:H &4;>2;1_ 64;>17164>15@ 4> >A: ?::>15@< 2= >A: 6;2g:7> 25 72?64;4>13:
2662<1>125< 15 >A: :4;D9 NOPQ<E LA2<: 6;27::H15@< D4>:; 74?: >2@:>A:; 15 >A: <:?154D 32DC?:
:H1>:H B9 +J !J V4AD YV4ADE NOPP_J (<>4BD1<A15@ LA2 >A: 153:5>2; 2= >A: D4B:D 1<E 4> 459 ;4>:E
A4< 4 D1?1>:H 1?62;>457:J UA4> V44DH:;G< >:<>1?259 <A2L< 1< >A4> >A: 7257:6> L4< C<:H 15H1==:;%
:5>D9 15 B2>A 64;>9 <9<>:? >A:2;9 45H :?61;174D 454D9<:< 2= H:?27;479 =;2? 1>< 3:;9 157:6>125J
^J #A: ;:=:;:57: A:;: 1< >2 >A: 7257:6>< 2= F?4g2; <>;C7>C;4D 2662<1>125GE 15>;2HC7:H B9 V4AD
YNOPP_E 45H 2= F2662<1>125 2= 6;15716D:GE 7215:H B9 T1;7AA:1?:; YNOPP4E B_J !D<2 >A: 7257:6> 2=
FH1<D294D 2662<1>125G Y/15XE NORZ_E S;<> C<:H 4 H2X:5 2= 9:4;< D4>:;E ;:=:;;:H :<<:5>14DD9 >2 >A: <4?:
;:4D1>9J
[J &7A:HD:; YNOOPa cOc_ D1<>< 4B2C> N] 2= <C7A D4B:D< C<:H 15 >A: D1>:;4>C;: >2 H:<7;1B: >A: 4>>1%
>CH:< 2= 62D1>174D 64;>1:<J K1< D1<> 1< 52> :IA4C<>13:a =2; :I4?6D:E 25: 72CDH 4HH >A: F45>1%<>;C7>C;:G
64;>1:< YV:L47A>:;E NOZRa cZO_E 2; >A: F45>1%64;>9 <9<>:?G 64;>1:< YT4>XE NOOPa N^^_J

Downloaded from http://jtp.sagepub.com at SWETS WISE ONLINE CONTENT on July 26, 2009
Nc `-.+"!/ -h #K(-+(#$,!/ *-/$#$,& N[YN_

64;>9 1><:D=J] )2;: @:5:;4DD9E >A: D4B:D 45>1%<9<>:? A4< B::5 C<:H =2; 4 64;>9
2; 4 @;2C6 L1>A 525%H:?27;4>17 1H:4D< YV44DH:;E NOPP4E B\ 8CH@: 45H
K:;?45E NORZ\ 325 8:9?:E NOZ]\ h:;;4;:<1E NOZZ_\P 2; LA2<: <C662;>:;< 2;
?:?B:;< :5@4@: 15 C57253:5>1254DE 1DD:@4D 2; 312D:5> B:A4312; Yi1??:;%
?455E NOZO_\ 2; LA17A 1< ?2;: 2; D:<< F1<2D4>:HG B9 >A: 2>A:; 62D1>174D
47>2;< Y*CDX:;E NOZR\ 81DD:E NOOQ_JR $5H::HE <2 6:;34<13: 1< 1>< C<: >A4> <2?:
4C>A2;< A43: 74<> H2CB> 25 1>< 454D9>174D 62L:;E 6;:=:;;15@ >2 H1<74;H >A:
7257:6> 4D>2@:>A:; 4< 2= 4D?2<> 5:@D1@1BD: 34DC: Y:J@J *;1HA4?E NOZR\ &?1>AE
NOZR_J
"25:>A:D:<<E >A:;: 4;: 4 5C?B:; 2= ;:4<25< >2 4;@C: >A4> >A: 7257:6> <>1DD
;:>415< 4 34DC4BD: 7D4<<1S74>2;9 62L:;E 45H >A4> 1>< 4B45H25?:5> L2CDH CD>1%
?4>:D9 D:4H >2 45 1?623:;1<A?:5> 2= 2C; C5H:;<>45H15@ 2= 62D1>174D ;:4D1>1:<J
$5 64;>9 <9<>:? 454D9<1<E =2; :I4?6D:E 25: 2= >A: ?415 155234>125< 2=
&4;>2;1G< 466;247A L4< >2 6;231H: 4 <2D1H 454D9>174D B4<1< 25 LA17A >2 H1<>15%
@C1<A B:>L::5 FD1?1>:H 45H ?2H:;4>:G 45H F:I>;:?: 45H 62D4;1X:HG 74<:< 2=
6DC;164;>1<?E LA17AE C5>1D >A:5E A4H >:5H:H >2 B: DC?6:H >2@:>A:; 4<
<1?6D: F?CD>1%64;>9 <9<>:?<GJ #A: 4B<:57: 2; 6;:<:57: 2= 45>1%<9<>:? 64;>1:<
4< 45 15H174>2; 2= 1H:2D2@174D 62D4;1X4>125 1< 6;:71<:D9 25: 2= >A: M:9 H:S515@
>;41>< 2= >A:<: H1==:;:5> >96:< 2= 64;>9 <9<>:?< Y&4;>2;1E NORPa N^cb[_J #2 H1<%
74;H >A: 7257:6> 2= >A: 45>1%<9<>:? 64;>9 72CDH >A:;:=2;: =2;7: C< B47M >2

]J #A: 7257:6> 2= 45>1%<9<>:? 64;>9 A4< <A2L5 4 725<1H:;4BD: ;:<1D1:57: 15 B2>A H1<6D4715@ 1><
2DH F;:D4>13:<GE 45H 15 ;:<1<>15@ >A: 4<<4CD> 2= >A: ?459 5:L 454D2@2C< >:;?< ?2;: ;:7:5>D9 7215:H
2; 4H26>:H >2 H:<7;1B: 4 7:;>415 =2;? 2= F;4H174DG 2662<1>125 2= 4 64;>9 2; @;2C6J ! 72?6C>:;1X:H
<:4;7A 15 <:3:;4D H4>4B4<:< YF$5>:;54>1254D *2D1>174D &71:57: !B<>;47><GE F$5>:;54>1254D 81BD12@;4%
6A9 2= >A: &2714D &71:57:<GE F&2712D2@174D !B<>;47>< NOZPbNOOOG_E 25 4;>17D:< 2= 62D1>174D <71:57:<
6CBD1<A:H 15 >A: D4<> NQbNc 9:4;<E <A2L:H >A4> >A: D4B:D F45>1%<9<>:?G 1< <>1DD ?2;: C<:H >A45 >:;?<
<C7A 4< F45>1%:<>4BD1<A?:5>G 2; F45>1%64;>9G 15 4 ;2C@A 6;262;>125 ;:<6:7>13:D9 2= 25: >2 >A;:: 45H
25: >2 S3:J #A: =CDD :I6;:<<125 F45>1%<9<>:? 64;>9G ;:7C;;:H 15 4B2C> A4D= 2= >A: 74<:< 15 LA17A >A:
4Hg:7>13: L4< C<:HJ #A: <:4;7A 4D<2 <A2L:H >A4> >A: >:;?< 2= FY?4g2;_ <>;C7>C;4D 2662<1>125GE
F2662<1>125 2= 6;15716D:G 45H FH1<D294D 2662<1>125G A43: 31;>C4DD9 H1<466:4;:H =;2? >A: D45@C4@:
2= 62D1>174D 454D9<1<J
PJ UA1D: 7;1>171X15@ >A: 466D174B1D1>9 2= >A: D4B:D 2= F45>1%<9<>:? 64;>1:<G >2 >A: :I>;:?1<>< 2= >A:
D:=> 45H 2= >A: ;1@A> Y464;> =;2? A1<>2;174D 74<:<_E &?1>A ?415>415< >A4> <:7:<<1251<> 64;>1:< 45H
?23:?:5>< 6;:<:5> C5:WC13274D 7A4;47>:;1<>17< 2= 45>1%<9<>:?5:<< Y&?1>AE NOZRa Pc\ <:: 4D<2
)25>:;2E NOO]_J $5 6;15716D:E >A: 7A4;47>:;1<>17 2= 1H:2D2@174D 45>1%<9<>:?5:<< 4< H:S5:H 15 >A:
6;:<:5> 4;>17D: 745 B: 466D1:H >2 <:7:<<1251<> 64;>1:< >22J $5 >A: >:I>E $ =27C< 25 45>1%H:?27;4>17
64;>1:< =2; >A: <4M: 2= <1?6D171>9J
RJ #A: FB:A4312C;4DG <:> 2= 4>>;1BC>:< 1< >A: D:4<> ;:=:;;:H >2E 4D<2 B:74C<: 15 >A: D4<> H:74H:<
6;47>174DD9 4DD 64;>1:<E :3:5 :I>;:?: 25:<E A43: 4H26>:H 64;D14?:5>4;9 ?:45< Y&?1>AE NOZR_J
8:A4312C;4D 7A4;47>:;1<>17<E A2L:3:;E :?:;@: 15 <:3:;4D 454D9<:< 15 LA17A >A: 7257:6> 2= F45>1%
<9<>:?G 1< C<:H Y)CDD:; :> 4DJE NOZc\ U:DX:DE NOO]\ -;26:X4E NOOZ_J $5 >A: <4?: ;:<6:7>E 1> 1<
15>:;:<>15@ >2 52>17: >A4> <2?:>1?:< >A: D4B:D A4< B::5 ;:=:;;:H >2 >:;;2;1<> @;2C6< Y*2DD47M
45H 0;C:@:DE NOZR_E 45H :3:5 >2 @C:;;1DD4 ?23:?:5>< Y&>43:5A4@:5E NOON_J #A: F;:D4>1254DG 7A4;%
47>:;1<>17< A43: 4D<2 B::5 C<:H & ."%,$&$-"E >2 H:59 >A: 466;26;14>:5:<< 2= >A: D4B:D =2; 7:;>415
64;>1:<E @13:5 >A:1; F525%1<2D4>125G Y*CDX:;E NOZRa cQ_J

Downloaded from http://jtp.sagepub.com at SWETS WISE ONLINE CONTENT on July 26, 2009
,!*-,,$!a !"#$%&'&#() *!+#$(& N^

;:D915@ 25 >A: 7;CH: 45H :<<:5>14DD9 C5A:D6=CD H1<>157>125 B:>L::5 >L2% 45H
?CD>1%64;>9 <9<>:?<J
$5 :?61;174D 454D9<:< 2= H:?27;479E >A: >:;? 45>1%<9<>:? A4< 45 2B312C<
A1<>2;174D ;:=:;:5>E H1<>15@C1<A15@ >A2<: 64;>1:< >A4> A43: 6D49:H >A: H:?2%
7;4>17 @4?: L1>A >A: 2Bg:7>13: 2= H:<>;2915@ H:?27;479 1><:D=J ! <1?1D4;
>A;:4> >2 H:?27;479 745 B: <>1DD 1H:5>1S:H 52L4H49< 4?25@ >A: ?2<> ;4H174D
2= >A: $<D4?17 =C5H4?:5>4D1<> 64;>1:< 45H @;2C6< >A4> 4;: 52L 47>13: 15 4
5C?B:; 2= 5:L H:?27;4>17 ;:@1?:<J "::HD:<< >2 <49E >A: H1==:;:57:< B:>L::5
>A:<: 45H >A: 2DH:; (C;26:45 F>2>4D1>4;145 64;>1:<G YVC3:;@:;E NO]N_ 4;:
1??:H14>:D9 4664;:5>J K2L:3:;E 45 1?62;>45> <1?1D4;1>9 725<1<>< :I47>D9 15
>A:1; 2662<1>125 >2 6DC;4D1<> H:?27;479E LA17A 1< <::5 4< 1572?64>1BD: L1>A
>A:1; 1H:2D2@174D ;:=:;:5><J #A1< 71;7C?<>457: A1@AD1@A>< >A: =47> >A4> >A:
D4B:D 2= 45>1%<9<>:?E 2; 45 454D2@2C< 25:E 72;;:<625H< >2 4 =C5H4?:5>4D
'"4-.&' 5:7:<<1>9E 15 H:?27;471:<J #2 6C> 1> 3:;9 <1?6D9a <157: H:?27;4>17
<9<>:?< 4;: B4<:H 25 >A: 15<>1>C>1254D1X4>125 2= 62D1>174D H1<<:5>E LA17A 1<
45 :<<:5>14D 64;> 2= >A: 62D1>174D 6;27:<< Y$25:<7C 45H H: )4H4;14@4E NOPZ_E
>A:;: 745 B:E 15 4B<>;47>E 52 4 6;12;1 D1?1>4>125 25 >A: H:@;:: 2= H1<<:5>
>A4> 45 2662<1>125 745 3217:J !< 4 ;:<CD>E >A:;: ?49 L:DD B: 4 64;>9 2;
@;2C6 >A4> H1<<:5>< 25 >A: B4<17 6;15716D:< 2; 15<>1>C>125< 2= H:?27;479
1><:D= Y157DCH15@ >A: 3:;9 ;1@A> >2 H1<<:5>_E >A:;:B9 @1315@ ;1<: >2 4 WC4D1>4>13:D9
H1<>157> M15H 2= 2662<1>125 >A4> 5::H< 4 H1<>157> D4B:D Y#2<1E NOPP\ ":>>DE
NOPZ_J

5..0)(/#)%"2 )" #+, 5"/072)2 %3 ?/$#7 @72#,82:


41,0/#)%"/09 5"#)6272#,8",22

$5 A1< <:?154D 454D9<1< 2= 64;>9 <9<>:?< &4;>2;1 YNORP_ 2==:;< >L2 H:S51>125<
2= 45 45>1%<9<>:? 64;>9E 25: B;24H 45H 25: 54;;2LJ #A: B;24H H:S51>125Z 1<
7257:13:H 4< :572?64<<15@ 4DD >A: 62<<1BD: 34;14>125< 15 >1?: 45H <647: 2= >A:
4>>1>CH:< 2= <C7A 64;>1:< 45H >A:1; :D:7>2;4>:<E ;45@15@ F=;2? 4D1:54>125 >2

ZJ
hC;>A:;?2;:E 52> 4DD >A: 45>1%<9<>:? 64;>1:< 4;: <C7A 15 >A: <4?: <:5<:a #A: 5:@4>125
723:;<E 2; ?49 723:;E 4 L1H: <645 2= H1==:;:5> 4>>1>CH:< ;45@15@ =;2? F4D1:54>125G 45H
>2>4D ;:=C<4D >2 F6;2>:<>GJ "2LE 7D:4;D9 4D1:54>125 45H 6;2>:<> 4;: H1==:;:5> 15 M15HE 52>
?:;:D9 15 H:@;:: J J J ':> >A: H1<>157>125 74552> B: :4<1D9 466D1:H 25 :?61;174D @;2C5H<E
B:74C<: D4;@: :D:7>2;4>:< 723:; 4DD >A:<: <:5>1?:5><E 2; 4>>1>CH:<J j2>:;< 745 B: 6;2%
>:<>:;<E LA1D: >A: 64;>9 47>131<>< 745 B: 4D1:54>:Ha /1M:L1<:E >A: 64;>9 D:4H:;<A16
745 B: 1H:2D2@174DD9 ?2>134>:HE LA:;:4< >A: ;45M 45H SD: ?49 <1?6D9 D47M B;:4HJ

#A1< H:S51>125 :572?64<<:< F4DD >A: ;:=C<4D%>2%6;2>:<> 64;>1:<G Y&4;>2;1E NORPa N^cb^_J

Downloaded from http://jtp.sagepub.com at SWETS WISE ONLINE CONTENT on July 26, 2009
N[ `-.+"!/ -h #K(-+(#$,!/ *-/$#$,& N[YN_

6;2>:<>G Y&4;>2;1E NORPa N^c_J #A: 34;12C< :D:?:5>< B;2C@A> L1>A15 >A1<
H:S51>125 A43: 4< 4 ?151?C? 72??25 72;: >A: 1+'+4-,-5-6-%4 -57&., 25
>A: ;:@1?: 2= >A: 64;>9G< 6;264@45H4 45H 47>125<J #A: 54;;2L H:S51>125E
B9 725>;4<>E =27C<:< 25 >A: 1H:2D2@174D 7A4;47>:;1<>17< 2= >A: 64;>9a F45 45>1%
<9<>:? 64;>9 L2CDH 52> 7A45@: b 1= 1> 72CDH b >A: @23:;5?:5> BC> >A: 3:;9
<9<>:? 2= @23:;5?:5>J $>< 2662<1>125 1< J J J 45 FF2662<1>125 2= 6;15716D:GG G
Y&4;>2;1E NORPa N^^_J !D>A2C@A A:;: >A: =27C< <::?< >2 B: 25 >A: 1H:2D2@174D
.*&$&.,+$ 2= 4 64;>9E >A: ;:D4>1254D 4<6:7> 2= >A: H:S51>125 <225 B:72?:< 7D:4;
LA:5 &4;>2;1 :D4B2;4>:< >A: 6215>a

#A: A4;H 72;: 2= >A: 7257:6> 1< <15@D:H 2C> B9 52>15@ >A4> 45 45>1%<9<>:? 2662<1>125
4B1H:< B9 4 B:D1:= <9<>:? >A4> H2:< 52> <A4;: >A: 34DC:< 2= >A: 62D1>174D 2;H:; 8-,*-%
8*-.* -, "7+$&,+02 !772;H15@ >2 >A: <>;17> H:S51>125E >A:5E 45>1%<9<>:? 64;>1:< ;:6;:<:5>
45 :I>;45:2C< 1H:2D2@9 b >A:;:B9 15H174>15@ 4 62D1>9 725=;25>:H L1>A 4 ?4I1?4D -1+"3
'"4-.&' 1-0,&%.+J Y&4;>2;1E NORPa N^^E :?6A4<1< 4HH:HJ_

&4;>2;1G< 7257:6> 2= >A: 45>1%<9<>:? 64;>9 1< >AC< F;:D4>1254DG 15 4 >L2=2DH


<:5<:a S;<>E 1> 1532D3:< >A: 1H:2D2@174D H1<>457: 2= 4 64;>9 ($"5 ,*+ ",*+$0
4D25@ >A: 62D1>174D YD:=>b;1@A>_ <647: 2= :D:7>2;4D 72?6:>1>125\ <:725HE 1>
;:=:;< >2 >A: H:D:@1>1?1X15@ 1?647> 2= >A: 64;>9G< 47>125< 45H 6;264@45H4
"% ,*+ $+4-5+ -% 8*-.* -, "7+$&,+0J /:> C< 4HH;:<< >A:<: >L2 ;:D4>:H 4<6:7><
15 >C;5J

