Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Abstract. For an odd prime p and a positive integer n, it is well known that there are two types of
extra-special p-groups of order p2n+1 , first one is the Heisenberg group which has exponent p and the
second one is of exponent p2 . This article mainly describes the endomorphism semigroups of both the
types of extra-special p-groups and computes their cardinalities as polynomials in p for each n. Firstly
a new way of representing the extra-special p-group of exponent p2 is given. Using the representations,
explicit formulae for any endomorphism and any automorphism of an extra-special p-group G for
both the types are found. Based on these formulae, the endomorphism semigroup End(G) and the
automorphism group Aut(G) are described. The endomorphism semigroup image of any element in
G is found and the orbits under the action of the automorphism group Aut(G) are determined. As a
consequence it is deduced that, under the notion of degeneration of elements in G, the endomorphism
semigroup End(G) induces a partial order on the automorphism orbits when G is the Heisenberg group
and does not induce when G is the extra-special p-group of exponent p2 . Finally we prove that the
cardinality of isotropic subspaces of any fixed dimension in a non-degenerate symplectic space is a
polynomial in p with non-negative integer coefficients. Using this fact we compute the cardinality of
End(G).
1. Introduction
1.1. Preamble. In the literature, for a prime p, a special group is defined as an elementary abelian
p-group or a p-group where the Frattini subgroup, the commutator subgroup and the center coincide
201
202 Int. J. Group Theory, 11 no. 4 (2022) 201-220 C. P. Anil Kumar and S. S. Pradhan
and the center is of exponent p. An extra-special p-group is a non-abelian special group where the
center is of order p. The extra-special p-groups arise in various contexts and are well studied groups.
This article mainly studies the endomorphism semigroups of extra-special p-groups and also computes
their cardinalities. As a consequence of this new study we answer the question of existence of a
certain partial order on the automorphism orbits. However, we mention three different contexts in the
literature where these groups arise.
Firstly, they occupy a distinctive place in the representation theory (D. E. Gorenstein [7, Chapter
5, Section 5, Theorem 5.4]), L. Dornhoff [5, Chapter 31, Theorem 31.5], H. Opolka [12]) and the
cohomology of finite groups (D. J. Benson and J. F. Carlson [1],[2]).
Secondly, the extra-special p-groups have generated considerable interest in the study of its non-
commuting subsets from a group theoretic and combinatorial view point (A. Y. M. Chin [4], M. Isaacs [3],
H. Liu and Y. Wang [10], [11]).
Thirdly, the automorphism group of an extra-special p-group is also an important topic of study in
the literature. D. L. Winter [14] has determined the structure of Aut(G) for an extra-special p-group
G. More precisely, he has proved that the automorphism group Aut(G) is the semi-direct product of
the normal subgroup N of centrally trivial automorphisms, (that is, those automorphisms which act
trivially on the center Z(G)) and a cyclic group of order (p − 1) generated by an automorphism of G
which is an extension of the generator of Aut(Z(G)). Moreover, it is shown that the quotient group
N
Inn(G) of N by the inner automorphism group Inn(G) is isomorphic to a subgroup of a symplectic
group whose structure is also known. It is also known that for an odd prime p, the group Aut(G) is
a split extension of the outer automorphism group Out(G) by Inn(G). For p = 2, this need not be
true as shown by R. L. Griess Jr. [8]. H. Liu and Y. Wang [9] have determined the structure of the
automorphism group of a generalized extra-special p-group.
We summarize briefly the contents of this article. For an odd prime p and a positive integer n, we com-
pute and give an explicit expression for an endomorphism and an automorphism of an extra-special
p-group of order p2n+1 . More precisely, first we present in an explicitly new way, the extra-special
p-group of order p2n+1 and of exponent p2 (Definition 1.3), just similar to one of the standard repre-
sentations of the Heisenberg group of order p2n+1 (Definition 1.2). These definitions are advantageous
to write down formulae for any endomorphism and any automorphism for both types of groups (in
main Theorems Ω, Σ). Even though the structure of the automorphism group in the literature [14]
exists, we derive the formulae for endomorphisms and automorphisms in a very natural and elegant
manner. The importance of these explicit formulae is that they facilitate us to compute the endo-
morphism semigroup images of elements in the group and the automorphism orbits. The notion of
degeneration of elements (Definition 1.5) via endomorphisms is introduced in the case of finite abelian
p-groups by K. Dutta and A. Prasad [6]. This notion gives rise to a partial order on the automorphism
orbits as observed by them in [6]. Here for the case of extra-special p-groups we explore the existence
of a similar partial order on automorphism orbits. Finally here, we have computed the cardinality
of the endomorphism semigroup and the cardinality of the automorphism group of an extra-special
http://dx.doi.org/10.22108/IJGT.2021.129815.1708
Int. J. Group Theory, 11 no. 4 (2022) 201-220 C. P. Anil Kumar and S. S. Pradhan 203
p-group of order p2n+1 for both the types as a polynomial in p with integer coefficients for each n.
