You are on page 1of 5

J Neurosurg Pediatrics 9:139–143,

9:000–000, 2012

Posterior fossa epidural hematomas in children: clinical


experience with 40 cases
Clinical article

AltAy Sencer, M.D., yAvuz ArAS, M.D., MehMet OSMAn AkcAkAyA, M.D.,
Burcu GOker, M.D., tAlAt kırıS, M.D., AnD Ali tuncAy cAnBOlAt, M.D.
Department of Neurosurgery, Istanbul School of Medicine, Istanbul University, Istanbul, Turkey

Object. Traumatic posterior fossa epidural hematoma (PFEDH) is rare, but among children it may have a slightly
higher incidence. With the widespread use of CT scanning, the diagnosis of PFEDH can be established more accu­
rately, leading to an increased incidence of the lesion and possibly to a better patient prognosis. This study presents
40 pediatric cases with PFEDH.
Methods. The authors assessed the type of trauma, clinical findings on admission, Glasgow Coma Scale scores,
CT findings (thickness of the hematoma, bone fracture, compression of the fourth ventricle, and ventricle enlarge­
ment), type of treatment, clinical course, and prognosis. Early postoperative CT scans (within the first 6 hours) were
obtained and reviewed in all surgical cases.
Results. Twenty­nine patients underwent surgery and 11 patients received conservative therapy and close fol­
low­up. All patients fared well, and there was no surgical mortality or morbidity.
Conclusions. Based on the data in this large series, the authors conclude that PFEDH in children can be treated
in experienced centers with excellent outcome, and there is no need to avoid surgery when it is indicated.
(http://thejns.org/doi/abs/10.3171/2011.11.PEDS11177)

key WOrDS • epidural hematoma • posterior fossa • children • surgery •


trauma

T
raumaTic PFEDHs represent a rare clinical entity. surgery Trauma Care Unit, Istanbul School of Medicine,
Their rate among all epidural hematomas ranges between January 1995 and April 2011, 473 patients were
between 1.2% and 15% for all age groups accord­ younger than 17 years. Files of those with PFEDHs were
ing to various reports.2,3,6–8,15,17 Among children, PFEDHs retrospectively reviewed. The study group consisted of 40
may have a slightly higher incidence.7,18,20 children with PFEDHs of traumatic origin. There were
With widespread use of CT scanning, the diagnosis 22 boys and 18 girls with a male/female ratio of 1:2. Ages
of PFEDHs can be established more accurately. Improved ranged from 1 to 17 years (mean 6.7 years). We recorded
diagnostic capability has led to an increased incidence of and evaluated the type of trauma, clinical findings on ad­
the lesion and possibly to a better prognosis.5,7,10,14,15,25 In mission, GCS score, CT findings (thickness of the hemato­
the present study we provide data obtained in 40 pedi­ ma, bone fracture, compression of the fourth ventricle, and
atric patients with PFEDH treated surgically or conser­ ventricle enlargement), type of treatment, clinical course,
vatively with no mortality or morbidity. We believe this and prognosis. Early postoperative CT scans (within the
report may be an important contribution to the literature first 6 hours) were acquired in all surgical cases.
because the literature contains a cumulative number of
approximately 100 cases and we provide 40 additional
cases.1,3,7–9,11,19,27 Results
The predominant cause of PFEDH was a fall from
Methods a height resulting in a blow to the back of the head in 34
Of 824 patients with epidural hematomas treated patients (85%). Motor vehicle accidents were the second
surgically or conservatively at the Department of Neuro­ most frequent cause (4 patients [10%]), and there was an
“other” type of injury in 2 patients (5%).
Abbreviations used in this paper: GCS = Glasgow Coma Scale; Thirty­one patients (77.5%) were admitted within
PFEDH = posterior fossa epidural hematoma; SAH = subarachnoid 24 hours of injury, 8 (20%) within 48 hours, and 1 was
hemorrhage. brought to the hospital within 72 hours.

