Professional Documents
Culture Documents
net/publication/262310666
CITATIONS READS
4 22,799
3 authors, including:
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
Value Addition of Fruits and Vegetable by Edible Packaging: Scope and Constraints View project
All content following this page was uploaded by Aditya Madan on 23 July 2014.
Abstract
The present study investigated the effect of modified atmosphere on the shelf-life of
banana fruit. Partially ripened banana fruits (var. Robusta) were placed inside the
modified atmosphere chamber, made up of high-grade acrylic sheet and in perforated
and non-perforated LDPE bags to study the physico-chemical changes and shelf-life of
banana. The quality of the stored product was adjudged by comparing with normal
atmospheric storage conditions. The fruits stored under modified atmosphere conditions
had a storage life as thrice the shelf-life of control (with retained firmness, freshness and
greenness). Non-perforated package was preferred over perforated package for banana
storage. Ranking test was employed for sensory evaluation, preference of panelists for
color, firmness, freshness and appearance was statistically analyzed at 5% significance
level. The overall acceptability of banana stored in MA chamber was significantly higher
(p < 0.05) as compared to other storage treatments.
RRJoFST (2014) 1-10 © STM Journals 2014. All Rights Reserved Page 1
Modified Atmosphere Effect on Shelf-Life of Banana Madan et al.
RRJoFST (2014) 1-10 © STM Journals 2014. All Rights Reserved Page 2
Research & Reviews: Journal of Food Science & Technology
Volume 3, Issue 1, ISSN: 2278-2249
Fig. 2: Experimental MA Setup with Gas Cylinders and Vacuum Pump (1: Vacuum pump, 2: Active
MA Chamber, 3: CO2 Inlet, 4: N2 Inlet, 5: Gas Analyzer Connection, 6: Gas Flow Meter, 7: CO2 Gas
Cylinder, 8: N2 Gas Cylinder).
According to Shorter et al. [8], the storage life removed with the help of a vacuum pump till
was increased fivefold when bananas were the concentration of O2 fell from 21 to 8%.
stored in plastic film (where the equilibrium During this process, N2 content also fell from
gas content was about 2% O2 + 5% CO2) with 78 to 52% v/v of chamber and the CO2 content
an ethylene scrubber compared with fruit was 0%. At this stage, the vacuum pump was
stored without wraps. Satyan et al. [9] stored stopped and only desired amount of CO2 and
Williams in 0.1 mm-thick PE tubes at 13, 20 N2 was purged into the chamber. In order to
and 28 °C and found that their storage life was achieve the desired gas composition of 10%
increased two- to threefold as compared with CO2, 8% O2 and the rest being nitrogen gas,
fruit stored without wraps. Tiangco et al. [10] the atmosphere within the chamber was
also observed that the green life of the variety modified by purging CO2 for 63 ± 2 min at the
Saba (Musa BBB) held in MA at ambient flow rate of 0.2 L/min and N2 gas for about
temperature had a considerable extension of 94 ± 2 min at the rate of 0.4 L/min. The
storage life compared with fruit stored without conditions of storage (temperature and relative
wraps, especially if combined with humidity) within the chamber were kept
refrigeration. Different workers have stored similar to that of ambient condition. It was
banana in various packaging materials but assumed that there was no leakage of gases
none has tried with acrylic sheet. Also the from inside to outside and vice-versa and
beneficial gas concentration for shelf-life whatever change in gas composition occurred
extension of bananas, with ethylene scrubber within the chamber was only due to the
as reported by Shorter et al. [8], was 2% respiration of placed banana during entire
O2 + 5% CO2. In the present study, neither the storage studies.
