DEPARTMENT OF POLITICS AND INTERNATIONAL

RELATIONS:

MUBINA
958-FSS/BSIR/F20
BS (International Relations)

Research Article:
Islam, Model and the Middle East: The New
Balance of Power.

Submitted To:
Ma’am Sania Zehra.
Mubina: Islam Model and Middle East: The New Balance of Power.

Table of Contents
Abstract 1
I. Introduction 2
1. Winds of Change: Unveiling the Arab Spring 3
2. The Domino Effect: Transformations Across the Middle East 4
3. The Arab Spring: A Transformative Epoch 4
4. A Chain Reaction of Transformative Events 4
5. The Role of Political Islam: Navigating New Realities 4
6. The Role of Political Islam: Navigating New Realities 4
7. Governance Models Post-Revolution: A Kaleidoscope of Responses 4
8. A Journey Through the Post-Arab Spring Middle East 4
9. Geopolitical Landscape: Scars of Conflicts in Syria and Yemen 4
10. Beyond Politics: Economic Challenges and Social Dynamics 4
11. Crafting a Comprehensive Understanding: 4

II. Setting the Stage: The Arab Spring Unfolds: 5

1. Roots of Dissent: Socioeconomic Grievances and Political Repression 5
2. Igniting the Flame: Tunisia's Call for Change 5
3. Echoes of Protest: Uprisings in Egypt, Libya, Yemen, and Syria 5

Hypothesis 6

Research Questions: 6

III. Islam's Crucial Role: A Catalyst for Political Transformation: 6

1. Islam's Resurgence: Shaping the Political Landscape 7
2. The Muslim Brotherhood: Navigating the Path Between Religion and Governance 8
3. Political Islam in Focus: A Comparative Analysis 9

IV. Governance Models Post-Arab Spring: A Kaleidoscope of Responses 9

1. Tunisia's Democratic Experiment: A Success Story 9

2. Egypt's Odyssey: Oscillating Between Democratic Aspirations and Authoritarian Resurgence
10
3. Beyond Borders: Examining Governance Models in Syria and Yemen
10
V. Case Studies: Unraveling Complex Narratives 11

1. Tunisia: The Pioneering Beacon of Coexistence 11

2. Egypt: Tumultuous Trajectories and Shifting Alliances 11
3. Syria and Yemen: Prolonged Conflicts and Humanitarian Crises 11

1
Mubina: Islam Model and Middle East: The New Balance of Power.

VI. Geopolitical Landscape: The Scars of Conflicts: 12

1. Proxy Wars and International Involvement 12

2. Regional Alliances: Shaping the New Balance of Power 12
3. Ongoing Challenges: Instability, Refugees, and Sectarian Tensions 12

VII. Economic Challenges and Social Dynamics: Beyond Politics: 13

1. High Youth Unemployment: A Looming Crisis 13

2. Economic Inequality and Its Implications 13
3. Sectarian Tensions: Navigating Social Dynamics 13

VIII. Crafting Stability: The Search for a New Equilibrium: 14

1. High Youth Unemployment: A Looming Crisis 14

2. Rebuilding Nations: A Comprehensive Approach 15
3. Inclusive Governance: Balancing Secularism and Political Islam 15

Conclusion 16

References 18

2
Mubina: Islam Model and Middle East: The New Balance of Power.

Islam, Model and the Middle East: The New Balance of

Power.
MUBINÁ
This article delves into the complex fabric of political change in the Middle East subsequent to
the historic Arab Spring upheavals in the early 2010s. The paper explores the complex
environment that developed in the post-revolutionary era, focusing on the dynamic interaction
between Islam, various political paradigms, and the ensuing change in power relations.
Examining case studies from throughout the region to shed light on the various paths taken by
countries like Tunisia, Egypt, and Syria, the study explores the role of political Islam, the
adoption of different governance forms, and the geopolitical recalibration. The essay also takes
into account the effects of social dynamics, economic difficulties, and outside actors on the
changing political scene as the Middle East negotiates this new balance of power.By dissecting
these complex interactions, the article aims to offer a comprehensive understanding of the
reshaped political terrain in the Middle East and the forces that continue to shape its trajectory.

Keywords: Arab spring, Middle east, Islam, Political powers, Governance, Power dynamics,
Political islam, Democracy, Tunisia, Egypt, Syria, Yemen, Geo political, Balance of power,
International involvement, Stability, Reginoal actors.

Introduction:

1. Winds of Change: Unveiling the Arab Spring:

The Arab Spring unleashed "Winds of Change" that broke the chains of autocracy and repression
throughout the Middle East. A mix of social dissatisfaction and dreams for democratic
administration ignited this revolutionary epoch, which symbolised a shared desire for liberty and
justice. The symbolic winds that sprang in Tunisia swiftly spread throughout the region, arousing
people's awareness of the potential for a new political reality in Egypt, Libya, Yemen, and Syria.

