You are on page 1of 3

Extended Summaries ± Neurotox '98

a-BgTx, EPI or IMI. In contrast the dissociation rate Nicotinic acetylcholine receptor chimeras of rat
was markedly increased when initiated by MLA a7 and Drosophila SAD reveal species-specific
compared to a-BgTx, EPI or IMI (Fig 1). agonist binding regions
Displacement of [125I]a-BgTx, [3H]EPI and
3 Ingeborg van den Beukel,1* Remco Klaassen,2
[ H]IMI by MLA was with high potency with an Guus B Smit,2 Regina GDM van Kleef1 and
IC50 value close to the Kd value of each of these Marga Oortgiesen1†
labelled ligands. Displacement of [3H]MLA by a- 1
Research Institute of Toxicology, Utrecht University, PO Box
BgTx, EPI and IMI resulted in low potency, but was 80176, 3508 TD Utrecht, The Netherlands
2
characterised by shallow displacement curves. Department of Molecular Neurobiology, Graduate School of
Neuroscience, Free University, De Boelelaan 1087, 1081 HV
Amsterdam, The Netherlands
Abstract: Species-speci®c agonist binding regions of
4 DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSIONS nicotinic acetylcholine receptors (nAChR) were
Saturation studies in M persicae membranes demon- examined. Imidacloprid and physostigmine (Phy)
strate that [125I]a-BgTx, [3H]EPI, and [3H]IMI all selectively activated insect nAChR composed of
label two binding components of differing af®nities in Drosophila second alpha-like subunit (SAD) and
a ratio of 1:3. In each case the sum of the high and low chick b2, in contrast to rat a7 nAChR. The Phy-
af®nity Bmax values approximated the Bmax value of the activated currents were a-bungarotoxin (a-BGT)
single site labelled by [3H]MLA. [3H]MLA is a novel sensitive, suggesting activation at the agonist bind-
ing loop C. Several SAD-a7 chimeras were con-
radioligand which is highly selective in vertebrate
structed, by switching agonist binding regions, and
nAChRs,3 but which appears to be unable to expressed in oocytes. Though none of the chimeras
distinguish between a heterogeneous population of was activated by a range of nicotinic agonists,
nicotinic ligand binding sites in insects. [125I]a-BGT binding revealed homomeric assembly
The increase in dissociation rate of [3H]a-BgTx of all chimeric cDNAs. Phy differentially displaced
using MLA instead of either a-BgTx, EPI or IMI is [125I]a-BGT from the nAChR chimeras, suggesting
consistent with an allosteric interaction by MLA at a that the b subunit is not involved in Phy binding, and
binding site other than that of the high af®nity [3H]a- that Phy targets the insect agonist binding loop C.
BgTx binding site. Keywords: nicotinic receptor; agonist binding;
Displacement studies have shown that MLA is a chimera; physostigmine; imidacloprid; acetylcholine
potent ligand at sites labelled with high af®nity by receptor; neonicotinoid
[125I]a-BgTx, [3H]EPI, and [3H]IMI. The shallow
displacement curves obtained when [3H]MLA is
displaced by a-BgTx, EPI, and IMI (data not shown) 1 INTRODUCTION
are likely to be due to displacement of [3H]MLA from Multiple nicotinic acetylcholine receptor (nAChR)
at least two distinct binding sites, for which the subtypes exist, both within and between species.
displacing ligands have different af®nities, but which Insects express only neuronal nAChR, while, in
are indistinguishable by [3H]MLA. vertebrates, endplate and neuronal nAChR types are
Interestingly, the high af®nity binding of [3H]IMI in distinguished. A range of different insect and verte-
hemipteran membranes compared to that in non- brate a subunits exist, which may be combined with
hemipteran insects may help explain why IMI is various b subunits to form functional nAChR. Three
particularly useful for the control of sucking pests. loops in the a subunits are thought to be involved in
acetylcholine (ACh) binding,1 ie loop A (residues 86±
93), loop B (residues 148±151), and loop C (residues
190±198). The latter includes the two adjacent
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
cysteines characteristic of a subunits. Distinct nAChR
Thanks to Matt Cahill of IACR Rothamsted for
subtypes are distinguished by their physiological and
supplying B tabaci. The work was supported by the
pharmacological properties. In addition, differential
BBSRC and Zeneca Agrochemicals.
sensitivities to chemical compounds may occur,
suggesting a role in species-selective toxicity. The
nitroguanidine insecticide imidacloprid selectively
REFERENCES activates insect nAChR by binding to the agonist
1 Elbert A, Becker B, Hartwig J and Erdelen C, Imidacloprid ± a new
systemic insecticide. P¯anzenschutz-Nachrichten Bayer 44:113±
136 (1991). * Correspondence to: Ingeborg van den Beukel, Research Institute
2 Lind RJ, Clough MS, Reynolds SE and Earley FGP, [3H]Imida- of Toxicology, Utrecht University, PO Box 80176, 3508 Utrecht,
cloprid labels high and low af®nity nicotinic acetylcholine The Netherlands
receptor-like binding sites in the aphid Myzus persicae (Hemi- E-mail: I.vandenBeukel@ritox.dgk.ruu.nl
ptera: Aphididae). Pestic Biochem Physiol 62:3±14 (1998). †
Present address: Department of Neurobiology, Duke University
3 Davies ARL, Hardick DJ, Blagbrough IS, Potter BVL, Wolsten- Medical Center, 435 Bryan Research Building, Durham, NC 27278,
holme AJ and Wonnacott S, [3H]Methyllycaconitine a novel USA
radioligand for a7-type nicotinic acetylcholine receptors. Soc (Received 20 August 1998; revised version received 25 November
Neurosci Abstr 23:477.2 (1997). 1998; accepted 20 May 1999)