Moreover, while computing the cardinality of the endomorphism group we prove that the cardinality
of isotropic subspaces of any fixed dimension in a non-degenerate symplectic space is a polynomial in
p with non-negative integer coefficients.
1.2. Statement of Main Theorems. We begin this section with a few required definitions in order
to state the main theorems.
Definition 1.1 (Extra-special p-group and its Associated Symplectic Form). Let p be an odd prime. A
finite group G is said to be an extra-special p-group if [G, G] = G0 = Z(G) and Z(G) is of order p. In
this case we have that G0 = Z(G) = Φ(G), the Frattini subgroup of G, and G
Z(G) is elementary abelian,
isomorphic to Z2n
p for some n ∈ N. The group G hence has order p2n+1 (refer to D. Gorenstein [7,
Chapter 5, Section 5, Theorem 5.2, p. 204]). It is equipped with a non-degenerate symplectic form
hh∗, ∗ii defined as:
G G
hh∗, ∗ii : × −→ Zp , hhx, yii = f (x, y) with x = xZ(G), y = yZ(G)
Z(G) Z(G)
where f : G × G −→ Zp is defined by the equation [x, y] = z f (x,y) for a fixed generator z of Z(G) (refer
to D. J. S. Robinson [13, Chapter 5, p. 145]).
Definition 1.2 (Extra-special p-group of First Type: Heisenberg Group). Let p be an odd prime, n be a
positive integer and Zp be the finite field order p. For u = (u1 , u2 , . . . , un )t , w = (w1 , w2 , . . . , wn )t ∈ Znp
Pn
where t stands for transpose, define hu, wi = ui wi ∈ Zp . Then the Heisenberg group is defined as a
i=1
set ES1 (p, n) = Znp ⊕ Znp ⊕ Zp with the following group operation. For (ui , wi , z i ) ∈ ES1 (p, n), i = 1, 2,
Definition 1.3 (Extra-special p-group of Second Type: Exponent p2 ). Let p be an odd prime, n be a
positive integer and Zpi = Z/pi Z be the cyclic ring of order pi , i = 1, 2. Let i21 : Zp = {0, 1, 2, . . . , p −
1} ,→ Zp2 = {0, 1, 2, . . . , p2 − 1} with i21 (a) = pa for a ∈ Zp be the standard inclusion as an abelian
group where the generator 1 ∈ Zp maps to p ∈ Zp2 . For u = (u2 , u3 , . . . , un )t , w = (w2 , w3 , . . . , wn )t ∈
n
Zn−1
P
p , define hu, wi = ui wi ∈ Zp . The extra-special p-group of second type is defined as a set
i=2
with the following group operation. For (ui1 , ui , w1i , wi ) ∈ ES2 (p, n), i = 1, 2,
u11 , u1 , w11 , w1 . u21 , u2 , w12 , w2 =
u11 + u21 + i21 (w12 )u11 + i21 (hu1 , w2 i), u1 + u2 , w11 + w12 , w1 + w2 .
Remark 1.4. Let p be an odd prime and G be an extra-special p-group. Then G is isomorphic to
either ES1 (p, n) or ES2 (p, n) for some n. This fact is justified in Section 2. If σ is an endomorphism
G
(resp. automorphism) of G then it gives rise to σ an endomorphism (resp. automorphism) of Z(G) .
http://dx.doi.org/10.22108/IJGT.2021.129815.1708
204 Int. J. Group Theory, 11 no. 4 (2022) 201-220 C. P. Anil Kumar and S. S. Pradhan
Definition 1.5 (Partial Order on Orbits and the Notion of Degeneration). Let G be a finite group.
Let Aut(G), End(G) be its automorphism group and endomorphism semigroup respectively. Let S be
the set of automorphism orbits in G. Let x, y ∈ G. We say y is endomorphic to x or x “degenerates
to” y if there exists σ ∈ End(G) such that σ(x) = y. We say y is automorphic to x if there exists
σ ∈ Aut(G) such that σ(x) = y. Let O1 , O2 be two automorphism orbits in G. We say O2 ≤ O1
if for some x ∈ O1 and for some y ∈ O2 , we have that y is endomorphic to x. The order ≤ is in
general need not be a partial order. We say the endomorphism semigroup induces a partial order ≤
on the automorphism orbits if whenever y is endomorphic to x and x is endomorphic to y then y is
automorphic to x. The motivation for the notion of degeneration is given and introduced for the first
time by A. Prasad and K. Dutta [6].
Remark 1.6. Let p be a prime and G be a finite abelian p-group. Then the endomorphism semigroup
End(G) (here an endomorphism algebra) induces a partial order on automorphism orbits [6].
