You are on page 1of 5

Regulating lobbying:

This comparative table provides an overview of the different approaches


adopted by countries with regard to lobbying regulation.

international comparative table Last update: June 2023

Date and Organisation Number of


Sanctions for
Geographical amendments responsible Definition registered Content Frequency Link to
Definition of «Lobbyist» breach of reporting Control methods
area to the for of «Lobbying activity» lobbyists of declarations of declarations the register
or ethical obligations
lobbying law the register (30/04/2023)

All companies, institutions


All activities via which and associations asserting
a direct influence the individual interests Administrative penalties
Purpose and value
Ministry is exerted on the legislator of persons or companies, up to EUR 60,000 lobbyreg.
Austria 2013 389 of spending on Annual Unspecified
of Justice or the government body or the collective interests justiz.gv.at
lobbying activities Removal from the register
via structured and of several persons or
organised contacts companies, before public
authorities

Preliminary assessments
• Identity of the public
Investigations: may assign
officials contacted
and ensure the presence
• Public institution targeted Re-registration every of an individual, and
Any communication or Fine (up to CAD 200,000)
Consultant lobbyist and • Data on clients initiating six months require the production
1989, 1995, 2003, Lobbying request for a meeting with Maximum prison sentence of documents lobbycanada.
Canada salaried lobbyist acting 5,207 lobbying activities If contact with
2008 Commission a “public office holder” of two years gc.ca
in a paid capacity • Subject and purpose a public official, monthly In the case of a violation
about certain public policies Two-year lobbying ban
of lobbying activities communication report of the Act or Code, notifies
a competent justice official
• Type of public decision
targeted 16 investigation reports
since 2011

A natural or legal person


in private law who carries
Department All activities conducted out active preparation
of Justice of with the aim of directly work in public policies • Identity of clients initiating Temporary suspension
the Generalitat or indirectly influencing or decision-making lobbying activities from the register Validation of the registered
According to the code
2014, 2016, 2017, de Catalunya the processes of preparing processes in Catalonia information governobert.
Catalonia 5,219 • Value of expenditure, of conduct of In the event of a serious
2021 and General or applying policies with the aim of influencing gencat.cat
type and purpose each organisation breach, removal No investigations afterwards
Directorate and decision-making, the direction of these
of Law and regardless of the means policies in alignment of lobbying activities from the register
Legal Entities or methods used with their own interests
or those of third parties,
or the general interest

• General information
about the entity
Monitoring is performed
• Links to EU institutions of new applications, or via
(legislative proposals, Temporary suspension targeted quality controls
Activities carried out by
initiatives targeted) from the register and as a follow up to
interest representatives
Management Formal warning complaints or as part
with the objective Any natural or legal person, • Financial information Obligatory annual update,
Board and to the registrant of own-investigations
European of influencing the or formal or informal group, with an invitation to update
Secretariat EU institutions also publish
2011, 2014, 2021 formulation or association or network, 12,154 every 6 months and Removal from the register In addition, 4 238 targeted ec.europa.eu
Union of the information on the
implementation of policy that engages in covered a further obligation to quality checks were
Transparency registrations, including on Prohibition of reregistration
or legislation, or the activities update upon request performed by the Secretariat
Register membership of Commission for a period of up to 2 years
decision-making processes in 2022. It received 65 new
expert groups, accredited and publication of the
of the EU institutions complaints and opened
individuals at the European measure on the website
13 own-investigation cases
Parliament, list of meetings
against registered entities
with the European
Commission, and other
Date and Organisation Number of
Sanctions for
Geographical amendments responsible Definition registered Content Frequency Link to
Definition of «Lobbyist» breach of reporting Control methods
area to the for of «Lobbying activity» lobbyists of declarations of declarations the register
or ethical obligations
lobbying law the register (30/04/ 2023)

For lobbying activities:


• The party who is being
influenced by lobbying
• The topic(s) concerning
which they were contacted
• The primary methods
for maintaining contact
Any communication • Financial information Twice a year for
Legal persons and private No control of the information
to influence a member Law 430/2023 the operating notification
National Audit operators who lobby declared in the register
Finland 2023 of Parliament or will enter into force Fines vtv.fi
Office or advise Parliament For consultancy activities: Annual for financial in advance, only an ex-post
Governement involved in on 01/01/2024
and ministries information supervision
public decision-making • The client’s identity
• Information on who/what
they focus their lobbying
activities on
• Information on the type
of support provided to the
client
• Financial information

