Microsoft Excel 16.

0 Answer Report
Worksheet: [ControllingAirPollutionCase5-2.xlsx]Sheet1
Report Created: 12/16/2023 10:00:27 AM
Result: Solver found a solution. All Constraints and optimality conditions are satisfied.
Solver Engine
Engine: Simplex LP
Solution Time: 0.016 Seconds.
Iterations: 8 Subproblems: 0
Solver Options
Max Time Unlimited, Iterations Unlimited, Precision 0.000001
Max Subproblems Unlimited, Max Integer Sols Unlimited, Integer Tolerance 1%, Assume NonNegative

Objective Cell (Min)

Cell Name Original Value Final Value
$D$21 TotalCostEmissionReduction 0 32.1546313304

Variable Cells
Cell Name Original Value Final Value
$D$19 EmissionReductionStrategyExtent TSB Furnaces 0 100%
$E$19 EmissionReductionStrategyExtent TSOH Furnaces 0 62%
$F$19 EmissionReductionStrategyExtent FB Furnaces 0 34%
$G$19 EmissionReductionStrategyExtent FOH Furnaces 0 100%
$H$19 EmissionReductionStrategyExtent BB Furnaces 0 5%
$I$19 EmissionReductionStrategyExtent BOH Furnaces 0 100%

Constraints
Cell Name Cell Value Formula
$K$10 Particulates ReductionAchieved 60 $K$10>=$J$10
$K$11 Sulfur oxides ReductionAchieved 150 $K$11>=$J$11
$K$12 Hydrocarbons ReductionAchieved 125 $K$12>=$J$12
$D$24 StrategyExtent TSB Furnaces 1 $D$24<=$D$25
$E$24 StrategyExtent TSOH Furnaces 0.62269745474 $E$24<=$E$25
$F$24 StrategyExtent FB Furnaces 0.34347940173 $F$24<=$F$25
$G$24 StrategyExtent FOH Furnaces 1 $G$24<=$G$25
$H$24 StrategyExtent BB Furnaces 0.04757281553 $H$24<=$H$25
$I$24 StrategyExtent BOH Furnaces 1 $I$24<=$I$25
me NonNegative

Integer
Contin
Contin
Contin
Contin
Contin
Contin

Status Slack
Binding 0
Binding 0
Binding 0
Binding 0
Not Binding 0.3773025453
Not Binding 0.6565205983
Binding 0
Not Binding 0.9524271845
Binding 0
Microsoft Excel 16.0 Sensitivity Report
Worksheet: [ControllingAirPollutionCase5-2.xlsx]Sheet1
Report Created: 12/16/2023 10:00:28 AM

Variable Cells
Final Reduced Objective
Cell Name Value Cost Coefficient
$D$19 EmissionReductionStrategyExtent TSB Furnaces 100% 0 8
$E$19 EmissionReductionStrategyExtent TSOH Furnaces 62% 0 10
$F$19 EmissionReductionStrategyExtent FB Furnaces 34% 0 7
$G$19 EmissionReductionStrategyExtent FOH Furnaces 100% 0 6
$H$19 EmissionReductionStrategyExtent BB Furnaces 5% 0 11
$I$19 EmissionReductionStrategyExtent BOH Furnaces 100% 0 9

Constraints
Final Shadow Constraint
Cell Name Value Price R.H. Side
$K$10 Particulates ReductionAchieved 60 0.1110469693 60
$K$11 Sulfur oxides ReductionAchieved 150 0.1268171084 150
$K$12 Hydrocarbons ReductionAchieved 125 0.0693256363 125
$D$24 StrategyExtent TSB Furnaces 1 -0.3362109682 1
$E$24 StrategyExtent TSOH Furnaces 0.6226974547 0 1
$F$24 StrategyExtent FB Furnaces 0.3434794017 0 1
$G$24 StrategyExtent FOH Furnaces 1 -1.8160850171 1
$H$24 StrategyExtent BB Furnaces 0.0475728155 0 1
$I$24 StrategyExtent BOH Furnaces 1 -0.0441616374 1
 Allowable Allowable
Increase Decrease
0.3362109682 1E+030
0.4294462873 0.6669616366
0.3816326531 2.0114599686
1.8160850171 1E+030
2.9752252252 0.0446383577
0.0441616374 1E+030

Allowable Allowable
Increase Decrease
14.297142857 7.48
20.453125 1.6896551724
2.0416666667 21.691956124
0.2462311558 0.7484774348
1E+030 0.3773025453
1E+030 0.6565205983
0.1106094808 1
1E+030 0.9524271845
0.0480863592 0.9627085378
Microsoft Excel 16.0 Answer Report
Worksheet: [ControllingAirPollutionCase5-2.xlsx]Sheet2
Report Created: 16-12-2023 10:52:00
Result: Solver found a solution. All Constraints and optimality conditions are satisfied.
Solver Engine
Engine: Simplex LP
Solution Time: 0.015 Seconds.
Iterations: 9 Subproblems: 0
Solver Options
Max Time Unlimited, Iterations Unlimited, Precision 0.000001, Use Automatic Scaling
Max Subproblems Unlimited, Max Integer Sols Unlimited, Integer Tolerance 1%, Assume NonNegative

Objective Cell (Min)

