Professional Documents
Culture Documents
net/publication/280638881
Serological diagnosis
CITATION READS
1 11,385
2 authors:
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Veerle Lejon on 19 August 2015.
Serological diagnosis
Veerle Lejon, Philippe Büscher
S
erological diagnosis of human African trypanosomiasis (HAT) can
be achieved by demonstrating the inflammatory responses, by specific
antibody detection or demonstration of parasite antigens in the
putative host. Serological diagnosis should be considered as indirect evidence
of trypanosomiasis, and should be followed by parasitological techniques to
confirm infection with Trypanosoma brucei.
fibrinogen, DNA, red blood cells, thymocyte antigens and central nervous
system components such as myelin, galactocerebrosides and neurofilament
[11-15]. Antibodies specific for other pathogens, such as T. gondii, S. stercoralis,
Epstein Barr Virus, cytomegalovirus, P. fieldi, P. brasiliana and B. burgdorferi
have been observed in patients with T.b. gambiense sleeping sickness [16-18]
and may constitute a considerable risk for misdiagnosis.
Body fluid
Test HAT type plain filter
serum plasma saliva CSF
blood paper
CATT gambiense x x x x
LATEX gambiense x x x x x
MOPATT rhodesiense x x x
Immuno-
gambiense + rhodesiense x x x x
fluorescence
ELISA gambiense + rhodesiense x x x x x
trypanolysis gambiense x x x
Table I - Overview of antibody detection test types and sample types suited for diagnosis of HAT.
1a - A negative (zone 1) and positive (zone 2) agglutination reaction occurring in CATT on whole blood.
1b - Negative (zones 3, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9), doubtful (zone 2) and positive reaction (zone 1, 4, 10)
in CATT on serum dilution 1:4.
In case of CATT whole blood positivity, plasma or serum dilutions are often
tested prior to parasitological examinations. Twofold dilutions of 1/4, 1/8, 1/16,
1/32 and 1/64 are prepared in CATT buffer. The CATT test is performed
in the same way, using 25 µl of dilution as sample. Only those subjects that
are CATT positive on serum dilution 1/4 or 1/8, depending on the national
control programme, will undergo parasitological examination, decreasing the
number of parasitological examinations and allowing a significant gain in time
and financial resources.
For screening individuals that cannot be reached by full mobile teams
during active case finding, the CATT can be performed on blood impregnated
filter papers [26, 27]. Constraints for widespread use of this “micro-CATT”
are its difficult reading and interpretation of the agglutination, due to the small
amounts of antigen and test sample used, and the rapid decrease in sensitivity
when filter papers are stored at ambient temperature [28]. An alternative
method, the macro-CATT, developed for testing blood impregnated filter
paper using the standard amount of antigen and a higher volume of eluate,
seems to perform better [29].
Performance of CATT may differ according to the geographical origin of
the patients (Table II).
[40-42]. False negative CATT results may also occur when testing undiluted
blood, or serum dilution <1/4. In such cases, the agglutination may be inhibited
by complement factors, a phenomenon called prozone. This problem can be
resolved by addition of EDTA in the dilution buffer [35, 43, 44].
Despite a specificity of around 95%, the positive predictive value of the
CATT-wb remains limited because the test is used for mass screening in
populations where the prevalence of HAT is low (<2%) [28, 30-36, 38, 39]. False
positive results can occur in patients with malaria and other parasitic diseases
such as transient infection by non-human trypanosomes. The specificity of the
CATT is further improved when performed on serum diluted 1/4 or higher
[32, 33, 38, 39].
The occurrence of CATT seropositives (serum dilution 1/4 or higher) that
cannot be confirmed parasitologically remains a matter of concern. One option
is increasing the sensitivity of parasite detection by examining serological
suspects at regular intervals [45]. Unfortunately, the adherence to follow-up
visits is usually low and the efficiency of this strategy is poor [46]. Another
option is, based on CATT end-titer, to determine a subgroup of serologically
suspected individuals at high risk of being infected and to treat them. This
approach was successfully tested in Angola and Sudan [45, 46]. Based on these
findings, treatment for all serological suspect individuals with a CATT end
titer ³ 1:16 has been proposed when the prevalence of HAT is sufficiently high
(>1%), when access to care is poor, and when availability of parasitological
diagnosis is limited.
Besides the occurrence of non-confirmed seropositives, CATT has some
minor practical inconveniences. The reagents should be kept at 4°C for long
term storage, requiring a cold chain. Vials contain 50 test doses, but once opened
and reconstituted, the reagents can be used only during 1 week when stored
between +2°C and +8°C, or up to 8 hours at 37°C. This limits the use of CATT
in health centers visited by very low number of HAT patients. Development of
an alternative test format containing less doses/vial is ongoing. However, due
to its simplicity, reliability, and low cost, CATT is used by almost all control
programs for screening for T.b. gambiense infection in the population at risk.
