Professional Documents
Culture Documents
net/publication/354185796
CITATIONS READS
5 1,157
3 authors, including:
Zheng Jianhong
Lingnan Normal University
37 PUBLICATIONS 59 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
All content following this page was uploaded by Zheng Jianhong on 28 August 2021.
To cite this article: Bao Xiaohong, Dong Jia & Zheng Jianhong (2021) A psychobiographical study
of Temujin’s (Genghis Khan) personality, Journal of Psychology in Africa, 31:2, 177-183, DOI:
10.1080/14330237.2021.1903154
Article views: 7
This psychobiography study of Temujin employed the Personality Adjective Evaluation Scale, the Personality Adjective
Classification Survey, and the Delphi method to characterise Temujin’s personality traits and probable influences . One
hundred and thirty-two participants rated Temujin’s personality on 248 evaluation words, while an expert panel (n = 4)
utilised the Delphi consensus building method for convergence of the trait characterisation . Following factor analysis
and multi-dimensional classification analysis, we found six personality trait categories to characterise Temujin: cruel and
aggressive, forthright and chivalric, intelligent and capable, outstanding, self-reliant, and martial spirit . Findings may be
explained by Temujin’s life experiences, role models, culture background, such as family upheavals, economic distress, the
metaphor of the sun and the moon of wise persons, the education received from his mother Hö’elün, the achievements of
the ancestors and father, and the manner of their achievements . Moreover, the harmony and separation culture, the worship
of power and heroes, and the nomadic and hunting life would have been significant influences . From these findings, we
concluded that personality traits are influenced by early experiences, role models, and cultural background .
Journal of Psychology in Africa is co-published by NISC (Pty) Ltd and Informa UK Limited (trading as Taylor & Francis Group)
178 Bao et al.
method (Stephenson, 1952) for the classification of the 106 participants on the 21 personality traits is shown
personality traits and adjectives . To profile the personality in Figure 1 .
traits, similar to a previous study (Sun & Wu, 2013), we Figure 1 shows that the 21 feature words are grouped
employed both factor analysis and multidimensional scale into six categories: (i) cruel and aggressive (which includes
analysis drawing on their relative advantage providing cruel, fierce, and aggressive); (ii) forthright and chivalric;
factor load and structure fitting indices by items or factors . (iii) intelligent and capable (which includes intelligent,
We applied the Q classification method in Microsoft Excel self-confident, decisive, determined, and strong); (iv)
and converted into 106 21×21 symmetric dissimilarity outstanding (which includes progressive, outstanding, and
matrices . We then imported symmetric dissimilarity promising); (v) self-reliant (which includes independent,
matrices data into IBM SPSS Statistics Software 23 .0 for first-hand, and self-esteem); and (vi) martial spirit (which
multidimensional scaling analysis . includes martial, adventurous, emulous, rebellious, and
competitive) .
Results
Factor analysis results Two dimensions
Following factor analysis on the 21 evaluation words, we The semantic space map of the 21 personality trait
extracted a total of four factors (see Table 1 for the results), words includes two dimensions . Dimension 1 refers to
which were named as “rare gifts and bold strategy,” “seek relationship/independence: most of the personality traits on
to prevail over others,” “martial arts and chivalry,” and the left are shown in the presence of others, and the ones
“cruel and aggressive .” The cumulative contribution rate on the right are shown in an independent state . Dimension
was 63 .09% . 2 refers to self/achievement: personality traits on the top of
the vertical axis mostly reflect Temujin’s inner self, while
Multidimensional scale analysis results personality traits on the bottom mostly reflect his pursuit
Participants divided 21 adjectives into 2 to 18 categories of external achievements .
with an average eigenvalue of 4 .9 . The results showed
that the conceptual structure of 21 personality traits Shared attributes by method
could be explained by two dimensions: stress = 0 .17870 Comparing the results of the factor analysis and the
and RSQ (squared correlation) = 0 .86935 . The model multidimensional scale analysis, we found the “cruel and
explained 86 .94% of the variation in scores . Further, the aggressive” factor consistent across methods . Furthermore,
scatter plot of linear fitting was approximately a straight the “martial arts and chivalry” factor includes the
line, indicating that the two-dimensional model fits the “forthright and chivalric” factor, both were also roughly
observed data well . The mental picture as determined by similar across methods . The minor difference is that even
Table 1. The results of factor analysis (after rotation) of the 21 personality trait words describing Temujin
Figure 1. The two-dimensional spatial distribution of the 21 personality trait words describing Temujin
though the results of the multidimensional scale analysis define Temujin and proffering explanations based on his
contain more items than the results from factor analysis, life experience, role models, and culture background .
