Professional Documents
Culture Documents
IWFM GPG BIM Data For FM Systems Screen DPS
IWFM GPG BIM Data For FM Systems Screen DPS
In partnership with
BIM Data for FM Systems
Contents
Foreword 2
What you’ll learn 3
Planning for the transfer of data from the BIM process 4
Why must FM’s understand BIM Workflow? 4
Planning for the transfer of data from the BIM process 6
Reporting and access to information 10
Process for planning and delivering the services FMs provide 14
Data environment 15
Common data environment (CDE) 18
Data mapping 24
Lifecycle considerations 26
Visual BIM 28
Conclusion 29
Appendix A 31
Key glossary/abbreviations
Appendix B 36
Standards and guidance
Appendix C 37
References
Contributor
Mike Ford, Digital/BIM Manager (co-chair of SW BIM Region),
University of the West of England (UWE Bristol)
1
Good Practice Guide BIM Data for FM Systems
Foreword
The development and adoption of the UK BIM Framework (now including ISO 19650) What you’ll learn
has created a trusted means to provide a fully populated asset data set at handover.
This process supports asset and facilities management activities through the use of This guide is intended to help facilities management professionals (FMs) as key
the owner’s defined enterprise asset management systems during the operational stakeholders involved in Building Information Modelling (BIM) projects. It provides
life of the built asset or facility. advice regarding planning what data requires collection, by whom and when in the
BIM process. It touches on key issues about the data transfer into Computer Aided
Facility Management (CAFM) and other FM management systems. Advice is provided
Having all this accurate information exchanged in a
secure manner to support the operational stage is a on essential aspects, which should be considered when planning the data transfer
big leap forward especially the indirect benefits. The from BIM models and other BIM project sources (for example, databases) into FM
fact that we now begin the information management systems such as CAFM, SAP etc.
lifecycle by determining requirements for information
to meet the needs of the asset management strategy,
systems and other organisational functions helps align BIM has become the chosen procurement route This guide will:
those operating with those planning - a big win! for ordering and constructing new built assets.
One of the potential benefits of BIM is that it provides • provide guidance on the strategic and operational
This guide supports developing appropriate and more a good opportunity to get well-structured essential benefits of better planning in the transfer of
timely exchange of asset data / information and is information from the construction phase, which information between BIM and FM software systems
aimed at helping teams to think ahead when planning can be used by FMs to help the optimisation and • outline steps to take in helping to plan what data
BIM projects and to be clear about what they want operation of built assets in the ongoing in use phase. should be collected, when and by whom
and how to get it smoothly into their CAFM and other BIM also offers an opportunity to capture information • clarify key interactions required to guide the
asset management systems. The idea is this should be which can be used for risk management, life cycle process with other BIM project team members
approached using a ‘minimal purposeful’ rather than cost planning and future refurbishment projects. • discuss what is the role of FM in planning a
the ‘everything’ scenario that often gets asked for. BIM project
The advice in this guide is closely linked to other • provide critical knowledge and understanding
IWFM guides regarding the role of FMs in a BIM required regarding the process of transfer of data
project (links can be found in the appendix): between BIM and other systems
ESSENTIALLY THE PRINCIPLES ARE SIMPLE:
• highlight issues and essential understanding required
• The Role of FM in BIM projects regarding the technology and processes involved
• meaningful and early collaboration between
• Operational Readiness Guide • highlight what FMs need to consider for long term
capex and opex teams
• Exchange Information Requirements (EIR) maintenance and use of information and data and
• determine explicit information requirements to
issues around keeping data up to date and current
support asset management activities
• help to inform the value of data validation of FM
• a structured and validated project information
related information before the handover period
model
• assist FMs to understand the jargon, acronyms
• early testing of data exchanges to asset
David Philp MSc BSc FICE FRICS FCIOB FCInstES FGBC and language of BIM
management systems such as the CAFM
Global BIM/MIC Consultancy Director Chartered
Construction Manager CIOB Trustee
2 3
Good Practice Guide BIM Data for FM Systems
BIM is not a new concept and until recently has mostly been seen as being acronyms used in the process. The end goal is to provide Asset Information Model (AIM)
more relevant to the Architecture, Engineering and Construction (AEC) industry. information into the Asset Information Model (AIM) This is the collection of useful information relating to
which will be used by FM teams in the operational phase. the asset and items contained within it and will include
The early concepts started with the evolution of drawing tools from 2D to 3D the information created during the BIM process for
and developed over time to include richer information about the objects in the The AIM information can then be fed into the handover through to operation. This may be a 3D model
drawing/model. respective management systems, for example and may include data from more than one source i.e.
