You are on page 1of 8

Article

Clinical Rehabilitation
26(5) 423–430
Comparing the effects of eccentric ! The Author(s) 2011
Reprints and permissions:

training with eccentric training sagepub.co.uk/journalsPermissions.nav


DOI: 10.1177/0269215511411114
cre.sagepub.com
and static stretching exercises
in the treatment of patellar
tendinopathy. A controlled
clinical trial

Stasinopoulos Dimitrios1,2,3,, Manias Pantelis4 and


Stasinopoulou Kalliopi1

Abstract
Objective:The aim of the present study was to investigate the effectiveness of eccentric training and
eccentric training with static stretching exercises in the management of patellar tendinopathy.
Design:Controlled clinical trial.
Setting:Rheumatology and rehabilitation centre.
Subjects: Forty-three patients who had patellar tendinopathy for at least three months. They were
allocated to two groups by alternative allocation.
Interventions: Group A (n ¼ 22) was treated with eccentric training of patellar tendon and static
stretching exercises of quadriceps and hamstrings and Group B (n ¼ 21) received eccentric training of
patellar tendon. All patients received five treatments per week for four weeks.
Outcomes:Pain and function were evaluated using the VISA-P score at baseline, at the end of treatment
(week 4), and six months (week 24) after the end of treatment.
Results:At the end of treatment, there was a rise in VISA-P score in both groups compared with baseline
(P<0.0005, paired t test). There were significant differences in the VISA-P score between the groups at
the end of treatment (+14; 10 to 18) and at the six-month follow-up (+19; 13 to 24); eccentric training
and static stretching exercises produced the largest effect (P<0.0005, one-way ANOVA).
Conclusions:Eccentric training and static stretching exercises is superior to eccentric training alone to
reduce pain and improve function in patients with patellar tendinopathy at the end of the treatment and at
follow-up.
Received: 6 November 2010; accepted: 1 May 2011

4
Private Clinic, Ithaki, Greece
1
Private Clinic, Patissia, Athens, Greece Corresponding author:
2
School of Health and Human Sciences, Leeds Metropolitan Stasinopoulos Dimitrios, 16 Orfanidou street, A. Patissia,
University, Leeds, UK Athens 11141, Greece.
3
European University of Cyprus, Nicosia, Cyprus Email: d_stasinopoulos@yahoo.gr
424 Clinical Rehabilitation 26(5)

the most effective treatment in patients with patel-


Introduction lar tendinopathy.
The term patellar tendinopathy refers to painful One of the most common physiotherapy treat-
overuse tendon without implying pathology; it ments for patellar tendinopathy is an exercise pro-
is ideal for clinical diagnosis.1 Patellar tendino- gramme. One consisting of eccentric exercises has
pathy was first referred to as ‘jumper’s knee’. shown good clinical results in patellar10–13 and
This term is not appropriate for clinical diagno- Achilles tendinopathy.14–19 On the other hand,
sis because the condition can occur in athletes eccentric and static stretching exercises seems to
who do not perform jumping in their sports as be an effective treatment for lateral elbow tendi-
well as in people who are not athletes.2 The term nopathy, commonly referred to as tennis elbow or
patellar tendonitis is also incorrect for clinical lateral epicondylitis.20–22 Such an exercise pro-
diagnosis because the condition is degenerative gramme is used as the first treatment option for
rather than inflammatory. This condition is patients with lateral elbow tendinopathy.23
characterized by the increased presence of fibro- To our knowledge, there have been no studies
blasts, vascular hyperplasia, increased amounts to investigate the effectiveness of eccentric and
of proteoglycans and glycosaminoglycans, disor- static stretching exercises in patients with patel-
ganized collagen, absence of inflammatory cells lar tendinopathy. Tightness of hamstring and
and prostaglandin.3 The term patellar tendinosis quadriceps has been found in patients with
refers to pathology of the patellar tendon and patellar tendinopathy as an aetiological factor.
is the best diagnostic term. It is possible to combine eccentric training with
The principal factors that lead to its develop- static stretching exercises to see if the combina-
ment are hard playing surfaces, increased tion of these two therapeutic approaches offers
frequency of training sessions with repetitive superior results to eccentric training alone in
eccentric movement and finally tight hamstring patellar tendinopathy patients. Therefore, the
and quadriceps.4,5 It is most commonly charac- aim of the present article was to make a com-
terized by pain at the inferior pole of the patella, parison of the effects of an exercise programme
although pain can also be at the tibial attach- consisting of eccentric training and an exercise
ment, in the attachment of the tendon to the programme consisting of eccentric training and
superior pole of the patella as well as midsub- static stretching exercises for the treatment of
stance pain has been reported.6–8 The pain can patellar tendinopathy.
be caused by performing a functional activity
such as squat or hop.8
However, no ideal treatment has emerged for
Methods
the management of patellar tendinopathy. Many A controlled, monocentre trial was conducted in
clinicians advocate a conservative approach9 and a clinical setting to assess the effectiveness of an
physiotherapy is usually recommended.2 A wide eccentric training programme and once involv-
array of physiotherapy treatments has been rec- ing eccentric training with static stretching exer-
ommended for the management of patellar tendi- cises. A parallel group design was used because
nopathy such as electrotherapeutic modalities, crossover designs are limited in situations where
exercise programmes, soft tissue manipulation, patients are cured by the intervention and do not
and manual techniques.1 These treatments have have the opportunity to receive the other treat-
different theoretical mechanisms of action, but all ments after crossover.24 Three investigators were
have the same aim, to reduce pain and improve involved in the study: (1) the primary investiga-
function. Such a variety of treatment options sug- tor who administered the treatments (DS); (2) a
gests that the optimal treatment strategy is not medical doctor (KS) who evaluated the patients
known, and more research is needed to discover to confirm the patellar tendinopathy diagnosis;
Stasinopoulos et al. 425

