Professional Documents
Culture Documents
© UK-RAS 2022
ISSN-2398-4422
DOI: 10.31256/WP2022.1
Legged Robotics:
Agile and Dynamic Interaction
www.ukras.org.uk
// Legged Robotics: Agile and Dynamic Interaction
Legged Robotics: Agile and Dynamic Interaction //
UKRAS.ORG.UK
// Legged Robotics: Agile and Dynamic Interaction
FO RE WOR D
LEGGED ROBOTICS:
AGILE AND DYNAMIC INTERACTION
Welcome to the UK-RAS White Paper the point where they move smoothly and omission of specific areas of development
Series on Robotics and Autonomous confidently over rugged real world terrain to that need to be covered, or major future
Systems (RAS). This is one of the core undertake tasks. In the future, will legged trends that deserve further debate and in-
activities of UK-RAS Network, funded by robots be the primary form of robot? This depth analysis.
the Engineering and Physical Sciences is certainly an exciting possibility of the
Research Council (EPSRC). By bringing future. I hope the white paper will inspire Please direct all your feedback to
together academic centres of excellence, future research, promote collaboration, and whitepaper@ukras.org.uk.
industry, government, funding bodies and identify key areas of future growth in this We look forward to hearing from you!
charities, the Network provides academic fascinating area of RAS.
leadership and expands collaboration with
industry while integrating and coordinating The UK-RAS white papers serve as a basis
activities across the UK. for discussing the future technological
roadmaps, engaging the wider community
This white paper explores the state of the and stakeholders, as well as policy makers
art in legged robots. Until recently, legged in assessing the potential social, economic
robots were imaginations of science and ethical/legal impact of RAS. It is our
fiction or at best clumsy demonstrations plan to provide updates for these white
in research labs. Research in the UK and papers so your feedback is essential - Prof. Robert Richardson
overseas has developed legged robots to whether it be pointing out inadvertent Chairman, UK-RAS Network
Prof Maurice Fallon Dr Ioannis Havoutis Dr Dimitrios Kanoulas Dr Zhibin (Alex) Li Dr David Megson- Dr Chengxu Zhou
Smith
mfallon@robots.ox.ac.uk havoutis@robots.ox.ac.uk d.kanoulas@ucl.ac.uk alex.li@ucl.ac.uk C.X.Zhou@leeds.ac.uk
david.megson-smith@bristol.
University of Oxford University of Oxford University College London University College London University of Leeds
ac.uk
Maurice is an Associate Ioannis is a Departmental Dimitrios is a UKRI Alex is an Associate Chengxu is a Lecturer
Professor and a Royal Lecturer at the Oxford Future Leader Fellow and Professor in Robotics University of Bristol in Mobile Robotics and
Society University Robotics Institute. His Lecturer in Robotics and and AI at UCL. His David is a Senior the Deputy Director
Research Fellow research combines Computation at UCL, research covers robotics, Research Associate in of the Institute of
at Oxford Robotics dynamic whole-body working in perception automation, perceptual- the Interface Analysis Design, Robotics and
Institute. He is also a motion planning and and learning for robots motor learning, general Center at the University Optimisation at the
Research Fellow of control with machine that have limbs, motor intelligence, of Bristol. He has University of Leeds. He
Wolfson College, Oxford. learning, focusing including quadrupeds, invention of new extensive experience is leading research in
He leads the Dynamic on robots with arms humanoids, and mobile technologies for real- in the development legged robotics at the
Robot Systems Group. and legs. manipulators. world robot applications. of advanced sensing Real Robotics Lab.
systems and data
analysis procedures.
Legged Robotics: Agile and Dynamic Interaction //
EX E CUTI V E S UM M ARY
Legged robots have long captivated the The progress towards industrially feasible, form factor, industrial grade depth cameras,
general public. The robots in science fiction technologically advanced walking robots is high quality MEMS IMUs and lightweight
are often depicted as anthropomorphic undeniable. While Boston Dynamic's Spot materials are other components which have
bipeds either helping or threatening quadruped and Atlas biped have achieved contributed to the commercialisation of this
mankind. However, locomotion as a a type of narrow super-human athleticism, generation of walking robots.