Theorem Ω.
Let p be an odd prime and n be a positive integer. Let G = ES1 (p, n). Then:
G
(A) If σ ∈ End(G) then the induced endomorphism σ of Z(G) satisfies
such that
!
A C
(1.1) σ= ∈ sympscalar (2n, Zp ), σ t ∆σ = l∆
D B
http://dx.doi.org/10.22108/IJGT.2021.129815.1708
Int. J. Group Theory, 11 no. 4 (2022) 201-220 C. P. Anil Kumar and S. S. Pradhan 205
satisfying
1 1
(1.3) e(u, w, z) = α(u) + β(w) + lz + ut (At D)u + wt (C t B)w + wt (C t D)u.
σ
2 2
It is also implied that if σ is given as in Equations 1.1, 1.2, 1.3 then σ ∈ End(G).
(C) An automorphism is a special case of an endomorhism σ for which l ∈ Z∗p implying σ ∈
Spscalar (2n, Zp ). It is also implied that if σ is given as in Equations 1.1, 1.2, 1.3 and l 6= 0
then σ ∈ Aut(G).
(D) The set of endomorphism semigroup images of an element g ∈ G is given by:
(a) {e} if g = e and has cardinality 1.
(b) Z(G) if g ∈ Z(G)\{e} and has cardinality p.
(c) G if g ∈ G\Z(G) and has cardinality p2n+1 .
(E) There are three automorphism orbits in G. They are given by:
(a) The identity element {e} and has cardinality 1.
(b) The central non-identity elements Z(G)\{e} and has cardinality p − 1.
(c) The non-central elements G\Z(G) and has cardinality p2n+1 − p.
(F) The endomorphism semigroup induces a partial order (in fact a total order) on automorphism
orbits which is given by
{e} < Z(G)\{e} < G\Z(G).
We introduce some further notation before stating the second main theorem.
• u e denote vectors in Znp for some n.
e, w
• Let i21 : Zp ,→ Zp2 be the inclusion of the abelian group Zp taking the generator 1 ∈ Zp to
p ∈ Zp2 .
• For u1 ∈ Zp2 , let u1 ∈ Zp be its reduction modulo p.
• Let π : Zp ⊕ Zn−1
p −→ Zn−1
p be the projection ignoring the first co-ordinate.
• For G = ES2 (p, n) let H = pZp2 ⊕Zn−1
p ⊕Zp ⊕Zn−1
p , K = pZp2 ⊕{0n−1 }⊕Zp ⊕{0n−1 } = Z(H)
and we have Z(G) = pZp2 ⊕ {0n−1 } ⊕ {0} ⊕ {0n−1 }.
We state the second main theorem of the article.
Theorem Σ.
Let p be an odd prime and n be a positive integer. Let G = ES2 (p, n). Then:
G
(A) If σ ∈ End(G) then the induced endomorphism σ of Z(G) satisfies
where l ∈ Zp is given by the equation σ(z) = z l for any generator z of Z(G). Let x1 =
(1, 0n−1 , 0, 0n−1 ), y1 = (0, 0n−1 , 1, 0n−1 ), xi = (0, en−1
i−1 , 0, 0
n−1 ), y = (0, 0n−1 , 0, en−1 ) ∈ G for
i i−1
2 ≤ i ≤ n. We have
(a) For each g ∈ G there exists σ ∈ End(G) such that σ(x1 ) = g.
(b) For any v ∈ {x2 , . . . , xn , y1 , y2 , . . . , yn } and any h ∈ H there exists σ ∈ End(G) such that
σ(v) = h. Moreover for any σ ∈ End(G), σ(v) ∈ H.
(B) The endomorphisms σ are in bijection with 7-tuples (A, B, C, D, α, β, a) where
such that
a12 = a13 = . . . = a1n = 0, c11 = c12 = . . . = c1n = 0
!
(1.4) A C
σ= ∈ sympscalar (2n, Zp ), σ t ∆σ = a11 ∆
D B
G
with respect to the ordered basis {x1 , x2 , . . . , xn , y 1 , y 2 , . . . , y n } of Z(G) = Z2n n−1 )∨ , β ∈
p and α ∈ (Zp
!
u1
(Znp )∨ , a ∈ Zp2 such that for (u1 , u, w1 , w) ∈ G with u e= = (e
u1 , u en )t ∈ Znp , w
e2 , . . . , u e =
u
!
w1
= (w
e1 , w en )t ∈ Znp . we have
e2 , . . . , w
w
satisfying
a ≡ a11 mod p with a11 allowed to be zero,
(1.6) 1 t t 1 t t
s = α(u) + β(e w) + u e (A D)e
u+ w e (C B)ew+w e t (C t D)e
u.
2 2
It is also implied that if σ is given as in Equations 1.4, 1.5, 1.6 then σ ∈ End(G).
