Professional Documents
Culture Documents
net/publication/375061221
CITATIONS READS
0 15
3 authors:
Miloš Čokić
University of Novi Sad
22 PUBLICATIONS 25 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
All content following this page was uploaded by Miloš Čokić on 29 October 2023.
PROCEEDINGS
VOLUME 2
SINARG 2023 CONFERENCE, NIŠ, 14-15 SEPTEMBER 2023
VOLUME 2
PUBLISHED BY:
FACULTY OF CIVIL ENGINEERING AND ARCHITECTURE, UNIVERSITY OF NIŠ
SERBIAN ACADEMY OF SCIENCES AND ARTS - BRANCH IN NIŠ
FOR PUBLISHERS:
SLAVIŠA TRAJKOVIĆ, PHD
VLADA VELJKOVIĆ, PHD
EDITORS:
SLAVIŠA TRAJKOVIĆ, PHD
VUK MILOŠEVIĆ, PHD
APPROVED TO BE PRINTED ON 7TH SEPTEMBER 2023. BY THE DECREE OF TEACHING SCIENTIFIC COUNCIL OF THE
FACULTY OF CIVIL ENGINEERING AND ARCHITECTURE, UNIVERSITY OF NIŠ, NO. 8/181
APPROVED TO BE PRINTED ON 4TH SEPTEMBER 2023. BY THE COMMITTEE FOR MANAGING THE WORK OF THE
SERBIAN ACADEMY OF SCIENCES AND ARTS - BRANCH IN NIŠ, NO. 1/23-159
ISBN 978-86-88601-81-8
ISBN 978-86-88601-82-5 (FOR PUBLISHING ISSUE)
ORGANIZED BY:
FACULTY OF CIVIL ENGINEERING AND ARCHITECTURE, UNIVERSITY OF NIŠ
SERBIAN ACADEMY OF SCIENCES AND ARTS - BRANCH IN NIŠ
SERBIAN ACADEMY OF SCIENCES AND ARTS - DEPARTMENT OF TECHNICAL SCIENCES
IN PARTNERSHIP WITH
SCIENCE TECHNOLOGY PARK NIŠ
INTERNATIONAL CONFERENCE SYNERGY OF ARCHITECTURE & CIVIL ENGINEERING
Key words reinforced concrete, prestressed concrete, design, structural art, aesthetic
of structures, bridges, schells
1
Dr, Prof. retired, . University of N. Sad, Novi Sad, Serbia; nfolic@gmail.com
2
Dr, Prof. emeritus, University of Novi Sad, Novi Sad, Serbia, folic@uns.ac.rs; and r.folic@gmail.com
3
Dr. Struct. designer, Termoenergo inženjering, Bulevar Kralja Aleksandra 298, Belgrade, Serbia;
cokicmilos@gmail.com
898 | S I N A R G
INTERNATIONAL CONFERENCE SYNERGY OF ARCHITECTURE & CIVIL ENGINEERING
INTRODUCTION
Until the 20th century, iron and steel prevailed in the construction of engineering
structures (ES), but reinforced concrete, owing to the competition between cement
factories and the steel industry, already took precedence during the last decades of
the 19th century, and especially at the beginning of the 20th century. This was
achieved thanks to the inventiveness and research of many creators who accepted
concrete as a material for shaping aesthetically valuable structures [1]. Many of well
known creators, with their talent and building philosophy, combined the structural
skills and architectural sensibility. Some of their works, as well as some other famous
authors, are presented here.
In addition to the different dates mentioned in the literature, it is believed that the
application of reinforced concrete began in 1850 when the Frenchman Lambot
reinforced the boat prepared for the World Exhibition in Paris in 1855. The
introduction of prestressing began in the 20s of the 20th century with the work of
Freysinet [1].
Many well-known structures in the World that represented the idea of structural
art were designed before advanced structural theory and modern tools were fully
developed. Structural design is concerned with much more then science and
techniques: it is very much concerned with art, common sense, sentiment, aptitude
and enjoyment of the task of creating opportune outlines to which scientific
calculations will add finishing touches, substantiating that the structure is sound and
strong in accordance with the requirements [2].
