You are on page 1of 7

LEARNING-BASED EDGE COMPUTING SERVICES

5G-Network-Enabled Smart Ambulance: Architecture, Application, and Evaluation


Yunkai Zhai, Xing Xu, Baozhan Chen, Huimin Lu, Yichuan Wang, Shuyang Li, Xiaobing Shi, Wenchao Wang, Lanlan Shang, and Jie Zhao

Abstract have applied wireless communication technology


to ambulance service [4, 5]. For instance, Rehman
As the fifth generation (5G) network comes et al. [5] propose a system model of an ambu-
to the fore, the realization of 5G-enabled service lance scenario where femto cellular base station
has attracted much attention from both health- and transceiver are deployed in an ambulance
care academics and practitioners. In particular, to transmit medical ultrasound video streaming
5G-enabled emergency ambulance service allows to a hospital‘s emergency department. The most
to connect a patient and an ambulance crew at recent study, conducted by Mukhopadhyay et
an accident scene or in transit with the awaiting al. [6], develops a wireless-communication-sys-
emergency department team at the destination tem-based medical transit service in which real-
hospital seamlessly so as to improve the rescue time patient vitals data can be transferred to a
rate of patients. However, the application of the doctor at the destination hospital though a smart-
5G network in ambulance service currently lacks phone application. These systems have been test-
a reliable solution and simulation testing of per- ed or simulated under various network conditions
formance in the existing literature. To achieve this such as second generation (2G), 3G, 4G, and
end, the primary aim of this study is to propose fiber to the home (FTTH).
a 5G-enabled smart ambulance service and then Nevertheless, the ambulance service with tradi-
test the quality of service of the proposed solution tional wireless communication technologies needs
in experimental settings. We also consider emer- to overcome several technological challenges.
gency scenarios to investigate the task completion First, wireless communication capability may be
and accuracy of 5G-enabled smart ambulance, limited due to high mobility of the ambulance.
and to verify the superiority of our proposed solu- Some advanced wireless communication such
tion. Our study explores the value of a 5G-en- as FTTH is only being deployed in some urban
abled smart ambulance and provides practical areas of the country and is mostly being used for
insights for 5G network construction, business commercial purposes. 4G emergency services in
development, and network optimization of smart the United Kingdom, for example, face significant
ambulance service. delays due to inefficiency in terrestrial trunked
radio (TETRA) network technology and inability to
Introduction integrate delivery partners and other contractors
As the demand for ambulance service increases, according to the National Audit Office‘s (NAO)
many hospitals are struggling to meet response report [7].
time targets. In the United Kingdom, approximate- Second, by using current wireless communi-
ly 500,000 ambulance hours were lost due to cation technologies, it is difficult to provide reli-
both hospital transfer and post-transfer prepara- able and high-quality communication capability
tion of ambulances in 2016 according to an NHS for ambulance service. Clearly, a real-time video
ambulance service report [1]. Surprisingly, only 58 streaming system deployed in an ambulance
percent of hospital transfers meet the expectation requires high-speed data and high-resolution
of transferring a patient from an ambulance to image/video transmission. In some cases, limited
an emergency department. In China, cities like and unstable wireless communication may not
Shanghai are suffering from a shortage of ambu- enable awaiting emergency department profes-
lance crews, indicating that a ratio of ambulance sionals to remotely monitor patients with specific
per population far exceeds the national standard conditions such as skin pallor and patient demean-
of one ambulance per 50,000 residents [2]. Such or, which limits decision making of paramedics
delay and shortage not only cause patients emo- and may cause potential patient risks.
tional distress, but also put patients in life-threat- Third, 4G networks currently encounter many
ening conditions. challenges such as high cost of energy consump-
In order to tackle turnaround delays in ambu- tion, high demand for ubiquitous coverage, and
lance service, a great deal of research has prior- varied quality of service (QoS) and quality of
itized the deployment of ambulance crews and experience (QoE) requirements [8]. Ambulance
the transportation of ambulances [3]. However, service with 4G wireless communication tech-
optimizing the transfer time and process of ambu- nologies cannot deal with the rapid explosion of
lance services through using the traditional oper- wearable medical devices. This requires additional
ation approach is not sufficient. Thus, prior works technical investment with potentially higher net-
Yunkai Zhai and Huimin Lu are with Zhengzhou University, Qingdao University, and Kyushu Institute of Technology; Xing Xu is with the
University of Electronic Science and Technology of China; Yichuan Wang and Shuyang Li are with the University of Sheffield; Xiaobing Shi and
Digital Object Identifier: Wenchao Wang are with The First Affiliated Hospital of Zhengzhou University; Lanlan Shang is with Henan Mobile Communications Group Co., Ltd;
10.1109/MNET.011.2000014 Jie Zhao is with the National Telemedicine Center of China.

