Professional Documents
Culture Documents
In DC circles, the story of the battle between the currents is The discussion on MVDC is not only limited to Distribution
well known and is almost slipping into popular folklore via Networks as Offshore Windfarm collector arrays are another
recent media conversations such as “War of the Currents” – area that there is much discussion. This paper is focused only
Tesla Vs Edison” [1]. on use for Distribution Networks, although the principles and
technology are applicable provided the appropriate
For those unaware of this past battle, in contrast to today’s marinisation steps are taken.
power systems, the first commercial distribution of electrical
energy was realized using direct current (DC). Edison’s Pearl 2 Scope of MVDC
Street installation was commissioned in 1882, featuring a 24-
km long two-wire cable system of copper conductors that Recent surveys have shown that loads being served by today's
distributed electricity at a voltage of 110 V for incandescent alternating current (AC) power grids are increasingly natively
lighting in Lower Manhattan, New York. But, due to the high DC [2,3]. In fact, according to some estimates, approximately
losses caused by the low distribution voltage, the dc 80% of loads in commercial and residential structures are
technology at that time was outperformed in terms of now DC. Given the enormous political and policy support for
efficiency by its alternating current (AC) counterpart, which inverter-based native DC power sources such as PV, it makes
was developed in the middle of the 1880s by Westinghouse sense to reduce DC-AC-DC conversion losses and integrate
(Tesla). The ac system could use transformers (a voltage DC distribution networks into the power supply infrastructure
converter invented and patented first in Europe) to step up the where practical.
generator voltage to high levels, that are suitable for long-
distance transmission of electric power. Consequently, the The market for direct current (DC) distribution networks is
medium-voltage alternating current distribution and not a single, cohesive market. Rather, it encompasses several
transmission system operated with lower currents and had disparate opportunities – utility networks, offshore networks,
considerably lower losses than low-voltage DC systems. data centres, green telecommunications towers, DC
subsystems within grid-tied commercial buildings, and off-
1
grid military networks. These all revolve around different 2.2 Substation Reinforcement Opportunities
market assumptions, dynamics, and drivers. This paper is MVDC can be used at a substation level to provide increased
focused on the application of DC to utility distribution power transfer capacity in situations where the up-rating
networks and leaves discussion on the other applications and cables and transformers is disruptive, expensive and hard to
LVDC to another paper. achieve. Some of these options include:
• Prevent voltage limits impinging before thermal limits by
2.1 MVDC for Utility Distribution Networks increasing the control options in the network.
MVDC is starting to be considered as an option for enhancing • Dynamically rebalancing voltage and flows to avoid limit on
transfer capacity and providing increased power quality at individual phase.
distribution networks. As a simple MVDC system consists of • Even up loading between transformers or create new routes
fully–controlled converters, then it creates a number of useful power between substations or parts of substations.
opportunities for a utility that are not available using • Alleviate power quality problems by splitting
conventional technology.
These can be achieved by using MVDC in a configuration by
The challenges facing Distribution Utilities in the modern era the so-called “Soft Open Point” (SOP) application (Figure 1).
are multi-faceted ranging from increased pressure on This is essentially two power converters connected in a back
investment and operational efficiency, restricted corridors for to back arrangement across a conventional Open-Point, or
expansion, ageing equipment, legacy systems and rapid busbar section.
growth in embedded generation. At the high-level the
following are some of the Site Characteristics where MVDC MVDC in a back-to-back configuration can provide “soft-
may provide a beneficial business case for deployment: open point” capability to improve power balancing at heavily
• Long overhead line circuits loaded substations and improve reliability, while maintaining
• Urban cable circuits short-circuit levels within circuit-breaker ratings. These
• Circuits through highly constrained or sensitive areas back-to-back configurations also allow the system to
• Fault-level constrained but capacity increase required overcome potential phase-angle differences and circulating
• Phase-angles across transmission in-feeds power-flows when the MV substations are fed from different
• Neighbouring feeders with different load factors or power transmission infeeds.
quality that linking will release additional capacity
• MV groups with voltage and power-flow challenges By using the controllable power transfer capability, and
individual voltage control capabilities of each converter, it is
The benefits of the use of MVDC can be summarised as: possible to dynamically force active power flows to balance
• Better utilisation of existing network assets. feeders (and phase loadings), and thereby better utilise the
• Deferred / avoided investment in network reinforcement. existing network capacity.
• Reduced losses in other equipment.
• Power electronics do not contribute fault current so This has further advantages where it is not otherwise possible
protection arrangements unchanged. to close up this open-point due to loop-flows, short-circuit
• Short circuit levels, voltage differences, loop flows or levels, voltage limits, or poor power quality on one of the
limitations due to phase-angle differences unaffected. groups.