use of any gas absorbents, scrubber or
scavenger was made nor was any sort of Gas Analyzer
refrigeration applied to the system. Keeping Orsat Analyzer Model VSC-33 (Apex
this in mind, the gas concentration was Instruments, Inc.) (Figure 3) was used for the
decided to be kept on a little higher side, i.e., analysis of gas concentration and it was
8% O2 + 10% CO2 v/v of chamber. connected to the modified atmosphere
chamber at point 5 (Figure 2). The chemicals
The banana sample was placed inside the like potassium hydroxide and alkaline
chamber to study the effect of modified pyrogallol, which act as absorbents for carbon
atmosphere on its physico-chemical properties dioxide and oxygen respectively, were used
and to estimate its shelf-life. Before the for gas analysis. The amount of these gases
atmosphere within the chamber was modified, absorbed was indicated by the difference in the
the air already present inside was partially volumetric reading of the burette. The reading
RRJoFST (2014) 1-10 © STM Journals 2014. All Rights Reserved Page 3
Modified Atmosphere Effect on Shelf-Life of Banana Madan et al.
was taken on each day till the first indication O2) expression. But, for understanding the
of spoilage was noticed. The amount of respiration process, only the change in O2 and
nitrogen gas present inside the chamber can be CO2 concentration was taken into
calculated on the basis of 100−(% CO2 + % consideration.
LDPE Packaging with five pinholes, but bags with ten holes had
MAP has shown that packaging in non- more decay. Not much work has been
perforated bags prolonged the pre-climacteric reported on the effect of perforation on shelf-
life of “Mas” banana fruit [11] and “Sucrier” life of banana. Therefore, considering the
banana [12]. However, its potential has not works reported by different workers for
been completely explored so far due to its different fruits, for moderate to higher
limited use by the industry [13]. The respiration fruit like banana, perforated (10
appropriate CO2 and O2 levels can be achieved perforations, each of 5 mm dia.) and non-
for fruits or vegetables with low or medium perforated LDPE bags (28.5 × 20.3) were
respiration rates where they are sealed in films selected, to find out the effect of perforation
such as LDPE, PP, OPP and PVC. However, on shelf-life of fruit. The packaging headspace
Rai and Paul [14], pointed out that for highly was not modified and kept at ambient
respiring produce, such as mushrooms, condition; as such, the only difference being
broccoli, asparagus and Brussels sprouts, the perforations (ten 5 mm diameter holes
packaging in these films can result in randomly) in one bag and no perforations in
fermentation. Punching holes in the plastic can the other one. Banana fruit stored in perforated
maintain a high humidity around the produce, and non-perforated LDPE bags is shown in
but it may be less effective in delaying fruit- Figure 4(a) and (b) respectively.
ripening because it does not have the same
effect on the CO2 and O2 content of the
atmosphere inside the bag. The holes may be
very small, and in these cases they are
commonly referred to as “microperforations.”
Larger holes are sometimes referred to as
“macroperforations,” but there is no definition
as to where one ends and the other begins.
RRJoFST (2014) 1-10 © STM Journals 2014. All Rights Reserved Page 4
Research & Reviews: Journal of Food Science & Technology
Volume 3, Issue 1, ISSN: 2278-2249
RRJoFST (2014) 1-10 © STM Journals 2014. All Rights Reserved Page 5
Modified Atmosphere Effect on Shelf-Life of Banana Madan et al.
Rank 1 – Like extremely, 2 – Like moderately, hand, the sample kept under normal
3 – Dislike moderately and 4 – Dislike atmosphere showed highest increase in TSS
extremely. from 19.2 to 25.6%. Perforated packaged
sample showed a little higher increase in TSS
Data gathered from sensory evaluation were as compared to non-perforated packaged
analyzed using analysis of variance (ANOVA) sample. The reason may be attributed to the
by IBM SPSS Statistics Version 21.0 software. perforations which avail normal respiration to
Differences between treatment means were the sample. The results obtained for the change
compared using Least Significant Difference in TSS content agree with the data reported by
Test at p = 0.05. Kulkarni et al. [18] for changes in TSS content
in bananas during artificial ripening. The
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION lower total sugars were due to the decrease in
Total Soluble Sugars respiration rate of the product under MA
Results indicated that banana fruit stored in condition. Lower values of TSS indicate
MA chamber had undergone a minimum delayed ripening of the fruits in the MA
change in total soluble sugars (TSS) as chamber. Increase in sugars during storage
compared to all other treated samples (Table took place due to the degradation of
1). Among all the treated samples, banana polysaccharides into simple sugars as reported
stored in MA chamber showed an increase in by Naik et al. [19] for tomatoes.
