Professional Documents
Culture Documents
First Adhyaya
First Pada
4. But that (i.e. the authoritativeness of Scripture with regard to Brahman) exists o
n account of the connection (of Scripture with the highest aim of man).
5. On account of seeing (i.e. thinking) that which is not founded on Scripture (i.e.
the Pradhana) is not (what is taught by the texts referring to the origination of the
world).
13. The Self consisting of Bliss (is the highest Self) on account of multiplication.
14. If, on account of its being a word denoting an effect, (anandamaya be said) not
(to denote the highest Self); (we say) no, on account of abundance.
16. And because that (Brahman) which is referred to in the mantra is declared (to be
the anandamaya).
19. And on account of desire, there is no regard to what is inferred (i.e. matter).
20. And Scripture teaches the joining of this (i.e. the individual soul) with that (i.
e. bliss) in that (i.e. the anandamaya).
21. The one within (the sun and the eye); on account of his qualities being declared.
22. And on account of the declaration of difference (the highest Self is) other (than
the individual souls of the sun, &c.).
26. If it be objected that (Brahman is) not (denoted) on account of the metre being d
enoted; (we reply) not so, because thus the direction of the mind (on Brahman) is dec
lared; for thus it is seen.
27. And thus also, because (thus only) the designation of the beings, and so on, bein
g the (four) feet is possible.
28. If it be said that (Brahman is) not (recognised) on account of the difference of
designation; (we say) not so, on account of there being no contradiction in either (d
esignation).
30. If it be said that (Brahman is) not (denoted) on account of the speaker denoting
himself; (we say, not so), because the multitude of connexions with the inner Self (i
s possible only) in that (speaker if viewed as Brahman).
31. The instruction (given by Indra about himself) (is possible) through insight base
d on Scripture, as in the case of Vamadeva.
Second Pada
2. And because the qualities meant to be stated are possible (in Brahman).
4. And because there is (separate) denotation of the object and the agent.
7. Should it be said that (the passage does) not (refer to Brahman) on account of the
smallness of the abode, and on account of the denotation of that (viz. minuteness of
the being meditated on); we say no, because (Brahman) has thus to be meditated upon,
and because (in the same passage) it is said to be like ether.
8. Should it be said that there is attainment of fruition (of pleasure and pain); we
reply, not so, on account of difference.
9. The eater (is the highest Self) on account of there being taken all that is movabl
e and immovable.
11. The 'two entered into the cave' are the two Selfs; on account of this being seen.
13. (The Person) within the eye (is the highest Self) on account of suitability.
15. And on account of the text referring only to what is characterised by pleasure.
17. And on account of the statement of the way of him who has heard the Upanishads.
19. The internal Ruler (referred to) in the clauses with respect to the gods, with re
spect to the worlds, &c. (is the highest Self), because the attributes of that are de
signated.
20. And not that which Smriti assumes, on account of the declaration of qualities not
belonging to that; nor the embodied one.
21. For both also speak of it as something different.
22. That which possesses the qualities of invisibility, &c., on account of the declar
ation of attributes.
23. Not the two others, on account of distinction and statement of difference.
25. Vaisvanara (is the highest Self), on account of the distinctions qualifying the c
ommon term.
27. Should it be said that it is not so, on account of the word, &c., and on account
of the abiding within; we say, no; on account of meditation being taught thus, on acc
ount of impossibility; and because they read of him as person.
28. For the same reasons not the divinity and the element.
29. Gaimini thinks that there is no objection to (the word 'Agni') directly (denoting
the highest Self).
32. On account of imaginative identification, thus Gaimini thinks; for thus the text
declares.
33. Moreover, they record him in that.
Third Pada
1. The abode of heaven, earth, &c. (is the highest Self), on account of terms which a
re its own.
2. And on account of its being declared that to which the released have to resort.
3. Not that which is inferred, on account of the absence of terms denoting it, and (s
o also not) the bearer of the Pranas (i. e. the individual soul).
7. The bhuman (is the highest Self), as the instruction about it is additional to tha
t about serenity.
9. The Imperishable (is Brahman), on account of its supporting that which is the end
of ether.
12. On account of his being designated as the object of seeing, he (i.e. the highest
Self) (is that object).
13. The small (ether) (is Brahman), on account of the subsequent (arguments).
14. On account of the going and of the word; for thus it is seen; and (there is) an i
nferential sign.
