Professional Documents
Culture Documents
US
Investment
Strategy
In this Issue
The Conventional Wisdom
02 A Stealth Earnings
Boom
• The consensus view seems to be We spent the last full week before the holi-
05 Multiples And The
Monetary Policy that equities have to cool off in days meeting with clients and prospects
Cycle 2020, even if the danger has passed: on the west coast. As they look ahead to
07 The Inflation Recession fears have dissipated as 2020, investors don’t see any major storm
Timetable the yield curve has returned to its clouds on the horizon, but they sense
08 Investment normal upward-sloping orientation and that stocks have run about as far as they
Implications US-China trade tensions have abated, can. We agree with the view that neither
but equity return expectations are a recession nor a bear market awaits, but
modest following last year’s bonanza. we expect equities will comfortably outdis-
tance bonds and cash. Forced to take a
• We agree that a bear market is
stand on whether the S&P 500 will beat or
unlikely, but expect a better year
fall short of the typical consensus expecta-
than the consensus, … : Bull markets
tion for mid-to-high-single-digit gains,1 we
tend to sprint to the finish line, and if
would happily bet the over.
the next recession won’t start before
the middle of 2021, 2020 should be As we detailed in our last two publications
another strong year for the S&P 500. in December, our optimistic take stems
from the deliberately reflationary policy
• … even if earnings growth is unin-
being pursued by the Fed and other major
spiring: Multiples almost always
central banks. Restoring inflation expecta-
Editorial Board expand when the Fed eases from an
tions to its desired range is job number one
Doug Peta already accommodative position, and
for the Fed, and its open commitment to
Chief US Investment they expand a lot provided the Fed isn’t
Strategist doing so ensures that risk assets will have
easing in response to a market bust or
Sara Porrello the monetary policy wind at their back for
financial crisis.
Senior Analyst an extended period. The European Central
Jennifer Lacombe • We expect that an inflation revival Bank and the Bank of Japan want to rekin-
Senior Analyst
will take the consensus by surprise, dle inflation as well, and can be counted
Caroline Miller upon to maintain easy policy settings.
Senior Vice President
but not this year: We think rising infla-
Mathieu Savary
tion will induce the Fed to bring the
Vice President curtain down on the expansion and the 1
The ten buy- and sell-side strategists surveyed in Bar-
Ryan Swift equity bull market, but not until 2021 at ron’s 2020 Outlook, published December 16th, called for
an average gain of 4%.
Vice President the earliest.
Copyright ©2020 BCA Research Inc. All Rights Reserved. Refer to last page for an important disclaimer.
US Weekly Report January 6, 2020 02
Investment The Conventional Wisdom
Strategy
bull market,
In our base-case scenario, easy monetary 300 300
not multiple
expansion. policy will encourage multiple expansion, CAGR = 14.6%
while a less threatening trade climate, 200 200
Copyright ©2020 BCA Research Inc. All Rights Reserved. Refer to last page for an important disclaimer.
US Weekly Report January 6, 2020 03
Investment The Conventional Wisdom
Strategy
Copyright ©2020 BCA Research Inc. All Rights Reserved. Refer to last page for an important disclaimer.
US Weekly Report January 6, 2020 04
Investment The Conventional Wisdom
Strategy
... thanks to
CHART 3
margin gains
powered Never Say Die Margin Growth, Nourished On ...
by falling
interest 10.0 S&P 500 PROFIT MARGIN 10.0
rates, falling
tax rates
and capital 7.5 7.5
capturing a
greater share
of the pie
5.0 5.0
from labor.
2.5 2.5
2020
CHART 4 CHART 5
... Rock-Bottom Rates ... ... And Labor's Woes
BPs BPs % %
INVESTMENT GRADE US:
LABOR SHARE OF INCOME
450 450
400 400
350 350 64 64
300 300
250 250 62 62
BOTH PANELS:
BPs HIGH YIELD YIELD TO WORST* BPs
1000 1000 60 60
900 900
800 800
58 58
700 700
600 600
56 56
500 500
2020 2020
2010 2012 2014 2016 2018 2020 1950 1960 1970 1980 1990 2000 2010 2020
* SOURCE: BLOOMBERG BARCLAYS INDICES.
