Professional Documents
Culture Documents
9 Vol. 2 Issue 5 May 2015 IJP RA 4973
9 Vol. 2 Issue 5 May 2015 IJP RA 4973
Received on 14 January 2015; received in revised form, 19 March 2015; accepted, 27 April 2015; published 01 May 2015
protective and corrective and detergency action stability, solid content, ash value, detergency, and
such as Acanthophyllum, Ziziphus, Lawsonia and wetting agent were done. The best quality
ash and so on. However, the first industrial formulation was chosen that has been shown in
production of detergent in Iran was happened Table 1 (F5). The procedure of preparing
in1964 by Tolid Daru Company. At present, there shampoos involves mixing water with EDTA and
are many local companies that are producing guar, glycerin, decyl glucoside, cocamide
cosmetics and toiletries in there. Four famous propylene betain, sodium lauryl ether sulphate and
Iranian companies which normal shampoos chose ammonium lauryl ether sulphate and cocamide
were from them were Kaf, Pakshoo, Negin diethanolamine until solvation respectively and
Behdasht Ariyan, and Cinere Natural Cosmetics followed by heating to 70 °C and then EGMS was
companies. added. After reaching room temperature panthenol,
opacifier, triethanolamine, preservative, and NaCl
Iran is a country that is located in the Middle East was added slowly with continuous stirring
with seventy-five million populations. This country respectively.
is one of the biggest markets for cosmetics and
toiletries and has seven ranking in the world. There Shampoo Evaluation Method:
are many cosmetics and toiletries from Physical Appearance / Visual Inspection: All
international and local companies in this market. chosen shampoos were evaluated for physical
Not only there are many cosmetics and toiletries appearance such as color and odor with smelling
produced by local companies in this country but and visual inspection by ten volunteers 6, 7.
also the export their different products to some
other country. One of the important products in this Determination of pH: The pH of 10% shampoo
country is normal hair shampoo that there are solution in distilled water was determined at room
indifference brands. temperature 25°C 5, 8, 9.
This study aimed to evaluate some characteristic of Rheological Evaluations: The viscosity of the
several famous commercial shampoos for normal shampoos was determined by using Brookfield
hair that are producing in Iran, based on Viscometer (Model DV-l Plus, LV, USA) set at
scientifically measurable properties. The data of different spindle speeds 20 rpm. The viscosity of
this article show scientific information of some the shampoos was measured by using spindle T95
famous and bestsellers shampoo that can be used at speed 20 rpm. The temperature and sample
for different aims, from consumers to cosmetics container’s size was kept constants during study 5, 10.
and toiletries producing companies, and also
Solid Content Determination: 10 g of each
proposed new formulation with better qualification
shampoo was weighed in a tare evaporating dish
for normal hair shampoo such as foam volume,
and kept in a hot air oven at 105 °C. Repeated the
ability to reduce the surface tension, detergency
drying until the constant weight loss was observed
power and wetting time and other physiochemical
after 4 h. The solid content was calculated for each
quantities.
sample 5, 10, 11.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: Four kinds of
Ash Value: Total ash: 2 g of each shampoo was
shampoos, chemicals, shampoo ingredient, a piece
taken and placed in a tarred silica crucible and kept
of cotton, canvas, velvet and Indian ink was
in a muffle furnace at 45 °C until free from carbon,
purchased from the market. Some hair tresses were
this was then cooled and re-weighed. Finally, the
obtained from the salon.
percentage of total ash was calculated 5, 14.
New Shampoo Formulation: With the different
ingredients and varying concentrations of them, Stability Studies: The thermal stability of
several different shampoos formulations for normal shampoos was studied by placing in glass tubes,
hair were prepared and visual assessment and and they were placed in a humidity chamber at
physiochemical controls tests such as Physical 45°C and 75% relative humidity. Their appearance
appearance/visual inspection, pH, dirt dispersion, and physical stability were inspected for one month
9
viscosity, surface tension, foam volume, and foam .
