Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ASE
for FVL
Response
V erification
M ission Parameters
4
The Journal of Electronic Defense | April 2020
A U.S. Army Electronic Ground Warfare team with 2nd Brigade Combat Team, 1st cavalry division, packs up their equipment at the end of Combined
Resolve XIII at the Joint Multinational Readiness Center in Hohenfels, Germany on Feb. 2, 2020. Combined Resolve XIII enhances professional
relationships and improves overall coordination with allies and partners during a crisis. (U.S. ARMY NATIONAL GUARD PHOTO BY SGT. DUSTIN JORDAN)
News Departments
The Monitor 15 6 The View From Here
First ODIN Laser Dazzle Device Installed on 8 Conferences Calendar
USS Dewey 10 Courses Calendar
12 From the President
World Report 20
36 DE 101
New NATO Contract for FlyingFish Satphone SIGINT
42 EW 101
46 AOC News
Features 48 AOC Industry and Institute/
FVL Program Aims For University Members
Overwhelming Advancement of 49 Index of Advertisers
Aircraft Survivability Capability 22 50 JED Quick Look
John Haystead
As the US Army’s Future Vertical Lift Program
downselects its helicopter designs, the EW aspects
of the program are beginning to take shape. This
month, we look at how the Army is approaching
FVL ASE. COVER PHOTOS COURTESY OF BELL TEXTRON AND SIKORSKY HELICOPTER
the view
f rom he re
EDITORIAL STAFF
Editor: John Knowles
Publisher: Elaine Richardson
Senior Editor: John Haystead
Production Editor: Hope Swedeen
Technical Editor: Barry Manz
B
Threat Systems Editor: Doug Richardson
Contributing Writers: Dave Adamy and Richard Scott
Marketing & Research Coordinator: Elyce Gronseth
ack in the mid-1990s, the Air Force’s EW acquisition office (SAF/ Proofreaders: Ken Janssens, Shauna Keedian
AQPE) was led by a gentleman named Col. John “Jack” Booher. Sales Manager: Tabitha Jenkins
He was a savvy operator, even by the standards of the Pentagon. Sales Adminstrator: Amanda Glass
Colonel Booher was responsible for coordinating most of the Air EDITORIAL ADVISORY BOARD
Force’s EW program funding. When he began to realize that his Mr. Petter Bedoire
Chief Technology Officer, Saab
acquisition leadership (mostly former fighter pilots) wasn’t pay- Dr. William Conley
ing enough attention to his EW programs, Colonel Booher brought a young Chief Technology Officer, Mercury Systems
COL Kevin Chaney
F-16 pilot onto his staff. He made sure to bring this young Viper driver to Program Manager, Aircraft Survivability Equipment,
most of his meetings with leadership, and it helped to break the ice. The PEO IEW&S, US Army
Mr. Anthony Lisuzzo
leadership was very receptive to hearing about EW from a fighter pilot, and Senior Vice President, JRAD, Inc.
these senior leaders became more more engaged with the EW acquisition shop Mr. Rick Lu
as a result. President and CEO, Spectranetix Inc.
Mr. Steve Mensh
Colonel Booher knew how to get things done, and this extended to devel- Senior Vice President and General Manager,
oping his staff. About this time in the mid-1990s, I arrived at JED as a new Textron Systems Electronic Systems
Mr. Edgar Maimon
6 editorial assistant, and I got to know some of the officers in Colonel Booher’s General Manager, Elbit Systems EW and SIGINT – Elisra
shop. I would speak to them for news articles and program updates (media Mr. Marvin Potts
Technical Director, System Technology Office
relations were less formal back then), and they would occasionally call our
The Journal of Electronic Defense | April 2020
BB60C
are
s Softw
Include
Converters Washington, DC
www.idga.org
INTEL TO RF
AWARDED THE ADVANCED F-35 BLOCK IV
C2D2 EW SIMULATOR PROGRAM
TextronSystems.com
© 2019 AAI Corporation.
c ale ndar c our se s & se mina r s
APRIL AOC Live Professional Development AOC Virtual Series Webinar:
Web Course: EW against a New Pulse Compression Techniques inside
AOC Virtual Series Webinar: Generation of Threats LPI Radars: Basic Principles and
Overview of Missile Design, April 13-29 Technology Trends
Development, and System Engineering 8 sessions, 1300-1600 EST April 23
April 9 www.crows.org 1400-1500 EST
1400-1500 EST www.crows.org
www.crows.org
MAY
AOC Virtual Series Webinar:
The Basic Concepts of ELINT
Defense officials have announced restrictions on domestic travel for service members, May 7
Department of Defense (DOD) employees and family members in response to the 1400-1500 EST
novel coronavirus, COVID-19. As all travel will be halted through May 11 per the DOD’s www.crows.org
memorandum, we have removed all in-person courses and seminars through that date.
For courses taking place after May 11, please contact the course provider. Advanced Radar Signals
Collection and Analysis
May 12-14
Atlanta, GA
www.pe.gatech.edu
Adaptive Arrays: Algorithms,
Architectures and Applications
MULTI-CHANNEL
May 12-15
Atlanta, GA
www.pe.gatech.edu
(MRSE-5000)
www.cranfield.ac.uk
AOC Virtual Series Webinar: Leveraging
Publicly Available Information to Map
For Testing Radar, RWR & EW Receivers and Track GNSS Interference
May 21
1400-1500 EST
10 Open Architecture Solutions Tailored to Your www.crows.org
Requirements
• Streaming I/Q data from hard drives to RF transmit
JUNE
The Journal of Electronic Defense | April 2020
WE BRING
Phone: (703) 549-1600
Fax: (703) 549-2589
PRESIDENT – Muddy Watters
TO THE FIGHT
PRESIDENT-ELECT – Glenn “Powder” Carlson
SECRETARY – Mark Schallheim
TREASURER – Richard Wittstruck
F
PAST PRESIDENT
Lisa Frugé-Cirilli
irst of all, for our international body of professionals, I want to express AT-LARGE DIRECTORS
Bob Andrews
my sincere hope that COVID-19 has not touched you or your loved Brian Hinkley
ones, as it literally changes many aspects of our lives. Amanda Kammier
Haruko Kawahigashi
This month I would like to touch on what the AOC community brings David Stupples
to the fight. For purists out there, I may blur traditional lanes. We all Richard Wittstruck
know it’s about the spectrum, or the Electromagnetic Environment APPOINTED DIRECTORS
Craig Harm
(EME) – using it, protecting it, controlling access to it. But, many people outside
