You are on page 1of 4

2012 International Conference in Green and Ubiquitous Technology

Estimation of Carbon Footprints from Diesel Generator Emissions

Abdul Qayoom Jakhrani Al-Khalid Othman


Faculty of Engineering, Universiti Malaysia Sarawak, Faculty of Engineering, Universiti Malaysia Sarawak,
Kota Samarahan, Sarawak, Malaysia Kota Samarahan, Sarawak, Malaysia
e-mail: aqunimas@hotmail.com e-mail: okhalid@feng.unimas.my

Andrew Ragai Henry Rigit Saleem Raza Samo


Faculty of Engineering, Universiti Malaysia Sarawak, Faculty of Engineering, Quaid-e-Awam University of
Kota Samarahan, Sarawak, Malaysia Engineering, Science and Technology, Nawabshah,
e-mail: arigit@feng.unimas.my Sindh, Pakistan
e-mail: sfaizsamo@yahoo.com

Shakeel Ahmed Kamboh


Faculty of Computer Science and Information Technology, Universiti Malaysia Sarawak,
Kota Samarahan, Sarawak, Malaysia
e-mail: shakeel.maths@yahoo.com

Abstract—The aim of this paper is to estimate the amount of emitted by any system to support human activities directly
carbon footprints emitted from diesel generators in terms of and indirectly is termed as carbon footprint [4]. It is difficult
carbon dioxide. A constant load demand of 1.05 kW per hour to get all required data for every particular greenhouse gas
(6.3 kW/day) with six hours of operation of a diesel generator emissions due to technical and monitoring problems.
per day was selected for this analysis. The fuel consumption
rate and carbon footprints in terms of carbon dioxide (CO2)
Therefore, for simplicity, it is often expressed in terms of the
were determined. It was discovered that emission of carbon amount of carbon dioxide (CO2) emitted [5]. The best way is
footprints increased by five folds as emission factor was to calculate the carbon dioxide emissions is based on the
increased from 1kg to 5 kgCO2/liter. Similarly, the increment of amount of fuel consumption by diesel generator [6]. Carbon
a single kW rated power diesel generator at a constant emission content of fuels slightly varies, but typically the average
factor increases 1.1 to 1.2 times carbon footprint emissions. It is carbon content values to estimate CO2 emissions could be
revealed that the efficiency of diesel generator is inversely
adapted [7]. The consumption of one liter diesel emits
proportional to its rated power, fuel consumption rate and CO2
emissions. Therefore, the rated power of selected diesel around 2.7kg of CO2 [8]. However, the number of kg of
generator should be close to the required load demand. CO2 produced per liter of fuel consumed by the diesel
generator depends upon the characteristics of the diesel
Keywords-carbon footprints; carbon dioxide emissions; diesel generator and of the characteristics of the fuel, and it is
generator; fuel consumption rate usually falls in the range of 2.4–2.8 kg/l [6]. Carbon foot
prints can also be expressed in kg carbon rather than kg
I. INTRODUCTION carbon dioxide [9]. It can be converted from kg carbon to kg
carbon dioxide by multiplying with a factor 0.27 (i.e. 1000
The diesel generators are the most widely used as small kg CO2 equals 270 kg carbon). The emission factor
electrical power generating units in off-grid locations in the considered for a diesel generator was 1.27 kg CO2/kWh [6],
world due to their low capital costs [1]. Sarawak Electricity 3.15 kgCO2/l [10] and 3.50 kgCO2/l [11].
Supply Corporation (SESCO) producing 68 MW power
In remote areas, the diesel generators can be replaced by
from small diesel generating units for supply of electricity in
SAPV power producing units. The SAPV units are
rural communities living in remote locations from national
environmental friendly as did not produce any greenhouse
grid. However, diesel engines release many hazardous air
gases which cause global warming [12-13]. The users can
contaminants and greenhouse gases (GHG) including
adapt the system capacity up to the desired level due to their
particulate matter (diesel soot and aerosols), carbon
modularity and expandability [14-17]. Additionally, the
monoxide, carbon dioxide and oxides of nitrogen. Particulate
manufacturing cost of PV cell per watt has been dropped and
matters are largely elemental and organic carbon soot, coated
its daylight-to-power conversion efficiency has also been
by gaseous organic substances such as formaldehyde and
increased [18-19]. It is estimated that by 2050, photovoltaic
polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) which are highly
systems will provide around 11% of global electricity
toxic [2]. In 2001, the mortality due to diesel soot exposure
production and avoid 2.3 gigatones of CO2 emissions per
was at least 14400 people out of 82 million people living in
year [20]. PV production has been increasing by an average
Germany [3]. The total amount of greenhouse gases (GHGs)
978-1-4577-2171-7/12/$26.00 ©2011 IEEE