Detergency Ability: There are several methods for pH Value: The pH of shampoos is important for
the determination of detergency ability of improving and enhancing the qualities of hair,
shampoos. Earlier work on detergency evaluation minimizing irritation to the eyes and stabilizing the
was done using greasy wool yarn by brand and ecological balance of the scalp. The pH is one of
powers 19. Later the method changed to evaluating the ways to minimize damage to the hair. Mild
detergency by using 10 mg hair swatch. Thompson acidity prevents swelling and promotes tightening
method used tresses soil with artificial sebum for of the scales, thereby inducing shine. As seen from
determination of detergency power and using of Table 2, all the shampoos were ranged 6 to 7,
gas chromatography data 20. Also in many articles, which is near to the skin pH.
the surface tension of ten percent shampoo solution
is attributed to detergency power, the less surface Rheological Evaluations: Viscosity is the
tension, the more detergency power. thickness or stickiness of a liquid. The viscosity of
shampoo is related at least in part to the number of
In this work, the detergency power was evaluated solids that are present. Product Viscosity plays an
by inspiring of brunet and powers method, but important role in defining and controlling many
there are some improvements on that for a better attributes such as shelf life stability and product
and repeatable response that are near to real hair aesthetics such as clarity and ease of flow of
washing by consumers. For detergency power product for packing and spreading ability of
evaluation a crumple of hair was washed with a 5% shampoos on hair and product consistency in the
sodium lauryl sulfate (SLS) solution, then dried and package. The viscosity of five shampoos change
cut into 10 inches, 2 g swatches. Swatches were from 2100 to 12800 cps that are acceptable,
suspended in an n-hexane solution containing 10% however, F2 shampoo has lower viscosity and
artificial sebum (soya oil 20%, coconut oil 15%, seems watery and F3 shampoo have relatively high
stearic acid 15%, oleic acid 15%, paraffin wax viscosity for shampoo. The volunteers choose F4
15%and lanolin 20%) and the mixture was shaken and F5 more proper in viscosity viewpoint.
for 15 minutes at room temperature. Swatches were
removed, the solvent evaporated at room Solid Content: If a shampoo has too many solids,
temperature, and the dried hair swatch weighed to it will be hard to work into the hair or too hard to
determine the sebum load. wash out. If it doesn’t have enough, it will be too
watery and wash away quickly. The solid content
In one percent solution of each shampoo, a soiled of a good shampoo will be between 20% – 30% by
swatch was washed with 250 ml of one percent weight. Between five candidate shampoos, only F2
solution of each shampoo for 150 seconds in 90 is out of range. It must be pointed out that F2
rotate per minutes by rotary in 40 °C respectively. shampoo has lower viscosity and seems more
It was then dried using a hair dryer and further watery between five candidate shampoos.
dried in an oven at 60 °C for 4 h to ensure uniform
moisture content and re-weighed. Finally, the Ash Value: The total Ash values of five shampoos
percentage of detergency power was calculated were found to be between 2.94- 4.04 w/w Table 2.
using the following equation: in which, DP is the The results showed that F2 and F4 formulations
percentage of detergency power C is the weight of have the lowest and highest ash value respectively
sebum in unwashed swatches, and T is the weight and new shampoo formulation has acceptable ash
of sebum in the swatches after washing. value.
decrease the surface tension of pure water to about dilution for each shampoo is considered as a good
40 dynes/cm 12. Surface tension reduction is one of detergent 13. The results are shown in Table 1. The
the mechanisms implicated in detergency and the only surface tension of F2 formulation is out of
reduction in surface tension of pure water from range, and also our new formulation has the lowest
72.8 dynes/cm to range of 30-40 dynes/ cm of 10% surface tension between five candidate shampoos.
TABLE 2: EVALUATION OF PHYSIOCHEMICAL CHARACTERISTICS OF SHAMPOOS
Parameter F1 F2 F3 F4 F5
Physical Pearl- Brownish Pearl-Light Pearl- Creamy
Appearance Yellow Yellow Yellow White Pearl- White
Fragrance Acceptable Acceptable Acceptable Acceptable Acceptable
pH (10% solution) 6.5 6.0 6.8 7 7
Viscosity 3900 2100 12800 6800 6300
Solid Content% 21.03 22.08 15.14 20.71 23.30
Ash Content% 3.78 2.94 3.97 4.04 3.73
Stability stable stable stable stable stable
Surface Tension 36 43.2 33.1 35.5 32.6
Consuming Cetrimide Volume 6.35 5.05 6.10 6.40 -
Determining of Anionic Surfactant: The total the foam will be difficult to rinse away. It will
anionic surfactant content of commercial shampoos redeposit on the hair. Four shampoos don’t show
(F1-F4) was determined by a titration method with dirt on foam, and F2 shampoo shows light foam in
0,00447 N of cetrimide and shown in Table 1. The the dirt. These results indicate almost no dirt
box for F5 is blank because the total anionic retained in the foam; so new and marketed
surfactant content is shown in Table 1. formulations are satisfactory.