(C) An automorphism is a special case of an endomorphism σ for which a11 ∈ Z∗p implying that
σ ∈ Spscalar (2n, Zp ). It is also implied that if σ is given as in Equations 1.4, 1.5, 1.6 and
a11 6= 0 mod p then σ ∈ Aut(G).
As a consequence we have in addition
(a) b11 = 1.
(b) b21 = b31 = . . . = bn1 = c21 = c31 = . . . = cn1 = 0.
(c) σ(x1 ) = xa111 g for some g ∈ H.
(d) σ(y1 ) = y1 h for some h ∈ Z(G).
(e) For 2 ≤ i ≤ n, σ(xi ), σ(yi ) ∈ H\K.
(D) The set of endomorphism semigroup images of an element g ∈ G is given by:
(a) {e} if g = e and has cardinality 1.
(b) Z(G) if g ∈ Z(G)\{e} and has cardinality p.
(c) H if g ∈ H\Z(G) and has cardinality p2n .
http://dx.doi.org/10.22108/IJGT.2021.129815.1708
Int. J. Group Theory, 11 no. 4 (2022) 201-220 C. P. Anil Kumar and S. S. Pradhan 207
2. Preliminaries
It is well known that any extra-special p-group has exponent either p or p2 and has order p2n+1 for
some n ∈ N. Moreover for any prime p and n ∈ N there are only two non-isomophic extra-special
p-groups of order p2n+1 (refer to D. E. Gorenstein [7, Chapter 5, Theorem 5.2, p. 204]). We also
observe that for an odd prime p, ES1 (p, n) is an extra-special p-group of order p2n+1 and exponent p,
ES2 (p, n) is an extra-special p-group of order p2n+1 and exponent p2 . Hence it follows that for an odd
prime p, if an extra-special p-group of order p2n+1 is of exponent p then it is isomorphic to ES1 (p, n)
and if it is of exponent p2 then it is isomorphic to ES2 (p, n). We also give one more way of presenting
the group ESi (p, n) using a symplectic form for i = 1, 2 which will be useful to prove certain results.
Definition 2.1 (Alternative Definition for ES1 (p, n)). Let p be an odd prime. Let ES
g1 (p, n) =
Znp ⊕ Znp ⊕ Zp . Let hh∗, ∗ii be a non-degenerate symplectic bilinear form on Z2n
p given by the matrix
∆ with respect to the standard basis. Then the group structure on ES g1 (p, n) is defined as: For
(ui , wi , z i ) ∈ ES
g1 (p, n), i = 1, 2 we have
! !
u1 u2
1
(u1 , w1 , z 1 ).(u2 , w2 , z 2 ) = u1 + u2 , w1 + w2 , z 1 + z 2 + , .
2 w1 w2
Definition 2.2 (Alternative Definition for ES2 (p, n)). Let p be an odd prime, n be a positive integer
and Zpi be the cyclic ring of order pi , i = 1, 2. Let i21 : Zp = {0, 1, 2, . . . p−1} ,→ Zp2 = {0, 1, 2, . . . , p2 −
1} with i21 (a) = pa for a ∈ Zp be the standard inclusion as an abelian group where the generator 1 ∈ Zp
maps to p ∈ Zp2 . Let
g2 (p, n) = Zp2 ⊕ Zn−1 ⊕ Zp ⊕ Zn−1 .
ES p p
Remark 2.3. The analogy between the definitions of ES1 (p, n) and ES
g1 (p, n) carries over to the
definitions of ES2 (p, n) and ES
g2 (p, n) as given in Theorem 2.4.
Proof. We prove for l = 1 first. Let ui = (ui1 , ui2 , . . . , uin )t , wi = (w1i , w2i , . . . , wni )t ∈ Znp , i = 1, 2.
n
Let u = (u1 , u2 , . . . , un )t , w = (w1 , w2 , . . . , wn )t ∈ Znp . Let hu, wi =
P
uj wj ∈ Zp . Let us fix the
j=1
symplectic form as
n
! !
u1 u2
X
u1j wj2 − u2j wj1 = hu1 , w2 i − hu2 , w1 i.
, =
w1 w2 j=1
n
! !
e1 e2
u u X
e1j w
ej2 − u
e2j w u1 , w
ej1 = he e 2 i − he
u2 , w
e 1 i.
1
, 2
= u
w
e w
e j=1
Proposition 2.5. Let G be an extra-special p-group (refer to Definition 1.1). Let z ∈ Z(G) be a fixed
G G
generator such that [g1 , g2 ] = z f (g1 ,g2 ) for g1 , g2 ∈ G and f : G × G −→ Zp . Let f : Z(G) × Z(G) −→ Zp
be its associated non-degenerate symplectic bilinear form defined as f (g1 , g2 ) = f (g1 , g2 ). Then we
have:
(1) For σ ∈ End(G), f (σ(g1 ), σ(g2 )) = lf (g1 , g2 ) for any g1 , g2 ∈ G where σ(z) = z l , l ∈ Zp and σ
G
is the induced endomorphism of Z(G) .
