Professional Documents
Culture Documents
7, 2014)
ebrahimiahad@gmail.com
minoo.gharehbeiglu@gmail.com
Mo_aliabadi@yahoo.com
234
ISSN:0254-0223 Vol. 29 (n. 7, 2014)
Abstract:
During recent decades searching for new geometrical innovations has been of great interest for
contemporary architects, recent years have borne new era in architectural design. With the aid of
various designing facilities, parametric architecture has begun to present new discourse in
architecture. The purpose of this study is show this kind of architectural design can be present as
an innovation route in Islamic architecture And using its facilities and tools can it take an action in
conveying Islamic Architecture concepts, based on its current era time and place. Investigation
answer following question: what extent using parametric architecture in Persian architectural
designing can be influential in conveying Islamic architecture philosophy and concept? The aim of
present investigation is to study theoretical principles of parametric architecture to obtain new
approach to develop for of contemporary Islamic architect. According to findings of present
research along with its applied and theoretical aspects, adapting parametric architecture shape
grammar capabilities to formed equivalents of Islamic traditional architecture has been examined
with geometrical approach. According to the finding of study it has been revealed that using
parametric architecture is conditioned to comprehensive attention to all human and divine
dimensions in Islamic architecture field, in a way that it would express logical and divine
relationship between architecture and sacred concepts.
235
ISSN:0254-0223 Vol. 29 (n. 7, 2014)
Introduction
236
ISSN:0254-0223 Vol. 29 (n. 7, 2014)
237
ISSN:0254-0223 Vol. 29 (n. 7, 2014)
Literature review
Till now considerable researches have been done about geometrical motifs
modeling, using new techniques and tools in Islamic architecture geometry and
issues related to updating this field some of which are introduced briefly to get
more familiar with research subject and review of related literature. Keith
Critchlow has analyzed all geometrical patterns and motifs, based on the fact that
all of these are derived from Islamic thoughts and spirituality. The book "an
analytical and cosmological approach to Islamic pattern" is his first work of wide
studies in this field. For the first time he explained to the world the amazing
reason of supernatural importance of geometrical patterns in Islamic art”
(Critchlow, 1976). It is worth mentioning that his compiles are among the first
which have been written in west for the aim of geometrical analysis of Islamic
patterns from metaphysics and cosmological aspects. His researches have had
profound influences on a group of young western architect and art historians. The
aim of book writer was to indicate the metaphysic and cosmological principles of
every artistic creation, trying to argument how employing mathematical
classification can confirm internal and innate unity of all things. Researches
carried out by Issam El-said and Asye Parman to understand geometrical concepts
employed in Islamic arts, through analyzing works in the form various pictures
and diagrams are of great interest. They consider the essence and foundation of all
different Islamic arts as a result of its different divisions and classifications (El-
said & Parman, 1991). Abbas and Salman have planned some algorithms about
Islamic geometrical patterns, related to evolution of traditional geometrical
methods, based on collective views to efficient production of all crystal-like
repeatable designs using computer graphic (Abas & Salman, 1992).Ostromoukhov
(1998) in a research tried to draw decorative and Islamic geometrical patterns
based on computer graphic using mathematical tools. Kaplan suggested a new
method to make Islamic starred patterns based on placement condition of
symmetrical and radial patterns which were reticular in a way (Kaplan C. S.,
2002). Aljamali, also, tried to make a pattern to create starred unites (Aljamali &
Banissi, 2003) Kaplan and Salsin carried out an investigation about Iranian
Islamic Starred patterns and using computer graphic they invented a new
parametric method to create starred and polygon patterns. According to results
obtained from their study digital parameters of geometrical structures and Islamic
motifs have been formed based on specific logic and they can be elicited and
change to software algorithms (Kaplan C. S., 2002). Based on rotational
symmetry, DJibril presented new method for Iranian Islamic starred patterns
classification and order (Djibril, Hadi, & Haj Thami, 2006). Grunbaum created a
fundamental region and space by starred patterns analysis using their symmetrical
systems (Grunbaum, 2006). Ilkturk (2008) could obtain a combination of math
238
ISSN:0254-0223 Vol. 29 (n. 7, 2014)
and visual arts with the aid of Iranian-Islamic geometrical pattern. Regarding
patterns digital design, as an example we can mention projects presented in
Architectural design journal in 2009. An article titled" parametric patterns"
published in this journal proceeds on actions taken in a workshop called
"parametric patterns" in 2009 located at University of applied arts, Vienna,
supervised by Patrick Schumacher and Zaha Hadid (Schumacher, 2009). These
two architects adhered using parametric design of motifs and geometrical patterns
levels as an important device architecture, production and mankind various and
different levels (Schumacher, 2009, p. 28). Zaera-Polo proceeds on investigating
opportunities and techniques of cultural and political complex patterning in
building envelop. Moreover they study the ability of using contemporary and
traditional geometrical patterns to find relationship between local traditions and
various native cultures with universal techniques (Zaera-Polo, 2009, p. 18).
