Uca Msa

1
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BANGALORE

(REGULAR SECOND APPEAL UNDER SECTION 100 OF THE CODE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE)
R.S.A No._____________ of 2018
IN THE COURT OF THE IVTH ADDITIONAL DISTRICT & SESSIONS JUDGE, DAKSHINA
KANNADA, MANGALORE
R.A No. 30 of 2011
IN THE COURT OF THE II ADDITIONAL SENIOR CIVIL JUDGE AT MANGALORE
O.S No. 151 of 2010

(REGULARSECOND APPEAL UNDER SECTION 100 OF THE CODE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE)
M.S.A No._____________ of 2018
BETWEEN: POSITION OF PARTIES BEFORE

TRIAL APPELLATE HIGH
The United Christian Association ®

Registered under Karnataka Society Registration Act,
Office at Shena Constructions, Dubois Complex,
Silver Gate, Kulashekar, Mangalore – 575005.
Rep. by its President
Mr. Alban Menzes,
Aged 41 years,
S/o Sydney Menezes,
The President,
The United Christian Association ®,
Mangalore. PLAINTIFFF APPELLANT-1 APPELLANT
AND
1. Rev. Bishop, Mangalore Diocese,

Bishops House, Kodialbail,
Mangalore – 575003.
(Present Incumbent In the office of Beshop,
Rev. Aloysious Paul D’Souza
Aged about 69 years.) DEFENDANT RESPONDENT-1 RESPONDENT-1
2
2. Mrs. Emilla Rita Monteiro,

aged about 50 years,
W/o. Edward R Monteiro,
R/at ‘Eden Gardens’, Kalai, Kulshekar Post,
Mangalore – 575005. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-2 RESPONDENT-2
3. Ms. Edrina Monteiro,

D/o. Edward R. Monteiro,
R/at ‘Eden Gardens’, Kalai,
Kulshekar Post, Mangalore – 575005. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-3 RESPONDENT-3
4. Ms. Elvia Monteiro,

D/o. Edward R. Monteiro,
R/at ‘Eden Gardens’, Kalai,
5. Mr. Alban Alwyn Monteiro,

S/o Late Peter Paul Monteiro,
R/at ‘Rocklands’, Kalai,
Padil Post, Mangalore – 575007. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-5 RESPONDENT-5
6. Mrs. Astrid Mabel Monterio,

aged 46 years,
W/o Alban Alwyn Monteiro,
R/at ‘Rocklands’, Kalai,
7. Mr. Edward Ronald Monteiro,

Aged about 58 years,
S/o. Late Peter Paul Monteiro,
R/at ‘Rocklands’, Kalai, Padil Post,
Kulshekar-Umikhan Maidan Road,
Kulshekar Post, Mangalore - 575005. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-7 RESPONDENT-7
8. Mr. Leo Tauro,

S/o late Paul Tauro,
R/at Karpinar House, Padil Post,
Alape Village, Mangalore - 575007. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-8 RESPONDENT-8
9. Mrs. Lucy Tauro,

W/o Leo Tauro,
3
10. Mrs. Jacintha Laveena Tauro,

D/o Leo Tauro,
11. Mrs. Anna Matilda,

W/o Mr. Edwin D’Souza,
R/at ‘Eden Villa’, Kongoor Mutt Road,
Padavu Village, Mangalore - 575005. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-11 RESPONDENT-11
12. Mrs. Naveen D’Almeida,

S/o late Lawrence D’Almeida,
R/at Kongoor Rajpal House,
Padavu, Kulshekar, Mangalore - 575005. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-12 RESPONDENT-12
13. Mrs. Irene Menezes,

W/o Richard Menezes,
R/at Kongoor House, Valankanni Compound,
Shakthinagar Post, Mangalore - 575016. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-13 RESPONDENT-13
14. Mrs. Helen Rebeiro,

W/o late Zackarias Rebeiro,
R/at ‘Shalon’ Casttelino Colony,
15. Mr. G. Thangachan,

S/o late A. Gyanasundara,
R/at Kongoor House, Kulshekar Post,
16. Mr. Godwin,

S/o S.A. Felix,
R/at Kongoor House,
17. Mrs. Rita Leena Sequeira,

W/o Charles Blany Sequeira,
R/at Kongoor House,
18. Mrs. Chris Everts D’Souza,

4

W/o Naveen D’Almeida,
R/at Kongoor House,
19. Mr. Peter D’Costa,

R/at Kongoor House,
20. Mrs. Gracy Rodrigues,

W/o late Robert Rodrigues,
R/at Robert Villa, Kongoor House,
Kulshekar Village, Mangalore – 575005. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-20 RESPONDENT-20
21. Mrs. Letitia Castelino,

W/o Daniel Castelino,
R/at Kongoor House,
22. Mr. Daniel Castelino,

S/o late Joseph Castelino,
R/at Kongoor House,
23. Mrs. Myrna Lobo,

D/o Oliver Lobo,
R/at Zion, Padavu Village,
Church Compound, 4th Cross,
Kulshekar, Mangalore - 575005. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-23 RESPONDENT-23
24. Mr. Noel Lobo,

S/o late Jacob Lobo,
R/at Lobo Compound, Kuchikad,
Padavu Village, Kulshekar,
Mangalore - 575005. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-24 RESPONDENT-24
25. Mrs. Lidwin Lobo,

W/o Mrs. Neol Lobo,
R/at Lobo Compound, Kuchikad,
5
26. Mr. Oliver Lobo,

R/at Zion Village, Padavu Village,
Kulshekar, Mangalore – 575005. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-26 RESPONDENT-26
27. Mrs. Laveena Lobo,

W/o Oliver Lobo,
28. Mr. Sunil Lobo,

4th Cross, Kulshekar,
29. Mr. Alphonso D’Souza,

S/o late Lawrence D’Souza,
R/at Alape Village, Kulshekar Post,
30. Mrs. Theresa D’Souza,

W/o Alphonso D’Souza,
31. Miss. Manisha Crasta,

D/o Michael Crasta,
32. Mr. Henry D’Souza,

S/o late Raymond D’Souza,
R/at Alape Village, Niddle Gokarna,
33. Mr. Preem D’Souza,

S/o Mr. Monthu D’Souza,
6
R/at Alape Village, Niddle,

34. Dolphy D’Souza,

S/o Victor D’Silva,
R/at ‘Dolphin’, Sirla Padpu,
Kulshekar, Mangalore -05. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-34 RESPONDENT-34
35. Mrs. Olivia D’Silva,

D/o Dolphy D’Silva,
Kulshekar, Mangalore –05 NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-35 RESPONDENT-35
36. Debora D’Silva,

D/o Dolphy D’Silva,
37. Mr. Roshan Monteiro,

Residing behind Bejai Church, Bejai Post,
Mangalore -04. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-37 RESPONDENT-37
38. Mrs. Josephine Pereira,

W/o late Luvies D’Souza,
R/at Attavar, Baabugudda,
near Grama Sanga,
39. Precilla Saldanha,

W/o late Philip Saldanha,
R/at Carmel Nagar, Bajjodi,
Bikarnakatte, Kulshekar Post,
40. Mr. Leo Mascarenhas,

S/o late Baptist Mascarenhas,
R/at ‘Levens Dwell’,
1st Cross, Cirlapadapu,
41. Veena Mascarenhas,

7
D/o late Philip D’Souza,

R/at ‘Levens Dwell’,
1st Cross, Cirlapadapu,
42. Mr. Derick D’Souza,

S/o late Henry D’Souza,
R/at 5th Cross, Kodical Katte,
Ashoknagar Post, Mangalore - 575006. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-42 RESPONDENT-42
43. Mr. Charles D’Souza,

S/o late Valerian D’Souza,
R/at Pinto Compound, Cirla Padpu,
Kulshekar, Mangalore. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-43 RESPONDENT-43
44. Smt. Priya D’Souza,

W/o Charles D’Souza,
45. Mr. J. Alban Pinto,

S/o late S. Pinto,
46. Dorothy Pinto,

W/o Fedrick Pinto,
R/at Shirla Padpu House,
Kulshekar Post,
47. Fedrick Pinto,

S/o Jacob Pinto,
48. Mr. Richard Joy Pinto,

S/o Fedrick Pinto,
49. Savitha Pinto,

8

S/o Richarg Joy Pinto,
50. Mr. John Sushil Noronha,

S/o late Joseph Noronha,
R/at ‘Eden Veera’, Sirlapadpu,
51. Edna Noronha,

W/o John Sushil Norohna,
R/at ‘Melvita’, Behind Kulshekara church,
52. Stella Noronha,

W/o Late Joseph Noronha,
53. Mrs. Violet Noronha,

W/o Melwyn Prakash Noronha,
54. Mrs. Lydia D’Souza,

W/o Noel D’Souza,
R/at Padauv Village,
55. Mr. Vincent Jose,

S/o C.D. Jose,
56. Mrs. Teresa Jose,

W/o C.D. Jose,
57. Mr. Noel D’Souza,

9
S/o Late Alphonso D’Souza,

58. Ancilla D’Cunha,
W/o Jerald D’Cunha,
59. Mr. Oswald Madtha,

S/o Monthu Madtha,
60. Mr. George D’Souza,

S/o. Anthony D’souza, NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-60 RESPONDENT-60
61.Elizabeth Catelino,
D/o Thomas Catelino,
R/at Padau Village, D. No.11-235,
Kakkebettu, Kulshekara,
62. Mr. Jerald Lobo,

aged 32 years,
S/o. Lawrence Martin Lobo,
R/at Saripalla House, Padil Post,
Alape Village, Mangalore – 575007. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-62 RESPONDENT-62
63. Mr. Ryner Fernades,

aged 53 years,
S/o Sylvester Fernandes,
64. Mrs. Lavine Pinto,

aged 26 years,
D/o M.L. Pinto,
65. Mr. Alban D’Souza,

aged 21 years,
S/o Raymond D’Souza,
10
Alape ward, Mangalore - 575007. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-65 RESPONDENT-65
66. Mr. Anitha D’Souza,

aged 43 years,
W/o Ronald D’Souza,
R/at Saripalla Maidan House,
Padil Post, Alape ward,
67. Mr. Ronald D’Souza,

aged 49 years,
S/o. John Baptist D’Souza,
R/at Saripalla Maidan House,
68. Mr. Stany Pinto,

Aged 43 years,
S/o. Cyrill Pinto,
R/at Saripalla House, (near club),
Padil Post, Alape Village,
69. Mr. Cyrill Pinto,

aged 65 years,
D/o. Marcel Pinto,
R/at Saripalla House,
70. Mrs. Lethitia Pinto,

aged 52 years,
S/o Raymond D’Souza,
Saripalla House, Padil Post,
71. Mrs. Mary D’Souza,

aged 64 years,
W/o Late Monthu D’Souza,
Sister Compound, Rd.No.1,
Saripalla House, Alape Ward,
72. Mrs. Thereza Alphonsi,

W/o. T.J.J. Thomas Alphonoso,
Saripalla House, Alape Ward,
Padil Post, Mangalore - 575007. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-72 RESPONDENT-72
73. Mr. Herald D’Souza,

11
aged 53 years,
S/o. John Abhraham D’Souza,
R/at Sister Compound, Padil Post,
74. Mrs. Stella D’Souza,

aged 47 years,
W/o Vincent D’Souza,
Saripalla House, padil Post,
75. Mrs. Eliza Fernandes,

aged 55 years,
W/o Late Joseph Fernandes,
76. Mr. Sapna Fernandes,

aged 25 years,
D/o Eliza Fernandes,
Alape ward, Mangalore - 575007. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-76 RESPONDENT-76
77. Mrs. Hilda D’Souza,

aged 54 years,
W/o. Ryner D’Souza,
78. Mr. Thomas Pereira,

aged 50 years,
S/o. David Pereira,
79. Mrs. Lilly D’Souza,

aged 39 years,
D/o. Marcel Pinto,
80. Mrs. Rita D’Souza,

aged 66 years,
W/o Alphonse D’Lima,
R/at S.B. Nagar, Rd.No.1,
Saripalla, Padil Post,
81. Mr. Valerian Lobo,

12
aged 51 years,
S/o Ignatious Lobo,
R/at S.B. Nagar, Rd.No. 1,
Alape Ward, Mangalore - 575007. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-81 RESPONDENT-81
82. Mr. Sunil D’Souza,

aged 33 years,
S/o. A. D’Souza,
83. Mr. Melwyn D’Souza,

S/o. Marcel D’Souza,
R/at S. Liberal House, P.O. Permannur. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-83 RESPONDENT-83
84. Mr. Manoj Ferao,

S/o. Late Everest Ferao,
R/at Mather House, P.O. Permannur. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-84 RESPONDENT-84
85. Mr. Prakash Pinto,

S/o. Theeador Pinto,
R/at Chemubdu De House,
P.O. Permannur. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-85 RESPONDENT-85
86. Mr. Ashok Ferao,

S/o. Late Everest Ferao,
R/at Mather House, P.O. Permannur. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-86 RESPONDENT-86
87. Mr. Praveen Veigas,

S/o. Andru Veigas,
R/at Ullal Hoige, Permannur Post. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-87 RESPONDENT-87
88. Dennis D Souza,

S/o Late Ladin D’Souza,
R/at Thokkottu,
Permannur post, Mangalore. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-88 RESPONDENT-88
89. Mr. Allan Pinto,

S/o Walter Pinto,
R/at Adam Kudru, Bolla House,
Permannur. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-89 RESPONDENT-89
90. Ms. Declcy D’Souza,

D/o Denis D’Souza,
R/at Bolla Bouse, P.O. Permannur. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-90 RESPONDENT-90
91. Mr. Ivan D’Souza,

S/o Late Gobert D’ Souza,
13
R/at Divine House, Adam Kudru,

92. Mr. Oliver D’Souza,

C/o. Ivan D’Souza,
93. Mr. Ivan John D’Souza,

S/o Marcel D’Souza,
R/at Adam Kudru, Permannur,
Mangalore. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-93 RESPONDENT-93
94. Ms. Glena Staffi D’Souza,