Pestic Sci 55:1027±1040 (1999) 1031


Extended Summaries ± Neurotox '98

binding site.2,3 The carbamate, physostigmine (Phy),


selectively activates whole-cell nicotinic currents in
locust neurons and in Xenopus oocytes expressing fruit
¯y nAChR resulting from cDNA injection of the
second a-like Drosophila (SAD) and the chick b2
subunit.4 Whole-cell currents during stimulation with
Phy could not be detected in various cell types
expressing different vertebrate nAChR.4 Phy appears
also to target the nAChR agonist binding site, as Phy-
activated currents are sensitive to competitive antago-
nists.4 This contrasts with previous reports that Phy
binds to a separate site instead of the agonist binding
site at vertebrate nAChR.5 These observations suggest
that ACh binding sites of insects differ from those of
vertebrates.
We investigated species-speci®c nAChR agonist
binding sites at the cellular and molecular level.
Several nAChR chimeras of rat a7 and Drosophila
SAD were constructed, in which distinct agonist
binding domains of a7 were replaced by the corre-
sponding domains of SAD cDNA. Agonist binding
and function of rat a7, insect SAD/chick b2, and the
chimeras in Xenopus oocytes was analysed.

Figure 1. Properties of oocytes expressing SAD/chick b2, a7 and a7-SAD


2 METHODS AND RESULTS chimeric nAChR. A. Phy (bar) induced a nicotinic inward current in oocytes
Pharmacological properties of rat a7 nAChR and fruit expressing SAD/chick b2 nAChR, in contrast to rat a7 nAChR. Holding
¯y nAChR resulting from co-expression of the potential ÿ80mV. B. Oocytes were preincubated for 60 min in phosphate-
Drosophila SAD a and the chick b2 subunit in Xenopus buffered saline (PBS), supplemented with 0.1% bovine serum albumin
(BSA), incubated for 120 min in PBS with 0.1% BSA containing 5 nM
oocytes were investigated, using the dual microelec-
[125I]a-BGT. After five washes radioactivity was counted. Non-specific
trode voltage clamp method. ACh activated the binding in non-transformed oocytes ranged from 9 to 22% of total binding,
wildtype rat a7 and SAD/chick b2 nAChR. Con- and was subtracted to calculate specific [125I]a-BGT binding. For all
centration-effect curves revealed EC50 values of subtypes, specific binding was significantly higher compared to nonspecific
179 (65) mM (n = 3) and 15 (4) mM (n = 3), with Hill binding (P < 0.001).
coef®cients of 1.44 (0.22) and 1.35 (0.09), respec-
tively, which are in the same range as those reported
previously.6,7 Imidacloprid at 10 mM (data not shown), ACh, Phy nor tetramethylammonium (TMA) was
and 100 mM Phy evoked inward currents in oocytes able to induce an ion current in any of the chimeras.
expressing SAD/chick b2 nAChR (Fig 1A). The Phy- To examine membrane expression of chimeric nAChR
activated current was completely blocked by 50 nM proteins, binding of [125I]a-BGT was analysed in
a-bungarotoxin (a-BGT; not shown), suggesting that single Xenopus oocytes. All chimeric cDNAs were
Phy binds to the agonist binding site of SAD/chick b2 capable of assembly into homomeric nAChR, and
nAChR. Neither Phy (Fig 1A) nor imidacloprid (not bound [125I]a-BGT (Fig 1B).
shown) activated any current at the rat a7 nAChR. Subsequently, displacement of [125I]a-BGT by Phy
The binding site for species-selective nAChR acti- was analysed. Phy at 1 mM displaced 42 (7)% (n = 3)
vation was determined by construction of chimeras of of bound [125I]a-BGT from oocytes expressing 7S.3
rat a7 and Drosophila SAD cDNA, in which agonist (containing SAD loop C) and 55 (19)% (n = 4) from
binding regions of a7 were replaced by the correspond- wild-type SAD/chick b2 oocytes. Displacement was
ing sequence of SAD cDNA. The chimeras were less (13 (47)% (n = 6)) from oocytes expressing 7S.4
constructed using a two-step PCR ampli®cation. For nAChR (containing SAD loop B with the putative
chimeras 7S.1 and 7S.2 the rat a7 cDNA region Phy-site).
His137 to Met226, including ACh binding loop B
with the putative Phy-site, and loop C were replaced,
whereas in 7S.2 the Phy-site (Lys165) was changed to CONCLUSIONS
Gln. 7S.3 and 7S.4 contain the SAD sequence corre- The results show that Phy and imidacloprid selectively
sponding to a7 His137 to Trp196 and a7 Trp196 to activate insect nAChR. Further, the nAChR chimeras
Met226, respectively, including SAD loop C and loop of the rat a7 and Drosophila SAD a subunits success-
B. The ®nal PCR products were cloned into the fully assemble into homomeric nAChR proteins, as
HindIII-XbaI sites of pcDNA3, were completely revealed by [125I]a-BGT binding. Lack of function of
sequenced, and expressed in Xenopus oocytes. Neither the a7-SAD chimeras appears to be due to de®cient