Jowers et.al studied different methods of design in creating Iranian-Islamic
geometrical patterns, obtaining three distinguished methods (Jowers, Prats, Eissa,
& Lee, 2010). In a study Maryam Al-ainati obtained similar results practically.
She tried to develop geometrical field rich with Islamic architecture from two
dimensional levels to three dimensional structures, through finding and combining
principles of Islamic traditional geometry with contemporary concepts (J.Al-
ainati, 2012). In another study, order and advanced geometry used in Islamic
knotting which on one hand are similar to crystal-like structures, emphasizing on
prominent place of advance geometry in traditional world on the other hand, were
studied to prove the domination of traditional architects on geometrical issues
(Mohammadian Mansour and Faramarzi 2012). Antoine Picon writer of
"Decoration: architectural policy and mentality" claims that: for innovation and
stepping beyond superficial level of fashion-like trends of architecture, we need to
avoid pure providing and pay attention to history and traditions feedback on
architecture (Picon, 2013, p. 128). Most scholars including Ardalan, Bakhtiyar,
Burkhardt and Nasr have carried out comprehensive researches on different
aspects of Iranian Architecture metaphysics (Burckhardt, Art of Islam: Language
and Meaning, 2009) and others such as Babin, Pope (Pope, 1971), Ackerman,
Creswell and Critchlow (Critchlow, 1976) have proceeded on its mathematical
aspects. Necipoglu has devoted his scientific studies on these fields (Necipoglu &
al-Asad, 1996), indicating geometrical richness of Iranian Architecture during
several years.
239
ISSN:0254-0223 Vol. 29 (n. 7, 2014)
discussing the issue. Then the incidence capability of this kind of geometry
concepts and meanings will be studied using parametric geometry and digital
tools.
240
ISSN:0254-0223 Vol. 29 (n. 7, 2014)
achieve meanings (Kharzmi & Afhami, 2010). Though, geometry has had
different application in sacred art. There is an emphasis on expression beyond
appearance of materials to indicate their essence and nature (Rahbarnia &
Rahnavard, 2006, p. 103). Existence of countless geometrical designs in Islamic
art formed in relation with Pythagorean math confirms the meaning that principles
inserted in this art have been combined with sacred geometry and Sophia Perennis
with full attention and elegance (Critchlow, 1976). Scholars like Burkhardt and
Seyyed Hossein Nasr believe that geometrical and plant patterns express the
secret of unity and superabundance (Rahnavard, 2002, p. 2). Generally, from
Islamic philosophy point of view and considering studies carried out in this field,
the authors believe that following principles can be expressed for geometry of
Iranian architecture presented in diagram 1:
Diagram 1: principles of geometry in Iranian Architecture from Art philosophy and Islamic
architecture perspective, ref: authors 2013
Geometry has long been a generator of architecture (M. Maleki & F. Woodbury,
2008, p. 376). Using figures and geometry, as mathematical expressions, shapes
creation is considered as eternal patterns of allegoric universe. Taking this into
consideration, math is seen as a language and a device of interpretation which
based on its nature leads from sensible world to active world. Math is subjective;
it is related to our senses, though its typical nature is objective. These subjections
241
ISSN:0254-0223 Vol. 29 (n. 7, 2014)
of active world are used as basic guidance for eternal and objective essence of
divine order (Ardalan & Bakhtiar, 2000, p. 51). In religious art, self is considered
as substantiation of inspiration, intuitions and realities received from superior
world, this is while in non-religious art, self is considered as independent artist,
looking for no reality (Aavani, 1996). Taking most thinkers' opinions" techniques
and tools don’t create holly art; rather they are source of inspiration causing
blowing sacred sprite to them (Rahbarnia & Rahnavard, 2006, p. 104). However
abandonment of new tools and novel geometry and their absolute confirmation,
both are rejected, since it is subjected to its position in servicing or protagonists
(the same p107). Employing novel tools for facilitation can help esoteric
expression (the same p108). Hence it can be concluded that art inspired by
superior order can be substantiated in different forms, one of which is utilizing
updated tools. The most important thing is the role of art in human loftiness.