15. And on account of there being observed in that (small ether), supporting which is
a greatness of that (i. e. Brahman).
17. If it be said that on account of reference to the other one he is meant; we say n
o, on account of impossibility.
18. Should it be said that from a subsequent passage (it appears that the individual
Soul is meant); rather (the soul) in so far as its true nature has become manifest.
20. If it be said, owing to the scriptural declaration of smallness; that has been ex
plained.
25. Also beings above them (i.e. men), Badarayana thinks, on account of possibility.
26. If it be said that there results a contradiction to work; we deny this, on accoun
t of the observation of the assumption of several (bodies).
27. If it be said (that a contradiction will result) with regard to words; we say no,
since beings originate from them (as appears) from perception and inference.
28. And for this very reason eternity (of the Veda).
29. And on account of the equality of names and forms there is no contradiction, even
in the renovation (of the world); as appears from--Sruti and Smriti.
30. On account of the impossibility (of qualification for the madhuvidya, &c.) (Gaimi
ni maintains the non-qualification (of gods, &c.).
31. And on account of (meditating on the part of the gods) being in the Light.
33. (That) grief of him (arose), this is intimated by his (Ganasruti's) resorting to
him (Raikva) on hearing a disrespectful speech about himself.
37. And on account of the procedure, on the ascertainment of the non-being of that.
38. And on account of the prohibition of hearing, studying, and performance of (Vedi
c) matter.
42. The ether, on account of the designation of something different, and so on.
Fourth Pada
1. If it be said that some (mention) that which rests on Inference; we deny this beca
use (the form) refers to what is contained in the simile of the body; and (this the t
ext) shows.
2. But the subtle (body), on account of its capability.
3. (Matter in its subtle state) subserves an end, on account of its dependence on him
(viz. the Supreme Person).
5. Should it be said that (the text) declares (it); we say, not so; for the intellige
nt Self (is meant), on account of subject-matter.
9. But she begins with light; for thus some read in their text.
10. And on account of the teaching of formation (i.e. creation) there is no contradic
tion; as in the case of the honey.
11. Not from the mention of the number even, on account of the diversity and of the e
xcess.
12. The breath, and so on, on the ground of the complementary passage.
17. Should it be said that this is not so on account of the inferential marks of the
individual soul and the chief vital air; we reply that this has been explained before.
18. But Gaimini thinks that it has another purport, on account of the question and an
swer; and thus some also.
20. (It is) a mark indicating that the promissory statement is proved; thus smarathy
a thinks.
21. Because (the soul) when it will depart is such; thus Audulomi thinks.
22. On account of (Brahman's) abiding (within the individual soul); thus Kasakritsna
(holds).
23. (Brahman is) the material cause on account of this not being in conflict with the
promissory statements and the illustrative instances.
Second Adhyaya
First Pada.
1. If it be said that there would result the fault of there being no room for (certai
n) Smritis: (we reply) 'no,' because there would result the fault of want of room for
other Smritis.
4. Not, on account of the difference of character of that; and its being such (appear
s) from Scripture.
6. But it is seen.
7. If it be said that (the effect is) non-existing; we say no, there being a mere den
ial.
12. Should it be said that inference is to be carried on in a different way; (we repl
y that) thus also it follows that (the objection raised) is not got rid of.
13. Thereby also the remaining (theories) which are not comprised (within the Veda) a
re explained.
14. If it be said that from (Brahman) becoming an enjoyer, there follows non-distinct
ion (of Brahman and the individual soul); we reply--it may be as in ordinary life.
15. The non-difference (of the world) from that (viz. Brahman) follows from what begi
ns with the word arambhana.
16. And because (the cause) is perceived in the existence of the effect.
21. From the designation of the 'other' (as non-different from Brahman) there result
(Brahman's) not creating what is beneficial, and other imperfections.
23. And as in the analogous case of stones and the like, there is impossibility of th
at.
24. Should it be said that (it is) not, on account of the observation of employment;
we say, not so; for as in the case of milk.
25. And as in the case of the gods and so on, in (their) world.
26. Or the consequence of the entire (Brahman entering into the effect), and stultifi
cation of (Brahman's) being devoid of parts.
27. But on account of Scripture; (Brahman's possession of various powers) being found
ed upon the word.
28. And thus in the Self; for (there are) manifold (powers).
29. And on account of the defects of his view also.
30. And (the divinity is) endowed with all powers, because that is seen.
31. Not, on account of the absence of organs; this has been explained (before).
32. (Brahman is) not (the cause); on account of (the world) having the nature of what
depends on a motive.
