oye
YABANCILARIN HATIRALARINDA OSMANLI
IMPARATORLUGU VE
YABANCI YAZARLARIN OSMANLILARLA ILGiLi
OLARAK TURKGE’DE YAYIMLANMIS ANILARI UZERINE
BIR BIBLILYOGRAFYA DENEMESI
IRFAN KARAKOG
FATIH ONIVERSITESI FEN-EDEBIVAT FAKULTES
allen dug kaa aileerio de bee
K demeke olan anila, zeit
1. viiaysldan icibacen Gzel
itmesi ve toplumun sosyal dav
sosyal bilim
mesi bakimundan degerlidi
azma biling altyapisiyla Osman ttke-
, seal, gexi, cicaret, miss
vb. sebepledte gelen batillar, kaldiklan sire
_gorilen ve XIX. ylizysl comanciklerinin
i olaylan, gesidli bakis agilart ve
lagen ani eid, bizde hemen her yeni fikrin ve k: ditmelerle yazmuslar ve bunlact yayimlamss
ji Tanzimat'can sonca aremasina, diger yimlanan bu anulas, yabancilarin dzellikle baulaca
bi tirleri beslemesine ve onlara kaynaklik etmesine diinya siyasecinde ylizyillar boyunca nem rol o
s
ramen verilen eserler cok aadir, Bu eksiklik bugiine ka olan Osman Imparatorlagu/Devledi’yle” ilgili digiince-
dat birgok yazar tarafindan gegitli se i leri vermesi bakumindan de ays bie
beplerle agiklanmaya calisisa bile, nem tagimaktadie.
son za yavas yavag canlanan
Osmanls Devleti'ain kuculma, gelis
tiiriin cemel olarak yazi hayatimiza peleetectene eile
li ve dlgindiitict igine alan
ak Kargun
gecerliligini an-
devletin ya
ain; An
bie deyisle
yeter ola yeni cesil
bir yaga gelip de ant yazmayan Kiy bu anularda
yokeur.”* Béylelikle ant yezma bilin agilarindan kaynaklanan
‘sabe, Vis Yinnlan 1967,
MULLER, Mex. Gosegina Ma, dea don Moker gx: fie Bug, fan
cms 1 Teel Eos Sei Ni 131, Keren Yay 198,
16 4Orj, Lee fom Caan, Londen, 1897)
\NEAVE, Dota L. ki Lead Haya, ce: Osan Onde, Istanbul Tec-
30 1001 Teel Ese Sri N: 128, 1978, 1525. (Of. Tae Six Yo
th Bus Lond, 1933)
NERVSL, Gent de, i Spd, Anka, Kale ve Tarim Bais Ys
wo.
IER, Tike Spatrcomes (1790 Yolande Take ve lll, Gee
(Of Gokes, Anka, Ay Macs A, 1977, XV 183-4
PAPULAS, Gn Yusan Ase Sula Orusu Kunupdan), Geel Pape ie
Feat, Ss, Ase Mata, 192°, 168
PARDOE, Nis Jul, Ve Gi de 125 Vl Ou [antl (Sate ie oe
Til ile Haya Goll): Betive San, isabel, to
Teli we Aka Kittel 1967, 212s,
PEDRO. Pde Zr seb Seabed, abel, Gael Yerinci, 199.
PACK THALL, Wit M are Tare Bini 1914, ev Dog De. Kemi-
lecia Yigiez,Aakare, Kt Baas Yaya, 190, IX 182
POOLE. Stanley Lane, Land Satin Tie Hasan, kale gov Can
‘Yee, Akar, Bakas Yay, 1959, XL 2785
PSKIN, Alksnde Segeig, Bram Yao, ev: Z Bag, Anka
‘bs Yana, 1995, 915
RACZYNSKI, Eduaed, 1814 lanl oe Coulee She, ge: Kemal
Turn, Ieanbul, Tecan 1001 Temel Fe Sei N 150, 198 200s
"Oj, Osis Py de Toi Od W Raby MDCCCKIN Pros Be
‘ede Rasystigs, Wroclaw Besa), 1821)
SANDERS, Gul. Linann Von, Tike By Sr taba, Mata Asti,
199° 1921126351 (Yen Had, Tre By Yl, eb Bu.