1032 Pestic Sci 55:1027±1040 (1999)


Extended Summaries ± Neurotox '98

coupling of agonist binding to gating of the ion Abstract: The summary deals with the anti-con-
channel, indicating that agonist binding and subse- vulsant and antilethal effects of a new benzodiaze-
quent ion channel opening are separate, but related pine receptor partial agonist, imidazenil, in DFP
processes. Phy differentially displaces [125I]a-BGT intoxication. It has been demonstrated that imida-
from the chimeric nAChR, suggesting that the b zenil (2±5 mg kgÿ1) signi®cantly decreases convul-
sion intensity, rapidly inhibits seizure patterns in
subunit is not involved in Phy binding, and that Phy
brain bioelectrical activity and signi®cantly in-
targets the insect agonist binding loop C. creases the anti-lethal ef®cacy of atropine plus
obidoxime therapy. These effects are comparable
to diazepam at 5 mg kgÿ1. However, diazepam ex-
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS hibits myorelaxant activity at therapeutic doses,
We would like to thank Dr B Schmitt (Max-Planck- which are only observed at 5±10 times the therapeu-
Institut fuÈr Hirnforschung, Frankfurt, Germany) and tic doses of imidazenil.
Dr M Ballivet (University of Geneva, Switzerland) for Keywords: benzodiazepines; convulsions; DFP;
kindly providing us with cDNA encoding the SAD and imidazenil; organophosphate
the chick b2 subunit, respectively.
This work was ®nancially supported by the US-EPA
(CR#82192701).
1 INTRODUCTION
Centrally mediated seizures are one of the toxic signs
REFERENCES following poisoning with organophosphates (OP),
1 Arias HR, Topology of ligand binding sites on the nicotinic Benzodiazepines (BDZ), especially diazepam, are very
acetylcholine receptor. Brain Res Rev 25:133±191 (1997).
effective in the management of these convulsions when
2 Zwart R, Oortgiesen M and Vijverberg HPM, Nitromethylene
heterocycles: selective agonists of nicotinic receptors in locust given as adjuncts to atropine and oxime.1,2 However,
neurons as compared to mouse N1E-115 and BC3H1 cells. Pest sedation, myorelaxation and dependence make BDZ a
Biochem Physiol 48:202±313 (1994). poor choice for the treatment in these states. Partial
3 Yamamoto I, Tomizawa M, Saito T, Miyamoto T, Walcott EC BDZ receptor agonists are regarded as producing
and Sumikawa K, Structural factors contributing to insecticidal
these side effects only in very high doses. Some of these
and selective actions of neonicotinoids. Arch Insect Biochem
Physiol 37:24±32 (1998). drugs, like compound CGS9896, are very effective in
4 Van den Beukel I, Van Kleef RGDM, Zwart R and Oortgiesen M, the treatment of OP intoxications3 but unfortunately
Physostigmine and acetylcholine differentially activate nicotinic they are not registered as drugs. The recently reported
