Professional Documents
Culture Documents
تأثير تضخم تكلفة الغذاء- إنجليزي
تأثير تضخم تكلفة الغذاء- إنجليزي
of Food Cost
Inflation
Since the launch of Vision 2030 Under the leadership of King Salman and HRH Crown
Prince, the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia has focused on increasing the contribution of the
private sector and empowering the third sector in order to contribute to the development
and implementation of initiatives that work to achieve the pillars of the Kingdom's Vision
2030: a healthy society, a prosperous economy, and an ambitious nation.
One of the core initiatives is the mechanism for developing and implementing public
policies and enabling the private sector to be an effective partner in the process.
Mukatafa has specialized in lobbying the private and public sectors to join hands and
work together to identify high-impact legislation to increase the growth of business,
reduce the cost of doing business costs, and increase the ease of doing business in the
private sector. Hence, cooperate very effectively to develop new legislation and improve
existing ones. Finally, measure the impact on the legislative system after implementation
to assess opportunities for improvement.
One of the means used in Mukatafa is to enable decision-makers to see the constraints
facing the private sector is doing studies since they identify and analyze the legislations
that are hindering the private sector and also provide a comparison of best practices
within the Group of Twenty (G20) and the expected impact of improving legislation. The
studies contain private sector recommendations on legislation and initiatives needed to
increase the growth of business, reduce the cost of doing business costs, and increase the
ease of doing business.
1.37% Saudi
Arabia
While the global trend of inflation in
17.3% 13.8% 4.5%
food prices has tailed off and prices UK USA India
have stabilized in the first half of 2023, 4.8% 6.3%
food-related businesses around the world UAE Kuwait
This relatively low rate has been the result of a Education 16%
14%
combination of factors including government-led
Moral decline
inflation-control measures, enhanced social safety nets, Crime and violence 11%
11%
the low proportion of private label sales, and changing
Healthcare
Immigration control 9%
Nonetheless, food businesses – restaurants and retailers – have been hit hard by higher food/ingredient
costs and rising costs (labor, fuel, rent, fees etc.) in their supply chains, and many have had to pass at
least some of this onto the consumer. And, while inflation may have fallen back, there is no indication
that prices themselves, perhaps with the exception of fuel, will fall any time soon.
In fact, despite its fall and current relatively low level, inflation and its impact on purchasing pow-
er and consumption behaviors remains the number one concern for consumers in KSA.3 In response
to these concerns, Mukatafa commissioned a pulse check survey to assess the state of the market,
explore how different stakeholders have been impacted by high food prices and, critically,
capture some of the behaviors and strategies they have adopted to mitigate the pressure on their
budgets. Mukatafa partnered with Monitor Deloitte to conduct this snapshot research, which was
carried out in May and June 2023.
We present the results here not as the definitive state of play in the food sector but as an indication
of the scale of the impact and change that businesses and consumers have had thrust upon them,
and to provide other sector players with ideas to help them optimize their businesses in this altered
landscape.
1
Trading Economics. (2023). Saudi Arabia Food Inflation. Available at: https://tradingeconomics.com/saudi-arabia/food-inflation
2
Trading Economic. (2023). Food Inflation of countries: Available at: https://tradingeconomics.com/country-list/food-inflation
3
Sources: IPSOS - Primary Consumer Sentiment Index (May 2023)
06.
Executive summary
08.
Methodology
10.
Survey insights
13.
Case studies
22.
Conclusion
24.
Glossary
25.
Appendix
26.
Authors
The impactofof
The impact food
food cost
cost inflation
inflation 55
Executive summary
Dining out/take away
92% of respondents who have seen rising costs when dining
92%
rising
out say this has impacted their household budgets – 55% say costs
significantly so. Of those reporting a significant increase, 37%
put it at more than 10%.
Consumer behavior is changing in response to price pressure:
(respondents had the chance to choose more than one option)
92%
92% of respondents who have seen rising costs when
grocery shopping say this has impacted their household
budgets – 61% say significantly so. Of those reporting a rising
significant increase, 54% put it at more than 10% costs
61% 63%
are budgeting household are shopping with a different
needs prior to shopping retailer that offers better
for groceries prices and/or discounts significant
non-food
increases
40% 40%
are buying fewer branded are shopping
products and switching to less
white-label products frequently
46
major food ingredient and grocery items in consumers and
food businesses’ ‘shopping baskets’. They took this long list
to a panel of out-of-home dining businesses and grocery
retailers and, with their input, developed a ‘shopping list’ of
46 key ingredients from 14 product categories – those items key ingredients from 14
of greatest significance to consumers and food-businesses product categories
from a price perspective (see Appendix).
