BOMBAY HIGHCOURT

DAILY MAIN CAUSELIST

For Monday The 6th November 2023
COURT NO. 54
DIVISION
AT 10:30 AM
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE G. S. KULKARNI
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE JITENDRA SHANTILAL JAIN

HEADER NOTE :
Listing of cases would be as under: Both Appellate and Original Side
Monday and Tuesday:
(A) Writ Petitions in indirect tax matters under Central Act and State
Acts (including Excise Duty, Customs Duty, Service Tax, FERA and FEMA)
(B) Writ Petitions relating to National Stock Exchange and Securities
and Exchange Board of India Act, 1992 (SEBI)
Wednesday:
(A) Writ Petitions relating to resettlement of project affected
persons.
Thursday:
(A) Appeals, Reference and Applications under Indirect Taxes under Central
Acts
Friday:
(A) Final Hearing Matters
Also following directions are for Admission and Final Hearing matters:-
1. A brief list of dates and propositions of not more than one or two pages
appropriately be prepared to assist the Court, irrespective of the nature
and stage of the proceedings, along with page numbers be furnished by 4
p.m. on the day prior to the listing of the matter. It should be in normal
font having one and half spacing.
2. Priority for admission and final hearing shall be given to old matters.
3. In respect of illegible and handwritten documents, Legible / Typed copies
be kept ready when matter is called out in all matters.
4. For circulation of Urgent Matters, Advocates and parties-in-person are
requested to give one page typed praecipe (in proper font), setting out
urgency, indicating the date of the impugned order, the date of filing
of the petition and date as per allocation mentioned above, to the Associate/
Sheristedar of the Court strictly between 10.15 a.m. to 10.25 a.m.
5. Non urgent matters shall not be circulated.
6. Senior Advocates are requested not to mention for circulation
7.The following link is to be used for the Online hearing.
Website : https://zoom.us
Meeting ID : 205 574 1536
Link : https://zoom.us/my/bhcjgsk

Sr. CASE NO. PARTIES ADVOCATES

AT 2.30 P.M.

04/11/2023 18:53:17 1/8

 DAILY MAIN CAUSELIST COURT NO 54-FOR MONDAY THE 6TH NOVEMBER 2023 BOMBAY HIGHCOURT - 2 -

1 WP/13216/2023 YOGESH RAMESH PAWAR AND ANR Chintamani Kamlakar Bhangoji

[Civil] VS
THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA
THR.ITS SECRETARY TRIBAL
DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT. AND
ORS
REMARK : ADJ. FROM 03/11/2023===

2 WP(L)/30198/2023 SHANTANU SANJAY HUNDEKARI DMD ADVOCATES

[Original] VS
(ECHCBM02200312023) UNION OF INDIA
REMARK : Praecipe Dated : 27-10-2023.

3 WP(L)/30199/2023 VIKASH AGARWAL DMD ADVOCATES

[Original] VS
(ECHCBM02200422023) UNION OF INDIA
REMARK : Praecipe Dated : 27-10-2023.

4 WP(L)/30200/2023 YOGESH AGARWAL DMD ADVOCATES

[Original] VS
(ECHCBM02200262023) UNION OF INDIA
REMARK : Praecipe Dated : 27-10-2023.

5 WP(L)/30241/2023 MAMTA GUPTA DMD ADVOCATES

[Original] VS
(ECHCBM02199852023) UNION OF INDIA
REMARK : Praecipe Dated : 27-10-2023.

FIRST ON BOARD (FOB)

6 WP/9835/2015 SHRI. SHANKAR JAYATU MUKANE UDAY BHAGWANRAO NIGHOT

[Civil] (KATKARI) SINCE (DECD) THROUGH FOR R. NO. 1
HIS LRS. SHRI VITTHAL MUKANE GOVERNMENT PLEADER WRIT
VS CELL
THE COLLECTOR, PUNE AND ORS
REMARK : Note :- 1) As per court's order dtd.11/10/2023, Advocate Mr.Nighot has tendered List of Dates and
Events in Court on 18/10/2023 is kept separately. 2) Additional Affidavit in Reply on behalf of Resp.Nos.1 to 3
tendered in Court on 13/09/2023 is kept separately as paging not proper (at Pg.Nos.51 to 61). 3) Affidavit in
Rejoinder of Petitioners filed on 07/10/2023 is kept separately as paging not proper (at Pg.Nos.80 to 93). Court
(DB) For Compliance#(F.O.B.)#(as pe ct's order dtd.30/10/2023)