CAFM, SAP and so on. data from the BIM model as well as data within a CAFM
BIM enables the capture of vast amounts of information Why must FM’s understand The graphic (on page 4) highlights some of the
platform, databases, documents, models and drawings.
The AIM should ideally be integrated but, if integration
about individual objects just by creating them from a
pre-defined library. This is clearly very efficient and cost the BIM workflow? common information requirements that are used
when discussing the BIM process. It is important
is not possible using the current systems in place, it
should at least support the work that FMs do.
effective when designing complex buildings and other
that FMs understand these, and how they relate to
assets, but also can add an increased level of complexity. The key aspect of BIM is the ‘I’, information. To help
an organisation’s asset management and everyday Project Information Requirements (PIR)
As time has passed and BIM has become more common organise and define the data that is collected, a number
FM operational tasks. This is the information required relating to the
within the AEC industry, the requirement for information of basic information containers have been defined as
delivery phase. The PIR should be developed based
has come to the fore as one of the most important shown in Figure 1 below from the international BIM ISO
To put the above into context, the following section on information outlined in the OIR and AIR. The PIR
topics. It is this information and data that will enable Standard 19650-1. Understanding an organisations
explains the terms used. A full description of the also needs to inform the design and construction
optimisation and improvements for the operation and information requirements (OIR) and asset information
standard definitions can be found in ISO 19650-1. teams so, may contain requirements that are
maintenance phase of a building’s life. However, despite requirements (AIR) should be the start of the process.
outside the scope of FM needs.
the advances in digital design and construction delivery It should be clear why this information is needed for
Organisational Information Requirements (OIR)
(and its associated supporting softwares), FM has been, everyday operational processes and reporting needs.
This is the information the organisation requires in Exchange Information Requirements (EIR)
until recently, largely excluded from the early planning This will help FMs to plan for what is needed to deliver,
order to deliver its core strategic business objectives This is the document which defines the information
and design phases which are critical to making the whole operate and maintain built assets over the asset’s
and supporting FM functions. This includes things that requirements for use in appointing contractors and
process work. FM were mainly invited to the table only whole lifecycle.
organisations will need to report on and why, as well sets out managerial, commercial and technical aspects
for the traditional handover FMs know well. BIM has
as what data to capture. The information needed to of producing project information. The EIR brings
brought about a fundamental shift in the way we deliver It helps to have a basic overview of the BIM process and
report on assets and produce these reports etc. for together the information requirements for all parties
information and a realisation that in order to get the how it links to the provision of data and information
the organisation will shape the content of the detailed in order for the project to be specified and organised
maximum benefit out of BIM the facility managers need for the operational phase. Figure 1 below outlines
Asset Information Requirements (AIR). effectively. The EIR should guide the delivery of the
to be included at the start of a BIM project. key elements (information containers) and their
asset and clearly lay down “who”, “how” and “when”
Figure 1: Asset Information Requirements (AIR) various contributors should work together. It is the
Key information containers Source ISO 19650 pt 1: 2018 This is the detailed information required to identify, key document that enables effective collaboration.
operate, service and inspect assets and equipment
Interested parties’ Appointment information Information within built assets. It should set out managerial, Project Information Model (PIM)
information requirements requirements deliverables commercial and technical aspects of producing The PIM relates to the delivery phase, which will
the required asset information and will specify eventually be part of the AIM at handover. From
Contributes to
Contributes to
things such as make, model, serial number, surface the EIR a detailed BAP must be developed by the
Organisational Asset Asset
covering, warranty dates, lifecycle, cost etc. A key construction team which will be used to specify and
Information Information Information
point to bear in mind is that the AIR should contribute generate the PIM, as well as identify the information
Requirements Requirements Model
to the OIR. There needs to be a logic and benefit required to be captured to populate the AIM. The
(OIR) (AIR) (AIM)
to capturing data as this cost’s money. Careful PIM will enable the separation of data that can be
thought is needed around what data to capture, archived and held for reference, the data that needs
Contributes to Contributes to Contributes to there is no point in increasing expense by capturing to be accessible periodically and data that is used
unnecessary data. day to day.
