Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Blood Transfusion Research Center, High Institute for Research and Education in Transfusion Medicine, Tehran, Iran
SUMMARY blood components are the most important parts of patient care
systems of all countries and depend on the generosity of donors
Objectives: The aim of this study was to determine the rate of and government support for finance of blood collection, produc-
blood component wastage before and after interventions at Yazd tion of blood components, laboratory investigations and storage
Blood Transfusion Center. and distribution of blood and blood components (Veihola et al.,
Background: The growing need for blood components along 2008; National Blood Authority, 2013; Bots et al., 2016).
with blood safety issues and rising costs constantly pressurise The yearly cost of blood components in Iran is ∼500 mil-
blood centres to improve their efficiency. Reducing the quantity lion dollars, and with the ever-growing need for higher safety
of discarded blood at all stages of the supply chain can decrease levels of blood supply, this figure is constantly on the rise. It
the total costs. is therefore necessary to increase the efficiency of blood sup-
Methods: Data on discarded blood components were extracted ply along with the reduction in inappropriate use of blood in
from the database of Yazd Blood Transfusion Center. Multi- order to overcome the pressures of increasing costs of blood
ple interventions, including implementation of wastage manage- (Veihola et al., 2006; Collins et al., 2015). Accordingly, two basic
ment standard operating procedures and reduction of red blood pathways should be the top priority: the first half of the blood
cells (RBCs) inventory level, were implemented. Discard rates of chain from blood collection to blood distribution in blood trans-
blood components in the 3 years after intervention (2013–2015) fusion centres and reducing the blood discard rate and patient
were compared with the discard rates in the 3 years before inter- blood management in healthcare centres (Heitmiller et al., 2010;
ventions. Zoric et al., 2013; Yazer et al., 2016). Increased efficiency at blood
Results: The total wastage rate of blood components decreased transfusion centres, together with management of blood usage at
by almost 60%. Discard rates of RBCs, platelets and plasma hospitals, leads to decreased costs and prevention of wastage of
decreased from 9·7%, 18·5% and 5·4% to 2·9%, 10·5% and 2·3%, national resources (Morish et al., 2012). The Blood Transfusion
(P < 0·001) after intervention, respectively. The most prevalent Organization of Iran, with its branches in all of the provinces of
reason for discarding units was expiration of RBCs and platelets. the country, is the sole agency responsible for the supply of blood
Plasma units were discarded mostly due to technical faults dur- and blood components. However, it has no involvement in the
ing processing. The cost saving of reduction in blood wastage was second part of the chain in hospitals (Javadzadeh Shahshahani
estimated to be 1,500,000 dollars. et al., 2015; Pourfathollah et al., 2015).
A few studies on blood components wastage in blood centres
Conclusion: Interventions had a significant impact on the
have been published in different countries (Kajja et al., 2010;
reduction of blood wastage with respect to both cost and blood
Baesler et al., 2014). Blood wastage rates range from 0·2 to 30%
supply saving.
in different studies depending on the type of blood component
Key words: blood transfusion, blood components, wastage. level (Veihola et al., 2008). However, there has been no study to
date on blood wastage management in Iranian blood transfusion
INTRODUCTION centres. The present paper aimed to investigate the blood wastage
The main aim of blood centres worldwide is the provision of levels at the Blood Transfusion Center of Yazd province in Iran.
safe and sufficient blood and blood components. Safe blood and Several interventions were also implemented in order to reduce
wastage to an acceptable.
© 2017 British Blood Transfusion Society Transfusion Medicine, 2017, 27, 348–353
13653148, 2017, 5, Downloaded from https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/tme.12433 by Ufrgs - Universidade Federal Do Rio Grande Do Sul, Wiley Online Library on [14/12/2023]. See the Terms and Conditions (https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/terms-and-conditions) on Wiley Online Library for rules of use; OA articles are governed by the applicable Creative Commons License
350 H. Javadzadeh Shahshahani and N. Taghvai
Fig. 1. Frequency of total blood components prepared and wasted from 2010 to 2015. The total number of blood components prepared or wasted from
2010 to 2015. The blood component wastage rate as a percentage of the number of units prepared showed an ascending trend from 2010 to 2012, whereas
it descended from 2013 to 2015. Despite a 2–4% increase in the production of blood components in 2014–2015, the total wastage rate decreased from
5·7% to 2·1%. The total amount of wastage prior to the intervention was 31 248 U, and it decreased to 13 270 U after intervention.