HIGH ON BOARD (HOB)

7 WP/2848/2021 KISHA TELELINKS PRIVATE India Law Alliance

[Original] LIMITED AND ANR sangeeta yadav
VS
UNION OF INDIA AND 4 ORS
8 WP/6053/2021 GULAB RAJARAM PATIL TANAJI MHATUGADE
[Civil] VS
SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE
BOARD OF INDIA AND ORS

04/11/2023 18:53:17 2/8

 DAILY MAIN CAUSELIST COURT NO 54-FOR MONDAY THE 6TH NOVEMBER 2023 BOMBAY HIGHCOURT - 3 -

REMARK : Note:- 1] Affidavit in Reply on behalf Respondent No. 1, filed on 13/12/2022 by way of E-filling [Page
Nos.323 to 411]. 2] As per Court's order dated 17/10/2023, Amendment carried out on 23/10/2023. 3] As per
Court's order dated 17/10/2023, Reply is not filed till date. 4] Office objections are not removed till date.

9 WP/2762/2022 D CORP AGRO FOOD PVT.LTD. ALAKSHA LEGAL

[Original] VS Government Pleader OS
DEPUTY COMMISSIONER OF STATE
TAX
10 WP/15717/2022 ETERNIS FINE CHEMICALS LTD. Economic Laws Practice
[Civil] (FORMERLY KNOWN AS M/S. ATLAS OMLE MAMTA RAMCHANDRA
FINE CHEMICALS PVT. LTD. )
VS
THE UNION OF INDIA THROUGH
THE MINISTRY OF FINANCE , DEPT.
OF REVENUE AND ORS
REMARK : Note:- 1) Affidavit in Reply not filed till date, as per Court' order dtd. 17/10/23 2] Affidavit of Service
filed on 31/1/2023, which is kept in II part. 3] All Office objections are removed on 13/12/2022. 4) Adv. Omle
Namita R. for Res. no.2 (VP filed on 24/05/2023 by way of E-filing.) 5] Citation tendered in Court on 17/10/2023
is kept herewith separately.

11 WP/13862/2023 MAXIM TUBES COMPANY PVT. LTD. PDS Legal

[Civil] VS
(ECHCBM01091482023) THE UNION OF INDIA
12 WP(L)/24184/2023 THE HONGKONG AND SHANGHAI Khaitan and Co
[Original] BANKING CORPORATION LIMITED MAMTA RAMCHANDRA OMLE
(ECHCBM02156432023) VS
UNION OF INDIA
13 WP(L)/27637/2023 SAMEER ANSARI Vinit Dubey
[Original] VS
(ECHCBM02183842023) UNION OF INDIA
14 WP(L)/27864/2023 AAMIL FRUITWALA Vinit Dubey
[Original] VS
(ECHCBM02183882023) UNION OF INDIA
FOR CIRCULATION

15 WP/9484/2019 IMS PROSCHOOL PVT. LTD. RESP NO. 2 TO 5

[Civil] VS RESP NO. 2,5
THE UNION OF INDIA THROUGH GOVERNMENT PLEADER WRIT
THE SECRETARY, MINISTRY OF CELL
FINANCE , DEPT. OF REVENUE AND Maya Majumdar
ORS
REMARK : Coram : G. S. Kulkarni And Jitendra S. Jain, JJ. Circulation granted on 06/11/2023. Dt.16/10/2023 For
Registrar (J.) Note : 1) Affidavit in Reply on behalf of Res No.6 filed on dt. 15/02/2022 is kept herewith as
paging not done properly. 2) Affidavit in Rejoinder filed on dated 22/04/22 is kept herewith as paging not done
properly. 3) As per courts order dtd. 08/02/2023, The summary and compilation tendered in Court on 16/2/2023
is kept separately.