(2) For σ ∈ Aut(G), f (σ(g1 ), σ(g2 )) = lf (g1 , g2 ) for any g1 , g2 ∈ G where σ(z) = z l , l ∈ Z∗p and σ
G
is the induced automorphism of Z(G) .
Proof. We have
z lf (g1 ,g2 ) = σ(z f (g1 ,g2 ) ) = σ[g1 , g2 ] = [σ(g1 ), σ(g2 )] = z f (σ(g1 ),σ(g2 )) .
2.1. Some Commutative Diagrams on Extra-special p-Groups. We show that certain diagrams
of groups and maps for the extra-special p-group of the first type are commutative. First we observe
that Z(ES1 (p, n)) = {0n } ⊕ {0n } ⊕ Zp = Z(ES
g1 (p, n)). Let
ES1 (p, n)
π1 : ES1 (p, n) = Znp ⊕ Znp ⊕ Zp −→ = Znp ⊕ Znp ,
Z(ES1 (p, n))
Id k λ Id k
π1
0 −→ Zp = Z(ES1 (p, n)) ES1 (p, n) Znp ⊕ Znp −→ 0
(2.1)
Φ
e1
Aut(ES
g1 (p, n)) GL2n (Zp )
λ◦(∗)◦λ−1 ∼
= Id k
Φ1
Aut(ES1 (p, n)) GL2n (Zp )
http://dx.doi.org/10.22108/IJGT.2021.129815.1708
210 Int. J. Group Theory, 11 no. 4 (2022) 201-220 C. P. Anil Kumar and S. S. Pradhan
e 1 ) = Im(Φ1 ) ⊂
Here λ is as defined in the proof of Theorem 2.4. In particular we get that Im(Φ
GL2n (Zp ).
We show that certain diagrams of groups and maps for the extra-special p-group of the second type
are commutative. First we observe that Z(ES2 (p, n)) = pZp2 ⊕{0n−1 }⊕{0}⊕{0n−1 } = Z(ESg2 (p, n)).
Let
π2 : ES2 (p, n) = Zp2 ⊕ Zn−1
p ⊕ Zp ⊕ Zn−1
p −→
ES2 (p, n)
= Zp ⊕ Zn−1
p ⊕ Zp ⊕ Zn−1
p = Z2n
p ,
Z(ES2 (p, n))
π g2 (p, n) = Zp2 ⊕ Zn−1 ⊕ Zp ⊕ Zn−1 −→
e2 : ES p p
ES
g2 (p, n)
= Zp ⊕ Zn−1
p ⊕ Zp ⊕ Zn−1
p = Z2n
p ,
Z(ES 2 (p, n))
g
be the quotient maps of groups. Let the induced maps be
ES2 (p, n)
Φ2 : Aut(ES2 (p, n)) −→ Aut = GL2n (Zp ),
Z(ES2 (p, n))
g
g2 (p, n)) −→ Aut ES 2 (p, n)
Φe 2 : Aut(ES = GL2n (Zp ).
Z(ES
g2 (p, n))
Then the following two diagrams commute.
π
Z2n
e2
0 −→ pZp2 = Z(ES
g2 (p, n)) ES
g2 (p, n)
p −→ 0
Id k δ Id k
π2
0 −→ pZp2 = Z(ES2 (p, n)) ES2 (p, n) Z2n
p −→ 0
(2.2)
Φ
e2
Aut(ES
g2 (p, n)) GL2n (Zp )
δ◦(∗)◦δ −1 ∼
= Id k
Φ2
Aut(ES2 (p, n)) GL2n (Zp )
e 2 ) = Im(Φ2 ) ⊂
Here δ is as defined in the proof of Theorem 2.4. In particular we get that Im(Φ
GL2n (Zp ). We describe this image exactly in Proposition 4.1.
http://dx.doi.org/10.22108/IJGT.2021.129815.1708
Int. J. Group Theory, 11 no. 4 (2022) 201-220 C. P. Anil Kumar and S. S. Pradhan 211
e(u1 + u2 , w1 + w2 , z 1 + z 2 + hu1 , w2 i) = σ
σ e(u1 , w1 , z 1 )+e
σ (u2 , w2 , z 2 )+
(3.1)
hAu1 + Cw1 , Du2 + Bw2 i.
(3.2) e(u1 + u2 , 0n , 0) = σ
σ e(u1 , 0n , 0) + σ
e(u2 , 0n , 0) + hAu1 , Du2 i.