34. Not inequality and cruelty, on account of there being regard; for so (Scripture)
declares.
35. If it be said 'not so, on account of non-distinction of deeds'; we say, 'not so,
on account of beginninglessness'; this is reasonable, and it is also observed.
36. And because all the attributes are proved (to be present in Brahman).
Second Pada
3. And because from the independence (of the Pradhana) there would follow the non-exi
stence of what is different (from creation, i.e. of the pralaya condition).
4. Nor like grass and so on; because (milk) does not exist elsewhere.
5. And if you say--as the man and the stone; thus also.
7. And if another inference be made (the result remains unchanged), on account of (th
e Pradhana) being destitute of the power of a knowing subject.
10. Or in the same way as the big and long from the short and the atomic.
11. On both assumptions also there is no motion, and thence non-being (of the origina
tion of the world).
12. And because owing to the acknowledgment of samavaya, there results a regressus in
infinitum from equality.
14. And on account of (the atoms) having colour and so on, the reverse (takes place);
as it is observed.
17. Even on the aggregate with its two causes, there is non-establishment of that.
19. And on account of the cessation of the preceding one on the origination of the su
bsequent one.
20. There not being (a cause), there results contradiction of the admitted principle;
otherwise simultaneousness.
23. And in the case of space also, on account of there being no difference.
26. And thus there would be accomplishment on the part of non-active people also.
34. Nor also is there non-contradiction from paryaya; on account of change, and so on.
35. And on account of the endurance of the final (size), and the (resulting) permanen
cy of both; there is no difference.
38. If you say, as in the case of the organs; we deny this, on account of enjoyment a
nd so on.
41. And there is not (origination) of the instrument from the agent.
42. Or, if they are of the nature of that which is knowledge and so on, there is no c
ontradiction to that (i.e. the Bhagavata doctrine).
Third Pada
4. There may be (a double sense) of the one (word), as in the case of the word 'Brahm
an.'
7. But the division (origination) extends over all effects; as in ordinary life.
13. Earth on account of the subject-matter, the colour, and other texts.
14. But he; from the inferential mark supplied by their reflection.
15. But the order of succession (which is stated) in reverse order (of the true one)
is possible, (only if the origination of all effects is) thence (i.e. from Brahman).
16. If it be said that knowledge and mind (which are mentioned) between (breath and t
he elements) (are stated) in order of succession, owing to an inferential mark of thi
s; we say, not so, on account of non-difference.
17. But that which abides in the things movable and immovable, i.e. the terms denotin
g those things, are non-secondary (i.e. of primary denotative power, viz. with regard
to Brahman); since (their denotative power) is effected by the being of that (i.e. Br
ahman).
18. Not the Self, on account of scriptural statement, and on account of the eternity
(which results) from them.
19. For this very reason (the individual soul is) a knower.
22. If it be said that (the soul) is not atomic, on account of scriptural statement o
f (what is) not that; we say no, on account of the other one being the topic.
25. Should it be said (that this is not so) on account of specialisation of abode; we
say no, on account of the acknowledgment (of a place of the Self), viz. in the heart.
27. There is distinction as in the case of smell; and thus Scripture declares.
29. But (the Self) is designated as that because it has that quality (viz. knowledge)
for its essential quality; as in the case of the intelligent (prag a) Self.
30. And there is no objection, since (the quality of knowledge) exists wherever the S
elf is; this being observed.
31. Since there may be manifestation of that which exists; as in the case of virile p
ower and so on.
35. And on account of the designation (of the Self as the agent) in actions. If not s
o, there would be change of grammatical expression.
36. (There would be) absence of definite rule, as in the case of consciousness.
41. But with a view to the efforts made (the Lord makes the soul act) on account of t
he (thus resulting) non-meaninglessness of injunctions and prohibitions and the rest.
42. (The soul is) a part, on account of the declarations of difference and otherwise;
some also record (that Brahman is of) the nature of slaves, fishermen, and so on.
47. Permission and exclusion (result) from connexion with a body; as in the case of l
ight and so on.
52. Should it be said (that that is possible) owing to the difference of place; we de
ny this, on account of (all upadhis) being within (all places).
Fourth Pada
4. (They are seven) on account of the going of the seven and of specification.
5. But the hands and so on also; (since they assist the soul) abiding (in the body).
Hence (it is) not so.