The history of the relationship between architects and structural engineers went
through a series of phases from the mid-19th century, when reinforced concrete
began to be technologically advanced. This relationship had its ups and downs, but
it became especially important when large covered spaces were formed. Both
architects and structural engineers tend to make the reinforced concrete structures
more attractive, but their design is therefore becoming more and more complex. This
complexity directly reflects on the relation between the architect and the engineer,
on the mutual understanding of the idea and the possibility of materializing it. This
paper will deal in more detail with this problem by review of several important
examples, based on which a conclusion can be drawn on the state of this
relationship in the 21st century and points out the need to harmonize the relationship
between the architect and the structural engineer [3].
900 | S I N A R G
INTERNATIONAL CONFERENCE SYNERGY OF ARCHITECTURE & CIVIL ENGINEERING
Figure 2. Inspirations for Guggenheim Museum, New York, F. L. Wright, 1959 [3]
The TWA Flight Center, designed by renowned architect Eero Saarinen and
Associates, is an iconic airport terminal and hotel complex located at JFK airport in
New York City. Built between 1959 and 1962, the original terminal building features
a distinctive shape of a bird with spread wings with wiwing-shaped roof supported
by “Y”-shaped piers and boasts an open interior with tall windows and two tube-
SINARG | 901
SINARG 2023 CONFERENCE, NIŠ, 14-15 SEPTEMBER 2023
shaped departure-arrival corridors. Despite its demolition in parts, the head house
remained and was adapted into the TWA Hotel in 2019. The encircling Terminal 5
addition, designed by Gensler, was constructed between 2005 and 2008 and
houses the 26 active gates at Terminal 5, as well as various dining and shopping
options. Recognized as both a New York City and National Landmark, the TWA
Flight Center remains a timeless masterpiece (Fig. 3).
Figure 3 The TWA Flight Center, New York, E. Saarinen and Associates, 1962.
The Sydney Opera House is a modern expressionist design, with a series of
large precast concrete "shells", each composed of sections of a sphere, forming
the roofs of the structure, set on a monumental podium. Although the 'shells' of
the Opera House resemble sails of a ship, the building's design was actually
inspired by nature. Architect Jørn Utzon says he was more influenced by birds,
clouds, walnuts and trees. Devising the roof sails proved to be one of the most
difficult aspects of the process. The Opera House was also the focus for many
architectural innovations. These included the pioneering use of computers to
calculate the stresses and loads on the two-way curved roofs, and development
of a way to build the roofs in concrete (Fig. 4).
At the same time in Europe was opened the Bürgi Garden Center. This thin
shell that floats over a part of the garden in Camorino, Switzerland is a project of
civil engineer Heinz Isler from 1973. His work, which imitates the sky, is the best
evidence that thin shells were more popular than ever in the mid-XX century (Fig.
5).
An example of an in-depth approach to the nature of human body is the study
drawing for the Torso building project in Malmö-Sweden and the building itself,
by S. Calatrava. The building with 54 floors, 190 m high, was built in 2005. Its
design was inspired by a marble sculpture of a twisting human torso made by
Santiago Calatrava himself. Multi-educated as an architect, civil engineer and
artist, it is no surprise that he describes his approach to architecture as more of
an art than a science (Fig. 6). Thin shells were additionally seen as a sound
design choice because when shaped correctly, they experienced little to no
bending moment, and any compression that was found within the shell was
uniformly distributed [12].
902 | S I N A R G
INTERNATIONAL CONFERENCE SYNERGY OF ARCHITECTURE & CIVIL ENGINEERING
Figure 4. Inspirations for developing the form of Sidney Opera House, J. Utzon , 1973.
Figure 5. Heinz Isler, Bürgi Garden Center, Camorino, Switzerland, 1973, [3].
904 | S I N A R G
INTERNATIONAL CONFERENCE SYNERGY OF ARCHITECTURE & CIVIL ENGINEERING
Figure 8. Palazzeto dello sport, Rome, P. L. Nervi with A. Vitellozzi, 1956-5, [9].
The variety of buildings where thin concrete shells and other concrete sculptural
forms were used for special functions as is shown in figures 9, 10 and 11. Memorial
structures were a great challenge to express the sculptural possibilities of concrete
through them. Although innovative materials are often used today for sculptural
forms, concrete as a material has survived and is still used in memorial structures
until now, as evidenced by the memorial park in Ethiopia, which is being built in 2023.
The monumental memorial-ossuaries represents the great concrete architecture
and symbolic originality.
