Professional Documents
Culture Documents
MARK A. ALOISIO
The Maltese islands, located in the narrow channel that separates Sicily
from Tunisia, served as a base for corsairs and privateers well before
the arrival of the Order of St. John in the sixteenth century. In the
early thirteenth century, the Genoese count of Malta, Enrico Pescatore,
used the island to attack Pisan and Venetian interests in the central
and eastern Mediterranean, while an intervention in Malta by Frederick
IV of Sicily in 1372 was possibly provoked by piratical activities against
Genoese ships by the captain of the island.1 The archipelago, part of
the kingdom of Sicily since the Norman conquest in 1127, was drawn
into the Aragonese orbit from the late thirteenth century.2 Late medieval
Malta and Gozo were peripheral, but by no means isolated, outposts
of the crown of Aragon, largely cut off from the main trade routes that
traversed the Mediterranean, and exposed to attacks from the crown’s
enemies. The intention of this paper is to describe the political, social
and economic context that made the Maltese islands a fertile ground
for corsair activity in the central Mediterranean during the fifteenth cen-
tury. I will begin by describing the process whereby the crown’s policy
of delegating the defense of the archipelago to its galley-captains led to
the establishment of a military aristocracy on Malta who were also
financiers and organizers of corsairing ventures. Secondly, I will look at
the links that existed between corsairing and trade on the islands, and
show that here, as elsewhere in the Mediterranean, corsairing was often
an economic enterprise. I will then conclude with a brief discussion of
the impact of corsairing on Maltese society in the fifteenth century as
3
J. H. Pryor, Geography, technology, and war. Studies in the maritime history of the Mediterranean
649-1571 (Cambridge, 1988), 153-64. On the use of corsairs by the crown of Aragon,
M. del Treppo, I mercanti catalani e l’espansione della Corona d’Aragona nel secolo XV (Naples,
1972); M. D. López Pérez, La Corona de Aragón y el Magreb en el siglo XIV (1331-1410)
(Barcelona, 1995); J. L. Yarrison, ‘Force as an instrument of state policy: European mil-
itary incursions and trade in the Maghrib, 1000-1355’ (Ph.D. thesis, Princeton University,
1982).
4
I. Schiappoli, La marina degli aragonesi di Napoli (Naples, 1940), 50.
5
H. Bresc, ‘La course méditerranéenne au miroir sicilien (XIIe-XVe siècles)’ in
H. Bresc, Politique et société en Sicile, XII e-XV e siècles (Aldershot, 1990), 94-6.
CORSO 195
6
On the impact of these events on Malta see the articles by R. Valentini published
in Archivio Storico di Malta (henceforth ASM ), especially ‘Gli ultimi Re Aragonesi ed i
primi Castigliani in Malta’, ASM, vii, 4 (1936) and supporting documents, ASM, viii, 1
(1936-7). More generally, R. Brunschvig, La Berbérie Orientale sous les Hafsides, des origines
à la fin du XV e siècle, 2 vols. Paris, 1940; C. Trasselli, ‘Sicilia, Levante e Tunisia nei sec-
oli XIV e XV’ in C. Trasselli, Mediterraneo e Sicilia all’inizio dell’epoca moderna (Ricerche
Quattrocentesche). Cosenza, 1977.
7
H. Bresc, ‘The ‘secrezia’ and the royal patrimony in Malta: 1240-1450’ in Luttrell,
Medieval Malta, 146.
8
Document published in R. Valentini, ‘L’espansionismo aragonese nel Mediterraneo
come causa della decadenza di Malta’, ASM, xii, 2-3 (1941), 100.
9
C. Dalli, ‘Capitoli: the voice of an elite’, Proceedings of History Week 1992, ed.
S. Fiorini (Malta, 1994).
10
G. Wettinger, ‘The castrum maris and its suburb of Birgu during the middle ages’
in Birgu: a Maltese maritime city, 2 vols., eds. L. Bugeja, M. Buhagiar, S. Fiorini (Malta,
1993), 43.
196 .
