Professional Documents
Culture Documents
!
" # $ %
( 400920094 )
#((!
) $
)* ( (
* +
2013,2012
ب
ج
د
-
*+ * &*, ) ( # $ % &'! ! " !
&$ * 1* ! / 0 &/! #! ' .-(
6 ) 7 + 8(! & 46 &/! #! '
*' *' 8(! & 49 1 / 1 :; &! <# #' & =
&+(*> * */ ? &+ < ' / &+(> 4
# ; <4' ! - 8 + 0', & #
* &*, ' (> &+ , 1 ( ' ) >'
* &*+ ) 0 " C! #! , ' @ <@ + # # ! < /
) < D 4 , , #' &/! #! '>
* 6 :;! < &+ ( 6 %' + 7 E 6
0(./
<<<<<<<1+ 4 E 1!
$ 12
$% 34
! #'
G H >
I 40,
/
* 83
J +
D 7
6 7
1 F :;
K 0 '3 F :;
- :)* )%
2 + 1L1
4 +7! 2L1
5 2! 3L1
6 ! 4L1
7 ( 5L1
8 I' 6L1
9 7 3 > > 7L1
11 8L1
- " / : )%
13 " / :)* 6$
14 ' &+> 1L2
17 ' ! 2L2
19 ' ' 3L2
32 4L2
34 ; 5L2
35 ; ! 6L2
ز
) 9
$% ) ; )
77 ; J / (1L3)
78 (>! O' ) E & (2L3)
83 P G ' - 0 (1L4)
87 G 40+! F ' (2L4)
89 ' ' (3L4)
91 ' / ' (4L4)
93 '> & ) > ' (5L4)
95 ' (6L4)
:- F '
97 (7L4)
; &='
EC ( Simple Regression) ' ; N7'
99 >' ; &=' G 40+! (8L4)
EC ( Simple Regression) ' ; N7'
100 ; &=' ' (9L4)
>'
EC ( Simple Regression) ' ; N7'
101 >' ; &=' ' (10L4)
EC ( Simple Regression) ' ; N7'
102 >' ; &=' '> & ) > (11L4)
EC ( Simple Regression) ' ; N7'
103 >' ; &=' (12L4)
ط
)* 9
$% ) ; )
8 I' (1L1)
ي
<
&=' ' &; E! 2 ,
# # # =' + # K < >' ;
'E ' ' # # ' - Q #R 2+ ) / .
? ? ? (206) ' + 0 & ' &; & < 6 '
' &; E! %'! :+ N7' # ,
( <& ) <' < ' <G 40+!)
.# # # =' + # >' ; &='
&; ' :+! # N7' 8(
< >' ; &=' 5( E6 '
4/ /' <2( /' , 2 $ 8 , >' 0
Abstract
The Impact of Information Technology on Internal Control
System Effectiveness in Kuwaiti Oil Companies
The aim of this study was to identify the impact of information technology on
internal control system effectiveness in Kuwait oil companies, from the view
of financial managers and accountants in these companies. To achieve this
aim, the study employed a questionnaire survey that covered (206) financial
managers and accountants working in these companies.
)* )%
2 1,1
)* )%
2 1,1
+! 3 F # E! ' '
(+' ( .6 =' '! <6 4 , / <5@
- SE 3 '/ G 6 ' ' + =' 4 F
.' +7/ => / < F +
Q < E 4 0 ' = / 0 6 ;!
4 0 D 6 & = G < 4 0 ) / J ' 0
'! ;( ! ', =' 1! & G < > 48> ) / '3
> ' 4 8/ I'3 #7 # >;
* ' 4 += < & &+!
* # > ; ='! -( <+ / + 0
* 8 *3! &! ! 4 3 ! Q < 4 3 &0
0* * ; * &=' -( @; # <+' ; + ;
* *; # <4 3 6 # %/ & > 48>
* *' #! * <+ ! ? ; 8 , +
* * '+ * # /E' ( ! / J! 7 G 6
*+ 0 & Q < '! >' ; +! # ! 4
#! * < * T 6 4 ; E6 ' ; 4 ,
) ; 8 , ) , ? P # E! ' ,
<2010 <1 *>) * * '+ *=' + ' %( >
.(26:
* ; ! ; '+ + : 0 / K
> @ + , < '+ '
*, U> & J6 >( ) K <'+
D*' *+ #(* * N*+' + V &0 <4 > /
#* * ? ? ? ? & ; > = 1V
* * *' 1 * ' >; 40+! , <&
T! <+ ) & #, <8
1 3 0', + K # < ; ='! & / # 4 0
4 3 , 4 &/ %' <) C W ! < 48> 8! &+
* )* *0', &* 4 26 #! # C <
8 F - H ! 1 ' 0 <4 /
<* ' &; G &6 &! # ; &=' X
* / ; + 4 3 0 ! # + K
*7 * # - T '/ ; G <G'
.4 3 ; ; + 4 ; #
&=' ' &; E! 2 2+ 8
# ; 8 K , # < >' ;
# K < W( 4 &+@ K # #
! D' G' ' 4 , &+ +' # -' !
* +' *E / - # + /
1 < ; > = ? ? L0 LY/' E <
* ' # ; > /' > V # E
&=' ' &; E! 2 @; # -! ) Z , <1 /
&* 2( Q G #
* ; &=' E! ' &;
# 2 8;6 # ' ! # &P K < >'
# H F ) / # . & / 8 # # + , '
\ >' ; &=' G 40+! E! :)* )?
>'* * * ; &=' ' E! : )?
\
\ >' ; &=' ' E! :6 )?
>'* * * * ; &=' '> & ) E! :7 )?
\
>'* * * ; &=' E! :1 )?
\
; &=' ' &; E! 2 L1
' 7 = ; > = & / L2
W'! 2 @; # ; > = ) T 8( 8/, L3
. N7' V' K % & / 0@ '
! > Q # >' / ; ='! L4
# // / & = >' & , ! -
* ; * * 4 ( # K % <+ '6
#(* < >' # 7/ + # < ' - / +
/ #! , .+ 0> &E # < C 4 3 W'3
* :/' < / ; ) + W@ Q 5 !
W*( ' ' + 8( ; > =
4/ 2( /' # #] +' # + ! G
# + # # #! ; > = G 1 <
4 3 4 / < ' '+
, J' % # < 48> + , &+ & / + &
4 * * ! K + 0 >' #! 2
< ' >' G <E '
*> = E! ' &;R / 3 & #
* * * EV 2 C / ' 2
< K' 2; T ;! % &+ 1 < '
7
* <* & W/ V - <# < V
G 40+6 ( 0.05 ) T ' 7, E! :* 4
' ( 0.05 ) T ' 7, E! : 4
' / ( 0.05 ) T ' 7, E! : 4
'> & ) > ( 0.05 ) T ' 7, E! : 4
( 0.05 ) T ' 7, E! : 4
-* * F / F # N7' EC K' # , 2 <+ :;
B$ CD2
)%A
(1,1) )
=>
Q # :
9
* / F - 7 3 ' & / H P6
2+ '' ; :; + + &/ 8 3 K :
6 @ # C K </ ( 26 ) / T # C
<1 >) ' 0@ 8 3 ; &E # 26 ) / 0', &
.(25: <2010
* * #* G 40+! &; &/ :
*='6 * # 2+ &+ <+ 4C +; )
* 4 *( <E ' + 7 &+ , (, <V
+ & .( 6: <2004 < 0 ) ' - 4 / E
- # ' / ! # &; + / 6 >;
Turban and Porter, 2006, ) 0@ / , +' 0; + 2 6
.(p:162
Q < ; &=' ; ' 40+6 F
Laudon ) '! - G' & / 4 40+6
+ => < 7 '0; @ >
) >' @ + '! + ?> #(
< ' / < '
.(Seen, 2008, p:35) ' #; #F #
# ' + ! # # (
< >' 5 4 3 ' V :
* * *>; *+ * >' ' ; # &/
4 *') 1 * /' 70 - ) I'3 2
.(2009 <86 <+ V # 4 >
11
. >' - : $ ,1
>'* * * # # # # ' Q ; : $ ,2
. I' 4 F - # ' &+' <
.2012 + 2012 # 4 > @; ' : D $ ,3
12
)%
)%
K ' / & > 2 , > 2+
?! `X 1 =' > , , K < ; &='
' 1 =' 3 6 ' Q # E , > & / & < '
Q ' < ' a 6 &+> Q # ; &='
. W( / +P 6 &6 'E
<* += 8* ' ' &; <+ #+ # F < '+ !
* 0* - Z 4 >' &=' +>=
+ ; 'R +/ 4 ; K' #! , ' , &P # <
#* 5*! )' # <( ; +@; G@ !