REGIONAL DIRECTORS
our community sometimes wonder, what do we bring to the fight? First it’s the Central: Keith Everly
cadre of professional warfighters – skilled, trained, experienced – who are doing Mid-Atlantic: Jim Pryor
Northeastern: Mike Ryan
the planning, coordinating activities, synchronizing effects/effectors, conduct- Northwestern: Mark Schallheim
ing operations and making it happen in this all-domain world we fight in. Second Mountain-Western: Sam Roberts
Pacific: Rick Lu
it’s the program managers, engineers, and scientists in the labs and throughout Southern: Karen Brigance
industry who develop, build and help deploy technologies to the warfighter. International I: Sue Robertson
International II: Jeff Walsh
So we have the people and the technology for the EME. What’s the impact? We
AOC FOUNDATION ADJUNCT GOVERNORS
shape the battlefield in the early phases of any conflict by using Signals Intel- Nino Amoroso
12 ligence (SIGINT) and cyber operations to build situational awareness, we deploy Gary Lyke
deception (information warfare) to influence our adversaries, and begin to deny, AOC PROFESSIONAL STAFF
Shelley Frost
delay, degrade and deceive opposing forces’ operational capability by using elec- Executive Director
The Journal of Electronic Defense | April 2020
tronic attack and cyber operations to conduct information warfare. This further frost@crows.org
Glorianne O’Neilin
influences their decision makers. Director, Membership Operations
When the shooting starts, our weapons systems are shielded from adversary oneilin@crows.org
EW by the electronic protection that has been built into the sensors, commu- Amy Belicev
Director, Meetings & Events
nications and Precision, Navigation and Timing (PNT) systems, and we protect belicev@crows.org
the platforms themselves with the self-protection systems that provide jamming, Brock Sheets
Director, Marketing & Education
decoys, chaff and flares. Our planners have synchronized the “dance” as events sheets@crows.org
progress using the combination of EW and cyber to confuse and blind enemy Ken Miller
forces. We complicate enemy targeting with decoys and deception to delay his re- Director, Advocacy & Outreach
kmiller@crows.org
sponses and degrade his ability to engage our forces. We provide the unseen force Tim Hutchison
multipliers that provide our forces with critical advantages in time and space, and Marketing & Communications Manager
hutchison@crows.org
we enable our ability to attack enemy targets and achieve our larger war-fighting
Sean Fitzgerald
objectives. We are the force behind “deny, degrade, delay, destroy.” Without our Sales and Client Operations Manager
EME community, wars are lost. fitzgerald@crows.org
Blain Bekele
Our community had been handcuffed in the past by lack of vision, direction, Membership Support and STEM Coordinator
investment and prioritization. However, each of us can be an advocate for our blain@crows.org
community. We are beginning to improve EW appreciation among military and Meron Bekele
Membership Support
government leaders. We need to keep the gas pedal down, stay engaged, show meron@crows.org
the requirement/benefit that our warfighting capabilities bring and keep moving Caleb Herr
Education Coordinator
forward. herr@crows.org
Part of “moving forward” is to keep yourself informed. While many of us are Sylvia Lee
affected by COVID-19 protection measures that have restricted our work activi- Manager, Exhibit Operations
lee@crows.org
ties, I hope that you will take advantage of the many Webinars and online courses Tori Cruz
that AOC offers live and on demand via our Website, www.crows.org. It’s an es- Coordinator, Meetings and Events
cruz@crows.org
sential resource for an essential community. Have a great month and stay safe.
– Muddy Watters
OCTAVE BAND LOW NOISE AMPLIFIERS
Model No. Freq (GHz) Gain (dB) MIN Noise Figure (dB) Power -out @ P1-dB 3rd Order ICP VSWR
CA01-2110 0.5-1.0 28 1.0 MAX, 0.7 TYP +10 MIN +20 dBm 2.0:1
CA12-2110 1.0-2.0 30 1.0 MAX, 0.7 TYP +10 MIN +20 dBm 2.0:1
CA24-2111 2.0-4.0 29 1.1 MAX, 0.95 TYP +10 MIN +20 dBm 2.0:1
CA48-2111 4.0-8.0 29 1.3 MAX, 1.0 TYP +10 MIN +20 dBm 2.0:1
CA812-3111 8.0-12.0 27 1.6 MAX, 1.4 TYP +10 MIN +20 dBm 2.0:1
CA1218-4111 12.0-18.0 25 1.9 MAX, 1.7 TYP +10 MIN +20 dBm 2.0:1
CA1826-2110 18.0-26.5 32 3.0 MAX, 2.5 TYP +10 MIN +20 dBm 2.0:1
NARROW BAND LOW NOISE AND MEDIUM POWER AMPLIFIERS
CA01-2111 0.4 - 0.5 28 0.6 MAX, 0.4 TYP +10 MIN +20 dBm 2.0:1
CA01-2113 0.8 - 1.0 28 0.6 MAX, 0.4 TYP +10 MIN +20 dBm 2.0:1
CA12-3117 1.2 - 1.6 25 0.6 MAX, 0.4 TYP +10 MIN +20 dBm 2.0:1
CA23-3111 2.2 - 2.4 30 0.6 MAX, 0.45 TYP +10 MIN +20 dBm 2.0:1
CA23-3116 2.7 - 2.9 29 0.7 MAX, 0.5 TYP +10 MIN +20 dBm 2.0:1
CA34-2110 3.7 - 4.2 28 1.0 MAX, 0.5 TYP +10 MIN +20 dBm 2.0:1
CA56-3110 5.4 - 5.9 40 1.0 MAX, 0.5 TYP +10 MIN +20 dBm 2.0:1
CA78-4110 7.25 - 7.75 32 1.2 MAX, 1.0 TYP +10 MIN +20 dBm 2.0:1
CA910-3110 9.0 - 10.6 25 1.4 MAX, 1.2 TYP +10 MIN +20 dBm 2.0:1
CA1315-3110 13.75 - 15.4 25 1.6 MAX, 1.4 TYP +10 MIN +20 dBm 2.0:1
CA12-3114 1.35 - 1.85 30 4.0 MAX, 3.0 TYP +33 MIN +41 dBm 2.0:1
CA34-6116 3.1 - 3.5 40 4.5 MAX, 3.5 TYP +35 MIN +43 dBm 2.0:1
CA56-5114 5.9 - 6.4 30 5.0 MAX, 4.0 TYP +30 MIN +40 dBm 2.0:1
CA812-6115 8.0 - 12.0 30 4.5 MAX, 3.5 TYP +30 MIN +40 dBm 2.0:1
CA812-6116 8.0 - 12.0 30 5.0 MAX, 4.0 TYP +33 MIN +41 dBm 2.0:1
CA1213-7110 12.2 - 13.25 28 6.0 MAX, 5.5 TYP +33 MIN +42 dBm 2.0:1
CA1415-7110 14.0 - 15.0 30 5.0 MAX, 4.0 TYP +30 MIN +40 dBm 2.0:1
CA1722-4110 17.0 - 22.0 25 3.5 MAX, 2.8 TYP +21 MIN +31 dBm 2.0:1
ULTRA-BROADBAND & MULTI-OCTAVE BAND AMPLIFIERS
Model No. Freq (GHz) Gain (dB) MIN Noise Figure (dB) Power -out @ P1-dB 3rd Order ICP VSWR
CA0102-3111 0.1-2.0 28 1.6 Max, 1.2 TYP +10 MIN +20 dBm 2.0:1
CA0106-3111 0.1-6.0 28 1.9 Max, 1.5 TYP +10 MIN +20 dBm 2.0:1
CA0108-3110 0.1-8.0 26 2.2 Max, 1.8 TYP +10 MIN +20 dBm 2.0:1
CA0108-4112 0.1-8.0 32 3.0 MAX, 1.8 TYP +22 MIN +32 dBm 2.0:1
CA02-3112 0.5-2.0 36 4.5 MAX, 2.5 TYP +30 MIN +40 dBm 2.0:1
CA26-3110 2.0-6.0 26 2.0 MAX, 1.5 TYP +10 MIN +20 dBm 2.0:1