91+"'"4-.&' :-0,&%.+ &%1 ;&0-. <&'#+0


UA4> 1< 1?62;>45> >2 ;:72@51X: A:;: 1< >A4> >A: 725>:5> 2= 1>< 1H:2D2@9 4< <C7A
H2:< 52> ;:5H:; 4 64;>9 45>1%<9<>:?\ LA4> ?4>>:;< 15<>:4H 1< LA:5 <C7A 725%
>:5> 1< 725<1H:;:H 15 ;:D4>125 >2 >A: B4<17 34DC:< 2= >A: ;:@1?: L1>A15 LA17A
>A: 64;>9 26:;4>:<J &C7A =C5H4?:5>4D 34DC:< 745 721571H: L1>A >A: B4<17
H:?27;4>17 34DC:< Y2= 459 H:?27;479_E 4< 15 >A: 74<:< 15 LA17A 4 62D4;1X:H
?:7A4517< L4< >;1@@:;:H B9 =4<71<> 45H 72??C51<> 64;>1:<E 2; 745 725<1<>
2= 34DC:< 45H 1<<C:< >A4> 4;: B4<17 >2 4 <6:71S7 H:?27;4>17 ;:@1?: 15 4 <6:71S7
6A4<:E 45H LA17A >A:;:=2;: 4;: <A4;:H B9 4DD 2>A:; Y6;2%<9<>:?_ ;:D:345>
64;>1:<J &C7A 1<<C:< 4;: <2 <4D1:5> >A4> >A:9 725<>1>C>: 45 1?62;>45> :D:?:5>
2= >A: 1H:2D2@174D <647: 2= :D:7>2;4D 72?6:>1>125 Y&4;>2;1E NORPa ^^[b[c_J !<
<C7AE >A: >A;C<> 2= >A: H:S51>125 1<E 15 =47>E @13:5 B9 >A: ;:D4>125 2= 4 64;>9G<
1H:2D2@9 >2 >A: =C5H4?:5>4D 34DC:< 2= >A: <6:71S7 ;:@1?: 15 LA17A 1> 26:;4>:<E
;4>A:; >A45 B9 >A: 2Bg:7>13: 725>:5> 2= >A: 64;>9G< 1H:2D2@9 6:; <:= 45H >A:
62D1>174D 2Bg:7>< >A4> 1> 2662<:<J
#A: >L2 7A4;47>:;1<>17< 2= 1H:2D2@174D H1<>457: =;2? 2>A:; 64;>1:< 45H
2662<1>125 >2 B4<17 34DC:< 2= >A4> <6:71S7 ;:@1?: 4;: ;:k:7>125< 2= >A:
<4?: ;:4D1>9E >A4> 2= 4 ;:D4>1254DD9 45>1%<9<>:? 64;>9J #A: D2@174D 7255:7>125

Downloaded from http://jtp.sagepub.com at SWETS WISE ONLINE CONTENT on July 26, 2009
,!*-,,$!a !"#$%&'&#() *!+#$(& N]

*/=0, AB !>>;1BC>:< 2= +:D4>1254D !5>1%<9<>:?5:<< 45H ,25<:WC:57:<


25 >A: *4;>9 &9<>:? ):7A4517<

!>>;1BC>: 2= 4 *4;>9G< +:D4>1254D !5>1%<9<>:?5:<< &9<>:?17 ,25<:WC:57:

NJ V1<>45> <64>14D D274>125 2= 1>< :D:7>2;4>: =;2? >A4> 2= .5:WC4D <64715@ B:>L::5
NJ 5:1@AB2;15@ 64;>1:< 64;>1:< Y2; <647: H1<gC57>125_
cJ /2L 724D1>125 62>:5>14D )CD>1%62D4;1>9
^J -C>B1HH15@ 6;264@45H4 >47>17<eH:D:@1>1?1X15@ ?:<<4@:< ,:5>;1=C@4D1>9 45H 157;:4<:
15 62D4;1X4>125 Y6;27:<<_

B:>L::5 >A:<: >L2 6;26:;>1:< 1< >A4> 45 45>1%<9<>:? 64;>9 L1DD 2662<: <2?:
=C5H4?:5>4D 34DC: 2= >A: ;:@1?:E LA17AE =2; 1>< 3:;9 <4D1:57:E 1< <A4;:H B9
4DD 2>A:; 64;>1:< 45H 725<>1>C>:< 4 ?4g2; B4<1< =2; :D:7>2;4D 72?6:>1>125J
#A1< 6C>< >A: 45>1%<9<>:? 64;>9 4> 25: ;:?23: 25 >A: 1H:2D2@174D <647:
L1>A ;:<6:7> >2 >A: 2>A:;<E 45H >A1<E 15 >C;5E :572C;4@:< >A: 64;>9 >2 6C;<C:
724D1>125 45H 6;264@45H4 <>;4>:@1:< >A4> A43: >A: :==:7> 2= 6C<A15@ >A:
64;>9 <9<>:? >2L4;H< 4 F62D4;1X:HG ?:7A4517<J

)*+ >"%0+?#+%.+0 ("$ /&$,@ A@0,+5 B+.*&%-.0


#A: 6;157164D 7A4;47>:;1<>17< 2= 4 62D4;1X:H ?:7A4517< ?49 B: <C??4;1X:H 4<
?CD>1%62D4;1>9E <647: <>;:>7A15@ Y2; H1<gC57>125_E 45H 7:5>;1=C@4D 72?6:>1>125
YV1 *4D?4E NORR_J !D>A2C@A <:3:;4D =47>2;< ?49 H:>:;?15: >A: H:3:D26?:5>
2= >A:<: <9<>:?17 7A4;47>:;1<>17<E >A:1; ;:D4>125<A16 >2 >A: 4>>;1BC>:< 2= 45
45>1%<9<>:? 64;>9 15 64;>17CD4; 4;: <C??4;1X:H 15 #4BD: NJ #A1< >A;::=2DH
H1<>157>125 1<E 2= 72C;<:E 454D9>174Da 15 459 @13:5 64;>9 <9<>:? >A: >A;::
7A4;47>:;1<>17< ?49 L2;M >2@:>A:; 45H 6;23: ?C>C4DD9 ;:15=2;715@ Y&4;>2;1E
NORPa N[Q_J
#A: ?2<> 1?62;>45> 7A4;47>:;1<>17 2= >A: 45>1%<9<>:? 64;>9 1< >A4> 4<<2%
714>:H L1>A <64>14D H1<>457: Y&451 45H &4;>2;1E NOZ^\ &4;>2;1E NOZ[B_J #A1<
A4< D1M:D9 725<:WC:57:< 4> >A: D:3:D 2= 724D1>125 =2;?4>125E ;:<CD>15@ 15 4
D2L 724D1>125 62>:5>14DE L1>A >A: 45>1%<9<>:? 64;>9G< ;4H174D 2662<1>125 25
1?62;>45> 1<<C:< <:;315@ >2 1<2D4>: >A: 64;>9 =;2? >A: 2>A:;< 15 >A: <9<>:?J
F)CD>1%62D4;1>9G A1@AD1@A>< 4 =C;>A:; 7A4;47>:;1<>17 2= 62D4;1X:H 64;>9 <9<>:?<E
L1>A 4> D:4<> >A;:: YD:=>b7:5>:;b;1@A>_ 62D:< 2; 7DC<>:; 2= 64;>1:<E 45H L1>A 4
?:7A4517< >A4> 1< 52> B4<:H 25 72?6:>1>125 B:>L::5 >L2 724D1>125< YB1%
62D4;1>9_E BC> 25 4 7:5>:; >A4> @23:;5< 4@415<> B1D4>:;4D 2662<1>125< Y&4;>2;1E
NORP_J !?25@ >A: =47>2;< 6;2?2>15@ >A: 7:5>;1=C@4D :D:7>2;4D 72?6:>1>125
7A4;47>:;1<>17 2= 62D4;1X:H <9<>:?< 4;: 4D<2 >A: H:D:@1>1?1X15@ ?:<<4@:< 45H

Downloaded from http://jtp.sagepub.com at SWETS WISE ONLINE CONTENT on July 26, 2009
NP `-.+"!/ -h #K(-+(#$,!/ *-/$#$,& N[YN_

>A: 2C>B1HH15@ >47>17< >96174D 2= >A: 62D1>174D 6;264@45H4 2= 45>1%<9<>:?


64;>1:<JO (I7DCH:H =;2? @23:;5?:5> 724D1>125<E 45H 1H:2D2@174DD9 2662<:H
>2 >A: ;:@1?: 15 LA17A >A:9 26:;4>:E 45>1%<9<>:? 64;>1:< H:3:D26 >A: 62>:5%
>14DD9 ;:L4;H15@ >47>17 2= H:D:@1>1?1X15@ >A: F<9<>:?G Y4>>47M15@ <2?: 2= 1><
B4<17 34DC:< 15 >A:1; 6;264@45H4_E 45H H1<>2;>15@ >A: 62D1>174D ?4;M:>J #A:
D4>>:; 1< 4772?6D1<A:H B9 LA4> &4;>2;1 ;:=:;< >2 4< >A: 62D1>17< 2= F2C>B1HH15@G
2; F23:;%6;2?1<15@GE >A: 6;47>17: 2= F1;;:<625<1BD: 2662<1>125G Y&4;>2;1E NORPa
N^Ob[Q_E LA17A 1><:D= H1<72C;4@:< 459 7:5>;16:>4D >:5H:571:<J $5 B;1:=E 45>1%
<9<>:? 64;>1:< =::D >A:9 745 6;2?1<: 459>A15@ 15 >A: M52LD:H@: >A4> >A:9
L1DD 5:3:; B: 74DD:H C625 >2 ?4M: @22H 25 >A:1; 6D:H@:<J #A:1; H:D:@1>1?1X15@
466;247A <:;3:< >2 <C<>415 7:5>;1=C@4D 72?6:>1>125 45H >A1<E 15 >C;5E 157;:4<:<
>A: 62D4;1X4>125 2= >A: <9<>:?E >A4> 1<E >A: 23:;4DD 1H:2D2@174D H1<>457:JNQ
-C>B1HH15@ >47>17< 47> 15 >A: <4?: L49E 4>>;47>15@ 32>:< =;2? >A: :D:7>2;< 2=
>A: 6;2%<9<>:? 64;>1:< 45H >AC< :?6>915@ >A: 62D1>174D 7:5>:; YV44DH:;E
NOZ[a OOE NQ^_J

C+'&,-"%&' D%,-30@0,+5%+00
!> >A1< <>4@:E >A: ?:4515@ 2= ;:D4>1254D 45>1%<9<>:?5:<< 4< 4 H1?:5<125 4D25@
LA17A 64;>1:< 745 B: 72?64;:H 15 64;>9 <9<>:? 454D9<1< B:72?:< 7D:4;:;J #A:
;:D4>1254D 45>1%<9<>:?5:<< 2= 4 64;>9 725<1<>< 2= >A: >A;:: 7A4;47>:;1<>17< D1<>:H
15 >A: D:=>%A45H 72DC?5 2= #4BD: NJ $> 1< 1?62;>45> >2 52>17: >A4> >A:<: 4;:
7A4;47>:;1<>17< 2= >A: 64;>9 6:; <:E 4D>A2C@A H:S5:H -% $+'&,-"% ," 2>A:;
:5>1>1:<J &C7A 7A4;47>:;1<>17< 4;: ;:D:345> >2 64;>9 <9<>:? 454D9<1< 15<2=4;
4< >A:9 725>;1BC>: >2 2; :3:5 >;1@@:; >A: >A;:: <9<>:?17 725<:WC:57:< 15H1%
74>:H 15 >A: ;1@A>%A45H 72DC?5 2= >A: >4BD:J #A: ?2<> 7;C714D 6215> A:;:E
A2L:3:;E 1< >A4> >A:<: 7A4;47>:;1<>17< H2 52> 5:7:<<4;1D9 ;:WC1;: 45 2662<1>125
2= >A: 64;>9 >2 34DC:< >A4> 4;: =C5H4?:5>4D 15 &'' H:?27;471:<J $5 &4;>2;1G<
2L5 L2;H<E Fd>fA: <9<>:? d62D4;1X:H 6DC;164;>1<?f 1< 7A4;47>:;1X:H B9 45
45>1%<9<>:? 2662<1>125 b :<6:714DD9 2= >A: h4<71<> 2; ,2??C51<> 34;1:>9E
E#, &'0" "( ",*+$ F&$-+,-+0G Y&4;>2;1E NORPa N^c\ :?6A4<1< 4HH:H_J !< 4 725<:%
WC:57:E >A: >;C: H1?:5<125 2= 72?64;1<25 1< 52> @13:5 B9 >A: 62D1>174D 2Bg:7%
>13:< L1>A LA17A >A: 64;>9G< 1H:2D2@9 1< 1572?64>1BD:E BC> B9 >A: 1?62;>457:
2= <C7A 2Bg:7>13:< =2; >A4> 64;>17CD4; ;:@1?:E 45H >A:;:=2;: 4D<2 =2; >A: 2>A:;
64;>1:<J #A1< ?49 B: 1DDC<>;4>:H B9 ;:=:;:57: >2 4 5C?B:; 2= 74<:< LA17A ?1@A>

OJ !52>A:; ?4g2; =47>2; H:>:;?1515@ 7:5>;1=C@4D 6C<A:< 15 >A: 72?6:>1>125 1< @13:5 B9 >A: 3:;9
<>;C7>C;: 2= 72?6:>1>125 2= 62D4;1X:H <9<>:?<E LA17A 1< Y4> D:4<>_ >;1%62D4;J #A1< ?:45< >A4> >A:
?:>;17 7:5>:; 2= >A: <9<>:? 1< 277C61:HE LA17A ?4M:< 7:5>;16:>4D 72?6:>1>125 C5;:L4;H15@J K2L%
:3:;E 7:5>;4D 64;>1:< 7461>4D1X: 25 >A: =:4; 2= :I>;:?1<><E 45H >A:;:=2;: ?415>415 >A:1; :D:7>2;4D
<>;:5@>AJ
NQJ -5 62D4;1X4>125 4< 4 <>4>: 45H 4< 4 6;27:<<E <:: &4;>2;1 YNOZca ^Q[b]_J

Downloaded from http://jtp.sagepub.com at SWETS WISE ONLINE CONTENT on July 26, 2009
,!*-,,$!a !"#$%&'&#() *!+#$(& NR

52> 52;?4DD9 B: <::5 >2 =4DD L1>A15 >A: 45>1%<9<>:? 74>:@2;9E B:15@ 4DD
2<>:5<1BD9 H:?27;4>17 2662<1>125<E 9:> LA17AE 15 ;:D4>1254D >:;?<E 7D:4;D9
H2 ?::> >A: ;:D:345> 7;1>:;14J
-5: <C7A :I4?6D: 1< >A4> 2= >A: h14554 h4l1D 64;>9 15 $;:D45H 15 >A: 6:;12H
=;2? NOcP >2 NO^cE 4 64;>9 LA17A )41; YNORO_ H:S5:< 4< 45>1%<9<>:? 52> 25
>A: B4<1< 2= 459 2662<1>125 >2 >A: =C5H4?:5>4D 34DC:< 2= H:?27;479E BC>
;4>A:; 25 >A: B4<1< 2= 1>< 6;15716D:H <>457: 4@415<> >A: NOcN >;:4>9 L1>A >A:
.TE LA17A A4H 64;>1>125:H $;:D45H 15>2 52;>A 45H <2C>AE 45H LA17A A4H
@;45>:H >A: <2C>A 4 ,454H145%<>9D: H2?15125 <>4>C<E C5H:; >A: 52?154D
4C>A2;1>9 2= >A: 8;1>1<A ?254;7A9J !66D915@ &4;>2;1G< =;4?:L2;M 15 A1< 454%
D9<1< 2= >A: H:3:D26?:5> 2= >A: $;1<A 64;>9 <9<>:?ENN )41; YNOROa [[Z_ <C@@:<><
>A4> F>L2 23:;D46615@ 2662<1>125<E >A: 725<>1>C>1254D 45H >A: :7252?17E
;:<CD>:H 15 >A: H:3:D26?:5> 2= 4 <A4;6D9 62D4;1X:H <9<>:?GJ ! <1?1D4; :I4?6D:
1< 2==:;:H B9 >A: V451<A 74<:E 15 LA17A >A: *;2@;:<< *4;>9 YG$+50H$-1,7&$,-+,_
1< 725<1H:;:H B9 81DD: YNOOQa [O_ 4< 45>1%<9<>:?E <157: 1> F4>>47M:H 31@2;2C<D9
>A: H2?1545> 1H:2D2@9 2= >A: L:D=4;: <>4>: <9<>:?E 4< 1> L4< =2;?:HE H:3:D%
26:H 45H 1?6D:?:5>:H B9 >A: FF2DH 64;>1:<GG 23:; >A: 6;:312C< H:74H:<GJ
#A: *;2@;:<< *4;>9 L4< 25: 2= >L2 B1D4>:;4D 2662<1>125< b >A: 2>A:; 25:
L4< >A: ,2??C51<> *4;>9 b >A4> :?:;@:H 15 >A: V451<A 64;>9 <9<>:? 4=>:;
NOR^E 45H LA17A B;2C@A> V:5?4;M 157;:4<15@D9 7D2<: >2 4 <9<>:? 2= 62D4;%
1X:H 6DC;4D1<?E 15 LA17AE H:<61>: 4 B2C;@:21< ?4g2;1>9 15 >A: h2DM:>15@
=2DD2L15@ >A: :D:7>125< 2= NOR]E >A: *;2@;:<< *4;>9 FBD27M:H >A: =2;?4>125
2= 4 B2C;@:21< @23:;5?:5> =2; >A: ;:<> 2= >A: H:74H:G Y81DD:E NOOQa ]N_J 8C>
LA1D: >A: V451<A 64;>9 <9<>:? ?49 L:DD A43: :I6:;1:57:H >A: ?:7A4517< 2=
62D4;1X:H 6DC;4D1<? >A;2C@A >2 >A: ?1H%NOZQ<E 1> L2CDH B: ?1<D:4H15@ >2 725%
<1H:; V451<A H:?27;479 4< A4315@ <CBg:7> >2 7A4DD:5@: 15 >A1< <4?: 6:;12HJ
h154DD9E &4;>2;1G< 2L5 157DC<125 2= >A: h;:57A h2C;>A +:6CBD17 4?25@ >A:
74>:@2;9 2= 62D4;1X:H <9<>:?< 4D<2 1DDC<>;4>:< >A: 6215>J !D>A2C@A >A: WC4D1%
S74>125 2= >A: 04CDD1<> +4<<:l?BD:?:5> 62C; D4 h;457: Y+*h_ 4< 45 45>1%
H:?27;4>17 64;>9 745 B: 7A4DD:5@:H b LA1D: 45>1%H:?27;4>17 :D:?:5>< L:;:
7:;>415D9 47>13: 15 >A: 64;>9E >A: +*h 4D<2 157DCH:H <>;25@D9 45>1%=4<71<> :D:%
?:5>< 4?25@ 1>< ?:?B:;<A16 45H D:4H:;<A16 Y:J@J U1DD14?<E NORNa c^QbO_ b 1>
H1H 5:3:;>A:D:<< :?B2H9 4 @:5C15: 62D1>174D%725<>1>C>1254D 2662<1>125 >2 >A:
4<<:?BD9 ;:@1?: 2= >A: h2C;>A +:6CBD17J $5H::HE 15 >A1< 74<:E L1>A >A:
7;:4>125 2= >A: h1=>A +:6CBD17E L: 4D<2 A43: >A: 62<>%=47>C4D :31H:57: 2=
>A: M15H 2= ;:@1?: >A4> L2CDH A43: ?:> >A: H:?45H< 2= >A: 04CDD1<><
HC;15@ >A: :4;D1:; 62<>L4; 9:4;<J $5 >A1< 74<:E >A:5E >A2C@A 52> 2662<:H >2
H:?27;479 4< <C7AE >A: +*h 745 ;:4<254BD9 B: 725<1H:;:H 4< ;:D4>1254DD9
45>1%<9<>:? 15 1>< ;:g:7>125 2= >A: D:@1>1?479 2= >A: ;:@1?: 15 LA17A 1> >A:5

NNJ !< &4;>2;1 ?4M:< 7D:4;E F>A: ?2H:D d62D4;1X:H 6DC;4D1<?f 157DCH:< 459 >96: 2= d1H:2D2@174Df
H1<>457:G Y&4;>2;1E NOZca cO[\ >;45<D4>125 B9 >A: 4C>A2;_J

Downloaded from http://jtp.sagepub.com at SWETS WISE ONLINE CONTENT on July 26, 2009
NZ `-.+"!/ -h #K(-+(#$,!/ *-/$#$,& N[YN_

