Professional Documents
Culture Documents
To cite this article: Emmanuel Monfort, Antonio Mayol, Clotilde Lissot & Pascal Couturier
(2016): Evaluation of a Therapeutic Education Programme for French Family Caregivers of
Elderly People Suffering from Major Neurocognitive Disorders: Preliminary Study, Gerontology
& Geriatrics Education
Emmanuel Monfort
t
ip
Psychology Laboratory (LIP /C2S, EA4145), Univ. Grenoble Alpes, France
cr
Antonio Mayol
us
Psychology Laboratory (LIP /C2S, EA4145), Univ. Grenoble Alpes, France
an
Clotilde Lissot
M
Department of Geriatric Medicine, Grenoble Alpes University Hospital, France
ed
Pascal Couturier
Corresponding Author:
E-mail: emmanuel.monfort@univ-grenoble-alpes.fr
1
Abstract
The pertinence of a therapeutic programme of education has been studied with regard
adapted to the needs expressed by the carers, consisted of three workshops with a view
behavioural disorders and specific aids to identify and manage their emotional
t
ip
reactions. The results of this preliminary study show a moderate significant benefit to
cr
the level of anxiety in the participants, taking into account the specific expectations of
us
Keywords: therapeutic education, caregiving, major neurocognitive disorders, dementia
an
M
Introduction
In France, 4.3 million people over 16 are helping - today, regularly, at home - one or several
ed
persons over 60 in their entourage due to illness, or special needs (Weber, 2010). Because of
pt
this, these family carers have to learn to manage the numerous changes that appear in their
relative from a cognitive, functional and behavioural point of view. This help comes at a high
ce
cost, the burden (Sörensen, Duberstein, Gill, & Pinquart, 2006), that includes the whole of
the physical, psychological, emotional, social and financial consequences carried by the
Ac
carers (Bocquet & Andrieu, 1999). It is generally associated with a high level of stress and
depression (Cuijpers, 2005; Zarit & Femia, 2008), or anxiety (Cooper, Balamurali, &
Livingston, 2007), as well as problems of physical health (Pinquart & Sörensen, 2003). The
negative consequences of commitment to a close, sick relative emerge on the social level too.
Indeed, because of the very considerable time spent occupied with caring, 50% of children
2
and 70% of partners, who assume the responsibility of carer, state that the time spent with
their dependent charge is more than six hours a day (Kerhervé, Gay, & Vrignaud, 2008), the
carers having, as a result, little time to devote to themselves (Ferrara et al., 2008). This
commitment increases the difficulty of their taking up pleasurable activities (Stevens et al.,
2004), fosters the loss of social contacts (Ory, Hoffman, Yee, Tennstedt, & Schulz, 1999) and
increases the feeling of solitude (Beeson, 2003). At the same time their sources of social
t
ip
support would appear to diminish significantly over time (Clay, Roth, Wadley, & Haley,
2008); this confronts them then with the major risk of isolation. Their social relationships
cr
suffer different pressures especially if family conflict is added to this (Ferrara et al., 2008;
us
Neufeld & Harrison, 2003). Thus, the illness of their relatives, frequently considered by the
carers as a priority demanding their full attention, generally becomes a major source of stress.
an
Beyond the actual burden borne by family carers (Pinquart & Sörensen, 2003),
psychological factors play a central role in their stress process. What the carers believe to be
M
the behavioural problems of their charge has, of course, an influence - just as important, if not
ed
more so - on their health, more than the very presence of these disorders (Campbell et al.,
2008; Mittelman, Roth, Haley, & Zarit, 2004). Helping aging patients with cognitive
pt
disorders can also affect their well-being in a positive manner (Arai, & Zarit, 201). Some
carers described satisfaction in being able to care of the loved one and understanding that
ce
he/she could not reciprocate (Shim, Barroso, & Davis, 2012). The feeling of personal
Ac
efficiency (or auto efficiency) is also a determining factor in the caring experience. Carers,
who have confidence in their personal resources to deal with the different stress-provoking
situations, show less depressive symptoms (Gilliam & Steffen, 2006; Rabinowitz, Mausbach,
Thompson, & Gallagher-Thompson, 2007). Some strategies set up by carers to manage their
situation seem to have a positive effect on their mental health. The studies that have
measured the strategies of emotional management more specifically have shown that some of
3
these strategies could be adaptative for carers, whilst others could not. The self-blaming
factor (Batt-Leiba, Hills, Johnsons, & Bloch, 1998; Mausbach, Roepke, Depp, Patterson, &
Grant, 2009) could result in negative feelings on the part of carers, which could be
particularly linked to bouts of depression (Jermann, Van der Linden, d’Acremont, &
Zermatten, 2006). On the other hand, resignation (Spira et al., 2007) and refocusing or re-
evaluation could be linked to a lesser level of stress (Haley et al., 1996; Knight, 1991), the
t
ip
latter, as well as concentration on the action, being more negatively linked to depression
(Jermann et al., 2006). The distress of carers would be mainly the consequence of a fatalistic
cr
feeling, built up from dysfunctional thinking (Losada et al., 2010).