and (3) a physiotherapist (PM) who performed this request was monitored using a treatment
all baseline and follow-up assessments, and diary.
gained informed consent. All assessments were Communication and interaction (verbal and
conducted by PM who was blind to the patients’ non-verbal) between the therapist and patient
therapy group. PM interviewed each patient to was kept to a minimum, and behaviours some-
ascertain baseline demographic and clinical times used by therapists to facilitate positive treat-
characteristics, including patient name, sex, ment outcomes were purposefully avoided. For
age, duration of symptoms, previous treatment, example, patients were given no indication of
occupation, affected leg and dominant leg. the potentially beneficial effects of the treatments
Patients between 18 and 30 years old who or any feedback on their performance in the pre-
were experiencing anterior knee pain were application and post-application measurements.25
examined and evaluated in a private outpatient The eccentric training was the same for both
physiotherapy clinic located in Athens, Greece, groups. As eccentric exercises, participants car-
between September 2003 and September 2007. ried out three sets of 15 repetitions of unilateral
All patients lived in Athens, were native speak- squat on a 25o decline board. The squat was per-
ers of Greek and were either self-referred or formed at a slow speed at every treatment session.
referred by their physician or physiotherapist. The patients counted to 30 during the squat.20 As
The selection criteria for the study were1,3,9: they moved from the standing to the squat posi-
tion, the quadriceps muscle and patellar tendon
. tenderness with palpation over the inferior by inference were loaded eccentrically; no follow-
pole of the patella; ing concentric loading was done, as the nonin-
. no history of trauma to the knee; jured leg was used to get back to the start
. minimum duration of symptoms three months; position. At the beginning the load consisted of
. unsuccessful conservative treatment before the body weight and participants were standing
entering the study, but not in the preceding with all their body weight on the injured leg.
one month; Subjects were told to go ahead with the exercise
. no other current knee or lower extremity prob- even if they experienced mild pain. However, they
lems including anterior knee pain, muscle were told to stop the exercise if the pain became
strains and hip or ankle injuries; disabling. When the squat was pain-free the load
. positive decline squat test.1,3,20 This is a clin- was increased by holding weights in their hands.
ical diagnostic test. Between each set there was a two-minute rest. In
the eccentric training and static stretching exer-
All patients received a written explanation of cises group, static stretching exercises were per-
the trial before entry into the study and then formed as described by Jensen and Di Fabio28
gave signed consent to participate. They were before and after the eccentric training.10 Each
allocated to two groups by sequential, alternate stretch lasted 30 seconds and there was a one-
allocation: the first patient was assigned to the minute rest between each stretch. Each training
eccentric training and static stretching exercises session was to be completed once daily, five times
group, the second to the eccentric training per week, for four weeks and was individualized
group, and so on. on the basis of the patient’s description of pain
All patients were instructed to use their knee experienced during the procedure.28
during the course of the study but to avoid activ- Pain, function and dropout rate were
ities that irritated the joint such as jumping, hop- measured in the present study. Each patient was
ping and running. They were also told to refrain evaluated at baseline (week 0), at the end of treat-
from taking anti-inflammatory drugs throughout ment (week 4) and at six months (week 24) after
the course of study. Patient compliance with the end of treatment.
426 Clinical Rehabilitation 26(5)