accentuating the core meaning . For example, “cruel, fierce,
aggressive” all point to Temujin’s “cruel and aggressive”
personality traits when facing the enemy; while “forthright Cruel and aggressive
and chivalric” point to Temujin’s “forthright and chivalric” Historical records of the expression of these personality
personality traits towards his friends . The traits of traits date back to Temujin’s childhood . For instance,
“intelligent, self-confident, decisive, determined, strong” when Temujin was a child, he killed his half-brother
point to his “internal”, “intelligent and capable” personality (Bekter) over a hunting conflict . Moreover, it is worth
traits; while “progressive, promising, outstanding” all mentioning that Temujin and his biological young brother
point to his “external”, “outstanding” personality traits (Qasar) killed Bekter by shooting him from the front
in pursuit of achievement . The traits of “independent, and behind, that is, without giving him any chance to
first-hand and self-esteem” refer to his “self-reliant” escape . This character became more evident in his adult
personality traits when facing life . “Martial, adventurous, life . For example, because the Jürkins wounded Belgütei
emulous, rebellious, and competitive” all point to “martial and refused to take part in the war of revenge against the
spirit” personality characteristics . From this point of view, Tatars, and even raided Temujin’s strongholds, Temujin
the contribution of the factor analysis was to clarify the finally killed its three core leaders and wiped out the
general classification of Temujin’s personality traits, while entire tribe . In addition, Temujin ordered soldiers to kill
multidimensional scale analysis provided a more accurate civilians and cut open their bellies “to get the jewels” .
classification of his personality traits . Further, because his beloved grandson was killed in the
battle, Temujin ordered his soldiers to kill all the people
and animals (D’ohsson, 2013) .
Delphi method results We can understand the reasons for this aspect of his
Our sample of experts who completed two rounds resulted personality from the following two considerations . One is
with the following profiling by round: that the harsh natural environment and an underdeveloped
• Round 1: cruel and bloodthirsty, forthright and economy caused an “internal deficiency” in Mongolia,
chivalric, intelligent and capable, outstanding, self- predisposing them to overcome obstacles by utilising
reliant, martial spirit, heroic, and combatworthy . violence and aggression (Qian, 1988, p . 2) . The other
• Round 2: cruel and aggressive, forthright and chivalric, consideration is their belief in separation cultures (Meng,
intelligent and capable, outstanding, self-reliant, and 1999) . To the Mongolians, war was the primary means
martial spirit . of accomplishing great achievements at that time, and a
Thus, the consensus result list was as follows: cruel war of revenge was considered brave and praiseworthy .
and aggressive, forthright and chivalric, intelligent and In fact, both war and revenge were very unforgiving,
capable, outstanding, self-reliant, and martial spirit . because people had to eliminate their opponents . If they
failed, they were likely to be subjected to revenge actions
Discussion by their opponents, which would not only be accompanied
The formation of personality traits is influenced by many by civilian casualties and property loss, but also the death
factors . We profiled Temujin’s personality traits applying of individuals and relatives and the demise of the nation .
a mixed methods psychobiography approach (Zheng et As examples, the Tatars once killed Temujin’s ancestors;
al ., 2003) . We discuss the key personality attributes that Temujin’s father Yisügei killed the two leaders of the
Psychobiographical study of Temujin’s personality 181
Tatar tribe for revenge . Consequently, Yisügei himself was than 60 battles in his life, winning almost all of them . He
finally poisoned to death by the Tatars (Yu, 2014, pp.65– epitomised military genius to the greatest extent, which
86) . During this period, the two tribes suffered numerous had an immeasurable impact on the world of his time
casualties . The Tatars, the Tayichi’ut, and other tribes were (Balajinima et al ., 2005) .
afraid that Temujin’s power would grow . Consequently, The personality of Temujin was influenced by the
they could not allow him to continue to live; accordingly, following three factors. The first is his sense of identity
Temujin needed to treat them cruelly to ensure his own as a king . Temujin was born in the Golden family that is
survival (Yu, 2014) . considered the most central branch of the Mongol tribe
whose orthodox supremacy has never changed . Temujin
Forthright and chivalric was born “with a blood clot in his hand”, a spear-shaped
There are many records of Temujin’s love for his flag, and a symbol of the Mongolian God of war (Sukhbalu,
subordinates and the help he provided to friends . For 1984, p . 11) . The ancient Mongols generally believed that
example, when Temujin hunted with the Zhaolie, he took holding blood meant holding life and the capabilities for
the initiative to drive livestock to them so that the small conquering everything because of the special relationship
and weak tribe could obtain more food, and therefore between blood and life .