LATEX/T.b. gambiense
similar rotator (Fig. 2). Again field kits containing the reagent, control sera
and small equipment to perform the test are available from the Institute of
Tropical Medicine at a price of 0.5 €/test (price October 2012, production@
itg.be, TT&P, Institute of Tropical Medicine, Nationalestraat 155, B-2000
Antwerpen, Belgium, +32 3 247 6368).
LATEX/T.b. gambiense can be performed on undiluted blood, diluted
blood, serum, filter paper eluates and cerebrospinal fluid. When compared to
the CATT, the LATEX/T. b. gambiense showed a higher specificity (96-100%)
but a lower or similar sensitivity (71-100%) in recent field studies (Table III)
[28, 34, 36, 44]. The combination of three purified variable surface antigens
however results in high sensitivity e.g. in regions (for example Nigeria) where
CATT/T.b. gambiense fails [47].
Inconveniences are similar to the CATT. The reagents should be kept at
4°C for long term storage and vials also contain 50 test doses. Once opened
and reconstituted, the reagents can be used only during a limited time period,
or should be frozen for prolonged storage. Since LATEX/T.b. gambiense is
slightly more complicate to perform in the field than CATT and has similar
performance, its use is not especially promoted, unless in areas with low CATT
sensitivity.
Research to replace the purified native antigens by recombinant antigens or
synthetic peptides and to simplify the test format is ongoing.
Table III - Performance expressed as percent sensitivity (sens) and specificy (spec) of different
LATEX/T.b. gambiense test versions (LATEX-WB: LATEX on whole blood, LATEX-b: LATEX on
blood dilution, LATEX-s: LATEX on serum dilution, LATEX-FP: LATEX on filter paper eluate)
according to different authors.
Immunofluorescence assays
Immunofluorescence assays have been used with success for T.b. gambiense
sleeping sickness control in Equatorial Guinea [51] and in Gabon [52].
Immune fluorescence can be applied on serum, on filter paper eluates and on
cerebrospinal fluid [3, 20, 53, 54].
For performing the test, slides are coated with whole trypanosomes. A
drop of diluted test sample (serum dilution 1:100-200) is allowed to react
for 30 minutes, remnants are washed off with PBS. Following a 30 minutes
incubation with FITC conjugated anti-human IgG antibodies, slides are
washed again and mounted with glycerol-PBS and a cover slip. Reading is
done under a fluorescence microscope (40x10).
The availability of standardized and stabilized antigen for T.b. gambiense at low
cost has greatly improved the reliability of the test [39]. This antigen is available
from the Institute of Tropical Medicine, Antwerp at a price of 20 €/250 doses
(price October 2012, production@itg.be, TT&P, Institute of Tropical Medicine,
Nationalestraat 155, B-2000 Antwerpen, Belgium, +32 3 247 6368).
For testing of serum, it is important to use strictly IgG specific fluorescent
conjugates thus avoiding cross-reactive IgM. Research is still needed to
identify better antigens for T.b. rhodesiense sleeping sickness.
Depending on the antigen used, test sensitivity on serum has been described
to be 75-95% for T.b. gambiense [44, 55, 56] and 71-92% for T.b. rhodesiense [3,
51, 57]. Specificity is >90% [55].
Immunofluorescence is cheap and reagents are relatively stable at 4°C,
but an immunofluorescence microscope and electricity are necessary. It is
therefore especially suited for surveillance and remote diagnosis. At present
immunofluorescence is mainly applied for serodiagnosis of T.b. rhodesiense.
ELISA
Numerous ELISA tests for sleeping sickness have been described [58-64].
powder) before incubation with the sample dilution. The plate is washed, and
an anti-human IgG enzyme conjugate is added. After a second wash, the
substrate solution is applied. A color reaction is observed in case of presence of
trypanosome specific antibodies.
Serum, filter paper eluates, saliva and CSF can be tested with strict
standardization and quantification. Furthermore, it is possible to study
different immunoglobulin classes and isotypes [63]. There is a tendency to
use purified antigens instead of crude trypanosome lysates but investigations
should continue into the use of recombinant or synthetic peptides. Important
also is the incorporation of an antigen negative control well for each individual
sample, as trypanosomiasis sera tend to stick to the plates.
Although different test protocols have been used, the sensitivity of ELISA
is described to be 95-100% [58, 60-62, 64] in combination with a specificity
of 97-100% [58, 60-62, 64].
As for immunofluorescence, the need for sophisticated equipment and large
volumes of pure water, remain a serious drawback for widespread application
of the test. Due to its high sensitivity and specificity, ELISA is especially suited
to perform large scale surveys and for remote diagnosis.