The VISA-P questionnaire was used to age (P<0.0005, one-way ANOVA) or the mean
monitor the pain and function of patients. The duration of symptoms (P<0.0005, one-way
instrument is a simple questionnaire, consisted ANOVA) between the groups. Patients had
of eight questions that takes less than five minutes received a wide range of previous treatments
to complete and once patients are familiar with it (Table 1). Drug therapy had been tried by
they will be able to complete most of it themselves. 65%. All patients were non-athletes.
It is a valid and reliable outcome measure for Mean VISA-P score was 45 (95% confidence
patients with patellar tendinopathy.26 interval 32 to 59) for the whole sample at base-
A dropout rate was also used as an indicator line (n ¼ 43; Table 2). There were no significant
of treatment outcome. Reasons for patient drop- differences between the groups for baseline
out were categorized as follows: (1) withdrawal VISA-P score (P>0.05 one-way ANOVA;
without reason, (2) not returned for follow-up, Table 2). At week 4, there was a rise in VISA
and (3) request for an alternative treatment. score of 42 units in the eccentric training and
The change from baseline was calculated for static stretching exercises group and 28 units in
each follow-up. Differences in this change was the eccentric training group with the baseline
calculated between the groups and was deter- (P<0.0005, paired t test; Table 3). There was a
mined using a one-way analysis of variance significant difference in the magnitude of
(one-way ANOVA). Bonferroni post-hoc com- improvement between the groups (P<0.0005,
parisons were conducted when the results from one-way ANOVA, Table 3), so post-hoc tests
the one-way ANOVA were significant to deter- were performed.
mine how the two groups differed. A 5% level of The magnitude of improvement was signifi-
probability was adopted as the level of statistical cantly larger for the eccentric training and
significance. SPSS 11.5 statistical software was static stretching exercises group when compared
used for the statistical analysis (SPSS Inc., with eccentric training group (+14 VISA-P
Chicago, IL, USA). units, Bonferroni, Table 3). Similarly, at week
24 there were comparable magnitudes of
improvement with larger improvements for the
Results eccentric training and static stretching exercises
Sixty-three patients eligible for inclusion visited group than for eccentric training group (P<0.05,
the clinic within the trial period. Twelve were Bonferroni, Table 3).
unwilling to participate in the study, and eight There were no dropouts, no adverse effects
did not meet the inclusion criteria described were referred and all patients successfully com-
above. The other 43 patients were sequentially pleted the study.
allocated to one of the two possible groups:
(a) eccentric training and static stretching exer-
cises (n ¼ 22; 16 men, 6 women; mean (SD) age
Discussion
26.38 (4.32) years; the duration of patellar ten- The eccentric training with static stretching
dinopathy was 5.985 months); (b) eccentric exercises produced the largest effect at the end
training (n ¼ 21; 15 men, 6 women; mean (SD) of the treatment and six months after the end of
age 27.04 (5.11) years; the duration of patellar the treatment. The results obtained from this
tendinopathy was 6.126 months). Patient flow controlled clinical trial are novel; to date, there
through the trial is summarized in a CONSORT have been no data comparing the effectiveness
flowchart (Figure 1). of eccentric training on a 25" decline board
At baseline, there were more men in the with static stretching exercises and eccentric
groups (19 more in total). Patellar tendinopathy training alone for the reduction of pain and
was in the dominant leg in 93% of patients. improvement of function in patellar tendinopa-
There were no significant differences in mean thy in non-athletes between 18 and 30 years old.
Stasinopoulos et al. 427

All patellar tendinopathy patients presenting to the clinic


(n=63)

Unwillingness
(n=12)

Potential participants
(n=51)

Inclusion criteria

Not meeting inclusion


criteria
(n=8)

Eligible patients
(n=43)

Sequential allocation
(n=43)

Eccentric training and Eccentric training


static stretching exercises (n=21)
(n=22)

Completed trial Completed trial


(n=22) (n=21)

Figure 1. Study flowchart.

