Professional Documents
Culture Documents
net/publication/313843142
Internet use among secondary school students and its effects on their
learning
CITATIONS READS
26 65,127
3 authors:
Chang Zhu
Vrije Universiteit Brussel
281 PUBLICATIONS 6,452 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
All content following this page was uploaded by Chang Zhu on 12 March 2017.
Abstract
Internet represents the greatest collection of human knowledge and has enabled many communities in
the world to manage communication and solve problems faster. The Internet has made it possible for
students, teachers, and educational technologists, to communicate, create content, services,
applications and innovations for their staple endeavors. With the Internet access, a wide range of
ideas, teaching and learning resources, techniques and innovations have been widely shared. This
study explored internet use among secondary school students and its effects on their learning. Mixed
methods research with the descriptive design was employed and data were collected from 310
students using questionnaires, semi-interviews and observation. The results unveiled that majority of
students 170 (54.8%) had accessed to the internet through smartphones, internet cafes 100(32.3%)
personal computers,15(4.8%) via schools infrastructures, and homes 25(8.1%). Findings report that
although the internet uses for educational purposes had improved among secondary school students
most of them used the internet as a social media for chatting and socializing, watching movies and
listening to music. Wastage of time, delay on schoolwork submission, poor academic results and
school dodging were reported among effects associated with the internet uses among secondary
students. However, educational related websites widely used was the National Examination Council of
Tanzania (NECTA), e-SHULE, and e-School programme. The results of this study shed light on the
most effective use of the internet in the teaching-learning process among students on the proper use
of the internet.
Keywords: Internet use, secondary students, student learning, learning outcome, Tanzania.
1 INTRODUCTION
The Internet represents the greatest collection of human knowledge ever assembled and has been
widely used by students and their teachers for teaching and learning. As it has been pondered, the
internet has changed the way teacher teach and the way students learn and do school academic
work. However, the internet access and use among secondary school students contribute to their
academic work and improves their final grades. This study examined internet use among secondary
school students and its effects on their learning. In the context of this paper, the term learning was
used to answer the question as to what extent students learn when they use the internet. Students’
learning is based on their self-expression of what study materials they access, how they access them
and when they access study materials, and how they use the materials. This study aims to assess the
use of internet among secondary students and its effects on their learning. More specifically, the study
explores the access and use of internet among secondary school students; find out the types of
internet programmes that students access on the internet, explore the effects of the accessed internet
applications on students’ learning. This study is sought to answer the following research questions:
First, how are students knowledgeable about internet access and use? Second, what are the types of
internet programmes that students access on the internet? , and finally, what are the effects of the
accessed internet applications on students’ learning?
2380
educational problems and enhance students’ achievement. In Turkey, for example, most university
students at the graduate level (87.5%) use the internet (TUİK, 2009), while 82% of these cannot bear
the thought of daily life without access to the internet (Eğitişim Career Institute, 2010). The internet, in
particular, has provided people especially students with a foundation for meeting their information
needs (Christopher & Gorreti, 2012). Many private schools can boast of computer laboratories, but
only few can pride themselves on Internet access. The internet has come to befriend, dwell with, and
live beyond, both, the teacher and the student (ibid).
However, the use of the internet has been known to have a number of advantages as for example,
Oral (2004) as cited in Kutkun, (2011), maintain that providing information and communication
technologies for teaching-learning processes will have some advantages: students will play a more
active role, discussions of courses will contain more detail, students will become more independent,
communication between students and teachers will become level and direct, students will easily
process new student-based education material, student skills will increase, and the hierarchical
structure between teachers and students will be more flexible. It is also known that students will also
be able to access information pertaining to their courses and activities from different sources quickly
and without difficulty (Taşpınar and Gümüş, 2004), and will be able to evaluate these sources and
synthesize them.
In his study, Kutkun (2011) inform that female students use the internet in a more functional sense
than male students. Several studies reveal that students using ICT facilities mostly show higher
learning gains than those who do not use. For instance, Kulik’s (1994) study in the United States
showed that students who used computer tutorials in mathematics, natural science, and social science
scored significantly higher on test in these subjects. The findings also indicated that primary school
students who used the tutorial software in reading scored significantly higher on reading. In developing
countries, significant barriers have been identified often referred to as “the digital divide”-that limits the
ability of some countries to take advantage of technological developments. Access is chief among
them.
