Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ALTA
REPORT.
JANUARY 2024
02 | THE ALTA REPORT.
Welcome to
THE ALTA REPORT,
a quarterly compilation of BNY Mellon perspectives derived
from our unique vantage point at the intersection of markets.
Touching approximately 20% of the world’s investable assets
gives us insight into key trends, helping you navigate the
future arc of markets and macro developments.
20%
of the world’s
$45.7T
in assets (custody and/
$12.6T
in U.S. government
investable assets** or administration) as the securities daily*
world’s largest custodian*
$5.7T
average tri-party
$4.5T
in lendable securities*
$2.3T
of U.S. dollar
collateral management payments value*
balances*
M A N AGING IN V ES TING
$1.8T
assets under
$292B
for Wealth
management1* Management
clients2*
Tailwinds
for 2024?
The worst of the inflation battle may be behind us, with central banks in all
developed economies except Japan looking set to pivot to rate cuts this year.
Investors appear to be pulling cash off the sidelines and extending duration in bonds
while being short the U.S. dollar.
Our economists agree with markets that U.S. rate cuts will come this year, but they
are unlikely to be as deep as what is priced in. Investors should note the potential for
further rate volatility ahead and the risk of rising yields if those cuts do not materialize.
And even if the U.S. achieves a soft landing, there could still be some potential for a
global recession.
Europe already seems to be heading into recession, and the U.K. continues to battle
stubborn inflation. It is unclear how quickly their central banks will cut rates, but
the European Central Bank is likely to go first. Meanwhile, China is looking to fiscal
stimulus to boost its economy in 2024, but is still dealing with a property hangover.
Our iFlow strategists have favored U.S. equities over other developed markets but with
valuations high, 2023-like returns may be out of reach. Overall, the backdrop seems to
augur well for high-quality fixed income, given slowing economic activity, and investors
have already been extending duration ahead of anticipated rate cuts.
Global Macro
back demand for the dollar. Counteracting this is the
potential for investor outflows from dollar-denominated
assets if confidence sours further in Congress’s ability
H O P IN G F O R A U. S . S O F T L A ND IN G to lower government deficits.
The U.S. remains the macro bright spot, with market
consensus calling for a soft landing and below-trend Passing the Buck
Trade-weighted dollar holdings have fallen.
growth. One of our senior economists, Shamik 1.00
Dhar, believes there is a 40% probability of a U.S.
expectation of this spring, possibly as late as the fall. aggregate magnitude of those holdings over the past year. Trade-weighted USD positioning measures
aggregate proprietary FX holdings indicators for the 26 currencies in the trade-weighted U.S. dollar
index using weights provided by the Federal Reserve that reflect the level of bilateral trade between
Meanwhile, our macro strategist John Velis believes the each country and the U.S.
Source: BNY Mellon iFlow
Federal Reserve could shave 100 basis points off the
federal funds rate this year, reaching a range of 4.25%-
4.5% by year end, and that the 10-year Treasury yield will BULLISH ON YEN
likely rise to 5%, if not higher, in 2024 due to concerns Our institutional clients have taken
over the additional supply of Treasury issuance. out a moderately long position in
the Japanese yen over the last
Easy Landing
The market may be getting ahead of itself on the timing and extent few months. This comes amid
of rate cuts. expectations that the Bank of
When the Fed Where to put Japan (BoJ) will introduce policy
may ease the chips
shifts in 2024 by raising domestic
Early in
the year 15% interest rates.
In 2023, the BoJ signaled policy loosening by
Mid-year
35% recharacterizing its previous 1% cap on 10-year
Japanese government bond yields as just a reference
Late in the
year, if at all 50% point. Our strategist Bob Savage sees the BoJ ending
the policy completely in early 2024, and also exiting
Source: BNY Mellon’s Dreyfus
negative interest rates by raising them 10 basis points
and Mellon, divisions of Mellon to 0% and then increasing rates to 0.4% before the
Investments Corporation
end of 2024.
Most of the clients we price options trades for are
positioned for dollar/yen to fall below 140 before year-
end. If USD/JPY were to fall meaningfully by year-end,
they could potentially sell or exercise their options
profitably, and buy back dollars at a reduced cost.
D O L L A R M AY H AV E P E A K E D Going to Japan
Cooling inflation and rising expectations for Fed Overseas investors were buying into the Japanese yen in 2023.
rate cuts spurred a wave of U.S. dollar (USD) selling Cross-border institutional holdings of yen
-0.5
He also believes dollar weakening is not likely to be -1
significant, even after the Fed cuts rates. It is also -1.5
water but is still experiencing higher inflation than Source: BNY Mellon iFlow
1.2
1 remain highly competitive versus other liquidity
0.8 instruments if the Fed begins to cut interest rates.