TSS content from 19.2to 21.4%. On the other
RRJoFST (2014) 1-10 © STM Journals 2014. All Rights Reserved Page 6
Research & Reviews: Journal of Food Science & Technology
Volume 3, Issue 1, ISSN: 2278-2249
atmosphere, was due to the slower rate of vapor pressure difference between the fruit
respiration which caused reduction in water surface and the surrounding atmosphere [23].
Fig. 5: Average Physiological Loss in Weight (PLW) for all Storage Treatments.
(T1: Non-perforated package, T2: MA stored, T3: Control, T4: Perforated package)
Fig. 6: Changes in the CO2 and O2 Concentration over a Period of Nine Days MA Storage.
RRJoFST (2014) 1-10 © STM Journals 2014. All Rights Reserved Page 7
Modified Atmosphere Effect on Shelf-Life of Banana Madan et al.
1 2 1 4 3
2 2 1 4 3
3 2 1 4 3
4 2 1 4 3
5 2 1 4 3
6 3 1 4 2
7 1 2 4 3
8 1 2 3 4
9 2 1 4 3
10 2 1 4 3
11 2 1 4 3
12 2 1 4 3
13 2 1 4 3
14 1 2 4 3
Sum 26 17 55 42
T1: Non-perforated package, T2: MA stored, T3: Control, T4: Perforated package
z
Different letters in the row indicate that means are significantly different at the 5% level
a
Highly significant treatment (p < 0.05).
RRJoFST (2014) 1-10 © STM Journals 2014. All Rights Reserved Page 8
Research & Reviews: Journal of Food Science & Technology
Volume 3, Issue 1, ISSN: 2278-2249
Results indicated that all the treatments were Fresh‐Cut Kiwifruit Slices. J Food Sci.
significantly different (p < 0.05) from each 1999;64(3):433–40p.
other. Overall acceptability of banana stored in 5. Gorny JR, Kader AA. Low oxygen and
MA chamber was significantly higher elevated carbon dioxide atmospheres
(p < 0.05) as compared to other storage inhibit ethylene biosynthesis in
treatments. Non-perforated packaged banana preclimacteric and climacteric apple fruit.
fruit was second most accepted by the Journal of the American Society for
consumers. Consumers disliked extremely the Horticultural Science. 1997;122(4):
control sample. 542–6p.
6. Kader AA. Biochemical and physiological
CONCLUSIONS basis for effects of controlled and
Banana fruits (var. Robusta), of same maturity modified atmospheres on fruits and
phase, de-handed and stored under modified vegetables. Food Technol-Chicago.
atmospheric conditions in MA chamber can be 1986;40.
stored for a longer period of time (nine days) 7. Watada AE, Qi L. Quality of fresh-cut
at ambient temperature without much loss in produce. Postharvest Biology and
quality as compared to its storage under Technology. 1999;15(3):201–5p.
normal atmospheric conditions (three days) 8. Shorter AJ, Graham D, Scott KJ.
and also when stored in 202-gage-thick LDPE Controlled atmosphere storage of bananas
perforated (four days) and non-perforated bags in bunches at ambient temperatures.
(five days). Non-perforated package was CSIRO Food Research Quarterly.
proved to be more beneficiary as compared to 1987;47.
perforated package. At the end of three days of 9. Satyan S, Scott KJ, Graham D. Storage of
storage, there were indications of spoilage in banana bunches in sealed polyethylene
control due to ripening and decaying at faster tubes. J Hortic Sci. 1992;67.
rates whereas the fruits stored under MA 10. Tiangco EL, Agillon AB, Lizada MCC.
conditions retained firmness, freshness and Modified atmosphere storage of ‘Saba’
greenness. The overall acceptability of banana bananas. ASEAN Food Journal. 1987.
stored in MA chamber was significantly higher 11. Tan S, Mohamed A. The effect of CO2 on
(p < 0.05) as compared to other storage phenolic compounds during the storage of
treatments. Hence, it can be concluded that ‘mas’ banana in polybag. In Symposium on
active modified atmospheric storage, without Tropical Fruit in International Trade.
the aid of refrigeration, can extend the shelf- 1989;269:389–90p.
life and maintain the quality of banana fruit. 12. Romphophak T, Siriphanich J, Promdang
S, et al. Effect of modified atmosphere
storage on the shelf life of banana
REFERENCES ‘Sucrier’. J Hortic Sci Biotech.