D/o. Gerald D’souza,
95. Mr. Suraj S. D’Souza,

S/o. Ivan D’ Souza,
96. Mr. Waston D’Souza,

S/o. Walter D’Souza,
97. Mr. Deril D’Souza,

S/o. Denis D’Souza,
98. Mr. Shanu D’Souza,

S/o Marcel D’Souza,
Margathale. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-98 RESPONDENT-98
99. Mr. Wilson Monterio,

S/o. Aroel Monteiro,
100. Mr. Donald D’ Souza,

S/o Lukas D’Souza,
R/at Kallapu, Mangalore. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-100 RESPONDENT-100
101. Mr. Orsan D’Souza,

S/o. Roymad D’Souza,
R/at Ullal Hoige. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-101 RESPONDENT-101
14
102. Mr. Oswald D’Souza,

S/o. Peter D’Souza,
R/at Chumbu Gudda, Mangalore. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-102 RESPONDENT-102
103. Mr. Danny Joy D’Souza,

S/o Edward D’Souza,

S/o. Jockim D’Souza,
R/at Permannur. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-104 RESPONDENT-104
105. Mr. Rithesh Guniya,

S/o. Romma D’Souza,
106. Mr. Dilip D’Souza,

S/o. Patric D’Souza,
R/at Ullal. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-106 RESPONDENT-106
107. Mr. Daphny,

S/o. Abel,
R/at Kallapu. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-107 RESPONDENT-107
108. Mr. Naveen D’Souza,

S/o Cyril D’Souza,
109. Mr. Gowin D’Souza,

110. Mr. Sunid D’Sa,

S/o Joseph D’Sa,
111. Mr. Dany D’Souza,

S/o. Jockim D’Souza,
112. Mr. Godwin D’Souza,

113. Mr. Raja D’Souza,

114. Mr. Pius Montheirao,

S/o. Lvis Montheiro,
15
R/at Ullal Ullia, Ullal Post. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-114 RESPONDENT-114
115. Mr. Vinod D’Souza,

S/o. Victor D’Souza,
R/at Ullal Ullia, Ullal Post. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-115 RESPONDENT-115
116. Mr. Urban Montheirao,

S/o Ligory Montheirao,
R/at Krishna Nagar, Thokkottu. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-116 RESPONDENT-116
117. Mrs. Lidwin D’Souza,

W/o Walter D’Souza,
R/at Bolla House, Adam Kudru. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-117 RESPONDENT-117
118. Mr. Winston D’Souza,

S/o Walter D’Souza,

W/o. John D’Souza,
120. Mrs. Tressy D’Souza,

W/o Everest D’Souza,
121. Mrs. Ida D’Sa,

W/o. Cyprian D’Sa,
R/at Adam Kudru, Permannur Post. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-121 RESPONDENT-121
122. Mr. Walter D’Souza, Marcel D’Souza,

W/o. Cyprian D’Sa,
123. Mr. Cyprian D’Sa,

S/o. Francis D’Sa,
124. Mr. Thomothy D’sa,

S/o Francis D’Sa,
125. Mr. John D’Sa,

S/o Francis D’Sa,
126. Mr. Philip D’Sa,

S/o Francis D’Sa,
R/at Bolla House, Adam Kudru,
16
Permannur Post. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-126 RESPONDENT-126
127. Mr. Henry D’Souza,

S/o. Nicholas D’Souza,
R/at Rosario II Ward, Adam Kudru. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-127 RESPONDENT-127
128. Mr. Willson D’Sa,

S/o. Philip D’Souza,
129. Mr. Walter D’Sa,

S/o Francis D’Sa,
130. Mr. Raphel D’Souza,

S/o. Benjamin D’Souza,
131. Mr. Sobers D’Souza,

S/o Everest D’Souza,
20 R.A.No.30/2011
132. Mrs. Saritha Janet D’Souza,

W/o Neeran D’Souza,
Permannur Post, Mangalore. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-132 RESPONDENT-132
133. Mr. Paul D’Souza,

S/o. Marcel D’Souza,
134. Mrs. Nancy D’Souza,

W/o. Dennis D’Souza,
135. Mrs. Lilly D’Souza,

W/o. Jerome D’Souza,
136. Mr. Loyd S. Veigas,

S/o. Xavier Veigas,
17
R/at Chembugudde House, Permannur Post,

137. Mr. Stany D’Souza,

S/o Late Marcel D’Souza,
R/at Near Telephone Exchange, Permannur Post,
138. Mr. Vincent D’Souza,

S/o Late Albert D’Souza,
R/at Kapikad, Ullal Post - 575020. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-138 RESPONDENT-138
139. Mr. Patrick D’Souza,

S/o Late Michael D’Souza,
R/at Adam kudru,
Permannur Post - 578017. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-139 RESPONDENT-139
140. Mr. Baptist D’Souza,

R/at Ullala Ullia, Monepu,
141. Mrs. Irene D’Souza,

R/at Ullala Ullia, Monepu,
142. Rita D. Antonius,

R/at ‘Bosco Villa’, Pandeshwara,
143. Jecintha Mascarehas,

21 R.A.No.30/2011
144. Helen Celestine,

145. Joseph Celestine,

146. Sr. Mailyn,

147. Jean Louis Periera,

18
148. Tressy Dora Pinto,

R/at Julie Bagh Apt: 103, A Block,
Pandeshwara, Mangalore. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-148 RESPONDENT-148
149. Lybil Tanya Pinto,

R/at Julie Bagh Apt: 103, A Block,
Pandeshwara, Mangalore. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-149 RESPONDENT-149
150. Winnie Cutinha,

R/at Fernandes Villa, Hoige Bazar,
151. Mrs. Felcita R. Pais,

W/o Robert Pais,
R/at Opp. Cordel Hall, Seraphina Cottage,
Kulshekara, Mangalore. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-151 RESPONDENT-151
152. Mrs. Dorine Fernandes,

W/o Denzil Fernandes,
R/at ‘Maria Kripa’, Door No. 13-30/12,
Opp. Cordel Hall,
Kulshekara, Mangalore - 575005. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-152 RESPONDENT-152
153. Mrs. Irene Fernandes,

W/o. Late Richard Fernandes,
R/at ‘Maria Kripa’, Door No. 13-30/12,
Opp. Cordel Hall,
154. Mrs. Eugene D’Souza,

W/o Bonaventure Oswald D’souza,
R/at ‘Oshin Castle’, Door No. 13-23/1,
New Padau Road, Kulshekara,
155. Miss.Michelle Priya Pinto,

aged 18 years,
D/o Rony Pinto,
R/at ‘Grace Cote’, Opp. Cordel Hall,
22 R.A.No.30/2011
156. Mrs. Gracy Pinto,

19
W/o Rony Pinto,

R/at ‘Grace Cote’, Opp.Cordel Hall,
157. Mrs. Nora Placidia D’Costa,

aged 34 years,
W/o Leslie Mark D’ Costa,
R/at Opp: Kulshekar Church Hall,
‘Paraclete’, Church Gate,
158. Mrs. Lucy Rosario,

W/o. Joseph Rosario,
R/at Holy Beeder House, 13-30/10,
Behind Spoorthi Complex,
159. Mr. Joseph Rosario,

S/o. John Rosario,
160. Mr. Steevan Rosario,

S/o. Joseph Rosario,
161. Mrs. Precilla D’Souza,

W/o Geofry D’Souza,
R/at ‘Rolvin Villa’, Behind MCC Bank,
Kulshekar, Padavu Village,
162. Mrs. Veena Rosario,

W/o Lancy D’Souza,
163. Mrs. Reena Rosario,

D/o Joseph Rosario,
20

164. Mr. Joseph D’Silva,

S/o Late Benedicta D’Silva,
R/at Door No. 13-30/14,
23 R.A.No.30/2011
165. Mrs. Judith D’Silva,

W/o Joseph D’Silva,
R/at Door No. 13-30/14,
166. Mrs. Philomena D’Souza,

W/o Valerian D’Souza,
R/at Near Spoorthi Complex,
167. Miss. Jovita Daisy D’Souza,

D/o Ronald D’Souza,
R/at Niddel Gokarna House, Alape Village,
168. Mr. Ronald D’Souza ,

S/o. Late Santhan D’Souza,
R/at Niddel, Alape Village,
169. Miss. Reeda Luiza D’Souza,

D/o. Ida D’Souza,
170. Mr. Monthu D’Souza,

S/o. Late Raymond D’Souza,
21
171. Mrs. Cicila D’Souza,

W/o Monthu D’Souza,
172. Mr. Prakash D’Souza,

S/o Monthu D’Souza,
173. Mrs. Leena Maria Lobo,

D/o Mark Lobo,
R/at Niddel, Gokarna Road,
24 R.A.No.30/2011
174. Mrs. Helen Lolita Lobo,

W/o Jacob Walter Lobo,
R/at ‘Ave Maria’, 6-78/1, Niddel, Gokarna Road,
175. Mrs. Paulin D’Souza,

W/o John Alwyn D’Souza,
Alan Cottage, Alape Village,
176. Mrs. Letitia Madtha,

W/o late Gilbert Madtha,
R/at Rose Mary Glan, Alape Village,
Kulshekara Post, Mangalore - 575005. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-176 RESPONDENT-176
177. Mr. Ligory D’Souza,

aged about 80 yeears,
S/o Santhan D’Souza,
R/at Emmanuel, 7/44, Ummikan Maidan,
Kulshekara, Mangalore – 575005. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-177 RESPONDENT-177
178. Mr. Francis Sebastian D’Souza,

S/o Ligory D’Souza,
Kulshekara Post, Mangalore – 575005. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-178 RESPONDENT-178
22
179. Mrs. Lynette Shanthi D’Souza,

W/o Francis Sebastian D’Souza,
Kulshekara Post, Mangalore – 575005. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-179 RESPONDENT-179
180. Mrs. Jenifer Levitha D’Souza,

D/o Jerald D’Souza,
R/at J. D’Souza Villa, Neermarga House,
Pedamale Post, Mangalore - 575029. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-180 RESPONDENT-180
181. Mrs. Jacintha Cordeiro,

D/o late Valerian Pinto,
R/at Dharmagiri, Vamanjoor Post,
25 R.A.No.30/2011
182. Mr. Robert Charles Lobo,

S/o Baptist Lobo,
R/at ‘Hope’, Behind Kapikad School,
Bejai, Mangalore - 575004. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-182 RESPONDENT-182
183. Miss. Melita D’Souza,

D/o Santhan D’Souza,
R/at Emmanuel, Kunder House,
184. Mrs. Juliana David,

W/o Ronald David,
R/at ‘Hope’, Behind Kapikad School,
Bejai, Mangalore – 575004. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-184 RESPONDENT-184
185. Mrs. Mariea Monteiro,

W/o Herman A. Monteiro,
R/at ‘Mount Petro’,
Kalai, Padil Post, Mangalore - 575007. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-185 RESPONDENT-185
186. Mr. Herman A. Monteiro,

S/o late Peter Paul Monteiro,
R/at ‘Mount Petro’, Kalai,
23
187. Mr. Ashley P. A. Monteiro,

S/o Herman A. Monteiro,
R/at ‘Mount Petro’, Kalai,
188. Mr. Robert Naveen D’Souza,

S/o late Joseph D’Souza,
R/at Kalai, Padil Post,
189. Mrs. Shanthi D’Souza,

W/o Robert Naveen D’Souza,
R/at Kalai, Padil Post,
190. Jerry Cutinha,

S/o Simon Cutinha,
R/at Kapikad, Ullal 3rd Cross,
Ullal P.O., Mangalore. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-190 RESPONDENT-190
191. Felix D’Souza,

S/o Agustine D’Souza,
R/at Adamkudva P.O., Permannur,
Jappina Mogaru, Mangalore. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-191 RESPONDENT-191
192. Isac D’Souza,

S/o Gregory D’Souza,
Residing near Over Bridge, Thokkottu,
Ullal P.O., Mangalore. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-192 RESPONDENT-192
26 R.A.No.30/2011
193. Jyothi Cynthia D’Souza,

R/at Reesh House, Ganesh Nagar,
Near over Bridge,
Ullal Post, Mangalore - 575020. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-193 RESPONDENT-193
194. Henry D’Souza,

S/o Sylvester D’Souza,
R/at Ullal, Permannur Post,
195. Thereza Ferrao,

W/o Philip Ferrao,
R/at Infant Jesus, Ullal Bail,
Near Mobile Tower,
24
196. Francis D’Souza,

S/o Leo D’Souza,
R/at near C.R.S. Ullal Bail,
Ullal Post, Mangalore. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-196 RESPONDENT-196
197. Fedrick Pinto,

S/o Felix Pinto,
R/at Trinity Shelter, Ganesh Nagar,
Near Over Bridge,
198. Francis D’Souza,

S/o Valerian D’Souza,
R/at near ARS Ganesh Nagar,
3rd Cross Road,
Ullal Bail, Mangalore - 575020. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-198 RESPONDENT-198
199. Gerald D’Souza,

S/o Calist D’Souza,
R/at A.K. Bolla House,
200. Miss. Avita M. D’Souza,

D/o Denis D’Souza,
R/at A.K. Bolla House, Adam Kudru,
201. Mrs. Winston D’Souza,

S/o Walter D’Souza,
R/at Nithyadar Villa, A.K. Bolla House,
27 R.A.No.30/2011
202. Mrs. Rose M. D’Souza,

W/o Sunil S. D’Souza,

S/o Ivan D’Souza,
204. Jacintha D’Souza. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-204 RESPONDENT-204
205. Sparsha D’Souza. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-205 RESPONDENT-205
206. Sheethal D’Souza,

25
(Defendant No.204 to 206 are Residing at

D.No.19-10-644, Old Kent Road,
Pandeshwar, Mangalore). NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-206 RESPONDENT-206
207. Elias Lobo,

R/at Fathima Garden, Old Kent Road,
Pandeshwar, Mangalore. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-207 RESPONDENT-207
208. Mrs. Winnie Lobo,

209. Gretta Lobo,

210. Mrs. Fiona Pinto,

R/at 302/ Chandramma Aprts,
B.R. Karkera Road, Mangalore. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-210 RESPONDENT-210
211. Gladis Periera,

R/at Laxmi Doomappa Apartments,
1st Floor, Flat No.4,
Pandeshwar, Mangalore - 1. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-211 RESPONDENT-211
212. Judy Monteiro,