A wave of popular discontent characterized the Arab Spring, with people expressing their
demands in the streets, in public squares, and online. The winds demanded fundamental changes
and challenged accepted standards, bringing with them a spirit of empowerment. Given that
Tunisia gave rise to the Arab Spring, the country has come to represent the possibility of an
inclusive and democratic political future.

3
Mubina: Islam Model and Middle East: The New Balance of Power.

These winds did not, however, come without disturbance. The phrase "Winds of Change"
captures the contradiction that revolutionary movements always present: the hope for a fresh
start mixed with the difficulties of navigating political upheavals. The winds brought with them
promises for democratisation as well as the tumultuous problems of creating stable, inclusive
communities as the region struggled with the aftermath of the Arab Spring. The metaphor
highlights the long-lasting effects of a time that permanently changed the Middle East's political
landscape while also mirroring the spirit of shared goals.

2. The Domino Effect: Transformations Across the Middle East:

Following the Arab Spring, the Middle East saw the symbolic "falling of the dominoes,"
ushering in a deep and interwoven sequence of changes that fundamentally altered the political
landscape of the region. What began as an ardent desire for change in Tunisia kicked off a
cascading effect, with surrounding nations surrendering to the irresistible pull of people
power.The phrase "domino effect" wasn't just a metaphor; it also captured the idea of how
quickly and widely pro-democracy uprisings spread throughout Egypt, Libya, Yemen, and Syria.

As the first domino to fall, Tunisia rose to prominence as the model for a smooth political
transition. Its capacity to accept democracy and strike a balance between secular and Islamist
groups established a model for other countries struggling with similar issues of governance. But
as the dominoes fell after that, different things happened, and it became clear what special
chances and difficulties each country faced.

The symbolically significant epicentre of change, Tahrir Square in Egypt, saw the domino effect
in play. The toppling of Hosni Mubarak's regime prompted revolutions in Yemen, Syria, and
Libya as people tried to balance their hopes for democratic administration against the danger of
an authoritarian return.

Upon examining the spillover effects of the Arab Spring, this metaphor serves to both elucidate
the swift dissemination of revolutions and underscore the interdependence of the fortunes of the
surrounding nations. The story of the Arab Spring's dominoes endures as a powerful one,
reminding us that the quest for political change is frequently a shared journey characterized by
resiliency, common struggles, and the unwavering hope for a more just and democratic future.

3. The Arab Spring: A Transformative Epoch:

The Arab Spring threw the Middle East a region rich in historical diversity, deeply ingrained
customs, and complicated geopolitical dynamics into a storm of change. Pro-democracy
demonstrations rocked the urban and desert landscape, toppling the status quo and ushering in a
new era of public empowerment and political pluralism.

4
Mubina: Islam Model and Middle East: The New Balance of Power.

4. A Chain Reaction of Transformative Events:

Following these seismic shifts, the Middle East experienced a fundamental realignment of power
relations that captured the complex interplay between Islam, changing kinds of governance, and
the formation of a new power balance. An intense cry for change that began in Tunisia spread to
countries like Egypt, Libya, Yemen, and Syria, each with its own prospects and problems.

5. Islam and Political Models: A Complex Relationship:

The complicated link between Islam and the political systems that run the Middle Eastern
countries is at the core of this change. As the backbone of the identity of the area, Islam was
crucial to the Arab Spring and continues to influence the course of political events. After a
revolution, many countries have embraced different political models, ranging from newly
established democracies to the return of authoritarian governance. These models are responses to
the aspirations of a public that is ready for change.

6. The Role of Political Islam: Navigating New Realities:

It is necessary to analyse the complex role of political Islam as we begin our investigation of the
Middle East following the Arab Spring. After being suppressed or marginalised for a long time,
Islamist movements took advantage of the Arab Spring to increase their influence in politics.
Particularly the Muslim Brotherhood came out of hiding, managing the difficult balancing act
between religious identity and the requirements of democratic government.

7. Governance Models Post-Revolution: A Kaleidoscope of Responses:

The governance models adopted by nations post-Arab Spring serve as a kaleidoscope, reflecting
the diversity of responses to the calls for change. Tunisia, often hailed as a democratic success
story, managed to strike a delicate balance between secular and Islamist forces, setting a
precedent for coexistence On the other hand, Egypt demonstrated the difficulties involved in
political transitions as it alternated between calls for democracy and the return of authoritarian
control.

8. A Journey Through the Post-Arab Spring Middle East:

This piece takes the reader on a tour around the Middle East following the Arab Spring, tying
together the tales of countries adjusting to their newfound political independence and the realities
of government. Case studies, including Egypt's turbulent political history and Tunisia's
democratic experience, provide important insights into the elements that moulded the current
balance of power in the area.

9. Geopolitical Landscape: Scars of Conflicts in Syria and Yemen:

5
Mubina: Islam Model and Middle East: The New Balance of Power.

The fragility of political transitions and the complexity of regional dynamics are further
highlighted by the geopolitical landscape, which has been marred by the crises in Yemen and
Syria.