190 0890-8044/21/$25.00 © 2021 IEEE IEEE Network • January/February 2021

Authorized licensed use limited to: TKR Educational Society. Downloaded on November 22,2023 at 18:01:20 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
LU_LAYOUT.indd 190 2/1/21 7:58 PM
Generations 1G 2G 3G 4G 5G and beyond

Year 1980s 1990s 1998–2007 2008–2019 2019–2020

Digital signals • Voice and text • Completely IP-based • Low-latency communication


Analog signals
Key features for voice and • Wireless mobile • Speed up to hundreds • Ubiquitous connectivity
for voice
text • Internet access of megabytes • High-speed gigabit connection

Data rate 1.9 kb/s 14.4 kb/s 2 Mb/s 200 Mb/s Up to 10–20 Gb/s

Improved network (5G Core) as


Core
PSTN PSTN Packet network Internet an anchor point for multi-access
network
technologies
TABLE 1. Evolution of network communication.
working flexibility and transmission performance of exchange. Since then, network communica-
to make it suited for its purpose. tion has played a critical role in our society and
As the current wireless communication tech- experienced dramatic evolution, as presented
nologies are not sufficient to overcome the lim- in Table 1. Compared to previous generations
itations and challenges, more advanced solutions of network technology, 5G features increased
should be embedded into ambulance service. As capacity, reliability, coverage, connection densi-
the 5G network comes to the fore, the realization ty, and energy efficiency while reducing latency
of 5G-enabled service has the potential to bring [10, 11] . Low-latency communication, ubiqui-
tremendous benefits to individuals, organizations, tous connectivity, and high-speed gigabit con-
and society as a whole [9]. In particular, the 5G nection represent the most important features
network enables ambulances to connect a patient for supporting real-time content delivery and
who wears emergency medical equipment and user interaction [12–14]. These features also pro-
wearable devices to an awaiting emergency depart- vide smart devices with seamless mutual interac-
ment. Patient data starts to be collected at the inci- tion and data sharing without requirements of
dent scene and is continuously sent back to the human assistance, and facilitate critical services
destination emergency department while a patient around Internet of Things (IoT) applications such
is in transit. This allows the emergency department as factory automation, intelligent transportation
team to provide emergency treatment in a remote systems, virtual reality, augmented reality, and
and immediate manner and offer ambulance para- smart healthcare [12].
medics more intelligent decision support in order With the rapid adoption of the 5G network,
to stabilize a patient. However, there is a lack of some major deficiencies in the healthcare system
research focusing on developing medical emergen- can be revamped and addressed. First, commu-
cy service with the 5G network and examining its nication and access to healthcare resources in
performance in different first aid scenarios. There- the current system are problematic due to limited
fore, the primary aim of this study is to propose a bandwidth of 4G [15]. As an example, patients
5G-enabled smart ambulance service and test its have to physically visit the hospital for medical
performance in experimental settings. consultation, and healthcare facilities or services
In achieving this aim, the main contributions of are not equally accessible, which cause inconve-
this study are three-fold: nience for patients. The latest wireless technology
• We propose a system architecture for the (i.e., 5G core network) supports the applications
5G-enabled smart ambulance service. of telemedicine such as tele-surgery, tele-diagno-
• As the application of 5G in ambulance ser- sis, and tele-rehabilitation, which enables patients
vice lacks a reliable simulation, we test the to remotely access medical resources. Such wire-
QoS of 5G-enabled smart ambulance in less connectivity can advance telemedicine and
experimental settings. the provision of expert-based care.
• We consider an emergency scenario (i.e., Second, most medical data generated from
patients in transit at the speed of 30 km/h equipment and stored in medical information
and sending 4.5 GB of CT image data from systems and video communication systems has
an ambulance to a destination hospital ) to the feature of being highly heterogeneous. 5G
examine the task completion and accuracy enables the storage of data in the distributed
of 5G-enabled smart ambulance, and to veri- database system through the adoption of edge
fy the superiority of our proposed solution. computing, cloud computing, distributed storage,
The article is organized as follows. We intro- and other technologies, and then filtering, clean-
duce the 5G network technology and its appli- ing, conversing, and integrating the data in order
cations to health care. The architecture of the to build a pre-hospital emergency data center.
5G-enabled smart ambulance is then proposed. Specifically, to solve the problem of unstructured
We verify the performance of the proposed data in a pre-hospital emergency system, data-
5G-enabled smart ambulance by simulation tests. bases and systems being adopted include the
Lastly, conclusions are drawn in the final section. NOSQL database for data storage, the Apache
Hadoop platform for heterogeneous data man-
5G Network and Its agement, MapReduce for operating tasks of data
analysis, and secured access for the centralized
Application to Health Care stored data, visual display, and emergency deci-
The evolution of the wireless network can be sion support. These technologies contribute to
traced back to 1970s when voice was com- standardize rules of data acquisition mode, trans-
municated and considered as the main traffic mission protocol, and storage so that the data can

