Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Abstract: It was found from field surveys that suspension bridge cables were under severe corrosion environments due to the water and
high temperature inside the cable. Corrosion environments depended on the wire positions inside the cables. Wires were found to be
Downloaded from ascelibrary.org by New York University on 05/18/15. Copyright ASCE. For personal use only; all rights reserved.
continuously wet at the side, wet at night and dry during the day on the top, highly humid at the center, and soaked in the water at the
bottom. Accelerated corrosion tests using galvanized steel wires showed that the side wires were most severely corroded, the bottom wires
were also significantly corroded, but the upper and the center wires were rarely corroded. These phenomena agreed with the actual cable
corrosion. The tests also showed that galvanized steel wires did not corrode when they were kept with a relative humidity below 60%, but
became corrosive with the higher relative humidity. Larger amounts of sodium chloride increased corrosion considerably. The corrosion
rate also exponentially increased with temperature. It was predicted that the zinc layer would be consumed within 10 years when wires
were kept in the wet or soaked environments, 34 years with a relative humidity of 100%, and 211 years with a relative humidity below
60%.
DOI: 10.1061/共ASCE兲0899-1561共2004兲16:1共1兲
CE Database subject headings: Steel cables; Corrosion; Bridges, suspension; Bridge maintenance; Zinc.
Introduction cable surface was smooth with a better waterproof property. The
model cables with this new wrapping system and with the con-
There are many old suspension bridges in the U.S. and some of ventional corrosion resistant system were exposed near the sea-
them suffer deteriorated cables. Steel wires in the bridge cables shore for 4 years. Water was poured into the specimens to simu-
are heavily corroded and many of them are broken. Rehabilitation late the actual situations. The new method showed better
work on the corroded wires was carried out on the Brooklyn corrosion resistance than the conventional method, even though
Bridge and the Williamsburg Bridge 共New York City兲, and the the central part was corroded as a result of the water.
cable corrosion has been a major issue 共Sluszka and Hyaden Another new method was therefore proposed: dry air was in-
1989; Stahl and Gagnon 1996; Betti and Yanev 1998; and Mayr- jected and circulated inside the cable on the whole span to remove
baurl 2000兲. the water inside the cable and to keep it dry 共Furuya et al. 2000兲.
Long span suspension bridges are relatively new in Japan. It is widely known that steel does not corrode when it is kept dry,
However, it was found from field surveys that galvanized steel and this dehumidification system seems to be promising. But
wires were partly corroded on several suspension bridges within what has not been clarified is the lower limit of the relative hu-
10 years after the bridges were completed. A wide survey was midity to prevent corrosion, and how much sodium chloride
carried out on these bridges. It was reported by Furuya et al. worsens corrosion.
共2000兲 that water was present inside the cable and made the en- This paper demonstrates the environmental conditions inside a
vironment inside the cable highly humid, which caused the cor- cable, how galvanized steel wires corrode under different corro-
rosion of the wires. However, steel corrosion was not deep and no sion environments, and how much relative humidity, temperature,
pitting corrosion or broken wires were observed. and sodium chloride affect the corrosion rate of galvanized steel
The researchers tried to improve the corrosion resistance by wires.
developing a new protection method with the S-shape wire wrap-
ping system 共Furuya et al. 2000兲. The new wrapping wire had an
S-shape cross section and, when it was wrapped on the cable, the Corrosion Resistant System for Suspension Bridge
Cables
1
Manager, Technical Development Center, Nippon Steel Corpor-
ation, 5-9 Nishihasimoto, Sagamihara 229-1131, Japan. E-mail: The conventional corrosion resistant system for typical suspen-
suzumura.keita@eng.nsc.co.jp sion bridge cables is shown in Fig. 1. A cable consists of thou-
2
Professor, Dept. of Civil Engineering, Tokai Univ., 1117 Kitakaname, sands of high-strength steel wires with diameters of about 5 mm.
Hiratsuka 259-1292, Japan. E-mail: snakamu@keyaki.cc.u-tokai.ac.jp Each steel wire is coated with zinc with a thickness of about 50
Note. Associate Editor: David Trejo. Discussion open until July 1, m, equivalent to 350 g/m2 . The galvanized steel wire is then
2004. Separate discussions must be submitted for individual papers. To
coated with a primary coating, such as chromate, acrylic resin or
extend the closing date by one month, a written request must be filed with
the ASCE Managing Editor. The manuscript for this paper was submitted epoxy resin, to protect the steel wires during construction.
for review and possible publication on August 17, 2001; approved on After all of the wires are installed at the erection sites, they are
March 25, 2003. This paper is part of the Journal of Materials in Civil compacted to form a round shape and covered with anti-corrosion
Engineering, Vol. 16, No. 1, February 1, 2004. ©ASCE, ISSN 0899- paste on the surface. They are then wrapped with annealed gal-
1561/2004/1-1–7/$18.00. vanized steel wires with a diameter of about 4 mm. Finally the
nized steel wires were also covered with wet gauze but they were
kept in a partially open box. When the wet gauze became dry,
water was sprayed to wet it. Test L simulated the environment of
the lower part where it was continuously in the water. Galvanized
steel wires were therefore kept in water in the confined box. Test
C simulated the center part where it was not wet but highly
Downloaded from ascelibrary.org by New York University on 05/18/15. Copyright ASCE. For personal use only; all rights reserved.