0.6
Government money-market fund data from our Dreyfus
0.4
platform show those funds’ median WAMs had increased
0.2
to 36 days at the end of November, up from 27 days at
0
-0.2
the end of the third quarter, amid growing consensus that
-0.4
the Fed had finished rate hikes. (Typically, these funds’
-0.6
WAMs only move one to two days a month.) Across the
Dec Feb Apr Jun Aug Oct Dec industry, for funds that allow repo, Treasury and agency
2022 2023
securities, holdings exceeding 90 days in duration rose to
*
A scored flow is an exponential moving average asset flow, normalized by trailing asset
flow standard deviation, where asset flow is daily net aggregate trading. 13% from 9% from September to October, also signaling
Source: BNY Mellon iFlow
their comfort that rates have peaked.
When the Fed begins cutting interest rates, certain
T O O B E A R I S H OV E R C HIN A liquidity investors may rotate back into MMFs, given that
A modest recovery in China is possible in 2024. Although Treasury bills and repos should immediately reflect the
the yuan was underheld by our overseas institutional expectation of lower rates or reset lower.
investor clients last year, iFlow data shows that in Long Shot
December, Chinese sovereign bonds had their two best Even money market funds (MMFs) are extending duration
weeks of inflows since August 2021. in their portfolios.
Overnight 2-30 days 31-60 days 61-90 days 90 days+ WAM* (days)
For now, however, foreign net flows into China equities 100% 3% 35
Composition of Government and Treasury Repo MMFs by Asset Type (%)
3% 3% 4% 6%
are essentially flat, and cumulative China-based bond 6% 7%
8% 9% 8% 9%
13% 33
90% 6% 7%
and equity holdings (onshore and offshore) are now back 7%
8% 5%
15%
30
7% 5%
at 2020 levels. Our macro strategist Geoff Yu believes 80% 10%
11%
5%
27 5%
that markets are possibly too bearish at current levels, 12% 25
Weighted Average Maturity (days)
70%
even with household demand subdued and property- 23
15%
Source: BNY Mellon Liquidity Services and Dreyfus, as of Nov 23, 2023
06 | THE ALTA REPORT.
C A S H S E T T O U ND E R P E R F O R M D IP P IN G B AC K IN T O D U R AT I O N
With the Fed likely at peak rates, many ultra-high-net- Real-money investors, institutions that tend to
worth clients are already reducing excess cash in their invest for the long haul, ended up being steady
portfolios and adding duration in bonds. This has the buyers of Treasurys in 2023. Through iFlow, we
potential to not only lock in high income for a number of observed them buying longer-duration Treasurys
years, but also benefit from a rally that typically takes when 10-year yields hit 4.5% in August, seemingly
place in bond prices at the end of rate-hiking cycles. eager to catch the rally in bonds that tends to follow
peak rates. They then mostly exited those positions
The average percentage of wealth accounts holding
in September, only to return when yields hit a 5%
more than 5% in cash within our Wealth Management
intraday high, and they were able to ride the rally
business has halved in the past year, reaching its
that followed. More recently, however, real money
lowest levels since 2021.
has been buying all across the curve.
Historically, when Fed rates peaked, investors have
on average earned more attractive returns in short-
and intermediate-term municipal bonds on an
after-tax basis than in Treasury bills, assuming
a 40% federal tax rate and using the last three
tightening cycles as a general guide.
40
Banks began offering higher CD rates as a way to draw
in stable deposit flows after the collapse of Silicon 20
$60
ETFs even when they had realized negative returns
$50 through most of 2023. Our retail broker-dealer data
$40
from four major U.S. wirehouses show financial
advisors favored vehicles like the iShares 20+ Year
$30 Treasury Bond ETF “TLT” and the Vanguard Long-Term
$20
Treasury ETF “VGLT,” specifically.
$10
Short- and ultrashort-duration fixed income saw
significant outflows in the third quarter, with eight
$0
J F M A M J J A S O N D J F M A M J J A S O N D J F M A M J J A S O N D
out of the top 10 fixed income outflows in our data
2021 2022 2023
Source: BNY Mellon Pershing
07 | THE ALTA REPORT.
Janus Henderson
AAA CLO (JAAA)
(42%), smart beta ETFs (26%) and large blend Direct
6.5
Vanguard Long-Term
Overall, U.S. equity mutual funds represented 68%
30 -Day Yield
Treasury (VGLT)
SPDR Blmbrg
1-3 Mth
iShare U.S.