J Neurosurg: Pediatrics / Volume 9 / February 2012 139


A. Sencer et al.

During admission, the GCS scores were used to as­ TABLE 1: Summary of clinical fetaures of patients with PFEDH*
sess the level of consciousness of the patients. Thirty­one
patients (77.5%) had a GCS score of 15, 4 had a score of No. of Patients (%)
14 (10%), 1 had a score of 13, and 4 patients had GCS Clinical Features Total Op/No Op
scores of 11, 10, 9, and 8.
Symptoms and clinical findings on admission were interval btwn trauma & admission
nausea and vomiting in 23 patients (57.5%), occipital <24 hrs 31 (77.5) 24/7
swelling in 17 (42.5%), headache in 15 (37.5%), cerebellar 24–48 hrs 8 (20) 5/3
signs in 11 (27.5%), temporary loss of consciousness in 6 48–72 hrs 1 (2.5) 0/1
(15%), and drowsiness in 2 (5%). admission GCS score
Unenhanced head CT scans including bone window <7 0 0
settings were obtained in all patients. An epidural hema­
toma was present in the posterior cranial fossa in all cases. 8–12 4 (10) 4/0
The thickness of the clot varied between 0.2 and 2.5 cm. A 13–14 5 (12.5) 5/0
fracture of the occipital bone could be detected in 35 pa­ 15 31 (77.5) 20/11
tients (87.5%), and multiple intracranial injuries were pres­ symptoms & signs
ent in 9 patients (22.5%). Compression or effacement of the nausea & vomiting 23 (57.5) 15/8
fourth ventricle was encountered in 15 cases (37.5%), and occipital swelling 17 (42.5) 12/5
ventricular dilation was observed in 6 cases (15%).
One child with a diagnosis of hemophilia A was ad­ headache 15 (37.5) 6/9
mitted to the intensive care unit of our pediatrics depart­ cerebellar signs 11 (27.5) 9/2
ment, and another patient had a history of osteogenesis temporary LOC 6 (15) 6/0
imperfecta diagnosed earlier at another hospital. Both of asymptomatic 3 (7.5) 0/3
these patients were followed up conservatively without drowsiness 2 (5) 2/0
need of a surgical intervention. otorrhagia 1 (2.5) 1/0
Clinical and radiological features are summarized in
Tables 1 and 2. epistaxis 1 (2.5) 0/1
In 28 patients (72.5%), we performed immediate trauma type
surgery—a suboccipital craniectomy, usually restricted to fall from a height 34 (85) 25/9
the side of the hematoma and as wide as necessary to con­ MVA 4 (10) 3/1
trol the active bleeding if present. Figures 1 and 2 show bicycle accident 1 (2.5) 1/0
pre­ and postoperative CT scans obtained in one of the hit by a football 1 (2.5) 0/1
surgical cases, demonstrating removal of the hematoma
and resolution of the fourth ventricle compression. One * LOC = loss of consciousness; MVA = motor vehicle accident.
of the patients underwent surgery 24 hours after admis­
sion because the hematoma enlarged and the clinical sta­ counts for 9%–20% of all traumatic extradural hema­
tus worsened. Early postoperative scans acquired in the tomas in children, whereas in adults the range is much
surgical cases showed no significant residual hematoma lower, around 2%–11%. Because this is a rare entity, the
and resolution of ventricular dilation if present before sur­ pediatric cases of traumatic PFEDH published in the lit­
gery. Eleven patients (27.5%) were fully alert at admission erature are limited to case reports and small series. After
and harbored an epidural hematoma. They had no CT­ the introduction of CT scanning, clinical reports on child­
documented mass effect, no compression or displacement hood PFEDH have increased, but still they include only
of the fourth ventricle, obliteration of perimesencephalic small populations.2–5,7–9,11,14–19,21,22 In our institution, which
cisterns, or sign of ventricular dilation. These 11 patients has a busy emergency and traumatology unit, with ap­
were followed conservatively, undergoing clinical neu­ proximately 1500 cases of head trauma annually, trau­
rological examinations and serial CT scanning (at 6, 12, matic PFEDHs in children account for 4.9% of all pa­
24, 48, and 72 hours after admission). Figure 3 provides tients and 8.5% of pediatric­age patients with epidural
an example of a conservatively managed case in which hematomas.
the admission and 48-hour CT scans reveal no significant The cause of PFEDHs in children is most common­
change in hematoma thickness and mass effect. ly a fall, similar to many other forms of craniocerebral
All patients, treated surgically or conservatively, fared trauma in this age group.2,3,7,11,19 In 85% of our patients
well and were discharged with normal neurological status the hematoma was acquired by falling and hitting the oc­
after a mean hospital stay of 6.5 days. The patients were cipital region of the skull. Motor vehicle accidents, which
then followed up in the outpatient clinic 1 and 4 weeks af­ are unfortunately a major cause of death and disability in
ter surgery. An additional control CT scan was obtained 4
weeks after discharge. There were no radiological or clini­
this country, accounted for PFEDHs in 10% of our pa­
cal pathological entities found at the 4-week postdischarge
tients. Posterior fossa epidural hematomas are most often
noted in males in the first 3 decades of life. Most studies
examination. report higher incidences in the second half of the 1st de­
Discussion cade.7,20,22 In our large study group the male/female ratio
was 1:2 and the median age was 6.7 years in accordance
Posterior fossa epidural hematoma is rare. It ac­ with data in previous reports.

