Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ABSTRACT
Purpose: The study focused to conduct a comprehensive comparative analysis between social
media marketing and Traditional media marketing.
Theoretical Framework: The theoretical framework for this research on the comparative
analysis of traditional media and social media consists of a series of contrasting statements that
explore key dimensions like attractive advertising, informative advertising, reliability
advertising etc. aiming to elucidate the distinct characteristics and implications of each
marketing approach.
Findings: Research results found that there is a significant difference between social media
marketing and Traditional media marketing. The social media marketing is more preferred by
customers over Traditional media marketing.
Conclusion: Based on the research findings, the study intends contribute to a deeper
understanding of the evolving landscape of marketing strategies and assists businesses in
making informed decisions regarding choice of marketing channel in a small state like Manipur.
Originality/ Value: The study lies in the holistic exploration of the contrasting dynamic between
social media marketing and traditional media marketing. The study also enhances our insights
into optimizing marketing decisions and harnessing the synergies between these two distinct
yet interconnected avenues in the evolving landscape of media strategies.
Received: 26/06/2023
Accepted: 22/09/2023
DOI: https://doi.org/10.55908/sdgs.v11i8.1498
Orcid: https://orcid.org/0000-0001-8039-6815
1
Miami| v.11, n. 8| pages: 01-16| e01498 |2023. JOURNAL OF LAW AND SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT
Loitongbam, S., Sorokhaibam, R., Singh, S. S. (2023). Social Media as a Marketing Tool
RESUMO
Objetivo: O estudo se concentrou em realizar uma análise comparativa abrangente entre o
marketing de mídia social e o marketing de mídia tradicional.
Estrutura Teórica: O marco teórico desta pesquisa sobre a análise comparativa dos meios de
comunicação tradicionais e mídias sociais consiste em uma série de afirmações contrastantes
que exploram dimensões-chave como publicidade atraente, publicidade informativa,
publicidade de confiabilidade, etc. com o objetivo de elucidar as características distintas e
implicações de cada abordagem de marketing.
Conclusão: Com base nos resultados da pesquisa, o estudo pretende contribuir para uma
compreensão mais profunda do panorama em evolução das estratégias de marketing e auxilia
as empresas a tomar decisões informadas sobre a escolha do canal de marketing em um pequeno
estado como Manipur.
1 INTRODUCTION
The Internet is defined as an interconnection of networks worldwide operated by
different communities, institutions, academics, and private organizations. Internet since
1994 has expanded in serving millions of users. The improvement of mobile technology
has made it possible for greater reach of the internet and increased the number of users.
In this era of the internet, marketers also aimed to look for strategies that include
influencing of customers to purchase their goods that ensure profitability. Marketing is
about meeting the needs and requirements of customers. Traditional marketing is a form
of marketing that uses offline media to reach the audience. The promotion is done
through Newspaper Television, E-mail, text- messages, Billboards etc. The Social media
marketing on the other hand is a form of digital marketing that allows marketers to build
Miami| v.11, n. 8| pages: 01-16| e01498 |2023. JOURNAL OF LAW AND SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT
Loitongbam, S., Sorokhaibam, R., Singh, S. S. (2023). Social Media as a Marketing Tool
company brand, increase sales and share information. The promotions of social media
marketing are done through Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, YouTube, Linked In etc.
In many previous studies, social media marketing has made companies possible
to reach targeted consumers easily, effectively, and efficiently. The marketers are
beginning to understand the use of social media is a vital component in their strategies
and campaign to reach out to customers. The marketing firms can also provide unlimited
information to users and customers without human intervention. The study has been
conducted to understand the perception of customers towards social media marketing and
try to compare Social Media Marketing and Traditional Media marketing and analyze
which marketing media is more important in the present market situation in Manipur.
2 LITERATURE REVIEW
2.1 SOCIAL MEDIA MARKETING
The integration of social media can have a substantial positive impact for a
corporate entity and it has also become an important part of the company operational
Miami| v.11, n. 8| pages: 01-16| e01498 |2023. JOURNAL OF LAW AND SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT
Loitongbam, S., Sorokhaibam, R., Singh, S. S. (2023). Social Media as a Marketing Tool
strategy in the context of Global Business Environment (Abuhashesh, 2014). social media
has various merits but also has demerits which affect people negatively. False information
may lead to failure of education system, false advertisement may affect productivity.
