Professional Documents
Culture Documents
doi: 10.1093/ndt/gfab030
Advance Access publication 9 February 2021
review
Alessia Regusci1, Sebastiano A.G. Lava2, Gregorio P. Milani3,4, Mario G. Bianchetti5, Giacomo D.
Simonetti1,5 and Federica Vanoni 1
C The Author(s) 2021. Published by Oxford University Press on behalf of the ERA-EDTA. All rights reserved.
V
KEY LEARNING POINTS
injury and chronic renal failure was defined according to The development of TIN and uveitis was considered con-
KDIGO guidelines [4, 5]. We excluded those cases in which comitant if the interval between their respective onset was
uveitis or interstitial nephritis was secondary to other condi- <3 weeks. If this information was not given, we retained the
tions and cases in which demographic data (age and sex) were author’s definition as provided in the text.
missing. If two reports described the same case, we considered
only the more detailed publication. The literature search and ar- Statistics
ticle selection were conducted independently by two authors The Cohen’s j coefficient was used to assess the agreement
(A.R. and F.V.) who separately evaluated each article for eligi- between investigators for study inclusion and exclusion. The
bility. Incongruent results were resolved by consensus. When results are summarized either as the median and interquartile
consensus could not be reached, a third senior researcher range (IQR) or absolute number and frequency, as appropriate.
(S.A.G.L.) adjudicated the decision. To investigate differences between paediatric and adult
cases, we separately considered subjects who were <18 and
18 years of age.
Data extraction and analysis Fisher’s exact test and the Kruskal–Wallis test (with the
Data were extracted independently by two authors (A.R. and Bonferroni test adjustment for multiple comparisons) were
F.V.) using standardized, piloted forms prepared in advance used to compare categorical and continuous data, respectively.
and collected into a dedicated database. The following data To identify potential risk factors for chronic kidney disease
were retained: age at diagnosis, sex, type and localization of uve- (CKD) development, we exclusively considered cases with a
itis, triggering factors, ocular symptoms (visual loss, blurred vi- follow-up of at least 6 months and reported data on circulating
sion, ocular pain or redness, photophobia), onset of uveitis with creatinine levels both at baseline and follow-up. Odds ratios
respect to TIN development, systemic symptoms or complica- (ORs) of CKD and corresponding 95% confidence intervals
tions (including fever, weight loss, fatigue and arterial hyperten- (CIs) from multiple logistic regression models were calculated
sion), treatment(s), length of follow-up and clinical outcome. In for the following variables: age at onset (continuous variable),
addition, the following laboratory values were considered: cre- sex (female versus male), detection of ANA/ANCA (presence
atinine, urea, C-reactive protein, erythrocyte sedimentation versus absence), uveitis localization (anterior versus other local-
rate, white blood cell count, haemoglobin, urinalysis, b2-micro- izations), occurrence of monolateral uveitis (versus bilateral
globin, gammaglobulin, C3, C4, antinuclear antibodies (ANAs), uveitis), temporal relationship between uveitis and renal in-
anti-neutrophil cytoplasmic antibodies (ANCAs) and renal volvement (concurrent versus ocular involvement as the first
biopsy. manifestation versus renal involvement as the first
RESULTS
Records screened after
Search results duplicates removed (N=567)
Treatments
A total of 522 patients received steroids as first-line therapy:
topical in 356 cases and systemic in 448 cases. A second-line
therapy was reported in 108 patients. Of these, 90 patients were
prescribed single or multiple immunosuppressive agents, in-
cluding methotrexate (n ¼ 32), mycophenolate (n ¼ 30), cyclo-
sporine (n ¼ 19), azathioprine (n ¼ 16), cyclophosphamide
(n ¼ 6), chlorambucil (n ¼ 5) and other drugs (n ¼ 17).
Eighteen (n ¼ 18) patients required haemodialysis. Eleven
(n ¼ 11) patients did not receive any therapy (Supplementary
data, Table S2). The need for second-line therapy did not ap-
pear to be associated with the development of CKD at follow-
up. In fact, of the 108 patients receiving second-line treatment,
only 13 (12%) developed CKD. Similarly, among 409 patients
not receiving second-line treatments, 82 (20%) further devel-
oped CKD (P ¼ 0.0686 versus patients not developing CKD).
Univariate analysis
TIN preceded uveitis more often in children (52%) com- FIGURE 2: (A) Fundus examination of the left eye in a 13-year-old
pared with adults (37%; P < 0.001) (Table 2). Ocular relapse oc- boy affected by TINU. The picture shows papilloedema and venous
curred more frequently in children (56%) compared with adults turgor. (B) Optical coherence tomography shows oedema of the
(45%; P ¼ 0.03). On the other hand, CKD (P < 0.001) was more nerve fibre with extension towards the fovea of the left eye of a
frequent among adults (37%) than children (11%). Acute kid- 13-year-old boy with detachment of the sensorineural retina at the
ney injury (P < 0.001) was slightly less frequent among children subfoveal site.
