Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Fuel
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/fuel
h i g h l i g h t s
a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t
Article history: The main purpose of this work is to convert the mechanical injection system of a single cylinder diesel
Received 10 December 2013 engine to an electronically controlled dual-fuel system. The new system consist two different injectors.
Received in revised form 3 April 2014 First injector supplies the LPG (liquefied petroleum gas) , the other one supplies the diesel. LPG is sup-
Accepted 6 April 2014
plied via a port fuel injection system located in the intake port of the engine and the diesel injected
Available online 24 April 2014
directly into the combustion chamber before top dead center (TDC). All injectors were controlled by Pro-
grammable Logic Controller (PLC). After the adaptation and tests, the single cylinder Lombardini LDA
Keywords:
450 type diesel engine was modified to a high pressured PLC controlled dual-fuel research engine.
Diesel engine
LPG
Ó 2014 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Injection
Advance
PLC
1. Introduction well appropriate for S.I. engine. But when LPG is burnt in the usual
diesel engine there is a difficulty in self-ignition because of its
Environmental concerns and depletion in petroleum resources lower cetane number [10].
have forced researchers to concentrate on finding alternatives to Nowadays, LPG becomes more attractive at our country,
conventional petroleum fuels. A lot of experimental efforts are because of environmental benefits in terms of emissions and it is
focused on simultaneous achievement of high energy efficiency cheaper unit price. In general, SI (spark ignition) engine powered
and reduction of harmful emissions [7]. The emission problem old cars fuel system changed into dual fuel (LPG/Gasoline) system.
divided into two parts. The first is the engine and the old car pop- Recent years, due to the higher petrol prices and taxes, the unit
ulation; the second is the fuel. Due to developments in engine price of gasoline and diesel rises dramatically. High diesel fuel
technology, the emission pollutants levels are high because of price, have forced the issue of the use of LPG at diesel engine.
the fuel specifications. According to the new regulations the fuel Since the early 1930’s, there is a fluctuating interest in the
specifications are more important for the vehicles [23]. At this research of compression engines operating on dual fuels. Recently,
point, the use of gaseous fuels in I.C. engines has long been consid- dual fuel engines are receiving more interest from many scientists
ered as a possible method for reducing emissions while maintain- due to many reasons including the national concerns of the liquid
ing engine performance and efficiency [8]. LPG is considered, to be fuels limited resources, the environmental issues and the need to
one of the most proficient alternative fuels not only as a replace- use a reliable, durable and efficient engine [3].
ment for petroleum fuel but also as a basis of reducing NOx, soot The dual fuel engines studies focuses on utilizing the gaseous
and particulate matter. LPG has a high octane rating and hence fuels like natural gas, hydrogen and LPG as primary fuel in com-
pression engines, due to the higher ignition temperature of this
⇑ Corresponding author. Tel.: +90 2123832835; fax: +90 2122616659. fuels. This primary fuels increases the mixture temperature [4].
E-mail address: aergenc@yildiz.edu.tr (A.T. Ergenç). Furthermore, because of the higher octane number of the gaseous
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.fuel.2014.04.016
0016-2361/Ó 2014 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
274 A.T. Ergenç, D.Özde Koca / Fuel 130 (2014) 273–278
fuels, it can be used in conventional high compression engine with Application of high-pressure injection systems increases
minor modifications, with comparable efficiencies to diesel fuel [3] amount of fuel injection per crankshaft angle and also shortens
According to Yoong and Watkins, [9] a higher thermal efficiency the ignition delay. Naturally this delay has a minimum value that
and therefore, improved fuel economy can be obtained from inter- cannot be breached. The amount of the fuel injected into cylinder
nal combustion engines running on LPG as opposed to unleaded increases with the pressure till the ignition starts and this leads
gasoline. This is because LPG has a higher octane number, typically to higher levels of NOx and noise. In order to compensate these
112 Research Octane Number for pure propane, which prevents the problems pre-injection technique is utilized. NOx and noise levels
occurrence of detonation at high engine compression ratio [5]. diminish with this method [14–18]. In addition, high-pressure
Homoyer et al. [6] states that there is a penalty in power output injection improves specific fuel consumption and particle emission
when using LPG compared to gasoline due to the displacement of levels [19,20].