16 WP(L)/38499/2022 KIRAN NAGINDAS VORA UBR Legal

[Original] VS Saket Ramchandra Ketkar
UNION OF INDIA, THROUGH THE Saket Ramchandra Ketkar
SECRETARY
17 WP(L)/1784/2023 NEIL EUSTACE BARROW Irfan Ishak Khan
[Original] VS THAKKER RUJU
(ECHCBM02005002023) UNION OF INDIA Government Pleader OS

04/11/2023 18:53:17 3/8

 DAILY MAIN CAUSELIST COURT NO 54-FOR MONDAY THE 6TH NOVEMBER 2023 BOMBAY HIGHCOURT - 4 -

18 WP(L)/2142/2023 MUKESH N. VORA THOUGH VIPUL UBR Legal

[Original] LAKHANI Saket Ramchandra Ketkar
(ECHCBM02007182023) VS SAKET R KETKAR
UNION OF INDIA THROUGH THE Saket Ramchandra Ketkar
SECRETARY, MINISTRY OF
FINANCE, DEPARTMENT OF
REVENUE
WITH

WP(L)/37645/2022 NIP EXPORTS PVT LTD UBR LEGAL ADVOCATES

[Original] VS RUJU THAKKER
UNION OF INDIA
In
/0/

REMARK: === Praecipe Dated : 04/08-2023 along with wpl no. 12448 of 2023 ===
19 WP/2333/2023 PIRAMAL CAPITAL AND HOUSING PDS Legal
[Original] FINANCE LTD. Siddharth Chandrashekhar
VS
THE UNION OF INDIA AND 4
OTHERS
20 WP/4868/2023 PRITPAL SINGH KALSI S/O JASWANT Pankti Shah
[Civil] SINGH
VS
UNION OF INDIA THROUGH ITS
SECRETARY, DEPT. OF REVENUE
AND ORS
REMARK : Coram :- G.S. Kulkarni & Jitendra S. Jain, JJ. Circulation granted for 06/11/2023 Dt.-19/10/23 For
Registrar (Judl-I). Note : 1) Office objections are not removed till date.

21 WP/5446/2023 THE MUNICIPAL CORPORATION OF Aruna Savla

[Civil] GREATER MUMBAI DMD Advocates
VS
THE COMMISSIONER CGST
MUMBAI EAST AND ORS
REMARK : Coram :- G S Kulkarni and Jitenda Jain,JJ Circulation is on 06/11/2023 Dt 17/10/2023 For Reg(Judl I)
Note:-DMD Advocate for R.no 6(VP filed on 15/03/2022 is kept in IInd Part) 2) Office obj are not removed till
date 3) Matter filed before single bench hence I(ii) part not filed by Adv

22 WP(L)/8673/2023 NARENDRA TARACHAND PUROHIT INDIA LAW ALLIANCE

[Original] VS RUJU THAKKER
(ECHCBM02039862023) UNION OF INDIA RUJU THAKKAR
WITH

WP(L)/9063/2023
DUNGRARAM PUROHIT Ramprakash Pandey
(ECHCBM02052802023)
[Original] VS THAKKER RUJU
UNION OF INDIA RUJU THAKKER

REMARK: Praecipe dtd. 06.04.2023.

WITH

WP(L)/9064/2023
BHAGIRATH BHERARAM CHAUDH Ramprakash Pandey
(ECHCBM02052862023)

04/11/2023 18:53:17 4/8

 DAILY MAIN CAUSELIST COURT NO 54-FOR MONDAY THE 6TH NOVEMBER 2023 BOMBAY HIGHCOURT - 5 -

[Original] ARY THAKKER RUJU

VS
UNION OF INDIA

REMARK: Praecipe dtd. 06.04.2023.

WITH

WP(L)/9066/2023
VIJAYKUMAR SHEKHARAN NAIR Ramprakash Pandey
(ECHCBM02052872023)
[Original] VS THAKKER RUJU
UNION OF INDIA

REMARK: Praecipe dtd. 06.04.2023.