IEEE Network • January/February 2021 191

Authorized licensed use limited to: TKR Educational Society. Downloaded on November 22,2023 at 18:01:20 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
LU_LAYOUT.indd 191 2/1/21 7:58 PM
while the remote video communication allows the
real-time picture transmission of audio and video
information from accident scene, ambulance,
command center, and hospital. Telemedicine med-
ical data exchange is interconnected with hospital
information systems (HISs), laboratory information
systems (LISs), geographic information systems
(GISs), picture archiving and communications sys-
tems (PACSs), and document management sys-
tems (DMSs), which enable doctors in hospital
emergency centers to browse patients’ historical
medical records, register first aid information, and
issue examination sheets. This would simplify the
medical treatment process and improve the effi-
ciency of patient treatment. The components of
5G-enabled smart ambulance are shown in Fig. 1.

5G communIcAtIon network lAyer


The ambulance planning encompasses decisions
to be made on the strategic, tactical, and oper-
ational levels [3]. In the current ambulance ser-
vice, significant challenges remain at each level.
FIGURE 1. The proposed architecture of 5G-enabled smart ambulance. At the strategic level, selecting locations of ambu-
lance-based stations is generally determined for
a considerable time. At the tactical level, the
be converted and packaged for sharing among deployment of ambulances and crews at the base
the heterogeneous systems. stations is inefficient and idle. At the operational
Furthermore, the current healthcare system level, real-time dispatching of ambulances to inci-
is not patient-centric or customized to personal dents suffers from a lack of reliable and high-qual-
requirements. Tailoring treatments on the basis ity wireless communication.
of individual medical profile and history is difficult Our proposed 5G communication network
and costly [15]. The 5G network allows wearable attempts to fuel the next leap in shortening
devices to be attached to the core network and response and transfer times. Based on the wide
transmit data through sensors in a real-time man- range of scenarios that may occur in the acci-
ner, which sustains crucial medical information dent scene, mobile first aid, command center,
and has the potential to achieve personalized and medical emergency treatment, the hard-
treatments. In particular, a 5G medical custom- ware equipment such as mobile edge comput-
ized network utilizes technologies such as MEC ing (MEC), baseband units (BBUs), customer
and network slicing and thus is compatible with premises equipment (CPE), and user plane func-
VPN, Internet, cellular networks, and satellite. tion (UPF) gateway are deployed by using 5G
In its deployment, exclusive access could be fusion network characteristics, and the compati-
designed for hospital and inter-hospital business, ble fusion test medical private network of wired,
as the fixed location of medical services, long- wireless, and cellular networks that is built on the
term frequent existence, large business flow, and standalone (SA) architecture. Bearing the diversi-
high security and stability requirements require a fied business needs of vehicle positioning, audio
dedicated bandwidth-guaranteed line that is not and video interaction, medical data information
occupied by other business. sharing, medical resource scheduling, remote
Additionally, 5G enables better data analy- treatment guidance, and so on in the process of
sis, which can be used to assist decision making ambulance service, it provides a reliable network
for smart ambulance. With real-time interaction support for the deep integration of data, resourc-
and the sharing of heterogeneous information es, and services in the ambulance system and the
such as geographical location, patients’ medical development of multi-party collaborative work.
records, medical examination, and medical imag- The 5G network meets the demand of band-
es in pre-hospital emergency service, 5G assists width, delay, and other network performance
specialists at the hospital in obtaining information elements for the application of the pre-hospital
regarding pre-hospital first aid location, real-time emergency system. The main advantages are
video, and medical condition and transmission, reflected in the many aspects. First, accurate and
which therefore makes better decisions before timely access to geographical location, and real-
the patient entering hospital. time positioning of vehicles can automatically pro-
vide accurate real-time spatial location, according
proposed ArcHItecture to the scheduling information of the command
The architectural components of 5G-enabled center to avoid traffic congestion, greatly short-
smart ambulance proposed in this article includes: en the scheduling time. Second, virtual reality
• 5G communication network (VR) glasses are used at the scene of the acci-
• Remote video communication dent. The doctors at the destination hospital are
• Telemedicine medical data exchange allowed to grasp real-time status of patients and
The 5G communication network supports the accident scenes through a panoramic perspec-
access of vehicle-mounted positioning terminal, tive. Third, real-time vital signs data such as patient
video communication equipment, and multi-mon- blood pressure, blood sugar, blood gas, and other
itor acquisition equipment in the ambulance, patient medical records data information are col-