some of the inspired air by the fuel gas whose volume is much As a summary, in a test engine advance angle, duration and
greater than that of its elated liquid. In dual fuel compressed igni- number of injections are the parameters subject to be adjusted to
tion engines operating with LPG as primary fuel and a pilot amount discover best blending ratios of alternative fuels.
of diesel fuel as an ignition source, the LPG is induced along with In addition, a measurement system is vital to measure torque
the intake air and is compressed like in a conventional diesel output, speed, temperature, airflow rate, combustion pressure
Engine. The mixture of air and LPG does not auto-ignite due to and emissions. The data collected from the system associated with
its high auto-ignition temperature. A Small amount of diesel fuel control parameters and corresponding measurements can be used
is injected near the end of the compression stroke to ignite the gas- for system identification of the test engine and therefore; optimal
eous mixture. operational region would be determined.
Poonia et al. [11] performed experiments on LPG-diesel dual In dual-fuel operation, LPG fuel injected with a system located
fuel engine at various intake temperature and pilot quantities. It to the intake port of the DI (direct injection) diesel engine and die-
was found that by increase in the concentration of the gaseous pri- sel fuel injected directly into the combustion chamber with an
mary fuel, ignition delay increases considerably. At higher load electromagnetic injector before top dead center. All injectors were
condition, the combustion of the gaseous fuel takes place by flame controlled by Programmable Logic Controller. In dual fuel mode,
propagation after ignition of pilot fuel. with gas mixed into the air intake while liquid diesel is injected
Ganesan and Ramesh [12] used LPG as the primary fuel and die- as normal, but a reduced rate [26].
sel as pilot fuel. The brake thermal efficiency was increased from
35% in the diesel mode to 37% in dual fuel mode at full load condi-
2. Engine management
tion due to rise in the combustion rate. However, at lower load con-
dition and with high diesel substitution, brake thermal efficiency
The test engine system for alternative fuels consists of three
reduces and hydrocarbons and CO levels increase. It is also noted
main parts. First part is the engine and its controller. Second part
that NOx levels reduce in the dual fuel mode up to 60% of full load
is the fuel system including common-rail pressure line and low
condition. The smoke emission reduces from 1.3 Bosch Smoke Units
pressure fuel line (dual fuel). Finally, the third part is the measure-
(BSU) to 0.5 (BSU) with dual fuel mode at full load. The ignition
ment system that includes all the sensors and transducers, which
delay period increases by 2 °CA (crank angle) and the peak pressure
provides feedback from all the operational quantities listed above.
decreases under light load and high diesel substitutions conditions.
A Single cylinder diesel engine is coupled with a DC motor over
Saleh [2] studied the effects of LPG compositions on the exhaust
a belt pulley mechanism with a ratio of 1:2. A two quadrant driver
emissions of the dual fuel compression engine under different
is attached to DC motor. In the first quadrant, it operates as a star-
engine conditions. This study reported that LPG with 70% propane
ter motor for the engine and in the second one, as a generator to
blend is showing a similar performance compared to the conven-
load the engine.
tional diesel engine. For the 70% propane blend, NOx and SO2 emis-
sion decreased by 27–69% meanwhile, the CO emission decreased
by 15.7% compared to the conventional diesel engine. 2.1. Engine Controller Unit (ECU)
A high-quality formation for combustion is achieved by mixing
of pulverized fuel drops and the air inside the cylinder [13]. In this Electronic engine controls based on real time diagnosis of com-
matter, injection parameters such as timing and period of injection, bustion process can significantly help in complying with the
injection pressure and number of the injection beams affect quality exhaust emission regulations and fuel consumption. Information
of combustion and mixture formation. At this point, injection sys- on the combustion efficiency may provide a strong tool regarding
tem has an important role on mixture formation. Injection timing engine operation and may be profitably used for closed-loop elec-
and period determines the beginning of the combustion in terms tronic engine controls [24,25].