Contributes to
Contributes to
4 5
6
design systems
bill of materials
Good Practice Guide
£k
£100k
£200k
£300k
£400k
£500k
Figure 2:
in OPEX
6%
• reduced risk
Design
Reduced variance
• improved compliance
Build and
commission
Benefit distribution from one project
% of total saving
6%
Planning for the transfer of data from
Handover
insights/quantifying-benefits-of-bim.html
• a much more accurate asset register (when
and commission
gives an opportunity to change that narrative.
co.uk/industries/capital-projects-infrastructure/
engagement with this process. The answer will be:
73%
many of the benefits and demonstrates time, material
The RIBA Plan of Work 2013 organises the process of briefing, designing, constructing, maintaining, operating and using building projects
into a number of key stages. The content of stages may vary or overlap to suit specific project requirements. The RIBA Plan of Work 2013 www.ribaplanofwork.com
should be used solely as guidance for the preparation of detailed professional services contracts and building contracts.
Figure 3:
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
Stages
Strategic Preparation Concept Developed Technical Handover
Definition and Brief Design Design Design Construction and Close Out In Use
Tasks
Identify client’s Business Develop Project Objectives, Prepare Concept Design, Prepare Developed Design, Prepare Technical Design Offsite manufacturing and Handover of building and Undertake In Use services
Core Case and Strategic Brief including Quality Objectives including outline proposals including coordinated and in accordance with Design onsite Construction in conclusion of Building in accordance with
Objectives and other core project and Project Outcomes, for structural design, building updated proposals for Responsibility Matrix and accordance with Construction Contract. Schedule of Services.
requirements. Sustainability Aspirations, services systems, outline structural design, building Project Strategies to include Programme and resolution of
Project Budget, other specifications and preliminary services systems, outline all architectural, structural and Design Queries from site as
parameters or constraints and Cost Information along with specifications, Cost building services information, they arise.
develop Initial Project Brief. relevant Project Strategies Information and Project specialist subcontractor
Undertake Feasibility Studies in accordance with Design Strategies in accordance with design and specifications,
and review of Site Information. Programme. Agree Design Programme. in accordance with Design
alterations to brief and issue Programme.
Final Project Brief.
Initial considerations for Prepare Project Roles Table The procurement strategy does not fundamentally alter the progression Administration of Building Conclude administration of
Procurement assembling the project team. and Contractual Tree and of the design or the level of detail prepared at a given stage. However, Contract, including regular Building Contract.
*Variable task bar continue assembling the Information Exchanges will vary depending on the selected procurement site inspections and review
project team. route and Building Contract. A bespoke RIBA Plan of Work 2013 will set of progress.
out the specific tendering and procurement activities that will occur at each
stage in relation to the chosen procurement route.
The RIBA Digital Plan of Works showing 8 stages
Establish Project Programme. Review Project Programme. Review Project Programme. The procurement route may dictate the Project Programme and may result in certain
Programme stages overlapping or being undertaken concurrently. A bespoke RIBA Plan of Work
*Variable task bar 2013 will clarify the stage overlaps. The Project Programme will set out
the specific stage dates and detailed programme durations.
(Town) Planning Pre-application discussions. Pre-application discussions. Planning applications are typically made using the Stage 3 output.
A bespoke RIBA Plan of Work 2013 will identify when the planning
*Variable task bar application is to be made.
Review Feedback from Prepare Handover Strategy Prepare Sustainability Review and update Review and update Review and update Carry out activities listed in Conclude activities listed
Suggested and Risk Assessments. Strategy, Maintenance and Sustainability, Maintenance Sustainability, Maintenance Sustainability Strategy Handover Strategy including in Handover Strategy
previous projects.
Key Support Operational Strategy and and Operational and and Operational and and implement Handover Feedback for use during the including Post-occupancy
Agree Schedule of Services, review Handover Strategy Handover Strategies and future life of the building or on
Tasks Handover Strategies and Strategy, including agreement Evaluation, review of Project
Design Responsibility and Risk Assessments. Risk Assessments. future projects.
Risk Assessments. of information required for Performance, Project
Matrix and Information
commissioning, training, Outcomes and Research
Exchanges and prepare Undertake third party Undertake third party Prepare and submit Building
handover, asset management, Updating of Project and Development aspects.
Project Execution Plan consultations as required consultations as required Regulations submission and
future monitoring and Information as required.
including Technology and and any Research and and conclude Research and any other third party
maintenance and ongoing Updating of Project
Communication Strategies Development aspects. Development aspects. submissions requiring consent.
compilation of ‘As- Information, as required, in
and consideration of Common Review and update Project Review and update Project
Review and update Project constructed’ Information. response to ongoing client
Standards to be used. Execution Plan. Execution Plan.