192 IEEE Network • January/February 2021

Authorized licensed use limited to: TKR Educational Society. Downloaded on November 22,2023 at 18:01:20 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
LU_LAYOUT.indd 192 2/1/21 7:58 PM
lected through onboard medical equipment and
then delivered to the doctor at the destination The main advantages of using the remote video communication are through the VR glasses or the video
hospital so as to provide real-time guidance and terminal in the ambulance and real-time tracking of patients in the ambulance treatment, and the
treatment to the patient.
remote video communication can initiate remote consultation while a patient is in transit. It is conve-
The Remote Video Communication Layer nient for hospitals to make timely rescue preparations and guide the treatment.
Through the application of multimedia processing
technology, and audio and video interactive tech-
nology, hospital doctors can, through VR glasses and ambulance back to the patient signs infor-
or video terminal, grasp in real time the condi- mation, according to the patient’s condition, to
tion of patients in transit. Emergency and critical develop a pre-hospital treatment program. Finally,
patients can be the first to get expert rescue guid- this system could obtain the information from the
ance to improve the rescue quality and efficiency first aid database and first aid decision model. This
of ambulance doctors, and minimize rescue time, allows the command center to dispatch the cor-
truly achieving seamless connection before and responding medical staff and vehicles, optimize
in the hospital for emergency patients to get bet- the rescue route, and coordinate pre-hospital first
ter treatment; further improve the success rate of aid tasks.
emergency and critical patients rescue; and build
a more convenient platform. The main advantag- Test and Simulation
es of using the remote video communication are Research on 5G networks mainly focuses on
through the VR glasses or the video terminal in developing 5G-enabled collaborative models and
the ambulance, real-time tracking of patients in exploring their service functions and applications.
the ambulance treatment, and the remote video 5G network quality and data transmission qual-
communication initiating remote consultation ity for 5G service have not been tested, and its
while a patient is in transit. It is convenient for performance has not been compared to the 4G
hospitals to make timely rescue preparations and network yet. As the proposed 5G-enabled smart
guide the treatment. ambulance solution needs to meet the require-
ments of medical data collection, medical images
Telemedicine Medical Data Exchange Layer transmission, and medical information sharing in
Telemedicine medical data exchange utilizes real time, we aim to test the actual performance
the identity index and keyword identification of 5G network from the QoS perspective. Specif-
approaches to solve the inefficient system inte- ically, we tested the network carrying capacity of
gration issues. This layer allows a user to capture, medical data, cross-area network jitter, and net-
store, and process the patient data in the HIS, LIS, work bandwidth in a real-time transmission setting
PACS, hospital resource information database, by comparing the conditions of 4G to those of 5G
and geographical resource information database. under two scenarios. The first scenario was set up