Power of on-site
documentary control,
• Type of public official without recourse to
Natural person as part
Any communication contacted; expenses the defence of
of a professional activity,
initiated by the interest • Type and purpose of professional secrecy
High or legal entity in which Fine (EUR 15,000)
representative to certain interest representation
Authority for an executive manager,
France 2016 public officials with regard 2,584 Annual Maximum prison sentence hatvp.fr
Transparency an employee or a • Type of public decision 163 controls of interest
to certain public decisions of one year
in Public Life member conducts interest in question representatives launched
with a view to influencing
representation work as in 2022 (77 controls of
such decisions • Link to professional
their main or regular activity unregistered representatives
organisations
and 86 controls of annual
declarations)

• Identity of the natural


or legal person or
organisation
• Description of activities
Any contact made for and areas of interest
the purpose of directly All natural or legal persons, Annual for general entries No control of the imported
• Identity of clients whose
or indirectly influencing partnerships or other Some information relating information in the register
interests the registrant
the process of formulating organisations, which to names, addresses, in advance, only
represents Fine (up to EUR 50,000)
Parliament aims or taking decisions engage in the representation contact details etc, an elaborated ex-post lobbyregister.
Germany 2021 5,896 • Number of employees Ban on access to the supervision
(Bundestag) conducted by the bodies, of special interests has to be updated no later bundestag.de
Members, parliamentary themselves or commission involved with the premises of the Bundestag
than the end of the quarter Entries that have not been
groups or groupings of such representation representation of interests
following the occurrence updated in time are publicly
the German Bundestag or on their behalf • Financial expenditure of the change annotated as «not updated»
by the Federal Government involved in the
representation of interests
• Individual allowances
and grants from
the public purse
Date and Organisation Number of
Sanctions for
Geographical amendments responsible Definition registered Content Frequency Link to
Definition of «Lobbyist» breach of reporting Control methods
area to the for of «Lobbying activity» lobbyists of declarations of declarations the register
or ethical obligations
lobbying law the register (30/04/ 2023)

• The institutional body to


whom the lobbying activity
was addressed
Any type of direct • The policy area and NTA shall examine any
communication between Any natural or legal person the type of decision possible non-compliance
an interest representative, who carries out lobbying they targeted Fines (ranging from with the obligations of
National at its initiative, and activities with remuneration 40-50 lobbyists EUR 5,000 to EUR 20,000) interest representatives
• The identity of the person
Greece 2021 Transparency an institutional body, which through his/her contact estimation by Annual Suspension from lobbying Inspectors shall invite lobbying.aead.gr
who carried out the
Authority (NTA) is intended to influence with institutional bodies, the end of 2023 activities and from in writing the interest
lobbying activity
the decision-making for and on behalf of the Register representative to provide
process and which is carried his/her client • The client, the time and explanations within
out for remuneration manner of the lobbying one month
activity
• The intended result
of the lobbying activity

2015, 2016, 2019,


Legal entity with at least May require anyone
2022 (the law
10 employees carrying out to supply information
is reviewed
lobbying activities; or any • Identity of public officials Automatic penalty and produce documents
one year after
professional lobbyist paid contacted (EUR 200) for sending late
its adoption Standards Any communication with May enter and search
to communicate on declarations
and then every in Public a designated public • Data on clients initiating premises, inspect and take
Ireland behalf of a client; or any 2,468 Every four months lobbying.ie
three years). Office (SIPO) officer that relates to lobbying activities Maximum fine of EUR 2,500 copies of any document
representative or advocacy
Under the 2022 Commission a “relevant matter” • Type, subject and purpose Maximum prison sentence In 2021, 399 automatic
bodies with at least one
Amendment bill of lobbying activities of two years penalties for late submission
employee; anyone lobbying
(not yet in law) of the activity declaration
about development
it will be every were issued
or rezoning of land
5 years

• Identity of the lobbyist


• Identity of the client
of lobbying activities
Actions taken by a natural • Title of the legal act or
or legal person, in an Suspension from the register
A natural person, a legal the draft legal act being
attempt to exert influence (and thus from rights
person, another organization targeted
Chief official over defined public officials of access to meetings To inspect lobbying
or a division thereof • Brief description of In the seven days following and consultations that
Lithuania 2001, 2017, 2020 ethics to have legal acts adopted 320 activities and receive skaidris.vtek.lt
engaged in lobbying the subject matter, the lobbying activity are conditional upon
commission or rejected in the interests information from lobbyists
activities. Non-profit which the legal act aims membership of the register)
of the client or the
organisations are excluded to change
beneficiary of lobbying Fines
activities • Name of the authority
or institution lobbied
• Name and position of
the public official lobbied
Date and Organisation Number of
Sanctions for
Geographical amendments responsible Definition registered Content Frequency Link to
Definition of «Lobbyist» breach of reporting Control methods
area to the for of «Lobbying activity» lobbyists of declarations of declarations the register
or ethical obligations
lobbying law the register (30/04/ 2023)