Hence it seems that different schools and expressions, new or old tools have had
no sanctity or de-sanctity of art, not necessarily cause change in the nature
concepts hidden in works nature. Artistic aspect of technique dose not requires
permission, since it is resulted from creativity, though conceptual aspect of
techniques greatly depends on different ideologies inspiring artists.
Now a days considering tools development, providing new opportunities has been
appeared for computer application to create geometrical patterns and analysis
(Kaplan C. S., 2002). Technological innovations have brought creative solutions
in architectural design. Working with hand is replaced with three dimensional
modeling throughout procedure. This development is important, because human
mind has the ability of thinking about two-dimensional forms, though with
addition of third dimension to it, initial architectural designs and formal become
limited. Geometrical patterns have formed the main part of art and decorative
design throughout history.
242
ISSN:0254-0223 Vol. 29 (n. 7, 2014)
Diagram 2: current tools and new capabilities to create creativity by different sources in
contemporary era, parametric architecture as new instrument to create formic and spatial
creativities, ref: authors 2013
243
ISSN:0254-0223 Vol. 29 (n. 7, 2014)
Fig. 1: The pattern is composed of radial arrays, concentrically staggered around a central densely
patterned core. Sheikh Lotfallah Mosque (1618) in Esfahan, Iran
244
ISSN:0254-0223 Vol. 29 (n. 7, 2014)
with Hanif Kara about geometrical patterns: most admirable geometrical patterns
and motifs are from small to big which can have wide applications in Structure
Engineering (Garcia, 2009, p. 66) Investigation of existing references including
coordinates can be elicited from different books, geometrical and mathematical
principles governing geometrical patterns, by continuous study. Sketching
principles of these patterns can be defined in exact computer algorithm for
appropriate parameters, symmetry, coordinate, reflection, rotation, reduction and
induction calls to obtain clear forms. Generally similar aspects of parametric
geometry with Iranian-Islamic patterns can be mentioned as following:
Diagram 3: studying some similar aspects of principles of parametric geometry and principles of
designing Iranian-Islamic patterns, Authors
It goes without mentioning that present article lefts most issues unfinished for it
due to presenting new issues and novel views in Islamic architecture. The authors
hope, this issues would create new experiences and critic stimulants in this field.
Undoubtedly this project dose not claims to present a complete and faultless
scientific approach to provide a comparative study of geometrical patterns of
Iranian architecture, parametric architecture and their interpretation, though from
architecture, engineering and mathematical point; it can be considered as a
foundation for more studies to promote Islamic architecture.
245
ISSN:0254-0223 Vol. 29 (n. 7, 2014)
Many of the most complex and intricate designs we know adorn Dome`s internal
decorative elements in Persian architecture, including multi-level designs in which
patterns of different scales are combined to complement and enrich each other.
Here we give a Parametric analysis of some of Dome`s internal decorative
elements in Persian architecture exemplary designs, focusing on a modular
construction in which designs are produced by assembling copies of modular
parametric. This variety of Islamic geometric pattern is characterized by
combinations of Basic parameters (such as star forms) that range from the more
compatible (such as compound patterns) to the seemingly incompatible (such as
self-similar patterns).
Fig. 2: Analysis of repetitive modoule of Rasmi dome in Dowlatabad garden, Yazd, Iran, Authors
246
ISSN:0254-0223 Vol. 29 (n. 7, 2014)
Another parametric dome can be cited is Kar-bandi. The interface between Design
Foursquare far stems dome where it starts, if there is a sub-arcs of intersection,
say Karbndy (seyyed sadr, 2002, p. 439). Kar-bandi building consists of a vault
door is covered with geometric rules that determine arcs intersect and shape to
create the original cover. Karbndyha, consisting Azbarykh or vault door are a
Tqatshan, skeletal covering for ceilings occur and much of the time frame covered
by the second and shorter than the main roof, and often as the main roof of used.