213. Dayananda Monteiro,

28 R.A.No.30/2011
214. Lawrence D’Silva,

R/at GSI Complex, D.No.M-3,
215. Joachim Monteiro,

R/at D.No.23-12-1206,
Mangala Devi T. Road,
Monki Stand, Mangalore. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-215 RESPONDENT-215
216. Maxim D’Souza,

R/at D.No.23-12-1203,
Shantha Alva Compound,
26
217. Henry D’Silva,

R/at D.No.23-12-1205,
218. Leena D’Souza,

R/at D.No.23-12-1202/2,
219. Joseph D’Souza,

R/at D.No.23-12-1209,
220. Cyril Fernandes,

R/at D.No.23-12-1169,
Mangaladevi new Cross Road,
Attavara, Mangalore - 1. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-220 RESPONDENT-220
221. Vincent Rodrigues,

R/at D.No.23-12-1173, Lid-Lin-Villa,
Mangaladevi new Cross Road,
Attavara, Mangalore - 1. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-221 RESPONDENT-221
222. Stella D’Souza,

R/at D.No.23-12-1207,
Monki Stand, Mangalore - 1. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-222 RESPONDENT-222
223. Nelson Aranha,

R/at Shiva Nagar,
2nd Cross Road, D.No.23-12-1042,
Monkey Stand Mangalore - 1. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-223 RESPONDENT-223
29 R.A.No.30/2011
224. Albert D’Sa,

R/at D.No.32-12-1044/34, 3rd Cross Road,
Shivanagar, Mangalore - 1. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-224 RESPONDENT-224
225. Mrs. Angaline D’Souza,

R/at Opp. Ramakrishna Ashram,
226. Lawrence Noronha,

R/at D.No.23-11/970,
27
227. Mrs. Irene Noronha,

R/at Valentine Village, Tavarekere,
Bolar, Mangalore - 1. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-227 RESPONDENT-227
228. Valerian P. Rodrigues,

R/at ‘Venrin’, Subashnagar,
3rd Main, 3rd Cross,
229. Juliana Fernandes,

C/o A.C. Pinto,
Subashnagar, Mangalore. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-229 RESPONDENT-229
230. Gratian D’Souza,

R/at Subashnagar,
3rd Main Cross, Pandeshwar,
Near Ram Garage,
231. Michael D’Souza,

R/at St. Antony Villa, Subashnagar,
3rd Main Cross, Pandeshwar,
232. Janet D’Souza,

R/at Subash Nagar, St. Antony Villa,
3rd Main Cross, Mangalore. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-232 RESPONDENT-232
233. Gladys V. Lobo,

R/at Gladhill, St. Antony Villa,
Subashnagar, P.O., Pandeshwar,
234. Janet Menezes,

R/at ‘Sunshine’, Subhash Nagar,
30 R.A.No.30/2011
235. Julie D’Souza,

R/at Margaret Villa, Subashnagar,
236. Lawrence D’Souza,

R/at Subashnagar,
237. Marbel D’Souza,

28
R/at Subashnagar,
238. Hilary Lobo,

R/at Gladhill,
Subashnagar, 2nd Main Road,
P.O. Pandeshwar, Mangalore - 1. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-238 RESPONDENT-238
239. Dolphy D’Souza,

R/at Margaret Villa, St. Antony Villa,
Subashnagar, 2nd Main Road,
240. Lily Joe,

R/at ‘Lily Villa’,
3rd Main Road, Subashnagar,
241. Joe Antony,

R/at ‘Lily Villa’,
242. Veera Mascarenhas,

R/at ‘Venrin’,
243. S.M. Pinto,

R/at Flat No.601,
Albuquarque Apartments,
244. Edwin Madtha,

R/at Flat No.603,
Albuquarque House,
245. Ligoury A. Lobo,

R/at Flat No.603,
Albuquarque House,
246. Carmine Lobo,

R/at B-3, Parvathy Apartments,
Old Kent Road, Mangalore - 1. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-246 RESPONDENT-246
31 R.A.No.30/2011
247. Mary Fernandes,

29
R/at 505, Albuquarque House,

248. Mrs. Cynthia Ferear,

R/at 406, Albuquarque Apartments,
249. Mrs. J. Albuquarque,

250. Michael Montheiro,

251. Stany Menezes,

252. Mrs. Celiene Rego,

R/at 203, Entity Apartments
253. Grace Lobo,

R/at ‘Grace’,
Pandeshwar New Road, Mangalore - 1. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-253 RESPONDENT-253
254. Teresa Xavier,

W/o M.O. Xavier,
Pandeshwar New Road, Mangalore - 1. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-254 RESPONDENT-254
255. Lilly Lobo,

R/at 605, Albuquarque House,
256. Rolphy G. Rodrigues,

257. Gladys Mudarth,

258. Precilla D’Souza,

R/at Rosario Church Road,
Cozy Corner Apts, II Floor,
32 R.A.No.30/2011
30
259. Sunitha John Jimmy,

R/at Rosario Church Road,
Flat No.204, Cozy Corner Aprts, II Floor,
260. Michael Fernandes,

R/at ‘Craig Garden’,
Pandeshwar, 1st Cross Road,
261. Marie Fernandes,

262. Denziel Fernandes,

263. Vincent Menezes,

S/o late Gregory Menezes,
R/at St. Rita Church, Cascia Morgansgate,
264. Ligory Saldanha,

S/o Mingel Saldanha,
R/at St. Rita Church, Cascia Morgansgate,
265. Sandeep Castelino,

aged aobut 33 years,
S/o late Harold Castelino,
R/at ‘Terex’, Morgansgate,
266. Sandeep Castelino,

aged aobut 33 years,
S/o late Harold Castelino,
R/at ‘Terex’, Morgansgate,
267. Diamond D’Souza,

R/at Shanthinikethan, Jeppu Market Road,
31
268. Blanche D’Souza,

W/o Gratian D’Souza,
R/at Jeppu Bappal,
1st Cross, Kankanady,
269. Jecintha R. D’Souza,

D/o Joseph D’Souza,
R/at Jeppu Kudpady,
270. Mrs. Agnes Roche,

aged about 51 years, W/o Alexander Roche,
R/at Shanthi Vihar, Opp. Jeppu Market,
33 R.A.No.30/2011
271. Anil Lobo,

S/o V.M. Lobo,
R/at 202, Shangrila Apartments,
Morgansgate, Mangalore. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-271 RESPONDENT-271
272. Mrs. Benedicta D’Souza,

D/o late Michael Braggs,
R/at Cascia, near St. Ritas School,
Jeppu Market Road,
273. Ancy Tauro,

D/o Victor Monna Pinto,
R/at Sherurn Compound,
Jeppu, Kudpady Road,
274. Mr. Joseph Fredrick D’Souza,

S/o late Salvadore D’Souza,
R/at ‘Blessing’, H.No.25-26-1988,
M.R. Bhat Lane, Jeppu,
275. Mary Axeiliya,

32

D/o A.A. Patric,
R/at Jeppu, Kudpady Road,
276. Jessy D’Souza,

D/o John Pinto,
R/at St. Rita Church, Cascia,
Nandigudda,
277. Daisy D’Souza,

D/o Albert Lobo,
R/at Morgans Gate,
278. Preecilla D’Souza,

D/o John Cutinha,
Jeppu, Kudupady,
279. Lucy D’Souza,

aged 63 years,
D/o David D’Souza,
M.R. Bhat Lane,
34 R.A.No.30/2011
280. Rita D’Souza,

D/o Joseph D’Souza,
M.R. Bhat Lane,
281. Jane D’Souza,

D/o Mr. Mark Rasquinha,
R/at M.R. Bhat Lane, Larrisa Francis Villa,
Near IInd Bridge,
Opp. S.C.S. Hostel,
282. Rita D’Almeida,

33

D/o Louis D’Souza,
R/at M.R. Bhat Lane,
283. Anil Rupesh D’Souza,

R/at Babu Compound,
M.R. Bhat Lane,
284. Jossy Rodrigues,

S/o Joseph Rodrigues,
R/at Padekodi House, Padamale,
285. Gabriel Roddrigues,

S/o Santhan Rodrigues,
R/at Padekodi House,
Padamale, Mangalore - 575029. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-285 RESPONDENT-285
286. Jeevan D’Mello,

S/o late Pascal D’Mello,
R/at Padekodi House,
Padamale, Mangalore - 575029. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-286 RESPONDENT-286
287. Mrs. Rose Mary Rasquinha,

D/o Paul Rasquinha,
R/at Holy Family House,
Bondanthila Post, Mangalore - 575029. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-287 RESPONDENT-287
288. Richard Pinto,

D/o John Pinto,
R/at Kelarai Church Road,
Neermarga, M’lore. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-288 RESPONDENT-288
289. Richard D’Souza,

R/at Ligory D’Souza,
R/at near St. Anna Charch,
Kelarai, Mangalore. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-289 RESPONDENT-289
290. Robert Lancy Pais,

S/o late Lawrance Pais,
34
R/at Vally View,

Pademale Post, Mangalore - 29. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-290 RESPONDENT-290
35 R.A.No.30/2011
291. Baptist Crasta,

S/o late Sylvester Crasta,
R/at Crasta Compound,
292. Charls Vas,

S/o John Vas,
R/at Annavilla, 3-1621(4),
293. Alice Vas,

D/o P.F. D’Souza,
R/at Pleasant Cottage,
Upper Nekkare, Pademale Post,
Neermarga, Mangalore - 29. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-293 RESPONDENT-293
294. Irene Vas,

D/o Maurice Vas,
R/at Katinja House,
Bondanthila Post, Mangalore. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-294 RESPONDENT-294
295. Lambert Alvares,

S/o J.S. Alvares,
R/at Valley View, Fr. J.B. Alvares Road,
Kelarai, Mangalore. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-295 RESPONDENT-295
296. Ajay D’Souza,

S/o Edmond D’Souza,
R/at Vamadapadav House,
Bantwal Taluk. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-296 RESPONDENT-296
297. Lucy Martis,

W/o Cyril D’Souza,
298. Cyril D’Souza,

35
S/o Alex D’Souza,

299. George Thomas D’Souza,

S/o Cyprian Peter D’Souza,
R/at Codialbail Press, Konchady,
Mary Hill, Mangalore. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-299 RESPONDENT-299
300. Edwin P. Fernandes,

S/o late Hillary Fernandes,
R/at ‘Joy Nest’, Kuthukori Gudda,
Kankanady Post, Mangalore. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-300 RESPONDENT-300
36 R.A.No.30/2011
301. Francis Ashok D’Souza,

S/o Ignatius D’Souza,
R/at Katta House, Bangrakulur,
Kulur Post, Mangalore. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-301 RESPONDENT-301
302. Gregory D’Souza,

R/at ‘Sabeel’ D’Souza View,
Padavinangadi,
Konchady Post, Mangalore. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-302 RESPONDENT-302
303. Lancy D’Cunha,

S/o Albert D’Cunha,
R/at ‘Elcy Rose’, Pachanady,
Bondel Post, Mangalore - 575008. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-303 RESPONDENT-303
304. Leonilla Pinto,

W/o Herald Pinto,
R/at Niddel House,
Padil Post, Mangalore. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-304 RESPONDENT-304
305. Jessy D’Souza,

W/o Mr. Benedict D’Souza,
R/at Niddel House,
306. Philomena D’Souza,

36

W/o Martin D’Souza,
R/at ‘Souza Villa’, Niddel House,
307. Thomas Rodrigues,

S/o Michael Rodrigues,
R/at Niddel Gokarna House,
308. Mr. Herald Gracian Pinto,

R/at Green View, Niddel House,
309. Clara D’Souza,

W/o George D’Souza,
R/at Niddel House,
37 R.A.No.30/2011
310. Peter Mark D’Silva,

S/o late Joseph D’Silva,
R/at Niddel House,
311. George D’Souza,

S/o late Deog L. D’Souza,
R/at Niddel House,
312. Mr. Richard Pinto,

S/o late Joseph Pinto,
R/at Melthota House, Padavu Village,
313. Mr. Rayan Sequeira,

S/o Charles Sequeira,
314. Mr. John Noronha,

S/o late Michael Noronha,
37

315. Miriam Noronha,

316. Mr. Michael Noronha,

S/o John Noronha,
317. Mr. Neslyn D’Costa,

S/o late Gilbert D’Costa,
318. Mrs. Nancy D’Costa,

W/o Neslyn D’Costa,

W/o Thomas D’Souza,
38 R.A.No.30/2011
320. Mrs. Verdine Noronha,

D/o John Noronha,
321. Mr. Avil Pais,

S/o late Augustine Pais,
322. Mr. Eric Sequeira,

38
323. Mrs. Flavia D’Souza,

W/o Ronald J. D’Souza,
324. Miss. Zita Pais,

D/o Benny Pais,
R/at ‘Paisly Dale’, Melthota House,
325. Mr. Bernard K. D’Souza,

326. Mrs. Juliet Pereira,

327. Mrs. Irene Miranda,

W/o Eric Miranda,
328. Mrs. Louiza Miranda,

W/o late Ambrose Miranda,
329. Mr. Noel Sequeira,

S/o late Jerome Sequeira,
39 R.A.No.30/2011
330. Mrs. Teresa Sequeira,

W/o Noel Sequeira,
331. Mr. Mary Gulabhi D’Souza,

39

332. Mr. Joseph Serrao,

S/o Marian Serrao,
R/at Pompai Nagar, ‘A’ Block,
Pedamale, Mangalore - 29. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-332 RESPONDENT-332
333. Mr. Jerald Lobo,

S/o Lawrence Martin Lobo,
334. Mr. Ryner Fernandes,

S/o Sylvester Fernandes,
335. Mrs. Lavina Pinto,

D/o M. Lewis Pinto,
336. Mrs. Cecilia Rodrigues,

W/o Thomas Rodrigues,
R/at Niddel Gokarna House,
337. Fr. John Vas,

S/o Felix Vas,
C/o St. Anne Church, Kelarai,
338. Mr. Leo Cutinho,

R/at Anna Dale, near Kelarai Church,
Pedamale Post, Mangalore. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-338 RESPONDENT-338
339. Alphonse Crasta,