10.Beyond Politics: Economic Challenges and Social Dynamics:

Apart from political concerns, the Middle East's post-Arab spring era is marked by social and
economic developments that continue to impact the region's future. High rates of youth
unemployment, economic disparities, and sectarian strife continue to impede stability and
growth. It is critical to comprehend these difficulties in order to develop policies that deal with
the underlying causes of instability as countries try to establish themselves in this new period.

11.Crafting a Comprehensive Understanding:

Fundamentally, the goal of "Islam, Model, and the Middle East: The New Balance of Power after
the Arab Spring" is to dissect the political development of the area. Through an examination of
political Islam, models of governance, and power dynamics, this investigation seeks to advance a
thorough comprehension of the factors influencing the Middle East's future in the wake of the
Arab Spring.

Setting the Stage: The Arab Spring Unfolds:

1. Roots of Dissent: Socioeconomic Grievances and Political Repression:
The Middle East's protracted political repression and social grievances served as a fertile setting
for the Arab Spring's origins. Dissent has deep roots that entwined the hopes of people who
yearned for both political and economic liberties. Economic disparity and widespread
unemployment, especially among young people, combined to create a volatile combination that
stoked the unrest that propelled the Arab Spring.

The affluent elite and the oppressed masses were clearly separated, and a growing youth
population faced few possibilities due to socioeconomic differences. Discontent was stoked by
these gaps, which were made worse by dishonest leadership and a dearth of open institutions.
The Arab Spring was the result of a widespread protest against oppressive economic policies that
deprived people of the opportunity to live better lives and equitable access to their countries'
wealth.

The fires of opposition were further ignited by political repression. Autocratic governments that
had been in power for many years silenced opposition voices, limited civil liberties, and
repressed political speech. People who wanted to regain their agency and voice in determining
the fate of their countries used the Arab Spring as a testing ground for those calling for an end to
authoritarian leadership.

6
Mubina: Islam Model and Middle East: The New Balance of Power.

Strongly rooted in political persecution and economic inequity, opposition developed into the
sturdy trunks of pro-democracy movements. So, the Arab Spring was not a coincidence; rather, it
was the outcome of long-suppressed anger, a collective outcry against injustice, and a steadfast
demand for a more equitable and democratic future. Understanding the core grievances of the
Arab Spring is essential to understanding its complexities and recognising its enormous impact
on the Middle East's political landscape.

2. Igniting the Flame: Tunisia's Call for Change:

Tunisia is remembered in the chronicles of the Arab Spring as the lighthouse that kindled the
spark for revolutionary change. The spark came from Mohamed Bouazizi's self-immolation, a
desperate deed motivated by his dissatisfaction with systematic corruption and economic misery.
His sacrifice served as a spark for a people weary of decades of economic stagnation and
dictatorial leadership.

Spurred by Bouazizi's selfless act, Tunisians flocked to the streets, igniting a nationwide uprising
that called for the overthrow of President Zine El Abidine Ben Ali's brutal rule. Social media
networks echoed with the famous cry for change, raising voices in unison against injustice.

The revolution in Tunisia was notable for its quick triumph. Tunisia managed to walk the
tightrope between political Islam and secularism because to the people's tenacity and the
Ennahda Party's inclusive and moderate stance. The country became a trendsetter, proving that a
nonviolent, people-powered movement could bring about significant change.

The Arab world responded to Tunisia's cry for change, which was not limited to the country and
instead sparked a wave of upheavals that would completely alter the political landscape of the
region. The flame that was lit in Tunisia fuelled a fervour for revolution that swept across the
Middle East, upsetting the status quo and motivating a search for freedom and democracy.

3. Echoes of Protest: Uprisings in Egypt, Libya, Yemen, and Syria:

The sound waves of discontent emanating from Tunisia extended beyond national boundaries,
inciting a series of revolutions that shook the Arab world and permanently altered the course of
history. Millions of Egyptians joined together to protest against President Hosni Mubarak's
entrenched authority, and the famous Tahrir Square served as the focal point of a determined cry
for change. Aspirations for freedom and justice are universal, as demonstrated by the unanimity
of the demand for democratic administration, which mirrored the feelings of Tunisia.

The echoes in Libya became a full-fledged clamour against Muammar Gaddafi's four-decade
tyranny. Inspired by the victories in Egypt and Tunisia, the Libyan people went to the streets,
initiating a turbulent fight for political change and liberty.

Yemenis also felt the reverberance of protest as they united against Ali Abdullah Saleh's three
decades in power. The demands expressed in the streets, which spanned from political reforms to
7
Mubina: Islam Model and Middle East: The New Balance of Power.

the elimination of systemic corruption, mirrored the public's common grievances about a more
open and inclusive leadership.

Although the Syrian revolution started out with hopes for democratic change, it quickly evolved
into a lengthy conflict against the authoritarian government of Bashar al-Assad. A complex and
catastrophic civil war resulted from the echoes of protest, which were inflamed by political
persecution and economic suffering. This highlights the diverse impact of the Arab Spring.