Similarly, apart from internet access been an obvious challenge in developing countries, initiatives
have been made to improve and reform education, challenges related to teacher preparation,
curriculum, pedagogy, and assessment associated with ICT and internet uses. For example, a newly
established Halotel mobile company under its corporate social responsibility project donated 19
computers connected to internet that are used by students to carry out their private studies (Mbashiru,
2016). The firm has pledged to connect 450 public schools to the internet. As of current Lugoba
secondary schools enjoy a computer lab connected with internet. However, the internet has many
advantages to students, teachers and other users as discussed by various scholars. But the question
remains, do our students utilize these advantages to their fullest or do they use the internet for matters
that are not really beneficial to them? This paper examines the use of internet among secondary
school students and its effects on their learning.
2381
Chen, 2014). That is, not all internet usage is of benefits to students and all people all the time, for
example, pornography use and excessive chat among secondary students has a relatively negative
effect on their academic success and life after schools.
According to both access to, and use of, the computer and the Internet are heavily stratified by
educational level, income, age, gender and minority status (Fuchs & Woessmann, 2004; Kuhlemeier &
Hemker, 2007). In a nutshell, the Internet is used in daily life in educational settings; as a result, its
usage among secondary school students should be used appropriately so as to yield academic
success. If secondary-education teachers are to tailor their instruction to the needs of all students,
they need to develop an understanding of the extent to which incoming students have access to and
make use of internet at home (Downes, 2002) and they need to familiarise themselves with the digital
skills students bring to the learning situation (Lauman, 2000; Leu, 2002).
2 METHODS
2.2 Participants
The subjects were 310 students from two secondary schools whereby 235 (75.8%) students were
directly recruited from schools and the remaining 75 (24.2%) students from internet cafes in Ilala
Municipal. Off these 150(48.4%) students were female and 160 (51.6%) students were male with the
average age ranging from 14 to 20. In order to obtain students from the two secondary schools under
study who visited the internet cafes who by researchers experience, seemed to be students. The
following questions were asked to students who visited internet cafes on their consent to participate in
the study (1) are you a secondary school students? (2) Which secondary schools do you belong? (3)
Which form (class) are you? These questions were asked to students before they start using the
internet. 170 (54.8%) students were in the third year (form 3) and 140 (45.2%) were in the fourth year
of their study (form 4). The students were taking both science and arts subjects.
2382
3 RESULTS
2383
Table 3 Students’ means of accessing the internet.
Table 3 presents results on how often students accessed the internet. The findings indicate that the
majority of students 100(32.3%) had access to the internet once a week, about 15(4.8%) accessed at
least once a month. Again, about 25(8.1%) accessed once a month, 90(29%) accessed at every time
and 80(25.8%) did access at every day. It was observed that a good number of students oscillating
from 50 to 100 access via internet cafes and school internet lab once a week. On the interview, those
with smartphones outnumbered those without smartphones. Surprisingly, some of the interviewed
students who were having personal laptop divulged that they had accessed the internet at least once a
month.
In connection, to access and use of Internet, students’ knowledge on information retrieval was
explored to gauge their techniques on the ways used to search learning materials on the internet. This
was done to find out the knowledge of students in using the internet. It was assumed that students
with good searching skills or proper knowledge of searching will spend a short time getting what they
want. Searching learning materials and other information on the internet could be boring and
frustrating when one does not know how to do it. Based on interviews, the findings indicated that most
students used Google and Mozilla search engines for searching anything on the internet. Surprisingly,
no student reported to use other specialized search engines such as Google Scholar, Yahoo Search,
AltaVista, or even the popular search engines like Bing, and Ask, InfoSpace, and info.com.