The Registrar may


Any person or organisation
Communication which uses issue notices to request
that engages in face-
the opportunity to inform • Identity of public officials information. Investigations
to-face communication
or influence a member contacted can also be carried out by
(including video
of the Scottish Parliament, Scotland’s Ethical Standards
Scottish conferences) with a defined • Identity of clients initiating
Scotland 2016 a member of the Scottish 1,301 Every six months Report to Parliament Commissioner, who can then lobbying.scot
Parliament public official, if they are lobbying activities
Government, a subordinate report to Parliament. Very
discussing governmental • Type and purpose
Scottish minister, a special serious allegations can be
or parliamentary of lobbying activities
adviser or the permanent passed directly to the Crown
functions and acting
secretary Office (Scotland’s public
in a paid capacity
prosecution service)

Any natural or legal person • Identity of lobbyist or legal


registered in the Lobbyists person; number and date
Registry of decision on entry in
Communication in writing
Lobbying may also be the Register of lobbyists
Agency for targeting a public official
carried out by an individual • Identity of clients initiating Misdemeanor fine The Registrar may
prevention with the name of the law publicacas.
Serbia 2018 who is not registered if he or 45 lobbying activities Annual issue notices
of corruption or regulation which is the Removal from the register acas.rs
she is a legal representative to request information
(APC) subject of the lobbying • Subject matter and
activities or employee of an enterprise
purpose of lobbying
for which he or she carries
out lobbying activities • Data on the lobbied
(unregistered lobbyist) persons and authorities

• Identity of registered
lobbyist or interest group
• Payment received from
interest groups for each
matter concerned
• Purpose and objective of
lobbying for a particular Lobbyists:
interest group Crosschecking between
• Administrative sanctions annual reports of registered
Any non-public contact Any person who is engaged • The names of state bodies (from a ban on lobbying lobbyists, interest groups,
established between in lobbying and who is and officials targeted
Registered lobbysts or activities on a particular and records of the officials
Commission a natural person and registered in the register
• Types and methods interest groups: annual matter, to a removal from lobbied
for the a defined public official of lobbyists, or any person
Slovenia 2010, 2011, 2020 82 of lobbying the register); kpk-rs.si
Prevention with the aim of influencing who is engaged in lobbying Lobbied officials: The CPC can initiate
of Corruption the content or the adoption and is an employee of an • The type and value within 8 days of the contact • Minor-offence sanctions. a minor-offence proceeding
procedure of public interest group and lobbies of donations made to and reach a decision
Lobbied officials or interest
decisions on its behalf political parties and the on the offence whereupon
group:
organisers of electoral and it may impose a sanction
referendum campaigns • Minor-offence sanctions

Lobbied officials also have


to declare every contact with
a lobbyst within eigt days
(including name of lobbyist,
area of lobbying, purpose,
date and place of contact)
Date and Organisation Number of
Sanctions for
Geographical amendments responsible Definition registered Content Frequency Link to
Definition of «Lobbyist» breach of reporting Control methods
area to the for of «Lobbying activity» lobbyists of declarations of declarations the register
or ethical obligations
lobbying law the register (30/04/ 2023)

Review of published
information (transparency
UK VAT registered data, media reports etc)
Communications organisations and to identify unregisterd
(in person, writing or individuals who Civil penalty (max £ 7,500) consultant lobbying

United Registrar digitally) made personally communicate personally Clients lobbied for, or referral for criminal Registrar investigations
2014 of Consultant with Government Ministers with Government Ministers 212 or paid to lobby for Quarterly prosecution for a fine can be supported orcl.my.site.com
Kingdom Lobbyists or Permanent Secretaries or Permanent Secretaries in previous quarter (criminal route has not by Information Notices
(and equivalents) (and equivalents) been used) Civil Penalty Notices can be
on behalf of a client on behalf of a third party issued for late or inaccurate
and in return for payment quarterly information
returns and for unregistered
consultant lobbying

• Public institution
Any person employed by in question;
a client for financial gain 4,220 cases of potential
Any oral, written or electronic • Data on clients initiating
Office of whose services include more Fine (between $US 50,000 of potential breaches
communication addressed lobbying activities
United the House of than one lobbying contract $US 200,000) of theLobbying disclosurespre-
1946, 1995, 2007 to certain defined public 12,644 • Type of public decision Quarterly
States Representatives and whose lobbying Maximum prison sentence Disclosure Act sent to view.house.gov
officials concerning in question
Senate Office activities account for more of five years the prosecutor between
a public policy
than 20% of their time; • Value of expenditure, 2009 and 2019
or any salaried lobbyist type and purpose
of lobbying activities

You might also like