skill is deceptively complicated and other companies such as ANYbotics,
underappreciated as we learn to walk as Unitree Robotics and Ghost Robotics Within the UK, there is a vibrant research
toddlers.. In reality the Homo Sapien is one have brought products to the market community working on legged robots.
of the few species to walk which target different market segments; Several universities have invested in
on two feet because of this challenge. for example, industrial inspection, low-cost platforms and are carrying out research
platforms and military applications. in a variety of sub-fields. Core problems
One of the main drivers for this research such as high degrees of freedom compliant
field is that our world is largely built with the The key development that has enabled balancing and motion generation are
human morphology in mind. Staircases, rapid progress is force sensing and whole popular in the more established groups
doorways, counter-tops and work stations body balancing control. These core while the demonstration of the platform and
are all built around the typical size of a technological components have enabled its application in field situations has drawn
human adult. Mobile robots in the homes compliant and flexible locomotion. Modern in researchers (for example in the energy
and offices of our future need to adapt walking robots now adapt to the world's and nuclear sector).
to our space, rather than the other complexities rather than being brittle to the
way around. unexpected. Embedded computers in small
// Legged Robotics: Agile and Dynamic Interaction
One of the main drivers for legged robotics is that our world is
largely built with the human morphology in mind. Staircases,
doorways, counter-tops and work stations are all built around
the typical size of a human adult. Mobile robots in the homes
and offices of our future need to adapt to our space, rather
than the other way around.
Legged Robotics: Agile and Dynamic Interaction //
CONTENTS
1. Te c h n o l o g y B ri ef 2
2. I n t e r n a t i o n a l P ersp ect i ve 3
3. U K C h a l l e n g es and S t rengt hs 4
4. L e g g e d R o b o t Research A cross t he U K 5
6. S u m m a ry a n d Recommend at i ons 14
1 // Legged Robotics: Agile and Dynamic Interaction
1. TECHNOLOGY BRIEF
Mechanical walking systems actually date back to the Early humanoid robotics is much more associated with
1960s. General Electric built a four-legged walking truck, Japan. Honda started developing humanoid robots in the
powered by hydraulics, in the mid 1960s. It could carry late 1980s and had various prototypes of self-regulating
an operator, push heavy railway sleepers and give tactile bipeds before the release of ASIMO in 2000. Challenges
feedback to the operator, who needed to coordinate every to be overcome were that of climbing and descending
motion of the legged truck. The goal was to develop an staircases, as well as perceiving obstacles before depth
all-terrain mobility solution with military application. However, sensing technologies existed. Over 100 copies of ASIMO
cognitive burden on the operator was high, the ride was were created. Outside of Honda, the Japanese Ministry of
rough and the platform was decommissioned shortly after. Economy, Trade and Industry (METI) in collaboration with
Kawada Industries developed the HRP series of robots
Space exploration is another domain where legged robots
(in the Humanoid Robotics Project). About 5 different
have been promoted. A team led by Eric Krotkov and
generations of robots were developed. The HRP-2 robot
Reid Simmons in CMU developed the six-legged Ambler
is perhaps most recognisable. Japanese and also French
quadruped with funding from NASA which could cross soft
funding projects have demonstrated the HRP-2 in mock
and deformable terrains such as those found on the moon
industrial scenarios.
or nearby planets. Early approaches to sensor fusion and
legged odometry were studied in their research papers. A key point of evolution of humanoid robotics was the
The hexapod design was promoted because of its ability DARPA Robotics Challenge. The DRC was not specifically
to be statically stable at all times. focused on bipeds, but rather a biped was the most logical
solution for manipulation of a series of tasks posed by a
Meanwhile, an entirely different approach was being
mock disaster response situation. Teams from across the
developed by Marc Raibert (first in CMU and then at MIT).
world developed robots including several HPR-2 robots,
A 3D one-leg hopper was created in 1983 and could actively
self-built bipeds and multiple copies of the Atlas humanoid
balance with simple reflexive feedback control algorithms.
robot (developed by Boston Dynamics with DARPA funding)
It could hop in place, follow simple paths and maintain
competed in a series of competitions over 3 years up to
balance when disturbed. A core principle was the use of
2015. The winning team was the Hubo robot from KAIST
hydraulics to ensure a very quick reaction and to ensure
(Korea) which demonstrated significant flexibility in achieving
power availability. Throughout the 1980s Raibert's group
each of the eight tasks.
developed more complex biped and quadruped robots
before commercialising the research as Boston Dynamics.