During the interview, one student had the following to share “frequently I search information through
Facebook, YouTube and blog browsing and opera mini browser”. That is, is indicated that majority of
students had little knowledge of searching materials on the internet as they mostly used the Google
and Mozilla engines while the majority and social networks like Facebook and YouTube. Another
student had the following to share “I used Facebook and WhatsApp to organize social issues with my
colleagues, it is easier for to share information with friends, however, to me YouTube has changed the
way I learn, and I get everything there”. Importantly, one student lamented that “we have a group
discussion on WhatsApp where we share our ideas on how to tackle difficulties issues pertaining to
our studies”. It was observed that most students normally use email for communication with their
teachers and parents if necessary. A student was noted saying “I do Skype with both students and
parents because our teachers won’t accept Skype way of communication and getting in touch with
course information”
2384
programmes. Findings from observations indicated that most of the observed students 170(54.8%)
accessed the programmes via internet cafes used the internet for entertainment and socializing
purposes such as chatting on Tweeter, Facebook and Instagram. During the interview students with
smartphones revealed that they used software applications like Imo app, and WhatsApp messenger
for downloading and uploading photos, videos, and audio, listening to music, searching for friends,
playing games and watching movies. Results also showed that students also used the internet as a
source of information 79(25.5%), for searching and watching sports news and features, listening to
religious songs, and watching a variety of news on internet televisions. Other students 61(19.7%)
used the internet for studying purposes such as solving difficult questions, searching lesson notes and
new ideas, asking and answering questions on the internet. Students who used the internet as the
study source reported that they learnt various subjects from the internet such as history, obtained
subject notes, got help through the internet, viewed photos and diagrams, read books, asked
questions and got answers for NECTA and other questions. Studies done in the United States among
middle and high school students also indicate that students use the internet for a variety of reasons
such as a medium to communicate, to find information, to have fun (Daniel, 2005), and that the
percentage of children specifically discussing schoolwork online outpaces the percentage that spends
time downloading music (Nagel, 2007).
However, when such students were asked to name the educational websites they visited, they only
mentioned a few websites such as the NECTA, dictionary.com, Wikipedia and www.history.com.
Interestingly, the NECTA website does not provide any study materials and is only used to display
various final examination results of past students. The findings further signposted that the websites
mostly visited by students by students included Facebook, Twitter, BBM, gameloft.com,
dictionary.com, WhatsApp messenger, ESKIMI, YouTube, and Netlog. Other websites visited were
DTV.com, livescore, Wikipedia, Barcelona.com, ITV.com e –mails such Gmail. The only educational
related website was that of NECTA. Judging from the nature of the websites visited, entertainment,
socialization and information based websites were the most visited types.
2385
slows or kills their thinking because they know they can easily get answers from the internet instead of
using their brains to think creatively and that they waste so much time chatting, face booking and
sending messages. Those who said no argued that the internet is full of useful information, so it is the
user who decides what to use. In an interview, students revealed that their teachers encourage then
using internet while at home for schoolwork and personal readings. Conversely, the internet provided
them with quick answers and solutions to various assignments and questions provided in class.
4 DISCUSSIONS
Based on the results, internet accessibilities among secondary schools is of paramount importance for
their academic success and daily undertaking in schools and their life after schools. Our study
contributes to the understanding of the effects of the internet access and uses among secondary
school students conducted in Ilala District of Dar es Salaam city in Tanzania. Findings suggest that
effects related to internet access and uses depend on other factors like parental guidance, school
management, behavioral issues and recruitments of students because some schools and internet
cafes have installed software that monitor internet uses among students. Internet uses among
secondary students prepare them for further studies in tertiary education where the internet use is
higher than secondary schools. As Brafi and Arthur (2011) found that about 92.9 % of the tertiary
students in their study knew how to use internet services while about 7.1% stated that they did not
know how to use the Internet. Also, a study by Kikwa (2010) found that 98% of the respondents used
the internet. However, in context, assessment of the use of internet among students showed that
students enjoy searching issues related to social affairs rather than educational purposes. This is
consistent to Mazzuki (2010) who established that only a few respondents were able to access the
internet for academic purposes. That is, the majority of respondents accessed internet for other issues
as reported on the findings of this study.