R/at Kamala House,
Post Padamale, Mangalore. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-339 RESPONDENT-339
40 R.A.No.30/2011
40
340. Fr. Valerian Pinto,

S/o late John Pinto,
R/at Parish Priest,
Holy Cross Church, Cordel,
341. Fr. Arun Wilson Lobo,

S/o Felix Lobo,
R/at Assistant Parish Priest,
Holly Cross Church, Cordel,
342. Mr. Lawrence Praveen Patrao,

S/o Thomas Moras,
R/at Assistant Parish Priest,
Holly Cross Church, Cordel,
343. Mr. Lawrence Praveen Patrao,

S/o Thomas Patrao,
R/at “Prasad” Milk Dairy Road,
344. Mrs. Feclita Marceline Patrao,

W/o. Lawrence Praveen Patrao,
345. Mrs. Letitia Patrao,

W/o. Late Thomas Patroa,
346. Mr. Victor F. Vas,

S/o Late Sylvester Vas,
R/at Pompai Nagar, “A” Block,
347. Celine Vas,

W/o Victor Vas,
41
348. Mr. Sachin Vas,

S/o Victor Vas,
41 R.A.No.30/2011
349. Mr. Kevin Nelson Vas,

S/o Victor Vas,
350. Mrs. Gracy D’Souza,

W/o Lawrence D’Souza,
351. Mr. Lawrence D’Souza,

S/o Santhan D’Souza,
352. Smt. Lucy R. Rebello,

R/at Velley View,
353. Sr. Rita D’Souza,

R/at Fathima Convent, Kelari,
354. Mr. John Alfred Benis,

R/at Halony Cottage, Kelari,
355. Antony Pinto,

S/o Paustine Pinto. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-355 RESPONDENT-355
356. Felcy Pinto,

W/o Antony Pinto. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-356 RESPONDENT-356
42
357. Priya Jyothi Pinto,

D/o Antony Pinto. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-357 RESPONDENT-357
358. Arun Kiran Pinto,

S/o Antony Pinto. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-358 RESPONDENT-358
(Defendant Nos.355 to 358 are
residing at Kannagudde House,
Padil Post, Mangalore - 575007.)

S/o Late John D’Souza. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-359 RESPONDENT-359
360. Alvita D’Souza,

W/o Henry D’Souza. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-360 RESPONDENT-360
361. Mr. Vincent D’costa,

S/o Late Ignatius D’Souza. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-361 RESPONDENT-361
42 R.A.No.30/2011
362. Cyprian Fernandes,

S/o Late Albert Fernandes. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-362 RESPONDENT-362
363. Asumpta Fernandes,

W/o Cyprian Fernandes. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-363 RESPONDENT-363
364. Mollin Crasta,

W/o Francis Crasta. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-364 RESPONDENT-364
365. Mr. Alwyn Tauro,

S/o Leo Tauro,
R/at Karpinar House, Padil Postr,
366. Mrs. Laveena Lobo,

W/o Oswald Lobo,
R/at Kannagudha, Padil Post,
Alape Village, Mangalore - 575007.NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-366 RESPONDENT-366
43
367. Mr. Oswald Lobo,

S/o J.B. Lobo,
R/at Kannagudha, Padil Post,
Alape Village, Mangalore - 575007.NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-367 RESPONDENT-367
368. Basil S Rodrigues,

S/o. N. Rodrigues,
R/at Sirilapadev, 1st Cross,
Kulshekar, Mangalore – 575005.NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-368 RESPONDENT-368
369. Mabel Rodrigues,

W/o Basil Rodrigues,
R/at Sirilapadev, 1st Cross,
Kulshekar, Mangalore - 575005.NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-369 RESPONDENT-369
370. Nancy Menezes,

W/o Charles Menezes,
R/at Padav Village, Kakkebettu House,
371. Mary Lobo,

W/o Baptist Lobo,
372. Rosy Lobo,

W/o Joseph Bernad Lasardo,
R/at Padav Village, Castelino Colony,
Shaktinagar Post, Mangalore - 575016. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-372 RESPONDENT-372
43 R.A.No.30/2011
373. Jerald D’Souza,

S/o Lawrence D’Souza,
R/at Peruvai Village, Adka House,
Peruvai Post, Bantwal Taluk. D.K. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-373 RESPONDENT-373
374. Stany D’Souza,

R/at Padau Village, Kakkebettu House,
44
375. Judith D’Souza,

W/o Stany D’Souza,
376. Nanita Pinto,

W/o Dolphy Pinto,
377. Daphy Pinto,

D/o Dolphy Pinto,
R/at Thari Padav Village, Kakkebettu House,
378. Marchine D’Souza,

W/o Stany Pereira,
Kulshekar Post, Mangalore - 575005.NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-378 RESPONDENT-378
379. Bajil Sylvestar Mendonca,

S/o Thomas Mendonca,
R/at Alape Village,
Suryanagar, Alape, Mangalore. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-379 RESPONDENT-379
380. Joseph Lasrado,

S/o Salvadore lasrado,
R/at Padav Village, Castelino Colony,
Shaktinagar Post, Mangalore - 575016.NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-380 RESPONDENT-380
381. Sushan J. D’Souza,

S/o Stany D’Souza,
382. Elveera Pinto,

W/o Alwyn Pinto,
Kulshekar Post, Mangalore -575005. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-382 RESPONDENT-382
44 R.A.No.30/2011
383. Stany Fereira,

45

S/o Madthin Pereira,
384. Mrs. Perpetual Jose,

W/o Vincent Jose,
R/at Padau Village,
385. C.D. Jose,

S/o Devasya Jose,
R/at Padav Village,
386. Jerald D’Cunha,

S/o Lawerence D’Cunha,
R/at Padav Village,
387. Richard William Noronha,

S/o Late Joseph Noronha,
R/at Padav Village,
388. Celine Lizzy Noronha,

W/o Robert M Noronha,
R/at Padav Village,
389. Mrs. Jacintha Pinto,

W/o Lancelot Pinto,
R/at Padav Village,
Kulshekar Post, Mangalore - 575005. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-389 ESPONDENT-389
390. Mrs. E.L. Sarrao,

W/o Harry Serrao,
R/at Padav Village, Neerudpe,
391. Mr. John Fernandes,

S/o Late Thomas Fernandes,
46
R/at ‘Derbois’, Sirlapadppu House,

Kulshekar Post, Manglaore - 575005. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-391 RESPONDENT-391
392. Mrs. Carmine D’Souza,

aged 66 years,
W/o Late Philip Pinto,
R/at Kotimura,
45 R.A.No.30/2011
393. Ms. Rashmi Sheethal D’Souza,

aged 49 years,
S/o late Camil D’ Souza,
R/at Kotimura House,
394. Mr. Ronald D’Souza,

aged 49 years,
S/o late Camil D’ Souza,
R/at Kotimura House,
395. Mr. John B. D’Cunha,

S/o P.M. D’Cunha,
R/at Silva Gate House, Padavu Village,
396. Mrs. Jacintha D’Cunha,

W/o John B. D’Cunha,
R/at Silva Gate House, Padavu Village,
397. Mrs. Agnes A. Albuquerque,

aged 51 years,
W/o Alex G. Albuquerque,
R/at Kulshekar Padavu, Silva Gate,
398. Mr. Alex G. Albuquerque,

aged 62 years,
S/o late Joseph Albuquerque,
R/at Kulshekar Padavu, Silva Gate,
399. Mr. Victor L. D’Cunha,

aged 57 years,
S/o late Joseph D’Cunha,
R/at Neeradpe, Kulshekar Post,
Padavu House, Mangalore - 575005. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-399 RESPONDENT-399
47
400. Mrs. Jacintha D’Cunha,

aged 55 years,
W/o Mr. Victor L. D’Cunha,
401. Mr. Victor D’Cunha,

aged 56 years,
S/o late John Jacob D’Cunha,
402. Mrs. Nancy Jacob,

aged 59 years,
W/o Mr. Jacob Neeliyara,
R/at Neeliyara House, Dairy Road,
Kulshekar Post, Padavu Village,
46 R.A.No.30/2011
403. Mr. Alfred Mascarenhas,

aged 75 years,
S/o late Martin Mascarenhas,
R/at Kotimura, Kulshekar,
Padavu Village, Mangalore - 575005.NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-403 RESPONDENT-403
404. Mrs. Lilly Mascarenhas,

aged 65 years,
W/o Mr. Alfred Mascarenhas,
405. Mrs. Veera Mascarenhas,

aged 34 years,
W/o Ivan Mascarenhas,
406. Mr. Oswald Lobo,

aged 55 years,
S/o Thomas Lobo,
R/at Kalpane House, Padavu Village,
407. Mrs. Eveline Lobo,

aged 51 years,
W/o Oswald Lobo,
48
408. Mrs. Dicy Monis,

aged 44 years,
W/o Charles Lobo,
409. Mr. Charles Lobo,

aged 52 years,
S/o Thomas Lobo,
410. Mrs. Christine Lobo,

aged 91 years,
W/o Thomas Lobo,
411. Mrs. Joyee Noronha,

aged 52 years,
W/o Walter Noronha,
R/at ‘Simon Nivas’, Sarakody Padavu,
47 R.A.No.30/2011
412. Mr. Ashwin L. Noronha,

aged 24 years,
S/o Walter Noronha,
R/at ‘Simon Nivas’, Sarakody Padavu,
413. Mr. Sheldon V. D’Silva,

aged 19 years,
S/o Denis A. D’Silva,
R/at ‘Denida’, D.No.14-117/1,
Padavu, Sarakody,
414. Mrs. Juliana D’Souza,

aged 48 years,
W/o Valerian M. D’Souza,
R/at ‘Maria Nilaya’,
Cirlapadpu, Alape Village,
415. Elizabeth R. D’Silva,

aged 49 years,
49
R/at ‘Eden’, Kuchikad,

416. Mrs. Celestine D’Souza,

aged 52 years,
W/o Michael D’Souza,
D.No.1031/2, Mugrodi House,
417. Mr. Stany Mendonca,

aged 47 years,
S/o late Jerome Mendonca,
R/at ‘Christa Jyothi’,
Padavu, Kuchikad,
418. Mrs. Evelyn Mendonca,

aged 33 years,
W/o Ronald Mendonca,
R/at ‘Ave Cottage’,
Padavu Kuchikad,
419. Mrs. Maria D’Souza,

aged 36 years,
W/o Mr. Patric D’Souza,
R/at Inflow House,
Padavu Kuchikad,
420. Mrs. Emilda D’Silva,

aged 53 years,
W/o Denis A. D’Silva,
R/at ‘Denida’, D.No.14-117/1,
Sarakody, Padavu,
48 R.A.No.30/2011
421. Mr. Vikram B. D’Souza,

aged 19 years,
S/o Valerian M. D’Souza,
R/at ‘Maria Nilaya’, Cirlapadpu,
422. Mr. Henry D. D’Souza,

aged 45 years,
W/o late Jacob D. Almeida,
R/at ‘Almeida Cottage’, Sarakody,
50
423. Mr. Valerian Norbert D’Souza,

aged 59 years,
S/o latee Baptist D’Souza,
R/at ‘Vale Cote’,
Padavu, Kuchikad,
424. Mrs. E. Lilly D’Souza,

aged 58 years,
W/o Valerian Norbert D’Souza,
R/at ‘Vale Cote’,
Padavu, Kuchikad,
425. Mr. Dopphy D’Souza,

S/o Joseph D’Souza,
R/at ‘Little Star’, Ullal Bail Post,
Ullal, Mangalore - 575020. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-425 RESPONDENT-425
425. Judith Lobo,

D/o Antony Lobo,
R/at Ullal Bail Post,
426. Aaron Joy D’Souza,

S/o Herman D’Souza,
R/at ‘Joy Vihar’, Ullal Bail Post,
427. Vincent D’Souza,

S/o Ladin D’Souza,
428. Mr. Urban,

429. Demetris D’Souza,

S/o late Philip D’Souza,
R/at Ullal, Haji, Permanur Post,
49 R.A.No.30/2011
430. Mrs. Janet Monteiro,

W/o Bartam Monteiro,
R/at Uliya Moneppu,
Permanur Post, Mangalore. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-431 RESPONDENT-431
51
431. Mrs. Felcy Monteiro,

W/o Ivan Monteiro,
R/at Margathale Ullal Village,
Permanur Post, Mangalore. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT- 432 RESPONDENT- 432
432. Mrs. Gracy F. Rodrigues,

W/o Fedrick Rodrigues,
R/at Sunshine, Manchila,
Permanur Post, Mangalore. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-433 RESPONDENT-433
433. Mrs. Leena D’Souza,

W/o Willium D’Souza,
R/at Ullal Bail, near Over Bridge,
434. Mrs. Shanthi D’Souza,

W/o Lawrence D’Souza,
R/at Ullal Bail, near Over Bridge,
435. Mrs. Elizabeth Lobo,

W/o Robert Lobo,
R/at ‘Lobo Vihar’, Ullal Bail,
436. Mrs. Lilly Pinto,

W/o Vincent Pinto,
R/at ‘Laveena Villa’,
Ullal Bail, Ullal Post, Mangalore. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-437 RESPONDENT-437
437. Mrs. Janet D’Souza,

W/o John Maxim Veigas,
R/at Maria Kripa House,
Ullal Bail, Ullal Post, Mangalore. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-438 RESPONDENT-438
438. Mrs. Helen D’Souza,

W/o Charles D’Souza,
R/at C.H. Villa, Ullal Bail,
439. Mr. Antony Steven Veigas,

S/o Robert Veigas,
R/at Kuthar Padau,
Unnur Post, Ranipura - 575017. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-440 RESPONDENT-440
50 R.A.No.30/2011
440. Mr. Victor Lobo,

S/o Victor Lobo,
52
R/at Agathimar House,

Amtady Post, Bantwal - 574211. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-441 RESPONDENT-441
441. Mr. Maxim Norbert Menezes,

S/o Albert Menezes,
R/at Albert Menezes,
Shirva Post, Udupi. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-442 RESPONDENT-442