us
In general, psychosocial intervention for carers of the aged suffering from major
multicomponent counselling or respite solutions (Acton & Kang, 2001; Burgio et al., 2001;
M
Gallagher-Thompson & Coon, 2007; Pinquart & Sörensen, 2006; Schulz, O’Brien,
ed
Bookwala, & Fleissner, 1995). Among these, psycho-educative groups have been a particular
object of study over the last few years. They have shown to be of great effectiveness in
pt
reducing stress (Brodaty, Green, & Koschera, 2003; Pinquart & Sörensen, 2006), especially
dealing with diabetes and has become a reference for treating chronic illnesses, its aim being
to enable a patient to acquire the therapeutic skills necessary so as to be able to apply them to
himself/herself (Lacroix & Assal, 2011). The therapeutic education of the patient (TEP;
Lagger, Giordan, Chambouleyron, Moutet, & Golay, 2008) is structured as follows. First of
all, an analysis of needs gives the possibility of pinpointing the skills to be acquired and the
4
establishment of an educative diagnostic that determines the direction towards the learning
workshops. Although the TEP constitutes one of the most recent psycho-educative supports
among those intended to aid family carers (Pariel, Boissières, Delamare, & Belmin, 2013), it
has already showed its effectiveness on the health of, not only the elderly patients, but also
on that of their caregivers. Yet, in France in 2013, it was possible to list 30 programmes of
therapeutic education for old people - 12 of which concerned Alzheimer’s - , out of the 2 700
t
ip
authorized national programmes (Pariel et al., 2013) without their effectiveness being known
today. An analysis of the results and needs leads to envisaging the possibility of the
cr
appearance of new needs during the educative process, in order to reintroduce further
us
educative steps if necessary. It is also a question of refraining from imposing one specific
educative intervention for family carers. The aim of this intervention was to develop
M
competencies in dealing with the illness of their relative and to reduce caregiver anxiety and
ed
depression.
Method
pt
ce
Population
All family carers who volunteered (N = 12) were recruited from the Cognitive Behaviour
Ac
Therapy Unit at the University Hospital of X. To be eligible for the study, the carers had to
define themselves as having a responsibility towards the person diagnosed, around six
months before, with MNC-D according to the DSM-5 (APA, 2014), defined by a significant
decrement in cognitive functioning which interferes with daily activities, whether they lived
or not with the relative. The sample size was limited by the lack of available time of the
5
patients’ carers. The recipients concerned (N = 9) were of an average age of 83.83 (standard
et al., 1994; range 0–144), a caregiver-based report using two-part screening questions
(severity and frequency of behavioural symptoms, and impact on carers). Their average score
at their admission, was of 17.25 (standard deviation = 11.45), led to mild disturbance, with an
average impact score with professionals (range 1–60) of 5.52 (standard deviation = 3.78), led
t
ip
to minimal consequences. 5 were suffering from a probable Alzheimer’s disease, 1 from
Lewy body dementia and 3 from another type of MNC-D. The carers had not to participate at
cr
the same time in another programme of the same psycho-educative nature. The demographic
us
characteristics concerning the participants in this study are shown in table 1.
Educational materials were approved by the Cross-Sectoral Unit for Patient Education
an
of the X hospital and all participants provided appropriate informed consent.
M
Table 1.