This would also support the online input of past to test the network carrying capacity and network
diagnosis and treatment information, patient vital jitter when the remote video consultation along
signs data, rescue on-site video information, and with medical data was uploaded and downloaded
rescue information, and achieve real-time data under the condition where the ambulance was at
exchange and sharing among different healthcare the speed of 30 km/h. In the second scenario, the
systems. uploading process of large volume medical data
In addition, the telemedicine medical data was tested by a 4.5 GB CT image sent from the
exchange supports the functions of real-time ambulance to the awaiting emergency depart-
acquisition of patients’ vital signs data, online ment team at the destination hospital.
transmission of medical images and video on-site As part of this study, we built a test platform
pictures, and online storage of patients’ medical of a 5G-enabled smart ambulance in the National
records information, and provides medical data Engineering Laboratory of Internet Medical Sys-
support for the multi-linkage of doctors, hospitals, tem and Application of the First Affiliated Hospital
and command centers at the emergency scene of Zhengzhou University. We then performed the
(including ambulances). simulation test of QoS for the 5G-enabled smart
The telemedicine medical data exchange ambulance. The test platform consists of an intelli-
brings benefits to the 5G-enabled smart ambu- gent mobile terminal module, a 5G network trans-
lance in many aspects. First, doctors at the des- mission module, an edge cloud computing node,
tination hospital enable the use of an expert and a cloud computing node, as shown in Fig. 2.
knowledge base and other intelligent systems to The intelligent mobile terminal module is com-
make preliminary diagnoses of patients, and car- posed of a medical data acquisition device, a
ries out pre-hospital monitoring and treatment doctor workstation, and a video communication
of patients. Second, real-time grasp of a patient’s terminal, wherein the vital signs information from
condition and arrival time could overcome the patients can be collected in real time. The med-
problem that the hospital emergency depart- ical staff can realize rapid response to rescue at
ment cannot acquire the treatment situation and any time and any place, participate in the whole
patient‘s condition information in real time. Third, process of pre-hospital first aid and in-hospital
through the image and video function cloud, first special treatment, and support real-time medical
aid can be automatically recorded online to gen- data acquisition and remote consultation video
erate electronic files. Patient personal information communication.
and medical record information can be auto- The 5G network transmission module includes
matically shared among institutions in real time. a 5G CPE signal transceiver and a 5G UPF gate-
Fourth, this system grants access to the hospital way service flow forwarding device, which real-
database combined with patient medical history izes the separation of the user plane and the

IEEE Network • January/February 2021 193

Authorized licensed use limited to: TKR Educational Society. Downloaded on November 22,2023 at 18:01:20 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
LU_LAYOUT.indd 193 2/1/21 7:58 PM
FIGURE 2. Experimental environment.