Copyright ©2020 BCA Research Inc. All Rights Reserved. Refer to last page for an important disclaimer.
US Weekly Report January 6, 2020 05
Investment The Conventional Wisdom
Strategy
If margins
have finally CHART 6
peaked, Globalization Has Helped Corporate Profits
multiple 1.02 REAL WAGES* RELATIVE TO PRODUCTIVITY** 1.02
expansion
will have to
assume a
.98 .98
bigger role
in support-
ing the bull
market. .94 .94
.90 .90
2020
Copyright ©2020 BCA Research Inc. All Rights Reserved. Refer to last page for an important disclaimer.
US Weekly Report January 6, 2020 06
Investment The Conventional Wisdom
Strategy
It makes
CHART 8
perfect sense
that multiples
The Fed Funds Rate Cycle
expand when
the Fed cuts
rates, but it CYCLE PEAK
PHASE I PHASE IV
(EASY, TIGHTENING) (EASY, EASING)
Copyright ©2020 BCA Research Inc. All Rights Reserved. Refer to last page for an important disclaimer.
US Weekly Report January 6, 2020 07
Investment The Conventional Wisdom
Strategy
Multiples
have really TABLE 2
surged when Voluntary Cuts Turbocharge Multiples
the Fed has S&P ANNUALIZED FORWARD MULTIPLE GROWTH DURING DURING PHASE IV
provided
STARTING ENDING # OF
discretionary MULTIPLE MULTIPLE
CAGR
MONTHS
accommoda- May - Jul '80 6.91 7.47 36.8% 3
tion outside Aug '82 - Feb '83 6.31 8.94 81.7% 7
of periods of Apr - Oct '86 11.94 12.26 4.6% 7
distress. Nov '87 - Feb '88 10.81 11.28 13.7% 4
Sep '91 - Dec '93 14.33 14.63 0.9% 28
Sep '98 - May '99 18.02 23.52 42.7% 9
Apr '01 - May '04 19.51 16.48 -5.2% 38
Mar '08 - Nov '15 13.10 16.57 3.1% 93
Jul - Dec '19 16.97 18.38 17.3% 6
ALL PHASES 5.9% 195
EX-TMT & CRISIS 17.6% 64
There have been only two instances when recent past exerts a powerful influence on
the starting multiple has been as high as it near-term expectations about the future.
was at the start of the latest run of rate cuts. Inflation is way down the list of investors’
As noted above, conditions in the spring of concerns because it has been dormant
2001, when the NASDAQ was a year into its ever since the crisis, just as it was in the
eventual two-and-a-half-year slide, and a mid-‘60s once memories of high postwar
recession had just begun, bear little resem- inflation had faded. It conversely remained
blance to conditions today. The fall of 1998, an acute fear for more than a decade after
when the Fed delivered a rapid-fire 75 basis the Volcker Fed turned the tide in the early
points of easing to protect the economy ‘80s (Chart 9).
from the potential ramifications of Long
The slow but meaningful rise in the
Term Capital Management’s failure, looks
trimmed mean PCE (Chart 10, top panel)
a lot more like last summer. It is not our
and CPI series3 (Chart 10, bottom panel)
base case that the latest round of insurance
should pull core PCE and core CPI higher
cuts will push forward multiples to dot-com
over time. In the near term, however, the
levels, but they do have scope to expand.
absence of upward momentum in several
leading inflation indicators will likely
The Inflation Timetable stretch “over time” beyond the first half of
the year, if not the whole year. As tight as
It remains our high-conviction view that the labor market is, unit labor costs have
inflation expectations will not return to the
Fed’s target levels quickly. Their path has
seemed to provide a nearly perfect real-life 3
Trimmed-mean inflation series operate like figure skating
judging in the Olympics – the top and bottom readings are
case study supporting the adaptive expec- thrown out, and the mean is calculated from the remaining
tations framework, which posits that the scores.