#* * &=' %E! ' + ; ='! 4 (
<*>; ; &=' & / EC # + Technology
# ' ; & / , # % K
* *; #, , <( -( 0 /' 4 ; @;
14
Turban et al, 2008, ) ' & ' EV
.(p:160
* ' 5 # =' #b +'! , (, < #( ? ! ? 7 ?80
! * * - 2 ' +! <+ + - -
4 * @; # 2 H >; , (, < ; 7 &! +>' 8
2* = 4 % .# /' & =' < #0;
. 7 - G' + + ' '
#* 4> # < ' &; ' -
#, < * *7 #* 80 ' ! Q < ' , '
H *> *+' >; EC '
* ' */ * -* # . ; ='!
4 * =' > ; W #( <+ '/
O’brien, ) F - > ' ' '+ <
.(2008, p: 507
# &+' < # / G' &+ & =' %+ # <
%*' @; # <! K , %+> G ' !
Q* <* ' & &+> ! ' 2 ' #! ! F' <
)* 2* P # / # # < # HF # E %
# E* * EC* > =' C '
* ' 5 & > # += K < ! ( 80, &+7 Z 6
:+'
# ; # E #, , <+ +E +'0; + ' -
&=' # > ' +/ G ' E &=' ;
.0@ N ' 40+6 #(
&=' G & 1 1 3 +'C (Hayes, 2009, P: 23) + K
& .=' ''3 2; +/
# > # &; +'! 2; , + ! 2; '
& &; 4 3 # &=' 8' &; 6)
' #( < F / ; +
# # <' <40 N < '> N
806) / ' W'! - ) +'C ( ! ' 2
<8 3 <' < < < <%/ G
K +'0; +/' + =' < ' &; ( 6
# +E + ', - <+ ; ; <+ ' +
* * )* / + & ' T ;6 4 7
; + # + )E , + +' 0; +
& <& E ' ' ! C
- # 4 3 + + ! ' +P!
< ; ' / # F 5 #!
K < <4 3 <83 / # @;
4 , = # , T! 1 6 < & I'3 ;
.(362:
' 8 # % 4 c ' 5
/ 40 > + ; ! <4 4 7 ;
7 ( 7> # GF : 9 ,1
.( ' 4 V &; ) @/ , / LI
.( ; ' &; ) '> / L
18
! <8 3 H 2 ! < [ &=' &; ' &; L*
.+' ;
EC +' ( ! : G 9 ,2
<2004 <Y ' ) :+' <+ +( & E! ' # .+'
(80:
0 K E ) T ;6 / L2
.(
.> 4 3
J' < 3 / F 48>
.&
19
< <( ) 0 (
' #R K 8d ' .' '3 # F &=' '
/ F Q +; + & % '
H '> & ) H' H ' <G 40+ : ' ;
/ 40+6 806 ' G 0 + ( !
Q ' - J J J> 40+! +
' ' &! %/ G 40+! + + '0;
27= G < ' 6 G 0+ <
; G ) ; & F )! ' # 40+6 #
4 E % 4 <2 # + ;
- ' / 2 # 4 , < ' >V 40+6 W'
) 40+6 W' ; 4 3 H > < P
< ; + 4 27= &/ 7 80! # G #
' / ;3 40+! :(Input Devices) )/ $ ,
# & .G &=' , +;3 ' , , +
<(Key Board) 5 > E + G ' ;, +@;
.T ;6
&/ <47 E! , + &; '
&! < ' 8d <G F 4 >' &/
< 7 => - @ <)' G 4 # # < /'
&/ 'E # 0; 40+! ! . @; ' V
. 8'E! N ' # 0;
' I ;3 (Output Devices) :=/ $ ,
.G 7+' &; &+> +( G &=' # ' ' 3
! < / +/ G # ' I ;R 5
<I ;3 ;3 40+! < 0 4 #
.# ;
N W'! - &( + < 'E ' ' #,
F & # V N <+ =' (Hardware) 40+6 F 0@
+ @; # ' G' E +'! 1! .G
#0; H F G , (, 4 '/ &; < 4 , %
Q # < 3 27= 8! // ' -
> 4 , ' + # + 7+ #0;
) / #( / ' 0 4 >' 0 #
='6 & V ' ', , I < 2!
+'C (Martin and Brown, 2009, p: 57) 2
# > +'! 1! .G &=' Operations
G ' % (N ) #'3 # 4 6
.(60: <2002 < 7 ') 4 N7' H F ' /
22
G ! < 7 E >; ' > # ;
# P 4 + '! G + 0 73 !
++ # N # # ! 6 -( &
! 1! 8 , ', - G , ; Q <%' 27= 0',
Kim, ) :# ' , &/ . / ! 6 #
(2003, p: 16
% &/ G +; :System Software ,1
# 0; ;3 & W'! 2; <% !
+ & ; ='! .G 40+! I ;3 'E 7
; > &+ (CPU) 0 4 4 F &/
# T ;6 % & +7( <+' ) ' T ;6
Thompson and Cats-) : &=' < #( G
(Baril, 2003, p: 39
N # # # <) >' G
*F *! , F Q <F
.PASCAL
# > ; 4 &/ :Utility Programs 8 ,=
&/ K <+ ' > N G '! E <
# ;* 4*7 * 2+ <' '! 8! ' G &=' %
* <:*' * E % 27= >' ) &; <&='
N * *E 4 ! ; 27= K < ' 3 <' < ' 3
27= # P < < <
.(Excel) 6
24
N ) E N #' <' W # 0; &
.4 F
*' * <7 ; ' & ; '
# '! :7; + F ='! G ; ( 6 # K < &='
25
< ='! F &=' 4 , / => ) N )/ #!
%* &=' & ' # 6 ;V #! G #! #, ,
#* >* #* & #( )7 5 > 8 3 # -( @; #
&*=' *, ; G@ ', # :; 1! -' + ; I ; 2
# * 0 <+ ! > 48 @ @; # K
<H +( - ' # ' E
4 @ 8d ' # <' ! @; # + , 4 &
! ! 6 @ ' # 4 W'! # ?/
> # 4 /' & =' ' #!
/ '0; ' # Q <' @ ( +( -
# .(Turban and Porter, 2006, p:73) , + '
' :+' < F & > '
# < ; F ' # ; '
' # ' # 0; &/ :Data Warehouses ;D ,=
' ? 7 ? / < / '
<- ; ' # 80! ! fg' - 0 4R & / #
! ! F ' # ?;g' # 0 '
G # 7+' # ; # 4 ' > # >; W'! #
# & # ! < ; / # & / < # 4 E ,
# P ? World Wide Web ; <' '3
4 , &=' @; # &=' ' 4 - ' &;
& @ <+' + -/ Data Base Management System :DBMS '
27
# 4 ' 4 , &=' # < K @; # , ' -
+'! +> Q # + % <' 4 :+ ,
! ' 2 +' 1 < )'! )' 1
./ ) + / ' , ) &; &! D + </
(, # ' 4 2; >' 5 : ,B
. ' # C N' 8 'R ' 4 4 , &='
4 # ' # > # + :A @ ,=
< F +', , <' % # #! G 1 '
&; 4 1 # > 5 </ 4 ; G
.&='
<' 4 8' &; N :C 8 ,
#/> ! 2 # &=' ! # +' # 0; 4, <+;'
E ' - # %' + C &; 0
4 2+ <' Q <# 0; ; Q <- <8>;, <, <2 < (,
# # # ' 4 # ' / # < / ; ;
28
48> # E 1 ' 4 , &=' < >
+ & ' % # 4 ' #! Q T
/' @ ? G 40+! @; # + ; + 4 &
> '0; ' # % 1 8 # 4 ' / .+'
.+' 4> + , W + 4 > 5 + + &
<' 40+6 F N + ' -
' , <40+6 ' ! N ' +' ) 8d
8' < ' T ! + <1 >
.(255: <2010 <#@0 ) 4 F ' 2 = - 2 / 1 > J!
(56: <2004 < 0 7 ) : # , '+ '> & ) &/
&=' 4 7 #( 1 ) > & < 3 &=' # ' L1
' # # V #' <G 4 7 #( # 6 & < '> & ) L2
& < 3 &=' ; < &=' 40+6 ,
.' ; E 3 &=' / &; # #V 6
0 0 '+ '> & ) ! #! , ( 9: <2002 < ' )
&+ G' & +' G <# ; T 4
29
<+ +' 4> #! , 7+ >
=' ' G &9 / ' ='! G
. % V ' %'C , / 1 < /' + 5
# # 8' 6 +@; # +> ! + ! ) / , 1V
& + # , + 5 1 ' >; +' '
, % 1 # # ) + , 2+ .' W'
; / 2; ; H P3 + / -' -( 2;
K K ) / , 2+ #! . / ='
<( =' W ) T W +' ) 8 4 2 >;
<2010 <1 () T ;6 =' - 7 #( W +' ) &!