26:;4>:HJ )2;:23:;E >A1< 45>1%<9<>:? 2662<1>125 A4H 45 :31H:5> 1?647> 25


?:7A4517< 2= >A: 64;>9 <9<>:? 15 >A2<: :4;D1:; 9:4;<JNc
$5 <A2;>E >A: 7257:6> 2= ;:D4>1254D 45>1%<9<>:?5:<< ?49 B: C<:H >2 15H174>:
4 64;>9G< 1H:2D2@174D H1==:;:57:E LA17AE 15 <64>14D >:;?<E 4?2C5>< >2 4 A1@A
1H:2D2@174D H1<>457:E =;2? >A: 2>A:; 64;>1:< 26:;4>15@ 15 4 64;>17CD4; ;:@1?:J
8:15@ 4> 4 ;:?23: 25 >A: 1H:2D2@174D <647: 52;?4DD9 D:4H< >A: 64;>9 >2 A43:
4 3:;9 D2L 724D1>125 62>:5>14DE 45H >2 C<: 2C>B1HH15@ 45H H:D:@1>1?1X15@ >47>17<
15 :D:7>2;4D 72?6:>1>125J *4;>1:< 745 >AC< B: H:S5:H 4< ;:D4>1254DD9 6;2% 2;
45>1%<9<>:? 15 ;:D4>125 >2 >A:<: 7A4;47>:;1<>17< 45H 745 B: 72?64;:H 25
>A4> B4<1<J )2;:23:;E >A: 6;:<:57: 2= ;:D:345> 64;>1:< L1>A <C7A 7A4;47%
>:;1<>17< 1< D1M:D9 >2 >;1@@:; 4 62D4;1X:H ?:7A4517< 15 >A: 64;>9 <9<>:?J $=E
A2L:3:;E >A: 2Bg:7>13: 725>:5> 2= 4 64;>9G< 1H:2D2@9 4< <C7A 1< >4M:5 4< >A:
H:S515@ :D:?:5> 2= 4 64;>9G< 45>1%<9<>:?5:<<E >A:5E 4< $ L1DD 4;@C: 15 >A:
=2DD2L15@ <:7>125E 4 H1==:;:5> 64>A 2= 7257:6>C4D ;:725<>;C7>125 ?C<> B:
=2DD2L:HJ

*+, -%"(,.# )" #+, C8.)$)(/0 5"/072)2 %3 D,8%($/#)( ?%0)#)(/0


@72#,82: 4!&,%0%E)(/09 5"#)6272#,8",22

$5 >A1< <:7>125E $ S;<> H:4D L1>A <2?: D2@174D 1?6D174>125< 2= >A: 54;;2L H:S%
51>125 2= >A: 45>1%<9<>:? 64;>9E 45H >A:5 L1>A >A: 6;2BD:?< 7255:7>:H >2 >A:
7257:6>C4D ;:725<>;C7>125 2= 4 5:@4>13: >:;? YF45>1%<9<>:?G_ >A;2C@A 4 62<1%
>13: 25: YF<9<>:?G_J !=>:; 4;@C15@ >A4> F45>1%<9<>:?G >:5H< >2 B: C<:H 4< 4
<95259? =2; F45>1%H:?27;4>17GE $ 2C>D15: 45 :I4?6D: 2= 4 7257:6>C4D ;:725%
<>;C7>125 2= 1H:2D2@174D 45>1%<9<>:?5:<< B4<:H 25 L1H:D9 477:6>:H H:S51>125<
2= H:?27;479E >;:4>:H 1> S;<> 4< 4 7D4<<174D 45H >A:5 4< 4 ;4H14D 74>:@2;9
Y,2DD1:; 45H )4A25E NOO^_J
h2DD2L15@ &4;>2;1G< 54;;2L H:S51>125 2= 45 45>1%<9<>:? 64;>9 b F4 64;>9
>A4> L2CDH 7A45@:E 1= 1> 72CDHE 52> >A: @23:;5?:5>E BC> >A: <9<>:? 2= @23:;5%
?:5>G b 1> 1< :31H:5> >A4> LA1D: 45>1%<9<>:? 64;>1:< H1;:7> >A:1; 47>125< >2L4;H<
4 ;4H174D 7A45@: 2= >A: 62D1>174D <9<>:?E >A:1; @24D 1<E 4< 9:>E C5;:4D1X:HJ
.5D1M: >A: ;:D4>1254D 45>1%<9<>:?5:<< 2= 4 64;>9 45H 1>< <9<>:?17 725<:%
WC:57:<E LA17A 4;: B:<> 4<<:<<:H ;:>;2<6:7>13:D9E 1H:2D2@174D 45>1%<9<>:?5:<<
745 >A:;:=2;: 25D9 B: 4<<:<<:H B9 L49 2= <6:7CD4>125 4< >2 1>< =C>C;:
15>:5>125<J $5 2>A:; L2;H<E =C>C;: Y:I 62<>_ 725<:WC:57:< 4;: 62<>CD4>:H 25

NcJ $5 )47+4:G< L2;H<a F#A: D:4H:;<G d2= >A: @23:;515@ 64;>1:<f 2662<1>125 >2 V: 04CDD: 15
NO[RbNO]^ ;:3:4D:H >A: 1H:5>1S74>125 >A:9 ?4H: B:>L::5 >A: FF<9<>:?GG 45H >A: FF+:6CBD17GG G
Y)47+4:E NOPRa ^N]_J

Downloaded from http://jtp.sagepub.com at SWETS WISE ONLINE CONTENT on July 26, 2009
,!*-,,$!a !"#$%&'&#() *!+#$(& NO

>A: B4<1< 2= 4 725>:?62;4;9 Y:I 45>:_ 4<<:<<?:5>JN^ !> >A: 7257:6>C4D D:3:DE
>A: ?415 6;2BD:? 4;1<15@ A:;: :?:;@:< LA:5 >A: 1H:2D2@174D 7A4;47>:;1<>17< 2=
4 ;:D4>1254DD9 45>1%<9<>:? 64;>9 15 4 @13:5 62D1>9 4;: 52> C<:H >2 454D9X: >A:
=C57>12515@ 2= >A: 64;>9 <9<>:?E BC> ;4>A:; >2 15H174>: 4 7A4DD:5@: >2 >A:
D:@1>1?479E <>4B1D1>9 2; 725<2D1H4>125 2= >A: <9<>:? 2= H:?27;479 4< <C7AJ
$5 =47>E >A: D1>:;4>C;: 1< ;:6D:>: L1>A :I4?6D:< 2= 64;>1:< B:15@ 7A4;47>:;1X:H
4< 45>1%<9<>:? 25 >A: B4<1< 2= >A:1; 15>;15<17 1H:2D2@174D 7A4;47>:; Y:J@J
V44DH:; NOPP4\ *2DD47M 45H 0;C:@:DE NOZR\ /15X 45H &>:645E NOOP\ h:55:?4E
NOOR\ *47:E NOOR\ K45<25E NOOZ\ /1:B:;?45E NOOZ\ T:;:5E cQQQ_ 45H LA17AE
4> >A: <4?: >1?:E ?4M: 52 ;:4D ;:=:;:57: >2 A2L >A: 64;>9 H1==:;< =;2? 2>A:;<
15 >A: <9<>:?E 45H A:57: A2L 1>< 6;:<:57: 1< D1M:D9 >2 1?647> 25 >A: ?:7A4517<
2= >A: 64;>9 <9<>:?J !< <C7AE 1= 45>1%<9<>:?5:<< 1< <::5 4< 45 2Bg:7>13: 2662%
<1>125 >2 4 @13:5 <9<>:?E >A:5 15 2;H:; >2 C<: >A: 7257:6> =2; 72?64;4>13:
454D9<1< 1> 1< S;<> 5:7:<<4;9 >2 H:;13: 45 :WC4DD9 2Bg:7>13: H:S51>125 2=
LA4> >A4> <9<>:? 1<J #A1< H:S51>125 ?49 B: 457A2;:H 15 4 <6:71S7 74<:E
>A:;:B9 23:;D46615@ L1>A >A: 52>125 2= >A: F;:@1?: 15 LA17A >A: 64;>9 26:;%
4>:<G 45H A:57: L1>A ;:D4>1254D 45>1%<9<>:?5:<<J K2L:3:;E 1= >A: 7257:6> 1< >2
>;43:DE >A:5 >A1< L1DD 7D:4;D9 H:6:5H 25 1> 47WC1;15@ 4 H:@;:: 2= @:5:;4D1>9J
$5 >A: D1>:;4>C;: >A4> =27C<:< 25 >A: 1H:2D2@9 2= 4 64;>9 4< >A: B4<1< =2; 1><
7D4<<1S74>125 4< 45>1%<9<>:?E >A: F<9<>:?G 1><:D= 1?6D171>D9 ;:=:;< >2 <2?: 725%
7:6>125 2= H:?27;479J #A: 45>1%<9<>:? D4B:D 1< >A:;:=2;: <95259?2C< L1>A
45>1%H:?27;4>17 Y45H 1H:2D2@174D 45>1%<9<>:?5:<< L1>A 45>1%H:?27;4>175:<<_J
UA1D: 1> L2CDH B: 4H31<4BD: >2 C<: >A: D4B:D< 2= F45>1%H:?27;4>17G =2; >A1< M15H
2= 64;>9E ?2<> 4C>A2;< 6:;<1<> 15 C<15@ F45>1%<9<>:?G 2;E D:<< =;:WC:5>D9E 25: 2=
>A: 2>A:; F45>1%G D4B:D<J ! 62<<1BD: :I6D454>125 =2; >A1< 1< >A4> >A1< <>;4>:@9
4321H<E 4> >A: <4?: >1?:E >A: 34DC:%D4H:55:<< 45H >A: 725>:<>:H5:<< 2= >A:
D4B:D 2= F45>1%H:?27;4>17GJ UA4>:3:; >A: ;:4<25E >A: H:S51>125 2= 1H:2D2@174D
45>1%<9<>:?5:<< 5:7:<<4;1D9 1?6D1:< :<>4BD1<A15@ LA4> 6;:71<:D9 H:?27;479
:5>41D< b 4 >4<M >A4> 62<:< <:3:;: 7257:6>C4D H1=S7CD>1:< Y:J@J ,2DD1:; 45H
!H727ME NOOO_J
h2; 6C;62<:< 2= 1DDC<>;4>125E 45H >2 4321H 4 ?4g2; H:>2C; 15>2 >A: 34;915@
H:S51>125< 2= H:?27;479E D:> C< D22M 4> >A: <2%74DD:H F:I645H:H ?151?4D 6;2%
7:HC;4DG H:S51>125 ;:62;>:H B9 ,2DD1:; 45H /:31><M9 YNOORa [^^b[_E 45H LA17A
1H:5>1S:< 4 ;:@1?: 4< H:?27;4>17 1= 1> 157DCH:< >A: =2DD2L15@ 7A4;47>:;1<>17<a
Y4_ =CDD9 725>:<>:H :D:7>125<\ YB_ =CDD <C==;4@: 45H 45 4B<:57: 2= ?4<<13:
=;4CH\ Y7_ :==:7>13: @C4;45>::< 2= 7131D D1B:;>1:<\ 45H YH_ :D:7>:H @23:;5?:5><

N^J $5 A1<>2;174D 74<:< b =2; :I4?6D:E >A: "&V!* 15 U:1?4; 0:;?459 b >A: 4<<:<<?:5> 2= 4
64;>9G< F1H:2D2@174D 45>1%<9<>:?5:<<G 1< B4<:H :I7DC<13:D9 25 45 :I 62<> gCH@:?:5>J #A: :I 62<>
gCH@:?:5> L2CDHE A2L:3:;E B: 15<C=S71:5> >2 454D9X: 725>:?62;4;9 74<:<E 4< L:DD 4< C5<C77:<<=CD
A1<>2;174D 74<:<E 2= F1H:2D2@174DD9G 45>1%<9<>:? 64;>1:<E 45H ?C<> >A:;:=2;: B: 15>:@;4>:H B9 45 :I
45>: gCH@:?:5>J

Downloaded from http://jtp.sagepub.com at SWETS WISE ONLINE CONTENT on July 26, 2009
cQ `-.+"!/ -h #K(-+(#$,!/ *-/$#$,& N[YN_

>A4> A43: >A: 746471>9 >2 @23:;5JN[ 013:5 >A1< H:S51>125E A2L >A:5 745 L:
<6:71=9 LA4> 1< :5>41D:H B9 1H:2D2@174D 45>1%<9<>:?5:<<m
$> 1< 5:7:<<4;9 >2 C5H:;D15: A:;: >A4> 1H:2D2@174D 45>1%<9<>:?5:<<E B9 1><
3:;9 54>C;:E 1< 4 5:@4>13: 6A:52?:525 b 1> 7257:;5< >A: WC:<>125 2= LA:>A:;
4 64;>9 1< &4&-%0, 4 7:;>415 62D1>174D 2Bg:7>J #A1< A4< >L2 1?62;>45> 725<:%
WC:57:< =2; 2C; 7257:6>C4D ;:725<>;C7>125J #2 B:@15 L1>AE 4 64;>9 5::H 52>
2662<: 4DD 2= >A: 7A4;47>:;1<>17< 2= >A: <9<>:? 15 WC:<>125 >2 WC4D1=9 4<
B:15@ 45>1%<9<>:?a 2662<15@ 25D9 25: 2= >A:? 1< <C=S71:5>J &:725HE ;:725%
<>;C7>15@ 4 5:@4>13: >:;? >A;2C@A 1>< 62<1>13: ;:=:;:5>< 1532D3:< H1==:;:5>
C51>< 2= 454D9<1<J #AC< LA1D: >A: 62<1>13: >:;? <9<>:? ;:=:;< >2 7"'-,-+0E >A:
5:@4>13: >:;? F45>1%<9<>:?G ;:=:;< >2 7&$,-+0 Y2; @;2C6<_ 26:;4>15@ L1>A15
<C7A 62D1>1:<J #A1< 1< 1?62;>45> B:74C<: >A: 153:;<: ;:D4>125 B:>L::5 15>:5%
<125 45H :I>:5<125 >96174D 2= >A: FD4HH:; 2= 4B<>;47>125G Y&4;>2;1E NORQ4E
NOZ[4_ 2; FD4HH:; 2= @:5:;4D1>9G Y,2DD1:; 45H )4A25E NOO^_ 25D9 ;:@4;H< >A:
62<1>13: >:;? Y<9<>:?_E 45H 52> >A: 5:@4>13: >:;? Y45>1%<9<>:?_J ,253:5>125%
4DD9E >A: 5C?B:; 2= 74<:< Y:I>:5<125_ >2 LA17A >A: 7257:6> 2= <9<>:? 1< 466D1:H
L1DD B: ;:HC7:H 4< >A: 5C?B:; 2= H:S515@ 7A4;47>:;1<>17< Y15>:5<125_ :I645H<J
$5 >A: 74<: 2= >A1< 5:@4>13: H:S51>125E A2L:3:;E 45H <157: 1> 1< :52C@A >2 B:
4@415<> 25D9 25: 2= >A: 7A4;47>:;1<>17< 2= >A: <9<>:? >2 B: 45>1%<9<>:?E 5:L
74<:< 2= 45>1%<9<>:? 64;>1:< >A4> L:;: 52> 157DCH:H B:=2;: 745 B: 157DCH:H
4> D2L:; D:3:D< 2= @:5:;4D1>9E LA1D: 2>A:; 74<:< 72CDH B: :I7DCH:H :3:5
>A2C@A >A:9 L:;: 157DCH:H 4> <2?: A1@A:; D:3:D 2= 4B<>;47>125J !DD >A1< A4<
725<:WC:57:< =2; >A: C<: 2= >A: 7257:6> 15 72?64;4>13: 454D9<:<E <157: >A:
5C?B:; 2= 74<:< <:1X:H B9 >A: H:S51>125 2= >A: 62<1>13: >:;? 4D<2 H:>:;?15:<
>A: <726: 2= 466D174B1D1>9 2= >A: 5:@4>13: >:;?J
#A1< 745 B: =C;>A:; 7D4;1S:H 1= L: 52>: >A4> >A: 62<1>13: >:;? 745 B: H:S5:H
4> D2L:; D:3:D< 2= 4B<>;47>125 B9 :5;17A15@ >A: ?151?4D 6;27:HC;4D H:S51>125
2= H:?27;479 L1>A =C;>A:; 7A4;47>:;1<>17<E <C7A 4< >A: 5::H >2 ;:<6:7> AC?45
;1@A>< YB:925H >A: 7131D 45H 62D1>174D ;1@A>< 2= >A: 71>1X:5;9 5:7:<<4;1D9 1?6D1:H
15 6;27:HC;4D H:S51>125<_J UA1D: <C7A 4 7257:6> L2CDH A4;HD9 B: 466D174BD:
>2 ?459 2= >A: ;:7:5> >A1;H%L43: H:?27;471:<E 1> L2CDH 7:;>415D9 ;:k:7> >A:
D:@1>1?4>: 52;?4>13: 4<61;4>125< 4<<2714>:H L1>A ?459 2DH:; H:?27;471:<J
KC?45 ;1@A>< 745 =C;>A:; B: <6:71S:H 4< :7252?17 45H <2714D ;1@A>< 2;
7CD>C;4D ;1@A>< Y:J@J 8::>A4?E NOOO_E L1>A >A: 157DC<125 2= <C7A ;1@A>< 4< 4
5:7:<<4;9 64;> 2= >A: H:S51>125 2= H:?27;479 1><:D= 2B312C<D9 ;:HC715@ >A:
>;43:D15@ 746471>9 2= >A: 7257:6>J !> >A: <4?: >1?:E A2L:3:;E <C7A 45
:I645H:H H:S51>125 2= H:?27;479 L2CDH 7D:4;D9 157;:4<: >A: 62>:5>14D
5C?B:; 2= 1H:2D2@174D 45>1%<9<>:? 64;>1:<J #2 @13: 4 <1?6D: :I4?6D:E 4

N[J h2; 4D>:;54>13: F?151?4D H:S51>125<G 2= H:?27;479E <:: &4;>2;1 YNO]Ra NcQ_E /15X YNORZa ]_E
V4AD YNOZca NN_E V1 *4D?4 YNOOQa cZ_E KC5>15@>25 YNOONa O_E &7A?1>>:; 45H T4;D YNOON_E
&7A?1>>:; YcQQQ_J h2; 4 <9<>:?4>17 72?64;1<25 2= H:S51>125< 45H >A:2;1:< 2= H:?27;479E <::
&7A?1H> YNOOR_J

Downloaded from http://jtp.sagepub.com at SWETS WISE ONLINE CONTENT on July 26, 2009
,!*-,,$!a !"#$%&'&#() *!+#$(& cN