of more than 20% each year since 2002, making it world’s B. Fuel Consumption Model of Diesel Generators
fastest growing power producing system [21]. The fuel consumption of diesel generators varies
depending on the quality of engine. However, a linear model
A. Diesel Generators for diesel generator fuel consumption rate (F) is presented
A diesel generator is a combination of a diesel engine [22, 25] . It is expressed as:
with an electrical generator to generate electrical energy.
These generating sets are mostly used in locations without F 0.246 u Pout  0.08415 u Pr (2)
connection to the national power grid. Typically, two types
of diesel generators are in market either two poles with 3000
rpm or four poles with 1500 rpm characteristics. The speeds where F is the fuel consumption rate (liters/hour), Pout is
of 50 Hz synchronous diesel generators with 3000 or 1500
rpm can be matched by the following expression:
the actual operating output power (kW) and Pr is rated
power of diesel generator (kW).
120 u f nuP (1) II. METHODOLOGY

where n is the speed (rpm), f is the frequency, and P is A constant load demand of 1.05 kW per hour (6.3kW/day)
the number of poles of diesel generator. The 3000 rpm with six hours of operation of a diesel generator per day was
machines are simpler in structure with 2-poles and thus selected for this analysis. The fuel consumption rate and
results lower acquisition cost. These are most suitable for carbon footprints in terms of carbon dioxide (CO2) are
light duty applications and appropriate for operation of less determined. The rated power capacity of diesel generators
than 400 hours per year. The 1500-rpm units are 4-pole was changed from 2kW to 5kW for comparative results as
machines. These are more common for heavy duty shown in Fig. 1. The reported ranges of emission factor from
applications and are rather more expensive. 4-poles diesel diesel generators were found in literature from 2.4 to 3.5
generators are recommended when more than 400 hours of kgCO2/liter of diesel fuel consumption. Therefore, the
operation per year is anticipated. In general, the higher the emission factor of 3.0kgCO2/liter is considered for this
rpm, the more wear and tear on the bearings, consequently study. However, the influence of various emission factors
more recurrent maintenance requirements. The life time and rated power capacities of diesel generator on emission of
period of the diesel generator varies from 5000 to 50,000 carbon footprints are also determined. The estimated values
hours with an average of 20,000 hours depending on the of carbon footprint emissions in kgCO2/day and kgCO2/kWh
quality of the engine, its proper installation and execution of are shown in Figs. 2 and 3 respectively.
regular operation and maintenance [1].
III. RESULTS AND DISCUSSIONS
The diesel generators are characterized by their
It is revealed from the analysis that the efficiency of diesel
efficiency and rate of specific fuel consumption. The
generator is decreasing from 52% to 21% with increasing of
efficiency of diesel generator depends upon the ratio its rated
its rated power capacity from 2kW to 5kW with a load
power to output power. The overall efficiency of diesel
demand of 1.05kW/hour. The fuel consumption rate was
generator depends upon its thermal, mechanical and
found to be 2.56 liters/day (0.42 liters/kWh) with a 2kW
generator efficiency. The thermal efficiency depends upon
rated power and 4.07 liters/day (0.65 liters/kWh) with a 5kW
the quality of diesel oil. The typical mechanical efficiency of
rated power diesel generator as shown in Table 1 and Fig. 1.
diesel engine is around 80% to 85% and generator efficiency
Similarly, the carbon footprint in terms of kgCO2 emissions
is around 95% to 98%. The specific fuel consumption
were found to be 7.67 kg/day (1.22 kg/kWh) with a 2kW
(l/kWh) of a diesel generator is defined as the consumption
rated power and 12.21 kg/day (1.94kg/kWh) with a 5kW
of fuel required to produce 1kWh of energy at the rate of 1
rated power diesel generator. It is estimated that, the use of a
liter/h for supplying a given load during 1 hour time. When
2kW rated power diesel generator (DG) will consume 934.4
the diesel generator operates nearly 20% of its rated power,
liters of diesel oil and emit 2800.0 kgCO2 per year.
its specific fuel consumption will be too high (about 0.64
Similarly, 5kW rated power diesel generator will utilize
l/kWh) corresponding to a low efficiency of the generator
1485.5 liters of diesel oil and emit 4456.6 kgCO2 per year
[22]. The minimum specific fuel consumption of the diesel
with a load demand of 1.05 kW per hour or 6.3kW/day. The
generator will be around 0.324 l/kWh if the diesel generator
CO2 emissions from diesel generators could be avoided by
is operating between 70 and 89% of its rated power [23]. At
using standalone photovoltaic (SAPV) systems for the
this operating point it will consume less fuel. A typical diesel
supply of electricity to the people. The use of SAPV system
generator set consumes between 0.32 and 0.53 l/kWh at its
will help to avoid 70 tones of CO2 and 111 tones of CO2
rated power [24].
with the use of two and five kW rated power diesel generator
respectively in the 25 years life time of the system.