.(137:
, 0 , ( 35: <2010 < )
! =' 6 ' &6 7 # ' '
& ;! =' += 7 E < ; + # +7
; 8 += ! , < , 4 +=! <
7 # 4 + ! </ , # +/'
?' .H +( - G =' 0@ 40+6
< / ' & F 48> - &+ + E 4 3 '/ ?0
40+9 1 F < /' + 48> @; # K
' /' < <+; K
# [ W'6 %'! , (Laudon and Laudon, 2006, p: 272)
# <? ' F F /'
/' ; ! # 4 # K < / =' # # ! / # 4
< # W' 0 .' '3 @; # T ;!
G ' ) = # 4> & < ;
, += <T ;! , 4 T
4 =' + & G
)' F &/ .4 F - + '! '
G .' '3 4 E! #! <&
# ! ; &=' 2+ &=' E @; #
40+! &; G . 7(> @; # ! 4 C ; @;
' ! < 7( 2 ! <@ <2 ;) 7
# &;( & (, < # ; - &8@ (
, 1V <4 +; & / # =' #h .
! F /' &; +'! , <+>' !
4 F /' #( ' / ! + ( ! # ,
6 <# ! 1V # W' #( G 0+ #C 0
Laudon ) &; # > 1 2 (Client) #0
&/ 40+6 - #C 0 #! ' < &;
G 40+C @; # K & - F
@
? 7 ?/ #V Q ( )
E G ' # N 0 > 1 . ' )
4 7 < > <:' < < P>
.(2006, p: 60
& *=' *; (* ! * 3 ' &!
* * - < / ; ) '
33
*=' < ' # ) , 4 ( 1 D' ) /
+ ' +> = 1V 3 ' # ! ' +', ,
* 2*6 )* / D' T &/ Q <E 3 40+6
G *6 @* #* *C K < >' T 4 3 +(
. ; 7 # K 26 ) / 8 3
*; 2*6 - %' / 0', & J % , 2+ ) ;
5(* ( ; # 2 ' 5 0@ 8 3 ; <(
./ 4 2! ; ! + & / # &+ L1
. >' &0 T ( ; >' @ L2
& / ; > = G! 1 ' '
J C @; # K <>; '9 >' > + 4 3 & / '
C < =' ' # G @/ @; # ; N
, K <&+7! # & ! # # # 3 5'
<) + 2 6 7 3 % 4 3 ,
.(36: <2009
34
; + ; 8 3 &! ! ; &='
# 6 4 3 # 48> &=' ) , <+'
<# , ; +( # / <++ ;
E <G %' )' 1 J6 ; &=' & /
&=' # <' ; G' N' ! ' % 0 /'
Q < ''3 K 'C + ? =' ; > =
+ #6 ?( ! +'! <( -(; G ) # ! & + ! #!
#R ' # <& / :> &+ ! 6 W(; ) # K EC
<G % & 1 :7; & 2 D'
8 3 ; & / ; V G
@ # 4 7 7 6 0', # 7 # <@
>' + 4 3 4 & / ' J G #! Q <% ' 6
7 ', ' < ( -7 Q6 @; # 7 ' <+ '!
&/ < ; N' -( @; # '
26 1 3 ' ''/ &0 '
2 2+ K <4; 4; >' ' ; ; &+
+ GF <4 3 + -/ E ' 8;6
0 @ #( < ; > #! 8 3 ; G'
< / 2 0 ) 0 = #0 ) / , 1V V
.( 203: <2008
* F )* / *' 1* &=' # 80 K +'C ;
2 ** 4 3 + 4 ! <='
# C <+; + *6 ) / T* <&+0', # 8!
<J) ; 4 2 '3 #( < / >'
.(183: <2009
*/ /E / 26 ) / > 4 +' J 7 2+ <
*6 / < 48> 57 # '/ &0 &7/
W* #* * + 7* < / &=' 27= /
. # '/ ) : ( G@ YF 2 8;6
* >' # # C # +' 4! %' E 4 c ; &=' ! #,
* &7*/ / 26 ) / <(
Q* <&;* 8 G@ # ! <+ , / /
* <*+@ + 2( /' &=' & / 4 3 # G
36
K* <# * # *+ # Q6 ; (!
# 7/ :; 6 K < 3 2( ; # # 2 + 6
*; * >' 8*'E! * ' * 5 >'
8! ' 8;6 2 ', 40+! E ; 40+!
** *6 48, ! 8;6 G -' Q <
* Y *> :*> 2 3 ' <J@; W ( # +
* *; ?*/ * 8 * # , )/) +'C +> # <)/
! # C; ! 2( ' # + +( ! <(4 / 4/ 4
* *+ &*/ > = ) ( ! ' <(415: <2008 < ) -' + /
( + > 29 ?/ #! # )/ / ;
&*=' * H +( ' 1 ?=' ;
# ' / K <47> # ' ' ! / , @;@ ( 5
&+> #! Q <>; ! W( # E
* #! < '+ # G >; '0
&* *+' 4* K T ;! , V # 2; &='
* ''/ =' ' # 0; / <+ '
; (COSO) 6 I' # E
&=' -( # V 4 3 . ; &='
<* 48> 8! &+3 1 3 0', + 2+ < ;
2*6 #! #* *C < 4 3 4 <) C W !
* 1 ' 0 <4 / ) 0', & 4
8 *3 # # & # ; &=' T &
*' * 4; #( : 2 ,1
8 *3 < ; & / < 7 ++ + G # < &='
* #! # C < P &=' < &=' <
# K <6 4; + & & , : 9 - ,2
2 * * %* & %>( &=' T , !
* K 8( /@ % ; <8;6 -' '
2 *= 4; @; & , :CK - B # $ ,3
#* <+E ' 4 c / G < &7/ , EV
* * * 8 , ) # C 4; :0/ + ,4
<) ; =@ 1' :> E 7 H &; @; # <+ ;
Simon, 2002, p: ) + V 8C ! ' ; 8! ' /
.(71
K < &=' T & @; # # 4; : 92 - ,5
*! 2( ! G P &=' & < &=' ' # C
+ & / 2 = E , <&=' 2( & & %'R < '
<&*=' * & # %'R < 8 , ; 4 8'E!
* K , K #R < 8 , ; & 8;6 > , J
* 1* #! G* > &=' #! , (214 : <2000 <Y)
@ ( ( ; E =' 27= /' ( ; L1
*( 8 *, * - @ '6 &7@ &=' L2
, 4 27= &+ & / # # , L3
. +; :;
2@*; * # >=* 0*', 6 ' 86 4 ( L4
.&+
.H
^ % , 4+ 3 & / G
-*( ' / '+ J! ' ; ) &=' L6
.)
* 4 *' ( 8 3 ; &='
'(* < 4V> =' 4 #( + # +
40
@* C; YF 2 -' 4 3 &0
: 9 :A
* &*=' */ &+ ! &+ , 4 3 # 2 '
#( 8 H EC 7 <4 ' % ! ;
G*! 4 3 >* <% # 4 3 J > = :E 7 J
* ?* ? V 7 . &=' 4 ' =' + < F
#* *+/ <4 ='! ; ) &! < &='
*; *, 1V <@; 0 # &6 / 4 3 # 2
^ &
: :
+ >' #( 4 3 + 8 3 K '
*' W*' W' G W' <E6 G6 / +;
#( < ; 2 ) / H F 7 ( < % 1
&*=' *7 / 4 @ : / & / 8
: - :
< *; *+ 4 3 * > ; + &
* * < ; ; 2 = Q6 ' R +' ) ;
/ , , 4 EV
41
(; + 4 , G , ' 4 3 E, - )>
*+ #* 4 & # '/ >; # ; >' <1! 8,
4 *; / 8 3 N ; , #( <
* *; & / ; ='! 5> .T ;! ! > G
E 2! -( < ; EV ! ; EV # 8 ++
# 4 ; & / # K < ; & / ! (
*= .6 86 ; 4 26 ) / @ ;
*+ ! Q* # K # E! 2 + 1 ( # %' ;
.(Frazier, 2001, p: 45) + & / G ; + , > +E /
I*', * &*/ %' < &=' ' &! # &='
' # &=' # <G' + '
*3 <' 8 , :; ! Z G N <( Z G 40+! ')
* = # <4C ' @ @ /
4 3 *, + , G .K / # )/
* &* / * & '0 , K ; +' # ;Z
&*/ #! + <+ G #! - .T ;6 V ;
Q6 ; Q6 ) K G' + /E # 7@
*, 6 # ) ' # %' ) ! . ;
+ - G' # C 4 3 & , (, / ! ! J ! >6
42
'/ > 4 3 4@ + 6 ) / E + # ; T ;!
Taylor & ) * + % )E &+ # ) / +
: :
#! #( < '0 4 86 ' & / ; ='!
#( ; ='! & G .4 + & T ;6 ) N7'
.(Taylor & Glezen, 2004, p: 426) ; # 80
G* * &*=' & / Q # ' #(
:* ) * 86 #* * ) / # < 7 2 = F
* &* , *; )* ; ) 4 4 3 &=' & / L!