Yazdi-bandi is a kind of interior dome decoration in Iranian Architecture.
Particular type of Kar-bandi under the dome, covering the decorative arched
entries that are normally present in the atmosphere which gives specific
expression. Yazdi is a state Ranking the Rsmi-bndi and Muqarnas (seyyed sadr,
2002, p. 600). Yazdi-bandi is the Persian word for interior dome and Iwan
decoration. It is an originally Persian type of wall or ceiling decoration, which is
used to make a smooth transition from the rectangular basis of the building to
vaulted ceiling (Nejad Ebrahimi, Aliabadi, & Aghaei, 2013, p. 113). In addition
Muqarnas is the most famous parametric architectural decorations (Fig. 3).
Muqarnas is one of the most characteristic features of Islamic architecture and in
used throughout most of the Muslim world (Petersen, 1996, p. 206). In addition,
two-dimensional geometric patterns, such as painting can also be the basis of
parametric design module. (See table 1 & 2)
Fig. 3: Natanz Jaame Mosque, Natanz, Iran, Modular stucco Muqarnas, Authors
247
ISSN:0254-0223 Vol. 29 (n. 7, 2014)
1
Pineapple Dome (Ourchin)
248
ISSN:0254-0223 Vol. 29 (n. 7, 2014)
Name
Paramet Types based on the
Types Dome Basic Module Elements 2D Model
ers basic module
s
composed
of a
Orthogonal Shape- Grading- Diamonding- Granularity- Centrality- Uniformity- Focusing- Diffusion- Crystallized- Arching, Clustering-
Rasmi-bandi
infill
surfaces
equally
arranged Shaparak
around a Nimkar Pointed Arch
(Pendentive)
compressi
on ring
Compose Mortar paste arch
d of
Tier surface subdivision (layers)
smooth,
finely Brick
Repetition- Intricacy- Stellate shape- stepping- Conical shape
Classification of Parametric Ornamental Domes
gained,
diamond- Stucco
shaped Tile
modoules
of Brick -
Architectural-Decorative
yazdi –bandi
differing Tile
sizes, Brick-
with very stucco Star-shaped
Pa-barik1
3D Module
(Moussav Panel
i, 2009, p.
276)
Compose Simple
takht (Flat
d of Muqarn Square
element)
variable as
but Stretch
repeating
Basic Module Elements
(Matin) Parallelogra
Basic Shape Elements
tracks, Arch
which are Muqarn Shaparak Rhombic
stacked, as (Pendentive
corrugati )
ng the Do-payeh
surface of Tas
Shirazi Pa-barik
the dome (Squinch)
Muqarn
(Moussav as Extruded
i, 2009, p. vertical Square
326) plane
1
Diamond-shaped faceted modoule
1
Diamond-shaped faceted modoule
249
ISSN:0254-0223 Vol. 29 (n. 7, 2014)
Girih
Brickwo
Centrality- Uniformity- Focusing- Diffusion- Clustering- Repetition-
Growing- Diversity- Unit Cells- Attractor Motifs- Self Similarity Brick and Tile
The rk
arabesque Xowun1 Brickwork
is a form Mohri'chini (stamp brickwork)
of artistic Geometric patterns
decoration Arabesque motifs
Architectural -Ornamental
consisting
Stucco Animal and bird motifs
of
"surface Inscriptions
Surface Pattern
2D Module
Fig. 4: Amin-od Dowleh Timcheh, Kashan Bazaar, Modular Yazdi-bandi dome, Authors
By comparing the table 1 and Taking what was said previously into consideration,
some of most important characteristics of parametric design can be adapted to
1
Type of Persian brickwork used in elevation and entrance like Mosaic tile.
2
In this technique Pictures were painted on plain rectangle tiles, glazed and fired afterwards.
Besides economic reasons, the seven colors method gave more freedom to artists and was less
time-consuming.