CA26-4114 2.0-6.0 22 5.0 MAX, 3.5 TYP +30 MIN +40 dBm 2.0:1
CA618-4112 6.0-18.0 25 5.0 MAX, 3.5 TYP +23 MIN +33 dBm 2.0:1
CA618-6114 6.0-18.0 35 5.0 MAX, 3.5 TYP +30 MIN +40 dBm 2.0:1
CA218-4116 2.0-18.0 30 3.5 MAX, 2.8 TYP +10 MIN +20 dBm 2.0:1
CA218-4110 2.0-18.0 30 5.0 MAX, 3.5 TYP +20 MIN +30 dBm 2.0:1
CA218-4112 2.0-18.0 29 5.0 MAX, 3.5 TYP +24 MIN +34 dBm 2.0:1
LIMITING AMPLIFIERS
Model No. Freq (GHz) Input Dynamic Range Output Power Range Psat Power Flatness dB VSWR
CLA24-4001 2.0 - 4.0 -28 to +10 dBm +7 to +11 dBm +/- 1.5 MAX 2.0:1
CLA26-8001 2.0 - 6.0 -50 to +20 dBm +14 to +18 dBm +/- 1.5 MAX 2.0:1
CLA712-5001 7.0 - 12.4 -21 to +10 dBm +14 to +19 dBm +/- 1.5 MAX 2.0:1
CLA618-1201 6.0 - 18.0 -50 to +20 dBm +14 to +19 dBm +/- 1.5 MAX 2.0:1
AMPLIFIERS WITH INTEGRATED GAIN ATTENUATION
Model No. Freq (GHz) Gain (dB) MIN Noise Figure (dB) Power -out @ P1-dB Gain Attenuation Range VSWR
CA001-2511A 0.025-0.150 21 5.0 MAX, 3.5 TYP +12 MIN 30 dB MIN 2.0:1
CA05-3110A 0.5-5.5 23 2.5 MAX, 1.5 TYP +18 MIN 20 dB MIN 2.0:1
CA56-3110A 5.85-6.425 28 2.5 MAX, 1.5 TYP +16 MIN 22 dB MIN 1.8:1
CA612-4110A 6.0-12.0 24 2.5 MAX, 1.5 TYP +12 MIN 15 dB MIN 1.9:1
CA1315-4110A 13.75-15.4 25 2.2 MAX, 1.6 TYP +16 MIN 20 dB MIN 1.8:1
CA1518-4110A 15.0-18.0 30 3.0 MAX, 2.0 TYP +18 MIN 20 dB MIN 1.85:1
LOW FREQUENCY AMPLIFIERS
Model No. Freq (GHz) Gain (dB) MIN Noise Figure dB Power -out @ P1-dB 3rd Order ICP VSWR
CA001-2110 0.01-0.10 18 4.0 MAX, 2.2 TYP +10 MIN +20 dBm 2.0:1
CA001-2211 0.04-0.15 24 3.5 MAX, 2.2 TYP +13 MIN +23 dBm 2.0:1
CA001-2215 0.04-0.15 23 4.0 MAX, 2.2 TYP +23 MIN +33 dBm 2.0:1
CA001-3113 0.01-1.0 28 4.0 MAX, 2.8 TYP +17 MIN +27 dBm 2.0:1
CA002-3114 0.01-2.0 27 4.0 MAX, 2.8 TYP +20 MIN +30 dBm 2.0:1
CA003-3116 0.01-3.0 18 4.0 MAX, 2.8 TYP +25 MIN +35 dBm 2.0:1
CA004-3112 0.01-4.0 32 4.0 MAX, 2.8 TYP +15 MIN +25 dBm 2.0:1
CIAO Wireless can easily modify any of its standard models to meet your "exact" requirements at the Catalog Pricing.
Visit our web site at www.ciaowireless.com for our complete product offering.
Electro-Optical/Infrared
Sensor Engineering
Dr. Phillip Pace
Mondays & Wednesdays
13:00 – 16:00 EDT | October 5 – 28, 2020
This course presents the fundamentals of electro-
optical (EO) & infrared (IR) sensor technology, its
analysis and its application to military search, track
= Web Course, no travel required!
and imaging systems.
WASHINGTON D.C.
DARPA SEEKS PROPOSALS FOR mitted content over time and operat- and cyclostationary processing, as
SECURE TACTICAL RADIO RECEIVER ing frequency. Temporal and spectral well as collaborative receiver networks
The Defense Advanced Research Proj- spreading reduces transmitted power that coherently recombine power to
ects Agency’s (DARPA’s) Microsystems density, so as to potentially operate detect the transmitter.
Technology Office (MTO) has issued a below the adversary’s receiver detec- In order to improve radio perfor-
solicitation for its Wideband Secure tion limit. However, current spread mance, the WiSPER program “seeks to
and Protected Emitter and Receiver spectrum techniques lack sufficient develop a fundamentally disruptive
(WiSPER) program, which aims to de- complexity to evade detection by wireless air interface transceiver tech-
velop “wideband secure and protected modern signal intelligence (SIGINT) nology to enable and sustain secure
radio interface technologies” for use in receivers or interception by compro- and robust high-bandwidth RF commu-
future tactical radios. mised devices.” The solicitation goes nication links. The WiSPER wideband
According to the WiSPER solici- on to describe specific vulnerabilities adaptive air interface will also mitigate
tation, “Current DoD tactical radios of current secure tactical radios to impairment due to dynamic harsh and
attempt to achieve security over a hypersensitive receivers that utilize contested environments to maintain a
wireless channel by spreading trans- cryogenically cooled energy detectors stable communication link.”
t h e m o n i t o r | n e w s
WiSPER is structured into three phas- retary of Defense Electromagnetic Spec- cyber that was permissive and we had
es organized under a 48-month program trum Operations (EMSO) Cross Functional freedom of maneuver for a very long pe-
schedule. After contract awards in Sep- Team, the Electronic Warfare Executive riod of time, and that has changed. So
tember, companies will pursue Phase 1 Committee (EW EXCOM), the Services, it too has to have a certain level of ex-
over 18-months, developing and proving the DoD Chief Information Officer (CIO), pertise. The Services are working very
out a WiSPER architecture and providing the joint staff, and Under Secretary of hard on that. For example, if you would
benchtop units that will be evaluated in Defense offices to advocate for essential allow me to have a Navy flashback for
lab tests. The second phase, commenc- warfighter EMSO capabilities. Addition- a second. I am a joint commander now
ing in FY2022, also runs 18 months. It ally, we engage with Australia and North but just left the Navy. The submarine
will focus on enhancing performance, Atlantic Treaty Organization partners to force, which I recently commanded, has
and culminate in field tests of trans- ensure compatible JEMSO doctrine, ca- been an emergency flank wide open
portable units operating the WiSPER pabilities, and concepts of operation. trying to develop that expertise to the
Air Interface in clear weather condi- “USSTRATCOM led the effort to cre- point that we have restructured the
tions. The third and final phase, which ate the first Joint Publication for JEM- electronic technicians’ rating to elevate
runs another 12 months beginning in SO. Working with DoD CIO and Defense greater numbers, better training. And I
FY2023, will see the Air Interface in- Information Systems Agency (DISA), could go into more detail on that. You
tegrated into portable units and evalu- USSTRATCOM provided the initial warf- see all the Services working like that
ated in another field test with harsher ighter requirements for an Electromag- right now.