9. But like the eye and the rest, on account of being taught with them, and for other
reasons.
10. And there is no objection on account of its not having an activity (karana); for
(Scripture) thus declares.
13. But the rule (over the pranas) on the part of Fire and the rest, together with hi
m to whom the prana belong (i.e. the soul), is owing to the thinking of that (viz. th
e highest Self); on account of scriptural statement.
15. They, with the exception of the best, are organs, on account of being so designat
ed.
16. On account of scriptural statement of difference, and on account of difference of
characteristics.
17. But the making of names and forms (belongs) to him who renders tripartite, on acc
ount of scriptural teaching.
18. Flesh is of earthy nature; in the case of the two others also according to the te
xt.
19. But on account of their distinctive nature there is that designation, that design
ation.
Third Adhyaya
First Pada
1. In obtaining another of that, it goes enveloped, (as appears) from question and ex
planation.
7. Or it is metaphorical, on account of their not knowing the Self. For thus Scriptur
e declares.
8. On the passing away of the works, with a remainder, according to Scripture and Smr
iti; as it went and not so.
9. 'On account of conduct'; not so, since (karana) connotes works; thus Karshnagini t
hinks.
11. But only good and evil works, thus Badari thinks.
12. Of those also who do not perform sacrifices (the ascent) is declared by Scripture.
13. But of the others having enjoyed in Samyamana, there is ascent and descent; as su
ch a course is declared.
17. But, of knowledge and work--as these are the leading topics.
18. Not in the case of the third (place), as it is thus perceived.
21. The third term includes that which springs from heat.
22. There is entering into similarity of being with those, there being a reason.
24. Into (plants) animated by other souls, because the statement is as in the previou
s cases.
26. After that conjunction with him who performs the act of generation.
Second Pada
1. In the intermediate sphere the creation (is effected by the soul); for (Scripture)
says (so).
2. And some (state the soul to be) the shaper; and sons, and so on.
3. But it is mere Maya; on account of the true nature (of the soul) not being fully m
anifested.
4. But owing to the wish of the highest it is hidden; for from that are its bondage a
nd the opposite state.
7. The absence of that takes place in the nadis and in the Self, according to scriptu
ral statement.
10. In the swooning person there is half-combination; this being the remaining (hypot
hesis).
11. Not on account of place even (is there any imperfection) of the Highest; for ever
ywhere (it is described) as having twofold characteristics.
12. Should it be said 'on account of difference'; not so, because with reference to e
ach the text says what is not that.
15. And in the same way as (a Brahman) consisting of light; (the texts thus) not bein
g devoid of meaning.
18. For this very reason comparisons, such as reflected images of the sun and the lik
e.
20. The participation (on Brahman's part) in increase and decrease, due to its abidin
g within (is denied); on account of the appropriateness of both (comparisons), and be
cause thus it is seen.
21. For the text denies the previously declared so-muchness; and declares more than t
hat.
24. And there is non-difference (of the intention of Brahman's distinguishing attribu
tes), as in the case of light; and the light (is) intuited as constituting Brahman's
essential nature by repetition of the practice (of meditation).
25. Hence (Brahman is distinguished) by what is infinite; for thus the characteristic
s (hold good).
26. But on account of twofold designation, as the snake and its coils.
27. Or else like light and its abode, both being fire.
30. (There is something) higher than that; on account of the designations of bridge,
measure, connexion, and difference.
36. The omnipresence (possessed) by that, (understood) from the declaration of extent.
39. For the same reasons Gaimini (thinks it to be) religious action.
40. But the former, Badarayana (thinks), on account of the designation (of deities) a
s the cause.
Third Pada
1. What is understood from all the Vedanta-texts (is one), on account of the non-diff
erence of injunction and the rest.
2. If it be said (that the vidyas are not one) on account of difference, we deny this,
since even in one (vidya there may be repetition).
3. For (the sirovrata) concerns the mode of the study of the Veda; also on account of
(that rite) being a heading in the samakara; and the restriction is like that of the
libations.
5. (Meditation) thus being equal, there is combination (of gunas); on account of non-
difference of purport in the case of what subserves injunction.
6. If it be said that there is difference on account of the text; we say no; on accou
nt of non-difference.
11. Bliss and other qualities, as belonging to the subject of the qualities.
12. Such qualities as having joy for its head, and so on, are not established, for if
there were difference (of members) there would be increase and decrease.