140 J Neurosurg: Pediatrics / Volume 9 / February 2012


Posterior fossa epidural hematomas in children
TABLE 2: Summary of radiological fetaures in patients with
PFEDH

No. of Patients (%)


Radiological Features Total Op/No Op
thickness of PFEDH
<5 mm 11 (27.5) 0/11
5–15 mm 11 (27.5) 11/0
>15 mm 18 (45) 18/0
accompanying lesions
Fig. 2. Postoperative CT scans obtained in the same patient in Fig. 1.
occipital bone fracture 35 (87.5) 29/6
contusion 5 (12.5) 4/1
scanning at 6, 12, 24, 48, and 72 hours after admission—
pneumocephalus 3 (7.5) 2/1
may not be considered to be a cost­effective practice, but
traumatic SAH 3 (7.5) 2/1 taking into account the potential for rapid and fatal dete­
subdural hematoma 1 (2.5) 1/0 rioration, we find it a useful tool.
mass effect There are no defined criteria for deciding between
4th ventricle compression 15 (37.5) 15/0 conservative and surgical treatment.1,5,15 Neurological
obliteration of perimesencephalic 11 (27.5) 11/0 findings, GCS score on admission, the thickness of the
blood clot, accompanying compression of the fourth ven­
tricle, and ventricular dilation on the first CT scan are im­
cisterns
ventriculomegaly 6 (15) 6/0
portant. Different authors have tried to define indications
for surgery such as hematoma volume of no more than 10
The clinical picture in PFEDH can be grouped as cm3, hematoma thickness of no more than 15 mm, mid­
acute, subacute, and chronic according to the presenta­ line shift of no more 5 mm, and obliteration of perimes­
tion and duration of clinical symptoms. In the acute form encephalic cisterns.5 We used thickness instead of vol­
the clinical symptoms present within the first 3 days of ume as a surgical criterion because, on the one hand, an
injury; the acute variety is usually encountered in the extraaxial hematoma can have much greater volume if it
young children with diffuse injury.7,20 Our patients most is thin but smeared to the inner layer of the bone, whereas
often presented with the acute form of disease and under­ its thickness is much smaller and causes no mass effect.
went surgery on an emergency basis (when surgery was On the other hand, extraaxial hematomas with smaller
indicated); however, the age range was relatively wide, volumes but significant thickness may cause mass effect
with the average age around the middle of the 1st decade. or midline shift especially in a narrow space like the pos­
Clinically, the subacute (symptom onset between Days 3 terior fossa. In our 28 patients (70%) who had signs of
and 14) and chronic (symptom onset after Day 14) forms neurological deterioration or fourth ventricle compres­
were not encountered in our patients. sion, cases of ventricular dilation or epidural hematoma
As was also shown in our study, PFEDH may result with mass effect were immediately treated with surgery.
from mild to moderate head injury and symptoms may Twelve patients who had normal neurological status and
be minor, like headache and vomiting, but the clinical an admission CT scan showing a hematoma without mass
picture can progress rapidly.3,7,8,11,13,15,17,19 Therefore, wide­ effect, with no compression or displacement of the fourth
spread use of CT scanning has facilitated accurate diag­ ventricle, perimesencephalic cisterns, and no signs of
nosis and also improved outcome, and we recommend ventricular dilation, were followed up conservatively with
that CT scans be obtained even with the mildest of suspi­ close clinical neurological examinations.
cions. Moreover, the radiological follow­up criteria used
in our conservatively treated cases—namely control CT

Fig. 1. Preoperative CT scans revealing a large PFEDH in a 14-year- Fig. 3. Admission (left) and 48-hour postadmission (right) CT scans
old boy, displacing the fourth ventricle and causing ventriculomegaly. acquired in an 8-year-old boy with conservatively managed PFEDH.