Some unnecessary blogs can influence to take wrong actions. (Shabnoor Siddiqui, 2016;
Shabnoor Siddiqui, 2016). social medias apps and sites like WhatsApp, Facebook and
Instagram (Ojeleye, Opusunju, Ahmed, & Aku, 2018) should be encouraged as it
contributed positively on entrepreneurship development. (Edosomwan, Kalangot
Prakasan, Kouame, & Seymour, 2011) Social Media is a cost-effective tool and should
be used wisely, improving communications, considered customer’s queries otherwise it
would lose business brand loyalty and reliability. (Motwani, Shrimall, & Agarwal,
2014)identified that consumers are ready to share their preferences and likes in social
media which in turn help in business in targeting customers more efficiently.(Wilert &
Suchart, 2021) suggested that Digital Social Responsibility must be considered as one of
their business strategies as many firms are now have their social responsibility in digital
platforms and this resulted to be more successful method for encouragement of potential
customers and word of mouth. Trust, e-word of mouth, trendiness, entertainment,
customer online engagement has a positive impact on brand loyalty mediating with
consumer Perception and Purchase Intention (Vasanthakumar, Ferdous, & Jacquiline,
2023). (Saravanan & Rajasekaran, 2023) considered Digital marketing tools as one of the
opportunities to connect with customers and attract them.
Miami| v.11, n. 8| pages: 01-16| e01498 |2023. JOURNAL OF LAW AND SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT
Loitongbam, S., Sorokhaibam, R., Singh, S. S. (2023). Social Media as a Marketing Tool
response in their own way. Both have their own pros and cons. Choosing the best
approach depend on the type of business and depend on people, also the reason why they
want to use it.
Table 1: Cross-tabulation between different social media sites used and Involvement in Decision Making
Involvement in Decision making
To moderate
Never To great extent Completely
extent
count % count % count % count % Total
Very
1 1.30% 24 31.60% 36 47.40% 15 19.70% 76
Rarely
Rarely 1 1.70% 30 50% 20 33.33% 9 15.50% 60
Average 5 4.10% 46 38% 59 48.80% 11 9.10% 121
Facebook Frequently 7 9.50% 28 37.8 27 36.5 12 16.20% 74
Very
1 3.10% 6 18.80% 15 46.90% 10 31.30% 32
Frequently
363
Very
0 0% 13 37.10% 18 51.50% 4 11.40% 35
Rarely
Rarely 3 7.50% 19 47.50% 11 27.50% 7 17.50% 40
Average 4 4.40% 35 38.50% 34 37.40% 18 19.80% 91
Frequently 6 4.60% 50 38.20% 55 42% 20 15.30% 131
Very
Instagram 2 3.00% 17 25.80% 39 59.10% 8 12.10% 66
Frequently
363
Very
10 4.00% 100 40.20% 104 41.80% 34 13.70% 249
Rarely
Rarely 2 3.90% 21 41.20% 21 41.20% 7 13.70% 51
Average 2 4.50% 12 27.30% 1 2.30% 19 43.20% 44
LinkedIn Frequently 1 7.7 1 7.70% 7 53.80% 4 30.80% 13
Very
0 0.00% 0 0.00% 4 66.70% 2 33.30% 6
Frequently
363
Very
12 4.80% 100 39.70% 98 42 16.70% 252
Rarely
Miami| v.11, n. 8| pages: 01-16| e01498 |2023. JOURNAL OF LAW AND SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT
Loitongbam, S., Sorokhaibam, R., Singh, S. S. (2023). Social Media as a Marketing Tool
Interpretation: The division shows based on the use of different social media sites
by customers. There were 76 very rare users of Facebook. Nearly half, i.e., 47.4% of the
total Very rarely users involved in decision-making to a great extent. Among the 60 total
rare users of Facebook, 50% of it participated in decision-making to a moderate extent.
Among the 121 average users, almost half of it i.e., 48.8% Involved in decision-making
to a great extent. There were 74 frequent users, 37.8% of the total, involved in decision-
making to a moderate extent, and 36.5% involved in decision-making to a great extent.
The very frequent users of Facebook constituted 32 customers, 46.9% of the total
users participated in decision-making to a great extent.
Out of the total 363, Instagram users, 131 of it, uses Instagram very Frequently
and 91 customers use Instagram frequently. 51.5 % of the total very rarely users
participated to a great extent. 47.5% of the total rarely users involved in decision-making
to a moderate extent. Out of the total average users of Instagram, 38.5% being the highest
take part in the decision-making to a moderate extent. 42% of the total frequent users, are
involved in decision-making to a great extent. More than half of the frequent users of
Instagram i.e., 59.1% have taken part in the decision-making to a great extent.
Very rarely, the customer uses LinkedIn and Twitter. There were only 13
Frequently users and 6 Very frequently users in LinkedIn and 13 Frequent users and 3
Very Frequent users in the case of Twitter. However, more than half of the LinkedIn users
of both Frequently and Very Frequently took part in decision-making to a great extent.
Also, more than half of the Rarely, Average and Very Frequently users of Twitter are
involved in decision-making to a great extent.