The input value of emission factor is changed from 1 to TABLE III. CARBON FOOTPRINTS (KGCO2/KWH) AT VARIOUS RATED POWER
OF DIESEL GENERATOR AND EMISSION FACTORS
5kgCO2/liter and the rated power of DG is varied from 2 to
5kW as shown in Tables 2 and 3 and Figs. 2 and 3
respectively. It is revealed that emission of carbon footprints
increased by five folds as emission factor is increased from 1
to 5kgCO2/liter. Similarly, the increase of rated power of DG
at the increment of a single kW at a constant emission factor
increases the emission of carbon footprints from 1.1 to 1.2
times.

It is found that the efficiency of diesel generator is


inversely proportional to the rated power, fuel consumption
rate and CO2 emissions of the diesel generator. Therefore,
the rated power of selected diesel generator should be close
to the load demand. However, the effect of power factor
must be taken into account. For example, if a load demand is
1.5kW/h, and the diesel generator has a power factor of 0.85
then the rated power of diesel generator should be at least
1.8kW otherwise it will be undersized.

Furthermore, if the difference between peak power


demand and average energy demand is high, then the
selection of diesel generator should be based on peak power
demand to sustain load. However, in that situation, the Figure 1. Fuel consumption rate and carbon footprints versus rated power
efficiency of diesel generator will drop and it will consume of diesel generator
large amount of fuel and ultimately emit more greenhouse
gases. Additionally, the current selling price of diesel oil in 22 .5
DG Pr = 2 k W
Malaysia is approximately RM 1.70 (US$0.49) per liter. )
y
20 DG Pr = 3 k W
a 17 .5
However, the price of diesel is found to be irrationally high d
/
2
DG Pr = 4 k W
O 15 DG Pr = 5 k W
in rural areas. It is reported that the diesel fuel is priced at C
g
(k 12 .5
about RM 7.00 (US$ 2.03) per liter in very remote places in t
in
r 10
the Ulu Baram district, some 200 km inland from Miri, tp
o
o
f 7.5
Sarawak [26]. n
o
b
r
a 5
C
TABLE I. ESTIMATION OF FUEL CONSUMPTION AND CARBON FOOTPRINTS 2.5
FROM DIESEL GENERATORS 0
1 2 3 4 5
Em issio n fa cto r (k g C O 2 /Liter)

Figure 2. Carbon footprints (kgCO2/day) at various emission factors


and rated power of diesel generator

3.5
DG Pr = 2 kW
) 3 DG Pr = 3 kW
h
W DG Pr = 4 kW
/k2.5
2
O DG Pr = 5 kW
C
g 2
TABLE II. CARBON FOOTPRINTS (KG CO2/DAY) AT VARIOUS RATED POWER (k
t
ni
OF DIESEL GENERATOR AND EMISSION FACTORS r
tp1.5
o
of
n 1
o
rb
a
C0.5

0
1 2 3 4 5
Em ission fa ctor (kg CO2 /liter)