Characteristics N Values
Gender (male:female), n (%) 592 208 (35):384 (65)
Age (years), median (IQR) 592 17 (13–46)
Trigger(s) for TINUa, n (%) 352
None 223 (63)
Drugs 72 (21)
Infection 22 (6)
Toxic agent 23 (7)
More than one possible trigger 12 (3)
Uveitis, n (%) 592
Anterior 382 (65)
Posterior 13 (2.2)
Intermediate 29 (4.9)
Panuveitis 62 (10)
Not specified 106 (18)
(87%) than adults (98%). Children [n ¼ 4 (1.3%)] were less fre- DISCUSSION
quently (P ¼ 0.02) treated with dialysis than adults [n ¼ 14 According to the most recent systematic review on TINU syn-
(7.0%)]. No significant differences were detected with respect to drome, including ~600 cases, TINU syndrome is both a paedi-
uveitis characteristics, rate of renal relapse or triggering factors. atric and an adult disease. Children tend to have more ocular
Sex comparisons revealed that females (median 26, IQR ¼ relapses and are slightly less likely to develop acute kidney in-
14–49 years) were older than males (median 15, IQR ¼ 12.6– jury than adults. Adults more frequently develop CKD. Finally,
30 years) at the age of diagnosis (Table 3). No differences in the adult age and uveitis not being anterior (i.e. posterior uveitis or
characteristics of uveitis, time onset of nephritis with respect to panuveitis) (Figure 3) are associated with an increased risk of
uveitis, rate of acute and chronic renal failure or rate of developing CKD.
ocular and renal relapses were detected when comparing males This review confirms the known female predominance,
and females. which appears to be more striking in adult ages (55% females in
the paediatric age, 76% among adults). This finding is not sur-
prising. In fact, TINU syndrome is a multisystemic, presumably
autoimmune disorder. It is well known that autoimmune dis-
Multiple logistic regression analysis
eases occur more frequently in females. Oestrogens act as
Data from 254 subjects (138 studies) met the criteria for enhancers of humoral immunity and testosterone and proges-
multiple logistic regression analysis. In the final selected model, terone act as natural immunosuppressants [239]. Women have
age at onset [OR 1.07 (95% CI 1.04–1.10)] was associated with increased immune reactivity with higher immunoglobulin lev-
an increased risk of CKD development, whereas the develop- els and higher antibody production. This feature may also ex-
ment of (only) anterior uveitis [OR 0.06 (95% CI 0.01–0.31)] plain the increased frequency of autoantibodies (ANAs/
was associated with a decreased risk (Table 4). ANCAs) in females.
This analysis shows that adults develop kidney injury and Children seem to have a more severe course of uveitis with
CKD more frequently than children. These findings are consis- more frequent relapses. There is no clear pathophysiological ex-
tent with data reported by Legendre et al. [120] and Mackensen planation for the increased relapse and possibly chronic course
et al. [131]. Some authors suggest a high-risk correlation between of ocular disease in children. It is recognized that difficult and
changes in the first renal biopsy (such as tubular atrophy) and not optimal compliance with topical treatment in ocular dis-
permanent renal dysfunction [91]. We hypothesize that in adults eases, especially in adolescents, is frequent [240, 241]. On the
the kidneys are partially premorbid, depending on the lifestyle other hand, as previously discussed, children may not complain
and comorbidities (i.e. hypertension, hypercholesterolemia, over- about ocular symptoms, which could lead to a delay in diagno-
weight) with reduced functional reserve. Therefore, when a fur- sis [242] and therapy, eventually resulting in a more severe
ther insult occurs (such as TIN), kidneys are more severely course.
affected than in otherwise healthy children. However, at present Adult age is a potential risk factor for CKD development.
we do not have sufficient data to confirm this hypothesis. On the other hand, the presence of anterior uveitis alone was
This review confirmed that TIN often precedes uveitis, as less frequently associated with CKD. In contrast, Legendre et al.
noted in previous studies [2, 131, 181]. Interestingly, subgroup [120] and Mackensen et al. [131] reported that the courses of
analysis revealed that in children, uveitis is diagnosed more fre- uveitis and nephritis were not related. This discrepancy might
quently after TIN (Figure 3). This may be because uveitis is of- be explained by the small number of patients included in those
ten asymptomatic [91, 181] and children often do not complain studies. The present findings indeed suggest the need for the
about ocular symptoms, such as decreased vision. It is therefore closest follow-up for patients developing uveitis beyond the an-
not surprising that in children, ophthalmological investigations terior chamber who might also require a more aggressive treat-
are only performed after diagnosing nephritis, thereby unravel- ment. This hypothesis should be confirmed in well-designed
ling uveitis. prospective studies.