In addition, this study provides useful avenues on how to manage internet use among students in
secondary schools. As it has been known that managing students in secondary schools is an issue
which needs clear guidance policy, internalized individual student moral values and user-friendly
schools-rules. The observed restrictions on computer and internet services in schools were
appropriate only to some extent while the study recommends free access to the internet and technical
assistance to students and teachers. Installation of web management system could help students to
access educational programmes only while at schools rather than giving them restricted the time and
sometimes access to school internet lab were denied among students due to improper managerial
reasons. Schools management wanted to monitor the use of internet and assure them that the internet
is there for educational issues and not otherwise. An earlier study on internet access found that
students were found to access the internet from their homes and cyber cafes since they were denied
2386
access to their respective school (Christopher & Gorreti, 2012), however, most of the students in their
study used smartphones as alternatives to access the internet for educational activities. As a result,
students voted internet as most useful in their studying.
However, results also suggest that students’ ability to access educational resources on the internet
depends on their skills and knowledge to retrieve information. The ability of individual to retrieve
information helps to get the right information on time and use them wisely. In this regards, most of the
internet materials accessed by students reported to related with their social affairs like downloading
and listening to music. Educational programmes were retrieved only to a small amount and only when
students want to solve educational related problems. For example, Ojedukun (2001), as cited in Arthur
and Brafi (2011) found that 37.8% of the respondents used the email to communicate with friends and
relatives and 13.5% with students while 20.9% used it for entertainment and sports, 19.6% for news,
15.5% for academic materials and 15.5% non-use of the web. However, studies have shown that
Internet chat room were used by students for communication purposes (Mahumbwe, 2012). That is,
most students used the internet for socializing, entertainment purposes such as chatting, listening to
music, playing games, watching movies, uploading and downloading photos. Another activity include
chatting on the internet was the most, followed by watching movies, videos, and listening to music,
while studying or accessing learning materials was the last. Educational related materials which were
mainly visited by students participated in this study showed that students with mobile phones that can
access internet use them to retrieve subject core concepts and learning notes. This is in line with
(Katz, 2005) that student search for the definition of concepts and references; also, extract materials
relating to their study.
Learning in this paper has been conceived as is a term which includes all the processes and products
which describe the nature and extent of student’s learning (Child, 2004:360). Therefore, in the context
of this paper, the term learning was used to answer the question as to what extent students learn
when they use the internet. Although internet access and use by students in secondary schools is a
part of learning, it has been associated with some negative effects on students’ academic
achievements. Based on the findings internet use among secondary school students reported having
the following effects on their learning; waste of time while viewing non-academic programmes such as
listening to music, gaming, searching for friends on social media, chatting, watching movies and
downloading video and photos. A study of Colley and Maltby (2008) showed that the internet use
assisted them to make new friends or meet their study partner from other places, renewing old
friendships, accessing information and advice, studying online and negative aspects of the technology.
In another study, Brafi and Arthur (2011) showed that relatively greater number of the respondents
stated that the internet facility has led to improved communication with others while others mentioned
that it helped them upgrade their knowledge. Other respondents stated that the Internet has helped
them to improve their research skills and indicated that the Internet made their learning easier.
Kuhlemeier & Hemker (2007) found that home access to e-mail and the extent to which students use
the home computer for surfing, e-mailing, chatting and text processing accelerated students’ computer
skills and educational achievement. However, using the internet made students more active, develop
high interest, develop teamwork, ask questions and answer questions consistently during the lesson.
So far in Tanzania, only 17% of teachers in secondary schools received training on the use of the
internet (Kikwa, 2010). Apart from that, Mapunda (2004) found that teachers’ knowledge and levels of
access to the internet in Dar es Salaam was very low even though they knew the role it played in
enhancing learning. The findings from this study divulge that there is few computers lab connected to
the internet in most schools in Tanzania and students showed some demand on the internet. More
computers should be provided with internet access in the various secondary schools and be there a
significant improvement in internet speed to ensure fast and efficient use of internet services; internet
services must be affordable and that education on the use of the internet must be provided.