4 Yau 968
SLADE, Sir Adal. pte Pee Kardi' Br Salt cab. Hast,
Tah ecru ie, 72, 324.
SPEICO. Wis Ys gm eam, Ianbl, ante! Kxopbanes, (988
TCHITCHAGOFF Tite, Aromye te Por Kary 912 Res S00 A
of Tf Hata abl, 2, 39.
THEVENOT, Jean, 1655-1656de Tab, cev: Nur Yl, cab, Tee
man 1001 Teme Ese Svs N: 120, Keran Kip, 1978, 243s.
(Ori Voyages de M, de Thévenoen Evope, Ase e Arig Bal:
‘orage du Levan, Pais, 165)
“TINAYRE, Marcelle. Bir Kae Gein Tito Gout, Oss ler
131 Aart Oy. Inbal, Akay Yap, 198,168,
“TRPITZ, Tipe Hal, ee ST, Isao, Denia Maths, 1932,
al,
‘TOTS, Born De (Humes Ahned Pap 18, ie Tb: tabu Te
man 10 Teme Ec Ser. N: 89. Keron Kiar. 323
TOWSHEND, Gael Chces VE. Trt Sri, lanl. Matha Aki
132,494
“TRIKUPIS, Ga, Nikslos Gow Ttapiin Hater. ee: Ahmet agin.
Iwanbul, Husasbiar Matas )967, 17425,
LUBUCINI, BH. Ay 1835 Tanke, 2c, ges Aye Di, zal, Terctiman
1001 Teel Ese Ser, N: 98-99, eran Kip, 1977, 159.149
(5 Le Toru Aca Pais, Lite de L Hache, 185).
UUBUCINL, FH, A Tid 1850, 2 nb, Terman 100 Teel Bee Se
"si N: GB-64, Kevan Kite (OL Trg, ac, 18S
(ef aed bs, 18532
YACALOFOULOS, Aposcols, tuner Brea Siuit Leal, Hoa Th
Mec ie, 1972, 52
WET, Kal, Kein? Deen Hauler. ew: Fehr Cb, Anka,
Meade Kula Val Yin, 993,256
WHITE. George E, Bir Anchen Mise Aris Arden Rug Harn:
Inge Cem Tak Ve, anbul, Endean Kt, 1995, 346,
WOODS, Sie Honey F, Take Anton (Onn Baise Kid Vil 1869:
1908), ger: Em, Anil Fake Gok. Ianto, Mile Yaya, 1976,
385
\WRATISLAW Boron W, Bor Watt dlr 16, Vel Ooo I
ratanden Gigi gec: M. Sey Dien, nb, Miler Gaze-
tsi Yaynlan, 1996, 131s
Thien Bar Hatt ge: Sree Yell, aie Mab
3511930, 275,
1 ohare Gin i Tie, 2b, bax: Pe De A, Died, tan
‘ul, Yama Yale, 1974, 191 5. Opes Tues aps Les Aucees
(Céabes Dives Temovgnagese opinions sasbl, 1919.)
Tink De Vet, 1952-1936 Elyza yaaa: Man
el Seeano ¥ Sana, eA, Kurata. bal, Tacinan 1001 Teel
er Secs, NB, Kevan Kip oy, U4
lal best,
BAFRALL, De. Yanko, lcs Sbmanar, tanbal, Deve Matas, 1928
[MINTZURI, Hagen lko Ase 1897-194) hae: Nee Soka ge
Siles Kurumcuran. abu, Tih Vai Yur Yalan, 195,605
BENDASSA, Esther, Sor Grrl Hominy Meigen ot Iran Yao
Ianbul, 1998, 215 5 (On). Cngrand Rabin Séphaede en Pali
1892-1933)
SABUNCU, Li, Vile Soe Bir Paes Lat Solon nw Helens 198
1911, lxanbl, 195236 (apg Euan Tre Tec