16. There is reference to the Self, as in other places; on account of the subsequent
passage.
18. The new (thing is enjoined); on account of the statement of what has to be done.
23. And for the same reason the holding together and the pervading the sky.
24. And although (they both be) meditations on man; on account of others not being re
corded.
26. But in the case of the getting rid of (it has to be combined with the obtaining),
as it is supplementary to statements of obtaining; as in the case of the kusas, the m
etres, the praise, and the singing. This has been explained.
27. At departing; there being nothing to be reached. For thus others (also declare).
29. There is meaning of the soul's going (only) on the twofold hypothesis; for otherw
ise there is contradiction.
30. (That assumption) is justified; on account of the perception of things which are
marks of that; as in ordinary experience.
31. Of those who have a certain office there is subsistence (of their works) as long
as the office lasts.
32. There is no restriction (since) all (have to go on that path). (Thus) there is no
n-contradiction of sacred text and Smriti.
33. But the conceptions of the Imperishable are to be comprised (in all meditations).
There being equality (of the Brahman to be meditated on) and (those conceptions) exis
ting (in Brahman); as in the case of what belongs to the upasad. This has been explai
ned.
35. Should it be said that (the former reply refers) to that Self to which the aggreg
ate of material things belongs (since) otherwise the difference (of the two replies)
could not be accounted for; we say--no; as in the case of instruction.
36. There is interchange (of ideas), for the texts distinguish; as in other cases.
37. For one and the same (highest divinity), called the 'truly being,' and so on (is
the subject of that meditation).
38. Wishes and the rest, here and there; (as is known from the abode, and so on).
40. In the case of him who has approached (Brahman); just on that account, this being
declared by the text.
43. On account of the plurality of indicatory marks; for that (proof) is stronger. Th
is also is declared (in the Purva Mimamsa).
44. There is option with regard to what precedes (i.e. the altar made of bricks) on a
ccount of subject-matter, and hence there is action; as in the case of the manasa cup.
47. And on account of the greater strength of direct statement, and so on, there is n
o refutation.
48. On account of connexions and the rest, as in the case of the separateness of othe
r cognitions. And this is seen (elsewhere also); as declared (in the Purva Mimamsa).
49. Not so, on account of this being observed on account of similarity also; as in th
e case of Death; for (the person in yonder orb) does not occupy the worlds (of Death).
50. And by a subsequent (Brahmana) also the 'being of such a kind' of the word (is pr
oved). But the connexion is on account of plurality.
52. But this is not so, (but rather) difference; since it is of the being of that; as
in the case of intuition.
53. But those (meditations) which are connected with members (of sacrifices) are not
(restricted) to (particular) sakhas, but rather (belong) to all sakhas.
55. There is pre-eminence of plenitude, as in the case of the sacrifice; for thus Scr
ipture shows.
56. (The meditations are) separate, on account of the difference of words, and so on.
58. But meditations aiming at objects of desire may, according to one's liking, be cu
mulated or not; on account of the absence of the former reason.
62. And on account of the declaration of a quality being common (to all the Vedas).
63. Rather not, as the text does not declare their going together.
1. The benefit to man results from thence, on account of scriptural statement; thus B
adarayana thinks.
8. But on account of the teaching of the different one, Badarayana's (view is valid);
as this is seen.
18. A reference (only) Gaimini (holds them to be), on account of absence of injunctio
n; for (Scripture) forbids.
21. If it be said that they are mere glorification, on account of their reference; no
t so, on account of the newness.
23. Should it be said that (the stories told in the Upanishads) are for the purpose o
f the Pariplava; not so, since (certain stories) are specified.
24. This follows also from the textual connexion (of those stories with injunctions).
25. For this very reason there is no need of the lighting of the fire and so on.
26. And there is need of all (works), on account of the scriptural statement of sacri
fices and the rest; as in the case of the horse.
27. But all the same he must be possessed of calmness, subjection of the senses, &c.,
since those are enjoined as auxiliaries to that, and must necessarily be accomplished.
28. And there is permission of all food in the case of danger of life; on account of
this being seen.
32. The works of the asramas also, on account of their being enjoined.
34. In any case they are the same, on account of twofold inferential signs.
38. And there is the promotion (of knowledge) through special acts (of duty).
39. But better than that is the other also on account of an inferential mark.
40. But of him who has become that there is no becoming not that, according to Gaimin
i also, on account of (Scripture) restraining from the absence of the forms of that.