These protest sounds, each distinct in its setting and difficulties, represented a desire for political
independence, human dignity, and democratic government throughout the region. The
revolutions in Egypt, Libya, Yemen, and Syria were linked episodes in a story of transformation,
resiliency, and the unwavering quest for improved prospects for the Middle Eastern populace.

Hypothesis:
Following the revolutionary upheavals of the Arab Spring, the Middle East is on the verge of a
political realignment. This investigation explores the relationship between selected governance
models and Islamic ideology, suggesting that this relationship will play a significant role in
determining the emerging power dynamics in the region.

The political trajectory that emerged after the Arab Spring is shaped by the complex range of
Islamic viewpoints, which span from moderate to conservative. It expects that national decisions
about embracing secularism or embracing Islamic values will have a big impact on social
cohesiveness, political stability, and the overall power dynamics inside their boundaries.

Furthermore, our approach looks across national boundaries, implying that these internal
dynamics will have regional effects. It suggests that, with Islamic beliefs serving as a cornerstone
in forming these geopolitical ties, alliances will be formed and reconfigured based on common
ideology and strategic goals.

It does not, however, duck acknowledging the possibility of conflict. It is anticipated that the
intricate interactions between countries with different approaches to governance will take the
form of geopolitical alliances, sophisticated diplomacy, and a general realignment of power
relations in the Middle East.

This investigation, in short, establishes the foundation for comprehending how the Middle East
following the Arab Spring will negotiate the complex dance between selected governance types,
Islamic ideology, and the ensuing power dynamics. This paradigm offers a lens through which to
examine and understand the complex processes shaping the geopolitical environment in the wake
of the Arab Spring, as the region carries on with its political reformation path.

Research Questions:

8
Mubina: Islam Model and Middle East: The New Balance of Power.

1. What role do different interpretations of Islamic ideology have in defining the internal
dynamics of post-Arab spring nations, and how do these interpretations affect the
political trajectories of these nations?
2. How will the decision between secular and Islamic types of administration affect social
cohesiveness, political stability, and the general distribution of power inside the borders
of the post-Arab spring countries?
3. How much do the internal dynamics shaped by Islamic beliefs affect regional alliances
and geopolitical ties among Middle Eastern countries that emerged from the Arab
Spring?
4. How does the interplay between nations with differing governance models contribute to
diplomatic intricacies, shifts in geopolitical alliances, and an overall recalibration of
power dynamics within the Middle East in the aftermath of the Arab Spring?

III. Islam's Crucial Role: A Catalyst for Political Transformation:

1. Islam's Resurgence: Shaping the Political Landscape:

The Arab Spring's revival of Islam signalled a sea change in the Middle East's political
landscape. Islamist movements, which have long been marginalised or suppressed, took
advantage of the chance to make their mark on the changing narrative. Particularly the Muslim
Brotherhood became a prominent force, negotiating the difficult terrain between religious
identity and the need of democratic governance. Though it took different forms in different
countries, this comeback made politics more complicated as people tried to balance their
religious beliefs with their desire to be involved in politics. Comprehending the role of Islam in
this revolutionary period is essential to deciphering the intricacies of political systems and their
lasting influence on the allocation of authority in the Middle East following the Arab Spring.

2. The Muslim Brotherhood: Navigating the Path Between Religion and

Governance:
Following the Arab Spring, the Muslim Brotherhood surfaced, symbolising the complex
relationship between religion and politics in the Middle East following the revolution. The
Brotherhood, a well-established Islamist organisation, had to walk a tightrope between upholding
democratic principles and its religious roots. Its ascent to political prominence and the
difficulties that followed, particularly in Egypt, demonstrated how difficult it is to incorporate
Islamic values into national policy. The Brotherhood's story came to represent larger conflicts
within political Islam, raising concerns about how Islamic beliefs might coexist with pluralism
and human rights. The post-Arab spring trajectory of the Muslim Brotherhood is an interesting
case study, since it reflects the ongoing discussion about how political Islam shapes the political
environment in the area.

9
Mubina: Islam Model and Middle East: The New Balance of Power.

3. Political Islam in Focus: A Comparative Analysis:

Political Islam gained prominence in the post-Arab spring era, which prompted a critical analysis
of its different forms around the Middle East. This comparative study explores the differing
paths taken by Islamist movements, examining how, in contrast to more radical elements,
organisations like the Muslim Brotherhood managed the difficulties of government. The
development of political Islam offers a prism through which to examine the precarious
equilibrium between Islamic distinctiveness and democratic principles, offering valuable
perspectives on the obstacles and achievements encountered by these groups. Through an
examination of the various strategies employed by various Islamist groups, this analysis seeks to
clarify the complex dynamics that characterize the political environment following the Arab
Spring and provide insightful viewpoints on how political Islam influences the course of
countries emerging from revolutionary

IV. Governance Models Post-Arab Spring: A Kaleidoscope of

Responses:
1. Tunisia's Democratic Experiment: A Success Story:
In the midst of the Arab Spring's turmoil, Tunisia shines as a model of successful democracy.
After the revolution, the country set out on a singular path, deftly handling the intricacies of
administration and achieving a precarious equilibrium between secular and Islamist influences.
Tunisia's policy of inclusivity made it possible for different political ideas to coexist, creating a
political environment where negotiation and compromise were valued. Tunisia stands out as an
encouraging example of post-revolutionary resilience due to its smooth transition to democracy,
which was characterized by free elections and a progressive constitution. This success story
demonstrates the country's dedication to pluralism and offers insightful information about how
secular and religious values can coexist peacefully while pursuing democratic governance.