250
ISSN:0254-0223 Vol. 29 (n. 7, 2014)
principles of traditional geometry, which can be used to improve it. One of the
most important lessons taken from cases such as geometrical patterns and d
curved level expressed in Arcades is that updated tools are not used in designing
procedures. Case analysis indicated clearly that Iranian Arcades are more
complicated and advanced than construction tools and its spatial imagination.
Hence our contemporary artifacts are more simplified than tools which are in our
possession. Our dominance on contemporary advanced sciences and tools can
helps us in expressing Iranian-Islamic concepts with the aid of art. A considerable
point is that stemming intentions and motivations of past architects to create such
admirable works and enduring all difficulties and complications are of great
importance. After studying geometrical patterns of Iranian arcades and their
parametric design patterns various similarities were observed in principles and
procedures of creating shape in both methods. All arcade geometrical patterns rely
on center, growing like algorithmic growth of sun flower grains. Similarities of
two mentioned patterns have been shown in following figures. This is originated
from a common nature called geometry. With the aid of similarities, parametric
relation imagination has been shown graphically in the following analysis. (Fig. 4)
Taking this into consideration that geometrical patterns used in Iranian arcades
have symbolic and spiritual aspects in addition to imagery aspects, they have been
able to convey concepts of Islamic art. So studying geometrical patterns of
Timcheh and geometrical principles of parametric confirms the fact that:
symbolism of arches and Islamic architecture sketches are of geometrical type. It
seems that most parts of Iranian-Islamic patterns depend on center. Hence it can
be concluded that using principles of parametric architecture plays an important
role in conveying meanings and concepts of Islamic Art Philosophy.
251
ISSN:0254-0223 Vol. 29 (n. 7, 2014)
Conclusion
Diagram4: Indexes of parametric architecture and wide facilities which can be used as design
tools to develop Iranian-Islamic architecture through emphasizing geometrical patterns of Iranian-
Islamic architecture.
252
ISSN:0254-0223 Vol. 29 (n. 7, 2014)
Based on results obtained from present study, using parametric design patterns
can be developed apparently in eliciting and interpreting formic generative
algorithms of traditional Iranian-Islamic patterns in creation and combination with
traditional and local parameters and elements. These results can be generalized to
future studies in this field. Authors believe that designing is not completely an
innovation or exploration. When creating a completely new thing, design should
be considered as a result of an explorative reconstruction or revelation procedure.
So, as it can be observed parametric design can be efficient in reinterpretation,
recognition and domination of Iranian-Islamic patterns. Meanwhile, conveyance
degree of concepts and meanings of Iranian- Islamic architecture philosophy by
Man
Sacred Concepts
253
ISSN:0254-0223 Vol. 29 (n. 7, 2014)
parametric architect depend on one hand on creativity power of Islamic artist and
on the other hand on his utilization of divine concepts and contents. Since secular
ideologies have no ethical basis to use techniques and tools, and their aim is just
meeting financial needs of human. Based on Islamic anthropology, especially
from Imam Ali's point of view is reduction of human existential position reduction
to herbal or animal position. This is while Islamic ideology relies on Islamic
ethics philosophy when using techniques. According to Islamic wisdom and
philosophy art and architecture should try to develop human's spiritual loftiness
and mental growth. Hence, considering following diagram parametric design
employment can be presented and used in various semantic layers, considering
designer's ideology and aim, in spite of having the capability and potential of
concepts expression. Finally it seems that the nature of production tools of
parametric architecture is in accordance with definitions of Islamic art indexes
and qualities presented in principles of Islamic arts. It can also be used to promote
and develop Islamic Architecture.
References
Aavani, G. (1996). Wisdom and Spiritual Art (In Persian ed.). Tehran: Garous Press.
Abas, S., & Salman, A. (1992). Geometric and Group-Theoretic Methods for
Computer Graphics studies of Islamic Symmetric Patterns. Computer
Graphics Forum, Vol.1, No. 1, 43-53.
Aljamali, A. M., & Banissi, E. (2003, February). Grid Method Classification of
Islamic Geometric Patterns. WSCG, 3-7.
Arayin, R. (2008). Primary Notes on Perception of Historical Importance of
Geometry in Islamic Thought, and Its Suppressed Role in Genealogy of
World history. (F. Sasani, Ed.) Journal of Farhangestan-e-Honar. (Academy
of Art of Iran), 28-40.