Arguably the most powerful of these lineages were the de Nava, who
came to Malta from Sicily, where they had already established a strong
presence in Syracuse.11 Suero and Gonsalvo de Nava of Syracuse were
prominent corsairs and galley captains who preyed on Genoese ships
near Tunis and the small island of Djerba and probably made use of
Malta from time to time.12 In 1447 Suero was being sheltered by the
castellan of Malta to the consternation of the jurats of the universitas
who feared that the island might be the target of reprisals by his ene-
mies.13 Another member of the family, Gutierre de Nava was castellan
of Malta from 1421 to 1437 and served with the royal fleet on numer-
ous occasions.14 In 1429 he commanded a squadron of galleys when
Alfonso V attacked Djerba in response to the Hafsid attack on Malta
a few months earlier.15 He was later captured at the battle of Ponza
(1435) fighting for Aragon against the Genoese and spent many years
in a Genoese jail for his depredations against their ships.16 Two nephews
of Gutierre, Pedro del Bosch, who was castellan of Malta from 1435
to 1446 and Gonsalvo de Nava, both galley-captains, were likewise
responsible for various attacks against Muslim and non-Muslim ships in
Maghribi waters.17
While the Aragonese crown made extensive use of corsairs in time
of war, it sometimes struggled to restrict their activities after hostilities
ceased or were suspended. The Genoese and the Venetians lodged
numerous protests to Alfonso V in which they claimed that their mer-
chant ships were being attacked even during periods of peace.18 Corsairs
also threatened to undermine the king’s protracted negotiations with the
Hafsids. In 1446 negotiations for a truce between Abu 'Omar 'Othman
of Tunis and Alfonso V were stalled when subjects of the sultan were
11
M. del Treppo, I mercanti catalani e l’espansione della Corona d’Aragona nel secolo XV
(Naples, 1972), 498.
12
Ibid.
13
G. Wettinger, Acta iuratorum et consilii civitatis et insulae maltae. (Associazione di Studi
Malta-Sicilia. Centro di Studi Filologici e Linguistici siciliani) (Palermo, 1993).
14
Del Treppo, 498; (or 1429-35 according to Wettinger, ‘Castrum maris’, 42).
15
A. Ryder, Alfonso the Magnanimous, King of Aragon, Naples and Sicily, 1396-1458 (Oxford,
1990), 187.
16
Ibid., 205.
17
Wettinger, ‘Castrum maris’, 42; R. Valentini, ‘Documenti per servire alla storia di
Malta (1432-1450)’, ASM, viii, 4 (1937), § 20 (15.2.1441); Bresc, ‘Sicile, Malte et monde
musulman’, in Malta: a case study in itnernational cross-currents, ed. S. Fionini and V. Mallia-
Milanes (Malta, 1991), 73.
18
Del Treppo, 493-504.
CORSO 197
19
F. Cerone, ‘Alfonso il Magnanimo ed Abu 'Omar 'Othmân. Trattative e negoziati
tra il Regno di Sicilia di quà e di là dal Faro ed il Regno di Tunisi (1432-57)’, Archivio
storico per la Sicilia orientale, x, 1-2, n.d., § xvii and xviii.
20
M. L. de Mas Latrie, Traités de paix et de commerce et documents divers concernant les rela-
tions de l’Afrique septentrionale au moyen age (Paris, 1866), § XXIV.
21
S. Fiorini, Documentary sources of Maltese History. Part I. Notarial Documents: No. 1 Notary
Giacomo Zabbara R494/1 (I) 1486-1488 (Malta, 1996); idem, No. 2 Notary Giacomo Zabbara
R494/1 (II-IV) 1494-1497 (Malta, 1999).
22
F. Braudel, The Mediterranean and the Mediterranean world in the age of Philip
II, trans. S. Reynolds, 2 vols. (London, 1972), I, 152.
23
N. Zeldes, ‘Ad Piraticam Exercendam: two “piratical” contracts from early sixteenth-
century Sicily’, Mediterranean Historical Review, vol. 15, ii (2000).
24
Wettinger, Acta; S. Fiorini, Documentary sources of Maltese History. Part I. Notarial Documents:
No. 1 Notary Giacomo Zabbara R494/1 (I) 1486-1488 (Malta, 1996); idem, No. 2 Notary
Giacomo Zabbara R494/1 (II-IV) 1494-1497 (Malta, 1999); J. del Amo García, S. Fiorini,
G. Wettinger, eds. Cathedral Museum Mdina. Archivum Cathedralis Melitæ. Miscellanea 33: 1405-
1542. (Documentary Sources of Maltese History. Part III: Documents of the Maltese
Universitas) (Malta, 2001). To these should be added some notable earlier efforts, espe-
cially the Maltese capitoli, published in S. Giambruno and L. Genuardi, Capitoli inediti
198 .
delle città demaniali di Sicilia approvati sino al 1458, I Alcamo-Malta (Palermo, 1918) and var-
ious fifteenth-century documents published by R. Valentini in Archivio Storici di Malta
[ASM] during the 1930s.
25
Fiorini, Zabbara, 2, § 19 (22.10.1494).
26
Ibid., II, § 253 (11.4.1496).
27
Ibid., § 79, 82, 83 (6.2.1495), § 88 (10.2.1495).
28
On the participation of Gatt Desguanez in the deliberations of the universitas,
Wettinger Acta, passim.
29
Ibid., § 127 (3.7.1495). Falzon served as a judge and jurat of the universitas of Malta.
30
Ibid., § 253.
CORSO 199
31
López Pérez, 625-6.