weather conditions. netic Battle Management (EMBM) system Senator Blackburn: Let me ask you
Responses to the solicitation are due to achieve EMS superiority. In coordina- this. Are we at a point where we should
by April 28th. The overall WiSPER pro- tion with the DISA Defense Spectrum Or- develop a concept of operations for EW?
gram budget is estimated at $50 million. ganization, USSTRATCOM is establishing Admiral Richard: Yes, ma’am. You hit
DARPA is expected to award multiple the initial Joint Electromagnetic Spec- on a couple of things that we have to
contracts. The solicitation number is trum Information Analysis and Fusion continue to work on. There are numer-
BAA HR001120S0030. The program point capability that will provide spectrum ous concepts of operation. To be able to
of contact is Dr. Young-Kai Chen, e-mail specific data for battle management and knit them together in a whole is –
HR001120S0030@darpa.mil. – JED Staff combatant command operational cells. Senator Blackburn: Right, but we
“Our Command also led a combatant need one overriding strategy.
16 USSTRATCOM COMMANDER command JEMSO cell manpower require- Admiral Richard: One overarching
DISCUSSES JEMSO IN SENATE ment validation study through the joint piece –
TESTIMONY manpower validation process for the Senator Blackburn: And if you are
The Journal of Electronic Defense | April 2020
ADM Charles Richard, USN, Command- FY2022 Program Objective Memorandum reworking training and looking at a dif-
er, US Strategic Command (USSTRAT- budget. All of these warfighter require- ferent utilization of expertise, then it
COM) testified before the Senate Armed ment initiatives will require sustained seems to me we would be well served
Services Committee (SASC) on February investments.” to move to one concept of operations
13. In his testimony, he addressed the As SASC members asked questions that would enable each of our military
latest developments in Joint Electro- during the hearing, Sen. Marsha Black- divisions.
magnetic Spectrum Operations (JEMSO) burn (R-TN) focused on the Electromag- Admiral Richard: Senator, one, I
at USSTRATCOM. netic Spectrum. Here is the testimony not only agree, but I would also high-
In his written testimony, Admiral from this portion of the hearing: light another point you made earlier
Richard stated, “The Electromagnetic Senator Blackburn: Then highlight- that a key piece of that concept is go-
Spectrum (EMS) is the one physical ma- ing another area, let us move over and ing to be electronic battle management,
neuver space depended upon by forces talk about electromagnetic spectrum. electronic warfare battle management,
across all warfighting domains. If we And as you know, this is something the ability to visualize. We cannot be
cannot achieve EMS superiority and as- where I have spent a good bit of time statically assigned anymore in our use
sure access to the EMS, the joint force working on how we proceed in this area, of the RF spectrum. We have to be dy-
cannot prevail. Our adversaries have ob- how we utilize expertise when it comes namic. We have to maneuver, and we
served our use and dependence on the to working in a contested EW environ- are going to have to be able to visualize
EMS, and have developed and organized ment. Do we have that? Are we moving and understand it to accomplish that.
their forces to achieve EMS superiority; forward with the right type work, the Now, the concepts will start from there.
it is essential we develop capabilities visualization, the modeling, so that we – JED Staff
and appropriately organize to counter are growing the expertise in this area?
this threat. Achieving and maintaining Admiral Richard: So, ma’am, let me IN BRIEF
EMS superiority is the critical enabler start that. Senator, one, I applaud your The Defense Information Systems
for successful Joint Force operations. interest and your leadership in terms of Agency (DISA) has awarded a $121 mil-
“To address warfighter requirements, electromagnetic spectrum. That is yet lion contract to Expression Networks
USSTRATCOM collaborates with the Sec- another domain not unlike space and (Washington, D.C.) for Electromagnetic
t h e m o n i t o r | n e w s
Radar Amplifiers
✪ ✪ ✪
Elbit Systems of America (Fort Worth, TX) has received
a $471 million contract from the US Air Force to equip the
Air National Guard and Air Force Reserve’s F-16 aircraft with
pylon-based infrared missile warning systems. The 10-year,
firm-fixed-price contract includes an initial $17 million order
for FY2020. Work is expected to be completed by February 2030.
The ANG and AFRES have been working with Terma A/S to up-
grade their Pylon Integrated Dispenser System-Plus pylons on
their F-16s in order to accommodate the new missile warning
systems.
✪ ✪ ✪
Army Contracting Command – Rock Island (ACC-RI) an-
nounced its intent to issue a Request for Information (RFI)
for NextGen Software Defined Radio (SDR) modules capable of
meeting Joint Counter Radio Controlled Improvised Explosive
Device Electronic Warfare (JCREW) requirements. Responses
to the RFI must comply with JCREW system design, including
backplane design, open system architecture and other JCREW
www.ophirrf.com 310-306-5556
I1B1 interfaces. According to the notice, prototypes must also sales@ophirrf.com
include “the Digital/RF circuit card assembly, machined hous-
ing, Board Support Package, associated drivers, Software/
Firmware Development Kits and Inter- support of the Defense Advanced Re- spectrum operations (EMSO) community,
face Test Adapters,” and the final de- search Projects Agency’s (DARPA’s) Dis- including two assignments to the Penta-
sign must reach Technology Readiness tributed RF Analysis and Geolocation on gon. Brig Gen David M. Gaedecke, for-
Level (TRL) 6 with capabilities to sup- Networked System (DRAGONS) program, mer director, electromagnetic spectrum
port laboratory and module-level envi- which aims to integrate geolocation superiority, Deputy Chief of Staff, Strat-
ronmental testing. Issued on behalf of and signal identification capabilities in egy, Integration, and Requirements,
the U.S. Army Combat Capabilities De- drones. Hedgehog semiconductors are US Air Force has been assigned to vice
velopment Command – Chemical Biologi- designed using BAE’s MATRICS software commander, Sixteenth Air Force (Air
cal Center (CCDC CBC) (Rock Island, IL) defined radio (SDR) technology, with Forces Cyber), Air Combat Command, of
and Naval Sea Systems Command (NAV- applications including EW, SIGINT and Joint Base San Antonio-Lackland, (San
SEA) (Navy Yard, Washington, DC), the COMMS capabilities. Antonio, TX). In his place, Brig Gen
RFI notice is restricted to Cornerstone (select) Michael H. Manion, former
consortium members, with an estimated
✪ ✪ ✪ director, joint and National Security
closing date of 10 business days after its L3Harris Technologies (Clifton, NJ) Council matters, Deputy Chief of Staff,
issuance on March 23. Information on has been awarded a $49 million contract Operations, US Air Force (Pentagon,
the Cornerstone consortium and regis- option for the Suite of Integrated Radio Washington, DC) has been assigned to
tration is available at ibasp-public.ria. Frequency Countermeasures program for replace General Gaedeke. Manion is the
army.mil/cornerstone. US Special Operations Command (US- former commander of the US Air Force’s
SOCOM). This contract modification in- 55th Wing (Offutt AFB, NE). During his
✪ ✪ ✪ cludes program management, contractor tenure, he was responsible for training
BAE Systems (Arlington, VA) re- logistics support, field service represen- and equipping squadrons to execute in-
cently demonstrated its “Hedgehog” tatives and travel, and will increase the telligence, surveillance and reconnais-
small-form-factor semiconductor, and total contract ceiling to $50 million. sance; electronic attack; command and
its ability to sense radio frequency (RF) control missions, among others. Brig
and communication signals alongside
✪ ✪ ✪ Gen (select) Parker H. Wright, former
unmanned aerial systems (UASs) in The US Air Force Chief of Staff issued commander, National Air and Space In-
congested and contested battle environ- general officer assignments in February, telligence Center, Deputy Chief of Staff
ments. The demonstration took place in including several in the electromagnetic for Intelligence, Surveillance, Recon-
18
The Journal of Electronic Defense | April 2020
naissance and Cyber Effects Operations this will be achieved by “measuring im- Force. It was delivered to the 4th Space
(Wright-Patterson AFB, OH) has been as- pact of the operational landscape and Control Squadron (Peterson AFB, CO).