64;>9 2662<15@ >A: :I>:5<125 2= <2714D 45H :7252?17 ;1@A>< :?B:HH:H 15 4


3:;9 4H3457:H =2;? 2= L:D=4;: <>4>: L1DD B: 45>1%<9<>:? 15 >A: 1H:2D2@174D
<:5<: 15 >A2<: <9<>:?< ;:<625H15@ >2 4 H:S51>125 2= H:?27;479 :572?64<<15@
<C7A ;1@A><E BC> 52> 15 2>A:;<J #AC< >A: "2;L:@145 *;2@;:<< *4;>9 Yh;:?%
<M;1>>64;>1:>_ 15 >A: NOZQ< L2CDH B: ;:@4;H:H 4< 1H:2D2@174DD9 45>1%<9<>:?
Y>A4> 1<E 4< 45>1%H:?27;4>17_ C5H:; >A1< :I645H:H H:S51>125 2= H:?27;479JN]
,253:;<:D9E 1> L2CDH 52> B: 62<<1BD: >2 ;:@4;H 4 64;>9 L1>A 4 <1?1D4; 1H:2%
D2@174D 6;2SD: 4< B:15@ 1H:2D2@174DD9 45>1%<9<>:?E <49E 15 >A: !?:;1745 725%
>:I>E <157: >A: .& 74<: L2CDH 52> 15 1><:D= ?::> >A: 7;1>:;14 2= >A: :I645H:H
H:S51>125J $5 4 <1?1D4; L49E 4 ?2;: 4B<>;47> 45H D:<< 72552>4>13: H:S51>125
2= H:?27;479 L2CDH 157DCH: ?2;: 72C5>;1:<E BC> 4> >A: <4?: >1?: L2CDH
>A:;:B9 ;:HC7: >A: 5C?B:; 2= 64;>1:< 7464BD: 2= B:15@ 7D4<<1S:H 4< 1H:2D2@174D
45>1%<9<>:?J
$5 <C?E >A: 1H:2D2@174D 7257:6>125 2= 45>1%<9<>:?5:<< 1< 4D<2 5:7:<<4;1D9
;:D4>:H >2 4 <9<>:?E BC> >2 4 H1==:;:5> <9<>:?E 45H 15 4 H1==:;:5> L49E >A45
1< >A: 74<: L1>A ;:D4>1254D 45>1%<9<>:?5:<<J #A1< H1==:;:57: 1< 7;C714D LA:5
>A: 7257:6> 2= 45>1%<9<>:? 64;>9 1< C<:H 15 72?64;4>13: 454D9<:<E <157: >A:
>L2 ?:4515@< <A2CDH B: H1<:5>45@D:HE 45H >A:5 C<:H =2; >A: 6C;62<: >A4>
>A:9 B:<> <:;3:J +:D4>1254D 45>1%<9<>:?5:<< 1< ;:D:345> LA:5 1> 72?:< >2 >A:
72?64;4>13: 454D9<1< 2= >A: =C57>12515@ 2= 64;>9 <9<>:?<J $H:2D2@174D 45>1%
<9<>:?5:<<E <>45H15@ =2; 2662<1>125 >2 H:?27;479E 1< 45 1?62;>45> 7257:6%
>C4D >22D >2 454D9X: >A: 7A4DD:5@:< =47:H B9 64;>17CD4; >96:< 2= H:?27;479J
8C> B:=2;: ?2315@ >2 725<1H:; A2L >A1< 7257:6>C4D ;:725<>;C7>125 2= >A:
>L2 =2;?< 2= 45>1%<9<>:?5:<< 745 =;C1>=CDD9 B: :?6D29:H 15 72?64;4>13:
454D9<:<E 1> 1< 5:7:<<4;9 >2 :I6D2;: >A: 725<:WC:57:< =2; >A1< 454D9<1< 2= 4
<>;4>:@9 15 LA17A >A: 7257:6> 2= H:?27;479 1< >;:4>:H 4< 4 ;4H14D >96:J

91+"'"4-.&' D%,-30@0,+5%+00 &%1 :+5".$&.@ &0 & C&1-&' >"%.+7,


V;4L15@ 25 ;:7:5> H:3:D26?:5>< 15 D15@C1<>17 >A:2;9E ,2DD1:; 45H )4A25
A43: ;:7:5>D9 A1@AD1@A>:H A2L F525%7D4<<174DG ?2H:D< 2= 74>:@2;1:< Y4 >:;?

N]J $@54X1 <C??4;1X:< >A: 64;>9G< 1H:2D2@9 4< =2DD2L<a

Y4_ 5:2%D1B:;1<> #A4>7A:;145%D1M: :7252?17 62D179E LA1D: M::615@ A1@A%<>45H4;H <2714D


<:;317:< >A45M< >2 4 ;:HC7>125 2= >A: BC;:4C7;479\ B_ D:<< 41H >2 >A: #A1;H U2;DHE
;:<>;17>125 >2 477:<< =2; 1??1@;45><E 45H >A:1; =2;7:H ;:64>;14>125 Y15 >A1< >A: 64;>9
?C<> 725=;25> >A: 2662<1>125 2= >A: 92C>A 2;@451X4>125_\ 7_ 725<:5<C< >2 :5>;9 15
>A: ((, J J J \ H_ A2<>1D1>9 >2 =:?151<?E L1>A2C> B:15@ =432;4BD: >2 4 >;4H1>1254D
?2;4D1>9 Y<2 ?C7A >A4> >A: 92C>A 2;@451X4>125 1< 15 =432; 2= 4 H:%6:54D1X4>125 2=
H;C@<_\ :_ ?2;: D4L 45H 2;H:;J

! =:L D15:< D4>:;E $@54X1 ?415>415< >A4> >A: 64;>9 15 WC:<>125 <A2CDH B: D4B:DD:H 4< F45>1%<9<>:?G
Y$@54X1E NOO[a ZZbO_J

Downloaded from http://jtp.sagepub.com at SWETS WISE ONLINE CONTENT on July 26, 2009
cc `-.+"!/ -h #K(-+(#$,!/ *-/$#$,& N[YN_

>A4> >A:9 C<: 4< <95259? 2= F7257:6>G b <:: 4D<2 0:;;15@E NOOOa ^ZN_ A43:
7A4DD:5@:H >A: F7D4<<174DG ;CD:< 2= 7257:6>C4D ;:725<>;C7>125J $5 64;>17CD4;E
>A:9 :?6A4<1X: A2L >A: 3:;9 7257:6> 2= H:?27;479 >:5H< >2 B: 157;:4<15@D9
C<:H 4< 4 F;4H14DG 7257:6>E ;4>A:; >A45 4 7D4<<174D 74>:@2;9J h2; ;4H14D 725%
7:6><E >A: ;:D4>125<A16 B:>L::5 15>:5<125 45H :I>:5<125 1< H1==:;:5> =;2?
>A4> 2= 7D4<<174D 74>:@2;1:< Y,2DD1:; 45H )4A25E NOO^a :<6:714DD9 Z]Nbc\
?2;: 15 H:>41D 25 ;4H14D 74>:@2;1:<E <:: /4M2==E NOZRa RRbNN[_JNP 8C1DH15@
25 >A4> 454D9<1<E ,2DD1:; 45H /:31><M9 YNOOR_ A43: 454D9X:H >A: <>;4>:@9 2=
725<>;C7>15@ FH1?151<A:H <CB>96:<G 2= H:?27;479E ;:7:5>D9 4H26>:H B9
?459 <7A2D4;< 4< 4 L49 >2 157;:4<: H1==:;:5>14>125 LA1D: 4> >A: <4?: >1?:
4321H15@ 7257:6>C4D <>;:>7A15@J $= H:?27;479 1< >;:4>:H 4< 4 ;4H14D 7257:6>E
4 WC4D1=915@ 4Hg:7>13: L2CDH :?6A4<1X: >A: D47M 2= 25: 2= >A: 7A4;47>:;1<>17<
2= H:?27;479 4< H:S5:H 15 ?151?4D >:;?<J #AC<E >A: H1?151<A:H <CB>96:
F1DD1B:;4D H:?27;479GE =2; :I4?6D:E A1@AD1@A>< >A4> 4 64;>17CD4; <:> 2= 74<:<
D47M< >A: 4>>;1BC>: 2= F6;2>:7>125 2= 7131D D1B:;>1:<G 2= >A: ?151?4D H:S51>125
2= H:?27;479J !66;247A15@ H:?27;479 4< 4 7D4<<174D 74>:@2;9E B9 725>;4<>E
4 WC4D1=915@ 4Hg:7>13: L2CDH 4HH 4 7A4;47>:;1<>17 >2 >A2<: 157DCH:H 15 >A:
?151?4D H:S51>125J #AC<E >A: 7D4<<174D <CB>96: 2= F64;D14?:5>4;9 H:?27;479G
H:52>:< >A: 4HH1>125 2= >A: 64;>17CD4; 7A4;47>:;1<>17 >2 >A2<: 2= >A: ?151?4D
H:S51>125 2= H:?27;479 >A4> 72CDH B: H:<7;1B:H 4< F>A: :I:7C>13: H:6:5H< 25
>A: 725SH:57: 2= >A: D:@1<D4>C;:GJ $5 2>A:; L2;H<E LA1D: >A: 7D4<<174D <CB>96:<
1H:5>1=9 4 <CB<:> 2= 74<:< 2= >A: >;C: >96:E H1?151<A:H <CB>96:< :572?64<< 45
:5>1;:D9 H1==:;:5> <:> 2= 74<:< >A45 >A2<: <:1X:H B9 >A: H:S51>125 2= >A: ;22>
7257:6> Y,2DD1:; 45H /:31><M9E NOORa [^Rb[c_J
#A1< 4H3457: 15 7257:6>C4D 454D9<1< 1< 64;>17CD4;D9 ;:D:345> >2 7D4<<1=9 >A:
2=>:5 D:<<%>A45%6:;=:7> =2;?< 2= H:?27;4>17 ;CD: ;:7:5>D9 :<>4BD1<A:H 15
34;12C< 4;:4< 2= >A: L2;DHJ $> 4D<2 74552> B: 1@52;:H 15 >A: 6;:<:5> 454D9<1<E
:<6:714DD9 @13:5 >A: ;4H174D 2662<1>125 =2;7:< >A4> 26:;4>: 15 <:3:;4D 2= >A2<:
;:7:5>D9 :<>4BD1<A:H H:?27;471:<E LA17A 745 2=>:5 B: B:<> 7D4<<1S:H 4< 4
64;>17CD4; H1?151<A:H <CB>96: 2= H:?27;479J UA4> >A:5 4;: >A: 64;>17CD4;
725<:WC:57:< =2; >A: >;43:D15@ 746471>9 2= >A: 7257:6> 2= F45>1%<9<>:?G
64;>9 1= >A: 7257:6> 2= H:?27;479E 45H >A:;:=2;: >A4> 2= F<9<>:?GE 1< >;:4>:H
4< 4 ;4H14D 74>:@2;9m
!< 6;:312C<D9 4;@C:HE 4 64;>9 WC4D1S:< 4< 45>1%<9<>:? 1= 1> 2662<:< 459 25:
2= >A: 4>>;1BC>:< 2= >A: <9<>:? 4> >A: D:3:D 2= 4B<>;47>125 4> LA17A >A: D4>>:;

NPJ $5 ;4H14D 7257:6><E >A: ?:4515@ 1< 457A2;:H 15 4 F7:5>;4D <CB74>:@2;9GE 2; F;22> 7257:6>GE
LA17A 72;;:<625H< >2 >A: 6;2>2>96: 2= >A: 74>:@2;9E 45H 1< H:S5:H B9 4 7:;>415 <:> 2= 7A4;47>:;%
1<>17<J h;2? >A: 7:5>;4D <CB74>:@2;9E 525%7:5>;4D 74>:@2;1:<E 2; FH1?151<A:H <CB>96:<GE :?:;@:
LA:5 0#E0+,0 2= >A2<: 7A4;47>:;1<>17< 4;: C<:H >2 H:S5: 4 @13:5 2Bg:7>J ! <1?6D: :I4?6D: 1<
>A4> 2= F?2>A:;G 4< 4 7:5>;4D 74>:@2;9 4< 2662<:H >2 F<>:6?2>A:;G 2; F@:5:>17 ?2>A:;GE <CB%
74>:@2;1:< H:S5:H B9 <CB<:>< 2= >A: 7A4;47>:;1<>17< 2= >A2<: H:S515@ F?2>A:;G Y,2DD1:; 45H
)4A25E NOO^a Z[Z\ /4M2==E NOZRa RObOQ_J

Downloaded from http://jtp.sagepub.com at SWETS WISE ONLINE CONTENT on July 26, 2009
,!*-,,$!a !"#$%&'&#() *!+#$(& c^

7257:6> 1< ;:725<>;C7>:HJ *4;>1:< >A4> 2662<: 4> D:4<> 25: 2= >A: 7A4;47>:;%
1<>17< 2= H:?27;479 4< 6;:<:5> 15 >A: <CB>96:< 4;: 4< 45>1%<9<>:? 4< 64;>1:<
>A4> 2662<: >A: <4?: 7A4;47>:;1<>17< 15 F>;C:G H:?27;471:<J #2 @13: 45
:I4?6D:E >A: @24D< 2= >A: !D@:;145 $<D4?17 &4D34>125 h;25> 15 NOON L:;: 52
D:<< 1572?64>1BD: L1>A H:?27;479E 45H >A: ?23:?:5> >A:;:=2;: 52 D:<<
45>1%H:?27;4>17E B:74C<: !D@:;14 4> >A4> >1?: 72CDH 52> B: 7D4<<1S:H 4<
=CDD9 H:?27;4>17 Y:J@J +2B:;><E NOOc_J $5 >A1< <:5<:E 45 454D9<1< 2= 45>1%
<9<>:? 64;>1:<E LA:;:B9 >A: H:?27;4>17 <9<>:? 1< 15>:;6;:>:H 4< 4 ;4H14D 725%
7:6>E 5::H 52> B: H1==:;:5> =;2? >A4> 2= 45>1%<9<>:? 64;>1:< 15 4 H:?27;4>17
<9<>:? >A4> 1< C5H:;<>22H 4< 4 7D4<<174D 74>:@2;9J #A:;:=2;:E 45>1%<9<>:?
64;>1:< 2662<15@ 4 64;>17CD4; 4>>;1BC>: 2= >A: 62D1>174D <9<>:? 15 H1?151<A:H
<CB>96:< 2= H:?27;479 745E 15 6;15716D:E 4D<2 B: 454D9X:H 72?64;4>13:D9E
:1>A:; 47;2<< H1==:;:5> 3:;<125< 2= H1?151<A:H <CB>96:< 2; 15 72?64;1<25
L1>A 45>1%<9<>:? 64;>1:< 15 =CDD9 H:?27;4>17 <9<>:?<E LA17A ?::> 4DD >A:
;:WC1;:?:5>< 2= >A: ?151?4D H:S51>125J
UA1D: 72?64;4>13: 454D9<1< 47;2<< H1==:;:5> >96:< 2= H:?27;479 5::H 52>
62<: 459 6;2BD:?< 1= >A: C51>< 2= 72?64;1<25< 4;: >A: 45>1%<9<>:? 64;>1:<
15 >A:?<:D3:<E 15 6;47>17:E 72?64;1<25< 2= 45>1%<9<>:? 64;>1:< @:5:;4DD9
4D<2 >2C7A C625 <2?: 4<6:7> 2= >A:1; ;:D4>125<A16 L1>A >A: 62D1>174D <9<>:?J
)2;: <6:71S74DD9E >A: 6;:<:57: 2= 45>1%<9<>:?17 =2;7:< 1< 2=>:5 >4M:5 4< 45
15H174>2; 2= >A: D47M 2= <>4B1D1>9 2; D:@1>1?479 2= >A: H:?27;4>17 ;:@1?:E 2;
1>< H:@;:: 2= H:?27;4>17 725<2D1H4>125 Y:J@J /15X 45H &>:645E NOOP_J $5 <C7A
74<:<E 4 72?64;4>13: C<: 2= >A: 7257:6> 2= 45>1%<9<>:? 64;>1:< 47;2<< H1==:;:5>
>96:< 2= H:?27;479 1< ?2;: 6;2BD:?4>17J $5 =47>E 15 4DD D1M:D1A22HE 45H 4DD
2>A:; >A15@< B:15@ :WC4DE 1> 745 B: :I6:7>:H >A4> >A: ;2D: 2= 1H:2D2@174D
45>1%<9<>:? 64;>1:< 15 C5H:;?1515@ >A: D:@1>1?479E <>4B1D1>9 2; 725<2D1H4>125
2= 4 =CDD9 H:?27;4>17 ;:@1?: 1< H1==:;:5> =;2? >A4> 15 4 64;>17CD4; H1?151<A:H
<CB>96: 2= H:?27;479E LA:;: 6;:71<:D9 >A: 4B<:57: 2= <2?: 2= >A: 4>>;1BC>:<
2= 4 ?151?4D H:?27;479 1< 4D<2 D1M:D9 >2 :I:;> 4 ?4g2; 15kC:57: 15 >A: <4?:
H1;:7>125J T::615@ 15 ?15H >A4> >A: 26>1?4D 7;1>:;14 =2; 74<: <:D:7>125 L1DD
H:6:5H 25 >A: <6:71S7 @24D< 2= >A: ;:<:4;7AE 1= >A: ;:D4>125<A16 B:>L::5 >A:
6;:<:57: 2= 1H:2D2@174DD9 45>1%<9<>:? 64;>1:< 45H 4>>;1BC>:< 2= >A: 62D1>174D
;:@1?:E <C7A 4< D:@1>1?479 2; 725<2D1H4>125E 1< 4> >A: 72;: 2= >A: 454D9<1<E 1>
L2CDH >A:;:=2;: B: 4H31<4BD: >2 C<: >A: 7257:6> 2= 45>1%<9<>:? 64;>9 72?%
64;4>13:D9 25D9 8-,*-% 45H 52> &.$"00 :47A 2= >A: H1==:;:5> >96:< 2= <9<>:?E
B: 1> F>;C: >96:<G 2; FH1?151<A:H <CB>96:<GJ

5"#)6272#,8 ?/$#),2: 5 *7.%0%E7

$5 >A1< 454D9<1<E >L2 H1<>157> =2;?< 2= 45>1%<9<>:?5:<< A43: B::5 H1<%


>15@C1<A:HJ -5 >A: 25: A45HE 4 64;>9G< $+'&,-"%&' &%,-30@0,+5%+00 725<1<><
15 1>< A1@A H1<>457: =;2? >A: 2>A:; 64;>1:< 25 >A: 1H:2D2@174D <647:E 45H 1><

Downloaded from http://jtp.sagepub.com at SWETS WISE ONLINE CONTENT on July 26, 2009
c[ `-.+"!/ -h #K(-+(#$,!/ *-/$#$,& N[YN_