Standard eccentric exercises offer adequate patients’ symptoms because the opposite has
rehabilitation for tendon disorders, but many shown poor results.28 Eccentric exercises were
patients with tendinopathies do not respond to performed at a low speed in every treatment ses-
this prescription alone.27 The load of eccentric sion because this allows tissue healing.14,29 The
exercises was increased according to the avoidance of painful activities is crucial for
428 Clinical Rehabilitation 26(5)

tendon healing, because training during the programme. There are two types of exercise pro-
treatment period increases patients’ symptoms gramme: home exercise programmes and exer-
and delays tendon healing.30 cise programmes carried out in a clinical
Eccentric training and static stretching exer- setting. The former is commonly advocated for
cises appear to reduce the pain and improve patients with tendinopathies, such as patellar
function, reversing the pathology of tendinopa- tendinopathy, because it can be performed any
thy2,31–33 as supported by experimental studies time during the day without requiring supervi-
on animals.34 The way that eccentric training sion by a physiotherapist. Our clinical experience,
and static stretching exercises achieves the however, has shown that patients fail to comply
goals remains uncertain as there is a lack of with this regimen.23 This problem can be solved
good quality evidence to confirm that physiolog- by exercise programmes performed in a clinical
ical effects translate into clinically meaningful setting under the supervision of a physiotherapist.
outcomes and vice versa. For the purposes of this report, ‘supervised exer-
Eccentric training with or without static cise programme’ will refer to such programmes.
stretching exercises is called an exercise Therefore, such a supervised exercise programme
was used in the present trial.
Previous trials have found that a home exercise
Table 1. Previous treatments of participants programme reduced the pain in patellar,10–13
lateral elbow35 and Achilles14–19 tendinopathy.
Eccentric training
and static stretching Eccentric
However, it was performed for about three
exercises n (%) training n (%) months in all previous studies. In contrast, in
the present controlled clinical trial and the studies
Drugs 14 (63.6) 14 (66.6) of Stasinopoulos and colleagues,20–22 a super-
Physiotherapy 3 (13.63) 1 (4.76) vised exercise programme was administered for
Injection 5 (22.72) 6 (28.57) one month. Thus it seems that the supervised

Table 2. VISA-P score before each evaluation

Week 0 Week 4 Week 24

Eccentric training 44 (95%CI 31 to 58) 86 (95%CI 70 to 94) 94 (95%CI 75 to 100)


and static stretching
exercises
Eccentric training 46 (95%CI 33 to 60) 74 (95%CI 58 to 82) 77 (95%CI 68 to 84)
Values are means (95% confidence interval).

Table 3. Change in VISA-P score

Eccentric training
Eccentric training One-way ANOVA and static stretching
and static stretching Eccentric on change in VISA-P exercises versus
exercises training from baseline Eccentric training

Week 4 +42 (33.3 to 48.6) +28 (24.4 to 33.5) P<0.0005 +14 (*) (10 to 18)
Week 24 +50 (38.9 to 54.5) +31 (26.8 to 36.1) P<0.0005 +19 (*) (13 to 24)
(*) The mean difference is significant at the 0.05 level.
Values are means (95% confidence interval).
Stasinopoulos et al. 429