signed to director, intelligence, surveil- current capabilities, reporting future According to Col Stephen Purdy, SMC
lance, and reconnaissance operations, technological trends, identifying capa- Special Programs director, “CCS B10.2
Deputy Chief of Staff for Intelligence, bility gaps, recommending standards, represents the end of the traditional way
Surveillance, Reconnaissance, and Cy- and generating visual management aids of development. Future upgrades and
ber Effects Operations. and need statements to drive DoD’s stra- enhancements will make use of SMC’s
tegic decisions.” All project solutions Agile DevSecOps [Development, Security
✪ ✪ ✪ will be evaluated with the intent of and Operations] approach, adapting to
Naval Sea Systems Command awarding an Other Transaction Agree- the evolving battlefield while deliver-
(NAVSEA) (Navy Yard, Washington, DC) ment (OTA). The contracting point of ing capabilities to the warfighter faster
issued a request for solutions (RFS) for contacts for this RFS are Michael Allen, and better than our opponents.” The Air
the Electromagnetic Spectrum Predic- (812) 854-8714, Michael.t.allen@navy. Force is currently developing the next
tive Modeling Prototype project. The mil, and Don Davis, (812) 854-3709, generation CCS under the CCS Block 10.3
20
IN BRIEF Indonesian Navy’s Bung Tomo-Class ATP is also integrated onto the UAE’s
❍ The Royal Australian Air Force (RAAF) multi-role corvette, KRI Usman- F-16 Block 60 fleet.
The Journal of Electronic Defense | April 2020
has moved one step closer to buy- Harun, under the class’s Mid-Life ❍ Australia’s Flinders University
ing up to 200 Lockheed Martin AGM- Modernization (MLM) program. The (Adelaide, SA) last month announced
158C Long-Range Anti-Ship Missiles contract calls for the team to deliver a AUS$5 million initiative to estab-
(LRASMs) from the US. The US State and integrate Thales’s TACTICOS lish a National Electronic Warfare
Department announced in February combat management System, the Centre over the next five years.
that it has approved the sale of SMART-S Mk2 air and surface sur- The EW Centre is part of a partner-
the LRASMs to Australia under a veillance radar, the STIR EO Mk2 ship between the University and
Foreign Military Sale agreement radar and EO fire control system and Australia’s Department of Defence to
worth up to $990 million. The poten- the Vigile Mk2 radar electronic sup- sustain and develop EW skills within
tial deal also includes 11 ATM-158C port measures (ESM) system. The the defense sector. The University is
LRASM Telemetry Variant (Inert) same configuration has already been establishing a Chair of EW Studies
units, DATM-158C LRASM, Captive installed on the Indonesian Navy’s to oversee EW education and
Air Training Missiles (CATM-158C new Martadinata-Class frigates. The research, and it is currently recruit-
LRASM), containers, support and upgrade to the KRI Usman-Harun is ing candidates for the position. In
test equipment, publications and scheduled for completion in 2023. the meantime, the university is
technical documentation, person- ❍ Lockheed Martin will supply an also developing new graduate and
nel training and training equip- undisclosed number of Sniper undergraduate courses for EW. In a
ment. The RAAF plans to integrate Advanced Targeting Pods to the related move, Flinders University,
the LRASM on its F/A-18 E/F Super United Arab Emirates for its Mirage the Defence Science and Technology
Hornets. 2000 multirole fighters. The deal, Group (DST), the Joint Capabilities
❍ Indonesian electronics house Len conducted as a Direct Commercial Group and industry EW partner
Industri (Bandung) and Thales Sale, marks the first time the Sniper DEWC have signed a memorandum
(Hengelo, Netherlands) have signed Pod has been integrated onto Mirage of understanding to conduct EW
a contract with the Indonesian 2000 aircraft. The UAE currently research and deliver EW education
Government to modernize the sen- operates 43 Mirage 2000 fighters and training to help grow Australia’s
sors and combat systems on the across three squadrons. The Sniper EW workforce. a
FVL Program Aims For O
Advancement of Aircraft
T
By John Haystead
The US Army has identified aircraft survivability as the ASE at the Army Aviation Association of America (AAAA) ASE
single most important factor driving the design and de- Symposium last November. “If everything else fails, ASE will
velopment of its next-generation family of Future Verti- blunt them at their end game and we will still survive.”
cal Lift (FVL) rotorcraft. In that context, however, the The FVL initiative is actually a joint-Service DOD effort led by
Army views survivability in holistic terms to include the Army but including the Navy/Marine Corps and Special Opera-
platform detectability, maneuverability, standoff range, tions Command (SOCOM). The goal is to provide future forces with
multi-platform integration, smart weapons, etc. – with capabilities that dramatically overmatch enemy air defense sys-
on-board electronic protection systems, or aircraft sur- tems by, as General Rugen describes – “disintegrating their area
vivability equipment (ASE) providing the final element access/aerial deni-
of protection. BG Walter Rugen, Director of the Army’s al (A2/AD) layers
FVL Cross-Functional Team (CFT), summed up the role of and structures.”