Consumer survey: 520 consumers in KSA were surveyed about their views and changing
behaviors around food shopping and eating out.
CFO survey: 10 CFOs of leading food and beverage businesses spanning grocery retail
and out-of-home dining were surveyed about the impact of price inflation on their
operations and the actions they have taken to mitigate any damage.
CEO interviews: deep-dive interviews with 7 CEOs of food and beverage businesses
spanning grocery retail and out-of-home dining.
We conducted a survey and detailed interviews with senior executives from leading grocery chains,
and restaurant and cafés businesses to gain a sense of how price rises have impacted different
types of food and beverage businesses.
Grocery retailers:
We surveyed the CFOs of five grocery retailers and wholesalers and interviewed CEOs of three of
these businesses, including two large chains and one medium-sized retailer. 5
4
Medium-sized is defined as employing between 500 and 1,000 staff
5
Large is defined as employing more than 1,000 staff
The impact 8
The impact of of food
food costcost inflation
inflation 8
Breakdown of consumer sample:
We surveyed 520 consumers on the streets of Riyadh (239), Jeddah (134), Dammam (84), Mecca (36)
and Medina (27), capturing a broadly representative sample across age, gender and income.
45%
Age 25-34
34%
Age 35-44
13%
Age 16-24 8%
Age 45-49
69% 66%
Locals SAR 7,501 - 26,000
(Saudi) monthly income
16%
Expat
Arabs 24%
Less than
SAR 7,500
monthly income
15% 10%
Other
ethnicities SAR 26,001
or more monthly
income
86%
Noticed an increase
65%
increase in prices when
in food prices grocery shopping
92% of respondents
who have seen
rising costs when
dining out
88%
78%
of respondents
eat food prepared
outside the home at
least once a week of our sample, the
typical spend on
a meal is between
SAR 100 - 150
47%
38%
doing so several
times a week
it is lower
16%
than SAR 100
eating out
on a daily
basis
92%
of respondents who have
seen an increase in food
prices when eating out
say it has impacted their
household budgets
55% 37%
say that the impact
has been significant Of those reporting a
significant increase, put it at
more than 10%
All of the restaurant and café businesses CFOs that we spoke to have seen price increases of more
than 10% and most have seen increases in excess of 15%. These increases have been compounded
by rising COGS 6, with many executives citing labor, logistics, rent and regulatory costs adding to
the challenges they are facing.
Most of the restaurant and café CEOs that we spoke to had responded to price increases by
exploring opportunities to switch suppliers in search of lower prices or better terms. However, in
contrast to retailers, whose offer is significantly linked to the brands they stock, restaurants and
cafés can be agile in terms of what they offer to their customers: they can change the dishes
they serve and/or modify the recipes they use to reduce their reliance on ingredients whose price
has risen. All of the restaurant and café businesses we interviewed had reformulated recipes to
use different, cheaper or smaller quantities of ingredients to reduce costs. Most had elected to
communicate directly with their customers about the price pressure, either by updating prices on
their menus or displaying posters indicating the increases. However, while pragmatic and open,
these tactics have not been entirely successful. All of the CEOs that we interviewed reported a
reduction in customer footfall and revenue per table – a finding that corresponds directly with the
insights delivered by the consumer survey.
Looking to the future, restaurant and café bosses are not overly optimistic. All of them expect to
see cost increases of 2-6%, further inflation and supply chain disruption, and most anticipate
volatility in the commodities markets, with obvious implications for their planning.
6
COGS – Cost of Goods Sold
Impact/issue Response
Regulatory changes – particularly around The simplest response has been to pass
transport – high import and custom duties the cost increase onto customers.
and the shortage and cost of labor are all
adding to food-related cost increases. The impact of this has been cushioned by
customer perceptions of the brand as an
Vast majority of items are sourced ‘affordable’ option.
locally but French fries and meat – key
ingredients – are both imported.
Supply chain costs have risen The business has tried to diversify and
find local suppliers. Its stringent supplier
approval requirements mean that, once
approved, new suppliers can support the
whole network, which helps them to scale.
Dine-in has fallen since COVID with the Improved cost control, KPI measurement
growth of alternative channels. and transparency.
Delivery is now the fastest-growing Average check for delivery is higher than
channel, though a large proportion of dine in, but aggregator’s commission
the revenue growth is through third party charges negate this gain.
aggregators that charge ‘very high
commission’. With delivery and drive-thru growing so
fast, the business has launched an app so
that customers can order upfront online
and reduce waiting.