4H26>125 2= F1<2D4>1251<>G 724D1>125 <>;4>:@1:< 45H 7:5>;1=C@4D 6;264@45H4


>47>17<J 82>A >A: 64;>9G< ;:=C<4D >2 :5>:; 724D1>125< b 2; 1>< B:15@ ;:g:7>:H B9
1>< 62>:5>14D 64;>5:;< b 45H >A: 6;:34D:57: 2= 2C>B1HH15@ 45H H:D:@1>1?1X15@
?:<<4@:< 15 1>< :D:7>2;4D 6;264@45H4E >:5H >2 1<2D4>: >A: 64;>9 =;2? >A: 2>A:;<
45H >2 157;:4<: 62D4;1X4>125 15 >A: 64;>9 <9<>:?J ! 64;>9G< -1+"'"4-.&' &%,-3
0@0,+5%+00E 25 >A: 2>A:; A45HE 725<1<>< 15 >A: 1572?64>1B1D1>9 2= 1>< 1H:2%
D2@174D ;:=:;:5><E 45H >A:;:=2;: 1>< 62D1>174D @24D<E L1>A H:?27;479J #A:
H:S51>125 2= >A1< D4>>:; 7257:6> 4> H1==:;:5> D:3:D< 2= 4B<>;47>125 A4< 1?62;%
>45> 725<:WC:57:< =2; >A: >;43:D15@ 746471>9 2= >A: 7257:6> 2= 45>1%<9<>:?
64;>9 15 >A: 1H:2D2@174D <:5<:J
!59 725<1H:;4>125 25 >A: C>1D1>9 2= >A1< 7257:6>C4D 454D9<1< ?C<> >4M: >A:
D:4H =;2? >A: 6;:D1?154;9 2B<:;34>125 >A4> B2>A =2;?< 2= 45>1%<9<>:?5:<< 4;:
52> 52;?4DD9 <>CH1:H 6:; <:E BC> 15 ;:D4>125 >2 4 <9<>:?J #A: 6;:312C< <:7>125<
A43: A1@AD1@A>:H >A4> 1H:2D2@174D 45H ;:D4>1254D 45>1%<9<>:?5:<< A43: H1==:;%
:5> F<9<>:?<G 2= ;:=:;:57:E 45H ;:D4>: >2 >A:? 15 H1==:;:5> L49<J #A: 1H:2%
D2@174D 45>1%<9<>:?5:<< 2= 64;>1:< 2; @;2C6< 1< 1?62;>45> 15 ;:D4>125 >2 >A:
1+5".$&,-. 0@0,+5 4< 4 LA2D:E 4< 1> 1< D1M:D9 >2 A43: 45 1?647> b B9 2662<15@
25: 2; ?2;: 2= 1>< =C5H4?:5>4D 7A4;47>:;1<>17< b 25 >A: D4>>:;G< <>4B1D1>9E
D:@1>1?479E 2; 725<2D1H4>125E 15 >A: :I4?6D:< ?:5>125:H :4;D1:;J #A: ;:D4%
>1254D 45>1%<9<>:?5:<< 2= 64;>1:<E A2L:3:;E 1< 1?62;>45> =2; >A: 7&$,@ 0@0,+5E
4< 1> 1< D1M:D9 >2 A43: 45 1?647> 25 >A: D4>>:;G< ?:7A4517<E B9 6C<A15@ 1>
>2L4;H< 157;:4<:H 62D4;1X4>125 45H 7:5>;1=C@4D1>9J $5 2>A:; L2;H<E >A:
2B<:;34>125< 25 >A: 45>1%<9<>:?5:<< 2= 4 64;>9 4;: 52;?4DD9 74;;1:H 2C> 15
2;H:; >2 47WC1;: M52LD:H@: 25 4 H1==:;:5>E 45H A1@A:;E C51> 2= 454D9<1<J
#A: >962D2@9 15 h1@C;: N A1@AD1@A>< >A: 1?647> 2= >A: >L2 =2;?< 2= 64;>1:<G
45>1%<9<>:?5:<< 25 >A: 62D1>174D 45H >A: 64;>9 <9<>:?<E 45H 1H:5>1S:< H1==:;:5>
>96:< 2= 64;>1:<J
h2; >A: 6C;62<: 2= 1DDC<>;4>15@ >A: >962D2@9E >A: 4<<:<<?:5> 2= ;:D4>1254D
45>1%<9<>:?5:<< 1< B4<:H 25 4 @:5:;4D :34DC4>125 2= 4 64;>9G< 724D1>125 45H

+:D4>1254D !5>1%<9<>:?5:<<

':< "2

9$$+'+F&%, DA/0
':< )@7-.&'
$H:2D2@174D D%,-30@0,+5 7&$,-+0 D.."55"1&,-%4 DA/0
!5>1%<9<>:?5:<<
)@7-.&'
"2 /"'&$-6-%4 /&$,-+0 /$"30@0,+5 /&$,-+0

F)E'$, AB #962D2@9 2= *2D1>174D *4;>1:< !772;H15@ >2 #A:1;


!5>1%<9<>:?5:<<

Downloaded from http://jtp.sagepub.com at SWETS WISE ONLINE CONTENT on July 26, 2009
,!*-,,$!a !"#$%&'&#() *!+#$(& c]

6;264@45H4 <>;4>:@1:<E ;4>A:; >A45 25 1>< D274>125 25 >A: 1H:2D2@174D <647: b


4D>A2C@A 4DD :I4?6D:< ?4H: A:;: <A4;: >A: 72??25 6;26:;>9 2= B:15@
D274>:H 4> 25: :I>;:?: 2= >A: 72?6:>1>13: <647:JNR #AC<E 4 64;>9 L2CDH B:
7D4<<1S:H 15 >A: D:=>%A45H 7:DD< 2= >A: >962D2@9 1= 1> 4H26>< F1<2D4>1251<>G
<>;4>:@1:<E >:5H15@ >2 BC1DH 4 <:64;4>: F62D:G 2= >A: <9<>:? 45H >2 ;:=C<: >2
:5>:; 724D1>125< Y4> >A: 54>1254D D:3:D_E 45H ;:<2;>< >2 2C>B1HH15@ 6;264@45H4
>47>17<E <9<>:?4>174DD9 2662<15@ 45H H1<7;:H1>15@ <2?: =2C5H15@ 34DC:< 2= >A:
;:@1?:E 25 LA17A 4DD 2>A:; 64;>1:< 4@;::J
#A1< 1< 52> B:D1>>D15@ >A: 1?62;>457: 2= 1H:2D2@174D H1<>457: 15 &4;>2;1G<
=;4?:L2;MJ -5 >A: 725>;4;9E 4 A1@A 1H:2D2@174D H1<>457: B:>L::5 >A: 64;>1:<
b 4 D1M:D9 725<:WC:57: 2= 4 A1@A 5C?B:; 2= ;:D:345> 64;>1:< 72?6:>15@ 25 >A:
<4?: 1H:2D2@174D <647: b ;:?415< 4 3:;9 1?62;>45> :I6D454>2;9 =47>2; =2; >A:
:?:;@:57: 2= 4 62D4;1X:H 64;>9 <9<>:? ?:7A4517<J !< 6;:312C<D9 <6:71S:HE
A2L:3:;E >A: >962D2@9 2= h1@C;: N 41?< >2 7D4<<1=9 64;>1:< 15 ;:D4>125 >2
>A:1; 1?647> 25 >A: F<9<>:?G Y15 >A: 74<: 2= ;:D4>1254D 45>1%<9<>:?5:<<E >A:
64;>9 <9<>:?_J #2L4;H< >A1< 41?E =27C<15@ 25 >A: 724D1>125 45H 6;264@45H4
<>;4>:@1:< 52> 25D9 2==:;< 4 ?2;: 1??:H14>: 15H174>2; >A45 1H:2D2@174D H1<%
>457: BC> 1> 1< 4D<2 64;>17CD4;D9 466;26;14>:J $5 =47>E 4772;H15@ >2 &4;>2;1E
>A: ;:4<25 LA9 4 A1@A 1H:2D2@174D H1<>457: 1< 2=>:5 4> >A: B4<1< 2= 4 62D4;1X:H
?:7A4517< 1< >A4> 1> ;:5H:;< F7:5>;1=C@4DG >47>17< +'+.,"$&''@ $+8&$1-%4 =2; >A:
64;>1:<J &4;>2;1 ?4M:< 7D:4; >A4> A1< ?2H:D 1< 52> H:>:;?151<>17a >A: 64;>1:< 745
72C5>:;47> >A: <9<>:?17 6;26:5<1>1:< b >A: 25D9 6;:H17>125 2= >A: >A:2;9 1<
>A4>E 15 >A1< 74<:E >A:9 4;: D1M:D9 >2 D2<: 32>:< Y:J@J &4;>2;1E NOZca cQPbRE
^Q]bP_J $5 2>A:; L2;H<E &4;>2;1G< =;4?:L2;M 4DD2L< =2; >A: 62<<1B1D1>9 >A4>
64;>9 :D1>:<E 62<<1BD9 =2; H1==:;:5> 157:5>13:< >A45 >A: :D:7>2;4D 25:<E ?1@A>
;:<>;415 =;2? 4H26>15@ F62D4;1X15@G 724D1>125 45H 6;264@45H4 <>;4>:@1:<
:3:5 15 >A: 6;:<:57: 2= 1H:2D2@174D 157:5>13:< >2 H2 <2E 45H 317: 3:;<4E 45H
>A:;:B9 A43: 45 15H:6:5H:5> 1?647> 25 >A: L2;M15@ 2= >A: 64;>9 <9<>:?JNZ

NRJ ! ?2;: S5:%@;415:H 26:;4>1254D1X4>125 45H ?:4<C;:?:5> 2= ;:D4>1254D 45>1%<9<>:?5:<<


L2CDH 1532D3: <:3:;4D ?:>A2H2D2@174D 45H 6;47>174D 6;2BD:?<E 157DCH15@E =2; :I4?6D:E >A:
<4?6D15@ 45H 72H15@ 2= 6;264@45H4 <2C;7:<E >A: H1<7C<<125 2= LA17A L2CDH :I7::H >A: D1?1><
2= >A1< 4;>17D:J #A: 54>C;: 2= >A: 7257:6> L2CDH 2B312C<D9 ;:5H:; H1==:;:5> ?:4<C;:< 477:6>4BD:
45H 34D1HE H:6:5H15@ 25 >A: <6:71S7 41? 45H <:>>15@ 2= >A: ;:<:4;7AJ
NZJ #A: 7C;;:5> <1>C4>125 2= >A: !C<>;145 64;>9 <9<>:? 6;231H:< 45 15>:;:<>15@ :I4?6D: 15 >A1<
;:<6:7>a LA1D: >A: :I>;:?:%;1@A> !C<>;145 /1B:;4D *4;>9 Yh*-n_ 7:;>415D9 725>;1BC>:H >2 >A: 23:;4DD
62D4;1X4>125 2= >A: <9<>:? LA1D: 15 2662<1>125E 1> 1< ?C7A D:<< <2 52L >A4> >A: 64;>9 1< 15 @23:;5%
?:5>J #2 @13: 4 =C;>A:; :I4?6D:E V44DH:; :?6A4<1X:< >A: 62<<1B1D1>9 2= >A: 6;:34D:57: 2= 7:5>;1%
6:>4D 72?6:>1>125 4D<2 15 4 <9<>:? L1>A 4 ;:D4>13:D9 A1@A 5C?B:; 2= 64;>1:<E 4< 1> A466:5:H 15 #A:
":>A:;D45H<J UA1D: >A: 4B<:57: 2= <1X:4BD: :I>;:?1<>< 7:;>415D9 725<>1>C>:H 45 1?62;>45> :D:?:5>
15 :I6D41515@ >A: 4B<:57: 2= 62D4;1X4>125 45H >A: 6;:34D:57: 2= 7:5>;16:>4D >:5H:571:< 15 >A:
72?6:>1>125 15 >A: VC>7A 64;>9 <9<>:?E V44DH:; ?415>415< >A4> >A: VC>7A 64;>1:< FD:4;5:HG >2
72?6:>: 7:5>;16:>4DD9 45H >A:;:B9 @43: 45 1?62;>45> 725>;1BC>125 >2L4;H< H:62D4;1X4>125
YV44DH:;E NOZ[a NQ^_J

Downloaded from http://jtp.sagepub.com at SWETS WISE ONLINE CONTENT on July 26, 2009
cP `-.+"!/ -h #K(-+(#$,!/ *-/$#$,& N[YN_

#A: 4<<:<<?:5> 2= 4 64;>9G< 1H:2D2@174D 45>1%<9<>:?5:<< H:6:5H< 25 >A:


H:S51>125 2= H:?27;479 4H26>:H 15 >A: 454D9<1<JNO $5 >A: :I4?6D:< B:D2LE $
A43: 7A2<:5 4 ?151?4D%6;27:HC;4D H:S51>125 2= H:?27;479E LA17A 4DD2L<
WC1>: B;24H 72?64;1<25<E 45H A43: >;:4>:H H:?27;479 4< 4 F7D4<<174DG 74>:%
@2;9J !< :I6D415:H B:=2;:E A2L:3:;E H1==:;:5> <>;4>:@1:< 2= 7257:6>C4D ;:725%
<>;C7>125 4;: 62<<1BD:J #AC<E 4 64;>9 1< F1H:2D2@174DD9G 45>1%<9<>:? LA:5 1>
2662<:< 459 2= >A: 7A4;47>:;1<>17< 2= >A: ?151?4D H:S51>125 2= H:?27;479
Y=CDD 725>:<>4B1D1>9 15 :D:7>125<E =CDD 157DC<13:5:<<\ =41;5:<< 2= 32>:\ 7131D
D1B:;>1:<\ 47>C4D 62L:; >2 :D:7>:H 2=S714D<_JcQ
#A: 64;>1:< 157DCH:H 15 >A: C66:;%D:=> 45H D2L:;%;1@A> 7:DD< 2= >A: >962D2@9
H2 52> 62<: 64;>17CD4; 6;2BD:?<J #A: D2L:;%;1@A> 7:DD 157DCH:< >A: 6C;:
7$"30@0,+5 7&$,-+0E >A2<: >A4> H2 52> 7A4DD:5@: H:?27;479E 52; A43: 459
62D4;1X15@ :==:7> 25 >A: 64;>9 <9<>:? ?:7A4517<J #A: C66:;%D:=> 7:DD 725>415<
>A: ,@7-.&' &%,-30@0,+5 7&$,-+0E LA17A B2>A 7A4DD:5@: H:?27;479 45H A43:
62D4;1X15@ :==:7>< 25 >A: 64;>9 <9<>:? =C57>12515@J #A: D2L:;%D:=> 7:DD 157DCH:<
>A: 7"'&$-6-%4 7&$,-+0E LA17A H2 52> H1<6D49 459 1H:2D2@174D 7A4;47>:;1<>17< 2=
45>1%<9<>:?5:<< BC> LA17A H2E A2L:3:;E :572C;4@: 4 62D4;1X:H ?:7A4517< 15
>A: 64;>9 <9<>:? 25 4 ?151?4DD9 HC;4BD: B4<1<E 6;47>1715@ 2C>B1HH15@ 15 >A:
:D:7>2;4D 72?6:>1>125E 45H B:15@ 525%724D1>1254BD: 2; H1<D294D 15 724D1>125<J
! 743:4> 1< 15 2;H:; A:;:E >A2C@Aa 1> 1< 1?62;>45> >2 :?6A4<1X: >A4> <C7A 64;%
>1:< L2CDH B: 725<1H:;:H =CDD9 45>1%<9<>:? 1= &4;>2;1G< >A:2;:>174D =;4?:L2;M
L:;: C<:H 15 4 72?64;4>13: 454D9<1< 2= 64;>9 <9<>:?<E <157: >A:9 4;: :5H2L:H
L1>A ;:D4>1254D 45>1%<9<>:?5:<<E LA17A 1< >A: 7;C714D 7A4;47>:;1<>17 15 >A4> M15H
2= 454D9<1<J UA1D: ;:D4B:D15@ >A:? 15 >A: >962D2@9 4< F62D4;1X15@ 64;>1:<G
<A2CDH 52> 7257:4D >A1< =47>E >A1< 64;>14D H:64;>C;: =;2? &4;>2;1G< 2;1@154D
?:4515@ <::?< >2 B: 4H31<4BD: =2; >L2 ;:4<25<J h1;<>E >A: :I6D171> 45H 72;;:7>
C<: 2= &4;>2;1G< =;4?:L2;M =2; >A: 454D9<1< 2= 64;>9 <9<>:?<G ?:7A4517< 1<
72?64;4BD9 ?C7A D:<< =;:WC:5> >A45 454D9<:< 2= H:?27;4>17 ;:@1?:< 15

NOJ &1?1D4; >2 ;:D4>1254D 45>1%<9<>:?5:<<E 4D<2 4 ?2;: S5:%@;415:H ?:4<C;:?:5> 2= 1H:2D2@174D
45>1%<9<>:?5:<<E 4D>A2C@A L:DD 62<<1BD:E L2CDH :5>41D >A: H1<7C<<125 2= 6;2BD:?< >A4> L2CDH B:
<>;25@D9 ;:D4>:H >2 >A: 47>C4D ;:<:4;7A <:>>15@J 8:<1H:< >A: 6;2BD:?< 2= H:S51>125 5:7:<<4;1D9
:5>41D:H B9 45 F:<<:5>14DD9 725>:<>:H 7257:6>G <C7A 4< H:?27;479 Y04DD1:E NO]P_E 4 <26A1<>174>:H
26:;4>1254D1X4>125 2= >A: 7257:6> 2= 1H:2D2@174D 45>1%<9<>:?5:<< ?C<> 4D<2 725=;25>E =2; :I4?6D:E
>A: 4;HC2C< >4<M 2= S5H15@ 4 34D1H 45H ;:D14BD: ?:4<C;: 2= >A: 1H:2D2@174D 7A4;47>:; 2= 4 72?6D:I
:5>1>9 <C7A 4< 4 62D1>174D 64;>9 2; @;2C6J h2; 4 H1<7C<<125 2= >A: ?:>A2H2D2@174D 6;2BD:?<
:5>41D:H 15 >A1< 26:;4>125E <:: 0:;;15@ YNOOZa ]Nb[ 45H cZRbOZ_E LA1D: ;:k:7>125< 25 >A: <4?:
>2617 15 H1;:7> 7255:7>125 >2 72?64;4>13: ;:<:4;7A 25 :I>;:?1<> 64;>1:< 4;: 15 )CHH:
YcQQQa NObc[_J
cQJ #A:<: 7;1>:;14 4;:E >2 4 7:;>415 :I>:5>E >1?:%B2C5HE 4< >A:9 ;:=:; >2 4 ."%,+57"$&$@ ?151?4D
H:S51>125 2= H:?27;479J $= 25: L45>< >2 :I645H >A: 72?64;1<25 >2 :4;D1:; 6:;12H<E 15 LA17A ?151%
?4D H:?27;479 L4< @:5:;4DD9 7257:13:H 4< B:15@ 72?64>1BD:E =2; :I4?6D:E L1>A D:<<%>A45%=CDD
D:3:D< 2= 157DC<13:5:<<E >A:5 4 62<<1BD: <>;4>:@9 1< >A4> 2= 457A2;15@ >A: 7;1>:;125 2= 157DC<13:5:<<
>2 1>< 47>C4D 7257:6>125 15 H1==:;:5> 6:;12H<J

Downloaded from http://jtp.sagepub.com at SWETS WISE ONLINE CONTENT on July 26, 2009
,!*-,,$!a !"#$%&'&#() *!+#$(& cR