S/o Clement D’Souza,
R/at Ullal Bail,
443. Mrs. Plevy D’Souza,

W/o Leo D’Souza,
R/at Ranipura Village, Munnur Post,
Permanur, Mangalore - 575017. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-444 RESPONDENT-444
444. Mr. Titus D’Souza,

R/at Chembugudde,
445. Mr. Dona Veigas,

R/at Chembugudde,
446. Mr. Naveen D’Souza,

R/at Chembugudde,
447. Mr. Felcian D’Souza,

S/o Clement D’Souza,
R/at Chembugudde,
448. Mr. Jeevan D’Souza,

S/o James D’Souza,
R/at Hora Kudru Padpu,
449. Mr. Stany D’Souza,

S/o Francis D’Souza,
R/at Queen Mary Villa,
51 R.A.No.30/2011
450. Mr. Jerald D’Souza,

R/at Rosario Church Compound,
53
451. Mr. Pauline D’Souza,

452. Eliza D’Souza,

453. Ida Kutinha,

454. Mr. Joachim Kutinha,

455. Marcel Fernandes,

R/at Seva Vista Apartment, Rosario
Church Road, Mangalore - 575001. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-456 RESPONDENT-456
456. C.J. Wilson,

S/o C.P. Joseph,
R/at Sea Vista Apartment, Flat No.303,
Rosario Church Road,
457. K.J. Pinto,

S/o J.S. Pinto,
458. Juliana D’Souza,

W/o Alex D’Souza,

460. Vinitha D’Souza,

R/at Ave Maria, Rosario Church Road,
54
52 R.A.No.30/2011
461. Molly D’Souza,

R/at Ave Maria, Rosario Church Road,
462. Rosy D’Silva,

R/at Rosy Villa, Rosario Church Road,
463. Gilbert D’Silva,

R/at Rose Villa, Rosario Church Road,
464. Mabel D’Silva,

R/at Rose Villa, Rosario Church Road,
465. Marceline Pereira,

W/o Philip J. Pereira,
R/at Jenna Ghar, Trimoorthy Layout,
466. Philip J. Pereira,

467. Melissa Pereira,

468. Jenifer Mary D’Souza,

W/o Peter D’Souza,
R/at ‘Christ Light’, Doomappa Compound,
469. Peter D’Souza,

R/at ‘Christ Light’, Doomappa Compound,
470. Francis John D’Souza,

Bencil Correa Compound,
471. Treeza D’Souza,

Bencil Correa Compound,
472. Allen Fernandes,

55
R/at B/502, Julie Bagh Apartments,

473. Rita Fernandes,

53 R.A.No.30/2011
474. Rian Fernandes,

475. Hilda Pais,

R/at Fernandes Compound,
476. Lynette D’Souza,

R/at Fernandes Compound,
477. Florine D’Souza,

aged 51 years, Christian,
W/o Denis D’Souza,
R/at 4A, Sturruck Apartment, Falnir,
478. Silva Fernandes,

W/o Jude Fernandes,
R/at Flat No.104, Milagris Castle,
479. Blossom Y.A. Vaz,

W/o Lloyd Vaz,
R/at Shanthi Bhuvan, Sturrock Road,
Falnir, Mangalore. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-480 RESPONDENT-480
480. Florine Fernandes,

W/o Robert Fernandes,
R/at Paradise House, Lobo Lane,
Attavar, Mangalore. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-481 RESPONDENT-481
481. Flavia Lewis,

W/o Ivan Lewis,
R/at 17-11-849,
Attavar, Mangalore. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-482 RESPONDENT-482
56
482. Grazy Vaz,

W/o Hubert Vaz,
R/at 17-10-622, B.V. Road Attavar,
483. Hubert Vaz,

R/at 17-10-622, B.V. Road Attavar,
484. Ronald S. Coelho,

R/at Attavar Park Apartment,
S-1, Opposite Attavar KMC Dental Hospital,
54 R.A.No.30/2011
485. Jacintha D’Souza,

R/at Vijetha,
M.G. Road, Mangalore - 1. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-486 RESPONDENT-486
486. Theresa Pinto,

R/near Hebeck Institute, Mission Compound,
Balmatta, Mangalore. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-487 RESPONDENT-487
487. Mrs. Anitha D’Souza,

W/o Ivan D’Souza,
R/at JMJ Compound,
Attavar, Mangalore - 1. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-488 RESPONDENT-488
488. Mrs. Norma Mascarenhas,

aged 42 years,
W/o Felix Mascarenhas,
R/at Emmanuel,
Attavar 1st Cross, Mangalore. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-489 RESPONDENT-489
489. Joseph Camillus D’Souza,

R/at 101, Lobo Prabhu Court,
490. Ronald D’Souza,

R/at Melina Mogaru,
57
Attavar, Mangalore - 2. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-491 RESPONDENT-491
491. Anil Rodrigues,

R/at St. Antony Ward,
492. Mr. Lionel Oswald Pinto,

S/o late Charles Pinto,
R/at Pinto Lay,
Opp. Syndicate Bank,
Kinnigoli, Mangalore. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-493 RESPONDENT-493
493. Mr. George Saldanha,

S/o Peter Lawrence Saldanha,
R/at Namo Maria, Talipady Village,
Kinnigoli Post, Mangalore - 574150. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-494 RESPONDENT-494
494. Mrs. Philomena Sequeira,

W/o Joachim J. Sequeira,
R/at Navanagara, Goliyar Road,
Kinnigoli, Mangalore - 574150. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-495 RESPONDENT-495
495. Mrs. Janet Melita D’Souza,

W/o Cyprian D’Souza,
R/at God’s Gift, Appanakody,
55 R.A.No.30/2011
496. Mr. Robert D’Mello,

S/o L. Apoline D’Mello,
R/at Bittul House,
497. Mr. Robert Lobo,

S/o Simon Lobo,
R/at Perpetual Villa,
Padmanoor, Mangalore - 574150. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-498 RESPONDENT-498
498. Mr. Vincent Rodrigues,

S/o Santhan Rodrigues,
58
R/at Sacred Heart Home,

Kemarade House, Mannabettu Village,
499. Mrs. Margaret Aranha,

W/o Michael Aranha,
R/at ‘Marvel’, 4-78, Birrnakodi,
Kinnigoli Post, Talipady Grama,
500. Mr. Valerian A. D’Souza,

R/at Vavia Mansion,

aged 58 years,
S/o R. D’Souza,
R/at Upper Nekkare, Pedamale Post,
Neermarga, Mangalore. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-502 RESPONDENT-502
502. Ms. Lucy D’Souza,

aged 66 years,
D/o Martin Pinto,
R/at Pilikumari House,
Kudupu Post, Mangalore. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-503 RESPONDENT-503
503. Mr. Charles Mathias,

aged 69 years,
S/o Bernard Mathias,
R/at near Kelarai Church,
504. Mrs. Gracy D’Souza,

aged 52 years,
R/at ‘Sabeil’, D’Souza View, Padavinangadi,
Konchady Post, Mangalore - 575008. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-505 RESPONDENT-505
56 R.A.No.30/2011
505. Mr. John D’Souza,

aged 28 years,
S/o Antony D’Souza,
R/at Barabail,
Vamadapadav - 574324. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-506 RESPONDENT-506
506. Mr. Albert D’Souza,

59
aged 37 years,
S/o Francis D’Souza,
R/at Vamadapadav - 574324. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-507 RESPONDENT-507
507. Mrs. Leena Fernandes,

aged 35 years,
W/o Walter Fernandes,
R/at Karimale,
508. Mr. Amborse Walder,

aged 52 years,
R/at A.G. Villa,
Vamadapadav. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-509 RESPONDENT-509
509. Mrs. Juliana Pinto,

aged 53 years,
R/at Kenrol Villa, Siddakatte Post,
Bantwal Taluk, D.K. - 574237. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-510 RESPONDENT-510
510. Ms. Leena Sunitha Veigas,

aged 30 years,
W/o Albert D’Souza,
R/at Kalpana House,
Vamadapadav Post. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-511 RESPONDENT-511
511. Ms. Prescilla Monteiro,

aged 38 years,
D/o Annie Monteiro,
R/near Kelarai Church,
Pedamale post, Mangalore - 575029.NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-512 RESPONDENT-512
512. Ms. Florine D’Souza,

aged 43 years,
D/o Hilary Mendonca,
R/at Hill Shelter, near Kelarai Church,
Kelarai - 575029. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-513 RESPONDENT-513
513. Mr. Valerian Fernandes,

aged 40 years,
S/o Mary Fernandes,
R/at Karimale,
514. Mr. Oswald Crasta,

aged 45 years,
S/o Francis Crasta,
R/at Vamadapadav - 574324. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-515 RESPONDENT-515
60
515. Mrs. Pauline Pinto,

aged 46 years,
R/at Vas Villa, Siddakatte Post,
Bantwal Taluk - 574237. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-516 RESPONDENT-516
516. Mrs. Cicilia Lobo,

aged 68 years,
W/o Francis Saldanha,
R/at Mavinakatte House,
57 R.A.No.30/2011
517. Mr. Edmond D’Souza,

aged 60 years,
H/o. Apoline Fernandes,
R/at Vamadapadav House and Post,
518. Mrs. Apoline Fernandes,

aged 49 years,
W/o Edmond D’Souza,
R/at Vamadapadav House and Post,
519. Mrs. Cynthia Cutinho,

aged 62 years,
R/at ‘Anna Dale’,
near Kelarai Church, Pedamale Post,
Neermarga, Mangalore. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-520 RESPONDENT-520
520. Mrs. Agnes Mathias,

aged 62 years,
D/o Lawrence Menezes,
R/near Kelarai Church,
521. Mrs. Joan Lobo,

aged 56 years,
R/at Jaijith, near Kelarai Church,
522. Mr. Joseph Sequeira,

aged 38 years,
S/o late Peter Sequeira,
R/at Os.Vin Villa, Kumblu House,
523. Mr. Baptist Fernandes,

aged 50 years,
61
S/o late Peter Fernandes,

R/at Divya NIvas,
Pedamale Post, Mangalore – 29. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-524 RESPONDENT-524
524. Mr. Lancy Sequeira,

aged 54 years,
S/o late Basil Sequeira,
R/at Mangikundow House, Pedamale Post,
Neermarga, Mangalore - 575029. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-525 RESPONDENT-525
525. Mr. Louis Lobo,

aged 50 years,
H/o Emilda Lobo,
R/at Balayesh Nagar,
Karimale, Vamadapadav - 575324. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-526 RESPONDENT-526
526. Mr. Bernard Serao,

aged 51 years,
Kukkipady, Vamadapadav - 574324. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-527 RESPONDENT-527
527. Mr. Fedrick Fernandes,

aged 55 years,
S/o Maurice Fernandes,
58 R.A.No.30/2011
528. Mr. Wilfred Saldanha,

aged 31 years,
S/o Francis Saldanha,
529. Mr. Raymond Monteiro,

aged 43 years,
H/o Engem Monteiro,
R/at Milady House,
Bantwal - 574324. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-530 RESPONDENT-530
530. Mr. Walter Felix D’Souza,

S/o late David D’Souza,
R/at D.D. Souza Compound,
Paduperar Post, Bajpe - 574142. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-531 RESPONDENT-531
531. Mr. Fabian Pais,

aged 22 years,
S/o. Francis Pais.
R/at Bajpe. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-532 RESPONDENT-532
62
532. Mr. Stephen Lawrence Pinto,

aged 26 years,
S/o. Martin Pinto,
533. Mr. Preetham Amith,

aged 20 years,
S/o. Late Paul D’Cunha,
534. Mr. Santhosh D’Tauro,

aged 25 years,
S/o. Jospeph Tauro,
535. Mr. Valerian Crasta,

S/o Late Cyprian Crasta,
R/at Palthody House, Bajpe. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-536 RESPONDENT-536
536. Mr. Praveen Rodrigues,

aged 27 years,
S/o. J.B Rodrigues,
R/at Kaikamba Beson Compound,
Post Kinnikambla. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-537 RESPONDENT-537
537. Mr. Rony D’Souza,

S/o Alex D’Souza,
R/at Kunjody House,
Kolambe Post, Bajpe. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-538 RESPONDENT-538
538. Mr. Rolin Alexander Cunha,

aged 32 years,
S/o Joseph Peter Cunha,
539. Mr. Prakash D’Souza,

aged 29 years,
S/o Lawrence D’Souza,
59 R.A.No.30/2011
540. Mr. Santhosh Mascarenhas,

aged 28 years,
S/o. Raphal Mascarenhas,
541. Mr. Ruben D’ Souza,

aged 20 years,
63
S/o Irene D’Souza,

542. Mr. Linet Kiran D’ Souza,

W/o Kiran D’Souza,
R/at Rajshree Building,
Muranagar, Bajpe - 574142. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-543 RESPONDENT-543
543. Mr. Stany D’ Souza,