survive (Song, 1976) . Moreover, Temujin and his father Temujin obtained great affirmation from the wise and
helped Ong Qan defeat his enemies and regain his capable Dei-sechen of the Onggirat tribe, as evidenced by
throne many times . However, later, Ong Qan engaged in Dei-sechen symbolising Temujin as the sun and moon,
unsavoury behaviours, such as appropriating to himself which had the high status in ancient Mongolian culture
all the goods captured in the wars . Temujin chose to try (Yu, 2014, p . 80) . These factors laid the foundation
to repair their relationship rather than vanquish Ong Qan of Temujin’s identity as a king . Second, Temujin’s
(Yu, 2014, p . 258) . In his life, Temujin killed none of ancestors and father achieved great success . For example,
the generals with whom he built his empire . He not only Bodonchar, the tenth patriarch, conquered the Jarchi’ut
conferred meritorious titles on officials according to their tribe which ensured that he obtained many riches and
military achievement but also sincerely appreciated their power; the sixth ancestor Qaidu launched a war of revenge
contributions . against the Zarayier tribe, who became the generation
The following reason can explain the formation of this slaves of Qaidu and his descendants (Yu, 2014, pp . 39–43) .
personality . Hö’elün’s (Temujin’s mother) education about While Temujin’s father Yisügei did not have the title
unity affected Temujin deeply . For instance, Hö’elün often of the Khan, he was the leader of Mongolian tribes and a
admonished Temujin about the importance of unifying famous hero in this period (Zhu, 2004, p .55) . The glorious
the scattered Mongolian tribes into a prosperous national achievements of his ancestors and his father enhanced
(Erdunbielige & Zhao, 1989) . She also would have taught Temujin’s sense of identity with these ancestors and helped
him about harmony culture, expressed as respect and love establish his life goals . Thus, Temujin internalised the
for family and others (Inner Mongolia Institute of Law images of these people and hoped that he could become the
and Sociology of Laws, 2007) . These aspects of Temujin’s same as them, and even want to surpass them and achieve
background enabled him to be kind to subordinates, higher achievements . Third, the hero culture fostered in
relatives, and other tribes and to offer considerable help him the notion that everyone could become a hero . This
if necessary . hero culture encouraged people of his time to fight to earn
the honorary title of hero by performing great feats of
Intelligent and capable bravery . This was a common notion among Mongolians,
Young Temujin demonstrated superior intelligence and that heroes would have outstanding achievements .
capabilities early in his life, in being optimistic and with
no substance use problems . These capabilities enabled Self-reliant
him to escape from capture, “with the help of someone Temujin was only nine years old when his father died (Yu,
he could trust” (Yu, 2014, p . 110) . In defeat, he remained 2014, pp . 78–87) and the lack of a father figure motivated
hopeful, enabling him to regain the initiative and victory him to develop a sense of independence . This sense of
over his enemies . Earlier in his life, his family overcame independence helped him and his family to survive the
tribulations from incessant food shortages, robberies, and hardships they endured . He believed that: “close relatives
the revenge of old enemies . His heroic included wisdom, and friends are not better than … wisdom… although there
confidence, courage, responsibility, and so forth . are many confidants, the most trustworthy is yourself”
(Rosundzin, 1993, p . 182) .
Outstanding The personality of Temujin was influenced by the
Temujin attained many great achievements in his life . For following two factors. The first factor relates to Temujin’s
example, he created the largest empire in the world . His own experiences . After Yisügei died, his subordinates
vast steppe empire stretched from the Korean Peninsula in betrayed and abandoned the Temujin family . As Temujin’s
the east, to Poland and Hungary in the west, to the Russian power grew, his old reliable allies, such as Ong Qan of the
principalities of Siberia in the north, and to the Indo-China Kereyits, and Jamuqa of the Jadaran, eventually left him
Peninsula of Java in the south . It was three times the size and became his enemies (Yu, 2014) . They made Temujin
of China today . Temujin’s empire extended far beyond more firmly believe that steppe alliances were unreliable
the boundaries of Alexander the Great’s Macedonia and and fragile . The second factor was Hö’elün’s (his mother)
the Roman empire . Moreover, Temujin fought more far-reaching influence on him. After Yisügei died, the
182 Bao et al.
Temujin family was ostracised, but Hö’elün did not yield on the relatively static personality characteristics of
and fought against unfair treatment . Faced with an isolated Temujin but ignored the fact that personality is dynamic .
and dangerous life, Hö’elün bravely shouldered the heavy Moreover, we neglected to find the evidence to suggest any
responsibility of taking care of the family (Yu, 2014) . She changes in Temujin’s personality characteristics over his
was lifespan . Third, we relied on historical texts for the student
…wearing her high hat tightly on her head…she ran participant orientation and such texts lack in details of
upstream along the Onon’s banks, gathering ÖlirsÜn daily life important to exploring personality . Details of
and moyilsun with which to nourish their gullets day and daily life may be impactful on the individuals, perhaps
night…Wielding a pointed stick of juniper, she dug up
südün and chichigina and nourished them (Yu, 2014, p . more than those of large events, which are more likely to
99) . be modified due to their association with group interests.