“We have not increased the prices for customers, since they have nothing to do with
supply chain. Instead, we have focused on cost reduction, not only in ingredients
contracts but in other areas such as PPE and car rentals. This has been noticed by
the customers, who have compared us to other chains that increased prices.”
-Fast-food restaurant chain CEO
Impact/issue Response
Price increases have been most severe in The company has significantly increased
cheese sauce, which is imported from USA, the share of its ingredients that come from
and chicken and meat. domestic suppliers.
Price rises are a function of availability It has not passed on any of the supply
and competition, and regulation – chain pressures to its customers in the
requirement for SABER certificates is off- form of price increases and has instead
putting for international suppliers. absorbed the cost and accepted reduced
margins. It has also had to absorb
COGS have risen significantly. increased delivery costs as its delivery
Business has seen a shift towards delivery channel has grown but customers are
ever since beginning of COVID and unwilling to pay increased charges.
costs for this side of the operation have
increased though fuel, car rental and The company has implemented a range
labor increases. of strategies to mitigate COGS increases,
including:
While volumes have remained strong, • Building a new facility with greater
basket size has shrunk, which makes it ffffautomation
hard to increase prices to customer. • Menu efficiency
• Improved workforce management
• Process improvements
• Delivery route plan optimization
• Supply contracts renegotiated – longer
ffffterms for fixed prices
• Strong focus on cost reduction beyond
ffffingredients, for example PPE and car
ffffrentals.
Labor costs have increased, and The company has increased its use of
government fees account for a large part local labor but observes that local labor
of this. is relatively inefficient so retaining a mix
of local and ex-patriot staff is important.
Impact/issue Response
Almost all food items have seen price The company has sought alternative
increases, except olive oil. suppliers in different countries due to
Chicken feed costs have tripled since 2021 closure of previous markets and has
impacting poultry and eggs. sought to combine product purchasing to
achieve efficiencies and better prices.
Margins have been absorbed by the
majority of peers, impacting hiring, yearly It now conducts monthly re-evaluation
increases, and investment, and slowing of supply chain and menu pricing, and is
year-on-year growth. constantly choosing between absorbing
cost increases and passing them on.
Development and real estate costs have However, it says that inflation is limiting
also risen dramatically, especially in further price increases and restricting its
Riyadh. topline growth.
Impact/issue Response
Price increases at key suppliers mean that The company has resisted pressure from
costs for key ingredients, notably coffee board and franchisees and has not
beans and milk, are very significantly increased its prices in the last year.
higher.
Coffee beans are a global commodity - if
This has been compounded by the price increases it increases everywhere
government fees – VAT and sugar tax, so they haven’t sought to find new
which contributed around half of the cost suppliers.
increase it has experienced.
Instead, its strategy is to focus on
expanding its estate and entering new
markets to reach more customers.
Food price inflation is being felt at the till as well as the restaurant table and, again unsurprisingly,
it is those at the lower end of the income spectrum and whose grocery spend accounts for a greater
proportion of their overall income, who are most likely to feel this squeeze on their finances: 68% of
respondents earning less than SAR 7,500 report a significant impact compared with 52% of those
on higher incomes.
57% 71%
of respondents already allocated more than
respondents spend more 10% of their monthly income to groceries
than SAR 200 on groceries
54%
per week, including
Consumers who have seen an impact on their household budgets caused by increased
grocery prices have responded with a variety of changed behaviors, including:
63% 40%
are shopping with a different are buying fewer branded products and
retailer that offers better switching to white label products
prices and/or discounts
61% 39%
are budgeting household are shopping
needs prior to shopping less frequently
for groceries
So, the evidence from the street is that consumers are feeling the effects of increased food prices
and taking action, either by shopping less, buying white-label products or looking for deals and
lower prices. But consumer behavior is only one side of the story and to understand what is driving
their experience at the till, we have to look at what is happening on the supply side. What impacts
are grocery retailers seeing and how are they responding?
While many have sought to mitigate the price increases by negotiating with their suppliers, for
example to contract on locked-in prices, this has only gone part way to addressing the issue.
Alongside a range of strategies to manage price increases, all of the grocery retailers we spoke to
have had to raise their prices to consumers. Other strategies have included:
Finding
Renegotiating private label
with suppliers alternatives
Switching Reducing
to alternative product
suppliers sizes
And, despite reduced price inflation, most of the retailers we spoke to are anticipating further price
increases.
Echoing consumers’ changing behaviors, grocery executives report decreased footfall, decreased
basket size and, possibly reflecting the pressure on household budgets that consumers are experi-
encing an increase in customer complaints.