WITH

WP(L)/9195/2023
MAYUR TARACHAND PUROHIT Ramprakash Pandey
(ECHCBM02052252023)
[Original] VS THAKKER RUJU
UNION OF INDIA THAKKER RUJU
THAKKER RUJU
THAKKER RUJU

REMARK: Praecipe dtd. 06.04.2023.

23 WP/10452/2023 RAJENDRA JAGANNATH SONAWANE RG PANCHAL
[Civil] VS BBSharma
CITY AND INDUSTRIAL Prerna Shukla
DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION AND
ORS
REMARK : Coram:-G.S.Kulkarni and Jitendra Jain,JJ Circulation is on 06/11/2023 Dt 01/11/2023 For Reg(Judl I)
Note:- 1] Advocate B.B. Sharma waives service for Respondent No.1. 2] Advocate Nitin V. Gangal with Advocate
Prerna Shukla i/by Namita Mestry for Respondent Nos.2 to 11. 3] Affidavit in Reply filed for R.nos 2 to 11 on
04/09/023 which is kept herewith at page nos 70-77. 4] Affidavit in Reply filed for Respondent No.1 -CIDCO on
28/09/2023 by way of E-filling (at page nos.78-90). 5] Office objections are not removed till date.

24 WP/10534/2023 ARIHANT TRADERS THR ITS Pratik Rajopadhye

[Civil] PROPRIETOR AND ANR
VS
SHRIKANT R KHADE ASST.
COMMISSIONER STATE GOODS AND
SERVICE TAXAND ANR
REMARK : Coram:-G.S.Kulkarni and Jitendra Jain,JJ Circulation is on 06/11/2023 Dt 18/10/2023 For Reg(Judl I)
Note :- 1) As per courts order dt. 05/09/2023, Amendment is carried out in Court. 2) Office objections are not
removed till date. Court (DB) For Admission

25 WP/10545/2023 M/S SB CONSULTANTS AND Ashish Patankar

[Civil] ENGINEERS
VS
MR. ABASAHEB ANANTRAO
KHALADKAR AND ANR
REMARK : Coram:-G S Kulkarni and Jitendra Jain,JJ Circulation is on 06/11/2023 Dt 18/10/2023 For Reg(Judl I)
Note:- 1) As per Court's order dated 29/08/23, Amendment carried out on 30/08/23. 2) AGP waives service for
R. No. 1 (NOA not filed) 3) Adv. Kantharia waives service for R. No. 2 (V.P. not filed) 4) Office objections are not
removed till date.

04/11/2023 18:53:17 5/8

 DAILY MAIN CAUSELIST COURT NO 54-FOR MONDAY THE 6TH NOVEMBER 2023 BOMBAY HIGHCOURT - 6 -

26 WP/12295/2023 SHAMBHURAJ SHIVRAJ PATIL K S SHUKLA

[Civil] VS
THE UNION OF INDIA THR THE
SECRETARYAND ORS
REMARK : Coram:-G S Kulkarni and Jitendra Jain,JJ Circulation is on 06/11/2023 Dt 01/11/2023 For Reg(Judl I)
Note:-Office obj are not removed till date Court (DB) For Admission