ed
Methodology of the intervention. The main aim of the intervention was to increase the
resources of family carers for dealing with their relative’s illness and so improve the state of
ce
their own health and that of their patient. This aim has been delineated in three sub-aims for
carers:
Ac
• adapt his/hers attitudes to the difficulties of the relative in order to reconsider how
• foresee the sudden difficult behaviors, such as agitation and aggression to better deal
with it,
6
The duration of the TEP programme for each participant was 21 days maximum, after the
first meeting with the doctor. This began with a preliminary evaluation interview, the initial
shared educative assessment, devoted to the explanation of the programme to the family
carers, for pinpointing their needs, then for their orientation towards the different TEP
programme sessions, according to the needs identified. The support session finished up with
t
ip
Three workshop sessions were proposed: one for information on the illness of the
cr
with the behavioural fits of the relative (Know-what-to-do session) and a session for
us
improving knowledge - and one of the ways of regulating the emotions experienced, faced
with the relative’s difficulty (Know-how-to-be session). The general aim of the Know-how
an
session was to give information about the illness, going on what the carers of the patient with
MNC-D had experienced (“I have been living with this disease for years, but what is it?”). It
M
entailed identifying, understanding and adopting general knowledge of MNC-D and linking it
ed
situations. The general aim of the Know-what-to-do session was to help the carers to deal
ce
with behavioural disorders, by identifying their own attitudes and widening their range of
Ac
reactions (“You’re getting angry. You make me angry. I’m getting angry. We’re getting
the typical patient’s day, with a special focus on behavioural disorders, 2) Identification of
attitudes and reactions to behavioural disorders, and their effects, 3) Think to new attitudes to
cope with these disorders, 4) Summary and identification of the existing resources and
7
MNC-D and identifying the main difficulties the carers had dealing with them. Most
importantly, a typical day in the life of a MNC-D patient was presented to them, in order to
facilitate the identification of the disorders and encourage a thought process on the attitudes
and reactions for them to have, in order to deal with them, according to the effects they had.
The general aim of the Know how-to-be session was to assist the carers of MNC-D patients in
identifying their emotions and attitudes, both positive and negative (“What to do with these
t
ip
emotions?”). It was conceived with reference to Profile of Emotional Competence (Brasseur,
Grégoire, Bourdu, & Mikolajczak, 2013), that is delineated in five successive processes: the
cr
identification, comprehension, expression, regulation and use of emotions. It consisted of
us
four sequences of learning activities: 1) Identification of the resources and strategies
necessary to positive achieve a goal in day care, 2) Identification of negative emotions and of
an
possible solutions to make it less vivid, 3) Identification of positive emotions and of possible
solutions to make it more vivid, 4) Identification of strategies to cope with negative emotions
M
and classification of these strategies according to their efficiency. The aim was to encourage
ed
the carers to determine their own resources and limits and to elaborate strategies of attitude-
Each workshop lasted 90 minutes, was made up of at least six carers in order to
favour exchanges (Selwood, Johnston, Katona, Lyketsos, & Livingston, 2007), with a
ce
maximum of two carers for each hospitalised patient at the Cognitive Behaviour Therapy
Ac
Unit and was monitored by a group leader and an observer. To foster a gradual development
of competencies, the carers could not participate in the Know-how-to-be workshop without
having been involved beforehand in the Know-what-to-do workshop, and for to be in this
Methodology of the assessment of the participants. All the questionnaires were filled in
before the initial shared group programme and after the final group programme assessment,
8
with the aim to assessing the effects of the intervention. The evaluation was defined with
reference to the Pearlin et al. (1990) carers’ stress model, which proposes that the effect of
by functional and emotional strategies. The emotional strategies were measured with the aid
of refocus on planning items (thinking about what steps to take and how to handle the
negative event), positive reappraisal (thoughts of creating a positive meaning to the event in
t
ip
terms of personal growth) and self-blame (thoughts of putting the blame for what you have
experienced on yourself) from the Cognitive Emotion Regulation Questionnaire (Garnefski &
cr
Kraaij, 2007). This questionnaire measures the capacity of dealing with negative or
us
unpleasant events and the cognitive coping strategies. The non-adaptative mediators of
dysfunctional beliefs concerning care were assessed by means of the Dysfunctional Thoughts
an
about Caregiving Questionnaire scale (Losada et al., 2010), 16 items for assessing
caregivers’ ideas and attitudes that influence their reactions in stressful situations (perception
M
of sole responsibility and perfectionism). The mediators of the knowledge of the illness,
ed
behaviour disorders and emotional management, with reference to the Pearlin model (1990),
conceived specially for the study. Each level of need (need to know how, need how to do,
need how to be and other needs) was determined by the total number of reported knowledge
ce
which were lacking about the disease of their relative (neurological determination, cognitive
Ac
disorders, evolving mode, etc.), about how to cope with symptoms (communication,
behaviors, etc.), about how to cope with his/her own stress, sadness or anxiety, and about the
socio-economic context of the neurological pathology. The responsibility felt was measured
by means of the 22-item Burden Inventory of Zarit (Zarit, Orr, & Zarit, 1985), the most
widely used tool for measuring the level of subjective burden (personal strain and role strain)
among caregivers consisting. For each item, the carer is to indicate how often he/she feels as
9
described (“do you feel that your relative ask for more help than he or she needs?” etc.).