receptor subpopulations in Locusta migratoria neurons. Brain Res partial allosteric modulator of BDZ receptors, imida-
789:263±273 (1998).
zenil (6-(2-bromophenyl)-8-¯uoro-4H-imidazo [1,5-
5 SchroÈder B, Reinhardt-Maelicke S, Schrattenholz A, McLane KE,
Kretschmer A, Conti-Tronconi BM and Maelicke A, Mono- a] benzodiazepine-3-carboximide),4 is more like the
clonal antibodies FK1 and WF6 de®ne two neighboring ligand ideal drug for the management of OP-induced con-
binding sites on Torpedo acetylcholine receptor a-polypeptide. J vulsions. This drug is now under extensive studies in
Biol Chem 269:10407±10416 (1994). many laboratories and clinics and is considered as a
6 Palma E, Eusebi F and Miledi R, Co-expression of the neuronal a7
potential novel anti-epileptic drug.5 The present study
and L247T a7 mutant subunits yields hybrid nicotinic receptors
with properties of both wild-type a7 and a7 mutant homomeric was performed in order to determine anti-convulsant
receptors. Proc Natl Acad Sci. USA. 94:1539±1543 (1997). effects of imidazenil in acute OP intoxications, as well
7 Bertrand D, Ballivet M, Gomez M, Bertrand S, Phannavong B as to establish its antidotal ef®cacy in rodents.
and Gundel®nger ED, Physiological properties of neuronal
nicotinic receptors reconstituted from the vertebrate b2 subunit
and Drosophila a subunits. Eur J Neurosci. 6:869±875 (1994).
2 MATERIAL AND METHODS
2.1 Tested drugs
Imidazenil, a new drug for the management of Fluostigmine (diisopropyl phosphoro¯uoridate; DFP)
convulsions in organophosphate intoxication was used as a model OP compound
in rodents
Slawomir Rump,* Teresa Gidynska, Elzbieta Galecka, 2.2 Anti-convulsant efficacy
Oktawiusz Antkowiak and Marek Kowalczyk 2.2.1 Effects on convulsion intensity
Department of Pharmacology and Toxicology, Military Institute of These were determined on 20 Swiss strain male mice
Hygene and Epidemiology, 4 Kozielska Str, 01-163 Warsaw, divided in three groups (control and two experimental)
Poland
using a Convulsometer (Columbus Instruments,
USA). The control group received DFP (5 mg kgÿ1 sc)
* Correspondence to: Slawomir Rump, Department of and obidoxime (40 mg kgÿ1 ip) and experimental
Pharmacology and Toxicology, Military Institute of Hygene and groups additionally imidazenil (2 mg kgÿ1 ip) or diaze-
Epidemiology, 4 Kozielska Str, 01-163 Warsaw, Poland
pam (5 mg kgÿ1) immediately after the intoxication.
Contract/grant sponsor: State Committee for Scientific Research;
contract/grant number: 14863/C–T00/95
Intensity of subsequent convulsions was measured 10,
(Received 25 August; revised version received 2 November 1998; 30, 60 and 120 min after the treatment and presented
accepted 20 May 1999) in g sÿ1

Pestic Sci 55:1027±1040 (1999) 1033

You might also like