J Neurosurg: Pediatrics / Volume 9 / February 2012 141


A. Sencer et al.

Retrospective analysis of our data revealed that all pa­ area with an approximate population of 15 million inhabit­
tients with a hematoma thickness of less than 5 mm were ants. Compared with the data in the literature, our series
followed up conservatively. All 29 patients with a hema­ contains significantly more patients with a delayed admis­
toma thickness of greater than 5 mm underwent surgery. sion. Nine (22.5%) of our patients were admitted after the
In 18 patients the hematoma thickness was greater than first 24 hours. Most of these patients were referred to our
15 mm, which has been accepted as a surgical indication. clinic because of hematoma enlargement or clinical dete­
The other 11 patients, in whom the hematoma thickness rioration, as the patients were conservatively followed up
varied between 5 and 15 mm, had accompanying injuries/ in small state hospitals or private clinics. The initial CT
conditions (for instance, a contusion, pneumocephalus, or scan obtained at our institution was actually like a control
SAH) causing additional mass effect or a GCS score less CT scan for these patients, and in most of the patients sur­
than 15, so surgical intervention was chosen in their man­ gery was undertaken based on this investigation. This find­
agement. Morbidity and mortality rates were found to be ing indicates that conservative management of pediatric
higher in former publications. In our study, which to our PFEDH is a very dynamic process. Computed tomography
knowledge represents the largest pediatric PFEDH series scans play a crucial role in the decision-making process
to date, we believe the absence of mortality and morbidity because it is known that radiological findings occur before
might be associated with our surgical criteria. Based on the change in the clinical picture.4,5 We believe that repeat
our data and the successful outcomes in our series, we be­ CT scans are important in the follow­up of conservatively
lieve a 5-mm-thick hematoma might be a better surgical treated cases, and although recent reports suggest restric­
indication in pediatric cases. Considering the difficulty of tion of CT use in children due to the threat of radiation,
assessing of neurological status or administering the GCS early repeat CT scans may be lifesaving in the follow­up of
in small children, neurosurgeons must be aware of each PFEDH in children. Repeat CT scans should not be aban­
PFEDH, even those of a relatively “small” size. doned until there is more solid evidence of any harmful ef­
An occipital fracture accompanying PFEDH has fects of the radiation dose delivered by CT scanning. Newer
been widely reported in the literature. We have identified protocols for control cranial CT scans with readjustment of
occipital fractures in almost 87.5% of our patients and doses for children should be considered in the meantime.
multiple intracranial injuries in 22.5%. The frequent use Our radiology department complies with ALARA prin­
of CT is again of utmost importance in cases with multiple ciples12,23,24 (recently defined adjustment of imaging proto­
injuries. It helps to detect the types of injury and predict cols to reduce the radiation dose for pediatric patients, also
the prognosis and outcome in these cases. The literature known as “as low as reasonably achievable”) for children
suggests that the relative incidence of hydrocephalus or but other measures for control cranial CT scans in children
ventricular dilation is low in cases of PFEDH.3,4,7,16,17,21,22 can be considered, such as fewer scans of the supratento­
In our series, we observed ventricular dilation in 15% of rial area, just to rule out the development of hydrocephalus.
our patients. In all cases, ventricular dilation was resolved As with any surgical report, the focus of this paper
immediately after surgery. Displacement of the fourth should at least partly be on the success and outcome of
ventricle was more common (37.5%) with no associated surgery. In this study, 72.5% of the patients received sur­
hydrocephalus or ventricular dilation probably because gical treatment and 27.5% were followed up conserva­
emergency evacuation of the hematoma was performed tively. The neurological status in all patients was favor­
in these cases. There was no need for external ventricu­ able during admission, and there were no cases of severe
lar drainage insertion, considering that there were no head injury. All patients fared well after surgery, which
hematomas with mass effect in the conservatively man­ may imply, contrary to the opinion of some authors,
aged group, whereas other hematomas with a mass effect, that surgery may not add further morbidity or mortal­
clinical signs, and symptoms were evacuated immediate­ ity to the existing neurological state. Additionally, other
ly. In the postoperative period, ventricular dilation was reports with favorable results (also with no mortality or
dissolved and there was no need for external ventricular morbidity) have been published, as have other reports of
drainage during the hospital stay or further shunt surgery low mortality and morbidity rates, but they all included
after discharge in our patient group. much smaller patient populations.3,7,8,11,19,26 We believe
Our clinical protocol for conservatively managed pe­ that emergency surgery must be undertaken whenever
diatric PFEDHs is based on serial control scans obtained it is deemed necessary, especially considering the rapid
within the first 72 hours of trauma (at 6, 12, 24, 48, and and fatal progression of the lesion, although surgery may
72 hours postinjury). Enlargement of the hematoma and require other expertise due to anatomical considerations.
compression of the fourth ventricle with or without ven­
tricular dilation were evaluated as evidence of mass effect Conclusions
and brainstem compression. One patient (2.5%) underwent
surgery 24 hours after admission due to the enlargement This is a relatively large and recent review of data
of the hematoma and worsening of neurological status. from a university hospital with a busy emergency unit.
Regarding this data, one may question our serial imaging The favorable outcome may be attributed to the exclusive
protocol and the necessity of the extensive investigative use of CT scanning in the diagnosis and follow­up of all
protocol, considering that enlargement of the hematoma cases, the improvement of neuroanesthesia and intensive
resulted in delayed surgery in only 1 patient. However, our care, and cumulative data from very recent experience,
institution is a tertiary trauma center, which is the oldest in addition to the mostly favorable admission statuses of
and most experienced university clinic in a metropolitan the patients.