SINARG | 905
SINARG 2023 CONFERENCE, NIŠ, 14-15 SEPTEMBER 2023
SINARG | 907
SINARG 2023 CONFERENCE, NIŠ, 14-15 SEPTEMBER 2023
Figure 19. Panoramic view of Belgrade Fair - Hall 1, B. Žeželj, Halls 2 and 3, M.
Krstić, 1957.
However, even younger architects and constructors could not resist the
attraction of concrete, as evidenced by the buildings shown in Figures 20, 21 and
22, with extraordinary aesthetic values. In the XXI century, several exceptional
creators did not completely renounce the joy of creating in concrete. Although in
many of their works they use the most modern materials and technologies, they
also designed bold concrete structures.
Figure 20. Meiso no Mori Municipal Funeral Hall, Kagengahari, Japan, T. Ito, 2006.
Figure 21.Heidar Aliev Centre, Baku, Azerbejan, Z. Hadid, 2012.
Figure 22. Sarpi Border Checkpoint, Georgia, J.Mayer H. Architect, 2011.
908 | S I N A R G
INTERNATIONAL CONFERENCE SYNERGY OF ARCHITECTURE & CIVIL ENGINEERING
In designing, improving conceptual design will be developed. In addition to EN
1992 for design, guidelines for design and construction are being improved, such as
in the International Federation for Concrete fib, the American Concrete Institute and
others. In order to increase the durability of CS, protection against corrosion in the
design and application of special types of reinforcement and protective measures is
under way. Of particular importance is mitigating the impact of natural hazards on
CS. In the future, the impact of climate change on the behavior of CS will gain
importance. A very topical analysis of structural robustness (prevention of chain
collapse) was introduced in EN 1990:2002, because of possible incident actions. In
doing so, complex non-linear analyzes must be implemented, which require the use
of computers and software.
One of the goals of this work was precisely to point out the strength of talent,
sound construction logic and intuition that guided the builders creating incredibly
striking concrete forms, with no or minimal application of modern computer
techniques and other modern technologies.
REFERENCES
Folić, R. I beton ima dušu-dometi betona u graditeljstvu, Pristupna beseda,
VANU Godišnjak 2014, N. Sad, 103-117, 2015 ISSN 1452-2268
Torroja, E.: Philosophy of Structures, University of California Press, Berkley
and Los Angeles, 1962.
Kurtović Folić, N. Folić, R. Cooperation Between Architects and Structural
Engineers in the Design of Complex Reinforced Roof Structures',
Contemporary theory and practice in Construction XII, (B. Antunovic, ed.), May
20-21, Banja Luka, Univer. of BL, Fac. of Arch, CEG, 455-470. B. Luka, 2018.
Faber, C. Candela und seine schalen, G. D. W. Callwey, Reinhold PC, 1963
Rey-Rey, J. Nature as a Source of Inspiration for the Structure of the Sydney
Opera House, Biomimetics, 7, 23. MDPI, 2022;
https//doi.org/10.3390/biomimetics7010023
Nowak, A, Rokicki, W. Bionic forms in search of structural models in
architecture, MATEC Web of Conference, 174, 03020 (2018) ECCE 2018
Chilton, J., Chuang, C. C. Rooted in Nature: Aesthetics, Geometry and Structure
in the Shells of Heinz Isler, Nexus Netw J. 19: 763-785, 2017.
Meyer, C., Sheer, M.H. (2005): Do concrete shells deserve another look, ACI
Concrete International, October, 2005, pp. 45-50.
The Works of Pier Luigi Nervi, F. A. Praeger, New York, USA, 1957.
Nervi P. L. Architecture Aesthetics and Technology in buildings, Haward
University P, Cambridge, 1965.
Kurcjusz, M. Stefanska, A. Dixit, S. Starzyk, A. The interdisciplary designing
in form, funcion,and structure coherency, ACTA Sci. Pol. Architectura 21 (3),
3-13, 2022.
Hu, N. Feng, P. Dai, G-L. Structural art: Past, present and future, Engineering
structures, 79, 2014; 407-416.
Wang, S. Kotnik, T. Schwartz, J. Redefining structural art: A neuroaesthetics
Perspective on the art of structural design, Springer, Architecture, Structures
and Construction, no. 2, pp 3-16, 2022.
SINARG | 909