Foaming Ability and Foam Stability: Although, Wetting Time: The rate of wetting or wetting
foam generation has little to do with the cleansing ability of the surface-active agent is commonly
ability of shampoos, it has high importance to the used to determine their comparative efficacies.
consumer and is, therefore, an important criterion Wetting phenomena are complex and depend upon
in evaluating shampoos. All the five shampoos several processes and factors such as diffusion,
showed foaming volume between 272-386 cm3 in surface tension, concentration and the nature of the
distilled water Table 3. All five shampoos showed surface is wet. Each wetting agent has to reduce
comparable foaming properties. This value being surface tension. By comparing of results in Table 3
stable almost 10 min, so all these products were it can be seen that F3 and F5 have minimum
good regarding this parameter. wetting time respectively and F2 showed the more
wetting time. These results are corresponding with
It has been seen that the new formulation shampoo surface tension data.
showed more foam volume than commercial
shampoos that can be more acceptable for Detergency Ability: Some cosmetic chemists think
consumers. This fact is maybe due to the presence that shampoo should not be so powerful a detergent
of foam stabilizing ingredient in shampoos such as as to strip all natural secretions from the hair and
cocamide monoethanolamide and cocamide scalp. Although cleaning or soil/sebum removal is
diethanolamine. A point to be noted here is that the primary aim of a shampoo, experimental
there does not seem to be any direct correlation detergency evaluation has been difficult to
between detergency and foaming, which only standardize, as there is no real agreement on a
confirms the fact that a shampoo that foams well standard soil, a reproducible soiling process or the
need not to clean well. amount of soil a shampoo should ideally remove.
The targets of these testing shampoos are normal
Dirt Dispersion: Shampoo that causes the ink to hairs which have moderate soil on themselves. The
concentrate on the foam is considered poor quality; detergency ability of normal hair shampoos not to
the dirt should stay in the water. Dirt that stays in be so high or very low. The detergency ability of
normal hair shampoo must be higher than dry hair when compared with the marketed formulations. It
shampoos and lower than greasy hair shampoos; in was found between the detergency power range of
other words, the normal hair needs normal marketed normal hair shampoo. Therefore new
detergency. As seen from the results, there is a ring formulation shampoo could be classified as
in the amount of sebum removed from 62% to 80% ‘shampoo for normal hair.’ If detergency ability
by the marketed shampoos. The results of range of this marketed shampoos for normal hair
detergency studies showed that new formulation were chosen as the standard. The results are
(F5) has significantly medium detergency ability presented in Table 3.
TABLE 3: EVALUATION OF SHAMPOOING ABILITY
Parameter F1 F2 F3 F4 F5
Foam Volume (cm3) 272.90 288.20 311.15 334.11 385.12
Foam Stability % 94 94 95 96 96
Dirt Dispersion None Light None None None
Wetting Time (s) 31.6 41.3 26.5 29.3 27.2
Detergency Ability % 80 62 75 78 72
15. Preethi P, Padmini K, Srikanth J, Lohita M, Swetha K and 18. Chen YF, Yang CH, Chang MS, Ciou YP and Huang YC:
Vengal Rao P: A review on herbal shampoo and its Foam properties and detergent abilities of the saponins
evaluation. Asian Journal of Pharmaceutical Analysis from Camellia oleifera. International Journal of Molecular
2013; 3: 153-156. Sciences 2010; 11: 4417-4425.
16. Gorantla N, Prasad SK, Reddy TVT, Ragadeepika J, 19. Barnett G and Powers DH: Factors contributing to the
Hajarabi T and Ahad HA: Formulation and evaluation of performance of shampoos and to customer acceptance,
herbal shampoo containing chamomile, rose and orange Proceedings of the Scientific Section of the Toilet Goods
peel. International Journal of Medicine and Pharmaceutical Association 1995; 24: 24-28.
Research 2013; 1: 192-197. 20. Thompson D, Lemaster C, Allen R and Whittam J:
17. Draves CZ: Evaluation of wetting agents official methods. Evaluation of relative shampoo detergency. Journal of the
American Dyestuff Reporter 1939; 28: 421-424. Society of Cosmetic Chemists 1985; 36: 271-286.
This Journal licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Non-commercial-Share Alike 3.0 Unported License.
This article can be downloaded to ANDROID OS based mobile. Scan QR Code using Code/Bar Scanner from your mobile. (Scanners are
available on Google Playstore)