mation automatically distributes the mobile medi-


cal private network according to the service type
5G UPF gateway, and uploads to the appropriate
computing platform (i.e., local cloud or remote
cloud) in real time.
The proposed 5G-enabled smart ambulance
is deployed on the edge cloud computing node
FIGURE 3. 5G SA medical network. and the cloud computing node. This allows col-
lecting the transmission link state from the intel-
ligent terminal to the edge computing node and
control plane. The identification of the corre- from the edge computing node to the cloud
sponding ambulance service and the first aid assis- computing node. At the same time, the system
tant decision model are deployed on the edge can also collect vehicle location, patient medical
computer point and the cloud computing node, record information, and video call information,
which improves the service quality and medical and share medical information and available
treatment level of the remote first aid. The video computing resources between the ambulance
communication equipment synchronizes the pan- and the destination hospital. After the intelligent
oramic information in the ambulance and delivers terminal collects the vital signs signals and video
it to the hospital in real time. The collected infor- information of the patients, the intelligent termi-

FIGURE 4. 5G network monitoring software and traffic waveform.

194 IEEE Network • January/February 2021

Authorized licensed use limited to: TKR Educational Society. Downloaded on November 22,2023 at 18:01:20 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
LU_LAYOUT.indd 194 2/1/21 7:58 PM
nal is divided by the 5G network transmission
module and transmitted to different computing
nodes, and the processing results are fed back
to the ambulance and the destination hospital,
thereby supporting the data collection, transmis-
sion, processing, and display of the emergency
medical service.
Figure 3 reveals the 5G standalone medical
network. The network test equipment is connect-
ed to the vehicle-mounted 5G CPE through the
CTA6 gigabit network cable to collect the net-
work performance data when the smart ambu-
lance service occurs. The network bandwidth,
delay, jitter, and other specific conditions of the
service network can be intuitively seen through
the network test software. The dashboard of traf-
fic surveillance using 5G network monitoring soft- FIGURE 5. Comparison of network no-load rate.
ware is shown in Fig. 4.

result AnAlysIs
The results of comparison analysis are present-
ed in Fig. 3. The measured peak value of 5G
unloaded downlink rate is 18 times that of the
4G network, while the measured peak value of
5G unloaded uplink rate is 9 times that of the 4G
network (Fig. 5). In the first scenario, the average
downlink speed of 1080 p/30 Hz high-definition
video in the 5G network environment is 4.6 Mb/s.
Comparatively, the average downlink speed in 4G
network is 3.5 Mb/s with unstable network and
packet loss occurring during video call (Fig. 6).
In the second scenario, 5G network upload
rate is significantly higher than 4G. The upload
time is shortened by 33 percent compared to 4G
(Fig. 7). The average delay of 5G is 12.88 ms,
while the average delay of 4G is 76.85 ms which FIGURE 6. Comparison of downlink rate of remote video service.
is 6 times that of 5G (Fig. 8). Overall, with suffi-
cient 5G support, our smart ambulance solution
provides more efficient and stable medical data
delivery.

conclusIon
This article proposes an architecture for a smart
ambulance solution enabled by a 5G network,
with the aim of achieving response time targets
of medical emergency service. The 5G-enabled
smart ambulance consists of three key compo-
nents: 5G communication network, remote video,
and telemedicine medical data exchange. Given
the higher capacity of 5G, these three layers
are interconnected to optimize the transfer time
and process of ambulance services. Patient data
can be processed effectively to make timely res- FIGURE 7. Comparison of uplink rate of medical image.
cue preparations and guide the treatment while
patients are at the accident scene or in transit. We
also tested the proposed solution in experimental
settings, so the performance and quality of ambu-
lance service can be guaranteed. This is among
the first studies to examine the performance of
5G-enabled smart ambulance. To be specific, our
solution fully considers the emergency scenarios
to investigate network carrying capacity, cross-ar-
ea network jitter, and network bandwidth of
ambulance service. Our future will mainly focus
on improving quality of service of the proposed
architecture and solution.
reFerences
[1] N. A. Office, “NHS Ambulance Services,” 2017; https://
www.nao.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2017/01/NHSAmbu-
lance- Services.pdf. FIGURE 8. Comparison of uplink delay of medical image.