22
The Journal of Electronic Defense | April 2020
PhaseTrack®
Low PIM
www.timesmicrowave.com
techquestions@timesmicro.com
1-800 867-2629
1
CapSet 3 covers the Future Long “What we see in the seeable future, the modernized Chinook
Range Assault Aircraft (FLRAA) or will exploit maneuver windows in en-
squad carrier. In addition to replacing requirements arena emy defenses opened by FARA, FLRAA
Army/Navy-Marine Corp Black Hawk/
Apache/Seahawk/Venom aircraft, pos-
of Multi-Domain and joint forces.”
sible plans for the FLRAA had called for Operations is the need MATCHING ASE TO THE THREAT
it to replace SOCOM MH-60M Black Hawk Tracking advanced ASE development
helicopters. The Marine Corps had also to have a ‘shorter and integration with the FVL aircraft
been looking at replacing their UH-1Y
utility and AH-1Z attack helicopters
human-decision development schedule, as well as meet-
ing, and in fact out-pacing, the threat
with the FLRAA, but may now be look- cycle’ – to be able is obviously challenging. And, although
ing at a much-lighter platform better it is still relatively early in the devel-
suited to small-deck ships that would be to react, decide, and opment process, expectations are that
a spinoff of FARA. This would be known
do everything that the next-generation ASE suite support-
Don’t let your guard down BAE Systems Electronic Systems Sec-
tor (Nashua, NH), also emphasizes this
point. “We recognize that FVL will be
From simulating wideband required to operate in a contested and
background EME to emulating congested EM environment for extended
periods and under austere conditions.
dynamically changing threats- As the threats rapidly evolve, the next
Proteus, an Arbitrary generation ASE suite is going to have
Waveform Transceiver to provide multi-spectral detection and
enhances test and evaluation response across RF, IR, and EO portions
of the spectrum. You really need to be
moving toward a threat-agnostic type of
environment. As a result, these detec-
tion and response capabilities can no
Wide-bandwidth longer operate independently as stand-
26 Low noise, measurement alone systems.”
One challenge, observes L3Harris’s
direct to data streaming Baglio, will be balancing the require-
The Journal of Electronic Defense | April 2020
HOW DOES
COL Kevin Chaney, ASE Project Man-
ager (PM –ASE) within the Army’s Pro-
gram Executive Office for Intelligence
Electronic Warfare and Sensors (PEO
IEW&S) fully agrees. Noting that his pref- CONNECTIVITY
MAT TER TO YOU?
erence is to discuss the requirement in 27
terms of detect and defeat, Chaney says,
“On the detection side, Colonel Isaacson
hit it squarely on the head with sensor
fusion – the ability to take inputs from
different sensors and fuse those together
to obtain a holistic picture of the battle-
10,000 Over 625
Exhibiting Companies
Attendees from 48 Countries
10%
field. This is one of the key elements that
of which 37% are First-Time
we’re pursuing going forward.” Attendees! including
Another emphasis area related to ac- First-Time Exhibitors!
complishing shorter human-decision
time cycles, says Colonel Chaney, is the
33% 11%
development and implementation of AI
and automation to provide autonomy
and cognitive-offloading within the
20%
of Attendees are
of Attendees are
Design Engineers
or Engineering
of Attendees are
in Research and
Development
Senior Management Management
manned FVL cockpits. “One of the chal-
lenges we have right now is the cycle
time from detecting a threat to develop- Dedicated Discover New
tracks on 5G, Solutions and Countless
ing a countermeasure solution and push- Networking
Autonomous vehicles Gain Valuable
ing that out to the field. We need to get and Aerospace Insights Opportunities
to the point where, when we see some-
thing that maybe we haven’t previously
seen, but has similar characteristics to
Can’t Miss Event for the RF & Microwave Industry!
R E G I S T E R TO DAY !
something that we have seen, that we
will still be able to declare on it.”
Colonel Chaney points to his shop’s w w w. i m s - i e e e . o r g
Limited Interim Missile Warning System 21-26 June 2020
(LIMWS) program as an example of on-
going efforts aimed at maturing and im-
Integrated Digitization
• 2 Channels @ 32 GSps
• 4 Channels @ 16 GSps
• Resolution: 10 bits
TM
3 UltraScale+ FPGAs
100GbE over VPX Backplane
VITA 66/67 Support
Air- or Conduction-Cooled
TM
TM
WILDSTAR 6XBU
Annapolis
Micro Systems
www.AnnapMicro.com
AOC Virtual Series Webinars
AOC Virtual Series has been a tremendous asset providing the AOC’s audience with
learning, advocacy, and the exchange of information. Register today to hear from
subject-matter experts on all things EW!
Missile Design, Development, and System Engineering Pulse Compression Techniques Inside LPI Radars
Presenter: Eugene Fleeman Presenter: Renan Richter
The Basic Concepts of ELINT Leveraging Publicly Available Information to Map and
Track GNSS Interference
Presenter: Brian Moore Presenter: C4ADS
Deep Learning and Waveform Classification The Fundamentals of EO/IR Sensor Engineering
Presenter: Kyle Davidson Presenter: Dr. Phillip Pace
Denial & Deception: Getting back to SIGINT’s root EW System Development: Critical Thinking in Design Tradeoffs
33
The R&S SMW200A and the R&S Pulse Sequencer set-up - ready for testing
Advertorial
Create complex scenarios and watch them in 3D
In all stages of the development cycle, from initial functional testing to final operational simulation testing, engineers
need realistic test cases that reflect what the radar warning receiver will actually see when in operation. For that purpose,
engineers can use the R&S Pulse Sequencer software package to define a wide range of radar scenarios that extend
from simple pulses to dense multi-emitter RF environments. The software allows using smart pulse interleaving algo-
rithms with an optimized, user-defined priority scheme and lowest drop rates as a standard feature. Alternatively, the
user can also decide to simulate true pulse-on-pulse situations as they occur in reality, without any pulse dropping.
The user can configure all typical radar types such as CW radars, FMCW radars or pulsed radars such as wide band-
width, frequency agile radars with complex inter-pulse modulation (IPM) or modulation on pulse (MOP). For maximum
realism, emitters and the receiver can move along predefined or imported trajectories with six degrees of freedom
to make the simulation as realistic as possible. The usability is a core requirement for the software; because of that,
it offers 3D previews and graphical live visualization of configured scenarios to familiarize users quickly with the soft-
ware. In addition, calculation results even of complex multi-emitter scenarios are available fast so that the waiting time
for the results is reduced to a minimum and the user can optimize test cases conveniently.
Webinar: Simulating radar signals for meaningful radar warning receiver tests
Learn how to create radar scenarios ranging from simple pulses to the most demanding emitter
scenarios, generate complex radar signals and increase flexibility during radar simulation by
streaming pulse descriptor words (PDW).
With innovative test equipment from Rohde & Schwarz, radar engineers reduce testing uncertainty and gain confidence
to be able to test like in real operational scenarios.
