Name : john louis kho

Nim : 102223032

Cristiano Ronaldo is a Portuguese professional footballer born on February 5, 1985. He

plays as a forward and captains Al Nassr in the Saudi Pro League and the Portugal national team.
Regarded as one of the greatest players, Ronaldo has won numerous awards, including five
Ballon d'Ors, three UEFA Best Player in Europe titles, and four European Golden Shoes. He has
a successful career, winning 34 trophies, including league titles, UEFA Champions Leagues, and
international championships. Despite his achievements, opinions about Ronaldo's status as the
greatest of all time (GOAT) are debated. Some argue that he should be included among the
football legends, while others highlight perceived shortcomings, such as a focus on individual
achievements over team contributions. In a recent interview, Ronaldo discussed his time at
Manchester United and raised concerns about the club's progress. He criticized the Glazer
ownership and expressed frustration about not being used as a substitute. The interview stirred
controversy, with opinions divided on Ronaldo's statements and motivations. While Ronaldo is
acknowledged for his prolific goal-scoring and individual accomplishments, some critics point
out perceived selfishness and controversies. However, his impact on the field remains
undeniable, and he continues to be a central figure in the football world. After reading this
article, I think :
A. I agree about Ronaldo's status as the greatest of all time (GOAT) are debated.
B. I disagree about He criticized the Glazer ownership and expressed frustration about not being
used as a substitute.
C. I agree about his impact on the field remains undeniable, and he continues to be a central
figure in the football world.