The dilemma for grocery retailers of all sizes is the extent to which they should pass their increased
costs onto the consumer – with the risk of further changing their behaviors as outlined above – or
absorbing them and impacting their own financial strategies.
As one might expect, different grocery retailers are addressing this question in different ways, de-
pending on their own growth strategies, market positioning and relationship with their customers
and suppliers.
“We are caught in a tough spot, with deciding whether to absorb the rising COGS
or passing them down, increased cost of logistics, as well as employees, who are
highly sought after by all F&B companies. On the customer side, the spend has been
impacted greatly by the increasing spend on entertainment and social activities.
I am hopeful that our COGS will go down with technological advancements, but it
remains yet to be seen whether suppliers pass the cost reduction to us, or choose to
increase their margins.”
-Large domestic grocery retailer
Impact/issue Response
Rising price of food products caused by a Grow and increase sales through:
variety of factors including: • White and private labels – however,
Saudis typically value brands and
• Seasonality e.g. Ramadan when eggs deals
are less popular • Promotions – the company committed
• Rising consumption of protein significant revenue on promotions
• Significant increase in cost of oil • Renegotiating contracts with suppliers
and gas, labor, regulation, especially – focusing on achieving larger ‘baskets’
around labor and logistics at lower costs. The company has
• Low supply of staff, resulting in a very shared a proportion of saved basket
high demand of a very limited pool of with suppliers
candidates • Relaunching its loyalty program,
which delivered 10,000 new subscribers
Labor shortage leading to high churn. The company has refocused its workforce
strategy on core roles, training employees
for multiple tasks, and outsourcing non-
core roles.
Logistics – costs have risen following Streamlining with a move towards self-
regulatory changes delivery and improved analytics-driven
route planning
Impact/issue Response
Private/white label isn’t really a viable The company has discussed private or
option at this stage. white label goods and has introduced
some lines such as tissues. However,
it believes this approach has limited
potential because:
• Scale – only the very largest networks
can make it work owing to need to
the build up your own organization to
manage what was previously done by
suppliers
• High inventory cost
• KSA is currently a brand-focused
market – people love brands
“The impact of global and imported products varies depending on the categories.
Post-COVID, the impact has doubled, resulting in increased warehousing and retail
stores, mostly in Riyadh and Jeddah, with an increase of between 60% to 70%.
Our strategy is to increase the value of the product or service, which may involve
increasing prices, but not all customers may be fine with that. To maintain the
margin, we increase prices on selected items, not all.”
-Medium-sized domestic grocery retailer
Impact/issue Response
Consumer behavior has shifted towards The company has introduced a range
eating out and home delivery. of ready-to-cook/eat products to make
eating at home easier.
Customers increasingly value speed and The company has introduced a choice of
time saving. delivery options and is making increasing
use of push notifications to send
personalized offers and recommendations
based on customer behavior.
Inevitably, some of the increased costs that businesses are experiencing are being passed on to the
consumer – 92% of consumers say they have seen price increases in either the restaurant or grocery
sectors. However, some of the businesses that we spoke to have decided, boldly, to absorb the price
rises and insulate their customers from supply chain pressures.
Attracting and retaining consumers is challenging at the best of times but under intense cost pres-
sure, businesses are having to find new ways to appeal to budget conscious households.
For retailers, this means an increased focus on promotions, loyalty programs and, potentially, the
launch or expansion of white or private labels. Retailers emphasize the brand-consciousness of the
Saudi consumer, but our survey suggests that, under price pressure, consumers may be willing to
adapt: 40% of those feeling the pressure on their budgets say they are buying fewer branded prod-
ucts and switching to ‘white-label’ products.
Beyond the shop floor, grocery retailers are also exploring ways to reduce costs through staff train-
ing, automation, and logistics and they are looking to the government to reduce the burden of regu-
lation – much of it new – that they say is impacting their COGS.
For restaurants and cafés, the flexibility to change menus and modify recipes goes some way to
mitigate cost increases at the till, but the same structural pressures that apply to retailers also
apply. Increased costs in regulation, labor, logistics and rent are all impacting both their in-house
operations and their supply chains, amplifying the effect of inflation, and forcing them to review the
way they operate.
The unhappy truth is that, for food businesses of all kinds, the food-cost inflation that consumers
are experiencing and reacting to is a manifestation of rising costs across all aspects of operations,
not merely the cost of food items – whether they are goods or ingredients.