27 WP(L)/13158/2023 AMN LIFE SCIENCE PVT LTD UBR Legal

[Original] VS GP OS
(ECHCBM02079352023) UNION OF INDIA Saket Ramchandra Ketkar
28 WP/13779/2023 MMTC LTD TULI AND COMPANY
[Civil] VS
UNION OF INDIA THROUGH THE
SECRETARY AND ORS
29 WP/13967/2023 SUBRIGHT DESIGNERS PVT. LTD. Brijesh Pathak
[Civil] VS
STATE OF MAHARASHTRA THR PP
OFFICE AND ORS
30 WP(L)/16374/2023 GREAT EASTERN SHIPPING UBR Legal
[Original] COMPANY LIMITED THROUGH Satyaprakash Sharma Prop Global
(ECHCBM02097352023) AUTHORISED REPRESENTATIVE Juris
VS Satyaprakash Sharma
UNION OF INDIA THROUGH
SECRETARY, DEPARTMENT OF
REVENUE, MINISTRY OF FINANCE
31 IA/17046/2023 PACCAR INDIA PVT LTD PDS Legal
[Civil] VS PDS Legal
(ECHCBM01089892023) THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA
In
WP/4712/2023
32 WP(L)/25958/2023 MESSRS HARESH GIRDHARILAL MM
[Original] CHHABRIA
(ECHCBM02170172023) VS
ASST. COMMISSIONER, DIV- II,
CGST AND C. EX, MUMBAI EAST
COMMISSIONERATE
33 WP(L)/27997/2023 KIRAN NAGINDAS VORA UBR Legal
[Original] VS
(ECHCBM02183292023) UNION OF INDIA
34 WP(L)/28450/2023 MUKESH NAGINDAS VORA UBR Legal
[Original] VS
(ECHCBM02188402023) UNION OF INDIA
35 WP(L)/28762/2023 MUKESH NAGINDAS VORA UBR Legal
[Original] VS
(ECHCBM02182022023) UNION OF INDIA
36 WP(L)/28836/2023 MUKESH NAGINDAS VORA UBR Legal
[Original] VS
(ECHCBM02183832023) UNION OF INDIA
37 WP(L)/29147/2023 MUKESH NAGINDAS VORA UBR Legal
[Original] VS
(ECHCBM02193322023) UNION OF INDIA

04/11/2023 18:53:17 6/8

 DAILY MAIN CAUSELIST COURT NO 54-FOR MONDAY THE 6TH NOVEMBER 2023 BOMBAY HIGHCOURT - 7 -

38 WP(L)/29161/2023 YOUTH CONSTRUCTION PVT. LTD. SMA Law Partners

[Original] VS
(ECHCBM02193782023) CENTRAL BOARD OF INDIRECT
TAXES AND CUSTOMS THROUGH
DEPARTMENT OF REVENUE,
MINISTRY OF FINANCE
39 WP(L)/29301/2023 YOUTH CONSTRUCTION PVT. LTD. SMA Law Partners
[Original] VS
(ECHCBM02194042023) CENTRAL BOARD OF INDIRECT
TAXES AND CUSTOMS THROUGH
DEPARTMENT OF REVENUE,
MINISTRY OF FINANCE
40 IA(L)/30864/2023 TEJKUMAR S KUMAWAT AND 4 ORS. Jitendra Damani
[Original] VS Jitendra Damani
MUNICIPAL CORPORATION OF Dishang J Shah
GREATER BOMBAY THROUGH THE PRITESH ASHOK PARMAR
MUNICIPAL COMMISSIONER AND
CORPORATION AND5ORS.
In
WPL/26571/2023
FOR ADMISSION

41 CP/388/2023 INDOSHELL MOULD LIMITED Darekar Tejal S

[Civil] VS PRASAD HASIKA
(ECHCBM01015522023) UNION OF INDIA Shashi Bekal
In
WP/5593/2021
REMARK : NOTES :- 1) MATTER FILED THROUGH E-FILING. 2) AS PER ADMINISTRATIVE ORDER DTD.
03/03/2021, C.P. STAMP IS NUMBERED. 3) ADV. FOR PETITIONER HAS FILED AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE ON
13/06/2023 (E-FILING) IS KEPT HEREWITH. 4) ADV. FOR RESPONDENT HAS FILED AFFIDAVIT IN REPLY
ON 26/06/2023 (E-FILING) IS KEPT HEREWITH FROM PAGE NOS. 147 TO 160. 5) ADV. SHASHI BEKAL HAS
FILED V.P. ON 21/07/2023 (E-FILING) FOR RESP.NO.3 --COURT (D.B.) --- FOR ORDERS---