1. NHB. Database National Horticulture 2004;79(4):659–63p.
Board. Ministry of Agriculture, 13. Thompson AK. Controlled Atmosphere
Government of India: 2009. Storage of Fruits and Vegetables. CABI:
2. Singh HP. Research and development of 1998.
banana and plantain in India. In: Adopted 14. Rai DR, Paul S. Packaging requirements
from Souvenir for National Conference on of highly respiring produce under
Banana Production and Utilization of modified atmosphere: A review. J Food
Banana for Economic Livelihood and Sci Tech Mys. 2007;44(1):10p.
Nutritional Security 2007, October; 25–8p. 15. Son YK, Yoon IW, Han PJ, et al. Studies
3. Hintlîan CB, Hothckiss JH. The safety of on storage of pears in sealed polyethylene
modified atmosphere packaging. Food bags. Research Reports. Office of Rural
Technol. 1986;40(12):70–6p. Development, S. Korea, Soil Fertilizer,
4. Agar IT, Massantini R, Hess‐Pierce B, et Crop Protection, Mycology and Farm
al. Postharvest CO2 and Ethylene Products Utilization: 1983:25:182–7p.
Production and Quality Maintenance of 16. S Ranganna. Handbook of Analysis and
Quality Control for Fruit and Vegetable
RRJoFST (2014) 1-10 © STM Journals 2014. All Rights Reserved Page 9
Modified Atmosphere Effect on Shelf-Life of Banana Madan et al.
Products. Tata McGraw-Hill Education: 24. Wade NL, Kavanagh EE, Sepiah M.
1986. Effects of modified atmosphere storage on
17. Chauhan OP, Raju PS, Dasgupta DK, et al. banana postharvest diseases and the
Modified atmosphere packaging of banana control of bunch main-stalk rot.
(cv. Pachbale) with ethylene, carbon di- Postharvest Biology and Technology.
oxide and moisture scrubbers and effect on 1993;3(2):143–54p.
its ripening behaviour. American Journal
of Food Technology, Vails Gate. NOMENCLATURE
2006;1(2):179–89p. % percentage
18. Kulkarni SG, Kudachikar VB, Prakash °C degree Celsius
MK. Studies on physico-chemical changes ANOVA analysis of variance
during artificial ripening of banana (Musa CO2 carbon dioxide
sp) variety ‘Robusta’. J Food Sci Tech g gram
Mys. 2011;48(6):730–4p. kgf kilogram force
19. Naik DM, Mulekar VG, Chandel CG, et L liter
al. Effect of prepacking on physico- LDPE low density poly
chemical changes in tomato during ethylene
storage. Indian Food Packer, 1993;47:9p. MA modified atmosphere
20. Kudachikar VB, Kulkarni SG, Prakash MAP modified atmosphere
MK. Effect of modified atmosphere packaging
packaging on quality and shelf life of min minute
‘Robusta’ banana (Musa sp.) stored at low mm millimeter
temperature. J Food Sci Tech Mys. N2 nitrogen
2011;48(3):319–24p. NaOH sodium hydroxide
21. Mahajan BVC, Kaur T, Gill MIS, et al. O2 oxygen
Studies on optimization of ripening OPP oriented poly
techniques for banana. J Food Sci Tech propylene
Mys. 2010;47(3):315–9p. PLW physiological loss in
22. Adsule PG, Tandon DK. Assessment of weight
LDPE bags for enhancing shelf life of PP poly propylene
guava. Indian Food Packer. 1983. PVC poly vinyl chloride
23. Koca RW, Hellickson ML, Chen PM. RH relative humidity
Mass transfer from 'D' Anjou' pears in CA TSS total soluble sugars
storage. Transactions of the ASAE.
1993;36.
RRJoFST (2014) 1-10 © STM Journals 2014. All Rights Reserved Page 10