* & <G' , & / 4 3 LI
., # # >= 2 , 1V #! # G' + &
)* * < >= E # C # ; # / & / L
*7 EC* Q H K < ; &=' ' EV
&*=' c / +' + ! ; &+> '
Treadway *' #* /E' =' (COSO) ' %( 1 ;
: ' K (AICPA) # ''/ # 6 + # /E'
J* * >' :%'! ; > (COSO) ' (
*E 26 ) / # / #( & # >= 4 3 ! 4 4 ,
" > < / # '/ >' &0 < &7/ :
*''R " * 6" + ' ='
* ' #! ; < ; &+> ' EC K' J %'! T '
N * & &/ # #! <' 40+6 N # #
* ' */ & *> - )> &+> # K < 6 & ' -(
.
2! 0'3 ?7@ ? , (COSO) ; &=' 3 j
.&0 2! < / 2! < F 26 E@E ;
* = E ; 2! #! (82 : <2009 <)
* &; < 48> 2 ) / <+' @ C <
44
* @ # C E ' = 2! #R <48>
(3 <7 > @ <@; Q @ < ; @;
# /* ' ' F 4 <4 3 J # '
.# ;
#* * ' 7 EV 7 &+ #
(Taylor & Glezen, 2004, p: 440) : 0 ; )
E* */ 4 3 * ) :) @ - C/ ,
* *' ' 0 0 ) : ) . ,B
! ' 7 ) & ) : / + ,=
< 8 , ='! & F ) E, 4 3
.G @ )7E % D ', <> N %=>
4 3 8 , ) :<* - 0/ ,
I ; ' ) 4, ' /
K < ' = % ; K' K / < /
.+ +/ G :7; 2 + #
:
G* * / ' EV : ,
<#6 +' ! 4 & 48> EV <% & /
* G* ) / < G! F +' ='6
* @*; #* @; , &/ < ' % D ;
G K 8;6 5 ! -' ! 2 / < ;
! Q*6 #* +' ; ) E : ,
#* # W' ' EV <+ GP P
G <='6 N % D P -' @;
# 0; ) ! E ) &; 0 / K <' , ;
.C; @ >, -' +'! # @( <( : 6
' ' @; & 8;6 &+ :#A ,
*+ - 2 G < ' 1
46
* * * * 48 &; G 8;6 # W'
* ' EC G <%>' &=' # ;
* *+'! <4 8;6 G' ) & , I +'R # W'
2 * 3 * * ' H *> <) K+ H >;
.
C*; 5 * * &/ <+E 8;6 &+ : $ $% ,
* #! Q* <K* &*/ ' G <%7'
8;! Q ' 4 ' ! '
-( < ; ='! G' , ' ( / : ,=
G* K* * ' K* *; - G' # K
+*( ! *0 ) # + => > ' &+ : * L ,
*, @; # ' # # <G
.T ;! /
*C @; # K <@ ' ' &+ : L ,
* ' G ' <> @ #
* -* */' GC ' : ; -
<8*;6 * F 2 3 <+ / &+ 0'3 0@
4 3 * * =*> < F + &+ :( * L ,
* F * K* ; & / ; ; & G'
* * *' EV ' 2 =
*+ ! Q # C & 2 = ; =' + # 4 ; <
4 * * ! * F J/ ; < 2! ) / EC
#* * * * +E G ' <+ EV 4
* ; # # / + #
< *; K & / / W, G K # <+ ' 6 / 4 ;
) ( ! <) 8 , EV 4 ; T 4 / #
; 8 3 W, 4 ; /
#* *> * * + G' ' +' < ; 7+'
*+' <'; l # ' ! @ - / P @
8@ P &+ 0'3 (> / +'! , (, < ;
* ! ' ' ; & / &/
<* ' , ; @ &+ # :; 6 (Critical Data)
48
& * / &/ < ='6 K ) E ) <+E ='6 : &/
* ; * &*=' *; &/ ;! <# >= / 8 3
.(Isaacson, 2003, p: 2)
# <) G 40+! # K
4C* G* 40+! &; &+ < ' # # /
+ 7 &+ <='6 # P &+ <V ='6 &; <)
&*+ < * ;! ) G ; + 6 - <='6
<+E* T < 4 ; E )' <='6 K - >
* ' *= * :*; * ; & ) &! #,
K * ) G < > 4 ; - <
#! * < *; K =' + E #( < ; & / 4 3 -
4 *; ! ! Q 4 ; ! & / # / 4 3 & #
Grand, ) ; K 2 ;! + H & / K <) #
.(2001, p:12
*> :#* #* K & # <7 > &+
4 3 4 ) G K <'0 < ; <8@
K* .* K* G -' # < #! G # <' #! #
49
* EV Q6 # C ' = # ; # / G
* /' 4 *; < * 6 ' @; >( G ; L!
.6 ; ' + D P @ ; E +' '
*; *; '(* <( *; 7@ 4 ; ) 4 ; Q ', LG
K > .C & 2 = :4 ; 7 (/ - ', L*
7 &; , (2 # 7 T) > T L
*+' * ( P &! 6 '! 8 ) 6 ; & / L!
*; <G* 40+! ; 6 ; E6 # < /' F
* P 6 ; ) ! <:; 6 ; <) E ; <4 6
50
*; < F 4 / & ; <N ' ; :+'
*/ '! 8 ( ='C / :( T L0
+* #* > / &! 48> # ' + # 48>
. /' F
#! ) G < ; ; 46 ! / ' +
G 2! ) / #( K <4 3 - K +7' ; /
*; & * / * . *; &; + ' # 7> & 4 3
(p: 11
* + 6 <4 7 + 6 G : )% $ ,
.+ / ' K <+ / ; <='6 <N <G - :
* 'E 4; C <6 4; , :)%* M 74 7 ,B
4* + ! '! 8 ; 4 7 ' : $ ,=
.6 # E! ! W' , 4 # #! G ; <4 P &!
Q*6 #*! # 4 7 :2 . B$ 74 ,
*E! + , ; -( ( ! < ; , I
-* ; 2 ) > 8(! &/ ' : "$ 9 74 ,(.
K* +' K <K 4 V > ( #
. ;
&/ 4; :($ ) $ )%* B$ ! 3 ,
+ ! G ( ; ( E6 ) 6 7 -( )
K* ' D 7 < ; & / / # >' 80
. ; & / 2 ) 8! 4 7 & 1 : #' L
. f <) > 7 <4 7 , : L
.+ ! G 4 7 6 -( :6 L
K* G*' 2* -* + ! G ; H : ; ! -( L
. ;
52
* &( + . ' Q
8 *, * => <86 < C ! E >; ' #
* *7 * *+/ # '6 .+ => ' @ , <#6
0 G ' 7 @ ' &! # < ! '
<(2010) <# - <# ) : # +
(12:
.+ G' Q6 /> 5 L
* *='! *= * ( #! , (8: <2000 < /)
* ' /* * #* G*' + # #! G ' #,
G &; / &+ # ) E@E K' # K <
(Pathak, 2000, p: 4) :
. ; # 80 # / # ' ; L!
1 (* #* '/ - F G %'! Q T )
4 , +/ ' F < # 8 3
4* ' F , 1V < / - '
*(, V* -(* 4 G 40+! #! <+/ > +/ #
* 8 *3 * 1 ( # %' < 7+' &; ) '
86 E * *+' * ' 4 ' +'( # < 6
* ' 4 0 < ' &; 6
)7E , & , <+@; # @ >' 8 ! )7E &
&;* #/* - * , <) * > = + 6 # g
# * 5 < + + 0 '
54
* *@ *! , <8@ E! 8 3 ;
* / # Q <) / ' 5 8, , K # <)
.(Grand, 2001, p:17) / %7 # E!
; ! K' +! + ' ' )
4* 0 #* ' < 8/ D' ='6
K + 1V ; ='6
<* ; F ' 7/ F < 2 9
J* * (, <' K /' 2 H >; P 4 ; : ,
*+ ', / ' E 2
' 7 + ; & /E #! (Ozier, 2009, p:12) T
* 1V* * 4 * 8;! Q -' #! #
<&+' ; # ' #! K # >= G <
*+ ; 4 , &+ G #! 8 ; # /
<*'0; <* < ' ) / 6 E 8@
< ) ) 4 , )
( <) / # '/ ='6 , > ) / <(
55
* # K G 4 0 G '
- * F # N' K <# ' GC + ' +! 4 , # <&
! * * #! * < K 7 EV '
* * ' 7 = ' +(
K* * #* ( - )> [ # #! ,
.
# ; #/ ! # + - ', K' # #! LG
* * ' *7 &+ D # >= 4 3 &/ #! LI
' ! ' = G
# K & <G' ; # ', ! # <# >= # 27=
G V 27= #! . ! ' ' '
# + #! < ' 6 >' # # V
#* EV ' #! (Tucker, 2011, p: 45) T
' # # < ' / 8 ', > ,
*+ 8;6 2 + , < 2! )>
* ) # %'! , ( Gleim, 2002, p: 278)
: ) # ( !
-* < * ' # / 2 ' L!