142 J Neurosurg: Pediatrics / Volume 9 / February 2012


Posterior fossa epidural hematomas in children

Finally, we believe that with the use of modern tools acute clinical deterioration. Am J Emerg Med 25:989–995,
in neuroimaging, surgery, and intensive care, PFEDH 2007
in children can be treated safely at experienced centers. 14. Jang JW, Lee JK, Seo BR, Kim SH: Traumatic epidural hae­
matoma of the posterior cranial fossa. Br J Neurosurg 25:
There is no need to avoid surgery when it is indicated. 55–61, 2011
15. Karasu A, Sabanci PA, Izgi N, Imer M, Sencer A, Cansever T,
Disclosure et al: Traumatic epidural hematomas of the posterior cranial
fossa. Surg Neurol 69:247–252, 2008
The authors report no conflict of interest concerning the mate­ 16. Lui TN, Lee ST, Chang CN, Cheng WC: Epidural hematomas
rials or methods used in this study or the findings specified in this in the posterior cranial fossa. J Trauma 34:211–215, 1993
paper. 17. Malik NK, Makhdoomi R, Indira B, Shankar S, Sastry K:
Author contributions to the study and manuscript prepara­ Posterior fossa extradural hematoma: our experience and re­
tion include the following. Conception and design: Sencer, Aras. view of the literature. Surg Neurol 68:155–158, 2007
Acquisition of data: Akcakaya, Sencer, Aras, Goker. Analysis and 18. Mohanty A, Kolluri VR, Subbakrishna DK, Satish S, Mouli
interpretation of data: Akcakaya, Sencer, Aras, Goker. Drafting BA, Das BS: Prognosis of extradural haematomas in children.
the article: Akcakaya, Sencer, Aras. Critically revising the article: Pediatr Neurosurg 23:57–63, 1995
all authors. Reviewed submitted version of manuscript: all authors. 19. Mori K, Handa H, Munemitsu H, Oda Y, Hashimoto N,
Approved the final version of the manuscript on behalf of all authors: Kojima M: Epidural hematomas of the posterior fossa in chil­
Akcakaya. Study supervision: Sencer. dren. Childs Brain 10:130–140, 1983
20. Peter JC, Domingo Z: Subacute traumatic extradural haema­
References
tomas of the posterior fossa: a clinicopathological entity of
the 5­ to 10­year­old child. Childs Nerv Syst 6:135–138, 1990
1. Ammirati M, Tomita T: Posterior fossa epidural hematoma 21. Pozzati E, Tognetti F, Cavallo M, Acciarri N: Extradural he­
during childhood. Neurosurgery 14:541–544, 1984 matomas of the posterior cranial fossa. Observations on a se­
2. Asanin B: Traumatic epidural hematomas in posterior cranial ries of 32 consecutive cases treated after the introduction of
fossa. Acta Clin Croat 48:27–30, 2009 computed tomography scanning. Surg Neurol 32:300–303,
3. Berker M, Cataltepe O, Ozcan OE: Traumatic epidural hae­ 1989
matoma of the posterior fossa in childhood: 16 new cases and 22. Roda JM, Giménez D, Pérez-Higueras A, Blázquez MG,
a review of the literature. Br J Neurosurg 17:226–229, 2003 Pérez­Alvarez M: Posterior fossa epidural hematomas: a re­
