The document discusses 8 risks that could impact the bank's audit risk model:
1) Computer fraud risk, with medium inherent, control, and detection risks, leading to elevated overall audit risk.
2) Risk of management override of controls, with high inherent and control risks and medium detection risk, resulting in high overall audit risk.
3) Fraud by branch management, with medium to high inherent risk, medium control risk, and medium detection risk, influencing overall audit risk.
4) Fraud by accounting personnel, with medium inherent, control, and detection risks, influencing overall audit risk.
The document discusses 8 risks that could impact the bank's audit risk model:
1) Computer fraud risk, with medium inherent, control, and detection risks, leading to elevated overall audit risk.
2) Risk of management override of controls, with high inherent and control risks and medium detection risk, resulting in high overall audit risk.
3) Fraud by branch management, with medium to high inherent risk, medium control risk, and medium detection risk, influencing overall audit risk.
4) Fraud by accounting personnel, with medium inherent, control, and detection risks, influencing overall audit risk.
The document discusses 8 risks that could impact the bank's audit risk model:
1) Computer fraud risk, with medium inherent, control, and detection risks, leading to elevated overall audit risk.
2) Risk of management override of controls, with high inherent and control risks and medium detection risk, resulting in high overall audit risk.
3) Fraud by branch management, with medium to high inherent risk, medium control risk, and medium detection risk, influencing overall audit risk.
4) Fraud by accounting personnel, with medium inherent, control, and detection risks, influencing overall audit risk.
Risk Level: Medium Impact on Audit Risk Model: o Inherent Risk (IR): Medium. The risk of computer fraud increases the inherent risk as it suggests vulnerability in the system that could lead to material misstatements. o Control Risk (CR): Medium. The effectiveness of controls over the new computer system will determine control risk. Weak controls could increase the risk of fraud. o Detection Risk (DR): Medium. The auditor's ability to detect computer fraud depends on the effectiveness of detection procedures. o Audit Risk (AR): Overall audit risk is elevated due to the combination of medium inherent risk, control risk, and detection risk associated with computer fraud.
2. Risk Related to Management Override of Internal Control
Risk Level: High Impact on Audit Risk Model: o Inherent Risk (IR): High. Management's ability to override controls indicates a high inherent risk of intentional misstatements. The risk of intentional misstatements is elevated. o Control Risk (CR): High. The likelihood of management overriding internal controls is high, given the CEO's control over the board. This substantially increases control risk. o Detection Risk (DR): Medium. Detecting management override requires careful audit procedures, contributing to a medium detection risk. If these procedures are not effectively implemented, detection risk is moderate. o Audit Risk (AR): Overall audit risk is high due to the combination of high inherent risk, control risk, and medium detection risk associated with management override.
3. Fraud by Branch Management
Risk Level: Medium to High Impact on Audit Risk Model: o Inherent Risk (IR): Medium to High. If there are incentives for branch management to manipulate numbers, it increases the inherent risk. High if there are strong incentives for manipulation. o Control Risk (CR): Medium. Depending on the effectiveness of controls in place, control risk may vary. If controls are not strong, the risk of misstatements due to fraud is medium. o Detection Risk (DR): Medium. Detecting fraudulent activities at the branch level requires effective audit procedures. If these procedures are not well-designed, detection risk is moderate. o Audit Risk (AR): Overall audit risk is influenced by a combination of high to medium inherent risk, medium control risk, and medium detection risk associated with fraud by branch management.
4. Fraud by Accounting Personnel
Risk Level: Medium Impact on Audit Risk Model: o Inherent Risk (IR): Medium. Despite little turnover, consistent underestimation of loan loss allowances raises concerns, contributing to medium inherent risk. o Control Risk (CR): Medium. The effectiveness of controls in preventing fraudulent activities by accounting personnel influences control risk. If controls are not robust, the risk of misstatements due to fraud is medium. o Detection Risk (DR): Medium. Effective detection procedures are necessary to identify potential fraud by accounting personnel. If these procedures are not well-designed, detection risk is moderate. o Audit Risk (AR): Overall audit risk is influenced by a combination of medium inherent risk, medium control risk, and medium detection risk associated with fraud by accounting personnel.
5. Misstatement of Accounting Estimates
Risk Level: Medium Impact on Audit Risk Model: o Inherent Risk (IR): Medium. The consistent underestimation of the allowance for loan losses indicates a medium inherent risk related to accounting estimates. o Control Risk (CR): Medium. The accuracy of accounting estimates depends on the effectiveness of controls. If controls are not strong, the risk of misstatements due to inaccurate estimates is medium. o Detection Risk (DR): Medium. Detecting misstatements in accounting estimates requires careful audit procedures. If these procedures are not well-designed, detection risk is moderate. o Audit Risk (AR): Overall audit risk is influenced by a combination of medium inherent risk, medium control risk, and medium detection risk associated with misstatements of accounting estimates.
6. Fraud by Loan Processing Clerks
Risk Level: Low to Medium Impact on Audit Risk Model: o Inherent Risk (IR): Low to Medium. The risk is relatively lower compared to others, given the overall context. However, any fraud by loan processing clerks could impact the accuracy of financial transactions, contributing to a moderate level of inherent risk. o Control Risk (CR): Low to Medium. The effectiveness of controls in preventing fraudulent activities by loan processing clerks will influence control risk. If controls are not robust, the risk of misstatements due to fraud is moderate. o Detection Risk (DR): Medium. Detecting fraud by loan processing clerks requires effective audit procedures. If these procedures are not well-designed, detection risk is moderate. o Audit Risk (AR): Overall audit risk is influenced by a combination of low to medium inherent risk, low to medium control risk, and medium detection risk associated with fraud by loan processing clerks.
7. Fraud by Internal Auditors
Risk Level: Low to Medium Impact on Audit Risk Model: o Inherent Risk (IR): Low to Medium. The close relationship between the chairman of the audit committee and the internal auditor may introduce a potential risk, though at a lower level. The inherent risk is low to medium. o Control Risk (CR): Low to Medium. The effectiveness of controls over the internal audit function will influence control risk. If controls are not robust, the risk of misstatements due to fraudulent activities is moderate. o Detection Risk (DR): Medium. Detecting fraud by internal auditors requires effective audit procedures. If these procedures are not well-designed, detection risk is moderate. o Audit Risk (AR): Overall audit risk is influenced by a combination of low to medium inherent risk, low to medium control risk, and medium detection risk associated with fraud by internal auditors.
8. The Risk of Fraudulent Misstatement of Revenues
Risk Level: Medium to High Impact on Audit Risk Model: o Inherent Risk (IR): Medium to High. Depending on the accuracy of revenue recognition, the inherent risk could be medium to high. The bank's reliance on mortgage sales and the potential for aggressive revenue recognition practices increase the inherent risk. o Control Risk (CR): Medium to High. The effectiveness of controls over revenue recognition will influence control risk. If controls are not robust, the risk of misstatements due to fraudulent revenue recognition is high. o Detection Risk (DR): Medium. Detecting fraudulent misstatement of revenues requires effective audit procedures. If these procedures are not well-designed, detection risk is moderate. o Audit Risk (AR): Overall audit risk is influenced by a combination of medium to high inherent risk, medium to high control risk, and medium detection risk associated with the risk of fraudulent misstatement of revenues.