* @*; ' 8/' - , # ) # ' LG
&=' & ) 2 ) # K 8'E - ' F
.8'E -' 2 + # N -( %@,
K' #! , < ' G
#* *C ' <VF, ! F ! ;[ G # +/' +
G* * * #6 < / ; + + @
* #, , <2 3 ) # + +'! =>
.(Richter, 2002, p:6-9): #( ' 7
* ) / #/ # GP : ) ,
0'3 % D &; ! &+ G K < ! ' >
*' 4 + 4 # & < W@3
57
* ' 7 = # V :; 6 4 ( ' < 7 &! 4
*, 5* G*! - I : ) ,B
* T < 70 T T K '
*7 T* T* ' 4 =' , #
, # &+'R 70 T ) ! . '
# * * ; ! G :- ,=
* E! ?0 +7, ' F ' # : 9 :A
H* K' < '> 8> <8 3 <+ V ! <+ &
', '> 8> / J 4/ +'! :E ' 7 / (/
! * 0 * *+'! < ; ='6 - 8> K > ( !
*; + , I +'! < ' - G K ; H>;
4* ; 4 3 & ; & / #, : - :
* ' 2! ) /) ; ; #, </ 4 26 ) / ',
# ' - ' + # #! # (+ ; +
58
<*+ #! ' ; & G K < # T ;6 )'
&* 8 3 #( ' #, : :
='! # < ; H >; 2! ) / #( +(
*/ * / # ' '!
* 4 3 + #, : A%A :
4 7* 4* * E ' 4 , #! <26 ) /
* ' * * ' + &3 '
, <@ 2 9 + Q6 ' Z &/ <+
+ @* T* +* T ' 7 4 #,
* F *+ -' ( / + + T G' +;
*7 ; &=' @ ;C ' #, : :
P 26 +/ / & 26 # # +'6 <:; '
* ' 7 # < 2! H ) / & G! -( +'! <//
K* )* * ', T* 2*6 * * F (
* * >' * * *E ' &; 0 G %' K
2 *= / > 4 0 , 6 &/ 2+ <4 ;6 ' ;
&*/ <&* * 2! ) / 0', 48> ) / C &
.
H* # 4 3 < W( / 5 Q &
: # W( 4 @ +
4 *( 0 < / + 1V ; & / 2 1 ) # <
<' ' ; ='C ; E
(* ! * * :* ; +' 3 76 H (
* * * \ ; ) # +, # #
+=! . N+' ; <) (261) # ' ' '
< * + 7 ! F 2 : ( ! #!
*/ 8 3 &+ ; 4 , T ;6 2 6 - ) ' 4 (
= Q ) , 1 / ) > ' / -( L1
. '
# * *;6 - ) ; ; ) 4 ( L2
<* ' ' /' 8 , + , 2+ K <V
' :;6 ' ) & 4 8
(206) #* ' ' .:; &
: N7' , ; . ' #
* * ; ' ' l /E EV L1
* F * * # Q < F E , /E 2 ' # L2
EV* * /E 7 &( =' ' L3
*' *+ > # /E F *' /'
F - &=' K #, Q < + ;
(- ( " :#' (2005) 4 >; < ,
* * * * ' &; E! 2 ,
' ; + <E &=' &; < &;)
-* < 3 / J / (0' 86 4 < E6 &;
(111) # ' ' ! . V + > G6 Q
:+! # N7' 4 , . 0
- :E 0', 26 ) / &+3 , ' &; T! L1
*, <+ E6 &; ) / , ' &; T! L2
. / ' &; # 7, @ L3
62
( ( ( - 9 <9% :#'.(2007) < ''/ L
* * ' * '/ 7 :7; H 2
* * T J (@ #6 :7; <8@ :7; < 3 :7;)
F * ; :7; EC T , (3 < ' 6 2
* 4! * Q & .2 + # ; # / ' 6 2
# ' %' (64) - 0 & / 1 =' 3 , ' (# )
* ' 6 2 * * * ; 7 # # # 1 -
:+! N7' # , .2 + # ; # /
' '/ 7 :7; T #C 2 + # ; # / ' 6
. ' 6 2 (@ #6 <8@ < 3 :7;) &='
EC* T #C 2 + ' 8 Z # 7, ) L2
2 * F ; &=' ' '/ 7 :7;
. ' 6
63
Auditors
> Efficiency 48> Q # ' &=' & / ,
* ) ' / <Economies &=' Effectiveness
+' 0@ / & / + +8> T # )/ ;
*; #* * / ; & / , (, <; /
4 +E! / 3 @ '
&*=' * ' #6 ( 8 , T '
# '/ 4C ' - ; ( 8 , ) T <
* * * ; / (379) ' % Q T ! <
W # (%27) %' 1! ' (102) +' ! %' &; 4
' &=' &+, /> ' ! L1
* ' &*=' 48*> T* - 4 ( &+, )> ' C L2
.
N [ 0 + 4 ' 8 ! ' C L3
' &=' ( 8 , ) &+, )> ' C L4
#* *=' HF K <4 G C I ; ' , 4 '
* *E6 N # 4 3 0' '! &+ / # / # /
' ' . 6 < ' 2
. # ; / &=' & / ) # G L1
( $ :#' .(2010) <4(/ L
; &=' E! # ,
* *+ 0 & , <%' ' - Q ! < ' 6 K'
< ' 6 K' ; 4 7 # 6 E -
65
* .(T) *; ' > 83 @; # K
Q < ' 6 K' &=' EV L1
* / , <' / < </
.%! K <K' + &/ >; 6 - #
* ' 6 K' 3 &=' , E! K' L2
. 3 < F < 3 / ; I', Q
K' ; ( &=' , E! K' #! L3
2 * *, + 8 3 ) ' 7 - # @; # ' 6
Auditors
&=' ' > ='6 C ; &=' 2 ,
# * C 48> T <&=' >' K < &=' 48>
* / G ='! ' ' 3 &=' 48> T <&='
! ' < &=' / # P ' ='!
< * 2*! ) / ; ) +/ ; )
66
* 6 ' # YF -' + 8;6 2
*! &+ 0 K 4 3 + H ' ; & # / <+
< / =' % / ; &=' 48> T ; ; )
* V K' # ; # / & 5 8 R
:+! N7' # , #E .2000 & 4
4* * (, &+ 2 ; ; ) &=' #! L1
#* %'(* ) / 6 ; 26 ) / ='
Y*F * 8;6 2 # &+> , N7' ! L2
&='* / =' G' ) ( , G@
.
An E-Risk Primer
* * '+ ' &; E! # ,
*' * * ! <(AICPA) # ''/ # 6 - & 8(
N7*' #* * , ; .4 ' # 7
:0 !
#* # EV ; ' #! L1
* * *'! ; / 7 # <; ; '
* * &*+ 4 ( ) # G (94) & SAS #! L2
* *; * >' & ) #! + 8 <) ; ;
. ; >' '6 ' ; ; & / ;
)* <+ ; ; #( ' &=' #! L3
* &+ >' ! # + / :7; 2 & / 4 (
# E, ! ) I ' 3 ; & ' <)
. P ! &0 / 48> T
<) * ' EC &+> ; + ) #! G L4
+ &+ # 4 - #! G <) &='
: ) ; :#' :(2011) < L
9D -
* ; &=' > # 2
#( 2! ) / @; # 70
.4 ' # '/ &0 / E '> & ) 48> F
#! # * N7' +=! . 70 / !
) 48> K < 70 ; &=' > & #
4* & * / *+ @; # / E 4 0 + #! Q < '> &
*8@ @ 4 3 J / / a
68
* ' Q / ; D 3 8@ T & / '
. ; 8 R &0@ ' G ' # G
: / $ .(2011) <2 < L
&=' % ; 2 ,
, 1V G6 &! 2 <40P W 2 '
8 R Q & , . ; K W # 8 3 ; K Q
:+! N7' # <K' - '
#! , < [ &=' + 40P W 2 L1
W > Q 2 ' >= - )>
0 &+' # #; #>= ' G ='! F %+ 2=
<40P W 2 &=' ; Q & L2
% # >= K P ;3 ; # <
E! Q Q ; E! K &+ D P :; ! , '
. ! 4 , + 4 #
K' >= ) G! , - ' &=' ; Q L3
& ' 2 4 R ) G! , (, <G 4 ; '
.2 T / 6 8 3 2( (
69
+ C/ 1 .(2012) < 0 L
; ) 4 3 J 2 ,
' 2! ) / E! (COSO) 6 I' G
- ' 8 R Q & Q .(&0 / F )
' ! ! .(27) l ) 9 ) '
)* E ; ) # @ , N7' ;
< ; 80! ! ' < ; # 2+ 4 3 K , &+
&; T < ; ) 4 , 48> < ; 80! # 80
2! / ; 26 ) / # (+' 4> '
* #! Q 5( / W( @ / H
; &=' ' &; E! J , H & +'! L1
@
?( ; ! ; ) 0 += #R K < >'
N * * 8*;6 2 > G ) 8 , > 0 +'! L2
: @ # 0 # K
; &=' ' &; E! J / & L1
. >'
. >' 7 8 & ' +' L2
71
6 )%
2
82 1,3
6 )%
2
82 1,3
>* G*6 Q* *+ - ' #
* ; &=' ' &; E! 2 2+ <
@*; #* * F ' / ' & , < >'
; + 2+ K <J / F , P F
K* 2 , < N7' # ( >
*' , @; # + ' # E V 2 @; # < E6
*! < * * l >' # - #
* >' # # # # ' ; & %'R ' :;
# ?n 25 ' ; Q & Q < > = &+ 2;
* 5 < >' - E #
(211) * &* < - - 0 Q & Q .? (250)
' 5 & 0 < ' , # (%84.4) ' '
73
# * # (206) (; ' / K <+7 & +'
*' >'* * ! *+ >' W/ ; Q G !