I agree about Ronaldo's status as the greatest of all time (GOAT) are debated. Because,
Playing Style Comparison: Football fans often debate the playing styles of different eras and how
they impact a player's effectiveness. Ronaldo's powerful, goal-scoring approach is contrasted
with the dribbling finesse and playmaking skills of players like Lionel Messi or Diego
Maradona, leading to subjective assessments of what makes a player the GOAT. Team
Contribution vs. Individual Brilliance: While Ronaldo has consistently delivered outstanding
individual performances, some critics argue that his focus on personal achievements may
overshadow contributions to team dynamics. Comparisons are drawn with players who are seen
as catalysts for their team's success, influencing the overall style of play. Versatility and
Adaptability: GOAT discussions often consider a player's versatility and adaptability across
different positions and tactical setups. Ronaldo's evolution from a winger to a central striker
demonstrates versatility, but debates arise on whether this adaptation is comparable to the diverse
skill sets of other football legends. International Success: The success of a player's national team
is a crucial aspect of the GOAT debate. Ronaldo has led Portugal to triumphs in Euro 2016 and
the UEFA Nations League, but the argument is made that other players have achieved more
significant success on the international stage. Rivalries and Comparisons: Ronaldo's career
coincides with Lionel Messi's, leading to constant comparisons between the two. The Messi vs.
Ronaldo debate has divided football enthusiasts, and opinions on who deserves the GOAT title
are often influenced by individual preferences for playing styles and personalities. In essence, the
debate around Cristiano Ronaldo's GOAT status is multifaceted, involving considerations of
playing style, team dynamics, versatility, international success, personality, rivalries, and club
loyalty. Each factor contributes to the subjective nature of the discussion and allows room for
diverse opinions among.
I disagree about He criticized the Glazer ownership and expressed frustration about not
being used as a substitute. Because, Ownership Critique: While the Glazer ownership at
Manchester United has faced widespread criticism for financial decisions and lack of investment
in the squad, some may argue that vocalizing these concerns, especially during a period of
transition or rebuilding, may not align with the traditional role of a player. Disagreement may
stem from the belief that players should focus on their on-field contributions rather than publicly
addressing ownership matters. Team-first Mentality: Some football enthusiasts prioritize a team-
first mentality over individual preferences. Disagreeing with Ronaldo's frustration could be
rooted in the belief that a player should prioritize the collective success of the team and accept
managerial decisions, even if it means not being utilized in certain situations. Emphasizing team
dynamics and unity may lead to differing opinions on how players should handle their roles
within the squad. Managerial Authority: Disagreement could also arise from a perspective that
values the authority and decision-making autonomy of the manager. In football, managers are
responsible for tactical choices, including substitutions, and players are expected to respect and
adhere to their decisions. Expressing frustration publicly may be perceived as challenging the
manager's authority, which some may find inappropriate. Individual vs. Collective Success: The
disagreement could stem from a belief that individual concerns, such as frustration over
substitution decisions, should be secondary to the team's overall success. In a team sport like
football, some argue that prioritizing individual preferences over collective goals may not align
with the ethos of the sport. Timing and Public Expression: Disagreeing with Ronaldo's critique
might involve considering the timing and manner of expressing concerns. Some fans may feel
that addressing ownership and substitution issues publicly, especially during a challenging period
for the team, could potentially disrupt team morale and create unnecessary distractions. It's
essential to note that perspectives on player behavior, ownership criticism, and expressions of
frustration can vary widely among football fans, and disagreement with Ronaldo's stance may be
rooted in different values and priorities within the sport.
I agree about his impact on the field remains undeniable, and he continues to be a central
figure in the football world. Consistent Goal-scoring Prowess: Ronaldo's remarkable ability to
consistently score goals at the highest level of competition is a primary factor. His goal-scoring
record, spanning different clubs and leagues, showcases an extraordinary level of skill, precision,
and athleticism. Agreeing with his impact on the field may stem from a deep appreciation for his
goal-scoring prowess, which has been a consistent feature throughout his career. Versatility and
Adaptability: Ronaldo's versatility to adapt to different playing styles, positions, and roles within
a team is another reason for agreement. His ability to excel as a winger, forward, or central
striker demonstrates not only his individual skills but also his flexibility to contribute effectively
in various tactical setups. Recognizing this adaptability can contribute to the acknowledgment of
his impact on the field. Leadership and Experience: Agreeing with Ronaldo's impact may be
influenced by his leadership qualities and vast experience. As a seasoned professional, he often
takes on leadership roles both on and off the pitch. His experience in high-stakes situations, such
as Champions League finals and international tournaments, adds a valuable dimension to his
impact on the field, making him a central figure in influencing team dynamics. Global
Recognition and Marketability: Ronaldo's global recognition and marketability extend beyond
his on-field performance. His popularity and influence on a global scale, both in the football
community and beyond, contribute to his status as a central figure. Agreeing with his impact may
involve acknowledging the role he plays in promoting the sport worldwide and attracting a
diverse fan base. Record-breaking Achievements: Ronaldo's numerous record-breaking
achievements, including multiple Ballon d'Or awards, European Golden Shoes, and records in
various competitions, provide tangible evidence of his excellence. Agreeing with his impact on
the field often involves recognizing these achievements as a testament to his unparalleled skill
and dedication. Entertainment Value: Ronaldo's playing style, flair, and ability to deliver
spectacular moments contribute to the entertainment value he brings to the sport. Fans who agree
with his impact may appreciate the excitement and spectacle he adds to football matches, making
him a captivating figure for audiences worldwide. Ultimately, agreeing with Cristiano Ronaldo's
impact on the field is often grounded in a holistic appreciation for his footballing abilities,
adaptability, leadership, and the broader influence he wields in the football world.
Counterargument, Cristiano Ronaldo's success is primarily due to his physical attributes,
such as speed, strength, and athleticism, rather than technical skill or football intelligence. Critics
may argue that his reliance on physical prowess sets him apart from players who excel in terms
of intricate ball control, playmaking, and tactical understanding.
Refutations, Technical Skill Evolution: Counteracting the claim that Ronaldo relies solely
on physical attributes, one could argue that his technical skills have evolved significantly over
the years. From his early days at Sporting Lisbon to his current stage in his career, Ronaldo has
demonstrated improved ball control, dribbling, and finesse, showcasing a commitment to
refining his technical abilities. Adaptability to Different Positions: Critics might contend that
Ronaldo's success is position-specific, particularly as a forward, and that he may struggle in more
nuanced roles. A counter-refutation could point out his successful transition from a winger to a
central striker, demonstrating versatility and adaptability. This adaptability underscores a broader
football intelligence beyond physical attributes. Strategic Play and Goal Scoring Awareness:
Some critics argue that Ronaldo's style is more about individual brilliance than contributing
strategically to team play. However, one can counter this by highlighting his exceptional goal-
scoring awareness, off-the-ball movement, and positioning. These aspects showcase a deep
understanding of the game and an ability to contribute tactically to the team's success. Consistent
High-Level Performance: Skeptics may suggest that Ronaldo's career longevity is a result of
physical fitness rather than sustained skill. A counter-refutation could emphasize that
maintaining peak physical condition over such an extended period requires not just athleticism
but also a disciplined and professional approach to training and overall well-being. Leadership
and Team Dynamics: Some critics may argue that Ronaldo's assertive personality disrupts team
dynamics. A counter-argument could be made by highlighting instances where he has played
crucial leadership roles, inspiring teammates, and contributing positively to team cohesion.
Leadership qualities, when channelized effectively, can enhance team performance. International
Success and Big-Match Performances: Critics might downplay Ronaldo's international success
by emphasizing team contributions in those victories. A refutation could underline his role as a
talismanic figure for Portugal, especially in crucial moments and big-match scenarios. The
ability to deliver in high-pressure situations is a testament to his mental strength and skill under
various circumstances.
In conclusion, counterarguments against Cristiano Ronaldo often focus on specific aspects of his
playing style or personality. However, refutations can highlight his evolution as a player,
technical proficiency, adaptability, strategic contributions, consistent high-level performance,
positive leadership, and the ability to excel in crucial moments. The comprehensive evaluation of
his career and skills helps provide a more nuanced understanding of his footballing greatness.
Considering the multifaceted nature of the debate surrounding Cristiano Ronaldo, it is
evident that opinions on his standing as the greatest of all time (GOAT) vary widely. The debate
involves considerations of playing style, team dynamics, versatility, international success,
personality, rivalries, and club loyalty. Some argue for Ronaldo's inclusion among football
legends, emphasizing his goal-scoring prowess and adaptability, while others highlight perceived
shortcomings, such as a focus on individual achievements over team contributions. The recent
interview where Ronaldo criticized the Glazer ownership and expressed frustration about not
being used as a substitute has added another layer to the discussion. Some may agree with his
stance, attributing it to valid concerns about club management, while others disagree, viewing it
as a departure from the traditional role of a player and potentially disruptive to team dynamics.
Despite the ongoing debate, there is consensus among some that Ronaldo's impact on the field
remains undeniable. His consistent goal-scoring prowess, versatility, leadership qualities, global
recognition, record-breaking achievements, and entertainment value contribute to his central
figure status in the football world. In conclusion, the debate surrounding Cristiano Ronaldo
reflects the complexity of evaluating football greatness, encompassing diverse perspectives on
playing style, team dynamics, and individual achievements. The ongoing discourse is a testament
to Ronaldo's enduring influence on the sport and the diverse opinions that shape the narrative
around his legacy.