NONE

Variable Cells
Cell Name Original Value Final Value Integer

Constraints
Cell Name Cell Value Formula Status Slack
Microsoft Excel 16.0 Answer Report
Worksheet: [ControllingAirPollutionCase5-2.xlsx]Sheet1
Report Created: 17-12-2023 10:42:16
Result: Solver found a solution. All Constraints and optimality conditions are satisfied.
Solver Engine
Engine: Simplex LP
Solution Time: 0.031 Seconds.
Iterations: 11 Subproblems: 0
Solver Options
Max Time Unlimited, Iterations Unlimited, Precision 0.000001
Max Subproblems Unlimited, Max Integer Sols Unlimited, Integer Tolerance 1%, Assume NonNegative

Objective Cell (Min)

Cell Name Original Value Final Value
$D$21 TotalCostEmissionReduction 32.1546313304 32.1546313304

Variable Cells
Cell Name Original Value Final Value
$D$19 EmissionReductionStrategyExtent TSB Furnaces 100% 100%
$E$19 EmissionReductionStrategyExtent TSOH Furnaces 62% 62%
$F$19 EmissionReductionStrategyExtent FB Furnaces 34% 34%
$G$19 EmissionReductionStrategyExtent FOH Furnaces 100% 100%
$H$19 EmissionReductionStrategyExtent BB Furnaces 5% 5%
$I$19 EmissionReductionStrategyExtent BOH Furnaces 100% 100%

Constraints
Cell Name Cell Value Formula
$K$10 Particulates ReductionAchieved 60 $K$10>=$J$10
$K$11 Sulfur oxides ReductionAchieved 150 $K$11>=$J$11
$K$12 Hydrocarbons ReductionAchieved 125 $K$12>=$J$12
$D$19 EmissionReductionStrategyExtent TSB Furnaces 100% $D$19<=$D$25
$E$19 EmissionReductionStrategyExtent TSOH Furnaces 62% $E$19<=$E$25
$F$19 EmissionReductionStrategyExtent FB Furnaces 34% $F$19<=$F$25
$G$19 EmissionReductionStrategyExtent FOH Furnaces 100% $G$19<=$G$25
$H$19 EmissionReductionStrategyExtent BB Furnaces 5% $H$19<=$H$25
$I$19 EmissionReductionStrategyExtent BOH Furnaces 100% $I$19<=$I$25
me NonNegative

Integer
Contin
Contin
Contin
Contin
Contin
Contin

Status Slack
Binding 0
Binding 0
Binding 0
Binding 0
Not Binding 0.3773025453
Not Binding 0.6565205983
Binding 0
Not Binding 0.9524271845
Binding 0
Microsoft Excel 16.0 Sensitivity Report
Worksheet: [ControllingAirPollutionCase5-2.xlsx]Sheet1
Report Created: 17-12-2023 10:42:16

Variable Cells
Final Reduced Objective
Cell Name Value Cost Coefficient
$D$19 EmissionReductionStrategyExtent TSB Furnaces 1 -0.3362109682 8
$E$19 EmissionReductionStrategyExtent TSOH Furnaces 0.6226974547 0 10
$F$19 EmissionReductionStrategyExtent FB Furnaces 0.3434794017 0 7
$G$19 EmissionReductionStrategyExtent FOH Furnaces 1 -1.8160850171 6
$H$19 EmissionReductionStrategyExtent BB Furnaces 0.0475728155 0 11
$I$19 EmissionReductionStrategyExtent BOH Furnaces 1 -0.0441616374 9

Constraints
Final Shadow Constraint
Cell Name Value Price R.H. Side
$K$10 Particulates ReductionAchieved 60 0.1110469693 60
$K$11 Sulfur oxides ReductionAchieved 150 0.1268171084 150
$K$12 Hydrocarbons ReductionAchieved 125 0.0693256363 125
 Allowable Allowable
Increase Decrease
0.3362109682 1E+030
0.4294462873 0.6669616366
0.3816326531 2.0114599686
1.8160850171 1E+030
2.9752252252 0.0446383577
0.0441616374 1E+030

Allowable Allowable
Increase Decrease
14.297142857 7.48
20.453125 1.6896551724
2.0416666667 21.691956124
 Taller Smokestacks Filters
Blast Open-Hearth Blast
TSB Furnaces TSOH Furnaces FB Furnaces
Cost ($million) 8 10 7

Reduction in Emission (Maximum Feasible Use of Abatement M

Pollutant TSB Furnaces TSOH Furnaces FB Furnaces
Particulates 12 9 25
Sulfur oxides 35 42 18
Hydrocarbons 37 53 28

Taller Smokestacks Filters

Blast Open-Hearth Blast
TSB Furnaces TSOH Furnaces FB Furnaces
EmissionReductionStrategyExtent 100% 62% 34%

TotalCostEmissionReduction 32.15463133

TSB Furnaces TSOH Furnaces FB Furnaces

StrategyExtent 100% 62% 34%
UpperBound 100% 100% 100%
 Filters Better Fuels
Open-Hearth Blast Open-Hearth
FOH Furnaces BB Furnaces BOH Furnaces
6 11 9

Maximum Feasible Use of Abatement Method) (millions of lbs.)

FOH Furnaces BB Furnaces BOH Furnaces Min Reduction Rq ReductionAchieved
20 17 13 60 60
31 56 49 150 150
24 29 20 125 125

Filters Better Fuels

Open-Hearth Blast Open-Hearth
FOH Furnaces BB Furnaces BOH Furnaces
100% 5% 100%

FOH Furnaces BB Furnaces BOH Furnaces

100% 5% 100%
100% 100% 100%