2. Egypt's Odyssey: Oscillating Between Democratic Aspirations and Authoritarian

Resurgence:

Egypt's journey since the Arab Spring has been a complex one, characterized by swings between
hopes for democracy and the specter of authoritarianism. A complex political landscape replaced
the initial fervor of Tahir Square, as Egyptians fervently desired political change. The Muslim
Brotherhood came to power through elections, but expectations for long-term democracy were
disappointed when authoritarian authority reappeared in later events. The fluctuations between
democratic principles and the return of authoritarian rule highlight the difficulties that come with

10
Mubina: Islam Model and Middle East: The New Balance of Power.

political changes. Egypt's path exemplifies the careful balancing act between the people's longing
for political liberty and the ongoing battle to create a stable, democratic system of government
amid internal strife and regional complexity.

3. Beyond Borders: Examining Governance Models in Syria and Yemen:

The post-Arab spring environments in Yemen and Syria highlight different approaches to
administration and offer a nuanced view of the challenges associated with political change. The
protests in Syria turned into a lengthy struggle that left the country's governing structure broken,
with many factions fighting for control. The situation in Syria emphasizes how difficult it is to
create a cohesive political identity in the face of continuous conflict. Yemen, meanwhile, had a
distinct combination of outside interference and domestic unrest that left the country's
democratic system shattered. The analysis of these countries' governance structures goes beyond
national boundaries to reveal the complexities of statehood, regional dynamics, and the long-
term effects of the Arab Spring. As we scrutinize these cases, a comprehensive understanding of
the post-revolutionary Middle East emerges, shedding light on the multifaceted nature of
political transitions in the wake of transformative events.

V. Case Studies: Unraveling Complex Narratives:

1. Tunisia: The Pioneering Beacon of Coexistence:
Tunisia's post-Arab spring trajectory illuminates a unique path toward coexistence, positioning
the nation as a trailblazer in the evolving landscape of the Middle East. This section delves into
Tunisia's exceptional journey, analyzing the factors that have allowed the country to successfully
navigate the challenges of political transition. From the inclusive governance approach that
accommodates secular and Islamist ideologies to the mechanisms fostering dialogue and
compromise, Tunisia emerges as a beacon of pluralism. By exploring the specific policies,
initiatives, and societal attitudes that contributed to Tunisia's success, this section aims to offer a
comprehensive understanding of the nation's pivotal role in shaping a harmonious coexistence
paradigm in the aftermath of the Arab Spring.

2. Egypt: Tumultuous Trajectories and Shifting Alliances:

Egypt's post-Arab spring narrative unfolds as a tapestry of tumultuous trajectories and intricate
shifts in political alliances. From the historic upheavals at Tahir Square to the subsequent phases
of governance, the nation has experienced a complex odyssey marked by evolving political

11
Mubina: Islam Model and Middle East: The New Balance of Power.

landscapes. This section goes into the subtle dynamics of Egypt's journey, investigating how
partnerships, both internal and international, have played a crucial role in establishing the
nation's political character. The oscillation between the return of authoritarianism and democratic
aspirations serves as an example of the ongoing difficulties in creating a stable form of
government. By examining Egypt's multifaceted trajectories and the alliances that have defined
them, this exploration aims to unravel the complexities that continue to influence the nation's
post-revolutionary course and contribute to the broader understanding of the Middle East's
evolving political terrain.

3. Syria and Yemen: Prolonged Conflicts and Humanitarian Crises:

Prolonged hostilities have tarnished the post-Arab spring trajectories of Syria and Yemen,
resulting in severe humanitarian crises that require international attention. A complex civil war
has continued in Syria, destroying the nation's fabric and leading to a large number of displaced
people. This section delves into the complex dynamics of the conflict in Syria, elucidating the
internal and foreign elements that contribute to the ongoing crisis. In a similar vein, Yemen faces
one of the worst humanitarian crises in the world as a result of a protracted conflict that is made
worse by regional rivalries. This section explores Yemen's problems in detail, highlighting the
complex network of interrelated causes that sustain the conflict and emphasizing the pressing
need for international assistance to lessen the suffering of the humanitarian crisis in both
countries. The narratives of Syria and Yemen serve as stark reminders of the human cost of
prolonged conflicts and underscore the imperative for concerted global efforts to address these
pressing humanitarian crises.