32
G. Wettinger, The Jews of Malta in the Late Middle Ages (Malta, 1985). In 1436 Maltese
Jews stood surety for a corsairing venture. Bresc, ‘Sicile, Malte et monde musulman’, 73.
33
A. T. Luttrell, ‘Malta and the Aragonese Crown: 1282-1530’, Journal of the Faculty
of Arts (The Royal University of Malta), iii (1965), 6; S. Fiorini, ‘Relaciones Catalano-
Maltesas en la Baja Edad Media. Una approximacion a partir de los archivos malteses’
in Actas Primer Coloquio Internacional Hispano Maltes de Historia (Madrid, 1991).
34
Del Treppo, 178-79.
35
On slavery in Sicily, C. Verlinden, ‘L’esclavage en Sicile au bas moyen âge’, Bulletin
de l’Institut historique belge de Rome, XXXV (1963); for examples of purchases of slaves by
Sicilian Christians and Jews, Il registro del notaio ericino Giovanni Maiorana (1297-1300),
2 vols, ed. A. Sparti (Palermo, 1982), § 138. For Malta, Fiorini, Zabbara, 1,2.
200 .
36
Wettinger, Acta § 492.
37
Fiorini, Zabbara, II, § 74, 107.
38
Ibid., § 74 (27.1.1495).
39
Ibid., § 68 (21.1.1495).
40
Ibid., § 5 (10.9.1494).
41
Ransoming of captives: ibid., § 200 (12.12.1495), § 223 (3.3.1496). In 1483 the
Maltese Jew Azar Marsany travelled to Susa to negotiate the ransom of a Christian
Maltese: Wettinger, Jews of Malta, 78-9.
CORSO 201
cens of Barbary’ from Malta were exempted from the tax and as a
result ‘the audacity of the Saracens had decreased while that of the
Maltese and Sicilians had increased, and so the homeland was defended
and the enemy offended’.42 This document, however, does not seem to
reflect the general attitude that prevailed in the universitas towards cor-
sairs throughout most of the fifteenth century. The universitas, in fact,
seems to have been largely opposed to the use of Malta as a base by
foreign and Maltese corsairs. The reasons given for this stance, as repeat-
edly stressed in council meetings or in letters sent to the authorities in
Palermo, were two. First, it was argued that indiscriminate activity by
corsairs from Malta, especially when they were foreigners (and pre-
sumably more difficult to police), could provoke reprisals from the gov-
ernments or compatriots of those whose ships had been attacked. The
problem was compounded by the fact that an important part of the
island, namely the royal castle (castrum maris) at Birgu and its harbour
area, was outside the jurisdiction of the municipal authorities. The office
of castellan was normally in the hands of the military elite, which lim-
ited the ability of the universitas to enforce the law throughout the island.43
Hence the annoyance of the jurats with the castellan in 1447 at the per-
mission granted by him to the corsair Sueru de Nava to make use of
the Birgu harbour.44 The jurats claimed that de Nava had previously
attacked Venetian, Genoese, and even Catalan ships, implying that the
island might suffer the consequences if it granted shelter to de Nava.
Some years later the officials decided that Levantine privateers should
only be allowed to stop in Malta and Gozo if they gave an assurance
not to harm the inhabitants, be they Christians or Jews, and their prop-
erty, while in port.45 The second argument put forward by the universitas
against the corso was that corsair-captains, by recruiting Maltese to serve
on their vessels, were drawing local men away from the island, some
of whom failed to return, and thus compounding an already serious
population decline due to food shortages, migration, and razzias by
Muslim corsairs.46 In February 1453 the viceroy of Sicily acceded to a
42
R. Valentini, ‘Gli ultimi Re Aragonesi ed i primi Castigliani in Malta. Documenti’,
ASM, viii, 1 (1936-7), § 2: “la audacia di li Sarachini diminuia et di li Sichiliani et Maltisi aug-
mentava, et cussi era difisa la patria et uffisu lu inimicu”.
43
Wettinger, ‘The castrum maris’.
44
Wettinger, Acta, § 5.
45
Wettinger, Jews of Malta, 16.
46
‘Parti di quilli ki vanu cum ipsi tali fusti may hanu tornatu’: R. Valentini, ‘Documenti per
servire alla storia di Malta (1432-1450)’, ASM, viii, 4 (1937), § 25 (24.3.1449).
202 .
47
Giambruno-Genuardi, Capitoli inediti, § 10 (9.2.1453).
48
Wettinger, Acta § 82 (30.5.1457), addressed to Johanni de Guevara forbidding him
to arm vessels in Malta.
49
Bresc, ‘La course méditerranéenne’, 98-9.
50
Ibid., 98.
51
Valentini, ASM, viii, 4 (1937), § 16 (24.3.1449).
52
Pryor, 156.
CORSO 203