Miami| v.11, n. 8| pages: 01-16| e01498 |2023. JOURNAL OF LAW AND SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT
Loitongbam, S., Sorokhaibam, R., Singh, S. S. (2023). Social Media as a Marketing Tool
Table 2: Cross Tabulation of different social media sites use and Search for Products of Interest
Searching product of Interest
Never To moderate To Completely Total
extent great
extent
Count 6 30 29 11 76
Very 7.9% 39.5% 38.2% 14.5% 100%
Rarely
Count 2 24 28 6 60
Rarely 3.3% 40% 46.7% 10% 100%
Count 9 52 46 14 121
Facebook Average 7.4% 43% 38% 11.6% 100%
Count 0 30 37 7 74
Frequently 0% 40.5% 50% 9.5% 100%
Count 0 9 14 9 32
Very 0% 28.1% 43.8% 28.1% 100%
Frequently
Count 5 15 12 3 35
Very 14.3% 42.9% 34.3% 8.6% 100%
Rarely
Count 3 13 20 4 40
Rarely 7.5% 32.5% 50% 10% 100%
Count 3 47 28 13 91
Instagram Average 3.3% 51.6% 30.8% 14.3% 100%
Count 5 52 62 12 131
Frequently 3.8% 39.7% 47.3% 9.2% 100%
Count 1 17 33 15 66
Miami| v.11, n. 8| pages: 01-16| e01498 |2023. JOURNAL OF LAW AND SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT
Loitongbam, S., Sorokhaibam, R., Singh, S. S. (2023). Social Media as a Marketing Tool
Interpretation: Out of the total frequently and very frequently users of Facebook
51.4% and 43.8% customers searches their product of Interest to a great extent
respectively. Out of the total Instagram Average users 51.6% search product of interest
to moderate extent. 47.3% and 50 % of Frequently and Very frequently users searches
their product of Interest to a great extent. 69.2% of the frequently users of LinkedIn use
Linked In to a great extent for searching their product of Interest and 66.7% of the total
Very Frequently users of Twitter search for their product of interest to a great extent.
7,4
18,2
10,7
16,8
46,8
Strongly Disagree Disagree Neither agree nor disagree Agree Strongly Agree
Miami| v.11, n. 8| pages: 01-16| e01498 |2023. JOURNAL OF LAW AND SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT
Loitongbam, S., Sorokhaibam, R., Singh, S. S. (2023). Social Media as a Marketing Tool
Figure 2: I bring up several likes/ dislikes while considering any goods or services.
60,0
50,0 47,9
40,0
30,0
20,7
20,0 16,8
9,6
10,0 5,0
0,0
Strongly Disagree Disagree Neither agree nor Agree Strongly Agree
disagree
Figure 3: I share the links of my favorite brands with friends and relatives using social networking sites
8,0
16,0
11,3
17,9
46,8
Strongly Disagree Disagree Neither agree nor disagree Agree Strongly Agree
Miami| v.11, n. 8| pages: 01-16| e01498 |2023. JOURNAL OF LAW AND SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT
Loitongbam, S., Sorokhaibam, R., Singh, S. S. (2023). Social Media as a Marketing Tool
Interpretation: 46.8% of the total respondents share the links of their favorite
brands with friends and relatives using social networking sites indicating that many
respondents are endorsing or recommending those brands to their social circle. Word of
mouth can influence others’ opinions and potentially lead to increase customer
engagement for the brands being shared. It’s a way that expresses their preferences and
potentially helps their friends to discover products or services they might be interested in.
To achieve hypothesis 1 of the study “social media marketing is preferred by
consumers over Traditional media marketing”.
Consumers are asked to provide ratings from 1-5 on 9 items of Social Media
Marketing and Traditional media marketing. The item includes 1. Interesting and
attractive advertisements, 2. Interactive advertisements, 3. Informative advertisements, 4.
Reliable advertisements, 5. Ability to change views about the products, 6. The long-
lasting effect on the perception of a brand or product,7. Fast spreading advertisements, 8.
Reach the target population, 9. credibility.
The hypothesis is tested by taking the total score obtained by Social Media
Marketing channel (Group 1) and Traditional marketing channel (Group 2).
Miami| v.11, n. 8| pages: 01-16| e01498 |2023. JOURNAL OF LAW AND SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT
Loitongbam, S., Sorokhaibam, R., Singh, S. S. (2023). Social Media as a Marketing Tool
Interpretation: Using the Mann-Whitney U test, it is found that the mean rank
value for group 1 (Social Media marketing channels) is 522.10, and for group 2
(traditional media marketing ) is 204.90. The mean rank of Group 1 is more than Group
2. Also, The result of the statistics shows that the p-value is 0.000 which is less than 0.05
and therefore we reject the null hypothesis and revealed that social media marketing is
preferred by consumers over traditional channels of marketing.
To achieve hypothesis 2, “All marketing channels are not equally preferred by
consumers for buying decisions.”