* * <>' ! < ' @
* 4 * * ?+ ? 0 >' # <1 W/ + +C '
* / # * */ 0 ' W/ <E ' + '!
. /
, < 4 / ? ? >' J
; &=' ' &; E! ! C
* 3 * *'6 2; ?! +' # < >'
. '3
* 7 ', , - # 4' &/ #! Q V
4;[ >' 5 4 3 V <&1980 & V
&/ Q <@ >' W/ + ' <- '
? Q + @; # >' ' ; #
*70 -* ) I'3 2 >; +
* *3 *+ & V 6 > = E <1 /'
* *V #* 1' /) >' ' 1 /' - )
+ + @; # >' ; # &/
+ C V (' < ( 10 ) l
> 4 ') : [ &( &6 V !
' 3 0 ' >' +! & 1934 & C : ,1
#[ ) 6 0 2 (BP) ' & #[
* * ' + I', 2 V <(# >
/' ! &;(! ! K <& 1957 & C : : ,2
/' ! &;(! ! 4 , K@ < ! :; <& 1
0F @' ' @' &; >' @' &( <& 1
. J! < 0F 4 ' &; >'
0 ) &/ <>' 4 , <? :; W/
-' E@E 4 , <1963 & C : % ,4
! <# ' I'3 -' E@E 7 ' 4 3
# ' ' # + C & / < ,
' # <+' %42 '
4 - ' ;( &( <%6 ' ' # / %10
75
V # 4 > 4 ') @ # E 4 # E
' %49 ' ' %51 '
< V / T, ! / (BP) 4
; & / Q < 7 0 ' >'
. H ! 7 - 7 0 /
0 <1981 & C :(M ) : ,6
+ ' J 3 W ' 7 , )' 4 ? ? '
*( * <(Y@F' L&' LF' L ' LI LJ' L# L
*; , 6 JV /' # 2+ I ; >' # G /' + K
V W 1983 & C : ) ,7
I *; * - >' ' ) Q6 ' ,
–IDS 0 * * 0 ; K Q 4 - <
* Z 4 - ' K (International Diesel Services)
' 0 ' 1 /' 0 24
* # 7 &/ < ! 8'! - /'
.& 7
76
#* * * 4 , <2002 & C :8 ,8
< # >; / /' E
D*' 0* 4 +' #! < ++ N ; >'
) * <# 0; </' < <I'3 </ <2 8 R + C
>' / ! V >' ! -
; / >' V < / # ( :
. / V >' , - F
; V 2005 & C : 3- ,10
0 ' K < ; 4 >' V
# >= @ #6 ; + &/ &+ &! # < 7 ++ 8!
I' # (2) & ) < ( - F ' & Q &
# * 7 # !0* # ' # .# Q # % 0 & '
:
<:; <4 ; ') E P 2 :; :)* 0D ,
' ' E F F :; : 0D ,B
(25L21) % & 4 ( 5 ) :( )) )%A ,
.(33
6 8@ T G < ; J / Q &;
: (1L3) & 5( < '
( 1,3 ) )
1 -
+ G G $ + +
E L
C + C
1 2 3 4 5
2 3 3.75 4.5
# # # , ' 6
#
3 3.75 4.5 5
2
> ( 8@ T
78
<*+ / &+' / @ 8 , & <&+ &+ / ;6 & <
&;* ' - 4! T ; ) ; &
5*( >! O' & # =@ .J / 4! E T J / <>! O'
H P6 ' 4 ' F - E @ #C (3L3)
.
(2,3) )
*, *+;, 0 & 0@ ' - Q +'! #!
N*' #*( 7*3 G 6 ' < 73 N7' I ; [ G
@*; # + & ' &E # (SPSS) & 73
: 73 G 6 &; Q # <E ' '
2* K < 7 G' E : D D 1 - L1
K* <' 4 ! F ' 8 Z
* EC ; ! # K ( Simple Regression ) $ A ) $ L2
J* ; ' - 46 T ; K :T L3
* 6 * # # ' &
*; '* & * @; # + & ' K : *
1 *=' *3 *+' * G*' +' F Q < W(
* #* # + ' :
:E + 1 =' 3 J6 -( # / 6
. ' ; Q ; G L1
; ; W( ' ; L3
. '
. ' ; Q ! 7 L4
81
7 )%
7 )%
&* 7*3 0 N' &; 4! ' &
(Simple ; ' G! &; ( > ; & : 4 ,2
/ F EC ', J / T & G K <Regression)
*( > * Ho ( > H ;@ / 4 :' <- F
* ' T* ' K < + # ! ( T) & ' , Ha
/* F # > # 1 <- F # ' E 1
%6.8 14 CISA
%2.9 6 CMA
2 2
%10.2 21 CPA
% 3.9 8 CIA
G' I ; K <7> + / )7/ H # ! # < >
<:; <4 ; ' ) Q # < P ; 79 7
# % & / N7' + &E ( V < '+ + < > =
@; # + & 3 <# # # ,
: # Q (1L4) & ) + ; # ' # 6 80
&+ ; ' 0 ' # ? ( 62 ) #! (1L4) # 5(
<*E ' & , # 7 ( 30.1 ) &+' Q ' 21
7 (24.8) ' # ? 51 (' 15L11) 4 ; # # l '
' ? (49) ' 10L6 4 ; # # l # <' & , #
J>' (' 20L16) ' 5 # ! # 7> ! ' 7 (23.8)
#! *' -* 0 * *> .7 7 ( 10.7) ' J>' ? (22) 7
' W> #! .&+ , 6 & / 4 ; # ' # #
E #! K < &+ ; W> ' (21) # &+ ; ' 0 # #
; K => ! # ' >'
; ; + / #( 1 +
.( !
85
<% 2,1,4
# * # * # E6 & G V #! (1L4 ) @; # =@
*, # 7 ( 70.9) F ' ? (146) & l , <# #
*' ? * ( 31) l & K 8 &E .' &
& 6 4 , V ' # .' & , # 7 ( 15) F
V ! .' & , # 7 ( 9.2 ) F ' ? ( 19 )
* &*=' * ;! <7 ( 2.9 ) F ' / # ( 6 ) l /
&+'* :; ' # &+@V ' #! V . 3
* 4 */ (, 40 &+' K #R < 4 /
, < ' # # E6 & #! (1L4 ) @; # =@
K 8 &E .' & , # (%62.6) F ' ? (129) & l
.' & , # (%37.4) F ' ? ( 77 ) l # #
+ # E ' P #! ( 1 L4) & ) @; # #
> &+7, # # # # C . '+
. '+ 8C & / (, &+' 1 6 <) '+ + '
86
# & ' &= #! , (1L4) & )
& 4+ 8 &E < ' , # ( %67) &+' F , J
/ 4+ ! <(%11.6) ' F & &E <(%13.2) '
.E ' & , # (% 2.9) %' ;! <(5.3) &+'
& &/ & 4 0 G ' T T W> =@'
# # # T W> #, / # .
G #! < ! G >'
(/ 2; - # ' V 2 G (J ) '
#7* * < 7! # 4 ' # =@ &
.&+ + ' 7 Q 4 &+V 4 / &+ #! Q
87
K < 6 ' ' # (2L4)
. F J / ' ; 76 # ' , @; #
(2,4) )
C
.* " $
(4.021) // ; @; # F &
4 >' G 40+C ; ; 8 , #C
- ; &=' & 0@ G 40+! # =@ .
1 2 ' (4.261) // , <6 8 &!
/ , ' 0@ 40+6 #! :' 4 @ <(.613)
8 &E .(.663) 1 2 ' (4.153) ; &=' ;
' # 0; 0@ 40+6 :' 4 EE
1 2 ' (4.144) // Q < ; &=' )
/ + 0', ? ! ?80 G 40+! 8 <(.760)
.(.672) 1 2 ' (3.855) ; &='
+ / G 40+! :' 4 8 ;
(3.693) ; &=' ; ' / ! # &;
.(.735) 1 2 '
#! , < ) ' +
% @ $ A $ 2,2,4
K < 6 ' ' # (3L4)
. F J / ' ; 76 # ' , @; #
(3,4) )
C
.A " $
(4.124) // ; @; # F &
4 >' ' ; ; 8 , #C
& " (10) & 4 /> G ' # ' 6 #! # .