Execution Plan, including Feedback until the end of the
Change Control Procedures. Update Construction and building’s life.
Consider Construction Review Construction
Strategy, including offsite Health and Safety Strategies.
Review and update Strategy, including
fabrication, and develop Health Construction and Health and sequencing, and update
and Safety Strategy. Safety Strategies. Health and Safety Strategy.
Not required. Required. Required. Required. Not required. Not required. Required. As required.
UK Government
Information
Exchanges
© RIBA
7
*Variable task bar – in creating a bespoke project or practice specific RIBA Plan of Work 2013 via www.ribaplanofwork.com a specific bar is selected from a number of options.
Source RIBA, 2013
BIM Data for FM Systems
Good Practice Guide BIM Data for FM Systems
Figure 4:
Illustration of DPoW stages over an asset’s lifecycle Source RIBA, 2013
8 9
Good Practice Guide BIM Data for FM Systems
Table 1: Example of a simple reporting requirements matrix This could go on for some time until the front-line The CAFM/IWMS software industry in the UK should
delivery teams are reached but this is an important be more proactive in trying to satisfy the clients
Who Type of Report Frequency Format Responsible Comments step to consider. Whilst we can’t list every permutation information requirements. This is not to say that all
here, variations of ‘Report Types’ may include – software providers are bad, or in fact the same, but
Investment Fund Financial Monthly Table based MD Headline figures in
planned maintenance reports, outstanding works, it is common for application developers to provide
£100k increments
statutory maintenance, refurbishment, asbestos etc. a library of fixed standard reports that often stifle
Board Financial Monthly Table Based MD Headline figures in and will depend upon the needs of the organisation. rather than support information interrogation. We
£100k increments have seen much more use of disparate data sources
Board Asset Lifecyle 3 Monthly Trend Chart MD To show
Once this process, has been carried out, it is important recently and the use of Business Intelligence (BI)
Management (LCM) depreciation to understand the data needed, when and more applications being used to support reporting. Future
importantly, why. Often there are reporting tools developments will allow users of applications more
Board Asset Lifecyle 3 Monthly Gantt Chart MD Show lifecycles within FM information systems that offer a multitude flexibility and individuality in their reporting based
Management (LCM) over 5 and 25 years
of ‘standard’ reports that may or may not fit the on live query data rather than fixed reporting.
Board Asset Lifecyle 12 Monthly Condition Report MD Show items for needs of the organisation. However; if the reporting
Management (LCM) LCR over 5 years requirements are known, particularly in a BIM If FMs ask the questions before considering
environment, it will be easier to specify the ‘Level of procurement, (see appendix for other useful IWFM
Board Asset Lifecyle 5 yearly Condition Report MD Planned vs Actual
Management (LCM) Information Needed’ (LOIN) required to deliver the good practice guides) then they are more likely to
service FMs are expected to provide. The concept of be happy with the end result (The garbage in =
Regional Managers Asset Lifecyle 3 Monthly Trend Chart Senior Regional To show LOIN is explained in Section 11.2 of ISO 19650-1 and is garbage out scenario). Most good quality CAFM/
Management (LCM) Manager depreciation
the key to effective development of the Organisation, IWMS platforms in the UK are more than capable
Regional Managers Asset Lifecyle 3 Monthly Gantt Chart Senior Regional Show lifecycles Asset and Exchange Information Requirements of answering the questions above with relative ease.
Management (LCM) Manager over 5 and 25 years (OIR, AIR and EIR respectively) in a BIM process. The advent of BIM gives FM the opportunity to
influence and shape the data it needs with the
Regional Managers Asset Lifecyle 12 Monthly Condition Report Senior Regional Show items for
Management (LCM) Manager LCR over 5 years
It is worth mentioning here that whilst traditional end result in mind.
reports are still common, you should expect the use of
Regional Managers Asset Lifecyle 12 Monthly Condition Report Senior Regional Planned vs Actual live data and visual feedback to become more common
Management (LCM) Manager in day to day FM operations. In the future it’s expected
Regional Managers Performance 1 Monthly Bar/Column/Pie Senior Regional To show works that reporting information will be delivered directly to
Chart Manager completed on personal devices rather than via a pdf or spreadsheet
time, overdue attached to an email.
and incomplete
Regional Managers Performance 1 Monthly Bar/Column/Pie Senior Regional To show One of the most common problems seen in the
Chart Manager compliance
world of FM and CAFM/IWMS is a dissatisfaction
with the application itself. Quite often the statement
‘it doesn’t do what we want it to do’ or ‘it’s not telling
Whilst traditional reports
me what I need to know’ is heard on a new product are still common, you should
demonstration for a prospective client or evaluation
of an existing application. Sometimes, when the
expect the use of live data and
existing system is reviewed, it is discovered that visual feedback to become
the required data is not being captured to allow
the generation of reports the system is being
more common in day to day
asked to provide. FM operations.