In brief, Temujin’s self-reliant personality was formed
through his own experiences of fragile alliances, his Conclusion
mother’s self-reliant traits . Six personality traits characterised Temujin: “Cruel and
aggressive”, forthright and chivalric”, “intelligent and
capable”, “outstanding”, “self-reliant”, and “martial
Martial spirit spirit” . They intermingled by context and setting: “Cruel
Martial spirit was primarily reflected in resisting the and aggressive” was the personality trait when facing the
oppression of the Jin Dynasty and realising the goals of enemy; “forthright and chivalric” was the personality trait
internal unity and national independence . The Jin Dynasty in the presence of friends . Additionally, “Intelligent and
spared no effort to suppress competing tribes, which capable” was the personality characteristic in the aspect
impended unity of the Mongolian grasslands people . The of self-development . Further, “Outstanding” was the
dynasty even sent troops to slaughter the young steppe personality trait in the aspect of life goal; “self-reliant ”
people, aggravating the suffering of these people (Zhao, was the personality trait in terms of personal orientation;
1985, p .6) . Faced with the cruel rule of the Jin Dynasty, and “martial spirit” was the personality trait in the face of
Temujin waged a hard war and gained the independence oppression and suffering .
of the Mongolian plateau (Yu, 2014) . It was Temujin who The influencing factors of these personality traits are
eliminated the Tayichiud, the Merkids, the Tatars . The as follows: cultural background, including harmony and
Kereyits and other tribes, finally ending the steppe division separation, power and hero worship, nomadic and hunting
of nearly 400 years, thereby realising the grand unification life experience, including the death of his father Yisügei;
of the Mongolian Plateau (Yu, 2014) . Temujin’s martial economic distress; wars and rebellions; belief in symbols
spirit was of positive significance in achieving these goals . and in the divine influences of the sun and the moon, the
His nomadic and hunting culture combined to build in him education received from his mother Hö’elün and role
the character traits, such as being adventurous, rebellious, models, including his ancestors . These jointly promoted
and competitive, at a time when scholarly pursuits were the formation of Temujin’s personality characteristics .
looked down upon (Song, 1976) .
Declaration
Strengths and limitations of the study This research was supported by the 2016 General Project
This study is the first psychobiography study of Temujin . of Education of the National Social Science Foundation:
Research on the Growth Characteristics and Influencing Factors
First, although psychobiographical research has exhibited of Outstanding Scientific Talents from the Perspective of
consistent growth and popularity internationally (Du Psychobiography (BBA160043) .
Plessis, 2017; Ponterotto & Reynolds, 2017), and on the
Chinese mainland (Zheng, 2014) . Nonetheless, there
remains a great need for psychobiographies of ethnic ORCID
minority figures, contributing to the richness of the Zheng Jianhong http://orcid .org/0000-0002-5583-9853
international literature . Accordingly, the current study is
a significant contribution on a well-known ethnic minority References
figure, Temujin . Second, this study used a combination of Balajinima, Erdunzhabu & Zhang, J . X . (Ed .) . (2005) . The First
qualitative and quantitative methods, an approach which Man of the Millennium: Genghis Khan in the Eyes of World
Celebrities . Nationalities Press .
has been generally neglected in psychobiographical studies . Bruner, J . (1990) . Culture and Human Development: A New
This mixed methods approach minimized subjectivity Look . Human Development, 33(6), 344-355 .
and personal arbitrariness in our psychobiographical D’ohsson, B . C . (2013) . The Mongolian history of D’ohsson (I) .
analysis . Third, this study provides a specific and detailed (Feng . C . J . Trans .) . Oriental Press .
description of Temujin’s personality traits and explains Du Plessis, C . (2017) . The method of psychobiography:
Presenting a step-wise approach . Qualitative Research in
their formation based on his life experiences, role models, Psychology, 14(2), 216–237 . https://doi .org/10 .1080/14780
and cultural background, addressing deficiencies in extant 887 .2017 .1284290
research on Temujin in the field of psychology . Edentaogetao (2013) . On the Form of Nomadic Society . Liaoning
We acknowledge three important limitations of the Nationalities Press .