(Fig. 2). Expired units were defined as blood components that Table 1. Frequency of blood components issued to the hospitals in
were expired in the blood transfusion centre before delivery to comparison to the components requested by hospitals in the
pre-intervention and post-intervention years
hospitals. Causes of preparation wastage included conditions in
which the standard requirements during component processing Blood components No. of units requested No. of units issued (%)
were not met. These included inappropriate volume, abnormal
colour of the component, contamination with RBCs, rupture or Pre-intervention
leakage of blood bags and so on. Reactive test results for infec- RBCs 98 459 93 854 (95·3)
tious diseases and inappropriate temperature during storage Platelet 61 787 49 281 (79·8)
Plasma 37 129 34 874 (93·9)
or transport were also reasons for component wastage. Other
Post-intervention
reasons included withdrawing of components due to donor call
RBCs 102 995 102 131 (99·2)
back, look back and blood donation in the deferral period and Platelet 64 050 59 097 (92·3)
ABO/Rh blood group discrepancies. Plasma 43 719 43 091 (98·6)
The RBC wastage rate was calculated as a percentage of units
prepared. The major reason for RBC wastage was expiry. After
intervention, RBCs wastage due to expiration decreased dramat-
ically. Similar to RBCs, expiration was the main cause of PLT implementation of certain corrective actions to obviate the
wastage. Technical faults during preparation and inappropriate root causes occurring within production and storage of blood
storage were other important causes of PLT wastage. After the components were effective factors in the reduction of wastage.
intervention, PLT wastage due to preparation decreased by 89%, There were many reasons for wastage, of which expiration was
which was the highest rate of reduction of wastage during prepa- the most important one. One of the qualitative goals defined
ration among blood components. Wastage during preparation for blood transfusion centres in 2011 and 2012 was the annual
was the most common cause of plasma wastage. The number of increment of blood collection, which was not planned based
plasma units discarded due to expiration or inappropriate tem- on hospitals’ demand, and it played an important role in the
perature during storage or transportation was nil after interven- increased rate of wastage. In 2012, 13·3% of prepared compo-
tion (Fig. 2). nents were wasted. Discard rate of blood components in central
Blood components issued to the hospitals increased after the India was 14·6%, which was similar to the present study’s results
interventions (P < 0·001) (Table 1). (Kumar et al., 2014). In 10 European countries, the wastage level
was reported to range between 0·2 and 7·7%, with an average
of 4·5% (Veihola et al., 2006). This was much lower than the
DISCUSSION
wastage rate in the present study. In early 2013, the adjustment
Simple interventions resulted in a significant drop in blood of blood collection level based on hospitals’ demand led to a
component wastage. Among different types of blood com- highly significant reduction of wastage. From the beginning of
ponents, RBCs showed the highest reduction of wastage rate 2015, the RBCs’ inventory level in the Yazd blood transfusion
after intervention. Continuous monitoring of wastage and the centre decreased by 2 more days. Reduction in RBCs’ inventory
Transfusion Medicine, 2017, 27, 348–353 © 2017 British Blood Transfusion Society
13653148, 2017, 5, Downloaded from https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/tme.12433 by Ufrgs - Universidade Federal Do Rio Grande Do Sul, Wiley Online Library on [14/12/2023]. See the Terms and Conditions (https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/terms-and-conditions) on Wiley Online Library for rules of use; OA articles are governed by the applicable Creative Commons License
Blood wastage management in blood centre 351
© 2017 British Blood Transfusion Society Transfusion Medicine, 2017, 27, 348–353