Hébert, Bravo, and Préville (2000) suggested that a score of 21 to 40 represents a mild to
moderate burden, that a score of 41 to 60 represents a moderate to severe burden, and a score
above 60 indicate a severe burden. The consequences on anxiety and depression were
evaluated thanks to the Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale (Zigmond, & Snaith, 1983), a
14-item screening scale developed to indicate the possible presence of anxiety and depressive
t
ip
states, which has found to be valid in general setting. For each item, the respondent are to
indicate how often he/she experiences, or how important are positive feelings such as “I still
cr
enjoy the things I used to enjoy” and negative ones such as “I feel restless as I have to be on
us
the move”. To rate the two subscales (anxiety and depression), the authors proposed the
following thresholds: from 8 to 10, a disorder is suspected, and from 11 to 21, a disorder may
an
be effective.
Statistical analyses. Statistical analyses were carried out using IBM SPSS Statistics
M
23 Software (SPSS Inc., Chicago, IL, USA). Comparisons between the initial and follow-up
ed
time for carers’ mental health, beliefs, strategies and needs were made using the rank tests of
Results
ce
Before the intervention, the average levels of anxiety were situated above
Ac
pathological threshold. The average levels of depression were just below disorders threshold.
As far as the average burden level was concerned, it was moderate, with a mean score of 41.
The most important strategies were adaptatvive ones, refocus on planning and then positive
re-evaluation, be it before or after the intervention. Rates of use of dysfunctional belief were
similar across the categories of exclusive responsibility and perfectionism. Although anxiety,
burden, and depression all decreased at the end of the TEP, only the decrease in anxiety
10
among caregivers was statistically significant. Use of adaptive and non-adaptive strategies
did not change significantly after participation in the TEP. All the mediatory characteristics
and consequences for the health of the carers before the initial shared educative assessment
Table 2.
t
ip
Only one significant effect was registered on anxiety (Z= -2.50; p < 0.05). On the
cr
other hand, no significant differences appeared concerning depression (Z = -1.64.64; NS),
us
burden (Z = -1.41; NS), dysfunctional believes of exclusive responsibility (Z = -1.69; NS)
and perfectionism (Z = -.98; NS) adaptative strategies of centring on the action (Z = -0.99;
an
NS) and of positive re-evaluation (Z = -1.84; NS), and non-adaptative self-blame strategy (Z
= -1.49; NS). The size of the effect on the level of anxiety, calculated by means of the
M
The carers’ needs before the TEP were high for the Know-how, Know what-to-do and
to a lesser degree for the Know how-to-be. On the other hand, they were mainly low for the
pt
know-how on the MNC-D of the relative and the strategies of adaption to the behavioural
disorders, but much less for the emotional regulation (table 3). Significant effects were
ce
registered on the Know-how needs (Z = -3.09, p < .01), on Know what-to-do needs (Z = -
Ac
2.98, p < .01), and on the Know how-to-be needs (Z = -2.55 p < .05), but not on the other
needs (Z = -.91, NS). The size of the effects were large for the level of Know-how needs (r =
.89), and for the level of Know what-to-do needs (r = .86). It was moderate for the Know
11
Table 3.
Discussion
The participants in our study, family carers of old people suffering from MNC-D showed
high anxiety disorders as measured by a mean score higher than 7 at the HAD-Anxiety
subscale, as well as moderate levels of burden as measured by a mean score higher than 40 at
t
ip
the Burden Inventory of Zarit. It turned out therefore that these persons needed effective
cr
support, taking into account the great constraints they already had. The results obtained
showed a significantly moderate decline in the level of anxiety after the TEP programme,
us
although the low sample number and the absence of group control do not enable the
effectiveness of the TEP programme to be confirmed. The TEP may have a rapid impact on
an
generalized anxiety and panic (measured by the HAD-Anxiety subscale), rather than
cope with the future. However, the initial depression level was low, which could also explain
ed
that we observed non effect on it. Even if at the end of the TEP programme its level has
declined under the moderate threshold, no effect appeared for the burden level, corroborating
pt
for carers (Cooke, McNally, Mulligan, Harrison, & Newman, 2001; Schoenmakers, Buntinx,
ce
& DeLepeleire, 2010), although it is the most widely used measure for the negative
Ac
consequences experienced by caregivers. The Zarit Burden Interview often lacks, indeed,
sensitivity for detecting changes. However, our results do not enable us to differentiate
between the influence of the specific characteristics of the carers, any more than that of the
initial evaluation, an indispensible pre-requisite to the TEP. It will be a question, at the next
stage, of controlling the specific effects in the participation of the different workshops and
12
The subsequent results put forward the question of the influence of TEP on
The decrease in level of anxiety that was observed could be a question of more positive re-
evaluation of real-life situations during the period of care and a lesser feeling of exclusive
responsibility for the difficult moments during this caring period. It also seems that the effect
observed could be due to the solution of the adaptative strategy of positive re-evaluation.