Ardalan, N., & Bakhtiar, L. (2000). The Sense of Unity: The Sufi Tradition in Persian
Architecture (2nd Edition ed.). Kazi Publications Inc.
Broug, E. (2008). Islamic Geometric Patterns ( Pap/Cdr edition ed.). Thames &
Hudson.
Burckhardt, T. (1986). Sacred Art in East & West: Its Principles and Methods (2nd
Edition ed.). Perennial Books.
Burckhardt, T. (2009). Art of Islam: Language and Meaning (Commemorative
Edition ed.). World Wisdom.
Corbin, H. (1993). History of Islamic Philosophy. (K. Paul, Trans.) Routledge.
Critchlow, k. (1976). Islamic patterns: An Analytical and Cosmological Approach.
New York, USA: Schocken Books.
Djibril, M. O., Hadi, Y., & Haj Thami, R. O. (2006). Fundamental Region Based
Indexing and Classification of Islamic Star Pattern Images. Image Analysis
and, 4142, 865-876.
El-said, I., & Parman, A. (1991). Geometric Concepts in Islamic Art. London,
England: Interlink Publication.
Fallahfar, S. (1999). Dictonary of Iranian traditional Architecture. Tehran, Iran.
254
ISSN:0254-0223 Vol. 29 (n. 7, 2014)
255
ISSN:0254-0223 Vol. 29 (n. 7, 2014)
Nasr, S. H. (1972). Science and Civilization in Islam (2nd Edition ed.). London:
Islamic Texts Society.
Nasr, S. H. (1976). Islamic Science: An Illustrated Survey. London: World of Islam
Festival Publishing.
Necipoglu, G., & al-Asad, M. (1996). The Topkapi Scroll: Geometry and Ornament
in Islamic Architecture:. London: Oxford University Press.
Nejad Ebrahimi, A., Aliabadi, M., & Aghaei, S. (2013). Dome`S Internal Decorative
Elements In Persian Architecture Case Study: Yazdi-Bandi. Alam Cipta
(Universiti Putra Malaysia), 6(1), 113-127.
Nikfetrat, M. (2011). Structural Basics of Parametric Architecture. 2nd Conference of
Architecture and Structure, University of Tehran, Collage of Fine Arts,
Faculty of Architecture, pp. 1-12.
Noghrekar, A. (2011). Theoretical Foundations of Architecture. Tehran: Payame
Noor University Publication.
Okhovvat, H., Ansari, M., & Bemanian, M. (2008). Expression of Islamic Wisdom
and Christianity Wisdom on Geometry of Mosques and Churches. Ketab-e-
Mah-e-honar, 14-19.
Petersen, A. (1996). Dictionery of Islamic Architecture. London and New york:
Routledge.
Picon, A. (2013, 01). Counetrpoint: Architecture, Innovation and Tradition.
Architectural Design (AD), No 221, 128-133.
Pope, A. (1971). Introducing Persian Architecture. California: Oxford University
Press.
Rahbarnia, Z., & Rahnavard, Z. (2006). Encounter of Sacred Art with Technology.
Journal of Fine Arts (University of Tehran; In Persian), 26, 101-108.
Rahnavard, Z. (2002). Principles and Basics of Traditional Arts. Ketab-e-Mah-e-
honar (House of Book of Iran; In Persian), 1-4.
Schumacher, P. (2009, Nonember/December). Parametric Patterns. (H. Castle, Ed.)
Architectural Design, 202(Patterns of Architecture), 28-41.
seyyed sadr, a. (2002). Encyclopedia of architecture and urbanism. Tehran: Azade.
Tehrani, F., Mahdizade seraj, F., & Vali beig zade, N. (2011). Utilization of
Normalized Triangle in Mathematic Calculations and Implementation
Geometry in Build and Run of Traditional Architecture of Iran. Journal of
Renovation, Works and Historical and Cultural Contexts, 15-26. Retrieved 6
8, 2011
Zaera-Polo, A. (2009, November/December). Patterns, Fabrics, Prototypes,
Tessellations. (H. Castle, Ed.) Architectural Design, 202(Patterns of
Architecture), 18-27.
256