Research continued with the famous BigDog series of gas-
powered, all-terrain quadrupeds which were funded by a
series of DARPA and US Defence grants. The LS3 (Legged
Squad Support System) was the first robot that attempted
to have a product capability - acting as a pack mule for the
US Marines and able to carry 100s of pounds of supplies
over hills, ravines and through forests. Since about 2015
Boston Dynamics shifted to electric actuation and created
the refined product model of the much smaller Spot robot
which has now been sold to hundreds of companies and
research labs with applications including inspection,
security, healthcare and entertainment.
3 // Legged Robotics: Agile and Dynamic Interaction
2 . I NTE RN ATIO N AL P ER S P E CT I V E
It is notable that there are no UK-based manufacturers of the developed by Agility Robotics which has produced about a
leading legged robots. Boston Dynamics (USA), ANYbotics dozen copies for research labs across the US and Canada.
(Switzerland), PAL Robotics (Spain), Unitree Robotics The Boston Dynamics Atlas robot is not available for public
(China) being a few examples of growing companies in this purchase at this time.
sector across the world. Some research into mechanical
Oxford's Dynamic Robot Systems Group are part of the
design and development of legged robots is conducted,
winning team of the DARPA Subterranean Challenge - an
for example, in Imperial College and University of Bristol.
international competition to develop multi-robot collaborative
However the degree of investment and knowledge build-up
exploration solutions for disaster response and exploration.
makes it difficult to compete against international players.
Their team, called Cerberus, used multiple copies of
UK research groups have tended to focus instead on
the ANYmal from ANYbotics as well as both wheeled
collaboration and interaction with these organisations on the
and aerial robots from University of Reno, Nevada and
software level.
ETH Zurich. Within this competition, legged robots have
The University of Edinburgh is one of a few owners of a PAL proven to be surprisingly valuable. Wheeled robots
TALOS humanoid, which they use to carry out research immediately face limitations when terrain is rough or stairs
into dynamic coordinated motor control and human robot need to be traversed. The top competitors in the challenge
interaction within the MEMMO EU project. This is with the used combinations of the ANYmal robot, as well as several
Laboratory for Analysis and Architecture of Systems (LAAS) Boston Dynamics Spot in the finals of this competition that
in Toulouse, who also own an identical copy of the TALOS has been held in the United States in September 2021.
robot. Other international research with humanoids includes
the research programme with the Cassie and Digit platforms
Legged Robotics: Agile and Dynamic Interaction // 4
3 . U K CHAL L EN G ES A ND S T RE NGT HS
The UK's efforts in legged robots have been a combination which each include research strands for legged robots.
of fundamental scientific research (on the capabilities The NASA-produced Valkyrie robot has been a flagship
of motion planning, dynamic balance, state estimation platform for the Fairspace hub which is organised from
and loco-manipulation) with demonstrations in industrial Surrey University with a focus on space applications.
scenarios to showcase the emerging field. Both NCNR and RAIN hubs are nuclear orientated, with
quadrupeds seen to carry out gamma radiation mapping on
This general thrust has been enhanced by the Industry
the facilities of the UK Atomic Energy Authority. Finally, the
Strategy Challenge Fund (ISCF) which focused investment
ORCA hub concentrates on the offshore energy sector (Oil &
on robotics towards its application in extreme environments
Gas as well as renewables) and has hosted demonstrations
(space, nuclear, offshore and mining). The Robotics for a
on mock-up oil rig platforms carrying out inspection rounds.
Safer World programme funded four use-case inspired hubs
Figure 1
Four EPSRC/ISCF-funded research hubs have spurred development and deployment of legged robot demonstrator.