t
ip
What is more, estimating the needs expressed by family carers seems to confirm also that the
TEP programme has been an effective answer to their expectations, the need for Know-how
cr
and Know what-to-do and, to a lesser degree, the Know how-to-be, considerably diminishing
us
therefore their treatment. It can be seen that the needs initially expressed by the participants
appeared to be satisfied at the end of the programme, this being a way to dissipate the usual
an
reticence that is specific to carers (Coudin, 2004). Furthermore, new needs appeared
simultaneously (mainly needs relating to technical and social support, professional assistance,
M
especially psychological) at the end of the programme, which must be addressed in new
ed
sessions. It is important to note that our sample comprised mainly women and adult children
of MNC-D patients. Some research even indicates that the individual character of the carers
pt
revealed a non-negligible influence on their stress level and its physical and mental
consequences. For example, partners said they felt more distress than adult children (Pinquart
ce
& Sörensen, 2003; Schoenmakers et al., 2010). They could feel more psychological distress
Ac
than their children as they are more emotionally connected to their partner than the adult
children are to their parent. Similarly, endorsing the values of familial obligation increases
appraising caregiving (Losada et al., 2010). These elements will have to be monitored in
future research studies. According to the hypothesis of Schulz and his colleagues (1995),
13
confirmed by Mui (1995), a depressive contagion effect could also exist: elderly parents,
For several years now, testing the effects of psycho-education interventions for
improving the well-being of carers have been rather disappointing (Acton & Kang, 2001;
Brodaty et al., 2003; Pinquart & Sörensen, 2006). The number of carers recruited in the
majority of studies is too low to detect any sizeable effect; this has been the case to in our
t
ip
research. Moreover, the heterogeneity of the samples, with very open eligibility criteria,
means that the participating carers are not all necessarily in difficulty (Cooke et al., 2001).
cr
The framework of the TEP (Lagger et al., 2008), aiming at offering targeted interventions
us
with strict criteria of non-eligibility, has enabled this slant to be avoided, but has strongly
curbed the number of potential participants. Again, although there is no consensus on this
an
point (Gallagher-Thompson & Coon, 2007), the limited number of sessions offered -
compared to other programmes - could partly explain the barely significant results obtained.
M
The brevity of these interventions would result in their content being often dense and the
ed
carers having too little time to digest what they had been taught (Vézina, Ducharme, &
Landreville, 2005). The TEP could thus offer an adapted and adaptable solution, according to
pt
the needs and constraints expressed, though the effects of which are still to be confirmed,
especially in the long term. Besides, to answer the diversity of the needs, the TEP
ce
programme should include more work sessions in the future. In order to confirm the
Ac
pertinence of the TEP programme, it will be also necessary to evaluate in greater detail its
implantation and the adhesion of the participants (Burgio et al., 2001; Selwood et al., 2007).
that the TEP programme - for family carers of patients suffering from MNC-D - developed at
the University Hospital of X, helped to diminish the needs expressed by participants and
participants’ anxiety, even if no differences in adaptive strategies were observed. The TEP,
14
by its multidisciplinary approach, considering the patient as the central actor in a therapeutic
process, seems therefore to present a strong potential for undertaking the treatment of family
Acknowledgements
t
We owe special thanks to Elodie Damier, Sandy Fourre, Gina Corte Franco, Virginie Garnier, Fanny
ip
Javet, Nicolas Jouanneaux, Anna Lantez, and Sophie Scavone, who have been involved in the TEP
cr
programme, and to Anna Tcharkassof, for providing the database Dynemo (https://dynemo.upmf-
us
grenoble.fr/), which was used to design the Know-how-to-be space.
an
References:
APA. (2014). Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders. DSMV® (American
M
Acton, G. J., & Kang, J. (2001). Interventions to reduce the burden of caregiving for an adult
Arai, Y., & Zarit, S. H. (2011). Exploring strategies to alleviate caregiver burden: Effects of
183-189.
Ac
Batt-Leiba, M. I., Hills, G. A., Johnsons, P. M., & Bloch, E. (1998). Implications of coping
17(3), 135–143.
15