Treasury Bond ETF
iShare 20+ Year
Treasury Bond (TLT) of all outflows in the quarter, as flows into U.S.
4.5
(GOVT)
equity ETFs and SMAs accounted for 24% and 15%
T-Bill (BIL)
Vanguard Total
International Bond (BNDX)
continued to be their flexibility and having lower
fees than mutual funds, while the growing interest
3
-3 0 3 6 9 12 15 18 21 24
Effective Duration equity SMA flows. Wirehouse take-up of SMAs in
*
Trailing 12 Month Positive Net Sales, as of Sep 2023. the quarter reached their highest levels since the
Source: BNY Mellon Growth Dynamics, as of Dec 7, 2023
first quarter of 2022.
Core Competency
M O R T G AG E-B O ND L I Q U ID I T Y Large-cap blends and intermediate government fixed income lead
FA L L S T O 3Y R L OW S the top-ranked strategies.
A new liquidity score developed by our Buy-Side Large Blend (Index ETF) 7.0%
Trading Solutions team shows that liquidity in Asset Allocation (SMA) 5.5%
agency mortgage-backed securities (MBS) was Intermediate Government (Index ETF) 4.6%
back to its lowest point in more than three years.* Large Blend (Smart Beta ETF) 4.3%
Excluding the Covid period, it was at five-year lows. Intermediate Core-Plus Bond (MF) 4.3%
These results matched what our traders have seen in Source: BNY Mellon Growth Dynamics, as of Sep 30, 2023
2.75
in the third quarter (Colombia, Chile, Brazil and Mexico
2.25 sovereign bonds) on account of low local inflation and
1.75 higher rates relative to developed markets. For much
1.25 of the second half of 2023, LatAm currencies especially
0.75 the Mexican peso (MXN) and Colombian peso (COP)
0.25 have also been popular among so-called carry traders
2019 2020 2021 2022 2023
who borrow in low-yielding currencies like the Swiss
*
Liquidity score is a proprietary measure of liquidity using defined metrics such as percentage
of best quotes, time to quote and percentage of missing quotes.
franc and invest in higher-yielding ones. More recently,
Source: Buy-Side Trading Solutions, offered by BNY Mellon Capital Markets, LLC, as of Nov 24, 2023 high-yielding central and eastern European currencies
08 | THE ALTA REPORT.
Losing Luster
Clients are reducing some of their holdings of LatAm currencies.
0.6
0.5
0.4
Smoothed Monthly Flow*
0.3
0.2
0.1
0 M A R K E T B E HIND O N T+1
-0.1 Analysis of our U.S. custody base shows that
-0.2 roughly a third of trades settled by DTCC may
-0.3 face issues in preparation for the settlement
Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec
cycle reduction to trade date plus one day (“T+1”).
2023
*
Data is a 20-day smoothed flow of client purchases of Latin American currencies
The data show that about 25% of client transactions
(ARS, BRL, CLP, COP, MXN, PEN). need to adjust their workflows to meet the new
Source: BNY Mellon iFlow
settlement cutoffs. Another roughly 9% would
need significant operating model changes by late
May to meet the new deadlines. Only two-thirds of
client trades currently meet the future deadlines.
Settlement failures could impact the entire trade
lifecycle, affecting agent lending, cash management,
repo pricing and bank balance sheets. Rather than
and private credit are some of the other alternative The final rule also includes a few new exemptions:
areas set to benefit from increased allocations, our cash trades by hedge funds and leveraged accounts,
survey data showed, while many respondents pointed some inter-affiliate repos, and repos by state and
out the large opportunity with hedge funds targeting local governments will not have to be cleared.
munis. Where decreases are being considered, the top Participants have two years to comply (December
areas are public-market strategies, including long-only 2025 for cash trades and June 2026 for repo).
equities and long-only fixed income. This could be
Some were expecting that the final rule would include
another sign of the move away from public markets
a requirement for minimum margins for repos for
and into private ones.
all market participants. Under the rule, only FICC
members must post margin to the central counterparty,
ALL CLE ARED UP but they can collect that from clients as well under new
The U.S. finalized a rule in December that will expand customer segregated accounts. The official sector may
central clearing for Treasurys by requiring the vast continue to pursue broader use of minimum margins as
majority of cash and financing trades to be novated a companion to the expanded central clearing rule.
Trade-weighted dollar holdings have fallen.
to a central counterparty. Market participants In and Out
continue to digest the roughly 400-page final rule The majority of the U.S. Treasury market will be centrally cleared,
and its implications, but broadly speaking, it will with few exceptions.
change the way the market functions and how Cleared Uncleared
Does not include transactions in the Fed’s reverse repo program (RRP).
**