I
systems are now emerging, and initial
t is not often that one sees a new referred to as drones, increasingly ro- prototypes are being developed and in-
weapon emerge on the battle- bust advanced missile systems, and tegrated into various platforms to al-
36 field that significantly changes hypervelocity weapons. These threats low warfighters to assess their military
how targets are neutralized or have been infused with complex high- utility. The first installments of this
destroyed. The invention of gun- speed electronics for capabilities like DE101 series introduce the activities
The Journal of Electronic Defense | April 2020
powder in China in the 9th century, command and control, higher accuracy, and topics that need to be addressed to
followed by harnessing its power to pro- and stable flight, and they have been support the development, integration
pel projectiles in the 12th century, led to developed with requirements to oper- and operational employment of DEW
the end of spears, arrows, and catapults ate in the electromagnetic environ- capabilities. The author intends it to
as wartime weapons of choice. Since ment (EME) that they were expected be a primer on the topic of operational-
then, nearly all weapon systems impact to encounter during their use, whether izing DEWs, with subsequent articles to
targets through kinetic effects that are it’s a drone inspecting a pipeline, or a follow that explore those activities in
produced either directly by a projec- missile used in combat. Here, we will further detail.
tile, such as a bullet or Missile Defense include optical (i.e., laser) frequencies
Agency (MDA) hit-to-kill interceptor, or in our definition of the EME. In most ELECTRONIC WARFARE, ELECTRONIC
by shrapnel combined with blast over- cases, the EME that was factored into ATTACK, AND DIRECTED ENERGY
pressure effects, as with a 155 mm artil- those system designs was comprised WEAPONS
lery shell or a Standard Missile block 2 of non-hostile unintentional electro- Electronic warfare (EW) is typically
fired from a Navy surface combatant. magnetic (EM) sources, such as com- defined as the art and science of pre-
Although we have increased the rate of munication and radar emissions, or serving the use of the EM spectrum for
fire, range, accuracy, agility and area for some weapons, a hostile EME cre- friendly use while denying its use to the
coverage, in the end, we are still, except ated by conventional Electronic War- enemy. Since its inception, the EW com-
for nuclear weapons, delivering kinetic fare (EW), as discussed later. Since the munity has been very successful in us-
effects. Nuclear weapons are clearly an 1960s, the US government has made ing electromagnetic energy to deceive,
outlier in that they primarily produce significant investments in develop- deny or degrade enemy sensors and
blast overpressure with a large fireball ing capabilities that are specifically weapon systems, so much so that there
and heavy radiation close to the detona- designed to create an intense EME to are a number of formal EW Programs
tion point. disrupt, damage or destroy targets in of Record (PORs) and entire platforms
New threats have emerged, such as combat. These capabilities are referred dedicated to the EW mission. The Boe-
weaponized large and small unmanned to as directed energy weapons (DEWs), ing EA-18G Growler and the Lockheed
air systems (UAS), the latter sometimes and while they have been popularized EC-130H Compass Call aircraft are two
FAILURE IS NOT AN OPTION
Tektronix co-founder Howard Vollum, along with British and American engineers, developed a revolutionary,
high-resolution radar system during WWII. Since then, Tektronix has been innovating in both the time and frequency
domains. We’ve created advanced acquisition and simulation technology with bandwidths up to 70 GHz, utilizing
the industry’s most advanced measurement trigger systems.
With the innovative suite of products that make up Tektronix closed-loop systems, you won’t risk costly failures.
Be confident your countermeasures will be effective in the most complex environments.
egorized as solid-state, high average Other short-pulse and ultra-short- agation in general is a critical issue for
power, continuous wave (CW) lasers pulse (USP) lasers are also being evalu- consideration for all HEL weapons.1
that impact a target by delivering a suf- ated to determine their viability as HEL
ficient power density (in Watts/cm2), at DEWs. Unlike CW lasers that rely on en- RF WEAPONS
a predetermined aimpoint for a suffi- ergy deposition to damage a target, USP For this discussion, we will refer to
an HPM/HPRF weapon as an RF weapon
(RFW). Most RFWs in development for
counter-materiel applications rely on
the creation of extremely high peak
powers, in the range of megawatts to
terawatts effective radiated power
(ERP), with pulses typically less than
one microsecond that disrupt, degrade,
or damage a target’s electronics. RFWs
can affect targeted systems by either
coupling energy into intended RF aper-
tures, known as “front door” coupling,
or through unintended RF apertures
such as seams, non-conductive sur-
faces, or unshielded wires, which is
“back door” coupling. One example of
front-door coupling is RF energy from
1 Stoudt, D., (2018) “Cloudy and a chance of rain
need not sideline high-energy lasers,” C4ISRNET,
https://www.c4isrnet.com/opinion/2018/02/26/
cloudy-and-a-chance-of-rain-need-not-sideline-
The US Navy has been evaluating high-energy lasers on its ships beginning with the AN/SEQ-3 high-energy-lasers/, (downloaded 10 February
Laser Weapons System deployed on the USS Ponce in 2014. US NAVY PHOTO 2020).
Performance Driven Products with Proven Results
Custom MMIC has earned the reputation for designing and delivering
the best performing RF and Microwave MMICs in the industry.
Custom MMIC offers a broad range of GaAs and GaN products used in
the most challenging of applications including Aerospace/Defense,
Custom MMIC offers RF and Space and Test and Instrumentation. We are constantly releasing new
Microwave System Designers a broad and innovative MMIC devices that push the limits of performance.
range of high performance MMIC
devices in our standard product
portfolio. Visit our easy-to-use website
at www.CustomMMIC.com to start
your product search today. Where can we take you next?
electronics after the RF illumination
has ended.
Two counter-materiel RFWs with
very high average powers are the
counter-IED systems called the Neu-
tralizing Improvised Explosive De-
vices with Radio Frequency (NIRF)
system that the Navy/Marine Corps
deployed to Iraq in 2005, and the
MaxPower system that the Air Force
deployed to Afghanistan in 2012.
RFWs can also be used for coun-
ter-personnel applications. The most
well-known example is the Active
Denial System (ADS) developed by
the Joint Non-Lethal Weapons Di-
rectorate in Quantico, VA. The ADS
basically works as a CW RFW at a
millimeter wavelength, correspond-
HPM weapons, such as the Phaser, are being evaluated for counter-UAS missions. US ARMY PHOTO
ing to a frequency of 95 GHz. When
an RFW entering through the antenna voltages that can disrupt their op- directed at human skin, this fre-
of the targeted receiver to disrupt, eration or even exceed their physical quency is absorbed in the first 1/64
degrade, or damage the low-noise am- limits (which in some cases is only sev- inch, causing a quick and reversible
plifier (LNA) on the front end. In back- eral volts) causing breakdown or arc- heating sensation that does not pen-
door coupling, RF energy couples into ing within the microchips themselves. etrate the target.
circuits within the targeted system, Unlike conventional EW, these RFW ef- Rather than go into technical
resulting in the creation of transient fects in most cases will continue in the depth about the DE-related efforts
underway in the Department of
40 Defense (DOD), the initial series in
this column will address the need
to change the discussion from DEW
The Journal of Electronic Defense | April 2020
NEXT
In our next installment, we will
look at how the DOD has evolved its
DEW technology approach from one
in which it concentrated mainly on
HPM technology has seen dramatic reductions in size-weight and power over the past several
increasing power levels to a more ho-
years. Above, the Active Denial System (left) requires a truck, and the more recent Solid-State
Active Denial Technology demonstrator (right) fits on a table top. SMC PHOTOS listic technological approach. a
Planar Monolithics Industries, Inc.