S/o. Sebastian D’Souza,
R/at Kunjody House,
Kolambe Post,
Bajpe - Mangalore - 574189. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-544 RESPONDENT-544
544. Mrs. Victoria Vaz,

aged 66 years,
D/o Late Francis Fernandes,
R/at Deo Gratius Lower Urwa,
Ashoknagar, Manglaore - 575006. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-545 RESPONDENT-545
545. Mrs. Estella D’Souza,

aged 65 years,
R/at Rego Compound, Matadakani Road,
Boloor, Mangalore - 575006. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-546 RESPONDENT-546
546. Mr. Rena Sequeira,

aged 44 years,
D/o. William Sequeira,
R/at Palmora Matadakani III Cross Road,
Boloor, Ashoknagar Post,
547. Mr.Ludel Sequeira,

aged 51 years,
D/o. Willam Sequeira,
R/at Palmora Matadakani III cross Road,
548. Mrs. Agnes Sequeira,

aged 79 years,
W/o. Willam Sequeira,
549. Mr. Willam Sequeira,

aged 85 years,
S/o. Late Jerome Aloysius Sequeira,
64

60 R.A.No.30/2011
550. Mr. Hilary S. D’Souza,

aged 53 years,
S/o Kanvety D’Cunha,
R/at Ashirwad, Kandet 1st Cross,
Eliza Bai Compound, Urwa Store,
551. Mrs. Celine Pinto,

aged 49 years,
W/o Ronald Pinto,
R/at ‘Luben House’, Mannagudda Barke,
552. Mr. Norbert Tauro,

aged 56 years,
S/o. L. Louis Tauro,
R/at Berora, Bockapatna, Lower Bollor,
553. Mr. Felcy D’Souza,

aged 52 years,
W/o. Joseph D’Souza,
R/at Gem Castle Ashok Nagar,
Manglaore - 575003. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-554 RESPONDENT-554
554. Ms. Felcy Alvares,

aged 65 years,
D/o Thoma Alvares,
R/at Kandet House, Ashok Nagar Post,
555. Ms. Ida Pinto,

aged 46 years,
D/o Aloysius Pinto,
R/at Ashirwad, 1st A. Cross Road,
Mannagudda, Mangalore - 575003. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-556 RESPONDENT-556
556. Mrs. Dulcine Patrao,

aged 63 years,
W/o Gratian Patrao,
R/at Grace View, Marappa Colony,
Bockapatna, Mangalore - 3. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-557 RESPONDENT-557
65
557. Mrs. Celine Lobo,

aged 38 years,
D/o late Thomas D’Souza,
R/at Roshini Cold Storage, Urwa Store,
558. Mrs. Jacintha Saldanha,

aged 52 years,
W/o Joseph Saldanha,
R/at Urwa Mari Gudi, Ashoknagar,
559. Mrs. S. Latha Lobo,

aged 52 years,
W/o Michael Lobo,
R/at ‘Lobo Villa’, Alake, Lobo Compound,
61 R.A.No.30/2011
560. Mr. Adrian Dantis,

aged 45 years,
S/o Bernad Dantis,
R/at 105, Venus Apartment, Springs Field,
561. Mrs. Anita Cutinha,

aged 42 years,
W/o Melwyn Cutinha,
R/at ‘Chris’, near Malaraya Temple Road,
562. Mrs. Irene D’Souza,

aged 55 years,
W/o late Cyril D’Souza,
R/at Ashoknagar,
563. Mr. Vincent D’Souza,

aged 59 years,
S/o late B. D’Souza,
R/at Kala Kuteer,
564. Ms. Mabel Rodrigues,

aged 32 years,
R/at Celine Villa, Ashok nagar,
565. Mr. Brian Gonsalves,

66
aged 43 years,
S/o A.J. Gonsalves,
R/at Door No.7/3/452, Boloor,
Jarandaya Temple Road,
566. Mrs. Sarita Gonsalves,

aged 38 years,
W/o Brian Gonsalves,
R/at Door No.7/3/452,
Jarandaya Temple Road, Boloor,
567. Mrs. Auriel Pais,

aged 68 years,
W/o Archilbald Pais,
R/at Pais Eden, Boloor,
568. Mr. Archibald Pais,

aged 71 years,
S/o Simon Pascal Pais,
R/at Pais Eden, Boloor,
569. Mr. Antony Sylvester D’Souza,

aged 72 years,
S/o Balthazar D’Souza,
R/at H.No.7-1-16/1, Gemini,
62 R.A.No.30/2011
570. Mrs. Rosemarie D’Souza,

aged 62 years,
W/o Antony Sylvester D’Souza,
R/at H.No.7-1-16/1, Gemini,
571. Mr. Wilfred Goveas,

aged 63 years,
B2 Mahalasa Apartments, Gandhinagar,
8th Cross, Mangalore - 575003. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-572 RESPONDENT-572
572. Mrs. Jenevive B. Mathias,

aged 52 years,
W/o F.C. Mathias,
R/at ‘Joe-Shi’ Hillgrove, Chilimbi,
67
573. Mrs. Gertruede Mascarenhas,

aged 60 years,
W/o C.J. Mascarenhas,
R/at Fragrance, Sequeira Lane,
Lower Urwa, Mangalore - 575006. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-574 RESPONDENT-574
574. Mr. Frank Hilary D’Souza,

aged 55 years,
S/o Dominic D’Souza,
R/at Priyaghar Main Road, Madanthar,
Belthangady Taluk - 574224. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-575 RESPONDENT-575
575. Mr. Balthazar D’Souza,

aged 60 years,
S/o Joseph D’Souza,
R/at Jeppinamogaru,
576. Mr. Praveen Prakash Crasta,

aged 25 years,
S/o Gabriel Crasta,
R/at Kokkechal House,
Uppala, Kasaragod - 671322. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-577 RESPONDENT-577
577. Mrs. Hycintha Saldanha,

aged 57 years,
W/o Francis Saldanha,
R/at Behind Patro Traders,
Ashoknagar, Mangalore - 575006. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-578 RESPONDENT-578
578. Mrs. Sheila Baptist,

aged 46 years,
W/o Antony Madtha,
R/at No.7 Gulshan Apartment,
Dr. Mascarenhas Lane, Kankanady,
579. Mrs. Florine Pereira,

aged 47 years,
W/o Patrick Pinto,
R/at Block - B, 70, Divya Paradise, Bejai,
Kapikad, Mangalore - 575004. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-580 RESPONDENT-580
63 R.A.No.30/2011
580. Mr. Rajesh V.A. Lasrado,

aged 43 years,
S/o late Francis Lasrado,
R/at ‘Immanuel’, Lasrado Compound,
Ladyhill, Urwa,
68
581. Mrs. Maria Saldanha,

aged 37 years,
H/o Melwyn Saldanha,
R/at ‘Eosmos’, National Boloor,
582. Mr. Herald Sequeira,

aged 65 years,
S/o late Joseph Sequeira,
Sequeira Sadan, Urwa,
Ashoknagar Post, Mangalore. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-583 RESPONDENT-583
583. Mr. Joseph Lobo,

aged 49 years,
S/o late Michal Lobo,
R/at Opp: Prasanna Traders, Shediguri,
584. Mrs. Nancy J. Coelho,

aged 61 years,
W/o Melwyn Coelho,
R/at B-3, Narayani Apartment,
8th Cross, Gandhinagar,
585. Mrs. Jacintha Fernandes,

aged 48 years,
W/o Canute Fermandes,
R/at Kumar Residency, II Floor,
Lady Hill, Mangalore - 575006. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-586 RESPONDENT-586
586. Mr. Victor D’Mello,

aged 47 years,
S/o Francis D’Mello,
R/at Immaculate Conception Church,
Urwa Ladyhill,
587. Mr. Baptis Mascarenhas,

aged 69 years,
S/o late Peter Mascarenhas,
R/near Urwa Stores,
588. Mr. Francic D’Cunha,

aged 59 years,
S/o late Sabastian D’Cunha,
69
R/at 8th Cross Road, Gandhinagar,

589. Mrs. Celine Saldanha,

aged 58 years,
W/o Cyril Saldanha,
R/at Sirerlro Palace, 4th Floor,
Hathill, Lalbagh. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-590 RESPONDENT-590
64 R.A.No.30/2011
590. Mrs. Evet Lobo,

aged 41 years,
D/o Ignatius Lobo,
R/near Palmvihar, Urwa Store,
591. Mr. Hilary D’Souza,

aged 62 years,
S/o Adam D’Souza,
R/at 202, Fortune Pride,
Pais Hill, Bejai,
592. Mr. Ronald Lobo,

aged 57 years,
S/o late Thomas Lobo,
R/at Lobo Compound,
Alake, Mangalore - 575003. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-593 RESPONDENT-593
593. Mrs. Wenita Monteiro,

aged 48 years,
W/o Joseph Monteiro,
R/at Ashoknagar, 1st Cross, Urwa Store,
594. Mrs. Cynthia D’Souza,

W/o Leo D’Souza,
R/at Kotekani Road, Ashoknagar Post,
595. Mrs. Precilla Veigas,

aged 49 years,
W/o Herald Veigas,
R/at ‘Donida Villa’,
Matadakani, 1st Cross,
596. Mrs. Hilda Lobo,

aged 53 years,
70
W/o Denis Lobo,

R/at ‘Denhil’, Kambla Cross Road,
597. Mis. Sharrel Lobo,

aged 25 years,
D/o Denis Lobo,
R/at ‘Denhil’, Kambla Cross Road,
598. Mrs. Lilly Furtado,

aged 54 years,
W/o Peter Furtado,
R/at Bharathi Heights,
Chilimbi, Mangalore - 575006. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-599 RESPONDENT-599
599. Mrs. Anita Sherry,

aged 46 years,
W/o Ronald Sherry,
R/at ‘Sherlleys’, Kottara,
65 R.A.No.30/2011
600. Mrs. Lawrence Saldanha,

aged 65 years,
S/o late Casmir Saldanha,
R/near Urwa Marigudi,
601. Mrs. Julian Tellis,

aged 55 years,
W/o Franky Tellis,
R/at ‘Frajul’, Pais Hill, Ladyhill II Cross,
602. Ms. Grace Lasrado,

aged 65 years,
D/o Felix Lasrado,
R/near Urwa Church
603. Mrs. Carmine D’Almeida,

aged 59 years,
D/o late Kasmir D’Almeida,
R/at Guru Prasad Lane, Valencia,
604. Sr. Lavina Anitha Veigas,

71
aged 30 years,
R/at Ladyhill Convent, Urwa,
605. Sr. Philomina A.C.,

aged 33 years,
D/o John D’Souza,
R/at Ladyhill, Convent, Urwa,
Ashoknagar, Mangalore - 575 006. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-606 RESPONDENT-606
606. Mr. Deepak D’Cunha,

aged 32 years,
R/at Green View, Ashoknagar Post,
607. Mr. Lanwin Lobo,

aged 25 years,
S/o Leo Lobo,
R/at M-205, Mars & Venus Apts,
Spring Fields, Chilimbi,
608. Mrs. Lizzie Pinto,

aged 60 years,
W/o Clifford Pinto,
R/at Boloor, ‘Lanka’,
609. Mr. Cyril Crasta,

aged 27 years,
S/o. Mr. Felix Crasta,
C/o. Immaculate Conception Church,
Urwa, Ladyhill, Mangalore - 575006. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-610 RESPONDENT-610
610. Mr. Peter Futhado,

aged 62 years,
S/o. Late Joseph Futhado,
R/at 105, Bharathi Hights,
66 R.A.No.30/2011
611. Mrs. Juliet D’Cunha,

aged 49 years,
W/o Hillary F. D’Cunha,
R/at Ashirwad, Urwa Store,
Kandet, Mangalore - 575006. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-612 RESPONDENT-612
612. Mrs. Moly D’Souza,

aged 52 years,
72
W/o Alwyn D’Souza,

R/at ‘Ashok’, Ashoknagar Junction,
613. Mis. Ashwini Veigas,

aged 21 years,
D/o Late Herald Veigas,
R/at Boloor, 1st Cross,
Mangalore - 575 006. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-614 RESPONDENT-614
614. Mrs. Dorothy D’Souza,

aged 57 years,
W/o Augustine D’Souza,
R/at Nathal Mary Compound,
Urwastore, Mangalore - 575006. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-615 RESPONDENT-615
615. Mrs. Juliet D’Cunha,

aged 57 years,
W/o Vincent D’Cunha,
R/at ‘Green View’,
P.O. Ashoknagar, Mangalore - 575006. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-616 RESPONDENT-616
616. Mrs. Jacintha D’Souza,

aged 49 years,
W/o Vincent D’Souza,
R/at Little Star Apts., Urwa Store,
617. Mrs. Flecita Miranda,

aged 52 years,
W/o. Edwin Miranda,
R/at Miranda Compound, Matadakani,
Boloor, Mangalore - 575 003. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-618 RESPONDENT-618
618. Mrs. Gretta Lobo,

aged 63 years,
W/o Ignatius Lobo,
R/at Near Prem Vihar,
Urwastore, Mangalore - 575006. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-619 RESPONDENT-619
619. Mrs. Celine Pereira,

aged 56 years,
W/o Late Elfred Pereira,
R/at Salvadore Villa, Chilimbi,
620. Mrs. Mabel Cunha,

aged 72 years,
W/o Sebastian Cunha,
73
R/at J.J. Crasta, Chilimbi,

Manglaore - 575006. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-621 RESPONDENT-621
67 R.A.No.30/2011
621. Helen D’Souza,

aged 68 years,
W/o Late. J. D’Souza,
R/at Matadakani 1st Cross, Jarandaya Temple Road,
Urwa, Mangalore. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-622 RESPONDENT-622
622. Alwyn Pinto,

aged 66 years,
S/o Maurice Pinto,
R/at Garden Manor, Sulthan Battery Road,
623. Sr. Celine Vera A.C.,

aged 55 years,
D/o Xavier D’Souza,
R/at Ladyhill Convent,
624. Sr. Dora D’Souza,

aged 28 years,
D/o Late Albert D’Souza,
R/at Lady Hill Convent,
625. Sr. Maria Swarupa A.C,