12 13
Good Practice Guide BIM Data for FM Systems
Another important consideration when The third consideration is that of the data environment. What is meant by this?
designing BIM or FM information system In the world of FM or Asset Management (AM), the data environment may be
requirements (regardless of whether defined as all sources of information that are used to deliver day to day services.
the project is BIM enabled or a more In the AEC world, data environment often means an application that is used as a
traditional set up) is understanding central repository for documents, drawings and models. This is usually called the
internal and external process for Common Data Environment (CDE). CDEs are data sources (normally in the form
planning and delivering the service FMs of applications) used predominantly during the design and construction phases
provide. Quite often, this can be the by project teams. They allow for a central repository of all information about the
most challenging of all. Not because it asset and allow collaboration across multiple disciplines.
is more difficult or technically complex
but because it involves change. To fully integrate the PIM with the current or planned
operational systems FMs should firstly understand
what systems and sources of data are currently held
By defining the data needed and how it can be
within the organisation or that they have planned
presented to others, FMs will undoubtedly challenge
to gather going forward. It is important to look
the status quo. The trick is to compromise, and to do
beyond traditional M&E, consider asset management
it in favour of betterment. Any change should not be
in the holistic sense, as all assets within the facility
made lightly but, neither should it be made without
(including the building itself). It is highly likely that
due consideration. There are some views that new
in the organisation’s current environment there will
technology forces change and can’t be avoided.
be multiple sources of data that are used in daily
To an extent this is true however; effective and
operations. Some of these will be either a duplicate
lasting change can only happen if all parties buy
of another source or worse a contradiction of another
into the vision.
source of data.
14 15
Good Practice Guide BIM Data for FM Systems
Some organisations, may link between one or more You are unlikely to have all of the functionality derived If the team is able to make use of the Industry
applications but supporting a ‘Digital Ecosystem’ from some of the systems listed in a single software Foundation Classes (IFC) file format, this will allow
such as that shown in Figure 6, quite often, they platform. You will require a system of linking the data for 3D graphical and alphanumeric data to be
remain separate. environments that exist within each or have a single transferred directly from AEC into the FM systems.
source for the data environment. You must consider Currently, this file format is very rare in terms
Regardless of whether there is some form of the data sources as a CDE and consider BIM from of use within CAFM/IWMS but, is the standard
integration between systems or not, the software a building operator’s perspective as a Building ‘Open BIM’ solution for transferring models within
platforms are designed to operate essentially in Information “Management” tool. the AEC community. As BIM transfer becomes
a similar way and have three key aspects to them: more common, it will be more likely that IFC files
The FM idea of a CDE is quite different to that of will replace COBie spreadsheets/workbooks as
1 (Common) Data Environment CDE or database - someone from the AEC sector, so in order to bring the information exchange format.
into which data is collected, held and used these two worlds together, FMs need some form
2 workflow or process - which align to operational of common platform or exchange mechanism.
or service requirements Industry Foundation Classes (IFC) – IFC is an
3 reporting - used for contractual performance Until the integration of 3D files becomes common across agreed open source format text-based file. It
evidence or management decisions FM Information systems, it is likely that the international lists all objects in a model with their associated
standard for asset information - Construction Operations attributes. IFC is the defacto standard in the
Building Information Exchange (COBie) will be the AEC sector for sharing 3D models between
default basis for the data environment within the design applications. The IFC schema (which
BIM model. However, it is recommended that the is effectively the contents list) includes the
Figure 6:
selection of systems and tools is defined in advance of COBie fields enabling COBie requirements to
The digital ecosystem of which
preparing the requirements for the BIM model. Another be included in the model. IFC cannot easily
FM systems are a component
important aspect is testing the data exchange between be read without the use of a graphical display
the BIM model and the FM operational tools frequently application. Currently very few FM systems can
during the life of the BIM change project. use IFC imports although, it is likely that this
IoT devices
will evolve in the future.