exercise programme may give good long-term into the analysis of the effectiveness of such a
clinical results in a shorter period of time than a treatment approach in future trials.
home exercise programme. The most likely expla-
nation for this difference is that a supervised exer-
cise programme achieves a higher degree of Clinical messages
patient compliance. Studies to compare the effects . Eccentric training of patellar tendon and
of these two types of exercise programmes are static stretching exercises of quadriceps
required to confirm the findings of the present and hamstrings is superior to eccentric
controlled clinical trial. training alone in non-athletes with patellar
However, this trial does have some shortcom- tendinopathy aged between 18 and 30 years
ings. First, a power analysis was not performed. in terms of reducing pain and improving
Second, although this study was not a random- function.
ized controlled trial because a genuine randomi-
zation procedure was not followed, the use of
sequential allocation to allocate patients to treat-
ment groups allowed a true cause and effect rela- Funding
tion to be demonstrated. Third, no placebo This research received no specific grant from any
(sham) or no treatment group was included in funding agency in the public, commercial, or not-
the present trial. The placebo (sham)/no treat- for-profit sectors.
ment group is important when the absolute effec-
tiveness of a treatment is determined. However, References
the absolute effectiveness of technique-based 1. Kountouris A and Cook J. Rehabilitation of Achilles
interventions is difficult to investigate because a and patellar tendinopathies. Best practice and research
clinical rheumatology. 2007; 21: 295–316.
good and trustworthy placebo (sham)/no treat-
2. Peers E and Lysens J. Patellar tendinopathy in athletes.
ment control for exercise programmes appears Current diagnostic and therapeutic recommendations.
to be difficult or impossible to devise, due in Sports Medicine. 2005; 35: 71–87.
part to difficulties in defining the active element 3. Khan K, Cook J, Taunton J and Bonar F. Overuse
of these treatments. Absolute effectiveness also tendinosis, not tendonitis. The Physician Sportsmed.
2000; 28: 31–46.
does not provide the therapists with information
4. Ferretti A. The epidemiology of jumper’s knee. Sports
as to which is the most appropriate treatment for Med. 1986; 3: 289–295.
the management of a condition, in this case LET. 5. Stanish D, Curwin S and Mandell S. Tendinitis: Its
Finally, the blinding of patients and therapists etiology and treatment, 2nd ed. Oxford: Oxford
would be problematic in that case, if not impossi- University Press, 2000.
6. Molnar T and Fox J. Overuse injuries of the knee in
ble, because patients know if they are receiving
basketball. Clin Sports Med 1993; 12: 349–362.
the exercise programme treatment and therapists 7. Blazina ME, Kerlan RK, Jobe F, Carter VS and Carlson
need to be aware of the treatment to administer it GJ. Jumper’s knee. Orthop Clin North Am 1973; 4:
appropriately. 665–678.
In summary, eccentric training of patellar 8. Cook J, Karim M and Purdam C. Conservative treat-
ment of patellar tendinopathy. Phys Ther Sport 2001; 2:
tendon and static stretching exercises of quadri-
54–65.
ceps and hamstrings had reduced the pain and 9. Khan K, Maffulli N, Coleman D and Cook J. Patellar
improved the function in non-athletes between tendinopathy: Some aspects of basic science and clinical
18 and 30 years old with patellar tendinopathy management. Br J Sports Med 1998; 32: 346–355.
at the end of the treatment and at follow-up. 10. Purdam CR, Johnsson P, Alfredson H, et al. A pilot
study of the eccentric decline squat in the management
Controlled studies are needed to establish the
of painful chronic patellar tendinopathy. Br J Sports
effects and the mechanism of action of such a Med 2004; 38: 395–397.
treatment approach in patellar tendinopathy. A 11. Jonsson P and Alfredson H. Superior results with eccen-
cost-effectiveness analysis should be incorporated tric compared to concentric quadriceps training in patients
430 Clinical Rehabilitation 26(5)