2387
has no significant relationship to student learning performance, professional Internet use has a
positive relationship to learning performance (Chen et al., 2014). It should not be left to the student’s
prudence alone to decide what to go for on the internet, but training to both teachers and students is
necessary to enhance the wisest use of the internet. The results of this study could have important
implications for the most effective use of the internet in the teaching-learning process if students were
to be educated on the proper use of the internet.
A curriculum on the subject of internet use could be created and integrated into school subjects or
taught separately as an extra curriculum (Tutkun, 2011). These implications are based on the findings
that the internet has effects on the outcome of students learning as implicated in other studies such as
those of Pelgrum, Brummelhuis, Collis, Plomp, Janssen Reinen (1997) cited in Pelgrum (2001). Again,
basing on the findings of the study, it is recommended that students be given proper knowledge on the
use of the internet for the greater good and not just chatting and gossiping. The government should
train teachers on the use of ICT, particularly the internet so that they may be competent to help
students utilize the internet for better use. The presence of better internet facilities at schools may help
to have time for teachers to guide and direct students on the good use of the internet as a teaching
and learning resource material.
REFERENCES
[1] Aboderin, O. S., Fadare, O. G., Kumuyi, G. J., & Lawal, O. O. (2011). Pedagogical appraisal of
internet and computer usage among secondary school teachers and students in Southwest Part
of Nigeria. World Journal of Young Researchers, 1(4), 54-9.
[2] Almasi, M. (2010). The effects of television viewing on children’s learning in Ilala District, Dar es
Salaam, Tanzania. Unpublished Masters of Arts in Applied Social Psychology. University of Dar
es Salaam. Tanzania.
[3] Brafi, P. O., & Arthur, C. (2011). Internet Use among Students in Tertiary Institutions in the
Sunyani Municipality, Ghana., pp 1-18.
[4] Bryman, A. (2001). Social research method. New York. Oxford University Research.
[5] Child, D. (2004). Psychology and the teacher. China: Midas Printing International Ltd.
[6] Christopher, O. K., & Maria- Gorretti, E. (2012). Availability and the use of computer and
internet by secondary school students in Benin City, Nigeria. International Journal of Library and
Information Science, 4(2), 16-23.
[7] Colley, A., & Maltby, J. (2008). Impact of the Internet on our lives: Male and female personal
perspectives. Computers in Human Behavior 24, 2005–2013.
[8] Daniel, A.J. (2005). An exploration of middle and high school students’ perceptions of deviant
behavior when using computers and the internet. The Journal of Technology Studies. 31(2), 70-
80.
[9] Davis, R. A. (2001). A cognitive-behavioral model of pathological Internet use. Computers in
Human Behavior, 17, 187–195.
[10] Downes, T. (2002). Children's and families' use of computers in Australian homes.
Contemporary Issues in Early Childhood, 3(2), 182–196.
[11] Farrel, G., & Isaac, S. (2007). Survey of ICT and education in Africa: A summary report based
on 53 countries surveys. Retrieved on 20 April 28, 2013, from http//:
www.infodev.org/en/Document.353.pdf.
[12] Fuchs, Th., & Woessmann, L. (2004).Computers and student learning: Bivariate and
multivariate evidence on the availability and use of computers at home and at school.
Mu¨nchen, Germany: Institute for Economic Research.
[13] Hans Kuhlemeier, H., & Hemker, B. (2008). The impact of computer use at home on students’
Internet skills. Computers & Education 49, 460–480.
[14] Household Budget Survey 2007 – Tanzania Mainland, (2009). Retrieved from http//:
www.nbs.go.tz/tnada/index.php/catalog/2, Issue No. 11.
2388
[15] Kandell, J. J. (1998). Internet addiction on campus: The vulnerability of college students.
CyberPsychology & Behavior, 1, 11–17.
[16] Kasumuni, L. (2012, January 03). Number of Tanzania internet users. Retrieved on 27 April
2013 from http://www.thecitizen.co.tz/business/13-local-business/18518-number-of-tanzania-
internet-users-is-5m.html
[17] Kikwa, H. C. (2010). The internet access and use from a gender perspective. A case of
Kinondoni and Bagamoyo Districts, Tanzania. Unpublished Masters of Arts and Information
Studies dissertation. University of Dar es salaam. Tanzania.