of crankshaft angle. In an electronically controlled engine system a micro-controller
Commercial single cylinder engines are produced with mechan- based controller is necessary to collect data and generate necessary
ical fuel injection systems, which have predetermined parameters. signals to drive the injectors (LPG and diesel) in real-time. Pro-
Thus the effects of different operational parameters such as grammable Logic Controllers (PLC), which particularly developed
advance angle, injection pressure, and duration and phase numbers for industrial automation, can be utilized for controlling single cyl-
cannot be tested. In a test engine, injectors should be controlled inder engine.
depending on the operational parameters of the engine (speed, PLC have real-time operating systems, timers and counters cru-
gas position, etc.). cial for real-time control systems. Another advantage of is that
In alternative fuel studies, the injection system parameters like PLCs are relatively economical resolution for control applications.
pressure, injection advance, and injection character must be con- PLC, as an ECU, collects data from sensors such as crankshaft enco-
trollable. In general, single cylinder diesel test engines have der, pressure and temperature transducers, then generates driving
mechanical unit pump systems and this system have no change- signals of the injectors. Siemens S7-200 series CPU224 PLC is suit-
able parameters. Utilizing common-rail injection instead of able with its 14 digital inputs and 10 digital outputs. An analog
mechanical injection pump can control timing and period. Com- module is attached to the PLC for analog data acquisition [22].
mon-rail mechanisms provide us to employ efficient and flexible In the PLC used as the controller, there are precision timers for
control schemes on the injection system. injection timing, high-speed counters for counting incremental
A.T. Ergenç, D.Özde Koca / Fuel 130 (2014) 273–278 275
Fig. 2. (a) Diesel engine control algorithm and (b) control and feedback signals.
Power
8
7,8
7,6
7,4
7,2
kW
7
6,8
6,6
6,4
6,2
DİESEL DİESEL+10%LPG DİESEL+%20%LPG DİESEL+%25%LPG
3. Experimental setup As it is noted in the Figs. 4 and 5, output torque (Md), energy
(Ne) is increased even though specific fuel consumption (be)
In preliminary experiments, power and torque values are deter- decreased with the LPG addition. The thermal efficiency of the
mined for maximum power and torque output conditions. In cylin- engine (ge) increased. It is also obvious that the quality of the com-
der pressure measurements were recorded with using Kistler 6011 bustion is increased with electronic injection.
pressure transducer, Kistler 5011 type charge amplifier and LeCroy The test results are analyzed and it was found that, an increase
brand digital oscilloscope. Injection, pressure and incremental on performance was observed with the LPG addition. In general,
encoder signals recorded simultaneously with 0, 1 °CA intervals. we obtained maximum power for all the fuels at a spray angel of
The experimental setup is depicted in Fig. 3. 20 CA before TDC. When the diesel injection pressure set to
1400 bar, 7.11 kW of power was obtained at 3000 rpm. At the same
3.1. Experiment procedure engine speed and Injection pressure conditions, diesel + 10% LPG
showed 7.35 kW, diesel + 20% LPG and diesel + 25% LPG showed
Experiments are conducted based on procedure explained 7.70 kW and 7.81 kW respectively. However, reducing the injec-
below: tion advance before the TDC to 17 CA, caused a decrease in the
value maximum power.
(1) Common-rail pressure and advance angle are set.
(2) A speed value is determined and engine speed controller is
set to operate engine at constant speed.
(3) Engine is loaded with DC-motor and until the speed is
decreasing. This point is the operating condition where
engine can generate its maximum torque level for that
speed. If load is increased, speed of the engine decreases
even fuel consumption increases.
Torque
26
25
24
Nm
23
22
21
20
DiESEL DiESEL+10%LPG DiESEL+%20%LPG DiESEL+%25%LPG