Coaxial Monopulse Comparators
PMI designs and manufactures a variety of Coaxial Monopulse Compartors for
beamforming antenna applications up to 21.2 GHz. Form, fit and functional
designs can also be replicated to specific requirements. Standard models with
various options are available at PMI’s website:
Amplifiers - Solid State http://pmi-rf.com/Products/monopulse_comparators/features.htm
Attenuators - Variable/
Programmable
Bi-Phase Modulators
Couplers (Quadrature, 180,
Directional)
Detectors - RF / Microwave
DLVAs, ERDLVAs & SDLVAs MPC-20R2G21R2G-CD-LNF PMC-24-7D5-SFF PMC-3G3D5G-6D8-SFF PMC-33D7-6D8-SFF
Integrated MIC/MMIC
PMC-3G3D5G-6D8-SFF
Assemblies (IMAs) https://www.pmi-rf.com/product- 3 - 3.5 0.8 - 6.8 23 ±5° ±0.4
3.23” x 3.23” x 0.43”
SMA (F)
details/pmc-3g3d5g-6d8-sff
IQ Vector Modulators
Limiters - RF / Microwave PMC-33D7-6D8-SFF
https://www.pmi-rf.com/product- 3 - 3.7 0.8 - 6.8 24 ±7° ±0.5
3.23” x 3.23” x 0.43”
SMA (F)
Log Amps details/pmc-33d7-6d8-sff
Switches - Solid-State
West Coast Operation: East Coast Operation:
Systems - Radar Sense &
4921 Robert J. Mathews Pkwy, Suite 1 7311-F Grove Road
Avoid
El Dorado Hills, CA 95762 USA Frederick, MD 21704 USA
Systems - Fly Eye Radar Tel: 916-542-1401, Fax: 916-265-2597 Tel: 301-662-5019, Fax: 301-662-1731
Threshold Detectors
USB Products sales@pmi-rf.com • www.pmi-rf.com
ISO9001-2015 REGISTERED
EW 101
Link Vulnerability
By Dave Adamy
T
his column returns to the series which ran in the ERPJ is the effective radiated power of the jamming transmit-
JED from June 2016 to October 2017. If you would ter toward the target receiver in dBm,
like to reference the previous articles in this Space ERPS is the effective radiated power of the desired signal
EW series, you can download the earlier columns toward the transmitter in dBm,
from the JED archives at www.jedonline.com.
In the earlier parts of the series, we covered
orbit mechanics; spherical trigonometry; geometric relation- Satellite
ships between satellites and points on the Earth; and several Link
important calculations, such as distance to the horizon, Dop- Distance
pler shifts, and the time a satellite can see a point on the Satellite
Jamming
Earth. We also covered intercept and jamming of Earth-surface Link
targets from space. However, we did not cover the important Distance
Ground
subject of the vulnerability of satellites to threats from hostile Station
electromagnetic attacks. In this continuation of the series, we
Jammer
will fill this gap and talk about a few more related subjects to
round out the coverage.
SATELLITE VULNERABILITY
42 Satellites are far from the Earth, but they present excellent Area above
line-of-sight from a large part of the Earth’s surface. There- Horizon from Sub-vehicle
fore, they are highly susceptible to strong hostile transmis- Satellite Point
The Journal of Electronic Defense | April 2020
LOSSJ is the transmission loss from the jammer to the target Where: LLOS is the propagation loss in dB,
receiver in dB, 32.44 is a conversion factor in dB to simplify the formula,
LOSSS is the transmission loss from the transmitter to the d is the distance from the satellite to the ground station or
target receiver in dB, the jammer in kilometers, and
GRJ is the gain of the receiving antenna in the direction of the F is the signal transmission frequency in MHz.
jammer in dB, and
GR is the gain of the receiving antenna toward the transmitter This is a large number because of the great distanc-
in dB. es involved. For example, for a low Earth satellite with a
two-hour (i.e., 120 minute) period, the link distance to a
This formula has been used in many other “EW 101” col- ground station at the horizon would be 4,935 km. If the
umns dealing with communications jamming, but in this link transmission frequency is 2 GHz, the link line-of-sight
case, there are considerations associated with satellites. In loss would be:
the September and October 2016 EW 101 columns, we talked
32.44 dB + 20 log (4935) + 20 log (2000) = 32.44 + 73.87 +
about the path loss from a ground transmitter to the satel-
66.02 = 172.33 dB.
lite, or from a satellite to a receiver on the ground. These col-
umns dealt with line-of-sight loss, atmospheric loss, antenna Note that there is a large table of the horizon distances
misalignment loss, polarization mismatch loss and rain loss. vs. satellite periods in the June 2017 “EW101” column, along
Both of the transmission losses in the above equation must with the underlying calculations. That table is repeated here
include all of these space-related loss contributions. As the as Table 1 for your convenience. In this table: “p(min)” is the
two columns on this subject were published over two years period of the satellite in minutes “rng(km)” is the link propa-
ago, the relevant space-related formulas and figures are re- gation distance between the satellite and the Earth surface
peated here for your convenience. transmitter or receiver, and “dist(km)” is the Earth surface
distance between the sub-vehicle point and the Earth surface
SPACE-RELATED LINK LOSSES transmitter or receiver.
Line-of-Sight Loss
Since the satellite is orbiting far from the Earth, the trans- WHAT’S NEXT
mission loss is best modeled as line-of-sight loss for both de- Next month we will continue the space EW series with the
sired signals and jamming signals, defined by the formula: space-related link loss discussion. For your comments and
44 suggestions, Dave Adamy can be reached at dave@lynxpub.
LLOS = 32.44 + 20 log d + 20 log F
com. a
The Journal of Electronic Defense | April 2020
Table 1. Height, semi-major axis and range to horizon and Earth surface distance to horizon for circular satellites with the orbital period specified
p(min) h (km) a (km) rng(km) dist(km) p(min) h (km) a (km) rng(km) dist(km)
90 281 6652 1914 1859 330 9447 15818 14478 7365
105 1001 7372 3710 3359 345 9923 16294 14997 7447
120 1688 8059 4935 4198 360 10392 16763 15505 7523
135 2346 8717 5950 4785 375 10854 17225 16004 7593
150 2980 9351 6845 5232 390 11311 17682 16494 7658
165 3594 9965 7662 5587 405 11761 18132 16976 7719
180 4189 10560 8422 5880 420 12206 18577 17451 7776
195 4768 11139 9137 6127 435 12646 19017 17918 7830
210 5332 11703 9817 6339 450 13081 19452 18379 7880
225 5883 12254 10467 6523 465 13510 19881 18833 7928
240 6422 12793 11093 6685 480 13936 20307 19281 7973
255 6949 13320 11698 6829 495 14357 20728 19724 8016
270 7466 13837 12284 6958 510 14773 21144 20162 8056
285 7974 14345 12853 7075 525 15186 21557 20594 8095
300 8473 14844 13408 7180 540 15595 21966 21021 8131
315 8964 15335 13949 7277
OM :
.C TES
RO E U ER
PE PDA
EU EIV GIST
EW RE RE
C
TO
1,250+ EVENT
ATTENDEES 85+ SPONSORS
EXHIBITORS
&
60+ VIPS/
DELEGATIONS
46
The Journal of Electronic Defense | April 2020
SPEAKERS
The Journal of
Electronic Defense
in Print and Online
As the final word in electronic defense, you rely on JED as your go-to source on
electronic warfare throughout the year but did you know that in addition to print, JED
is also emailed to you in a digital format? The digital edition of JED lets you virtually
flip through pages, forward articles of interest to colleagues and click on ads to be
redirected to the company’s website. Enjoy JED wherever you are, in print and online.