Asset Procurement,
Management Logistics & Construction Operations Building Information
systems Stores systems Exchange (COBie) – A format developed
by the US Corps of Engineers that provides It should be noted that this does not mean that
a framework for capturing all information IFC will replace COBie. COBie is simply a filtered
relating to a building. Normally distributed in version of the massive amount of data held
spreadsheet form, COBie is easy to navigate and within an IFC for example. A sub-set. COBie will
update but can sometimes be complex and does therefore continue to be used as the framework
Fire and Life CAFM / IWMS for organising data.
not allow the information to be used proactively.
Safety systems systems
DIGITAL
ECOSYSTEM
“I think FMs need to be cautioned on COBie, it’s a great schema but has many
Reporting Audio/Visual
weaknesses and FMs believe if they ask for COBie they get everything they
and displays applications
need. This may not be the case for sophisticated assets and in many cases COBie
provides too many data fields for simple assets such as light switches. Why is
this important because in Revit (I’m not sure about other authoring tools) once a
parameter is added every asset has that parameter attached whether its needed
Finance ERP or not and whether it contains data or not. This leads to large amounts of dead
MBS / EMS
applications space and can be highly confusing to the end user understanding whether an
Access asset should or shouldn’t have data attached.”
Control
systems Andy Hamer - Invicara
16 17
Good Practice Guide BIM Data for FM Systems
Common data environment (CDE) Note: Replacement cost is almost certainly going
to be more than the initial purchase price as a result Some data fields in FM applications have a
of the replacement taking place in a built asset as limited number of characters that can be fitted
opposed to one that is being built. Allowance needs into them. This is to reduce data records and
to be made on top of the purchase price when thinking optimise database performance however; if you
about replacement to reflect degree of difficulty and have text/numbers that are longer than the field,
extent of replacement necessary. the entry may be clipped for example:
18 19
Good Practice Guide BIM Data for FM Systems
20 21
Good Practice Guide BIM Data for FM Systems
This is not necessarily about ensuring the BIM data is Where a user has little or no knowledge of BIM or Apart from giving the FM team a unique reference for In summary, facility managers need only a couple
fit for purpose, or helping the data to ‘drop’ into any the BIM process, we would recommend reading ISO an asset object, this can be used to generate barcodes/ of fields within the IFC or COBie data to be able to
particular CAFM/IWMS product. This is about giving 19650 parts 1&2 as this is the source of information QR codes etc for asset and location tagging. link one data set to another. In reality, this could be
FM a single field that will tell them all they need to relating to the way that BIM has evolved in the UK and one field. In practical terms however; FMs should
know about an object. It is not essential to BIM per se internationally. This standard quickly allows you to see As you can see from the COBie attribute table in be able to get what has been discussed above
although this method certainly helps us to identify, the correlation between the way that BIM developers Figure 8, whilst COBie gives quite a bit of detail included in the model data. As mentioned previously,
categorise and place objects in the correct place in describe files and documents in the BIM process and about objects, they are abstract to a large degree. this may only be a placeholder until it is clear what
an asset based hierarchy. This is especially true if FMs the way that FM has defined data objects for many What FM needs is to be able to articulate to AEC the data will be, in the same way that ‘xxxx’ is used
have software that does not have a direct COBie or years prior to the advent of BIM, a version of which the relationships between objects and their place within the ISO 19650 naming conventions in the
IFC import facility. is shown below. in the ‘system’ that is the built asset. AEC industry.
Table 2: Figure 8:
Example of setting an asset naming convention. Example of a COBie spreadsheet
22 23
Good Practice Guide BIM Data for FM Systems
Data mapping
CASE STUDY 1
UBS – 5 Broadgate
https://www.slideshare.net/
BritishInstituteofFa/ubs-building-information-
modelling
CASE STUDY 2
Slough Borough Council utilising MainManager
http://blog.fm180.com/2019/02/slough-
borough-council-and-morgan.html
24 25
Good Practice Guide BIM Data for FM Systems
Lifecycle considerations
Whilst this guide is predominantly geared towards informing FM about data Consider now that a modern university, hospital or
preparation for BIM projects, it is necessary to include some consideration for airport may have many hundreds or even thousands of
doors and the lifecycle savings would be considerable.
the use of Lifecycle information. When this system is then expanded across all items
we can see the potential for real benefits of BIM for
FM operations.
It is now commonplace for FM to be responsible Consider the simple comparison in Figure 9
for monitoring, maintaining and managing lifecycle below between door furniture quality or similar.