Looking ahead, food businesses say they are anticipating further cost increases and slower growth,
suggesting that despite its relatively low level of inflation, the KSA food sector is likely to be suffer-
ing from indigestion for some time as it adjusts to a changed diet.
Costs Of
Imported
Goods
Impact On
Financial Workforce
Strategies Instability Menu
And Turnover
Adjustment
Challenges
Pricing
Challenges
Supply
Chain High Cost
Instability Of Goods Sold
(COGS)
Increased
Operating Costs
(Labor,
Rent, Fees) Customer
Relationships
Bundled offer
promotion grouping menu items at a discounted price, for example a
burger, fries and drink combination.
CEO
Chief Executive Officer
CFO
Chief Financial Officer
COGS
Cost of Good Sold
PP&E
Property, Plant and Equipment
Private label
grocery store’s own brand of goods
SABER
a scheme launched by the Saudi Standards, Metrology and Quality
Organization (SASO) to ensure a high level of quality and safety of
products available in KSA. Importers are now required to obtain a SABER
certificate for their products.
SFDA
Saudi Food and Drug Authority – KSA’s quality and safety standards
body for food, drugs, medical devices, cosmetics, pesticides and feed
SG&A
Selling General and Administrative expenses
White label
non-branded goods
Mukatafa
Monitor Deloitte
Karim Mukhalalaty
Partner, Monitor Deloitte
Joerg Meiser
Director, Monitor Deloitte
Debarun Das
Manager, Monitor Deloitte
Siddharth Mehta
Consultant, Monitor Deloitte
The information in this study is based on Mukatafa database and its study partners, and
independent analyzes by Mukatafa.. Some of the information in this study was provided by
Mukatafa, while the views expressed therein are those of Mukatafa and its partners. This study
was prepared with utmost confidence and professional care, but Mukatafa and its partners in this
study do not provide any express or implied guarantees about the accuracy or completeness of
the information included in the study or about expectations, estimates, assumptions or numbers
included in the study.
The conclusions drawn in this study are governed by the recognized determinants of similar studies
in terms of limited circulation, limited time, and information obtained from a third party.
Mukatafa, in cooperation with its partners, produced this study using information provided by
it from the participants in the study. Thus, the study of market analyzes, services, or financial
forecasts is related to the extent of error, omission, or inaccuracy of expectations that may be
included in the reports and figures of the participants. Therefore, Mukatafa bears no responsibilities
for what this may result from a direct, or indirect defect resulting from the information or reports of
the participants
Regulatory Determinants: Mukatafa Company produced this study based on the requirements
of the regulations related to similar studies, and accordingly, any changes that may occur in the
regulatory processes, systems, or existing limitations, and/or under adoption, which would affect the
market study and be Outside of Mukatafa’s ability to control, anticipate, and/or estimate, in terms
of impact and/or implications, Mukatafa in this case is not responsible for any changes in policies
and regulations that could reduce or eliminate the economic opportunity or forecast.
Deloitte & Touche (M.E.) LLP (“DME”) is the affiliate for the territories of the Middle East and Cyprus
of Deloitte NSE LLP (“NSE”), a UK limited liability partnership and member firm of Deloitte Touche
Tohmatsu Limited, a UK private company limited by guarantee (“DTTL”).
Deloitte refers to one or more of DTTL, its global network of member firms, and their related entities.
DTTL (also referred to as “Deloitte Global”) and each of its member firms are legally separate and
independent entities. DTTL, NSE and DME do not provide services to clients. Please see www.deloitte.
com/about to learn more.
Deloitte is a leading global provider of audit and assurance, consulting, financial advisory,
risk advisory, tax and related services. Our network of member firms in more than 130 countries
and territories, serves four out of five Fortune Global 500® companies. Learn how Deloitte’s
approximately 410,000 people make an impact that matters at www.deloitte.com.
DME is a leading professional services firm established in the Middle East region with uninterrupted
presence since 1926. DME’s presence in the Middle East region is established through its affiliated
independent legal entities, which are licensed to operate and to provide services under the
applicable laws and regulations of the relevant country. DME’s affiliates and related entities
cannot oblige each other and/or DME, and when providing services, each affiliate and related entity
engages directly and independently with its own clients and shall only be liable for its own acts or
omissions and not those of any other affiliate.
Monitor Deloitte is the strategy service line of Deloitte’s consulting practice across different licensed
member firms globally and in the Middle East. From strategy through execution, Monitor Deloitte
helps deliver improved performance by increasing growth and de-risking strategic choices through
our strategy professionals who employ cutting-edge approaches embedded with deep industry
expertise, working with leaders to resolve critical choices, and drive enterprise value.