study . First, we relied on a student sample and a small Erdunbielige & Zhao, Z . X . (1989) . Lady Hö’elün and her
historical role . [Philosophy and Social Sciences Edition] .
sample of experts. There is need to replicate the findings Journal of Northwest University for Nationalities, 1, 55–60 .
of this study with a sample from the general population
and larger panel of experts . Second, this study focused
Psychobiographical study of Temujin’s personality 183
Inner Mongolia Institute of Law and Sociology of Laws . (2007) . Shlapentokh, D . (2009) . The image of Genghis Khan and ethnic
Genghis Khan’s Code and Original Theory. The Commercial identities in post-soviet Russia . Asia Europe Journal, 7(3-4),
Press . 491–504 . https://doi .org/10 .1007/s10308-009-0236-0
Kőváry , Z. (2011). Psychobiography as a method. The revival of Song, L . (1976) . History of the Yuan Dynasty . Zhonghua Book
studying lives: New perspectives in personality and creativity Company .
research . Europe’s Journal of Psychology, 7(4), 739–777 . Stephenson, W .(1952) . Q-Methodology and the projective
https://doi .org/10 .5964/ejop .v7i4 .162 techniques . Journal of Clinical Psychology, 8(3), 219-229 .
Ma, G . Y . (2013) . Study on the Relationship between Man https://pubmed .ncbi .nlm .nih .gov/12981171/J
and Nature in Mongolian Culture . Liaoning Nationalities Sukhbalu . (1984) . Legend of Genghis Khan (Volume one) . Jilin
Publishing House . People’s Press .
Maikhiyev, D . K . (2014) . Development of tactics in military Sun, J ., & Wu, J . X . (2013) . Cai Yuanpei’s personality traits
art of Genghis Khan . Middle East Journal of Scientific and their influences on Chinese University education
Research,21(2), 414-417 . https://www .idosi .org/mejsr/ reform . Advances in Psychology, 03(01), 1–8 . https://doi .
mejsr21(2)14/20 .pdf org/10 .12677/AP .2013 .31001
Meng, C . B . (1999) . Grassland Culture and Human History (Vol . Wu, L .V . (2017) . Study on Mongolian Tengri Belief [Unpublished
I) . International Culture Publishing Corporation . doctoral dissertation] . Minzu University of China .
Ponterotto, J . G ., & Reynolds (Taewon Choi), J . D . (2017) . Yang, F . Y . (2012) . Characteristics, advantages and disadvantages
Ethical and legal considerations in psychobiography . of Delphi method . Journal of Inner Mongolia University for
The American Psychologist, 72(5), 446–458 . https://doi . Nationalities. 18(2), 195–196 .
org/10 .1037/amp0000047 Yu, D . J . (Ed .) . (2014) . The secret history of Mongolia . Inner
Qian, M . (1988) . Introduction to Chinese cultural history . Mongolia University Press .
SDX Joint Publishing Company . Yu, Q . Y . (2007) . Millennium Culture . China Braille Press .
Rosundzin . (1993) . The Golden History of Mongolia. (Sedorji, Zhao G . (1985) . Mongolian records . Zhonghua Book Company .
Trans) . Mongolian Studies Press . Zheng, J . H . (2014) . Psychobiographical studies in mainland
Runyan, W . M . (2005) . Evolving conceptions of psychobiography China and the research model thereof combining qualitative
and the study of lives: Encounters with psychoanalysis, and quantitative methods . In J . H . Zheng, W . M . Li, & X .
personality psychology and historical science . In W . T . X . Ding (Eds .), Life narrative and psychobiography (pp .
Schultz (Ed .), The handbook of psychobiography (pp . 41–61) . Central Compilation and Translation Press .
19–42) . Oxford University Press . Zheng, J . H ., Huang, X . T ., & Zhang, J . F . (2003) . A
Schinbatu . (2006) . Mongolian epic: From formula to metaphor. psychobiographical study of Liang-Shuming’s personality .
Nationalities Press . Psychological Science, 26(1), 9–12 . https://doi .
Schultz, W . T ., & Lawrence, S . (2017) . Psychobiography: Theory org/10 .16719/j .cnki .1671-6981 .2003 .01 .002
and method . The American Psychologist, 72(5), 434–445 . Zhu Y . T .(2004) . Biography of Genghis Khan. People’s
https://doi .org/10 .1037/amp0000130 Publishing House .