with jumper’s knee: A prospective randomised study. Br J 23. Stasinopoulos D and Johnson MI. Treatment/manage-
Sports Med 2005; 39: 847–850. ment for tendinopathy. Rapid response to Khan et al
12. Young MA, Cook JL, Purdam CR, et al. Eccentric (2002) article Time to abandon the ‘tendinitis’ myth.
decline squat protocol offers superior results at 12 BMJ 2004.
months compared with traditional eccentric protocol 24. Johannsen F, Gam A, Hauschild B, et al. Rebox: An
for patellar tendinopathy in volleyball players. Br adjunct in physical medicine? Arch Phys Med Rehabil
J Sports Med 2005; 39: 102–105. 1993; 74: 438–440.
13. Bahr R, Fossan B, Loken S, et al. Surgical treatment 25. Vicenzino B, Collins and Wright A. The initials effects
compared with eccentric Training for patellar tendino- of a cervical spine manipulative physiotherapy treatment
pathy (jumper’s knee). A randomized, controlled trial. on the pain and dysfunction of lateral epicondylalgia.
J Bone Joint Surg Am 2006; 88: 1689–1698. Pain 1996; 68: 69–74.
14. Alfredson H, Pietila T, Johnson P, et al. Heavy load eccen- 26. Visentini PJ, Khan K, Cook J, et al. The Visa score:
tric calf muscle training for the treatment of chronic An index of severity of symptoms in patients with
Achilles tendinosis. Am J Sports Med 1998; 26: 360–366. jumper’s knee (patellar tendinosis). Victorian institute
15. Mafi N, Lorentzon R and Alfredson H. Superior short- of sport tendon study group. J Sci Med Sport 1998; 1:
term results with eccentric calf muscle training compared 22–28.
to concentric training in a randomized prospective 27. Cannell L, Taunton J, Clement D, et al. A randomized
multicenter study on patients with chronic Achilles clinical trial of the efficacy of drop squats or leg exten-
tendinosis. Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc 2001; sion/leg curls to treat clinically diagnosed jumper’s knee
9: 42–47. in athletes: A pilot study. Br J Sports Med 2001; 35:
16. Niesen-Vertommen SL, Taunton JE, Clement DB, et al. 60–64.
The effect of eccentric versus concentric exercise in the 28. Jensen K and Di Fabio R. Evaluation of eccentric exer-
management of Achilles tendonitis. Clin J Sports Med cise in treatment of patellar tendinitis. Phys Ther 1989;
1992; 2: 109–113. 69: 211–216.
17. Ohberg L, Lorentzon R and Alfredson H. Eccentric train- 29. Kraushaar B and Nirschl R. Current concepts review:
ing in patients with Achilles tendinosis: Normalized Tendinosis of the elbow (tennis elbow). Clinical features
tendon structure and decreased thickness at follow up. and findings of histological immunohistochemical and
Br J Sports Med 2004; 38: 8–11. electron microscopy studies. J Bone Joint Surg 1999;
18. Roos EM, Engstrom M, Lagerquist A, et al. Clinical 81: 259–285.
improvement after 6 weeks of eccentric exercises in 30. Visnes H, Cook J and Bahr R. No effect of eccentric
patients with mid-portion Achilles tendinopathy: A ran- training on Jumper’s knee in volleyball players during
domised trial with 1-year follow-up. Scand J Med Sci the competitive season. A randomized clinical trial. Clin
Sports 2004; 14: 286–295. J Sports Med 2005; 15: 227–234.
19. Silbernager KG, Thomee R, Thomee P, et al. Eccentric 31. Hawary R, Stanish W and Curwin S. Rehabilitation of
overload training with chronic Achilles tendon pain: A tendon injuries in sport. Sports Med 1997; 24: 347–358.
randomized controlled study with reliability testing of 32. Khan KM, Cook JL, Kannus P, et al. Time to abandon
the evaluation methods. Scand J Med Sci Sports 2001; the ‘tendonitis’ myth. BMJ 2002; 324: 626–632.
11: 197–206. 33. Ohberg L, Lorentzon R and Alfredson H.
20. Stasinopoulos D and Stasinopoulos I. Comparison of Neovascularisation in Achilles tendons with painful ten-
effects of exercise programme, pulsed ultrasound and dinosis but not in normal tendons: An ultrasonographic
transverse friction in the treatment of chronic patellar investigation. Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc
tendinopathy. Clin Rehabil 2004; 18: 347–352. 2001; 9: 233–938.
21. Manias P and Stasinopoulos D. A controlled clinical pilot 34. Vilarta R and Vidal BDC. Anisotropic and biomechan-
trial to study the effectiveness of ice as a supplement to ical properties of tendons modified by exercise and
the exercise programme for the management of lateral denervation: Aggregation and macromolecular order in
elbow tendinopathy. Br J Sports Med 2006; 40: 81–85. collagen bundles. Matrix 1989; 9: 55–61.
22. Stasinopoulos D and Stasinopoulos I. Comparison of 35. Pienimaki T, Tarvainen T, Siira P, et al. Progressive
effects of Cyriax physiotherapy, a supervised exercise and strengthening and stretching exercises and ultrasound
polarized polychromatic non-coherent light (Bioptron for chronic lateral epicondylitis. Physiotherapy 1996;
light) for the treatment of lateral epicondylitis. Clin 82: 522–530.
Rehab 2006; 20: 12–23.

View publication stats

You might also like