" ; &=' > ( ; Q
" 'E 8 <(.657) 1 2 ' (4.360)
(9) & 4 /> " ; &=' ' H 6 &;
N :' 4 /> @ <(1.004) 1 2 ' (4.162)
1 2 ' (4.063) ; &=' ; 0'3 4
' 40+6 F ='6 8 <(.741)
<(.971) 1 2 ' (4.036) ; &=' ) 0@
&=' '! - G' & / 4 / :;
.(.700) 1 2 ' (4.000) ; 8 / ;
#! , < ) ' +
K < 6 ' ' # (4L4)
. F J / ' ; 76 # ' , @; #
(4,4) )
.* " $
> ' 11
;
; ; 8 , #! , (4L4) & +'( N7'
& l Q < 4 >' ' /
@ => " :' 4 /> #! Q <(.531) 1 2 ' (3.851)
(4.000) < ' " ; &=' @; # >' &
' 4 " :' 4 /> 'E @ <(.831) 1 2 '
2 ' (3.936) ; &=' _@3 * 5
&=' / '6 2 => ) ! <(.754) 1
<(.807) 1 2 ' (3.801) EE 8 / ;
@ > ' " %' :' 4 @
(3.791) < ; &=' :; 7 '0;
#! :' ; (14) & 4 /> 8 <( .736) 1 2 '
&=' / >; ' 4
#! , < ) ' +
+ @ $ A $ 4,2,4
K < 6 ' ' # (5L4)
. F J / ' ; 76 # ' , @; #
(5,4) )
C
.* " $
5 .720 3.810 &=' & # '
;
(3.985) // ; @; # F &
4 >' '> & ) > ; ; 8 , #C
8! 0', H F ' # #! , N7' .
6 # (19) & 4 /> E ; &='
(18) & 4 /> # @ 'E @ <(.748) 1 2 ' (4.144)
; &=' ' - >' # ; # :'
# ' # #! :' (30) & 4 /> <+
1 2 ' (4.009) < ' + ' ' &C
/ #0 # #! N7' ' < (.939) (.694)
(3.955) 8 4 F ' 2 = - 2
40+! F N 4 8 ' <(.652) 1 2 '
; ; &=' & # '
#! , < ) ' +
K < 6 ' ' # (6L4)
. F J / ' ; 76 # ' , @; #
(6,4) )
C
.* " $
1 .711 4.144 &=' #( 40+6 ; # '
;
(4.015) // ; @; # F &
4 >' ; ; 8 , #C
+ 4 :' 4 #! , N7' .
8 ; &=' #( 40+6 ; # '
& 4 /> 'E @ <(.711) 1 2 ' (4.144) 6
N7' & / ; &=' +; 4 :' (25)
) ) ! <(.877) 1 2 ' (4.108) K <4
/ < G + ; &=' >; 3 #
4 /> 8 <(.645) 1 2 ' (4.036) EE 8
/ ; &=' :' (21) &
1 2 ' (3.909) <+ # G'
&=' >; &6 :' (23) & 4 /> 8 <(.803)
; + ;
#! , < ) ' +
K < 6 ' ' # (7L4)
. F J / ' ; 76 # ' , @; #
(7,4) )
:7 @ $ A $
#$ A
C
.* " $
(3.824) // #E @; # F
(31) & 4 /> #! (7L4) & N7' ! .(.814) 1 2 '
C; G : / , 1V ) ; &=' #! :'
! Q 6 ' <+/ ' YF
' ! #! ' (.711) 1 2 ' (3.945)
; &=' #! :' (29) & 4 /> :; ! . ' 4 />
'E 8 / < 48> > 0 )
(28) & 4 /> EE @ <(.574) 1 2 ' (3.918)
I' 4 ;@ &7@ ) ; &=' #! :'
1 2 ' (3.909) E ! F ' 8 ' /
) ; &=' #! :' (35) & 4 /> 8 &E <(.720)
; & ; 8! # ? Z 5
8 &E <(.699) 1 2 ' (3.828) < /
E ; - ) ; &=' #! :' (31) & 4 />
#! , < ) ' +
40+6 ( 0.05 ) T ' 7, E! " %' ( > :'
(Simple Regression) ' ; &; & / ( > ;
. ( > ; ' + & N7' # ( 8L4 ) &
( 8 ,4) )
B$ CD2 E ( Simple Regression) $ A 89
T T
9%$/ - $ R2 Sig. )- @
( > H 1.96 7.590 CD(((((2
.297 .000
B$
* ; + , & & / ' / <(1.96) + F (7.590)
( > H & %'R K < / # ! / #! # < ( >
* G 40+6 7, E! " %' :' ( >
# * # * *=' *+ #* >' ; &='
, <%5 # ! +', , ? > F (Sig.) V ."#
* ; &=' # # (.297) %' > G 40+! # #!
100
( 0.05 ) T ' 7, E! " %' ( > :'
. >' ; &=' '
(Simple Regression) ' ; &; & / ( > ;
. ( > ; ' + & N7' # ( 9L4 ) &
( 9 ,4) )
% E ( Simple Regression) $ A 89
T T
9%$/ - $ R2 Sig. )- @
( > H (((((%
1.96 .526 .000
8.640
T #! ( 9 L4) ) 4 ' # 5(
; + , & & / ' / <(1.96) + F (8.640)
( > H & %'R K < / # ! / #! # < ( >
&=' ' EC " %'! :' ( >
V <" # # # =' + # >' ;
' # #! , <%5 # ! +', , ? > F (Sig.)
101
=' + # ; &=' # # ( .526) %' >
/ ( 0.05 ) T ' 7, E! " %'! ( > :'
. >' ; &=' '
(Simple Regression) ' ; &; & / ( > ;
. ( > ; ' + & N7' # ( 10L4 ) &
( 10 ,4) )
E ( Simple Regression) $ A 89
T T
9%$/ - $ R2 Sig. )- @
( > H
1.96 6.396 .417 .000
; + , & & / ' / <( 1.96 ) + F (6.396)
( > H & %'R K < / # ! / #! # < ( >
&=' ' / EC " %'! :' ( >
V <" # # # =' + # >' ;
102
F # #! , <%5 # ! +', Q ? > F (Sig.)
# =' + # ; &=' # # (.417) %' > '
) > ( 0.05 ) T ' 7, E! " %'! ( > :'
. >' ; &=' '> &
(Simple Regression) ' ; &; & / ( > ;
. ( > ; ' + & N7' # ( 11L4 ) &
( 11,4) )
+ E ( Simple Regression) $ A 89
T T
9%$/ - R2 Sig. )- @
$
( > H
1.96 11.62 .428 .000 +
* ; + , & & / ' / <(1.96) + F (11.62)
( > H & %'R K < / # ! / #! # < ( >
&=' '> & ) > EC " %' :' ( >
V <" # # # =' + # >' ;
103
) F # #! , <%5 # ! +', Q ? > F (Sig.)
*=' *+ # ; &=' # # ( .428) %' > '> &
( 0.05 ) T ' 7, E! " %'! ( > :'
. >' ; &='
(Simple Regression) ' ; &; & / ( > ;
. ( > ; ' + & N7' # ( 12L4 ) &
( 12 ,4) )
)%A E ( Simple Regression) $ A 89
T T
9%$/ - $ R2 Sig. )- @
( > H
.342 .000 )%A
1.96 5.974
* ; + , & & / ' / <(1.96) + F (5.974)
( > H & %'R K < / # ! / #! # < ( >
* 7, E! " %' :' ( >
104
# * # * *=' *+ #* >' ; &='
, <%5 # ! +', , ? > F (Sig.) V ."#
* &=' # # (.342) %' > F # #!
1 )%
% 89
89 1,5
% 2,5
106
1 )%
% 89
# * # # ' 3 - > & 1 8(
*' *> * #R < ! >' #
*> * + & 76 # R <Q + , N7' ?(
N7*' 8( <+ ' ( > + E # 6
N7' &! : ; # < # Q & + , &
: ' 4 ' , @; # % , & )
89 1,5
; &=' G 40+6 E! %'! , N7'
# * . # # # =' + # >'
&*! -* * ; &=' & 0@ G 40+! EC K' #!