Similarly we have
(3.3) e(0n , w1 + w2 , 0) = σ
σ e(0n , w1 , 0) + σ
e(0n , w2 , 0) + hCw1 , Bw2 i.
• We observe that
e(0n , 0n , z 1 + z 2 ) = σ
σ e(0n , 0n , z 1 ) + σ
e(0n , 0n , z 2 )
(3.7)
e(0n , 0n , z) = lz for some l ∈ Zp .
⇒σ
The cardinality of End(G) for G = ES1 (p, n) is computed in Section 5, Theorem 5.3.
http://dx.doi.org/10.22108/IJGT.2021.129815.1708
Int. J. Group Theory, 11 no. 4 (2022) 201-220 C. P. Anil Kumar and S. S. Pradhan 213
It is G if g ∈ G\H since an element of order p2 can get mapped to any element under an endomorphism.
First we will show that an element g = (a, A21 , d11 , D21 ) ∈ G of order p2 is automorphic to the element
(1, 0n−1 , 0, 0n−1 ) where a ≡ a11 6≡ 0 mod p. Consider the automorphism σ ∈ Aut(G) such that σ
equals
a11 01×(n−1) 0 01×(n−1)
−At21
A21 a11 I(n−1)×(n−1) 0(n−1)×1 0(n−1)×(n−1) t
where D12 = D21 , B12 = .
d
11 D12 1 B12
a11
D21 0(n−1)×(n−1) 0(n−1)×1 I(n−1)×(n−1)
This automorphism can be used to move (1, 0n−1 , 0, 0n−1 ) to (b, A21 , d11 , D21 ) where b ≡ a ≡ a11
mod p. We can change (b, A21 , d11 , D21 ) to (a, A21 , d11 , D21 ) further by another inner automorphism.
Now we will show that
End(G).(1, 0n−1 , 0, 0n−1 ) = G.
For this the following matrix can be further used.
0 01×(n−1) 0 01×(n−1)
A21 0(n−1)×(n−1) 0(n−1)×1 0(n−1)×(n−1)
∈ sympscalar (2n, Zp ).
d 01×(n−1) 0 01×(n−1)
11
D21 0(n−1)×(n−1) 0(n−1)×1 0(n−1)×(n−1)
It is H if g ∈ H\Z(G) since a non-central element of order p can get mapped under an endomorphism
to any element of order at most p. If g = (pz, u, w1 , w) ∈ H then there are two cases. Either u or w
is non-zero or both u or w are zero and w1 6= 0.
or w is non-zero. Then we show that g is automorphic to! (0, e1n−1 , 0, 0n−1 ). Let M =
Suppose u !
A22 C22 u
∈ Sp(2n − 2, Zp ) be such that the first column of M is . Consider an automorphism
D22 B22 w
σ ∈ Aut(G) such that σ equals
1 01×(n−1) 0 01×(n−1)
A21 A22 0(n−1)×1 C22
d D12 1 B12
11
D21 D22 0(n−1)×1 B22
t A t t t
where D12 = D21 22 − A21 D22 , B12 = D21 C22 − A21 B22 . Here we choose D21 and A21 such that
t A − At D )
(D12 )11 = (D21 22 21 22 11 = w1 . Note that such choices of D21 and A21 exist because the matrix
M is invertible and its first column is non-zero. σ moves (0, e1n−1 , 0, 0n−1 ) to (pz 0 , u, w1 , w) ∈ H for
http://dx.doi.org/10.22108/IJGT.2021.129815.1708
Int. J. Group Theory, 11 no. 4 (2022) 201-220 C. P. Anil Kumar and S. S. Pradhan 215
We consider second case when both u = 0 = w = 0 and w1 6= 0. In this case we show that
!
G A C
(1) Im(Φ2 ) = Im Aut(G) −→ Aut( Z(G) ) = σ = ∈ Spscalar (2n, Zp ) | A = [aij ], B =
D B
[bij ], C = [cij ], D = [dij ] ∈ Mn (Zp ) with a11 6= 0, b11 = 1, a12 = . . . = a1n
= c11 = c12 = . . . =
c1n = 0 = c21 = c31 = . . . = cn1 = b21 = b31 = . . . = bn1 and σ t ∆σ = a11 ∆ .
!