5 // Legged Robotics: Agile and Dynamic Interaction
4. L
E G G E D R O B O T R E S E A R CH A CROS S T HE U K
Several UK institutions and industries, have invested in The Interface Analysis Centre at the University of Bristol has
legged robots, either bipeds, quadrupeds, or hexapods. used the Boston Dynamics Spot for radiation inspection at
In this section, we will give a brief overview of the robotic Chernobyl in collaboration with RACE (part of UKAEA). The
hardware that is currently used in the UK and the main Oxford Robotics Institute at the University of Oxford has two
research and application areas targeted. versions of the ANYbotics ANYmal quadruped-model B and
C, a Boston Dynamics Spot and a Unitree A1 quadruped
The Edinburgh Centre of Robotics (Heriot Watt University
robot. This group works on motion planning and navigation
and University of Edinburgh) has been a pioneer in this
targeting challenging terrain and remote facilities. In 2021,
field within the UK. Their platforms include the ANYbotics
they competed in the DARPA Subterranean Challenge as the
ANYmal and Boston Dynamics Spot quadrupeds, as well
only UK involvement.
as the bipeds NASA Valkyrie and Pal Robotics TALOS. The
ongoing research at the Edinburgh Centre of Robotics is The University of Manchester's robotics group has
focused on optimized motion planning for the legged robots. developed their own custom hexapod robot for nuclear
inspection. The University of Plymouth (Centre for Robotics
The Robot Intelligence Lab at Imperial College London has
and Neural Systems) used the NAO bipeds and custom
focused on the mechatronics design including the novel
humanoid robots in teaching. University College London is
SLIDER biped which uses a linear knee actuator.
working with several legged robots including Unitree A1,
The Real Robotics Lab at the University of Leeds has been Go1, and B1, ANYbotics ANYmal, and Boston Dynamics
working with various legged robots, from mini-size pipe Spot, as well as DeepRobotics Jueying Lite2 in several
inspection “wheeleg” robots, to small-size humanoid application, such as enabling natural sampling of
robots, to middle-size quadruped robots, such as several volcanic environments.
Unitree Laikago, Aliengo and A1 robots, as well as an
In addition to research activities, researchers from the
ANYbotics ANYmal. Highlights include the use of the
UK also organise international workshops on real-world
Laikago to carry out disinfection operations during the
locomotion, for example, at the IEEE International
COVID-19 pandemic in Leeds.
Conference on Robotics and Automation (ICRA) conference1.
1
http://leggedrobots.org
Legged Robotics: Agile and Dynamic Interaction // 6
Figure 2
Legged robots from across the UK: University of Oxford, University of Leeds, Edinburgh Centre of Robotics, and University College London.
7 // Legged Robotics: Agile and Dynamic Interaction
Figure 3
ANYmal quadruped inspecting the Offshore Renewable Energy Catapult Facility in Blyth. (Credit: ORCA Hub)
Legged Robotics: Agile and Dynamic Interaction // 8
Figure 4
Using the Spot quadruped to monitor radiation at the Chernobyl New Safe Confinement (NSC) structure, Ukraine. (Credit: University of Bristol)
9 // Legged Robotics: Agile and Dynamic Interaction
Figure 5
Overlay showing the Jueying quadruped being pushed over, recovering and continuing on its way. (Credit: University of Edinburgh)
Legged Robotics: Agile and Dynamic Interaction // 10
Figure 6
TeLeMan concept (left) and EOD demo (right). (Credit: University of Leeds)
Legged Robotics: Agile and Dynamic Interaction // 12
Figure 7
6 . S UM M A RY A N D R EC OMME ND AT I ONS
This white paper outlined the key challenges and the UK at a competitive global position, the UK funding
opportunities of developing and deploying legged robotics. agencies needs to ensure there is sufficient funding
We described promising ongoing research across the UK. support to renew equipment and to retain engineering
and research staff for maintaining platforms, building and
Finally, to conclude we offer some recommendations for
enhancing expertise.
future directions and investment based on an analysis of
existing capabilities including: • The UK legged robotics community would greatly benefit
from an integrative effort to bring together the research
• Legged robots now have the attention of major industrial
groups mentioned above to create more cohesive and
companies. They are being deployed in field trials and
science-based progress. This would in turn drive industrial
have growing credibility in sectors such as power grid
applications. A multi-institute project or programme grant
patrol, offshore asset inspection and maintenance.
can catalyse such development significantly and increase
Enabling researchers to develop industrial use cases is
the international standing and competitiveness of the UK
essential. Focused industry/academic projects should be
research community.
funded to achieve this.
• Platforms and hardware are expensive, and technology
ages quickly. The average life cycle of a new technology
in legged platforms is about 3-5 years. In order to place
// Legged Robotics: Agile and Dynamic Interaction
www.ukras.org.uk
:scitoboR deggeL
noitcaretnI cimanyD dna eligA