[18] Kozma, B. R. (n.d.). ICT and educational reform in developed and developing countries.
Retrieved on April 20, 2013, from http//:
schoolnet.org.za/CoL/ACE/.../core1b.ICT_and_Educational_Reform.pdf
[19] Kuhlemeier, H., & Hemker. B. (2007). The impact of computer use at home on students Internet
skills. Computers & Education, 49, 460–480.
[20] Lasswell, D. H. (1948). The structure and function of communication in society. Retrieved 24
November 2015 from http// HD Lasswell - The communication of ideas, 1948 - dhpescu.org/pdf.
[21] Lauman, D. J. (2000). Student home computer use: A review of the literature. Journal of
Research on Technology in Education, 33(2), 196–203.
[22] Leu, D. J. (2002). The new literacies: Research on reading instruction with the Internet and
other digital technologies. In S. J. Sameuls & A. Farstrup (Eds.), What Research has to say
about Reading Instruction (pp. 310–336). Newark, DE: International Reading Association.
[23] Machumu, H. J., & Kisanga, S. H. (2014). Quality assurance practices in higher education
institutions: Lesson from Africa, Journal of Education and Practice, 5 (16), 144-156.
[24] Mahumbwe, N. (2012). Application of internet as a resource material for teaching and learning
in Secondary schools in Dar es Salaam. Unpublished Masters of Education Science
Dissertation. University of Dar es Salaam. Tanzania.
[25] Mapunda, S. H. (2004). The use of internet by secondary schools teachers: A case of twelve
secondary schools in Dar es Salaam, Tanzania. Unpublished Masters of Arts (Information
Studies). University of Dar es salaam. Tanzania.
[26] Mazzuki, S. D. (2010). Assessment of the use of the internet and professional development of
mathematics teachers in Dar es Salaam City and Iramba District secondary schools, Tanzania.
Unpublished Masters of Education Science Dissertation. University of Dar es Salaam.
Tanzania.
[27] Miniwatts Marketing Group (2015) Internet World Stats (data of November 30, 2015) retrieved
on January 26, 2016, from http://www.internetworldstats.com/stats.htm
[28] Moeller, B. (1996). Learning from television. A research review CCT REPORTS.
[29] Nagel, D. (2007).Research: Students actually use the internet for education. Retrieved January
15, 2016, from https://thejournal.com/articles/2007/08/14/research-students-actually-use-the-
internet-for-education.aspx
[30] Odaci, H. (2011). Academic self-efficacy and academic procrastination as predictors of
problematic Internet use in university students. Computers & Education, 55, 1614–1617.
[31] Odaci, H., & Kalkan, M. (2010). Problematic Internet use, loneliness and dating anxiety among
young adult university students. Computers & Education, 55, 1091–1097.
[32] Pelgrum, W. J. (2001). Obstacles to the integration of ICT in education: results from a
Worldwide Educational Assessment. Computers & Education, 37 (2), 163-178.
[33] Tutkun, F. O. (2011). Internet access, use and sharing levels among students during the
teaching-learning process. The Turkish Online Journal of Educational Technology, 10 (3),152-
160.
[34] United Republic of Tanzania (URT). (2007). Information and communication technology (ICT)
policy for basic education. Dar es Salaam: Ministry of Education and Vocational Training.
2389
[35] United Republic of Tanzania (URT), (2014); Tanzania Education and Training Policy, Dar es
salaam Ministry of Education and Vocational Training.
[36] Widyanto, L., & Griffiths, M. (2006). ‘Internet addiction’: A critical review. International Journal of
Mental Health and Addiction, 4(1), 31–51.
[37] Young, K. S. (1996). Internet addiction: The emergence of a new clinical disorder.
CyberPsychology & Behavior, 3, 237–244.
[38] Young, K. S. (2004). Internet addiction: A new clinical phenomenon and its consequences.
American Behavioral Scientist, 48, 402–415.
2390