IEEE Network • January/February 2021 195

Authorized licensed use limited to: TKR Educational Society. Downloaded on November 22,2023 at 18:01:20 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
LU_LAYOUT.indd 195 2/1/21 7:58 PM
[2] A. Yan, “Ambulance Crew Shortage Costing Lives, Shanghai [8] H. Lu et al., “The Cognitive Internet of Vehicles for Auton-
Experience Shows,” 2014; https://www.scmp.com/news/ omous Driving,” IEEE Network, vol. 33, no. 3, May/June
china/article/1586875/ambulancecrew- shortage-cost- 2019, pp. 65–73.
ing-lives-shanghai-experience-shows [9] C. X. Wang et al., “Cellular Architecture and Key Technolo-
[3] T. C. V. Barneveld et al., “The Effect of Ambulance Reloca- gies for 5GWireless Communication Networks,” IEEE Com-
tions on the Performance of Ambulance Service Providers,” mun. Mag., vol. 52, no. 2, Feb. 2014, pp. 122–30.
Euro. J. Operational Research, vol. 252, no. 1, 2016, pp. [10] L. Bai et al., “Multi-Satellite Relay Transmission in 5G: Con-
257–69. cepts, Techniques, and Challenges,” IEEE Network, vol. 32,
[4] M. C. Batistatos, G. V. Tsoulos, and G. E. Athanasiadou, no. 5, Sept./Oct. 2018, pp. 38–44.
“Mobile Telemedicine for Moving Vehicle Scenarios: Wire- [11] S. Li, L. D. Xu, and S. Zhao, “5G Internet of Things: A Sur-
less Technology Options and Challenges,” J. Network and vey,” J. Industrial Info. Integration, vol. 10, 2018, pp. 1–9.
Computer Applications, vol. 35, no. 3, 2012, pp. 1140–50. [12] N. C. Luong et al., “Applications of Economic and Pric-
[5] I. U. Rehman, N. Y. Philip, and R. S. Istepanian, “Performance ing Models for Resource Management in 5G Wireless Net-
Analysis of Medical Video Streaming over 4G and Beyond works: A Survey,” IEEE Commun. Surveys & Tutorials, vol. 21,
Small Cells for Indoor and Moving Vehicle (Ambulance) no. 4, 2019, pp. 3298–3339.
Scenarios,” Proc. 2014 4th Int’l. Conf. Wireless Mobile Com- [13] M. Chen et al., “Data-Driven Computing and Caching in
mun. and Healthcare — Transforming Healthcare Through 5G Networks: Architecture and Delay Analysis,” IEEE Wire-
Innovations in Mobile and Wireless Technologies, 2014, pp. less Commun., vol. 25, no. 1, Feb. 2018, pp. 70-75.
211–16. [14] I. Parvez et al., “A Survey on Low Latency towards 5G:
[6] A. Mukhopadhyay et al., “A Cloud-Based Smartphone RAN, Core Network and Caching solutions,” IEEE Commun.
Solution for Transmitting Bio-Signals from an Emergency Surveys & Tutorials, vol. 20, no. 4, 2018, pp. 3098–3130.
Response Vehicle,” Int’l J. E-Health and Medical Commun., [15] S. Latif et al., “How 5G Wireless (and Concomitant Tech-
vol. 10, no. 3, 2019, pp. 22–38. nologies) Will Revolutionize Healthcare?” Future Internet,
[7] National Audit Office, “Progress Delivering the Emergency vol. 9, no. 4, 2017, pp. 93–93.
Services Network,” 2019; https://www.nao.org.uk/wp-con-
tent/uploads/2019/05/Progressdelivering-the-Emergen-
cy-Services-Network.pdf.

196 IEEE Network • January/February 2021

Authorized licensed use limited to: TKR Educational Society. Downloaded on November 22,2023 at 18:01:20 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
LU_LAYOUT.indd 196 2/1/21 7:58 PM

You might also like