D/o Late Alphose D’Souza,
626. Sr. Regin A.C.,

aged 66 years,
D/o Camil Lasrado,
627. Mrs. Flavy Veena Lasrado,

aged 34 years,
D/o late Lawrence Lasrado,
R/behind Patrao Traders, Ashoknagar,

aged 41 years,
D/o late Ignatius D’Souza,
74
R/at Flat No.304, Bharathi Heights,

629. Sr. Mary Jane A.C.,

aged 65 years,
D/o Alex Serrao,
R/at Lady Hill Convent, Ashoknagar Post,
630. Sr. Mary Tara A.C.,

aged 65 years,
D/o Alex Serrao,
68 R.A.No.30/2011
631. Sr. M. Marcellita A.C.,

aged 82 years,
D/o Louis Rego,
632. Sr. Pramila D’Souza, A.C.,

aged 27 years,
D/o Maria D’Souza,
633. Sr. Judith Frank A.C.,

aged 23 years,
D/o late Albert Frank,
634. Sr. Gracy Lobo A.C.,

aged 32 years,
D/o Denis Lobo,
635. Sr. Alena A.C.,

aged 50 years,
D/o Salvadore Mathias,
636. Sr. N. Ruthiha A.C.,

aged 44 years,
D/o Paul Saldanha,
75

637. Sr. Anastasis A.C.,

aged 68 years,
D/o Joseph Mary Carvalho,
638. Sr. Maria Basty A.C.,

aged 26 years,
D/o Philip Rebero,
639. Sr. Maria Premal A.C.,

aged 25 years,
D/o Cyril Dias,
640. Sr. Maria Clara A.C.,

aged 25 years,
D/o Inas Rodrigues,
69 R.A.No.30/2011
641. Mrs. Pauline Saldanha,

aged 57 years,
W/o late Deny Saldanha,
R/at Suraksha, Laxmi Nagar, Bejai,

aged 39 years,
R/at Prashanthi Gurudev Nagar, Bejai Church Road,
643. Mrs. Dorothy M. Menezes,

aged 53 years,
W/o Leo Lobo,
R/at Mars Apartment, M-205, Spring Field,
644. Mrs. Dorita Lobo,

aged 39 years,
D/o Lucy Monterio,
R/at Monterio Compound, Ashoknagar,
76
Dambel, Mangalore - 575006. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-645 RESPONDENT-645
645. Mrs. Elizabeth Danial,

aged 45 years,
D/o P.M. Daniel,
R/at N.M.P.T. Colony, D.No.15/10th Street,
Panambur, Mangalore 575002. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-646 RESPONDENT-646
646. Mrs. Dorothy M. Menezes,

aged 53 years,
W/o Leo Lobo,
R/at Mars Apartment M-205, Spring Field,
647. Mrs. Ida Pinto,

aged 50 years,
W/o Baptist D’Souza,
R/at Kankanady Bypass Road,
648. Mrs. Flosy Lobo,

aged 57 years,
R/at Love Joy Dale, Bikarnakatta,
649. Mrs. Icy Maria D’Souza,

aged 43 years,
W/o Herbert Charles Lobo,
R/at ‘Classica’, near St. Dominic Church Hall,
650. Mrs. Leena Santhanez,

R/at Subashnagar, Munnur Post,
Via Permannur, Mangalore. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-651 RESPONDENT-651
651. Mrs. Philomina D’Souza,

aged 49 years,
W/o Denis D’Souza,
R/at Matadakani, 1st Cross,
70 R.A.No.30/2011
652. Mr. Denis D’Souza,

aged 54 years,
W/o Louis D’Souza,
R/at Matadakani, 1st Cross,
653. Mr. Kevin Ajay Maritis,

77
aged 46 years,
S/o B. Venedict Maritis,
R/at ‘Jeeva’, Spring Field, Chilimbi Urwa,
654. Mrs. Jeneview J. D’Souza,

aged 38 years,
D/o Rosy Lasrado,
R/at Spring Fields, Chilimbi Urwa,
655. Cecelia Lasrado,

D/o Rosy Lasrado,
R/at Ashoknagar Post,
656. Mrs. Gretta Lobo,

aged 63 years,
W/o Ignatius Lobo,
R/at Panchvihar, Urwa Post,
657. Mrs. Celine Pereira,

aged 56 years,
W/o late Elfred Pereira,
R/at Palvadore Villa, Chilimbi,
658. Mrs. Mabel Cunha,

aged 72 years,
W/o Sebestian Cunha,
R/at near J. Craft, Chilimbi,
659. Mr. Paul Pinto,

S/o Michal Pinto,
R/at Anil Sadan, Permude,
660. Mr. Marcel Fernandes,

S/o Peter Fernandes,
R/at Permude,
661. Mr. Julian D’Souza,

W/o Leo D’Souza,
R/at Permude,
78

71 R.A.No.30/2011
662. Mr. Prakash Vaz,

S/o late Mark Vaz,
R/at Permude,
663. Mrs. Prethi D’Souza,

W/o Clifford D’Souza,
R/at Clifford Cottage, Kallady,
Bajpe, Mangalore - 574142. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-664 RESPONDENT-664
664. Mrs. Benedicta Gracy Menezes,

W/o Valerian Denis Menezes,
R/at Anna Villa, Adkabare,
Bajpe, Mangalore. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-665 RESPONDENT-665
665. Mrs. Benedicta Nazareth,

W/o Basil Nazareth,
R/at Nazareth Cottage, Cross Padava,
Permude, Permude Post, Mangalore. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-666 RESPONDENT-666
666. Mrs. Cynthia Moras,

W/o Lancy Moras,
R/at Crystal Rock, John Kamath Compound,
Near Bajpe Church, Mangalore. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-667 RESPONDENT-667
667. Mr. Eugene D’Souza,

S/o Leo D’Souza,
R/at Hall View, Sunkadakatte,
Kolambe Post, Mangalore. NOT PARTY RESPONDENT-668 RESPONDENT-668
668. Mrs. Rosy D’Souza,

W/o Josy D’Cunha,
R/at Behind P.H.C.,
669. Mr. maxim D’Souza,

S/o Paul D’Souza,
R/at Sunkadakatte,
670. Mr. Charles D’Souza,

(deleted vide order dt: 1.6.2016)
S/o late Basil D’Souza,
aged 77 years,
R/at “Wilfo Villa”,
79
Sirlapadpu House,
Kulashekar Post,
Mangalore. PLAINTIFF APPELLANT-2 RESPONDENT-670
671. Mr. Alban Menezes,

S/o Sydney Menezes,
aged 41 years,
C/o Shena Constructions,
Dubois Complex, Silver Gate, Kulashekar,
Mangalore – 575005. PLAINTIFF APPELLANT-3 RESPONDENT-671
672. Mr. Jeevan Vas

(deleted vide order dt: 1.6.2016)
S/o late A,S,Vas,
Aged 51 years,
R/at Kalpane,
Kulashekar,
Mangalore -5. PLAINTIFF APPELLANT-4 RESPONDENT-672
673. Mr. Vincent D’Cunha,

S/o Mary D’Cunha,
Aged 42 years,
Church Gate, Kulashekar,
Mangalore – 575005. PLAINTIFF APPELLANT-5 RESPONDENT -673
674. Mr. Ronald Crasta,

S/o Xavier Crasta,
Aged 45 years,
R/at Church Compound,
Kulashekar, Mangalore – 575005. PLAINTIFF APPELLANT-6 RESPONDENT -674
675. Mr. Joe Rego,

S/o late S.D. Rego,
Aged 51 years,
C/o Star Caterers,
676. Mr. Naveen Fernandes,

S/o Thomas Fernandes,
aged 33 years, R/at Niddel,
Gokarnath House, Kalpane,
677. Mr. Francis D’Costa,

S/o late Ingenious,
Aged 44 years,
R/at Anand Apartments,
Kalpane, Kulashekar, Mangalore – 575005. PLAINTIFF APPELLANT-9 RESPONDENT -677
678. Mr. Alphonse D’Souza,
80
aged 49 years,
S/o Late Lawrence D’Souza,
R/at “Astral”, Church Compound,
Kulshekar Post, Mangalore – 575 005. PLAINTIFF APPELLANT-10 RESPONDENT -678
679.Mr. Robert D’Souza,

S/o J.P.D’Souza,
R/at Saripella House, Padil Post,
Kulshekar, Mangalore – 575 005. PLAINTIFF APPELLANT-11 RESPONDENT -679
680. Benedict Noronha,

aged about 64 years
S/o. Casmir Noronha,
Advocate, Canara Towers,
Udupi – 576 101 (in person) PLAINTIFF APPELLANT-12 RESPONDENT -680
681. Mabel D’Souza,

W/o Sylvester D’Souza,
R/at Soolkudru, Pandeshwara Village,
Udupi Taluk & Dist. PLAINTIFF APPELLANT-13 RESPONDENT -681
682. Claude Lewis,

S/o Alphonse Lewis,
R/at Mabukala – Balkudru,
Post Hangarkatta – 576226,
683. Edward D’Almeida,

S/o late Benedict Almeida,
R/at ‘Benson’, Karavali Road,
Sasthana Post, Udupi. PLAINTIFF APPELLANT-15 RESPONDENT -683
684. Hillary Lewis,
S/o late Patrick Lewis,
R/at Airody Village & Post,
Udupi Taluk & Dist.- 576226. PLAINTIFF APPELLANT-16 RESPONDENT -684
685. Oswald Gosalves,

S/o Telsphore Gonsalves,
686. Reginald Lewis,

81

S/o late Cyrie Lewis,
R/at Balkudru Village, Post Hangarkatta,
687. Mathias Dias,

S/o late Danat Dias,
R/at Balkudru Village, Post Hangarkatta,
688. Lucas D’Souza,

S/o late Paul D’Souza,
R/at “Jetluna”, Behind R.C. Church,
Sasthan, Udupi Taluk & Dist.- 576226. PLAINTIFF APPELLANT-20 RESPONDENT -688
689. Valearn D’Souza,

S/o late Paul D’Souza,
R/at Pandeshwar Village, Sasthana Post,
690. Hubert Gonsalves,

S/o Telespore Gonsalves,
691. Rudalph Meneges,

S/o Late Joachim Meneges,
R/at Pandeshwar, Sasthana Post,
692. Vijay Lewis,

S/o Late Lawrence Lewis,
R/at ‘Vista Planifolia’, Pandeshwar Village,
Sasthana Post, Udupi Taluk & Dist. PLAINTIFF APPELLANT-24 RESPONDENT -692
693. Sylvester D’Souza,

S/o Late Leo D’Souza,
R/at Pandeshwar Village,
Udupi District. PLAINTIFF APPELLANT-25 RESPONDENT -693
4 R.A.No.30/2011
82
694. Godwin Gosalves,

S/o Late David,
R/at Poornima Cloth Stores,
Sastana, Udupi Taluk & District. PLAINTIFF APPELLANT-26 RESPONDENT -694
695. P.B.D’Sa,
S/o J.F.M. D’sa,
Parishioner of St. Vincent Ferrar Church, Valencia,
Educationist by Profession, ‘Pauline’,
Muller Road, Valencia,
Mangalore – 2. PLAINTIFF APPELLANT-27 RESPONDENT -695
696. Antony D’ Souza,

S/o Thomas D’ Souza,
Parishioner of Holly Rosary Church, Nidpalli,
Agriculturist by Profession,
Saroli Nilaya, Nidpalli Post,
Puttur Taluk, D.K. PLAINTIFF APPELLANT-28 RESPONDENT -696
697. Jayaprakash D’Souza,

S/o. Antony D’Souza,
Parishioner of Holly Rosary Church, Nidpalli,
Mason by Profession,
Kallrpe House, Nidpalli Post,
698. Mr. Francis B Saldana,

S/o. Baptist Saldana,
Parishioner of Kelarai Church, Mangalore,
Shyla shine home, Kliye,
Pedanamale Post, Mangalore – 575029. PLAINTIFF APPELLANT-30 RESPONDENT -698
699. William Mark Lewis,

S/o. Late Antony J Lewis,
R/at Dur Villa Matapady Village and Post,
Brahmavar – 576213.
(Holy Family Church Brahmavar). PLAINTIFF APPELLANT-31 RESPONDENT -699
700. Walter D’Souza,

S/o Jacob D’Souza,
R/at ‘Sidyala House’,
83
Parishioner of St. Antony Church Bannur,

Anemajalu House, Banoor Post,
701. Alwyn Gonsalves,

S/o Benjamin Gonsalves,
R/at ‘Sidyala House’,
Parishioner of St. Antony Church Bannur,
Anemajalu House, Banoor Post,
5 R.A.No.30/2011
702. Paul Pasanna,

S/o Mareet Pasanna,
Coppersmith by Profession,
Parishioner of Mai Deus Church Puttur,
Samethadka, Puttur Taluk & D. K. PLAINTIFF APPELLANT-34 RESPONDENT -702
703. Alwyn Tauro,

S/o Vincent Tauro,
Driver by Profession,
Parishioner of Mai Deus Church Puttur,
Samethadka, Puttur Taluk & D. K. PLAINTIFF APPELLANT-35 RESPONDENT -703
704. Charls Coelho,

S/o Simon Coelho,
Businessmen by profession,
Parishioner of Sacred Heart Church Maril,
Kudumane House, Maril, Darbe Post,
705. Robert Rosario,

S/o S.H. Rosario,
Metal Fabrication by Profession,
Parishioner of Our Lady of Remedies, Church Kirem,
Aikala Village & Post,
Mangalore Taluk, D.K. – 574 141. PLAINTIFF APPELLANT-37 RESPONDENT -705
706. Alex D ‘Souza,

S/o Valerian D’Souza,
R/at Shantigudda, Permannur,
Mangalore, D.K. PLAINTIF APPELLANT-38 RESPONDENT -706
84
707. Steevan D ‘Souza,

S/o Clement D ‘Souza,
R/at Ullalhoige, Permannur,
Mangalore. PLAINTIFF APPELLANT-39 RESPONDENT -707
708. Ronald D ‘Souza,

S/o Marshal D ‘ Souza,
R/at Rejoice House, Kallapu Monepu,
Permannur Post, Mangalore. PLAINTIFF APPELLANT-40 RESPONDENT -708
6 R.A.No.30/2011
709. Melvyn D ‘ Souza,

S/o Fedric D’Souza,
R/at Souza Villa, Near Thokkottu Check Post,
Permannur, Mangalore PLAINTIFF APPELLANT-41 RESPONDENT -709
710. Delson D’ Souza,

S/o Fedric D’Souza,
R/at Souza Villa, Near Thokkottu Check Post,
Permannur, Mangaluru. PLAINTIFF APPELLANT-42 RESPONDENT -710
711. Pius Monthiro,

S/o Late Mathias Monthiro,
R/at Shanthi Villa, Kallapu,
Permannur, Mangalore. PLAINTIFF APPELLANT-43 RESPONDENT -711
712. Aural D ‘Souza,

S/o. Alphonse D ‘Souza,
R/at Adam Kudru, Jeppinamogaru,
713. Ozzie Prakash Monthiro,

S/o. Dennis Monthiro,
Near Thokkottu Under Bridge,
Ullal Post, Mangalore. PLAINTIFF APPELLANT-45 RESPONDENT -713
714. Noel Monthiro,

S/o Late Salvadar Monthiro,
R/at Kallapu Monepu, Near Sarkar Mill,
Permannur Post, Mangalore- 17. PLAINTIFF APPELLANT-46 RESPONDENT -714
85
715. Joseph D’ Souza,

