Subscribe for $29.99 $6 for 12 weeks.

Newsletter Sign In Subscribe

The Latest News Books & Culture Fiction & Poetry Humor & Cartoons Magazine Puzzles & Games Video Podcasts Goings On Shop

You are reading your last free article. $29.99 $6 for 12 weeks. Cancel or pause anytime. Subscribe now

Photograph by Mark Peterson / Redux for The New Yorker

Daily Comment

What Kind of Trouble Is Eric Adams

In?
New York City’s mayor has downplayed the federal investigation into his campaign fund-raising, but, by
dodging questions and obfuscating, he’s invited even more public scrutiny.
By Eric Lach
November 13, 2023

Because public attention is a finite resource, political crises have a way

of obscuring and supplanting one another. On the morning of

November 2nd, New York City’s mayor, Eric Adams flew to ,

Washington, D.C., for a full day of meetings about New York’s migrant
crisis “We are headed to D.C. to meet with our congressional delegation
.

and the White House to address this real issue,” Adams said in a video
posted on his X account at 7:41 A.M. “We’ll keep you updated as the day
goes on.”

For more than a year, without much success, Adams had been calling on
the federal government to defray the astronomical costs of housing tens
of thousands of immigrants in city-run shelters. He had gone as far as
suggesting that without federal help the migrant crisis would “destroy”
New York. Though the dispute had damaged his public relationship with
President Joe Biden the Mayor was getting an audience at the White
,

House. But Adams never made his meetings. That same morning, news
broke of an F.B.I. raid at the home of one of his campaign fund-raising
officials, Brianna Suggs. Already on the ground in D.C., Adams caught
the first plane home, in order to “deal with a matter,” as a City Hall
spokesperson put it.

Suggs, who is twenty-five, lives with her father and grandmother in a

row house in Crown Heights, Brooklyn. She graduated from Brooklyn
College in 2020, and she served on Adams’s 2021 mayoral campaign as a
fund-raiser and “logistics director,” according to her LinkedIn page. At
Suggs’s house, federal agents reportedly confiscated two laptops, three
iPhones, and a manila folder labelled “Eric Adams.” The Times reported
that the U.S. Attorney’s office in Manhattan is trying to determine
whether representatives of the Turkish government illegally funnelled
money into Adams’s campaign.

Back in New York, Adams avoided reporters, and put off public
appearances. News outlets began combing through his campaign-finance
records, paying close attention to the fourteen thousand dollars in
donations made by employees of a Brooklyn construction company
reportedly owned by Turkish New Yorkers, and to the ten thousand
dollars in donations made by employees of a small private university with
ties to Turkish institutions. Adams is not the world’s most disciplined
public speaker, and City Hall reporters have learned to take him
seriously, if not always literally. (“Adams doesn’t just polish anecdotes,”
my colleague Ian Parker wrote in a profile of Adams earlier this year. “He
is unusually ready to repeat things that are confirmably untrue.”) Yet

some of his former statements, particularly those regarding Turkey, took

on a newfound significance after the raid. “When I get elected, you’re
going to have your first Turkish Mayor,” Adams once told a Turkish
American business news Web site. “The Turkish community has really
supported and held several fundraisers for me. I’m extremely appreciative
of the substantial dollar amount they have.”

Six days after the raid, Adams convened a press conference to address
what was going on. He told the assembled reporters that he wanted to be
“completely transparent,” and then refused to detail what exactly he had
done or whom he had spoken to after returning from Washington. “I did
not want to be sitting inside a meeting somewhere when there was
something playing out here in the city,” he said. When asked if he was
worried that he himself might face criminal charges, he laughed. “I
would be shocked,” he said. “WilmerHale . . that’s the law firm that I’ve .

retained . . they are professionals in this area.” He insisted that, as a

.

former police captain, he knew right from wrong. “I cannot tell you how
much I start the day with telling my team we’ve got to follow the law,”
he said. “Almost to the point that I’m annoying.” Here was a new crisis
for the city to grapple with: Could the Mayor be believed?

For years, Adams’s critics have been predicting that a corruption

scandal would do him in. Many aides, allies, friends, and associates
of his have been investigated, and some indicted, for a range of frauds

and bad acts in office. He’s generally stuck by them, valuing loyalty over
any other political consideration, even at the risk of appearing personally
compromised. In July, the Manhattan District Attorney brought
campaign-finance charges against several donors to Adams’s 2021
mayoral campaign, two of which have pleaded guilty. Adams waved it off,
saying he was totally uninvolved. “I follow one rule: follow the rules,” he
said. In September, his former Department of Buildings commissioner,
Eric Ulrich, was indicted on allegations of favor trading and bribery.
According to the Daily News Ulrich, who has pleaded not guilty, told
,

investigators that Adams had warned him to “watch your back and
watch your phones.” Adams denied saying this. He has long suggested
that he faces more scrutiny than other politicians because he is Black.
“My face will show up on front pages of, ‘Is there unethical and immoral
behavior?,’ ” he said last week, speaking to a Brooklyn church
congregation three days after the F.B.I. raid. “We’re going to be all
right.”

It’s true that Adams, despite having come under law-enforcement

scrutiny before, has always survived, politically and legally. But the
scrutiny this time is of the highest level: on Friday, the Times reported
that, two days before Adams’s press conference, he was stopped on the
street by F.B.I. agents, who confiscated two of his phones and his iPad. “I
have nothing to hide,” Adams said in a statement, though he had chosen
not to disclose this incident at the press conference—even after he was
asked whether he had been personally contacted by law enforcement. In
a statement also released on Friday, Adams’s attorney said, “The mayor

has not been accused of any wrongdoing.”