42 WP/2215/2023 KUNAL HOUSEWARES PVT LTD AGRUD PARTNERS

[Civil] VS
THE UNION OF INDIA AND ORS
REMARK : Note : 1] As per Courts order dtd 13/10/2023, Amendment carried out on dtd 18/10/2023 2] As per
Courts order dtd 13/10/2023, rejoinder not filed till date. 3] Affidavit in Reply of Respondents filed on
01/03/2021 is kept herewith serially at Page Nos.484 to 493. 4] Affidavit in Rejoinder on behalf of the Petitioner
filed on dated 30/03/23 by way of E-FILLING. 5] Affidavit in Rejoinder on behalf of the Petitioner filed on dated
25/04/23 by way of E-FILLING. 6] Writ Petition No.2234 of 2023 is kept herewith. 7] Draft amendments
tendered in Court on dtd 09/10/2023 are kept herewith. 8] Order in original dtd 06/10/2023 of Commissioner of
Customs, NS II tendered in Court is kept herewith. 9] Notification no. 58/2017-CUSTOMS (N.T) dtd 29/06/2017
tendered in Court is kept herewith [Only 1 set received kept with i(i)] 10] Compilation -I [Only 1 set received
kept with i(i)] and Compilation -II tendered in Court on 09/10/2023 are kept herewith. 11] As per courts order
dt. 27/10/2023, Reply affidavit not filed till date.

WITH

WP/2234/2023 KITCHEN ESSENTIALS AND AN ARGUD PARTNER

[Civil] R
VS
THE UNION OF INDIA AND OR
S

04/11/2023 18:53:17 7/8

 DAILY MAIN CAUSELIST COURT NO 54-FOR MONDAY THE 6TH NOVEMBER 2023 BOMBAY HIGHCOURT - 8 -

REMARK: NOTE : OFFICE OBJ. NOT REMOVED TILL DATE,

43 WP/12343/2023 POONAM PARASMAL JAIN Brijesh Pathak
[Civil] VS
UNION OF INDIA AND ORS THR
CENTRAL GOVT. ADVOCATES AND
ORS
REMARK : Note : 1] Affidavit in Reply not filed by Respondents till date. 2] Ms. Sangeeta Yadav waives service
for Respondents. (VP not filed) 3] Office objections are not removed till date. 4] List of Dates and events
tendered in court by Advocate of petitioner on 16/10/2023 is kept herewith separately.

44 WP/12394/2023 SHAHAJI BHANUDAS BHAD PDS Legal

[Civil] VS
(ECHCBM01085992023) UNION OF INDIA AND ANR
REMARK : Note : This matter filed through E-FILLING. Copy of Petition kept herewith. 1) Affidavit in Reply not
filed till date.

45 WP/13122/2023 ISHWAR RAMESH NERKAR Pritesh K Bohade

[Civil] VS
THE STATE OF MAHARSHTRA THR
PRINCIPAL SECRETARY SCHOOL
EDUCAITION AND SPORT AND ORS
46 WP(L)/14714/2023 PINAKIN SODA Neha Sanghvi
[Original] VS Saket Ramchandra Ketkar
(ECHCBM02091202023) PRINCIPAL COMMISSIONER RA AND
EX OFFICO ADDITIONAL
SECRETARY TO THE GOVERNMENT
OF INDIA
47 WP(L)/17943/2023 RAJESH BHANWARLAL JAIN SHREY S LODHA
[Original] VS Satyaprakash Sharma Prop Global
(ECHCBM02115782023) UNION OF INDIA THROUGH Juris
SECRETARY
48 WP(L)/18082/2023 TASTY BITE EATABLES LIMITED Adv Siddharth Kakka
[Original] VS
(ECHCBM02116392023) UNION OF INDIA
49 WP(L)/18396/2023 SIDHARTH SHARMA ADV MRANAL MANDHANE
[Original] VS
(ECHCBM02110942023) COMMISSIONER OF CUSTOMS NS
GEN
50 WP(L)/28362/2023 CREATIVE LABELS PVT LTD Tejas Mahamuni
[Original] VS
(ECHCBM02187482023) STATE OF MAHARASHTRA
INTERIM APPLICATION

51 IA(L)/12399/2023 BIYANI SILK MILLS AND ANR PDS Legal

[Original] VS PDS Legal
(ECHCBM02074972023) COMMISSIONER OF CUSTOMS
IMPORT II AND ORS
In
WPL/35455/2022

04/11/2023 18:53:17 8/8