S/o. Jerom D’Souza,
R/at Adam Kudru House,
Permannur Post, Mangalore – 17. PLAINTIFF APPELLANT-47 RESPONDENT -715
716. Ronald D’ Souza,

S/o. D’Souza,
R/at Chenbagudda House, Permannur Post,
MEMORANDUM OF REGULAR SECOND APPEAL UNDER SECTION 100 OF

THE CODE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE
I. The Appellant’s address for service of summons, notices etc., from this Hon’ble Court
is as stated supra in the cause title and also in care of his counsel Ajith Anand Shetty,
SA Partners, Advocates, No.71, 66th Cross, Rajajinagar 5th Block, Bangalore-560 010.
II. The Respondent’s addresses for similar purpose are as reflected above in the cause
title.
III. That being aggrieved by the order dated 23 rd August, 2017, passed by the Hon’ble
IVth Additional District & Sessions Judge, Dakshina Kannada, Mangalore, in Regular
Appeal No.30/2011, in effect confirming the Order/ Judgment and Decree dated
11thFebruary, 2011, passed by the learned II Additional Civil Judge (Sr.Dvn), at
Mangalore in O.S No.151 of 2010, the Appellant seeks leave of this Hon’ble Court to
present this regular second appeal on the facts and grounds narrated hereunder and to be
urged at the time of hearing;
IV. FACTS OF THE CASE

86
1. The Appellant is an association, registered under provisions of the ‘Karnataka

Societies Registration Act’ and is governed by its own Articles of Association and
a set of bye-laws. The Appellant association consists of 230 individual members.
The 1st Respondent herein brings about a constitution for governance of all the
‘Parishes’ with the ‘Dioceses’ once in three years, within frame work of
democratic principles and laws governing Churches and Churth activities. Latest
of such Constitution of Governance was brought about by the 1 st Respondent
herein, effective from 01st November, 2010, which contained certain rules/ bye-
laws, which according to the Appellant herein and many individual believers, are
totally opposed to democratic principles, principles of natural justice, fundamental
rights to speech and expression, basic human rights, right to take recourse to
judicial proceedings and certain other rights guaranteed under the Constitution of
India. According to the Appellant and its fellow believers, the set of rules were
draconian, dictatorial and quite secretive, in as much a major portion thereof
having been kept away from public gaze.
2. The Appellant, having gained access to two sets of copies of such impugned
rules/bye-laws , addressed to separate representations to the 1 st Respondent
herein, on 20/11/2010 and on 01/02/2010, voicing its concerns and objections
over the impugned rules/ bye-laws and has also south for suitable amendments to
the same. This has however fell on deaf ears of the 1 st Respondent. That in the
meanwhile, Respondents __ to __ herein, who had at a later point in time joined
the Appellant as co-PLAINTIFFfs, filed their nominations to be elected as Ward
Representatives before the Parish Priest of Holy Cross Church, Cordel,
Kulshekara, Mangalore, on the 14th day of November, 2010 as per provisions of
the previous constitution of governance, with elections scheduled to be held on
the 05th day of December, 2010. Of these individuals, Respondents __ and __
remained unopposed in their respective wards. Overlooking these facts,
nominations of Respondents __ to __ were rejected en-mass, for the sole reason
that they were PLAINTIFFfs in O.S No.130 of 2009, filed against the Parish
Priest and others. This decision was apparently taken under the new set of rules/
bye-laws, with an intent to intimidate Parishioners, who were otherwise
87
questioning certain illegal and unethical practices of the Church managing

committee, the Parish Priest and the Bishop. As such, the present suit, seeking
declaration of such impugned rules/bye-laws as being illegal and therefore, null
and void.
3. The 1st Respondent entered appearance and proceeded to file an application under
Order 7 Rule 11, read with Section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure, with a
prayer to reject the plaint, primarily on the ground that the Church and its
activities were governed solely by the “Code of Canon Laws” and that such
activities could be subjected to the scrutiny of “Ecclesiastical Courts” alone and
that the Civil Court had no jurisdiction to try such suit and grant reliefs prayed for
therein. The said application was allowed by the Hon’ble Court of first instance,
vide its order dated 11th February, 2011, culminating in a decree of like date and
as such, the suit came to be rejected as not being maintainable. The said order/
Judgment and Decree was questioned by the Appellant herein by way of a regular
appeal before the Hon’ble Lower Appellate Court. While the Hon’ble Lower
Appellate Court was pleased to reverse the findings of the Hon’ble Trial Court as
regards maintainability of the suit, it was erroneously noted that the ‘Constitution
of Governance’ dated 01st November, 2010 was valid for a period of three (3)
years alone and since seven years had elapsed from the date of filing of the suit,
the appeal had been rendered infructuous and as such, the Hon’ble Court
proceeded to reject the appeal has having spent itself out.
4. Hence the present appeal on the following;
V. GROUNDS
(a) That the impugned Judgment and Decree is in clear contravention of settled positions
of law and has been passed in an apparent case of misinterpretation of pleadings and
material evidence placed on record. Hence the same deserves to be set aside.
88
(b) The Hon’ble First Appellate Court has rightly held that since there were no
‘Ecclesiastical Courts’ in India, the Jurisdictional Civil Court did have jurisdiction to try
the present suit. The said finding has attained finality as none of the Defendants have
questioned the same. However, the Hon’ble First Appellate Court misdirected itself
while observing that the impugned rules/ bye-laws had been rendered redundant owing
to efflux of time. The Hon’ble Court below has failed to appreciate the fact that a set of
rules/bye-laws, once incorporated in the Constitution of Governance, were valid and
applicable until unless they are expressly removed by way of a fresh amendment.
Though the changed ‘Constitution of Governance’ was stated to have a shelf life of three
(3) years, the same would remain unchanged if a new amendment is not brought about to
replace it. The fact remains that the impugned rules/ bye-laws still find place in the
Constitution of Governance and as such, the grievance cited by the PLAINTIFFfs does
exist even to this date and the cause of action does survive.
(c) The Hon’ble First Appellate Court was required to have atleast conducted an enquiry
as to whether an amendment was indeed brought about and whether the particular set of
rules/bye-laws, which were questioned, were diluted. Even if the Hon’ble Court had
expressed that such doubt had lingered, the Appellant would have had the opportunity of
having proved the fact that the impugned rules/ bye-laws continued to exist in the
prevailing Constitution of Governance. Having not done so, the Hon’ble First Appellate
Court had deprived the Appellant, of an opportunity to clarify the said issue. This would
also be a reason why the order impugned deserves to be set aside.
(d) That viewed from any angle, the impugned Judgment and Decree cannot be
maintainable and deserves to be set aside. That in light of the foregoing discussions, the
following question/s of law would arise for the kind consideration of this Hon’ble Court;
VI. QUESTIONS OF LAW
1. Whether the lower Appellate Court was justified in rejecting the appeal on the
ground that the appeal had outlived the impugned set of rules/ bye-laws, without
89
enquiring as to whether the impugned rules/ bye-laws had been removed from
contemporary Constitution of Governance?
2. Whether the lower Appellate Court could have rejected the appeal on grounds of
the same having been rendered infructuous, without even framing a point on that
count?
VII. LIMITATION
That the appeal has been preferred beyond the period of limitation as envisaged under
the C.P.C and hence, a separate application has been preferred seeking condonation of
the said delay.
VIII. That the Appellant has not preferred any other appeal on the very same cause of
action.
IX. VALUATION
The suit was valued at Rs.______/- and a Court fee of Rs.___/- was paid under section
___ of the ‘Karnataka Court Fee and Suits Valuation Act’. While applying the same
valuation, a Court Fee of Rs.___/- is paid on the appeal memorandum before the lower
appellate Court. Similar Court fee of Rs.____/- has been paid on the present
memorandum of appeal as per Section ___ of the K.C.F.S.V Act..
PRAYER
WHEREFORE, the Appellant prays that this Hon’ble Court be pleased to;
(i) call for records;
(ii) to set aside the order dated 23 rd August, 2017, passed by the Hon’ble IVth
Additional District & Sessions Judge, Dakshina Kannada, Mangalore, in
Regular Appeal No.30/2011 to the limited extent of the finding that the appeal
had been rendered infructuous;
90
(iii) In effect, to set aside the Order/ Judgment and Decree dated 11 th February,
2011, passed by the learned II Additional Civil Judge (Sr.Dvn), at Mangalore
in O.S No.151 of 2010 and restore such suit to its original file,in the interest of
justice and equity.
Bangalore
Dated: ADVOCATE FOR APPELLANT

I.A No.__
In
R.S.A No._____________ of 2018
Between:
THE UNITED CHRISTIAN ASSOCIATION ..........…………APPELLANT
AND
REV.BISHOP, MANGALORE DIOCESE

AND OTHERS .........………RESPONDENTS
APPLICATION FOR CONDONATION OF DELAY UNDER SECTION 5 OF THE

LIMITATION ACT
91
That for reasons stated in the accompanying affidavit, the Appellant prays that this
Hon’ble Court be pleased to condone the delay of an approximate _____ days in
presenting this memorandum of appeal as against the order dated23 rd August, 2017,
passed by the Hon’ble IVth Additional District & Sessions Judge, Dakshina Kannada,
Mangalore, in Regular Appeal No.30/2011, in the interest of justice and equity.
Bangalore
Dated: ADVOCATE FOR APPELLANT
R.S.A No._____________ of 2018

Between:
THE UNITED CHRISTIAN ASSOCIATION ..........…………APPELLANT
AND
REV.BISHOP, MANGALORE DIOCESE

AND OTHERS .........………RESPONDENTS
AFFIDAVIT
92
I, _________________, S/o_____________, aged about __ years,

R/o__________________, now here at Bangalore do hereby solemnly affirm and state
on oath as hereunder;
I state and submit that I am the authorized signatory of the Appellant herein and I am
conversant with the facts and circumstances of the present case. Hence this affidavit.
I state and submit that the contents of the appeal memorandum may kindly be read as
part and parcel of this affidavit without prejudice to each other.
I state and submit that the 1 st Respondent and other contesting Respondents have always
tried to place road blocks in our attempt to seek justice. To begin with, the impugned set
of rules/ bye-laws were kept out of public domain for quite some time and were being
selectively implemented, so as to prevent any individual from questioning the same.
I state and submit that when we eventually realised what was happening, these
contesting Respondents had made it extremely difficult for any person to gain access to
such set of rules/ bye-laws. However, we were successful in getting access to such rules/
bye-laws with the assistance of some members in the Committee, who answer to their
conscience and who have realised that what is being done is of extreme prejudice to the
Church and its believers.
I state and submit that the order passed by the Hon’ble First Appellate Court came as a
complete surprise for us as at no point in time was any question raised as to whether the
impugned rules/ bye-laws were still part of contemporary Constitution of Governance.
I state and submit that having gotten over such shock, we have immediately taken on the
task of verifying as to whether the impugned set of rules/ bye-laws continued to part of
the current Constitution of Governance. We have now found that they continue to find
place in our existing Constitution of Governance. As such, our cause of action survives
to this day.
93
I state and submit that such process did take a considerable period of time , owing to the
secretive manner in which the 1st Respondent is running the Church administration.
I state and submit that the delay in filing of the present appeal is purely owing to bona-
fide reasons stated supra and is definitely not intentional as the Appellant does not stand
to gain in any manner from such a delay.
I state and submit that in the event of the delay being condoned, no prejudice would be
caused to the other side, while anything to the contrary would prove fatal for the
legitimate legal rights of scores of believers.
I therefore pray that this Hon’ble Court be pleased to allow the accompanying
application and thereby condone the delay involved in filing the present appeal.
Bangalore
Dated:
Identified by me:
ADVOCATE
94

Uca Msa

Uploaded by

Document Information

Original Title

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

Uca Msa

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

1

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BANGALORE

R.S.A No._____________ of 2018

R.A No. 30 of 2011

IN THE COURT OF THE II ADDITIONAL SENIOR CIVIL JUDGE AT MANGALORE

O.S No. 151 of 2010

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BANGALORE

M.S.A No._____________ of 2018

BETWEEN: POSITION OF PARTIES BEFORE

The United Christian Association ®

1. Rev. Bishop, Mangalore Diocese,

2. Mrs. Emilla Rita Monteiro,

3. Ms. Edrina Monteiro,

4. Ms. Elvia Monteiro,

5. Mr. Alban Alwyn Monteiro,

6. Mrs. Astrid Mabel Monterio,

7. Mr. Edward Ronald Monteiro,

8. Mr. Leo Tauro,

9. Mrs. Lucy Tauro,

10. Mrs. Jacintha Laveena Tauro,

11. Mrs. Anna Matilda,

12. Mrs. Naveen D’Almeida,

13. Mrs. Irene Menezes,

14. Mrs. Helen Rebeiro,

15. Mr. G. Thangachan,

16. Mr. Godwin,

17. Mrs. Rita Leena Sequeira,

18. Mrs. Chris Everts D’Souza,

aged about 27 years,

19. Mr. Peter D’Costa,

20. Mrs. Gracy Rodrigues,

21. Mrs. Letitia Castelino,

22. Mr. Daniel Castelino,

23. Mrs. Myrna Lobo,

24. Mr. Noel Lobo,

25. Mrs. Lidwin Lobo,

26. Mr. Oliver Lobo,

27. Mrs. Laveena Lobo,

28. Mr. Sunil Lobo,

29. Mr. Alphonso D’Souza,

30. Mrs. Theresa D’Souza,

31. Miss. Manisha Crasta,

32. Mr. Henry D’Souza,

33. Mr. Preem D’Souza,

R/at Alape Village, Niddle,

34. Dolphy D’Souza,

35. Mrs. Olivia D’Silva,

36. Debora D’Silva,

37. Mr. Roshan Monteiro,

38. Mrs. Josephine Pereira,

39. Precilla Saldanha,

40. Mr. Leo Mascarenhas,

41. Veena Mascarenhas,

D/o late Philip D’Souza,

42. Mr. Derick D’Souza,

43. Mr. Charles D’Souza,

44. Smt. Priya D’Souza,

45. Mr. J. Alban Pinto,

46. Dorothy Pinto,

47. Fedrick Pinto,

48. Mr. Richard Joy Pinto,

49. Savitha Pinto,

aged about 35 years,