In the past this was almost impossible to do but, BIM
replacements. BIM brings about an opportunity This demonstrates that cost does not always
now makes it technically possible. The difficult part
to do this much more intelligently, with more equate to long term savings if quality does
still remains the trade off between savings in CAPEX
accuracy and for the right reasons rather than not give enough robustness or resilience to
vs the translated savings that could be made during
simply for cost saving. an item.
OPEX however; that is a subject in itself.
Assume 50 YEARS
26 27
Good Practice Guide BIM Data for FM Systems
Throughout this guide we have Having a good indication of the information required makes it possible to articulate
concentrated on the preparation, and specify the data requirements when embarking upon a BIM project.
collation and mapping of data into
FM systems. We have given little “The ease of access to information
weight to the visual benefits of created in the design, construction Facility Managers must be: applications (hopefully, the best ones for a particular
job), intelligent objects and processes that we can
BIM even though they are many. and operation of a building is an
• clear about the information requirements of the bring together into an effective solution for the
important success factor for BIM. relevant organisation organisation. Part of this solution is undoubtedly a
Even though this aspect is still developing, we must To improve uptake it’s also important • able to define how that data needs to be captured CAFM/IWMS platform but this should now be seen
understand and accept that we humans are used to that the information contained is • clear on how it will be presented back to the FM more as the hub of FM operations rather than the
receiving data but tend to interact and react better team and other stakeholders single, often disconnected article.
true! How we choose to access this
to visual cues than to flat, written records within
spreadsheets. Where possible, you should include information is not prescribed. It’s very So, do the designers know what FM wants and how to At the point of handover, you should receive
and consider the possible uses of visual data in all much the choice of those that will achieve it? This should be possible if we have clearly an effective, accurate and relevant data set that
its forms when specifying BIM requirements. This benefit from using the data. For FMs, defined organisational requirements in the form of populates any relevant systems/applications
may include aspects such as business intelligence the OIR as it is based on the reporting process and needed to allow the asset to function and be
knowing what options are available is
(BI) dashboards, laser scans, images and videos, but asset information requirements in terms of the AIR. maintained throughout its lifecycle. The ideal
in the future will also include 3D models, interaction often a source of frustration. Whether There should be a clear picture of the scope and would be to have the ecosystem in place prior to
and visualisations using models and the continued the data is viewed in a spreadsheet, a content required for the Level of Information (LOI) the handover so that the transition from construction
development of AR and VR technologies to support Revit model, a Matterport Scan or an FMs need to effectively operate and maintain the to operation is seamless and follows the principle
the FM operative on the ground. Figure 11 below asset. Your requirement can then be included in the of the soft-landing approach.
annotated 2D pdf floorplan is a
illustrates some of the visual benefits. Exchange Information Requirements which becomes
matter of preference. Access to the the contractual blueprint for delivering the asset to As apps and objects become smarter, we see assets
data and maintaining a single version the end user. with IoT capability becoming more common with
of ‘the truth’ is paramount to the ability to create not just smart buildings but,
Throughout the process you should be engaged smart cities. We already have BMS, Access Control,
successful implementation of BIM/
to ensure the data required is present, in the Finance and Fire Systems amongst others gaining
CAFM integration in all buildings.” right level of detail either via involvement in the the capability to send information as well as allowing
Figure 11:
validation of data drops or, more commonly, via access to their database for reporting and other
Visual feedback for the FM is key. Here we see Derek Lawrence, Arup access and interaction with the CDE used by the purposes. The future will allow us to specify not just
objects with planned work in blue and overdue
project team. the applications we build into our facilities but also,
works in red
how they will communicate.
The modern data environment is becoming more
fragmented than ever but with the ability to share The potential for the volume of data to swamp us
data between applications becoming the norm. The without any real benefit is clear (and can be seen in
emphasis now is less on large enterprise applications some early projects). Asking the right questions at
that do everything, as we have come to expect in the the start will enable us to navigate the plethora of
past, but on developing ecosystems of connected data contained in BIM designed and delivered assets.
applications and data sets. It will allow us to capture the BIM data in its entirety
but, use only the data we need to fulfil our operational
Technology moves so fast that we must embrace and reporting requirements. In short, we should aim to
solutions that deliver specific parts of our requirement cherry pick the quality data for the right reasons, not
as opposed to a single solution that can do most of simply accept a COBie workbook or IFC file because
it. The future is one where we select a number of the BIM mandate requires it.