LA17A >A: >:;? 45>1%<9<>:? 1< C<:H 15 1>< F1H:2D2@174DG ?:4515@J &:725HE 4=>:;
>A: L4515@ 2= >2>4D1>4;145 1H:2D2@1:<E >A: :?61;174D 23:;D46 B:>L::5 >A: >L2
=2;?< 2= 45>1%<9<>:?5:<< 1< ?C7A D:<< =;:WC:5> >A45 15 >A: 6;:312C< H:74H:<J
,2?15@ >2 >A: 64;>1:< 15 >A: 2>A:; 7:DD< 2= h1@C;: NE B2>A >96:< 15 >A: C66:;%
;1@A> 7:DD 2= >A: >962D2@9 H2 52> A43: 459 <1@51S745> 62D4;1X15@ :==:7>< 25 >A:
64;>9 <9<>:? ?:7A4517< 45H 9:> 62<: 4 >A;:4> >2 H:?27;479J #A: 454D9<1< 2=
>A: 64;>1:< L1>A >A:<: 7A4;47>:;1<>17< 74DD< =2; 4 6;:D1?154;9 H1<7C<<125 2= >A:
6;2BD:? 2= >A: >A;:<A2DH< 2= ;:D:3457: 2= 4 64;>9 15 >A: 64;>9 <9<>:? 45H
>A: 62D1>174D <9<>:? 4< 4 LA2D:J $5 &4;>2;1G< L2;H<E 45 45>1%<9<>:? 64;>9 1<
;:D:345> =2; >A: =C57>12515@ 2= >A: 64;>9 <9<>:? 1= 1> 15kC:57:< >A: H1;:7>125
2= 72?6:>1>125 45H ?4M:< 7:5>;1=C@4D 6C<A:< 6;:341D 15 1>J !5 15H174>2; 2=
>A1< 7A4;47>:;1<>17 1< >A: H: =47>2 3:>2 62L:; >A4> >A: 64;>9 15 WC:<>125 745
:I:;> 25 D:@1<D4>125 Y&4;>2;1E NORPa Nc[_J $5 >A: 725>:I> 2= >A1< 454D9<1<E >A:
7;1>:;125 2= ;:D:3457: 2= 4 ;:D4>1254D 45>1%<9<>:? 64;>9 745 B: ;:=2;?CD4>:H
4< 4 =C57>125 2= >A: 64;>9G< <1X: 45H HC;4>125JcN #A:;:=2;:E 4 ;:D4>1254DD9
45>1%<9<>:? 64;>9 1< ;:D:345> LA:5 1> 745 A15H:;E 2; ?4M: ?2;: H1=S7CD>E
>A: =2;?4>125 2= FB162D4;G 724D1>125< >A4> L2CDH 2>A:;L1<: A43: B::5
=2;?:H b 4< 15 >A: 74<:E ?:5>125:H B:=2;:E 2= >A: V451<A *;2@;:<< *4;>9J
#A: <4?: 466D1:< LA:5 4 64;>9 <C662;>< <C7A F1<2D4>1251<>G <>;4>:@1:< B9
=27C<15@ 1>< 6;264@45H4 25 >A: 64;>9G< ;4H174D H13:;<1>9 15 ;:<6:7> >2 >A:
?2H:;4>: F5:1@AB2;15@G 64;>1:< b 4< 15 >A: 74<:E =2; :I4?6D:E 2= >A: $>4D145
,2??C51<> +:=2C5H4>125 *4;>9 15 >A: NOOQ<E 25 LA17A <:: D4>:;J #2 >A: 725%
>;4;9E 1= 4 64;>9 1< >22 <?4DDE 2; ;:47A:< 4 ;:?4;M4BD: <1X: BC> D4<>< >22 <A2;> 4
>1?:E >A:5 1>< 724D1>125 <>;4>:@1:< 45H 6;264@45H4 L1DD 52> A15H:; >A: =2;?4%
>125 2= B162D4; 724D1>125<E 45H >A: 64;>9 L2CDH B: 1;;:D:345> =2; >A: 23:;4DD
=C57>12515@ 2= >A: 64;>9 <9<>:? 45HE 4< <C7AE 52> L2;>A 725<1H:;15@ 15
72?64;4>13: 454D9<:< 2= 64;>9 <9<>:?<J
':>E <C7A 4 <?4DD 2; :6A:?:;4D 64;>9 L2CDH 52> 5:7:<<4;1D9 A43: >2 B: H1<%
74;H:H =;2? 72?64;4>13: <>CH1:< 2= >A: H:@;:: 2= D:@1>1?479E <>4B1D1>9 2; 725%
<2D1H4>125 15 H1==:;:5> H:?27;4>17 <9<>:?<J $5 >A: 725>:I> 2= >A: 62D1>174D
<9<>:? 4< 4 LA2D:E 4 <?4DD 64;>9 ?1@A> B: 1?62;>45> B:74C<: 1> A4< 2;@4517
725>47>< L1>A ?2;: <1X:4BD: 45>1%<9<>:? @;2C6< 2; :3:5 L1>A >:;;2;1<> ?23:%
?:5><E =2; :I4?6D:J $5 2>A:; L2;H<E >A: 454D9>174D ;:D:3457: 2= 1H:2D2@174DD9
45>1%<9<>:? 64;>1:< H:6:5H< 25 >A: 47>C4D 6;2BD:? <>CH1:HJ #AC<E 4 64;>9

cNJ #A1< 1< 4 D:<< H:?45H15@ 7;1>:;125 >A45 &4;>2;1G<E 45H 4< <C7A 1> 745 4772C5> =2; >A: ?2;:
;:7:5> H:3:D26?:5>< 15 ?459 64;>9 <9<>:?<E <2?:>1?:< H1<6D4915@ 52> 4 =CDD9 62D4;1X:H
?:7A4517<E BC> 5:1>A:; 62<<:<<15@ 4DD >A: 7A4;47>:;1<>17< 2= 5"1+$&,+ Y525%62D4;1X:H_ 6DC;4D1<?E
2=>:5 B:74C<: 2= >A: 6;:<:57: 2= ;:D4>1254DD9 45>1%<9<>:? 64;>1:< >A4> A2L:3:; H2 52> A43: 4 <C=S%
71:5> <>;:5@>A >2 :I:;> 4 H: =47>2 3:>2 62L:; 25 D:@1<D4>125J !D>A2C@A 15 <2?: 74<:< 4 64;>9G< ;:D:%
3457: L1DD B: H1=S7CD> >2 4<<:<< C513274DD9 Y4< 1> L2CDH 4D<2 B: L1>A &4;>2;1G< 2;1@154D 7;1>:;125E 4>
459 ;4>:_E >A: 7;1>:;14 4H26>:H A:;: 4D<2 ?4M: 62<<1BD: >2 4772C5> =2; >;45<1>1254D 6A4<:< 2= 64;>9
<9<>:?<E LA17A ?49 6;:DCH: :1>A:; >2 4 =CDD9 k:H@:H 62D4;1X4>125 2= >A: <9<>:?E 2; >2 4 72?6D:>:
15>:@;4>125 2= >A: 45>1%<9<>:? 64;>9J

Downloaded from http://jtp.sagepub.com at SWETS WISE ONLINE CONTENT on July 26, 2009
cZ `-.+"!/ -h #K(-+(#$,!/ *-/$#$,& N[YN_

?49 B: 1;;:D:345> =2; >A: 64;>9 <9<>:? ?:7A4517< 45HE 4> >A: <4?: >1?:E B:
3:;9 1?62;>45> =2; >A: <>CH9 2= <6:71S7 4<6:7>< 2= >A: 62D1>174D <9<>:?J
#AC<E -$$+'+F&%, &%,-30@0,+5 7&$,-+0 4;: :1>A:; >22 <?4DD 2; D4<> >22 <A2;> 4
>1?: >2 A43: 459 <1@51S745> 1?647> 25 >A: 64;>9 <9<>:? ?:7A4517<J #A:1;
F;:D4>1254DG <>4>C< 1< <1?6D9 1;;:D:345>a >A: 64;>9 <9<>:? L2;M< 15H:6:5H:5>D9
2= >A:1; <>;4>:@1:<J $5 725>;4<>E &.."55"1&,-%4 &%,-30@0,+5 7&$,-+0 A43: 4
<C=S71:5> <1X: 45He2; HC;4>125 >2 62>:5>14DD9 15kC:57: >A: 64;>9 <9<>:?
?:7A4517<E BC> H2 52> A43: 62D4;1X15@ :==:7>< 25 1>J #A4> 1<E H:<61>: >A:1; 1H:2%
D2@174D 45>1%<9<>:?5:<<E 4772??2H4>15@ 45>1%<9<>:? 64;>1:< 4;: 724D1>1254BD:
45H D294D 15 724D1>125< b >A:;:B9 52> :572C;4@15@ ?CD>1%62D4;1>9 b 45H 6;47%
>17: D1?1>:HE 1= 459E 2C>B1HH15@ b >A:;:B9 52> =2<>:;15@ 7:5>;1=C@4D 72?6:>1%
>125J !772??2H4>15@ 45>1%<9<>:? 64;>1:< ?49 4H26> <C7A <>;4>:@1:< =2;
34;12C< ;:4<25<a 6;4@?4>17 4H46>4>125E >2 LA17A 1H:2D2@174D 7A45@: A4<
52> 9:> =2DD2L:H <C1>E 2; <1?6D9 =2; >47>17<E L1>A >A: 41? 2= 47A1:315@ >A:
;:4DD9 1?62;>45> 62D1>174D @24D< >A;2C@A 525%725=;25>4>1254D ?:45< 2; 4> 4
D4>:; <>4@:J
#A:;: 4;: <:3:;4D :I4?6D:< 2= ,@7-.&' &%,-30@0,+5 7&$,-+0\ L1>A2C> 5:7:<%
<4;1D9 @215@ B47M >2 >A: >2>4D1>4;145 64;>1:< 2= >A: 15>:;%L4; 9:4;<E 25:
72CDH ?:5>125 >A: h;:57AE h1551<A 45H $>4D145 ,2??C51<> *4;>1:< 2= >A:
S;<> H:74H:< 2= >A: ,2DH U4;E >A: 5:2%=4<71<> $>4D145 &2714D )23:?:5>
Y)&$_E <2?: 74<:< 2= ;:D1@12C< =C5H4?:5>4D1<> =2;?4>125< 15 ?2;: ;:7:5>
9:4;<J (I4?6D:< 2= -$$+'+F&%, &%,-30@0,+5 7&$,-+0 4;: >A: !C<>;145 ,2??C51<>
*4;>9 YT*-n_E 45H >A: 8:D@145 ,2??C51<> *4;>9 Y*,8_E 47>13: b 45H 7:;>415D9
H1<6D4915@ 1H:2D2@174D 45>1%<9<>:?5:<< b =2; 4 D25@ >1?:E BC> 4DL49< >22 <?4DD
>2 A43: 4 <1@51S745> 15kC:57: 25 >A: 64;>9 <9<>:? ?:7A4517<J ,4<:< 2= 1;;:%
D:345> 45>1%<9<>:? 64;>1:< A4315@ <>;25@ D15M< L1>A 45>1%<9<>:? 4$"#70 4;: >A:
&155 h:15 15 >A: .T 45H K:;;1 84>4<C54 15 &6415 15 >A: D4<> H:74H:<E D15M:H
;:<6:7>13:D9 >2 >A: >:;;2;1<> =2;?4>125< 2= $+! 45H (#!J #A: 54>1254D 64;>9
<9<>:?< 2= >A:1; ;:<6:7>13: 72C5>;1:< A43: B::5 31;>C4DD9 C54==:7>:H 15 >A:1;
?:7A4517< B9 >A: :?:;@:57: 45H >A: <>;4>:@1:< 2= <C7A 64;>1:<E 9:> 1> 745
A4;HD9 B: ?415>415:H >A4> >A: 64;>1:< 15 WC:<>125 4;: 52> ;:D:345> =2; >A:
D1=: 2= >A: 8;1>1<A 45H &6451<A H:?27;4>17 <9<>:?<J #A: 0:;?45 :I>;:?:
;1@A>%L15@ "4>1254D V:?27;4>17 0:;?45 *4;>9 Y"*V_ 15 >A: NOPQ<E 45H 15
64;>17CD4; B:>L::5 NOPP 45H NOPOE A4H 4 D1?1>:H 15kC:57: 25 >A: 64;>9
<9<>:? ?:7A4517< H:<61>: 1>< 725<1H:;4BD: :D:7>2;4D <>;:5@>AJ ':> >A: 64;>9
1< 4DD BC> 1;;:D:345> =2; >A: <>CH1:< 25 :I>;:?: ;1@A>%L15@ >A;:4>< >2 H:?27%
;479 15 0:;?459J !54D2@2C< 725<1H:;4>125< 745 B: ?4H: =2; >A: :I>;:?:
;1@A>%L15@ 64;>1:< 2= >A: +:6CBD1M45:; 45H >A: 0:;?45 *:26D:G< .5125
YVj._ 15 D4>:; H:74H:<E 7:;>415D9 ?2;: ;:D:345> =2; >A:1; ;4?1S74>125< 45H
725>47>< L1>A 45>1%<9<>:? @;2C6< >A45 =2; >A:1; <A::; :D:7>2;4D <>;:5@>AJ
!< :I4?6D:< 2= &.."55"1&,-%4 &%,-30@0,+5 7&$,-+0 745 B: ?:5>125:H >A:
72??C51<> 64;>1:< >A4> 15 <:3:;4D 72C5>;1:< :5>:;:H 724D1>125< 4> 34;12C<
D:3:D<E LA1D: M::615@ 2;>A2H2I 1H:2D2@174D 62<1>125<J #A1< A466:5:HE =2;

Downloaded from http://jtp.sagepub.com at SWETS WISE ONLINE CONTENT on July 26, 2009
,!*-,,$!a !"#$%&'&#() *!+#$(& cO

15<>457:E HC;15@ >A: <:725H A4D= 2= >A: NO^Q<E L1>A >A: *26CD4; h;25> @23:;5%
?:5> 724D1>125< 15 h;457: 45H &6415J #A: h;:57A ,2??C51<> *4;>9 Y*,h_
745 B: 725<1H:;:H 4< 45 4772??2H4>15@ 45>1%<9<>:? 64;>9 4D<2 15 >A:
(1@A>1:<E LA:5 1> :5>:;:H 4 D:=>%L15@ @23:;5?:5> 724D1>125 Y)41;E NOOPa O^_J
#A: <4?: D4B:D 745 B: 466D1:H >2 >A: $>4D145 ,2??C51<> *4;>9 Y*,$_ 15 >A:
<:725H A4D= 2= >A: NORQ<E LA:5 1> 6C;<C:H >A: <>;4>:@9 2= :5>:;15@ 4 724D1>125
L1>A >A: @23:;515@ ,A;1<>145 V:?27;4><J !D>A2C@A >A1< <>;4>:@9E D4B:D:H
4< FA1<>2;174D 72?6;2?1<:GE 25D9 7257;:>1X:H 15 >A: ,2??C51<><G :I>:;54D
<C662;> >2 >A: @23:;5?:5>E >A: 7A45@: 15 >A: 724D1>125 <>;4>:@1:< 2= >A:
*,$ L4< 725<1H:;:H B9 h4;5:>1 4< A4315@ 4 ?4g2; 15kC:57: 25 >A: =C57>125%
15@ 2= >A: $>4D145 64;>9 <9<>:?E H:>:;?1515@ 1>< 7A45@: =;2? F62D4;1X:HG >2
F7:5>;16:>4DG 6DC;4D1<? Yh4;5:>1E NOZ^_Jcc !< :I4?6D:< 2= >A: <4?: M15H >A:
h1551<A 45H $7:D45H17 ,2??C51<> *4;>1:<E LA17A :5>:;:H @23:;5?:5> 72%
4D1>125< 15 >A: NOPQ< 45H NORQ< 745 B: ?:5>125:HJ UA1D: :47A 2= >A:<:
74<:< A4< 2B312C<D9 <2?: 6:7CD14;1>1:<E >A:9 4DD <A4;: 25: >;41>a >A: 1H:2D2@174D
72??1>?:5> >2 H:?27;479 2= >A:<: 64;>1:< L4< 3:;9 H2CB>=CDE BC> >A:1;
724D1>1254D 45H 6;264@45H4 <>;4>:@1:< H1H 52> 725>;1BC>:E 15 >A2<: 6A4<:<E
>2 >A: 62D4;1X4>125 2= >A: 64;>9 <9<>:? Y*CDX:;E NOZRa cQ_J
!< =4; 4< 7"'&$-6-%4 7&$,-+0 4;: 7257:;5:HE 464;> =;2? >A: 74<:< ?:5>125:H
B:=2;: 2= >A: $;1<A h14554 h4l1D B:=2;: NO^cE >A: V451<A *;2@;:<< *4;>9 15 >A:
NORQ< 45H >A: h;:57A 04CDD1<>< 15 >A: h2C;>A +:6CBD17E 2>A:; :I4?6D:<
745 B: =2C5HJ #A: $>4D145 ,2??C51<> +:=2C5H4>125 *4;>9 Y*+,_E LA17A
:?:;@:H 15 NOON =;2? 4 <6D1> 15 >A: ,2??C51<> *4;>9E 745 A4;HD9 B: 725%
<1H:;:H 4< 1H:2D2@174DD9 45>1%<9<>:?J ':>E >A: 64;>9 A4<E 15 @:5:;4DE B::5 H1<%
D294D 15 724D1>125<E A4< 52> ;:52C57:H 1>< :I>;:?1<> 6;264@45H4 45H A4< 6C>
>A: 7:5>:;%D:=> @23:;5?:5> 15 H1=S7CD>9 25 <:3:;4D 2774<125<E <2 >A4> 1> 745E
L1>A ;:4<25E B: 6:;7:13:H 4< 4 <:64;4>: F62D:G 15 >A: $>4D145 64;>9 <9<>:?J
+2C@AD9 >A: <4?: 745 B: <41H 2= >A: 0:;?45 *4;>9 2= V:?27;4>17 &2714D1<?
Y*V&_E LA17AE 4D>A2C@A 725<>45>D9 :I7DCH:H =;2? >A: 54>1254D @23:;5?:5>E
745 52 D25@:; B: 725<1H:;:H 4< 4 >;45<1:5> :D:?:5> 2= >A: 0:;?45 64;>9
<9<>:?E 4=>:; >A;:: :D:7>125< 15 LA17A 1> A4< 157;:4<15@D9 725<2D1H4>:H 1>< :D:7%
>2;4D <C662;>J $>< <A4;: 2= <:4>< 15 >A: 8C5H:<>4@ Y466;2I1?4>:D9 ] 6:;7:5>_E
15 =47>E ?4M:< D:=>%2=%>A:%7:5>:; 64;D14?:5>4;9 724D1>125< ?2;: H1=S7CD> 45H
>A: 7257:5>;4>125 2= 1>< <C662;> 15 >A: 622;:; :4<>:;5 ;:@125< YLA:;: 1>
2B>415< 4B2C> 25:%WC4;>:; 2= >A: 32>:<_ 7:;>415D9 ;:15=2;7:< 1>< BD47M?41D
62>:5>14D 31<%4o%31< >A: 64;>1:< 2= >A: ?2H:;4>: D:=>J )2;:23:;E 1= 25: 4H26><
4 ?151?4D H:S51>125 2= H:?27;479E >A: "2;L:@145 *;2@;:<< *4;>9 WC4D1S:<
4< 4 62D4;1X15@ 64;>9E 454D2@2C<D9 >2 1>< V451<A >L15J

ccJ K: ?4M:< :I6D171> ;:=:;:57: >2 >A: F6;2@;:<<13: H:?9<>1S74>125G 2= 6;264@45H1<>17 23:;%
6;2?1<15@ 15 >A: <4?: 9:4;< Yh4;5:>1E NOZ^a c^O_J

Downloaded from http://jtp.sagepub.com at SWETS WISE ONLINE CONTENT on July 26, 2009
^Q `-.+"!/ -h #K(-+(#$,!/ *-/$#$,& N[YN_