G A C
∈ sympscalar (2n, Zp ) | A =
F
(2) Im End(G) −→ End( Z(G) ) = Im(Φ2 ) σ =
D B
[aij ], B = [bij ], C = [cij ], D = [d
ij ] ∈ M n (Zp ) with a11 = a12 = . . . = a1n = c11 = c12 =
(6)
| Aut(G) | = p2n | Im(Φ2 ) |
n−1
n2 +2n
Y
=p (p − 1) (p2j − 1).
j=1
The cardinality of End(G) for G = ES2 (p, n) is computed in Section 5, Theorem 5.3.
n
X
hhv, wii = (vi wn+i − vn+i wi ).
i=1
http://dx.doi.org/10.22108/IJGT.2021.129815.1708
Int. J. Group Theory, 11 no. 4 (2022) 201-220 C. P. Anil Kumar and S. S. Pradhan 217
Let ei = e2n 2n 2n
i , fi = en+i ∈ Zp , 1 ≤ i ≤ n be the standard basis such that hhe i , fj ii = δij , hhei , ej ii = 0 =
G
hhfi , fj ii, 1 ≤ i, j ≤ n. Let V1 = he2 , . . . , en , f1 , f2 , . . . , fn i. Let Ei = Im End(G) −→ End( Z(G) )
where G = ESi (p, n), i = 1, 2. Then the following holds.
F
• If G = ES1 (p, n) then E1 = Im(Φ1 ) X where the algebraic set X = {N ∈ M2n (Zp ) |
N t ∆N = 0} and Φ1 is as defined in Section 2.1. So | End(G)| = p2n |E1 | using Equations 1.2,1.3
in Theorem Ω.
F
• If G = ES2 (p, n) then E2 = Im(Φ2 ) Y where the algebraic set Y = {N ∈ M2n (Zp ) |
N t ∆N = 0, Im(N ) ⊆ V1 } and Φ2 is as defined in Section 2.1. So | End(G)| = p2n |E2 | using
Equations 1.5,1.6 in Theorem Σ.
n
It is well known that the p-binomial coefficient k p is a polynomial in p with non-negative integer
coefficients for any 0 ≤ k ≤ n and n 6= 0. We state a theorem about enumeration.
Proof. If N ∈ M2n (Zp ) and N t ∆N = 0, that is, Im(N ) is an isotropic subspace of Z2n
p then
dim(Im(N )) ≤ n. So (1) and (2) immediately follow.
We prove 3(a). It is clear that α0 (p, n) = 1. For 1 ≤ k ≤ n, let Tk = {(v1 , v2 , . . . , vk ) ∈ (Z2n k
p ) |
(v1 , v2 , . . . , vk ) is an ordered k-tuple of linearly independent vectors whose span is isotropic}. Then
http://dx.doi.org/10.22108/IJGT.2021.129815.1708
218 Int. J. Group Theory, 11 no. 4 (2022) 201-220 C. P. Anil Kumar and S. S. Pradhan
we have
|Tk | = (p2n − 1)(p2n−1 − p) . . . (p2n−(k−1) − pk−1 ).
Hence we have
k−1
(p2n − 1)(p2n−1 − p) . . . (p2n−(k−1) − pk−1 ) n Y
αk (p, n) = = (pn−i + 1).
(pk − 1)(pk − p) . . . (pk − pk−1 ) k p
i=0
2n−1
We prove 3(b). It is clear that β0 (p, n) = 1, β1 (p, n) = 1 p
. For 2 ≤ k ≤ n, let Sk =
{(v1 , v2 , . . . , vk ) ∈ (Z2n
p )
k | (v1 , v2 , . . . , vk ) is an ordered k-tuple of linearly independent vectors whose
span is isotropic and is contained in V1 }.
Let L ⊂ (Z2n
p , hh∗, ∗ii) be a subspace. We make the following observations.
So
(p2n−2 − 1)(p2n−2 − 1)
β2 (p, n) =
(p2 − 1)(p2 − p)
n−1 2 n−2 n−1 n−1
= (p + 1) p (p + 1) + .
2 p 1 p
Extending the same argument for 3 ≤ k ≤ n we get
We also have
(p2n−1 − p)(p2n−2 − p2 ) . . . (p2n−(k−1) − pk−1 )(p2n−k − 1)
βk (p, n) =
(pk − 1)(pk − p) . . . (pk − pk−1 )
k−1
k n−k n−1 n−1 Y
= p (p + 1) + (pn−i + 1).
k p k − 1 p i=1
We prove (4). It is clear that γ0 (p, n) = 1. To compute the number of surjective maps we consider
all maps from Z2n k
p −→ Zp and subtract the number of maps of rank less than k. Hence we get for
1 ≤ k ≤ n,
k−1
2nk
X k
γk (p, n) = p − γi (p, n).
i p
i=0
This completes the proof of the theorem.
http://dx.doi.org/10.22108/IJGT.2021.129815.1708
Int. J. Group Theory, 11 no. 4 (2022) 201-220 C. P. Anil Kumar and S. S. Pradhan 219
Proof. First we observe that for G = ES1 (p, n), | End(G)| = | Aut(G)| + p2n |X| and for G = ES2 (p, n),
| End(G)| = | Aut(G)| + p2n |Y | where X, Y are as defined in Theorem 5.2. Now using Theorem 5.2,
Corollary 3.1(3), we conclude (1) and then again using Theorem 5.2 and Proposition 4.1(6), we
conclude (2). This completes the proof of the theorem.