13653148, 2017, 5, Downloaded from https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/tme.12433 by Ufrgs - Universidade Federal Do Rio Grande Do Sul, Wiley Online Library on [14/12/2023]. See the Terms and Conditions (https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/terms-and-conditions) on Wiley Online Library for rules of use; OA articles are governed by the applicable Creative Commons License
352 H. Javadzadeh Shahshahani and N. Taghvai
important role in processing of blood components. Therefore, central India showed that 1·2% of RBCs or FFP units were dis-
sufficient and continuous training to personnel and use of carded due to seropositivity for transfusion-transmissible infec-
proper and update techniques facilitates the reduction of tech- tions (TTIs) (Kumar et al., 2014). The total blood discard rate
nical wastages. Breakage was the other important reason for due to positive serology in a blood centre in Curitiba-Brazil was
plasma wastage. Frozen plasma is very sensitive to fracture, and 5% (Monich et al., 2016). The screening test results for TTIs
in case of inappropriate transport, it experiences breakage and in The Netherlands and the Austrian Red Cross Blood Estab-
leakage. Accordingly, staff training with regards to the proper lishment showed that the annual average for repeatedly reactive
transportation and storage of frozen plasma in order to reduce donations was ∼0·1%. Based on the Guide of the Council of
wastage due to breakage of plasma bears great importance. Europe, these units were rejected (De Kort et al., 2016). These
Reduced plasma preparation wastage indicates the effectiveness differences in discard rates among various blood centres may be
of interventions (Fig. 2). With regards to sending plasma for due to the variation in the prevalence of TTIs among popula-
fractionation, plasma expiration gradually decreased to zero tions who are eligible for blood donation, policies for educat-
in 2014 and 2015. Since 2005, IBTO initiated a contract frac- ing and selecting healthy donors and type of donors (voluntary
tionation programme to use surplus plasma for improving the non-remunerated donors from lower risk population).
availability and affordability of plasma-derived medicine. The Reduced wastages during post-intervention years led to the
volume of plasma shipped for fractionation has gradually signif- saving of more than 8000 blood units collected and the produc-
icantly increased in subsequent years (Cheraghali, 2012). In the tion of 18 000 blood components units and ∼1 500 000 dollars.
Yazd Blood Transfusion Center, the rate of plasma shipment to a During the study period, although the overall total num-
fractionator during 2010–2015 increased by 40% (from 19 000 ber of prepared units decreased, it then proceeded to increase.
to 27 000 plasma units), and therefore, plasma wastage rate due The present study was limited to the first half of the blood
to expiration decreased significantly. chain; therefore, it is essential to develop recommendations for
The reduction of wastage during storage after interventions the proper use of blood components to minimise inappropriate
was due to accurate implementations of SOPs for maintenance use. Implementation of a proper inventory management system
of temperature during storage and validation of components’ at the hospital blood banks can also result in a reduction in
temperature during transportation. It is important that blood blood wastage and unnecessary demands. Recent studies show
components be transported at the appropriate temperature. that improvement in inventory management resulted in a sig-
Therefore, all transit containers, packing materials and pro- nificant decline in wasted blood units by the hospitals (Chung
cedures have been validated for various transport times and et al., 2016). Implementation of a patient blood management
environmental temperatures. These validations have been programme in ∼40% of AABB hospitals was associated with
performed in advance to ensure that blood components are a decrease in the number of transfused units (Whitaker et al.,
maintained at the correct temperature for the duration of antici- 2016).
pated transport time. Validation has been repeated periodically.