Immune Trypanolysis
This test for antibody detection makes use of live bloodstream trypanosomes
and is restricted to laboratories which have facilities to maintain cloned
populations. The test is based on recognition of the variable epitopes on the
surface of the trypanosomes by the corresponding antibodies resulting in
complement mediated lysis. The test is highly specific and therefore mainly
used as the reference test for evaluation of other antibody detection systems
and for research purposes [22].
The antigen detection tests developed so far [65-68] have not been
validated and cannot be recommended for diagnostic purposes. Reliable
antigen detection tests remain to be developed.
ELISA
CIATT
REFERENCES
[10] APTED FIC - Clinical manifestations and diagnosis of sleeping sickness. In: The
African Trypanosomiases. Mulligan HW, eds., George Allen and Unwin Ltd., London,
1970, 661-83.
[11] BOREHAM PFL, FACER CA - Autoimmunity in trypanosome infections. II.
Anti-fibrin/fibrinogen (anti-F) autoantibody in Trypanosoma (Trypanozoon) brucei
infections of the rabbit. Int. J. Parasitol. 1974; 4: 601-7.
[12] KOBAYAKAWA T, LOUIS J, IZUI S, LAMBERT PH - Autoimmune response
to DNA, red blood cells, and thymocyte antigens in association with polyclonal
antibody synthesis during experimental African trypanosomiasis. J. Immunol. 1979;
122: 296-301.
[13] ASONGANYI T, LANDO G, NGU JL - Serum antibodies against human brain
myelin proteins in gambian trypanosomiasis. Ann. Soc. Belg. Méd. Trop. 1989; 69: 213-
21.
[14] AMEVIGBE MDD, JAUBERTEAU-MARCHAN MO, BOUTEILLE B, DOUA
F, BRETON JC, NICOLAS JA, DUMAS M - Human African trypanosomiasis:
presence of antibodies to galactocerebrosides. Am. J. Trop. Med. Hyg. 1992; 47: 652-
62.
[15] AYED Z, BRINDEL I, BOUTEILLE B, VAN MEIRVENNE N, DOUA
F, HOUINATO D, DUMAS M, JAUBERTEAU MO - Detection and
characterization of autoantibodies directed against neurofilament proteins in human
African trypanosomiasis. Am. J. Trop. Med. Hyg. 1997; 57: 1-6.
[16] BLANCHOT I, DABADIE A, TELL G, GUIGUEN C, FAUGERE B, PLAR-
PELL AM, ROUSSEY M - Accès fébriles à répétition chez un enfant africain:
difficultés diagnostiques d’une trypanosomiase en France. Pediatrie 1992; 47: 179-83.
[17] DAMIAN MS, DORNDORF W, BURKARDT H, SINGER I, LEINWEBER
B, SCHACHENMAYR W - Polyneuritis und Myositis bei Trypanosoma gambiense
Infektion. Dtsch. Med. Wochenschr. 1994; 119: 1690-3.
[18] SAHLAS DJ, MACLEAN JD, JANEVSKI J, DETSKY AS - Out of Africa. N.
Engl. J. Med. 2002; 347: 749-53.
[19] PAQUET C, ANCELLE T, GASTELLU-ETCHEGORRY M, CASTILLA
J, HARNDT I - Persistence of antibodies to Trypanosoma brucei gambiense after
treatment of human trypanosomiasis in Uganda. Lancet 1992; 340: 250.
[20] MIEZAN TW, DJE NN, DOUA F, BOA F - Trypanosomose humaine africaine
en Côte d’Ivoire: caractéristiques biologiques après traitement. A propos de 812 cas
traités dans le foyer de Daloa (Côte d’Ivoire). Bull. Soc. Pathol. Exot. Fil. 2002; 95:
362-5.
[21] WORLD HEALTH ORGANIZATION - Trypanosomiasis control manual.
African Medical and Research Foundation Nairobi, Kenya. Geneva 1983, 142 pages.
[22] VAN MEIRVENNE N - Biological diagnosis of human African trypanosomiasis.
In: Progress in human African trypanosomiasis, Sleeping Sickness. Dumas M, Bouteille
B, Buguet A, eds., Springer, Paris 1999, 235-52.
[23] BALASEGARAM M, CHAPPUIS F, KARUNAKARA U, PRIOTTO G, RUIZ
JA - Sleeping sickness. A practical manual for the treatment and control of human
African trypanosomiasis. Médecins sans Frontières 2004, 179 pages.
[24] LAVEISSIERE C, PENCHENIER L. Manuel de lutte contre la maladie du
sommeil. IRD Editions. Paris 2005, 366 pages.
[25] MAGNUS E, VERVOORT T, VAN MEIRVENNE N - A card-agglutination test
with stained trypanosomes (C.A.T.T.) for the serological diagnosis of T.b.gambiense
trypanosomiasis. Ann. Soc. Belg. Med. Trop. 1978; 58: 169-76.