When he took office, Adams embraced the title of “the night-life mayor.”
His club-going, flashy clothes, and self-described “swagger” have invited
comparisons to Jimmy Walker, the flamboyant Tammany man who held
sway as the city’s “night mayor” in the Roaring Twenties. Walker
resigned, in 1932, in a corruption scandal, after accepting bribes from
businessmen who wanted municipal contracts. According to the Times ,

the U.S. Attorney’s office is examining whether Adams pressured New

York Fire Department officials to fast-track approvals for a new Turkish
consulate building in Manhattan, whose grand opening was presided
over by President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan The events in question took .

place in 2021, after Adams had won the Democratic Party’s mayoral
primary, when he was Brooklyn borough president and the de-facto
mayor-elect. And yet all of this commotion, over just tens of thousands
of dollars in donations and a “temporary certificate” of occupancy
negotiated by someone who had not yet taken office?

Adams does himself no favors with his erratic decision-making and

inability to avoid drip, drip news stories. During the campaign, he never
quite managed to quash suspicions that he actually lived in New Jersey.
In the current case, one mystery is why Adams decided to appoint a
recent college graduate to a top fund-raising position. Suggs has been
described in news reports as “mild-mannered,” “professional,” and the
“goddaughter” of Ingrid Lewis-Martin, Adams’s close aide and political
enforcer. (“I’m not Michelle Obama,” Lewis-Martin told an interviewer
last year. “When they go low? We drill for oil.”) Adams has explained
Suggs’s hire by saying that he and Lewis-Martin were looking to create
more opportunities for young Black and brown New Yorkers in politics.
“We saw an opportunity for her, to open a pathway for her,” he said.
“And we brought her on board, and I was pleasantly surprised.” When I
went by Suggs’s house recently, her grandmother, a former Metropolitan
Transportation Authority worker, answered the door. Her eyes were red,
like she’d been crying, and she told me that she had nothing to say to
me.

The Mayor’s political instinct when under attack is to return fire. In a

Trumpian flourish, one source suggested to the Post that the federal
investigation of the Mayor reeks of political retribution by the President:
“the manner in which he had his phones taken away in public seems
targeted against the mayor in response to his stance on the immigration
crisis.” This kind of argument is ludicrous, and dangerous.

Two former federal prosecutors I spoke with acknowledged that taking a

sitting mayor’s devices was an extremely aggressive step for the U.S.
Attorney’s office, adding that this would only be done at the end stage of
an investigation, close to the time when charging decisions would be
made. “I think they’re sitting on the ‘we’re going to charge’ button,” one
said. Until it’s clear what kind of trouble the Mayor is in, the city’s other
crises— the housing shortage and the ever-increasing number of
,

migrants —are going nowhere. On Sunday, the city opened up an

enormous tent facility to house migrants on the grounds of an old
airfield in southern Brooklyn. Few know how many shoes have yet to
drop here. Adams, for his part, wears Ferragamos. ♦

New Yorker Favorites

First she scandalized Washington. Then she became a princess .

The unravelling of an expert on serial killers .

What exactly happened between Neanderthals and humans ?

When you eat a dried fig, you’re probably chewing wasp mummies, too .

The meanings of the Muslim head scarf .

The slippery scams of the olive-oil industry .

Critics on the classics: our 1991 review of “Thelma & Louise.”

Sign up for our daily newsletter to receive the best stories from The New
Yorker .

Eric Lach , a staff writer, has contributed to The New Yorker

since 2008. He writes a regular column about New York City
politics, people, and more. He previously served as The New
Yorker’s deputy news editor.

More: Eric Adams Investigations New York City Mayor

Federal Bureau of Investigation (F.B.I.) Turkey

Read More

The Political Scene Daily Comment Daily Comment Comment

Why a State Department The Uprooting of Life in Gaza The Lessons of Ohio’s Trump Gets Fined in Court
Official Lost Hope in Israel and the West Bank Abortion-Rights Victory but Wins in the House
For more than a decade, Josh Paul Israel’s Prime Minister has vowed to Tuesday’s election results in that state The former President is delusional on
helped send American weapons destroy Hamas and turn its territory and elsewhere offer fresh evidence of many subjects, but Mike Johnson’s
overseas. After the Hamas attack, he into a “deserted island,” but Palestinians how the issue is likely to help victory in the Speakership race suggests
resigned in protest of arming the Israeli are determined not to be displaced. Democrats in 2024. that he is clear-eyed about his hold on
response. By Raja Shehadeh By Peter Slevin congressional Republicans.
By Benjamin Wallace-Wells By Amy Davidson Sorkin

Sections More
News Crossword Customer Care Digital Access
Books & Culture Video Shop The New Yorker Newsletters
Fiction & Poetry Podcasts Buy Covers and Cartoons Jigsaw Puzzle
Humor & Cartoons Archive Condé Nast Store RSS
Magazine Goings On

About Contact Media Kit Accessibility Help

Careers F.A.Q. Press

© 2023 Condé Nast. All rights reserved. Use of this site constitutes acceptance of our User Agreement and Privacy Policy and Cookie Statement and Your California Privacy Rights.
The New Yorker may earn a portion of sales from products that are purchased through our site as part of our Affiliate Partnerships with retailers. The material on this site may not be
reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of Condé Nast. Ad Choices