Using appropriate containers for the correct number of blood
CONCLUSION
units, equilibration of transit containers to their storage tem-
perature prior to filling with components, minimising dead air The present study was the first interventional research in Iran
space in packaging containers and transporting blood compo- on the management of wastage of blood and blood components
nents exactly according to the validation documents minimised and showed that interventions implemented to reduce blood
wastages. In the present study, wastage level reduced to zero wastage were effective. Establishment of a centralised informa-
after interventions (Fig. 2). tion department in the country to determine the surplus of each
A certain level of blood component wastage was inevitable, provincial centre, along with the accurate need of all centres, can
which included discarded units due to reactive infectious test lead to effective inventory management and a significant drop in
results with a rate of ∼0·5% of prepared units. The blood dona- wastage of blood and blood components in the country.
tions are all screened for HBsAg, HIV antigen/antibody and
anti-HCV using approved and similar commercially available
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
ELISA kits across the country. Treponemal antibodies are also
screened as a marker for syphilis infection. According to the H. J. S. designed the research, analysed the data and prepared
IBTO regulation, initial reactive donations are discarded. The the manuscript; H. J. S. and N. T. reviewed the manuscript
repeatedly reactive samples are confirmed using HBsAg confir- and approved it. The authors thank Dr S. Amini Kafiabad,
matory assay, HIV I/II Western Blot (WB) and HCV recombi- Dr F. Amiri, M. Bahri, H. Dehghanizadeh who helped in the
nant immunoblot assay (RIBA). The confirmed positive donors study and Dr M. T. Yavari for the final English revision of the
are recalled for counselling and follow up (Kafi-abad et al., 2009). manuscript.
Discard rates due to reactive infectious tests vary widely among
blood centres. In a study of blood services in Uganda, the discard CONFLICT OF INTEREST
rate due to infectious test reactivity was nearly 6% (Kajja et al.,
2010). Analysis of reasons for discarding blood components in The authors have no competing interests.
Transfusion Medicine, 2017, 27, 348–353 © 2017 British Blood Transfusion Society
13653148, 2017, 5, Downloaded from https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/tme.12433 by Ufrgs - Universidade Federal Do Rio Grande Do Sul, Wiley Online Library on [14/12/2023]. See the Terms and Conditions (https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/terms-and-conditions) on Wiley Online Library for rules of use; OA articles are governed by the applicable Creative Commons License
Blood wastage management in blood centre 353
REFERENCES Javadzadeh Shahshahani, H., Hatami, H., Mer- to Minimize Blood and Blood Product
aat, N. & Savabieh, S. (2015) Epidemiology Wastage. URL www.blood.org.au/wastage
Baesler, F., Nemeth, M., Martinez, C. & Bastías,
of blood component recipients in hospitals (Accessed 11/09/2015).
A. (2014) Analysis of inventory strategies for
of Yazd, Iran. Transfusion Medicine, 25, 2–7. Pourfathollah, A.A., Hosseini Divkolaye,
blood components in a regional blood cen-
Kafi-abad, S.A., Rezvan, H., Abolghasemi, H. N.S. & Seighali, F. (2015) Four decades
ter using process simulation. Transfusion,
54, 323–330. & Talebian, A. (2009) Prevalence and trends of National Blood Service in Iran: out-
Bots, M., de, Grouw, E.P., van, Rooyen- of human immunodeficiency virus, hepati- reach, prospect and challenges. Transfusion
Schreurs, I.H., van den, Akker, G.J., Sturk, tis B virus, and hepatitis C virus among Medicine, 25, 138–143.
A., Klinkspoor, J.H. & Zeerleder, S.S. (2016) blood donors in Iran, 2004 through 2007. Van Dijk, N., Haijema, R., van der, Wal, J. &
Strategies to reduce wastage of red blood Transfusion, 49, 2214–2220. Sibinga, C.S. (2009) Blood platelet produc-
cell units. Vox Sanguinis, 110, 143–149. Kajja, I., Kyeyune, D., Bimenya, G.S. & Sibinga, tion: a novel approach for practical opti-
Cheraghali, A.M. (2012) Cost effectiveness of C.T. (2010) Bottlenecks of blood process- mization. Transfusion, 49, 411–420.