4. Bor­Seng­Shu E, Aguiar PH, de Almeida Leme RJ, Mandel view and synthesis. Surg Neurol 19:419–424, 1983
M, Andrade AF, Marino R Jr: Epidural hematomas of the pos­ 23. Scaife ER, Rollins MD: Managing radiation risk in the evalu­
terior cranial fossa. Neurosurg Focus 16(2):ECP1, 2004 ation of the pediatric trauma patient. Semin Pediatr Surg
5. Bozbuğa M, Izgi N, Polat G, Gürel I: Posterior fossa epidural 19:252–256, 2010
hematomas: observations on a series of 73 cases. Neurosurg 24. Singh S, Kalra MK, Moore MA, Shailam R, Liu B, Toth TL,
Rev 22:34–40, 1999 et al: Dose reduction and compliance with pediatric CT pro­
6. Bullock MR, Chesnut R, Ghajar J, Gordon D, Hartl R, Newell tocols adapted to patient size, clinical indication, and number
DW, et al: Surgical management of posterior fossa mass le­ of prior studies. Radiology 252:200–208, 2009
sions. Neurosurgery 58 (3 Suppl):S47–Siv, 2006 25. Stone JL, Schaffer L, Ramsey RG, Moody RA: Epidural he­
7. Ciurea AV, Nuteanu L, Simionescu N, Georgescu S: Posterior matomas of the posterior fossa. Surg Neurol 11:419–424,
fossa extradural hematomas in children: report of nine cases. 1979
Childs Nerv Syst 9:224–228, 1993 26. Wong CW: The CT criteria for conservative treatment—but
8. Costa Clara JM, Claramunt E, Ley L, Lafuente J: Traumatic under close clinical observation—of posterior fossa epidural
extradural hematomas of the posterior fossa in children. haematomas. Acta Neurochir (Wien) 126:124–127, 1994
Childs Nerv Syst 12:145–148, 1996 27. Zuccarello M, Andrioli GC, Fiore DL, Longatti PL, Pardat­
9. Dhellemmes P, Lejeune JP, Christiaens JL, Combelles G: scher K, Zampieri P: Traumatic posterior fossa haemorrhage
Traumatic extradural hematomas in infancy and childhood. in children. Acta Neurochir (Wien) 62:79–85, 1982
Experience with 144 cases. J Neurosurg 62:861–864, 1985
10. Dirim BV, Orük C, Erdoğan N, Gelal F, Uluç E: Traumatic
posterior fossa hematomas. Diagn Interv Radiol 11:14–18, Manuscript submitted May 6, 2011.
2005 Accepted November 1, 2011.
11. Ersahin Y, Mutluer S: Posterior fossa extradural hematomas in Please include this information when citing this paper: DOI:
children. Pediatr Neurosurg 19:31–33, 1993 10.3171/2011.11.PEDS11177.
12. Frush DP, Soden B, Frush KS, Lowry C: Improved pediatric Address correspondence to: Mehmet Osman Akcakaya, M.D.,
multidetector body CT using a size­based color­coded format. Department of Neurosurgery, Istanbul Universitesi Istanbul Tıp
AJR Am J Roentgenol 178:721–726, 2002 Fakultesi Norosirurji Anabilim Dalı, Norolojik Bilimler Binası 6.kat
13. Hayashi T, Kameyama M, Imaizumi S, Kamii H, Onuma T: Çapa/Fatih/İstanbul 34093, Turkey. email: moakcakaya@gmail.
Acute epidural hematoma of the posterior fossa—cases of com.

J Neurosurg: Pediatrics / Volume 9 / February 2012 143

You might also like