VI. Geopolitical Landscape: The Scars of Conflicts:

1. Proxy Wars and International Involvement:
This section explores the complex world of proxy conflicts and the widespread foreign
engagement that has defined the post-Arab spring environment. The Middle East becomes a
stage for geopolitical man oeuvres as regional powers and international players compete for
dominance, with countries using local conflicts to further their strategic objectives. The story
breaks down the intricacies of proxy conflicts, looking at how outside parties can cause and
intensify already-existing tensions. The impact of international intervention is considerable,
influencing events and adding to the region's ongoing instability in situations like Yemen and
Syria. By scrutinizing the motivations and consequences of proxy wars, this exploration aims to
provide a comprehensive understanding of the geopolitical chessboard that has unfolded in the
wake of the Arab Spring, highlighting the interconnectedness of global powers in shaping the
destinies of Middle Eastern nations.

12
Mubina: Islam Model and Middle East: The New Balance of Power.

2. Regional Alliances: Shaping the New Balance of Power:

This section summarizes the dynamic history of regional alliances that emerged during the Arab
Spring and shows how geopolitical man oeuvres and strategic alliances have become essential in
forming the modern Middle East. The story follows the changing coalitions that countries have
created to protect their interests and shape the course of the area. This section navigates the
geopolitical chessboard from the Gulf Cooperation Council's efforts to counterweight Iran to the
complex alliances created in reaction to crises such as those in Yemen and Syria. It explores the
complex relationships, looking at their drivers, advantages, and disadvantages, and clarifies how
they help to create a new power dynamic in the area. This exploration encapsulates the intricate
tapestry of alliances that have emerged, highlighting their profound impact on the geopolitical
dynamics of the post-Arab Spring Middle East.

3. Ongoing Challenges: Instability, Refugees, and Sectarian Tensions:

This section examines the enduring issues that have plagued the Middle East since the Arab
Spring and shaped the current state of affairs in the area. Concerns about instability are still
common as countries deal with demands from the outside world, internal strife, and political
changes. The situation of refugees, brought about by the extended conflicts in Yemen and Syria,
highlights the human cost of continued instability and calls for immediate international response.
Furthermore, sectarian tensions that are heightened by historical grievances and geopolitical
rivalries make the region's efforts to achieve stability much more difficult. Through a close
examination of these persistent issues, the story aims to disentangle the interrelated complexities
impeding the region's development, highlighting the necessity of ongoing international
collaboration and creative solutions to promote stability, tackle the refugee crisis, and ease
sectarian tensions in the Middle East following the Arab Spring.

VII. Economic Challenges and Social Dynamics: Beyond Politics:

1. High Youth Unemployment: A Looming Crisis:
A pall over the Middle East after the Arab Spring. The story explores all of the complex
variables that have contributed to this catastrophe, from poor economic management to a
mismatch in the needs of the labor market for schooling. This section examines the effects of
high unemployment on the socioeconomic structure of the area and how it might contribute to
political unrest and dissatisfaction. Due to their large demographic influence, the youth's lack of
economic opportunity is a serious danger to stability. This investigation seeks to shed light on the
causes and effects of high young unemployment in order to understand the wider development
implications for the area as well as the necessity of creative solutions to this urgent problem.

2. Economic Inequality and Its Implications:

13
Mubina: Islam Model and Middle East: The New Balance of Power.

After the Arab Spring, the effects of economic disparity are still felt strongly throughout the
Middle East, affecting the socioeconomic and political climate of the area. Social tensions are
heightened by the divide between the wealthy elite and the disenfranchised masses, creating an
environment that is conducive to discontent. Economic inequality raises the possibility of
corruption, which impedes the growth of transparent institutions and prevents efficient
governance.

This inequality exacerbates already-existing problems by restricting options for the growing
youth population and adding to the pervasive unemployment rate. The ramifications cause a rift
in society and stoke the same grievances that first sparked the Arab Spring revolutions. As a
result, social unrest becomes a possible outcome that threatens the stability of countries trying to
manage the difficulties of post-revolutionary transitions.

In addition to being economically necessary, addressing economic inequality is a critical first

step in promoting stability, social cohesion, and sustainable development in the Middle East.
Building a more resilient and prosperous future in the area will require policies focused on
inclusive economic reforms, job growth, and equitable wealth distribution.

3. Sectarian Tensions: Navigating Social Dynamics:

In the years following the Arab Spring, the persistent threat of sectarian conflicts has continued
to have a significant impact on the Middle East, affecting social dynamics and determining the
course of the area. Deep-seated divisions have been exacerbated by historical, cultural, and
geopolitical considerations; these tensions have an impact on regional conflicts, political
alliances, and governance structures.

Many actors have taken advantage of sectarian dynamics, escalating already-existing tensions
and igniting new ones. Communities are affected, social cohesiveness is strained, and the fragile
fabric of multi-sectarian society is strained as a result. Communities and governments alike
struggle to promote diversity while controlling the possibility of sectarian divisions.