Iran national plasma contract fractionation ing in Uganda. Transfusion Medicine, 20, Veihola, M., Aroviita, P., Linna, M., Sinto-
program. DARU Journal of Pharmaceutical 329–336. nen, H. & Kekomäki, R. (2006) Variation
Sciences, 20, 63. Kumar, A., Sharma, S.M., Ingole, N.S. & Gan- of platelet production and discard rates in
Chung, K.W., Basavaraju, S.V., Mu, Y., van, gane, N. (2014) Analysis of reasons for dis- 17 blood centers representing 10 European
Santen, K.L., Haass, K.A., Henry, R., Berger, carding blood and blood components in a countries from 2000 to 2002. Transfusion,
J. & Kuehnert, M.J. (2016) Declining blood blood bank of tertiary care hospital in cen- 46, 991–995.
collection and utilization in the United tral: a prospective study. International Jour- Veihola, M., Aroviita, P., Kekomäki, R., Linna,
States. Transfusion, 56, 2184–2192. nal of Medicine and Public Health, 4, 72–74. M., Linna, M. & Sintonen, H. (2008) Dis-
Collins, R.A., Wisniewski, M.K., Waters, J.H., Monich, A.G., Dantas, T.W., Fávero, K.B., carded cellular components and the tech-
Triulzi, D.J. & Yazer, M.H. (2015) Effective- Almeida, P.T.R., Maluf, E.C., Capeletto, nical efficiency of component preparation.
ness of multiple initiatives to reduce blood C.D.M. & Nisihara, R.M. (2016) Blood European Journal of Health Economics, 9,
component wastage. American Journal of discard rate in a blood center in 325–331.
Clinical Pathology, 143, 329–335. Curitiba – Brazil. Ten years of study. Trans- Whitaker, B., Rajbhandary, S., Kleinman, S.,
De Kort, W., Janssen, M., Kortbeek, N., Jansen, fusion and Apheresis Science, 56, 130–134. Harris, A. & Kamani, N. (2016) Trends
N., van der, Wal, J. & van, Dijk, N. (2011) DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.transci.2016. in United States blood collection and
Platelet pool inventory management: theory 10.007. transfusion: results from the 2013 AABB
meets practice. Transfusion, 51, 2295–2303. Morish, M., Ayob, Y., Naim, N., Salman, H., Blood Collection, Utilization, and Patient
De Kort, W., Mayr, W., Jungbauer, C. et al. Muhamad, N.A. & Yusoff, N.M. (2012) Blood Management Survey. Transfusion,
(2016) Blood donor selection in European Quality indicators for discarding blood in 56, 2173–2183.
Union directives: room for improvement. the National Blood Center, Kuala Lumpur. Yazer, M.H., Deandrade, D.S., Triulzi, D.J.,
Blood Transfusion, 14, 101–108. Asian Journal of Transfusion Science, 6, Wisniewski, M.K. & Waters, J.H. (2016)
Gomez, A.T., Quinn, J.G., Doiron, D.J., 19–23. Electronic enhancements to blood ordering
Watson, S., Crocker, B.D. & Cheng, C.K. National Advisory Committee on Blood reduce component waste. Transfusion, 56,
(2015) Implementation of a novel real-time and Blood Products. Canadian Blood 564–570.
platelet inventory management system at a Services (2015). The National Plan for the Zoric, L., Daurat, G., Demattei, C. et al. (2013)
multi-site transfusion service. Transfusion, Management of Shortages of Labile Blood Blood wastage reduction: a 10-year observa-
55, 2070–2075. Components. URL http://www.nacblood.ca/ tional evaluation in a large teaching institu-
Heitmiller, E.S., Hill, R.B., Marshall, C.E., resources/shortages-plan/National_Plan_ tion in France. European Journal of Anaes-
Berkow, L.C., Barrasso, C.A., Zink, E.K. October72015.pdf (Accessed 14/09/2016). thesiology, 30, 250–255.
& Ness, P.M. (2010) Blood wastage reduc- National Blood Authority (2013) National
tion using Lean Sigma methodology. Blood and Blood Products Wastage Reduc-
Transfusion, 50, 1887–1896. tion Strategies, 2013–2017. Working Smarter
© 2017 British Blood Transfusion Society Transfusion Medicine, 2017, 27, 348–353