Example 5.4. For n = 1 and G = ES1 (p, 1) we obtain | Aut(G)| = p3 (p − 1)(p2 − 1) and | End(G)| =
p3 (p − 1)(p2 − 1) + p2 (1 + 11 p (p + 1)(p2 − 1)) = p6 .
6. An Open Question
This article leads to an open question which we pose in this section. In general for a finite group, its
center and commutator subgroup are characteristic subgroups. However it is not true that an endo-
morphism maps the center into itself, but an endomorphism maps commutator subgroup into itself.
Any automorphism or any endomorphism gives rise to a pair of automorphisms and endomorphisms
of the commutator subgroup and the abelianization of whole group respectively. The automorphism
group and the endomorphism algebra for finite abelian groups are known. We pose the following open
question.
Question 6.1. Let p be a prime. Let G be a p-group such that G0 = [G, G] is a non-trivial abelian
group, that is, G is a non-abelian metabelian p-group. Then:
• Determine the automorphism orbits in G.
• Determine the endomorphism semigroup image of any element in G.
• Determine for which type of such groups G the endomorphism semigroup induces a partial
order on the automorphism orbits.
In addition for the group G in Question 6.1, if the center coincides with the commutator subgroup
then any endomorphism maps the center into itself. Moreover for such a group, if Z(G) is elementary
G G
abelian, then we have a non-degenerate skew symmetric bilinear map Z(G) × Z(G) −→ Z(G). An
example of such a group is given below.
Example 6.2. Let p be a prime, r be a positive integer and q = pr . Let Fq be the finite field with q
elements. An example of a non-abelian metabelian p-group G which satisfies [G, G] = G0 = Z(G) and
http://dx.doi.org/10.22108/IJGT.2021.129815.1708
220 Int. J. Group Theory, 11 no. 4 (2022) 201-220 C. P. Anil Kumar and S. S. Pradhan
Z(G) is elementary abelian is the Heisenberg group H n (Fq ) = Fnq ⊕ Fnq ⊕ Fq over Fq of order q 2n+1 .
The group structure is defined in a similar manner as in ES1 (p, n). The answer to Question 6.1 can
be explored in the case of H n (Fq ).
Acknowledgments
The work is done while both the authors are post doctoral fellows at Harish-Chandra Research In-
stitute, Prayagraj-INDIA. Both the authors thank Prof. Amritanshu Prasad and Prof. Sunil Kumar
Prajapati for mentioning the problem of finding automorphism orbits in extra-special p-groups. The
authors also thank Prof. Manoj Kumar Yadav for suggesting a lot of improvements in the article.
References
[1] D. J. Benson and J. F. Carlson, The cohomology of extraspecial groups, Bull. London Math. Soc., 24 (1992) 209–235.
[2] D. J. Benson and J. F. Carlson, Corrigendum: ‘the Cohomology of Extraspecial groups’, Bull. London Math. Soc.,
25 (1993) 498–498.
[3] E. A. Bertram, Some applications of graph theory to finite groups, Discrete Math., 44 (1983) 31–43.
[4] A. Y. M. Chin, On non-commuting sets in an extraspecial p-group, J. Group Theory, 8 (2005) 189–194.
[5] L. Dornhoff, Group representation theory, Part A: Ordinary representation theory, Pure and Applied Mathematics,
7, Marcel Dekker, Inc., New York, 1971 pp. 1–254.
[6] K. Dutta and A. Prasad, Degenerations and orbits in finite abelian groups, J. Combin. Theory Ser. A, 118 (2011)
1685–1694.
[7] D. E. Gorenstein, Finite Groups, AMS Chelsea Publishing, 301 (1968).
[8] R. L. Griess Jr., Automorphisms of Extraspecial Groups and Nonvanishing of Degree 2 Cohomology, Pacific J.
Math., 48 (1973) 403–422.
[9] H. Liu and Y. Wang, The automorphism group of a generalized extraspecial p-group, Sci. China Math., 53 (2010)
315–334.
[10] H. Liu and Y. Wang, On non-commuting sets in a generalized extraspecial p-group, Acta Math. Sinica, 55 (2012)
975–980.
[11] H. Liu and Y. Wang, On Non-commuting Sets in Certain Finite p-Groups, Algebra Colloq., 22 (2015) 555–560.
[12] H. Opolka, Projective Representations of Extra-Special p-Groups, Glasgow Math. J., 19 (1978) 149–152.
[13] D. J. S. Robinson, A course in the theory of groups, Graduate Texts in Mathematics, 80, Springer-Verlag, New
York-Berlin, 1982.
[14] D. L. Winter, The automorphism group of an extraspecial p-group, Rocky Mountain J. Math., 2 159–168.
http://dx.doi.org/10.22108/IJGT.2021.129815.1708