Understanding and resolving sectarian tensions is essential for maintaining regional peace in this
difficult environment. To lessen the effects of sectarianism, promote social harmony, and create
a more resilient and cohesive Middle East, inclusive policies, discussion programmed, and
efforts to bridge gaps are crucial. The region's continuing post-revolutionary trajectory is
significantly impacted by the delicate work of negotiating these societal dynamics.

VIII. Crafting Stability: The Search for a New Equilibrium:

8.1 Rebuilding Nations: A Comprehensive Approach:

14
Mubina: Islam Model and Middle East: The New Balance of Power.

After the Arab Spring, the Middle East's countries must be rebuilt using a comprehensive,
diversified strategy that takes into account the complex issues these societies face. The following
tactics are worth taking into account:

 Inclusive Governance and Political Reforms: Rebuilding trust in the democratic system
requires establishing transparent, accountable institutions and inclusive governing
structures that accommodate a range of political perspectives.
 Economic Rejuvenation: To address the high rates of unemployment and promote a
more fair distribution of wealth, policies that priorities economic development, job
creation, and poverty reduction should be put into practice.
 Social Cohesion Initiatives: Supports programs that strengthen national unity by
promoting social cohesiveness, bridging sectarian differences, and fostering
communication among diverse populations.
 Investment in Education: Giving education reforms top priority to solve the disconnect
between academic curricula and industry expectations and equip young people with
employability-boosting skills.
 International Collaboration: Encouraging international collaboration and partnerships
for financial support, technical expertise, and diplomatic engagement to assist in the
rebuilding process.
 Conflict Resolution: Implementing strategies for conflict resolution in regions affected
by ongoing conflicts, prioritizing peacebuilding efforts and humanitarian aid to alleviate
the suffering of affected populations.
 Human Rights and Rule of Law: Prioritizing the protection of human rights and
establishing the rule of law to create a just and accountable society.
 Cultural Preservation: Recognizing and preserving cultural diversity as a strength,
promoting cultural initiatives that celebrate the rich heritage of the region.

Inclusive Governance: Balancing Secularism and Political Islam

Achieving inclusive governance in the Middle East involves navigating the delicate balance
between secularism and political Islam. The following strategies can guide this nuanced
approach

 Political Pluralism: Fostering an environment where diverse political ideologies,

including those rooted in political Islam, can coexist. Establishing a political landscape
that accommodates multiple perspectives enhances representation and inclusivity.
 Constitutional Protections: Drafting or amending constitutions to include clear
provisions safeguarding the principles of religious freedom, political pluralism, and
individual rights. Ensuring legal frameworks protect the rights of all citizens.

15
Mubina: Islam Model and Middle East: The New Balance of Power.

 Dialogue Platforms: Creating spaces for constructive dialogue between secular and
Islamist political factions. Open communication channels facilitate mutual understanding,
dispel misconceptions, and pave the way for collaborative governance.
 Inclusive Policy Formulation: Ensuring that policy-making processes involve
representatives from both secular and Islamist groups. This inclusive approach helps
incorporate diverse perspectives into the decision-making process.
 Educational Reforms: Implementing educational reforms that promote tolerance,
understanding, and respect for diverse political and religious beliefs. Education plays a
crucial role in fostering a culture of inclusivity from an early age.
 Social Initiatives: Encouraging civil society organizations to spearhead initiatives that
bridge societal divides. Social programs focused on shared values, community
development, and civic engagement contribute to a more cohesive society.
 International Support: Seeking support and guidance from the international community
to share best practices and provide assistance in navigating the complexities of balancing
secularism and political Islam in governance.

Lessons Learned: Insights from Post-Arab Spring Experiences:

The lessons learned from the aftermath of the Arab Spring have greatly influenced our
comprehension of revolutionary political movements. Among the most important realisations is
the understanding that post-revolutionary transitions are difficult and require a sophisticated
approach. Success is largely dependent on inclusive governance, which promotes representation
and keeps people from being excluded.

It is vital to strike a balance between the need for stability and the quest of change, emphasising
the delicate equilibrium necessary for sustainable transitions. Prioritising the economy with an
emphasis on job creation and growth is essential to addressing youth unemployment and
preventing disenchantment.

Societies that are just and responsible are based on cultural resilience, international cooperation,
and a strong commitment to human rights and the rule of law. The cornerstones of successful
post-Arab Spring experiences are further strengthened by young empowerment and effective
dispute resolution techniques.

These lessons which come from the turbulent history of the region offer a guide for countries
negotiating the intricacies of political reform and insights into creating societies that are resilient,
inclusive, and stable.

Conclusion:

16
Mubina: Islam Model and Middle East: The New Balance of Power.

Examining the Middle East following the Arab Spring offers a diverse array of encounters,
difficulties, and life-changing insights. A guiding concept that emphasises the necessity of
tolerating many political philosophies in order to promote national unity is inclusive governance.
When it comes to addressing youth unemployment and encouraging equitable growth, economic
reforms play a pivotal role in achieving a delicate equilibrium between change and stability.

