You are on page 1of 2

Hawthorne Studies (by Elton Mayo) Maslow’s Theory of Human Needs McGregor’s Theory X & Theory Y

 Elton Mayo's contributions came as  For Maslow, human behavior is purposeful and is motivated by the
part of the Hawthorne studies, a satisfaction of needs. A need is a physiological or psychological The style of management is a function of
series of experiments that applied deficiency a person feels. the manager’s assumptions about human
classical management approach only nature and behavior.
to reveal its shortcomings.
 Theory X assumes that workers:
 Mayo tested the impact of working
 Dislike work
conditions (length of rest pause,
length of working days, etc.) on  Lack ambition
productivity. No consistent
 Are irresponsible
relationship found.
 Resist change
 Instead, workers reacted more to
the psychological and social  Prefer to be led
conditions at work such as individual
recognition, and participation in  Theory Y assumes that workers :
decision making.  Willing to work
 Employees performed better when  Capable of self control
managers treated them positively. Abraham Maslow developed one of the most popular theories of
motivation  Willing to accept responsibility
A few years later, a second group of
experiments began. Mayo gave 1.Physiological. Hunger, thirst, shelter, sex, and other survival  Imaginative and creative
workers special privileges, such as needs.
 Capable of self-direction
the right to leave their workstations
without permission, take rest 2.Safety. Security, stability, and protection from physical or
periods, enjoy free lunches, and have emotional harm.
Douglas McGregor believed that two basic kinds of
variations in pay levels and
3.Social. Social interaction, affection, companionship, and managers exist. One type, the Theory X manager,
workdays. This experiment resulted
friendship. has a negative view of employees and assumes
in significantly increased rates of
productivity. The general conclusion that they are lazy, untrustworthy, and incapable of
4.Esteem. Self-respect, autonomy, achievement, status,
from the Hawthorne studies was that assuming responsibility. On the other hand, the
recognition, and attention.
human relations and the social needs Theory Y manager assumes that employees are not
of workers are crucial aspects of 5.Self-actualization. a need to find himself, self-fulfillment, and only trustworthy and capable of assuming
business management. achieving one’s potential. responsibility, but also have high levels of
motivation.
The central principle of Theory X is
Maslow’s Theory of Human Needs direction and control through a centralized
 Needs have a hierarchical structure of importance. A need is not an system of organization and the exercise of
effective motivator unless those lower in the hierarchy are authority. Employees must be coerced,
satisfied. A satisfied need is not a motivator. controlled, or threatened to achieve goals.
 Maslow’s ideas suggest that employee motivation is more complex Since they see people as responsible and
than was assumed by the scientific management approach, which conscientious, managers who follow
focused strictly on pay. Theory Y assume the opposite of theory X.
 Maslow assumed that pay can motivate only lower-level needs,
and once those are satisfied it loses its power to shape employee
behavior. Instead, nonmonetary factors such as praise, recognition,
and job characteristics motivate human behavior.

You might also like