Figure 3. Carbon footprints (kgCO2/kWh) at various emission factors and


rated power of diesel generator


IV. CONCLUSIONS [10] B. Fleck and M. Huot, "Comparative life-cycle assessment of a
small wind turbine for residential off-grid use," Renewable
energy, vol. 34, pp. 2688-2696, 2009.
It is revealed from the analysis that a 2kW and 5kW rated [11] R. Dufo-López, et al., "Multi-objective optimization minimizing
cost and life cycle emissions of stand-alone PV-wind-diesel
power diesel generator will consume 934.4 and 1485.5 liters
systems with batteries storage," Applied Energy, 2011.
of diesel oil and emit 2800.0 and 4456.6 kgCO2 per year [12] A.Q. Jakhrani, et al., "Model for Estimation of Global Solar
respectively with a load demand of 1.05kW/hour Radiation in Sarawak, Malaysia," World Applied Sciences
(6.3kW/day). Power producing by SAPV system facilitates Journal vol. (Special Issue of Food & Environment), pp. 83-90,
2011.
to avoid 70 tones of CO2 and 111 tones of CO2 to the [13] A. Q. Jakhrani, et al., "Evaluation of Incident Solar Radiation on
atmosphere emitted by a 2kW and 5kW rated power diesel Inclined Plane by Empirical Models at Kuching, Sarawak,
generator. It is discovered that emission of carbon footprints Malaysia," presented at the IEEE ICSET 2010, Kandy, Sri
increased by five folds as emission factor is increased from Lanka, 2010.
[14] A.Q. Jakhrani, et al., "Investigation of Solar Photovoltaic
1kg to 5kg CO2/liter. Similarly, the increment of a single kW
Module Power Output by various Models," NED University
rated power diesel generator at a constant emission factor Journal of Research, pp. 25-34, 2012.
increases 1.1 to 1.2 times carbon footprint emissions. [15] S. Shaahid and M. Elhadidy, "Economic analysis of hybrid
photovoltaic-diesel-battery power systems for residential loads
in hot regions--A step to clean future," Renewable and
It is found that the efficiency of diesel generator is Sustainable Energy Reviews, vol. 12, pp. 488-503, 2008.
inversely proportional to the rated power, fuel consumption [16] A.Q. Jakhrani, et al., "Determination and comparison of different
rate and CO2 emissions of the diesel generator. Therefore, photovoltaic module temperature models for Kuching, Sarawak,"
the rated power of selected diesel generator should be close in IEEE CET 2011, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia, 2011, pp. 231-236.
[17] A.Q. Jakhrani, et al., "Comparison of Solar Photovoltaic Module
to the load demand. The estimated net energy cost from Temperature Models," World Applied Sciences Journal vol.
SAPV system is found to be US$2.5/kWh, which is 20 times (Special Issue of Food & Environment), pp. 1-8, 2011.
higher than average electricity tariff in Malaysia. However, [18] I. F. Bitterlin, "Modelling a reliable wind/PV/storage power
the diesel prices are rising and PV system prices are system for remote radio base station sites without utility power,"
Journal of power sources, vol. 162, pp. 906-912, 2006.
continuously declining since last two decades. Therefore, [19] A.Q. Jakhrani, et al., "Cost Estimation of a Standalone
SAPV systems could be preferred with the combination of Photovoltaic Power System in Remote Areas of Sarawak,
other power producing units or where the electrical Malaysia," NED University Journal of Research, pp. 15-24,
transmission lines are expensive to build for the supply of 2012.
[20] A. Luque and S. Hegedus, Handbook of photovoltaic science
electricity in remote areas. and engineering: Wiley, 2011.
[21] J. Russell, "Record Growth in Photovoltaic Capacity and
ACKNOWLEDGMENT Momentum Builds for Concentrating Solar Power," Vital Signs,
2010.
The authors wish to acknowledge the support provided for [22] O. Skarstein and K. Uhlen, "Design considerations with respect
this research by Universiti Malaysia Sarawak (UNIMAS) to long-term diesel saving in wind/diesel plants," Wind
and Quaid-e-Awam University of Engineering, Science and engineering, vol. 13, pp. 72-87, 1989.
[23] S. H. El-Hefnawi, "Photovoltaic diesel-generator hybrid power
Technology (QUEST) Nawabshah, Sindh, Pakistan. system sizing," Renewable energy, vol. 13, pp. 33-40, 1998.
[24] D. Yamegueu, et al., "Experimental study of electricity
REFERENCES generation by Solar PV/diesel hybrid systems without battery
storage for off-grid areas," Renewable energy, 2010.
[1] F. Brikké and M. Bredero, "Linking technology choice with [25] R. A. Messenger and J. Ventre, Eds., Photovoltaic system
operation and maintenance in the context of community water engineering. CRC Press, Boca Raton, FL, 2004, p.^pp. Pages.
supply and sanitation," World Health Organsiation and IRC [26] K. Lau, et al., "Performance analysis of hybrid
water and sanitation centre, 2003. photovoltaic/diesel energy system under Malaysian conditions,"
[2] C. G. Schneider and L. B. Hill, "Diesel and Health in America: Energy, vol. 35, pp. 3245-3255, 2010.
The Lingering Threat," Clean Air Task Force, Boston2005.
[3] B. Johnke, et al., "Klimarelevanz der Abfallwirtschaft,"
Umweltbundesamt, Berlin, 2005.
[4] L. A. Wright, et al., "‘Carbon footprinting’: towards a
universally accepted definition," Carbon, vol. 2, pp. 61-72, 2011.
[5] A. J. East, "What is a Carbon Footprint? An overview of
definitions and methodologies," 2008.
[6] E. Alsema, "Environmental life cycle assessment of solar home
systems," Department of Science Technology and Society,
Utrecht University, Utrecht, The Netherlands, p. 89, 2000.
[7] USEPA, "Average Carbon Dioxide Emissions Resulting from
Gasoline and Diesel Fuel," USEPA, February, 2005.
[8] R. J. North, "Assessment of real-world pollutant emissions from
a light-duty diesel vehicle," Doctor of Philosophy Dissertation,
Imperial College London, 2006.
[9] E. Friedrich, et al., "Carbon footprint analysis for increasing
water supply and sanitation in South Africa: a case study,"
Journal of Cleaner Production, vol. 17, pp. 1-12, 2009.



You might also like