-%"(0'2)%"2

#A: ?415 @24D 2= >A1< 454D9<1< A4< B::5 >2 ;:725<>;C7> >A: 7257:6> 2= F45>1%
<9<>:?5:<<G 64;>17CD4;D9 15 ;:=:;:57: >2 62D1>174D 64;>1:<J #A: 7257:6> 2=
F45>1%<9<>:?G 64;>9 725>15C:< >2 <A2L 725<1H:;4BD: 1?62;>457: =2; >A: 454D9%
<1< 2= B2>A 64;>9 <9<>:?< 45H H:?27;4>17 ;:@1?:<J #A: 7257:6> L4< 7215:H 15
4 62D1>174D 725gC57>C;: 15 LA17A 64;>1:< >A4> :572C;4@:H 7:5>;1=C@4D H;13:< 15
>A: :D:7>2;4D 72?6:>1>125E 45H :I:;>:H 1;;:<625<1BD: 2662<1>125 Y&4;>2;1E
NORPa N[Q_ L:;: 4D<2 6;15716D:H 26625:5>< 2= H:?27;4>17 ;CD: >2C> 72C;>2
#A: L4515@ 2= >A: ?4g2; 45>1%H:?27;4>17 1H:2D2@1:<E A2L:3:;E A4< 52>
:D1?154>:H 6:; <: >A: :I1<>:57: 2= 62D4;1X:H 64;>9 <9<>:?<a 2>A:; =2;?< 2=
F6;15716D:H 2662<1>125G A43: 15 =47> :?:;@:HE LA17AE 4D>A2C@A 52> 4B1H15@
B9 459 7D:4;%7C> 45>1%H:?27;4>17 1H:2D2@9E A43: 15 =47> 4 ?4;M:H 62D4;1X15@
:==:7> 25 >A: 64;>9 <9<>:?< 2= >A:1; 72C5>;1:<J )2;:23:;E >A: ;:7:5> H1==C<125
2= H:?27;4>17 ;CD: >A;2C@A2C> >A: L2;DH A4< :52;?2C<D9 H13:;<1S:H >A:
;:4D1>9 2= H:?27;4>17 ;:@1?:<E <C7A >A4> 7:;>415 1H:2D2@174D 62<1>125< 4;:
D14BD: >2 @13: 157:5>13:< >2 62D4;1X15@ <>;4>:@1:< 15 7:;>415 >96:< 2= H:?27;4>17
62D1>1:< LA1D: 52> 15 2>A:;<J h47:H L1>A >A:<: H:3:D26?:5><E >A: 1?6D174>125<
2= >A: 7257:6> 2= 45>1%<9<>:?5:<< 5::H:H >2 B: 7D4;1S:HE 15 2;H:; 52> >2 D2<:
>A: 454D9>174D B:5:S>< 2= >A: 7257:6> 1><:D=J
#A: 72;5:;<>25: 2= >A: 7257:6>C4D ;:725<>;C7>125 74;;1:H 2C> 15 >A1< 4;>17D:
725<1<>< 2= >A: H1<:5>45@D:?:5> 2= >A: >L2 B4<17 =2;?< 2= F;:D4>1254DG 45H
F1H:2D2@174DG 45>1%<9<>:?5:<< 45H >A: 7D4;1S74>125 2= >A:1; 1?62;>457: =2;
72?64;4>13: 454D9<1< 2= 64;>9 <9<>:?< 45H H:?27;4>17 ;:@1?:< ;:<6:7>13:D9J
-5 >A: B4<1< 2= >A1< ;:725<>;C7>125E >A: =2DD2L15@ >A;:: 6215>< 745 B: C5H:;%
D15:Ha S;<>E 4 64;>9G< F;:D4>1254DG 45>1%<9<>:?5:<< 1< 52> @13:5 6:; <: B9 1><
1H:2D2@174D 7A4;47>:;E BC> ;4>A:; B9 1>< 1H:2D2@174D 1-((+$+%.+ =;2? >A: 2>A:;
64;>1:< 15 >A: <9<>:?J #AC<E 64;>1:< >A4> L2CDH 52> WC4D1=9 4< F45>1%
H:?27;4>17G 25 >A: B4<1< 2= 4 @13:5 H:S51>125 2= H:?27;479 745 4D<2 A43:
62D4;1X15@ :==:7>< 25 64;>9 <9<>:? ?:7A4517< 45H 745 >A:;:=2;: B: ;:D4>125%
4DD9 45>1%<9<>:?J #A: 7257:6> 2= F;:D4>1254D 45>1%<9<>:?5:<<G 745 B: C<:H >2
72?64;: >A: 724D1>125 45H 6;264@45H4 <>;4>:@1:< 2= 64;>1:< 47;2<< Y64;>9_
<9<>:?<E 4< L:DD 4< >A:1; :==:7>< 25 64;>9 <9<>:? ?:7A4517<J $> 1< 1?62;>45>
>2 A1@AD1@A> >A4>E 4< 4 725<:WC:57:E >A: :I1<>:57: 2= 62D4;1X4>125 45H 7:5>;1%
=C@4D 6;26:5<1>1:< 15 4 72C5>;9G< 64;>9 <9<>:? H2:< 52> ?:45 6:; <: >A4> >A:
H:?27;4>17 54>C;: 1><:D= 2= >A: ;:@1?: 1< 15 H45@:;J #A: 64;>9 <9<>:? ?49
<1?6D9 157DCH: 62D4;1X15@ 64;>1:< LA17A >A:?<:D3:< ?1@A> L:DD 4HA:;: >2
>A: ;:WC1;:?:5>< 2= >A: ?151?4D H:S51>125 2= H:?27;479J
,253:;<:D9E 45H >A1< 1< >A: <:725H 1?62;>45> 6215> >2 :?6A4<1X:E >A:
&E0+%.+ 2= 62D4;1X4>125 45H 7:5>;1=C@4D <9<>:?17 6;26:5<1>1:< 15 4 64;>9
<9<>:? 1< 52> 15 1><:D= 4 <C=S71:5> 725H1>125 >2 725<1H:; >A4> H:?27;479 4<
B:15@ L1>A2C> >A;:4><J #A: 7257:6>< 2= F1;;:D:345>G 45H F4772??2H4>15@G

Downloaded from http://jtp.sagepub.com at SWETS WISE ONLINE CONTENT on July 26, 2009
,!*-,,$!a !"#$%&'&#() *!+#$(& ^N

45>1%<9<>:? 64;>1:< 6215> :I47>D9 >2 4 <1>C4>125 15 LA17A ;:D4>13:D9 B1@ 45H
HC;4BD: 1H:2D2@174DD9 45>1%<9<>:? 64;>1:< 745 4H26> 7:5>;16:>4D >47>17<E 2;
<?4DD 45H Fk4<AG 1H:2D2@174D 45>1%<9<>:? 64;>1:< LA17A 4;: 157464BD: 2= 74C<%
15@ 62D4;1X4>125E 745 <>1DD 725<>1>C>: 4 ;:D:345> >A;:4> >2 H:?27;479J
hC;>A:;?2;:E >A: 7257:6>C4D ;:725<>;C7>125 2= 1H:2D2@174D 45>1%<9<>:?5:<<
H;4L< 4>>:5>125 >2 >A: =47> >A4> >A: 62<<1B1D1>9 2= 4 72?64;4>13: C<4@: 2= >A:
D4B:D 15 WC:<>125 H:6:5H< 25 >A: D:3:D 2= @:5:;4D1>9 4> LA17A >A: 7257:6> 2=
F<9<>:?G 1< ;:725<>;C7>:HJ $5 64;>17CD4;E >A: ;:725<>;C7>125 2= F<9<>:?G 4>
D2L:; D:3:D< 2= 4B<>;47>125E B4<:H 25 ?2;:%>A45%?151?4D H:S51>125< 2=
H:?27;479E 4DD2L< 15 6;15716D: 4 A1@A:; 5C?B:; 2= 64;>1:< >2 B: 725<1H:;:H
4< 1H:2D2@174DD9 45>1%<9<>:? >A45 L2CDH B: >A: 74<: 1= >A: 7257:6> 2= <9<>:?
L:;: ;:725<>;C7>:H 4> A1@A:; D:3:D< 2= 4B<>;47>125J K2L:3:;E <C7A :5;17A:H
H:S51>125< 2= <9<>:? 4C>2?4>174DD9 725S5: >A: <726: 2= >A: 72?64;1<25 >2
4 D2L:; 5C?B:; 2= 72C5>;1:<J $5 72?64;4>13: 454D9<:<E >A:;:=2;:E >A: 7257:6>
2= 1H:2D2@174D 45>1%<9<>:?5:<< <A2CDH 25D9 B: ;:=:;;:H >2 >A2<: 64;>1:< 47>13:
15 >A: 62D1>1:< <:1X:H B9 4 7:;>415 H:S51>125 2= F<9<>:?GE LA17A <:>< >A: B2C5H%
4;1:< 2= >A: 72?64;1<25J #A1< <>;4>:@9 :54BD:< >A: 61>=4DD 2= 7257:6>C4D
<>;:>7A15@ >2 B: 4321H:HJ
#A: H1<>157>125 B:>L::5 >A: >L2 =2;?< 2= 45>1%<9<>:?5:<<E 45H >A: H1==:;%
:5> >96:< 2= 45>1%<9<>:? 64;>1:<E 745 B: C<:H 15 <:3:;4D L49< 15 72?64;4>13:
454D9<1<J #A: >962D2@9 2= h1@C;: NJ 745 <:;3: 4< 4 F7257:6>C4D ?46G =2;
<957A;2517 72?64;1<25< 2= >A: 45>1%<9<>:?17 1?647> 2= <6:71S7 =4?1D1:< 2=
64;>1:<E <C7A 4< >A2<: 2= F62<>%72??C51<> 64;>1:<G 45H F5:L :I>;:?: ;1@A>%
L15@ 64;>1:<GE LA17A A43: ;:7:5>D9 H;4L5 >A: 4>>:5>125 2= ?459 72?64;4%
>131<>< Y:J@J $@54X1E NOOcE NOO[\ 8CDD 45H K:9L22HE NOO[\ )CHH:E NOO]E
NOOPE cQQQ\ 82X2M1E NOOR\ $<A194?4E NOOR\ <:: 4D<2 325 8:9?:E NOZZ_J #A:
6;:D1?154;9 7D4;1S74>125 2= 4 <6:71S7 H:S51>125 2= H:?27;479 L2CDH A43:
>2 <:> >A: <64>14Db>:?62;4D B2C5H4;1:< 2= >A: 72?64;1<25E 45H L2CDH 4DD2L
>A: 7D4<<1S74>125 2= >A: 34;12C< 64;>1:< 4772;H15@ >2 >A:1; 1H:2D2@174D 7A4;47%
>:;E LA1D: >A:1; 1?647> 25 64;>9 <9<>:? ?:7A4517< 72CDH 4D<2 B: 7A4;>:H 4> >A:
<4?: >1?:J #A: >962D2@9 745 4D<2 B: C<:H 15 H147A;2517 72?64;1<25<E L1>A
>A: 41? 2= ?251>2;15@ >A: :32DC>125 2= 64;>1:< D274>:H 4> >A: :I>;:?:< 2= 4
64;>17CD4; 62D1>174D <647: 15 25: 2; ?2;: 72C5>;1:< 23:; 4 @13:5 6:;12HJ
,A45@:< >2L4;H< 45 477:6>457: 2= H:?27;4>17 34DC:< 15 >A: 1H:2D2@9 2=
>A:<: :I>;:?: 64;>1:< L1DD 74C<: >A:? >2 F?23:G =;2? >A: C66:; >2 >A:
D2L:; ;2L 15 >A: >962D2@9J UA:5 4DD 64;>1:< 15 4 @13:5 <64>14D C51> A43: 4B45%
H25:H >A:1; 1H:2D2@174D 45>1%<9<>:?5:<<E >A1< 72CDH B: 45 15H174>125 >A4>
H:?27;479 A4< B:72?: F>A: 25D9 @4?: 15 >2L5G 45H 745 B: <::5 4< 4 <1@5
2= H:?27;4>17 725<2D1H4>125 Y/15X 45H &>:645E NOOPa P_ 2; @23:;5?:5>
<>4B1D1>9 Y#49D2; 45H K:;?45E NORN_E =2; :I4?6D:J !54D2@2C<D9E >A: <>4BD:
4H26>125 2= 7:5>;16:>4D <>;4>:@1:< L1DD 74C<: 4 64;>9 >2 F?23:G =;2? >A:
;1@A>% >2 >A: D:=>%A45H 72DC?5 2= >A: >962D2@9J ! @:5:;4D1X:H ?23:?:5> 2=

Downloaded from http://jtp.sagepub.com at SWETS WISE ONLINE CONTENT on July 26, 2009
^c `-.+"!/ -h #K(-+(#$,!/ *-/$#$,& N[YN_

>A1< M15H L2CDH B: 4> >A: B4<1< 2= >A: F23:;7;2LH15@G 2= >A: >96: 2= ?2H:;4>:
6DC;4D1<? 15 &4;>2;1G< >962D2@9 2= 64;>9 <9<>:?<E LA17A )41; A4< ;:7:5>D9
C5H:;D15:H Y)41;E NOOPa ZZ_J
$5 7257DC<125E >A: ;:7:5> 45H 157;:4<15@ H1==C<125 45H H1==:;:5>14>125 2=
H:?27;4>17 <9<>:?< 74DD< =2; >A: 4H26>125 2= ?2;: ;:S5:H 7257:6>< >A4>
745 B: C<:H 15 72?64;1<25< 47;2<< H1==:;:5> <:>>15@< 45H 6:;12H<J $5 >A:
4>>:?6> >2 7257:6>C4D1X: >A: 7A45@:< >A4> ;4H174D =2;?< 2= 2662<1>125 15
H:?27;471:< A43: C5H:;@25: ;:7:5>D9E >A: <>;4>:@9 ?2<> 72??25D9 =2DD2L:H
B9 <7A2D4;< A4< B::5 >A4> 2= 7;:4>15@ 5:L F45>1%G >:;?<E 2=>:5 4H A27 45H
L1>A2C> <6:71=915@ >A: D2@174D 725<:WC:57:< 2= >A:1; 466D174>125 >2 H1==:;:5>
74<:<J $5<>:4H 2= ;C5515@ >A: ;1<M 2= F4HH15@E 4> B:<>E 6;2=C<125 >2 725=C<125G
Y&4;>2;1E NOZ[4a ]Q_E >A1< 4;>17D: A4< =2DD2L:H 4 H1==:;:5> 45H A26:=CDD9 ?2;:
=;C1>=CD L49 2= 6;27::H15@a >A4> 2= ;:725<>;C7>15@ >A: F2DHG 7257:6> 2= 45>1%
<9<>:? 64;>9E 15<>:4H 2= <1?6D9 ;:54?15@ 1>E 45H 2= 7D4;1=915@ 1>< 1?6D174>125<
45H >A: 62<<1B1D1>1:< 2= 1>< 72?64;4>13: C<4@: 4=>:; >A: 5:L:; H:3:D26?:5><E
15 2;H:; 52> >2 D2<: 1>< 1?62;>45> B:5:S>< =2; >A: 454D9<1< 2= H:?27;4>17
62D1>174D <9<>:?<J

1CFC1CG-C@
8::>A4?E V431H YNOOO_ :+5".$&.@ &%1 I#5&% C-4*,02 ,4?B;1H@:E .T 45H )4DH:5E )!a *2D1>9
*;:<<J
81DD:E /4;< YNOOQ_ FV:5?4;Ma #A: -<71DD4>15@ *4;>9 &9<>:?GE 15 *:>:; )41; 45H 02;H25 &?1>A
Y:H<_ J%1+$0,&%1-%4 /&$,@ A@0,+5 >*&%4+ -% K+0,+$% L#$"7+E 66J [cb]ZJ /25H25a h;45M ,4<<J
82X2M1E !5H;4< YNOOR_ F#A: $H:2D2@9 2= )2H:;51X4>125 45H >A: *2D179 2= )4>:;14D1<?a #A: V49
4=>:; =2; >A: &2714D1<><GE !"#$%&' "( >"55#%-0, A,#1-+0 &%1 )$&%0-,-"% /"'-,-.0 N^a ]PbNQcJ
8CH@:E $45 45H j4D:5>15: K:;?45 YNORZ_ F,24D1>125< 45H 023:;5?:5> h2;?4>125a !5 (?61;1%
74DD9 +:D:345> #A:2;9GE ;$-,-0* !"#$%&' "( /"'-,-.&' A.-+%.+ Za []ObRRJ
8CDDE )J`J 45H *J K:9L22H Y:H<_ YNOO[_ K+0, L#$"7+&% >"55#%-0, /&$,-+0 &(,+$ ,*+ C+F"'#,-"%0
"( MNONJ /25H25a )47?1DD45J
,2DD1:;E V431H 45H +2B:;> !H727M YNOOO_ FV:?27;479 45H V17A2>2?1:<J ! *;4@?4>17 !66;247A
>2 ,A217:< 4B2C> ,257:6><GE D%%#&' C+F-+8 "( /"'-,-.&' A.-+%.+ ca ]^RbP]J
,2DD1:;E V431H 45H `4?:< (J )4A25 `; YNOO^_ F,257:6>C4D FF&>;:>7A15@GG +:31<1>:Ha !H46>15@
,4>:@2;1:< 15 ,2?64;4>13: !54D9<1<GE D5+$-.&% /"'-,-.&' A.-+%.+ C+F-+8 ZRa Z[]b]]J
,2DD1:;E V431H 45H &>:3:5 /:31><M9 YNOOR_ FV:?27;479 L1>A !Hg:7>13:<J ,257:6>C4D $55234>125
15 ,2?64;4>13: +:<:4;7AGE K"$'1 /"'-,-.0 [Oa [^Qb]NJ
V44DH:;E K45< YNOPP4_ F*4;>1:<E (D1>:< 45H *2D1>174D V:3:D26?:5>< 15 U:<>:;5 (C;26:GE 15 `2<:6A
0J /4 *4D2?B4;4 45H )9;25 U:15:; Y:H<_ /"'-,-.&' /&$,-+0 &%1 /"'-,-.&' :+F+'"75+%,E 66J [^b
RZJ *;157:>25E "`a *;157:>25 .513:;<1>9 *;:<<J
V44DH:;E K45< YNOPPB_ F#A: ":>A:;D45H<a -662<1>125 15 4 &:@?:5>:H &271:>9GE 15 +2B:;> !J
V4AD Y:HJ_ /"'-,-.&' P77"0-,-"%0 -% K+0,+$% :+5".$&.-+0E 66J NZZbc^PJ ":L K43:5E ,# 45H
/25H25a '4D: .513:;<1>9 *;:<<J
V44DH:;E K45< YNOZ[_ F$5 &:4;7A =2; >A: ,:5>:; 2= (C;26:45 *4;>9 &9<>:?<GE D5+$-.&% /"'-,-.&'
A.-+%.+ C+F-+8 RZa OcbNQOJ
V4ADE +2B:;> !J Y:HJ_ YNOPP_ /"'-,-.&' P77"0-,-"%0 -% K+0,+$% :+5".$&.-+0J ":L K43:5E ,#a
'4D: .513:;<1>9 *;:<<J

Downloaded from http://jtp.sagepub.com at SWETS WISE ONLINE CONTENT on July 26, 2009
,!*-,,$!a !"#$%&'&#() *!+#$(& ^^