Fig. 5. Corrosion simulation tests Fig. 6. Corrosion rate of simulation test specimens
x-ray diffraction tests. The test results are shown in Fig. 8. The The dehumidification method was first implemented on the Little
zinc corrosion product of specimens S and L mainly consists of Belt Suspension Bridge in Denmark to prevent corrosion on the
ZnO and that of specimens U and C consists of ZnO and inside of steel box girders and the steel wires in anchorages. It
Zn4 CO3 (OH) 6 . It is thought that specimens U and C are covered was reported that the system had been working well since then
with the dense, adhesive layer of Zn4 CO3 (OH) 6 , that exhibits 共Bloomstine 1999兲. This dehumidification system was first ap-
good corrosion resistances, whereas, ZnO in specimens S and L plied to the main cables of the Akashi Kaikyo Bridge, a suspen-
sion bridge with a main span of 1990 m and completed in 1998. It
was reported that it took 6 months to dry the water inside the
cable and the relative humidity had remained below 60% after
dehumidification 共Furuya et al. 2000兲.
The principle of the dehumidification system is based on the
fact that steel does not corrode when it is kept dry. However, the
corrosion rate of galvanized steel wires may depend on the rela-
tive humidity, but this effect has not yet been clarified. From a
practical point of view, it is important to identify the target rela-
tive humidity at which the environment inside the cable should be
kept to prevent corrosion of galvanized steel wires.
The outside air is taken into the dehumidifying device, dried
with silica gel, and sent to the cable. The dry air may contain
sodium chloride 共NaCl兲 when suspension bridges are situated in
the marine environment. When sodium chloride attaches to the
wire surface, it absorbs moisture and breaks down the protective
passive film, causing the steel wires to corrode. The dehumidifi-
cation system should therefore include a device to remove sodium
Fig. 8. X-ray diffraction results Fig. 10. Corrosion simulation tests under different relative humidity
Fig. 11. Corrosion rate under different relative humidity Fig. 12. Corrosion rate of S specimen 共constantly wet兲
Fig. 13. Corrosion rate of D2 specimen 共60% relative humidity兲 Fig. 15. Corrosion rate of S specimen under different temperature
共constantly wet, no sodium chloride兲
more than ten times higher than that with tests D1, D2, and D3.
would be more likely to suffer corrosion problems in hot and
This indicates that corrosion is unlikely to occur when a cable is
humid countries than in cold areas.
kept at a relative humidity below 60%. It is also understood from
The corrosion rates of these four data are shown in Fig. 16.
the measured corrosion rate of the specimens absorbed with three
The corrosion rate is normalized with the average temperature in
different sodium chloride concentrations that, as the sodium chlo-
Japan of 16°C. It increases exponentially with the test tempera-
ride increases, more corrosion results in all of the test cases.
ture. The accelerated corrosion tests in the previous sections were
The accelerated corrosion tests were continued for 90 days.
conducted at a temperature of 40°C. Therefore, the acceleration
The mass loss of tests S, D2, and D3 for this period are shown in
rate of the corrosion simulation tests is about 4.6 when compared
Figs. 12, 13, and 14. The mass loss generally increases propor-
with the temperature of 16°C, as shown in Fig. 16.
tionally with time, but the increasing rate decreases with time in
some cases.
Life Index of Galvanized Steel Wires
Effect of Temperature It is difficult to predict the life of corroded cables because galva-
nized steel wires do not always corrode uniformly. However, pit-
In general, steel corrodes more when it is kept at higher tempera- ting corrosion was not observed on the bridge wires in the field
ture. The same corrosion simulation test S 共constantly wet condi- survey or in the present simulation tests. Hence, in general, the
tion兲 was performed for galvanized steel wires, which were kept zinc layer corrodes first and then the steel starts to corrode. The
in the confined box at four different temperatures, 0, 10, 20, and period until the total zinc of 350 g/m2 is completely consumed
40°C for 3 months. The S simulation test produced the severest would therefore be a good index to show the life of galvanized
corrosion in the previous tests. steel wires. As the remaining life can be expected even after the
The relation between mass loss and time is shown in Fig. 15. zinc is consumed, this would be a conservative value.
Each point in this figure is the average of three specimens tested The life index can be predicted from the corrosion rate in
under the same condition. The corroded mass was measured in 2 Table 3 using the acceleration rate of 4.6 共Fig. 16兲. The life index
weeks, 1 month, and 3 months after the start of the tests. These for the specimen S is calculated as follows. Taking the corrosion
four lines increase linearly with time. The corrosion rate is the rate of 963 g/m2 /year 共Table 3兲 and the acceleration rate of 4.6
highest in the specimen at 40°C, followed by 20, 10, and 0°C in 共Fig. 16兲, the zinc layer with 350 g/m2 is consumed over a period
this order. Judging from these results, suspension bridge cables