&=' ; / , ' 0@ 40+6 EC K' <
&=' ) ' # 0; 0@ 40+6 K < ;
&;* *E! * # (2005) 4 >; < ' - )> ' . ;
. 0 3 / '
107
&=' % 6 < ' &; - 2 @; # '
< E6 ( ! 3 < / ; < ;
K'+ < T G < 7 ' ' ;
+ / 4 G 40+! #! ! Q < ' # 4 c
% E 2,1,5
* &*=' * ' EC %' N7'
. * # # # =' + # >' ;
* > ( ; Q & / EC K' #! #
* * 6 &;* * * EC K' K < ; &='
*; 0'3 4 N EV K < ; &=' ' H
# *' * (Burton, 2007) * ' - )> ' . ; &='
*0@ / & / + +8> T # )/ ; ) '
! ; &=' ) ; / +'
.&
& / 4 / 00 <&=' &; D' + ? ' :;
G ; 4 ( # K <>; + '! - G'
108
>' ; &=' + 6 / F ='!
.
; &=' ' / EC %' N7'
# < # # # =' + # >'
#! < >' ; &=' ' / EC K' #!
# @( <% EV ; &=' @; # >' & @ =>
. ; &=' _@3 * 5 ' 4 %E 1 EC
T # ' (Edwards, Kusel & Oxner, 2010) ' - )> '
='! / G ='! ' ' 3 &=' 48>
6 ; 26 ) / < &=' / # P '
.6 8;6 D@3 # %'( ) /
>' ' 4 , &=' #! <Q T
; 4 , +;
> '0; ' # % 1 8 < , +',
( ! G .+' 4> + 4 > 5 +
' # % &( @; # ' 4 , > =
+ E 4,1,5
* &*=' * '> & ) > EC %'! , N7'
.* # # # =' + # >' ;
&*=' 8! 0*', H F ' # EC K' #! #
&*=' ' - >' # ; # EV K < ;
*' &C* # ' # # <+ ;
# ' (2011) < ' - )> ' . ' + '
# '/* &0* / E '> & ) 48> F
. 70 ; &=' > & + 4 '
; &=' # &+ # ; 0@ K 1
* 7, E! %'! , N7'
# * # * # * =' + # >' ; &='
* * * +* 4 / EC K' #! # .
* 4 / EC K' #! < ; &=' #( 40+6 ; # '
) * E* K*' K* <4 N7' & / ; &=' +;
110
. G + ; &=' >; 3 #
* * ' #! ' (Tucker, 2011) ' - )> '
#* <; ; ' # # EV ;
* * *, 0 - 0 &; #! Q T
# * *' * ' #( # K <
# * %' # < ; + # < 6 ' &6 7
% 2,5
# Q &/ < @; # + , & N7' 8(
* &*=' * 5( E6 ' &; ' :A
: [ W, @; # K < >' ;
' < &! - + / G 40+! L!
0' ! 80 +' < ' # 0; < / ,
. ; &=' # + 6 ; ;
111
<+ * ;* / ' 0 Q & / LG
* '! - G' >; &+ & / 4 /
.' < 40+6 F ='6 K <>;
4* 0 ; # + 6 48> ' &=' &; LI
&+ +' < ' &; ) ' ) / & 4 0 L
. ; &=' # < '! 4
* ' 0* *> < ' L*
/' <2( /' , 2 $ 8 , >' 0 :(
* &*=' * # E! < ' &; / 4/
* 4 3* ' ; &! , 8 ', L!
& ' < ' # V ! &( < =' + G
3 - ) ' @; # + - ; >'
.T ;6
1 ' G N , <G & LG
/ , < <+' 0; <' :E '6 2; #(
&=' - < ' &=' ' LI
@; # K < '! - +' 4 3 + ' <
&; # >' #X < '! 2; # ' 4 J C
<& @; # < +' ' ' 0 L
. & &=' - G' +' # :; ; &=' >'
- 4 / '> < 3 => L*
. '
D' &+ K #! Q < + ' L
<N # '/ '> & ) >' :
' - >' # ; # <8>6 40+6 F
: [ W, @; # K < ' + ' ' # &+' +
&=' # 4 # 4 ' L!
. ;
& ) > 1 > G 0 ; N LG
. '/ '>
113
/ ' 0 ' 2 = : LI
'0; [ G @; # 6 G ! G ! &; L
+ 4 / >' :
# W( 8 E, &+ #! # / Q6 D Q # :
+' ' #E ' Q < ; &=' #
+ >' P 4
.
# 6 # # # & / Q! 8 , LI
.
114
.
%* , * 1 W( J>' Q! 8 R Q L*
N7' +/ T # C 2+ K E F J>'
7 9
.C(% ( ( ( / ( .(2005) E # <J , L
#* < " ; +9 A )" <(2000) # < L
<* * 40+9 < <
.4 '
* &=' ; .(2011) <# 2 < & < L
<CK <40P W 2 / : ' 3
. : < C/ )% <(2009) < 'F < ' L
-* <# - <(2010) < <# L
:# <- 0 ' 8> <6 $ + ! ) .(2009) < < L
.# 6
/ - <(2005) 2 ' .4 >; L
: ' 6 < H : D
.# 6 <#
116
: . .(2008) <& 8' <)'; L
." ' 7'3 - 86 48> & / ) " .(2000) .& ' <Y L
G * 4 , <( ( $ %( C <(2009) < # L
. ='
0 <6 < - $ B <( 2010 ) <#'! <#@0 L
*' *7 < <CD. B$ H(2004) < < 0 L
<#9 C/ W (2008) <& < / <# 1+ <2 0 L
.# 6 <) > : ! < < *
<# < < H(2010) <)0 8@ < L
.# 6 <#
<- 0 ' 8> <" / <(2004) <&E < 0 <# , < 7 L
.# 6 <#
<- 0 ' 7 < / - <( 2001 ) <& <_ < < L
.# 6 <#
117
<' ' < ) 9 ) / .(2011) ) 9 ) L
.2010 ' 4 ' < @ & < ) 9 ) L
( ( C/ C D %A .* <( 2002 ) " < ' L
.# 6 < >@ J; 1' V &/ Q < $
– ; &=' > # <(2011) ' + < L
& < 6$ ; < 70 /
. ' : H C/ H(2008) <0 0 & , < L
< $ / W <( 2006 ) < <_ <# <D L
< ' G < / <( 2001 ) < < 7 L
2- A $ <( 2004 ) <2 ) <Y < <' L
. + C/ 1 .(2012) 0 < 0 L
: ) < < % #. + -$
.# 6 <#
:#* < - 0 ' 4 <C/ <(2009) < <J L
.# 6
118
$ .(2010) <> #P <4(/ L
. <K H < : * M
; ' '/ 7 :7; E! .(2007) < ; < '' L
: .2 <13 HC < ' 6 2 " F
.256L201 :
.(2- .(2002) <( # , < 7 <& , < ' L
.# 6 <# <45+44 # H+ H ; <(2000) <& < L
* : '*3 <+( ( ; : <(2010) <2 <1 > L
. '
:4 / < < $ .(2009) < # ! < > L
.
<* '/ 7 H2- - <( 2010 ) <& G <1 ( L
*' #* 4 * <(2009) < 0P ! @ ,
.# 6 <# <# ''/ # - ' # <
.#' < <# @ & <(2010) <6 0P ! & L
.86 : > 4 ' <(2009) <+ V L
.' ' - : > 4 ' <(2009) < V L
119
.86 : > 4 ' <(2009) <+ V L
<6 H D $ C/ <( 2001 ) <! .1 ,
:#* <-* 0 ' ) V <( .(2010) <" 2; < L
.# 6
D A @ 7
(1) +$
* +
$ /)*
ا ا ا
&=' ' &; E! 2 , 2+
3 & W( & ! 6 < >' ;
Q H P3 ' - & %'C / 76
./
&'
6$
" # $ %
555720002 #.
124
:C ,1
<% ,2
,3
G
2 2 ,4
CMA CISA CFA
T ;! CIA CPA
).? ,5
^ & J &
125
' &; E! & ! # 48 : -
1 G 80, ( √) 4 , -( K < >' ; &='
.'
)
B$ CD2
- ; &=' & 0@ G 40+! 1
&!
) ' # 0; 0@ 40+6 2
; &='
&=' ; / , ' 0@ 40+6 3
;
+ 0', ? ! ?80 G 40+! 4
; &=' /
/ ! # &; + / G 40+! 5
; &=' ; '
%
; &=' ; 0'3 4 N 6
0 ' 40+6 F ='6 7
; &=' )
- G' & / 4 / 8
; &=' '!
' H 6 &; 9
; &='
> ( ; Q & 10
; &='
126
&=' _@3 * 5 ' 4 12
;
; &=' @; # >' & @ => 13
>; ' 4 14
; &=' /
&=' / '6 2 => 15
;
- +
-* 2* * ; &=' ) # 16
4 F ' 2 =
+
X +
$
)
E ; ) ; &=' - 26
G' 7@ ; ; &=' - 27
;*@ &*7@ ) ; &=' 28
E ! F ' 8 ' / I' 4
* > * ) ; &=' 0 29
48>
* ? Z ) ; &=' 5 30
/ ; & ; 8! #
G : / , ) ; &=' 1V 31
+/ ' YF C;
*/ *; * ) ; &=' &+ 32
48> '
D*' * ? ? ) ; &=' G 33
+! 8!
(2) +$