V4ADE +2B:;> !J YNOZc_ :-'+55&0 "( /'#$&'-0, :+5".$&.@2 D#,"%"5@ F02 >"%,$"'J ":L K43:5E
,# 45H /25H25a '4D: .513:;<1>9 *;:<<J
V:L47A>:;E U1D=;1:H YNOZR_ F,A45@:< 15 4 *4;>17;4>1:a #A: 8:D@145 *4;>9 &9<>:? =;2? NO[[ >2
NOZPGE 15 K45< V44DH:; Y:HJ_ /&$,@ A@0,+50 -% :+%5&$H= D#0,$-&= A8-,6+$'&%1= )*+ Q+,*+$'&%10=
&%1 ;+'4-#5E 66J cZ]b^P[J /25H25a *15>:;J
V1 *4D?4E 01C<:66: YNORR_ A#$F-F-%4 K-,*"#, R"F+$%-%42 )*+ 9,&'-&% /&$,-+0 -% /&$'-&5+%,J
8:;M:D:9E ,!a .513:;<1>9 2= ,4D1=2;514 *;:<<J
V1 *4D?4E 01C<:66: YNOOQ_ )" >$&(, :+5".$&.-+0J 8:;M:D:9E ,!a .513:;<1>9 2= ,4D1=2;514 *;:<<J
VC3:;@:;E )4C;17: YNO]N_ S+0 7&$,-0 7"'-,-?#+0J *4;1<a ,2D15J
h4;5:>1E *42D2 YNOZ^_ 9' 0-0,+5& 1+- 7&$,-,- -% 9,&'-& MNTUVMNWNJ 82D2@54a $D )CD152J
h:55:?4E ):15H:;> YNOOR_ F&2?: ,257:6>C4D $<<C:< 45H *;2BD:?< 15 >A: ,2?64;1<25< 2= !5>1%
1??1@;45> *4;>1:< 15 U:<>:;5 (C;26:GE /&$,@ /"'-,-.0 ^a [R^bOcJ
h:;;4;:<1E h;4572 YNOZZ_ F#A: +4H174D +1@A> 15 *2<>L4; $>4D9GE /"'-,-.0 &%1 A".-+,@ NPa RNbNNOJ
04DD1:E UJ0J YNO]P_ F(<<:5>14DD9 ,25>:<>:H ,257:6><GE /$".++1-%40 "( ,*+ D$-0,",+'-&% A".-+,@
]Pa NPRbOZJ
0:;;15@E `2A5 YNOOZ_ /&$,@ 91+"'"4-+0 -% D5+$-.& MOXOVMNNUJ ,4?B;1H@:E ,4?B;1H@: .513:;<1>9
*;:<<J
0:;;15@E `2A5 YNOOO_ FUA4> )4M:< 4 ,257:6> 022Hm ! ,;1>:;14D h;4?:L2;M =2; .5H:;<>45H15@
,257:6> h2;?4>125 15 >A: &2714D &71:57:<GE /"'-,@ ^a ^]RbO^J
K45<25E &>:6A:5 (J YNOOZ_ F$H:2D2@9E .57:;>415>9 45H >A: +1<: 2= !5>1%<9<>:? *4;>1:< 15 *2<>%
,2??C51<> +C<<14GE !"#$%&' "( >"55#%-0, A,#1-+0 &%1 )$&%0-,-"% /"'-,-.0 N[a OZbNcRJ
KC5>15@>25E &4?C:D *J YNOON_ )*+ )*-$1 K&F+2 :+5".$&,-6&,-"% -% ,*+ S&,+ )8+%,-+,* >+%,#$@2
"2;?45a .513:;<1>9 2= -MD4A2?4 *;:<<J
$@54X1E *1:;2 YNOOc_ F#A: &1D:5> ,2C5>:;;:32DC>125 b K962>A:<:< 25 >A: (?:;@:57: 2= (I>;:?:
+1@A>%U15@ *4;>1:< 15 (C;26:GE L#$"7+&% !"#$%&' "( /"'-,-.&' C+0+&$.* cca ^b^[J
$@54X1E *1:;2 YNOO[_ SY +0,$+5& 1+0,$& -% L#$"7&2 82D2@54a $D )CD152J
$25:<7CE 0A1>4 45H $<4B:D H: )4H4;14@4 YNOPZ_ P77"0-,-"%2 /&0, &%1 /$+0+%, "( & /"'-,-.&' 9%0,-3
,#,-"%J /25H25a U4>><J
$<A194?4E `2A5 #J YNOOR_ F#A: &17MD: 2; >A: +2<:m *;:312C< +:@1?: #96:< 45H >A: (32DC>125 2=
>A: (I%,2??C51<> *4;>1:< 15 *2<>%,2??C51<> *2D1>1:<GE >"57&$&,-F+ /"'-,-.&' A,#1-+0
^Qa cOOb^^QJ
T4>XE +17A4;H YNOOP_ F*4;>9 -;@451X4>125 45H h15457:GE 15 /4L;:57: /:VC7E +17A4;H ":1?1 45H
*1664 "2;;1< Y:H<_ >"57&$-%4 :+5".$&.-+0E 66J NQRb^^J #A2C<45H -4M<a &4@:J
T:;:5E )17A4:D YcQQQ_ F*2D1>174D *:;=:7>1251<? 45H >A: FF!5>1%<9<>:?GG *4;>9GE /&$,@ /"'-,-.0
Pa NQRbNPJ
T1;7AA:1?:;E ->>2 YNOPP4_ F0:;?459a #A: j451<A15@ -662<1>125GE 15 +2B:;> !J V4AD Y:HJ_
/"'-,-.&' P77"0-,-"%0 -% K+0,+$% :+5".$&.-+0E 66J c^Rb]OJ ":L K43:5E ,# 45H /25H25a
'4D: .513:;<1>9 *;:<<J
T1;7AA:1?:;E ->>2 YNOPPB_ F#A: #;45<=2;?4>125 2= U:<>:;5 (C;26:45 *4;>9 &9<>:?<GE 15 `2<:6A
/4 *4D2?B4;4 45H )9;25 U:15:; Y:H<_ /"'-,-.&' /&$,-+0 &%1 /"'-,-.&' :+F+'"75+%,E 66J NRRb
cQQJ *;157:>25E "`a *;157:>25 .513:;<1>9 *;:<<J
/4M2==E 0:2;@: YNOZR_ K"5+%= G-$+ &%1 :&%4+$"#0 )*-%402 K*&, >&,+4"$-+0 C+F+&' &E"#, ,*+
B-%1J ,A174@2 45H /25H25a #A: .513:;<1>9 2= ,A174@2 *;:<<J
/:L1<E *4CD 0J YNOOR_ F#A: +:62<1>12515@ 2= -662<1>125 15 (4<>%,:5>;4D (C;26:GE R"F+$%5+%,
&%1 P77"0-,-"% ^ca PN[b^QJ
/1:B:;?45E 8:5 YNOOZ_ F#A: ):4515@< 45H hC57>125 2= !5>1%<9<>:? $H:2D2@9 15 >A: U:1?4;
+:6CBD17 F= !"#$%&' "( ,*+ I-0,"$@ "( 91+&0 ]Oa ^]]bRPJ
/15XE `C45 `J YNORZ_ F,;1<1<E 8;:4MH2L5 45H +::WC1D1B;4>125GE 15 `C45 `J /15X 45H !D=;:H &>:645
Y:H<_ )*+ ;$+&H1"8% "( :+5".$&,-. C+4-5+0E 66J ^bNc[J 84D>1?2;:E )VE 45H /25H25a `2A5<
K26M15< .513:;<1>9 *;:<<J

Downloaded from http://jtp.sagepub.com at SWETS WISE ONLINE CONTENT on July 26, 2009
^[ `-.+"!/ -h #K(-+(#$,!/ *-/$#$,& N[YN_

/15XE `C45 `J 45H !D=;:H &>:645 YNOOP_ /$"E'+50 "( :+5".$&,-. )$&%0-,-"% &%1 >"%0"'-1&,-"%J
84D>1?2;:E )Va `2A5< K26M15<J
)47+4:E VC5745 YNOPR_ /&$'-&5+%,= /&$,-+0 &%1 A".-+,@ -% G$&%.+ MNTUVMNZOJ ":L '2;Ma
&> )4;>15G< *;:<<J
)41;E *:>:; YNORO_ F#A: !C>252?9 2= >A: *2D1>174Da #A: V:3:D26?:5> 2= >A: $;1<A *4;>9 &9<>:?GE
>"57&$&,-F+ /"'-,-.0 NNa [[]bPPJ
)41;E *:>:; YNOOP_ F*4;>9 &9<>:?< 45H &>;C7>C;:< 2= ,2?6:>1>125GE 15 /4L;:57: /:VC7E +17A4;H
":1?1 45H *1664 "2;;1< Y:H<_ >"57&$-%4 :+5".$&.-+0E 66J Z^bNQ]J #A2C<45H -4M<a &4@:J
)25>:;2E `C45 +J YNOO]_ F&2B;: D4< 6;:=:;:5714< :D:7>2;4D:< :5 (<645p4J h;4@?:5>4712l5 9 62D4;%
1X4712l5 YNORRbNOO^_GE 15 *1D4; H:D ,4<>1DD2 Y:HJ_ >"57"$,&5-+%," 7"'[\,-." @ +'+.,"$&'E 66J ]Nb
Nc[J )4H;1Ha ,$&J
)CHH:E ,4< YNOO]_ F+1@A>%U15@ (I>;:?1<? !54D9X:H b ! ,2?64;4>13:%!54D9<1< 2= >A: $H:2D2%
@1:< 2= #A;:: !DD:@:H +1@A>%U15@ (I>;:?1<> *4;>1:< Y"6HE "H6E ,6ZP_GE L#$"7+&% !"#$%&' "(
/"'-,-.&' C+0+&$.* cRa cQ^bc[J
)CHH:E ,4< YNOOP_ F#A: U4; 2= U2;H<J V:S515@ >A: (I>;:?: +1@A> *4;>9 h4?1D9GE K+0,
L#$"7+&% /"'-,-.0 NOa cc]b[ZJ
)CHH:E ,4< YcQQQ_ )*+ 91+"'"4@ "( ,*+ L],$+5+ C-4*,J )457A:<>:; 45H ":L '2;Ma )457A:<>:;
.513:;<1>9 *;:<<J
)CDD:;E (HL4;H "JE #A2?4< -J `CM4? 45H )1>7A:DD !J &:D1@<25 YNOZc_ FV1==C<: *2D1>174D
&C662;> 45H !5>1<9<>:? *2D1>174D 8:A4312;a ! ,2?64;4>13: !54D9<1<GE D5+$-.&% !"#$%&' "(
/"'-,-.&' A.-+%.+ cPa c[QbP[J
":>>DE `2A5 *J YNOPZ_ F#A: &>4>: 4< 4 ,257:6>C4D j4;14BD:GE K"$'1 /"'-,-.0 NPa ]]ObOcJ
-;26:X4E !5@:D )J YNOOZ_ F(D FF725SH:57: @46GGa C5 15<C?2 6<172%62D1>172 64;4 D4 :<>4B1D1H4H H:D
<1<>:?4 H:?27;4>172 3:5:X2D452GE >#+0,-"%+0 7"'-,-.&0 cQa [NbPZJ
*47:E !D:<<45H;2 YNOOR_ F/2< 6;27:<2< 725<>1>C9:5>:< 1>4D1452< YNOOPbNOOR_GE >#&1+$%"0 ."%0,-3
,#.-"%&'+0 cQbcNa ]bc]J
*2DD47ME 8:559 45H `:45 0;C:@:D YNOZR_ F-662<1>125 15 ,25>:?62;4;9 &6415a #;4H1>125 4@415<>
)2H:;51>9GE 15 (34 T2D15<M9 Y:HJ_ P77"0-,-"% -% K+0,+$% L#$"7+E 66J c^[bP^J /25H25a ,;22?
K:D?J
*;1HA4?E 0:2==;:9 YNOZR_ F-662<1>125 15 $>4D9a h;2? *2D4;1X:H *DC;4D1<? >2 ,:5>;16:>4D *DC;4D%
1<?GE 15 (34 T2D15<M9 Y:HJ_ P77"0-,-"% -% K+0,+$% L#$"7+E 66J NPObcNNJ /25H25a ,;22? K:D?J
*CDX:;E *:>:; YNOZR_ F$< #A:;: /1=: 4=>:; V4ADmGE 15 (34 T2D15<M9 Y:HJ_ P77"0-,-"% -% K+0,+$%
L#$"7+E 66J NQb^QJ /25H25a ,;22? K:D?J
+2B:;><E KC@A YNOOc_ F#A: !D@:;145 &>4>: 45H >A: ,A4DD:5@: 2= V:?27;479GE R"F+$%5+%, &%1
P77"0-,-"%E [a [^^b][J
&417AE #259 YNOOQ_ F#A: ,A15:<: ,2??C51<> *4;>9 45H >A: hC>C;:G= >*-%& 9%("$5&,-"% [a N]b^QJ
&451E 01472?2 45H 01234551 &4;>2;1 YNOZ^_ F*2D4;1X4>125E h;4@?:5>4>125 45H ,2?6:>1>125 15
U:<>:;5 V:?27;471:<GE 15 K45< V44DH:; 45H *:>:; )41; Y:H<_ K+0,+$% L#$"7+&% 7&$,@
0@0,+502 >"%,-%#-,@ &%1 >*&%4+E 66J ^QRb[QJ 8:3:;D9 K1DD<E ,!a &4@:J
&4;>2;1E 01234551 YNO]R_ :+5".$&6-& + 1+^%-6-"%-J 82D2@54a $D )CD152J
&4;>2;1E 01234551 YNOP^_ FV23: 34 1D *4;D4?:5>2mGE 15 01234551 &4;>2;1 :> 4DJ Y:H<_ 9' /&$'&5+%,"
9,&'-&%" MNTUVMNU_2 "46D:<a (&$J
&4;>2;1E 01234551 YNOPP_ F(C;26:45 *2D1>174D *4;>1:<a #A: ,4<: 2= *2D4;1X:H *DC;4D1<?GE 15 `2<:6A
/4 *4D2?B4;4 45H )9;25 U:15:; Y:H<_ /"'-,-.&' /&$,-+0 &%1 /"'-,-.&' :+F+'"75+%,E 66J N^Rb
RPJ *;157:>25E "`a *;157:>25 .513:;<1>9 *;:<<J
&4;>2;1E 01234551 YNORQ4_ F,257:6> )1<=2;?4>125 15 ,2?64;4>13: *2D1>17<GE D5+$-.&% /"'-,-.&'
A.-+%.+ C+F-+8 P[a NQ^^b]^J
&4;>2;1E 01234551 YNORQB_ F#A: #962D2@9 2= *4;>9 &9<>:?< b *;262<4D< =2; $?6;23:?:5>GE 15
(;1M !DD4;H> 45H &>:15 +2MM45 Y:H<_ B&00 /"'-,-.02 A,#1-+0 -% /"'-,-.&' A".-"'"4@E 66J ^ccb
]cJ ":L '2;M 45H /25H25E h;:: *;:<< q ,2DD1:;%)47?1DD45J
&4;>2;1E 01234551 YNORP_ /&$,-+0 &%1 /&$,@ A@0,+50J ,4?B;1H@:a ,4?B;1H@: .513:;<1>9 *;:<<J

Downloaded from http://jtp.sagepub.com at SWETS WISE ONLINE CONTENT on July 26, 2009
,!*-,,$!a !"#$%&'&#() *!+#$(& ^]

&4;>2;1E 01234551 YNOZc_ )+"$-& 1+- 7&$,-,- + .&0" -,&'-&%"J )1D45a &C@4;,2J
&4;>2;1E 01234551 YNOZ[4_ F0C1H:D15:< =2; ,257:6> !54D9<1<GE 15 01234551 &4;>2;1 Y:HJ_ A".-&'
A.-+%.+ >"%.+7,0E 66J N]bZZJ 8:3:;D9 K1DD<E ,!Ja &4@:J
&4;>2;1E 01234551 YNOZ[B_ F*DC;4D1<?2 62D4;1XX4>2 : 15>:;6;:>4X1251 1?6:;=:>>:GE 9' B#'-%"
^^a PR[bZQJ
&4;>2;1E 01234551 YNOON_ F,2?64;15@ 45H )1<72?64;15@GE !"#$%&' "( )*+"$+,-.&' /"'-,-.0 ^a c[^b
]RJ
&4;>2;1E 01234551 YNOOR_ >"57&$&,-F+ >"%0,-,#,-"%&' L%4-%++$-%42 /25H25a )47?1DD45J
&4;>2;1E 01234551E h;:H UJ +1@@< 45H K:5;9 #:C5: YNOR]_ )"8+$ "( ;&E+'2 P% ,*+ :+^%-,-"% &%1
D%&'@0-0 "( >"%.+7,0 -% ,*+ A".-&' A.-+%.+0J *1>><BC;@AE *!a $5>:;54>1254D &>CH1:< !<<2714>125J
&7A:HD:;E !5H;:4< YNOOP_ F!5>1%62D1>174D (<>4BD1<A?:5> *4;>1:<GE /&$,@ /"'-,-.0 ca cONb^NcJ
&7A?1H>E )45=;:H 0J YNOOR_ :+5"H$&,-+,*+"$-+%2 L-%+ L-%(#̀*$#%4J -6D4H:5a /:<M: q 8CH;17AJ
&7A?1>>:;E *A1D166: YcQQQ_ F(<<4915@ >A: ,25<2D1H4>125 2= V:?27;479GE )1?:2E (C;26:45
.513:;<1>9 $5<>1>C>:E hD2;:57:J
&7A?1>>:;E *A1D166: 45H #:;;9 /J T4;D YNOON_ FUA4> V:?27;479 $< J J J 45H UA4> $< "2>GE !"#$%&'
"( :+5".$&.@ ca R]bZZJ
&?1>AE 02;H25 YNOZR_ F*4;>9 45H *;2>:<>a #A: #L2 h47:< 2= -662<1>125 15 U:<>:;5 (C;26:GE 15
(34 T2D15<M9 Y:HJ_ P77"0-,-"% -% K+0,+$% L#$"7+E 66J ]cbRPJ /25H25a ,;22? K:D?J
&>43:5A4@:5E +2H2D=2 YNOON_ FKC?45 +1@A><E V:?27;479 45H V:3:D26?:5> 15 /4>15 !?:;174GE
L."%"5-. &%1 9%1#0,$-&' :+5".$&.@ Nca ^Nb[NJ
#49D2;E )17A4:D 45H j4D:5>15: K:;?45 YNORN_ F*4;>9 &9<>:?< 45H 023:;5?:5> &>4B1D1>9GE
D5+$-.&% /"'-,-.&' A.-+%.+ C+F-+8 P]a cZb^RJ
#2<1E &1D3452 YNOPP_ F$>4D9a !5>1%<9<>:? -662<1>125 U1>A15 >A: &9<>:?GE R"F+$%5+%, &%1
P77"0-,-"% Na [ObPcJ
325 8:9?: TD4C< YNOZ]_ /"'-,-.&' /&$,-+0 -% K+0,+$% :+5".$&.-+0J !DH:;<A2>a 02L:;J
325 8:9?:E TD4C< Y:HJ_ YNOZZ_ C-4*,3K-%4 L],$+5-05 -% K+0,+$% L#$"7+J /25H25a h;45M ,4<<J
U:DX:DE ,A;1<>145 YNOO]_ FV:; .?B;C7A H:< &(V%+:@1?:< 1? /17A>: @:5:;:DD:; #;45<1>125<%
?:7A451<?:5GE /"'-,-0.*+ <-+$,+'a&*$+00.*$-(,+% ^Pa PRbOQJ
U1DD14?<E *A1D16 )J YNORN_ S& F-+ 7"'-,-?#+ 0"#0 '& T+5+ C+7#E'-?#+J *4;1<a ,2D15J
i1??:;?455E (MM4;> YNOZO_ F*2D1>174D .5;:<> 15 (C;26:a #;:5H< 45H *;2<6:7><GE K+0, L#$"7+&%
/"'-,-.0 Nca NRObOPJ

0$-j!""$ ,!*-,,$! 1< h:DD2L 15 *2D1>17< 4> )4@H:D:5 ,2DD:@: 45H 4


D:7>C;:; 15 62D1>17< 45H $5>:;54>1254D ;:D4>125< 4> >A: .513:;<1>9 2= -I=2;HJ
K1< 6CBD174>125< 157DCH: S& R+$5&%-&b & #%-,& ($& >"%,-%#-,&c + $-%%"F&5+%,"2
A@0,+5" +'+,,"$&'+ + 0-0,+50 /&$,-,-.& %+' /$".+00" 1- $-#%-^.&6-"%+ ,+1+0."
Y+2?: NOO]_ 45H <:3:;4D 4;>17D:<J K1< ?415 ;:<:4;7A 15>:;:<>< 4;: 15 72?%
64;4>13: (C;26:45 62D1>17< 45H >A: ?:>A2H2D2@9 2= 72?64;4>13: ;:<:4;7AJ
!VV+(&&a )4@H:D:5 ,2DD:@:E -I=2;H -rN [!.E .T d:?41Da @1234551J
74627714s?4@HJ2IJ47JCMf

Downloaded from http://jtp.sagepub.com at SWETS WISE ONLINE CONTENT on July 26, 2009

You might also like