Copyright ©2020 BCA Research Inc. All Rights Reserved. Refer to last page for an important disclaimer.
US Weekly Report January 6, 2020 08
Investment The Conventional Wisdom
Strategy
Trimmed-
CHART 9 CHART 10
mean
inflation
Recency Bias In Action Inflation's Not Dead, ...
Ann% Ann%
measures Chg CORE PCE DEFLATOR* Chg
US INFLATION EXPECTATION PROXY TRIMMED MEAN PCE**
suggest that
9 9
core inflation 2.5 2.5
will eventually
rise, ... 8 8
2.0 2.0
7 7 1.5 1.5
1.0 1.0
6 6
Ann% Ann%
Chg CORE CPI* Chg
5 5 TRIMMED MEAN CPI**
4 4 3 3
3 3 2 2
2 2
1 1
2020 2020
1950 1960 1970 1980 1990 2000 2010 2020 1995 2000 2005 2010 2015 2020
* EXCLUDING FOOD AND ENERGY.
** SOURCE: FEDERAL RESERVE BANK OF DALLAS.
***SOURCE: FEDERAL RESERVE BANK OF CLEVELAND.
not been able to break out of the range market slack. Upward wage pressure could
that’s contained them for the last five years then filter into consumer prices either via
(Chart 11, top panel); the New York Fed’s a cost-push or demand-pull framework, as
Underlying Inflation Gauge has pulled a corporations either seek to defend margins
disappearing act after a seemingly decisive from higher input costs or try to imple-
breakout in mid-2018 (Chart 11, middle ment opportunistic price hikes. Cost-push
panel); and the share of small businesses or demand-pull, many investors seem to
planning price increases has come off the be dismissing the potential for an infla-
late 2018 boil (Chart 11, bottom panel). tion revival, especially the ones we met in
northern California, where the deeply held
consensus view asserts that looming job
Investment Implications destruction from artificial intelligence makes
We spent the holidays reading up on the broad wage growth all but impossible.
history of strikes in the United States and Inflation is not an immediate concern, but
believe a shift in the balance of negotiating we expect it will ultimately spell the end of
power from management to labor may be the bull market and the expansion. Allocat-
stirring, as a two-part Special Report will ing a generous share of long-maturity Trea-
soon explore. Such a shift would render sury exposures to TIPS is an excellent way
wages much more sensitive to a lack of labor
Copyright ©2020 BCA Research Inc. All Rights Reserved. Refer to last page for an important disclaimer.
US Weekly Report January 6, 2020 09
Investment The Conventional Wisdom
Strategy
1
Doug Peta, CFA -4
3
3
ALL PANELS:
TRIMMED MEAN 0
1 PCE DEFLATOR*
3
30
2 20
10
1
2020
Copyright ©2020 BCA Research Inc. All Rights Reserved. Refer to last page for an important disclaimer.
US Weekly Report January 6, 2020 10
Investment The Conventional Wisdom
Strategy
10. The Manufacturing Slowdown's Impact On The US Economy - October 14, 2019
20. Agency Mortgage REITs Are Back In Season - July 30, 2019
21. How Will Equities Respond To Rate Cuts? - July 15, 2019
24. The Fed, The Fed, The Fed (And China-US) - June 17, 2019
Copyright ©2020 BCA Research Inc. All Rights Reserved. Refer to last page for an important disclaimer.
US Weekly Report January 6, 2020 11
Investment The Conventional Wisdom
Strategy
Copyright ©2020 BCA Research Inc. All Rights Reserved. Refer to last page for an important disclaimer.