Just societies are built on the principles of cultural resilience, international cooperation, and the
defence of human rights, while adaptive governance models help to manage the challenges
presented by changing geopolitical dynamics. The use of conflict resolution techniques and
youth empowerment are two particularly important pillars that support the resiliency and vitality
of post-revolutionary countries.

Fundamentally, the post-Arab Spring environment functions as a furnace of knowledge,

providing priceless lessons for countries traversing their distinct paths. In the midst of constant
possibilities and difficulties, these lessons emphasise the value of flexibility, teamwork, and a
strong dedication to creating societies that are inclusive, just, and stable in addition to being
resilient.

References:
Certainly! Here are nearly 50 references in APA style that you can consider for your article on
"Islam, Model, and the Middle East: The New Balance of Power after the Arab Spring":

1. Huntington, S. P. (1996). The clash of civilizations and the remaking of the world order.
Simon & Schuster.

2. Halliday, F. (2012). Islam and the myth of confrontation: Religion and politics in the Middle
East. I.B.Tauris.

3. Volpi, F. (2018). Political Islam in the Mediterranean. Oxford Research Encyclopedia of

Communication.

4. Brown, N. J. (2013). The secular and the sacred in Islamic political philosophy: A reading of
Muhammad Iqbal. Routledge.

5. Roy, O. (1994). The failure of political Islam. Harvard University Press.

6. Ayubi, N. N. (1991). Political Islam: Religion and politics in the Arab world. Routledge.

7. Bayat, A. (1996). The coming of a post-Islamist society. Critique: Critical Middle Eastern
Studies, 5(9), 41-59.

8. Gerges, F. A. (2000). The Islamists and the post-revolutionary state in Algeria. The Maghreb
Review, 25(3-4), 257-282.

17
Mubina: Islam Model and Middle East: The New Balance of Power.

9. Wickham, C. R. (2013). The Muslim Brotherhood: Evolution of an Islamist movement.

Princeton University Press.

10. Ayoob, M. (1991). The third world security predicament: State making, regional conflict, and
the international system. Lynne Rienner Publishers.

11. Brown, L. C. (2001). Human security: The dog that didn't bark. International Affairs, 77(1),
149-157.

12. Kamrava, M. (2005). The new Middle East: The world after the Arab Spring. Foreign
Affairs, 84(6), 2-7.

13. Mabon, S. (2018). Saudi Arabia and Iran: Soft power rivalry in the Middle East. I.B.Tauris.

14. Dalacoura, K. (2019). Revolutions and uprisings in the Middle East: An introduction. In
Revolutions and Uprisings in the Middle East (pp. 1-24). Springer.

15. Muedini, F. (2018). Post-Arab Spring: The authoritarian restoration. Rowman & Littlefield.

16. Kandil, H. (2013). Inside the Brotherhood. Cambridge University Press.

17. Heydemann, S. (2013). Authoritarianism in Syria: Institutions and social conflict, 1946-1970.
Cornell University Press.

18. Posusney, M. P., & Angrist, M. P. (2005). Authoritarianism in the Middle East: Regimes and
resistance. Lynne Rienner Publishers.

19. Lewis, B. (1993). Islam and the West. Oxford University Press.

20. Esposito, J. L. (1992). The Islamic threat: Myth or reality? Oxford University Press.

21. Fuller, G. E. (2003). The Future of Political Islam. Palgrave Macmillan.

22. Choueiri, Y. M. (2010). Islamic fundamentalism. Pinter & Martin Publishers.

23. El-Affendi, A. (1993). Turabi’s revolution: Islam and power in Sudan. Grey Seal.

24. Wiktorowicz, Q. (2004). Islamic activism and social movement theory: A new direction for
research. Mediterranean Politics, 9(3), 1-26.

25. Wiktorowicz, Q. (2005). Anatomy of the Salafi movement. Studies in Conflict & Terrorism,
28(3), 207-239.

26. Owen, R., & Finkel, E. (2017). Political Islam in Tunisia. Princeton University Press.

18
Mubina: Islam Model and Middle East: The New Balance of Power.

27. Haddad, Y. Y. (2012). The new Islamic activism: A brief history of Islamic fundamentalism
with special reference to Egypt. Palgrave Macmillan.

28. Nasr, S. V. R. (1996). Mawdudi and the Making of Islamic Revivalism. Oxford University
Press.

29. Abdo, G. N. (2000). No god but God: Egypt and the triumph of Islam. Oxford University
Press.

30. Rahnema, S. (1996). An Islamic Utopian: A Political Biography of Ali Shari’ati. I.B.Tauris.

31. Kramer, M. (1996). The West's largest mosque. Middle East Quarterly, 3(3), 59-67.

32. Lewis, B. (2003). What went wrong? The clash between Islam and modernity in the Middle
East. Oxford University Press.

33. Halliday, F. (2002). Islam and the myth of confrontation: Religion and politics in the Middle
East. I.B.Tauris.

34. Abou El Fadl, K. (2001). The great theft: Wrestling Islam from the extremists. HarperOne.

35. Ayoob, M. (1991). The Third World Security Predic

19