• The 4-quadrant converters can also provide reactive power
support and voltage control at each end of the link and multi
terminal is also feasible.
2
and power-factor limitations. MV here is defined as from
10kV up to 70kV - but is not a limiting term.
3
However, the reliance on the Diesel generator was DC reactor : 0.5 mH, DC 15 kV / 400 A
undesirable to the client due to the following reasons: Dimension : Two containers, each 6m x 5m x 4.5m
• High cost of operation and maintenance.
• Serious air and noise pollution. Inverter Substation (14 – 3A)
• Limited generator capacity. Converters : 4MVA, DC 15 kV / AC 400 V, AC 35 kV
• Serious energy waste. Transformer : 400 V x 14 / 400 V x 1, 35 kV x 1, 400 V
x 1 (auxiliary), 4MVA
The alternative to MVDC for CNOOC was to install Power module : DC Input 1100 V, AC Output 400 V,
additional submarine cables and surge mitigation equipment. Rated Power 285 kVA
This was viewed as time-consuming and expensive. Valves : 14 power modules connected series on DC
side, AC output 400 V
4.2 Solution: MVDC CONVERTER DC reactor : 0.5 mH, DC 15 kV / 400 A
Extensive joint design evaluation was undertaken before Dimension : Two power module containers, each 6m x
settling on their existing high power MV drive platform to 2.7m x 2.9m; one transformer container,
form the technology platform for the MVDC application. 9.6m x 2.8m x 2.3 m; one reactor container,
This is a multiple branch converter topology that has good 9.6m x 2.8m x 2.1 m
efficiency, flexibility, modular configuration, and can directly
connect at MV AC voltage levels to remove the requirement
for external transformers.
V V
A A
4
5 MVDC Case Study – DC Distribution multi-branch topology with bridges in series on the MV side,
Technology Development Project and parallel on the LV side and multiple smaller isolation
transformers.
There is a China National Project currently underway to
develop and trial next generation DC Distribution Network MVDC Application Standard
A final important part of the project is to develop an initial
technology. This is to undertake key technology research and
standard of MVDC for the china power industry. This is an
application for VSC-DC intelligent distribution grids. The
important step in developing the supply chain as well as
project forms part of the national high-tech research and
industry acceptance in the technology and application.
development plan (863 plan) Sub-topics 4. The responsible
partners are: RXPE, Tsinghua University, Shenzhen power
supply bureau, Zhejiang University, and CSG Academy of Project Timeline
Project timeline is to run from August 2013 – Dec 2015. This
Sciences.
project under-pins part of the wider drive towards better
The topic purpose can be summarised as follows: understanding the application, opportunity and resolving
• Improve power supply capacity, solving distribution barriers to the deployment of DC distribution networks.
corridor limiting problem
• Improve power quality, solving the problem of 6 Summary
sensitivity of emerging industries for voltage quality
• Renewable energy through DC connected into grid, This paper has hopefully shown to the reader the technology
improve reliability and utilisation. and justifications behind MVDC and that there is a place for
MVDC within today’s distribution networks. While still
Key technology and application research to be undertaken on arguably niche applications at this stage, there is growing
DC Distribution grid as part of this project includes: awareness and wider industry movements suggesting that
1. Research of intelligent DC distribution network there may be a coming rematch of the classic “Battle of the
basic topology and optimisation. Currents”.
2. DC Distribution grid grounding method research
3. LV DC Distribution network voltage level selection It is also important to note that this is not just a technology for
4. DC distribution network energy storage equipment mature networks, but also has significant application and
optimal selection and capacity configuration relevance for developing countries facing rapid demand
research. growth and the need to maximise available network and
generation resources.
Some of the specific tasks being undertaking are to develop
and test some of the new equipment that will be required if Electricity demand is growing every day and the Smart Grid
DC distribution networks are to become a reality. The must be introduced in the near future. This calls for reliability
specific equipment being developed and tested as part of this and flexibility in the distribution system. At present, much of
project are: the majority of progress in developing DC-based technologies
has occurred at either the EHV (>100kV) or low voltage
MVDC Circuit Breaker (<100V) level of electricity service. Since distribution
This is to undertake the theoretic research and develop an networks have a different set of requirements to Transmission
engineering prototype of an MVDC circuit breaker. The and Microgrids, much work still needs to be done to bridge
specified parameters are a rated voltage of ±7.5kVdc with a this voltage innovation gap. This needs to be the focus of the
5ms interrupt time and 1kA rated current. power technology companies.