Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The correct answer was: d. There is no good reason to think that doing one action will inevitably lead to another
undesirable action.
Medical ethics An ethical continuum or 'slope,' the impact of which has been incompletely explored, and
which itself raises moral questions that are even more on the ethical 'edge' than the original issue
Which of the following is an example of a slippery slope argument applied to assisted death?
a. Physicians sometimes are in error when they conclude that people are terminally ill.
b. Most patients are not qualified to make end-of-life decisions for themselves.
c. We should not approve of assisted death for any particular person because that will encourage more
such deaths and with less selectivity.
d. It is very difficult to bring legal action against physicians who provide assisted death because they
usually slip out of charges.
If we allow passive euthanasia, then we will have to allow active euthanasia too. There
isno real difference between allowing someone to die through the cessation of treatment
andkilling them through active means. In either case the intention of the physician is the
deathof the patient, and in either case the effect, the death of the patient, is the same.
In this example it is said that if we allow passive euthanasia (A), then we will have to
allowactive euthanasia (B), because there is no relevant difference between active and
passiveeuthanasia. Because the argument is saying that active and passive euthanasia
areequivalent, this is an example of the logical version of the slippery slope argument