28 29
Good Practice Guide BIM Data for FM Systems
Appendices Appendix A
Key glossary/abbreviations
Term Definition
Appendix A Appendix A
Key glossary/abbreviations Key glossary/abbreviations
DOI Digital Object Identifier (See ISO 26324:2012) LOD Level of Definition
32 33
Good Practice Guide BIM Data for FM Systems
Appendix A Appendix A
Key glossary/abbreviations Key glossary/abbreviations
34 35
Good Practice Guide BIM Data for FM Systems
Appendix B Appendix C
Standards and guidance References
Collaborative production of information. Fulfilling employer's See PAS 1192 and BS Other sources
BS 1192-4:2014
information exchange requirements via COBie EN ISO 19650-1 & -2
IWFM https://www.iwfm.org.uk/Glossary
Code of practice for Asset Management
BS 8536-2 (Linear & geographical infrastructure): Part 2 FM Procurement GPG
IWFM
Briefing for Design and Construction. https://www.iwfm.org.uk/knowledge/procurement
Code of practice for AEC library objects Selecting FM Software GPG
BS 8541-1:2012 Part 1 IWFM
(Identification & classification) https://www.iwfm.org.uk/knowledge/software
Code of practice for AEC library objects The Role of FM in BIM projects GPG
BS 8541-3:2012 Part 3 IWFM
(Shape and measurement) https://www.iwfm.org.uk/knowledge/managerial/bim-projects
Code of practice for AEC library objects BIMTalk https://bimtalk.co.uk/bim_glossary:start
BS 8541-4:2012 Part 4
(Attributes for specification and assessment)
BIMDICTIONARY https://bimdictionary.com/about/
BS ISO 16757-1: Data structures for electronic product catalogues for building services:
Operational Readiness Guide
2015 Concepts, architecture and model IWFM BIM
EIR
ISO 9001:2015 International standard for QMS ISO 9001:2015 Guidance
The Role of FM in BIM Projects
International standard for implementing collaborative working over BRE https://bregroup.com/expertise/bim/
ISO 19650-1 & -2 ISO 19650-1 & -2
the asset lifecycle using BIM organisation
BSI https://www.bsigroup.com/en-GB/
International standard for FM systems:
ISO 41001:2018 ISO 41001:2018
Requirements & guidance for use CIC Protocol http://cic.org.uk/admin/resources/bim-protocol-2nd-edition-2.pdf
ISO 14000:2015 International standard for Environmental Management DB Wiki https://www.designingbuildings.co.uk/wiki/
ISO 14040:2006 Describes the principles and framework for LCA See LCA https://www.gsa.gov/real-estate/design-construction/3d4d-building-information-
GSA
modeling/bim-guides/bim-guide-terminology
ISO 15926 International standard for life cycle data integration In 11 parts
SFG20 http://www.sfg20.co.uk/
ISO 16739:2005 International standard for presenting IFCs buildingSMART
https://www.smartsheet.com/essential-guide-facilities-management-computer-aided-
ISO 20121:2012 International standard for sustainable events management system Green events smartsheet
facilities-management-software
ISO 20400: 2017 International standard for sustainable procurement Techopedia https://www.techopedia.com/dictionary
ISO 45001:2018 International standard for OH&S - replaces OHSAS OHSAS 18001 UK BIM Alliance http://www.ukbimalliance.org/
ISO 50001:2011 International standard for Energy Management Systems COBie standard https://www.nationalbimstandard.org/
ISO 55001:2014 Asset Management - Management Systems COBie QC
https://github.com/OhmSweetOhm/CobieQcReporter
Reporter
Publicly Available Specification for capital/delivery phase of UKG initiative
PAS 1192-2:2013
construction projects using BIM See BSI COBie Plugin
https://github.com/opensourceBIM/COBie-plugins
for BIMserver
Publicly Available Specification for operational phase of assets UKG initiative
PAS 1192-3:2014
using BIM See BSI
Publicly Available Specification for security-minded BIMs, UKG initiative
PAS 1192-5:2015
DBEs and SAM See BSI
Publicly Available Specification for collaborative sharing & use UKG initiative
PAS 1192-6:2018
of structured H&S information using BIM See BSI
36 37
The Institute of Workplace and Facilities Management (IWFM) is the body
for workplace and facilities professionals.
IWFM
Charringtons House
1st Floor South
The Causeway
Bishop’s Stortford
Hertfordshire CM23 2ER
ISBN: 978-1-909761-38-4
Price: £19.99