41. Nor the (expiatory performance) described in the chapter treating of qualificatio
n; that being impossible on account of the Smriti referring to such lapse.
42. A minor one, thus some; (and hence they hold) the existence (of expiation), as in
the case of eating. This has been explained.
43. But in either case (such men) stand outside; on account of Smriti and custom.
44. By the Lord (of the sacrifice), since Scripture declares a fruit--thus treya thi
nks.
45. (They are) the priest's work, Audulomi thinks; since for that he is engaged.
46. There is injunction of other auxiliary means for him who is such, as in the case
of injunction and so on; (the term mauna denoting) according to an alternative meanin
g a third something.
47. But on account of the existence (of knowledge) in all, there is winding up with t
he householder.
48. On account of the others also being taught, in the same way as the condition of t
he Muni.
50. What belongs to this world, there being no obstruction at hand; as this is seen.
51. In the same way there is non-determination with regard to what has Release for it
s result; that condition being ascertained, that condition being ascertained.
Fourth Adhyaya
First Pada
1. Repetition, on account of the text teaching (what has to be done more than once).
3. But as the Self; this (the ancient Devotees) acknowledge (since the texts) make (t
hem) apprehend (in that way).
4. Not in the symbol; for (the symbol) is not that one (i.e. the Self of the Devotee).
6. And the ideas of ditya and the rest on the member; on account of this being ratio
nal.
7. Sitting; on account of possibility.
11. Where concentration of mind (is possible), there; on account of there being no di
fference.
13. On the attainment of this, there result the non-clinging and the destruction of l
ater and earlier sins; this being declared.
15. But only those former works the effects of which have not yet begun; on account o
f that being the term.
16. But the Agnihotra and the rest, (because they tend) to that effect only; this bei
ng seen.
17. According to some (a class of good works) other than these, of both kinds.
Second Pada
1. Speech with mind, on account of this being seen and of scriptural statement.
4. That (is united) with the ruler, on account of the going to it, and so on.
7. And it is common up to the beginning of the way; and the immortality (is that whic
h is obtained), without having burned.
8. Since, up to the union with that (i.e. Brahman) the texts describe the Samsara sta
te.
9. And the subtle (body persists), on account of a means of knowledge, it being thus
observed (in Scripture).
11. And to that very (subtle body) (there belongs) the warmth, this only being reason
able.
12. If it be said that on account of the denial (it is not so); we deny this. From th
e embodied soul; for (that one is) clear, according to some. 13. Smriti also declares
this.
16. A lighting up of the point of the abode of that; having the door illuminated by t
hat (the soul), owing to the power of its knowledge and the application of remembranc
e of the way which is an element of that (viz. of knowledge), being assisted by him w
ho abides within the heart, (passes out) by way of the hundred and first artery.
18. Should it be said, not in the night; we say, no; because the connexion persists a
s long as the body does. Scripture also declares this.
19. For the same reason also during the southern progress of the sun.
20. And those two (paths) are, with a view to the Yogins, mentioned as to be remember
ed.
Third Pada
5. From thence by him only who belongs to lightning, the text stating that.
6. (Him who meditates on) the effected Brahman, (thus opines) Badari; because for him
going is possible.
9. On the passing away of the effected (world of Brahma), together with its ruler, (t
he souls go) to what is higher than that; on account of scriptural declaration.
14. Those not depending on symbols he leads, thus Badarayana thinks; there being a de
fect in both cases; and he whose thought is that.
15. And Scripture declares the difference.
Fourth Pada
1. (On the soul's) having approached (the highest light) there is manifestation; (as
we infer) from the word 'own.'
6. In the sole nature of intelligence; as that is its Self. Thus Audulomi thinks.
7. Thus also, on account of existence of the former qualities (as proved) by suggesti
on, Badarayana holds absence of contradiction.
12. For this reason Badarayana (holds him to be) of both kinds; as in the case of the
twelve days' sacrifice.
13. In the absence of a body, as in the state of dream; that being possible.
15. The entering is as in the case of a lamp; for thus Scripture declares.
16. It refers either to dreamless sleep or to union (sampatti); for this is manifeste
d.
18. If it be said that this is not so, on account of direct teaching; we reply not so,
on account of the texts declaring that which abides within the spheres of those entr
usted with special functions.
19. That which is not within change; for thus Scripture declares the abiding (of the
soul).