Kruskal Wallis Test and Mann Whitney test are done on the total score of both
social media and Traditional media. In the above diagram, group 1 represents the social
media channels and group 2 refers to the Traditional Media.
Interpretation: The Kruskal Wallis test result shows the comparisons between
different social networking sites (Social Media Channels and Traditional Media
Channels, P value = 0.000 shows that there is a significant difference between the use of
social networking sites and traditional sites by customers for a purchase decision.
11
Miami| v.11, n. 8| pages: 01-16| e01498 |2023. JOURNAL OF LAW AND SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT
Loitongbam, S., Sorokhaibam, R., Singh, S. S. (2023). Social Media as a Marketing Tool
12
Miami| v.11, n. 8| pages: 01-16| e01498 |2023. JOURNAL OF LAW AND SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT
Loitongbam, S., Sorokhaibam, R., Singh, S. S. (2023). Social Media as a Marketing Tool
LinkedIn 257.61
0.000
Television 469.39 104,324.000
LinkedIn 349.45
0.056
E-mail 377.55 70,984.000
LinkedIn 360.23
0.658
Text-messages 366.77 67.071.000
LinkedIn 448.53
0.000
Billboards 278.47 35,017
LinkedIn 308.20
0.000
YouTube 418.80 85,959.500
YouTube 321.16
0.000
Newspaper 405.84 81,252.500
YouTube 311.00
0.000
Television 416.00 84,943.500
YouTube 403.73
0.000
E-mail 323.27 51282.500
YouTube 411.68
0.000
Text messages 315.32 48,395.500
YouTube 481.32
23,117.500 0.000
Billboards 245.68
Source: Computed from Primary
13
Miami| v.11, n. 8| pages: 01-16| e01498 |2023. JOURNAL OF LAW AND SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT
Loitongbam, S., Sorokhaibam, R., Singh, S. S. (2023). Social Media as a Marketing Tool
services and they also agreed to sharing links of their favorite brands with friends and
relatives using social networking sites. The analysis of both Traditional Media marketing
and social media marketing reveals significant insights and differences between the two.
It was found out that social media marketing is preferred by customers over traditional
media marketing. Also, the paper proves that customers does not equally prefer all
marketing sites for buying decisions. By examining the result, the study underscores the
undeniable influence of social media platforms in today’s marketing landscape, with their
ability to engage and interact with audiences in ways that traditional media cannot
replicate. Although the social media marketing has various strengths over traditional
media marketing. Nevertheless, the traditional media marketing still retain its significance
particularly for more broader audience. In conclusion, social media marketing is a
dynamic and ever-evolving field. Staying ahead of technological trends will always
captivate audiences in an increasing and digital connected world.
14
Miami| v.11, n. 8| pages: 01-16| e01498 |2023. JOURNAL OF LAW AND SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT
Loitongbam, S., Sorokhaibam, R., Singh, S. S. (2023). Social Media as a Marketing Tool
REFERENCES
Arunprakash, G, A. K., Raj, A., & Dr.Vasudevan. (2021, May 10). A Comparative Study
On Digital Marketing Over Traditional Marketing. Turkish Journal of Computer and
Mathematics Education, 12(11), 6483-6491.
Edosomwan, S., Kalangot Prakasan, S., Kouame, D., & Seymour, T. (2011). the History
of Social Media and its impact on Busines. The Journal Of Applied Management and
Entrepreneurship, 16(3), 79-91.
Hasa. (2020, April 30). Difference between Traditional Media and Social Media. Peddia.
Kumar, B. P., & Akhilesh, K. (2020). Traditional Vs Digital Marketing: A comparative
study. ZENITH International Journal of Multidisciplinary Research, 10(12), 16-26.
Motwani, D., Shrimall, D. D., & Agarwal, M. K. (2014, April). Customers Attitude
Towards Social Media Marketing. Journal of Business Management and Social Science,
3(4).
Ojeleye, y. C., Opusunju, M. I., Ahmed, A. I., & Aku, s. (2018, October). Impact of Social
Media on Entrepreneurship development among users in Zamfara State. Journal of
Economic and Finance, 2(2), 1-24.
Shabnoor Siddiqui, T. S. (2016). Social Media it impact with positive and Negative
Aspects. International Journal of Computer Applications, Technology and Research,
5(2), 71-75. doi:http://dx.doi.org/10.7753/IJCATR0502.1006
Simplilearn. (2023, August 9). Traditional Marketing Vs Digital Marketing : Which one
is better?
Vasanthakumar, K., Ferdous, A., & Jacquiline, T. (2023, May 8). FACTORS
INFLUENCING OF SOCIAL MEDIA ON CONSUMER PERCEPTION AND
PURCHASE INTENTION TOWARDS BRAND LOYALTY: A CONCEPTUAL
PAPER. International Journal Of Professional Business Review, 1-22.
doi:https://doi.org/10.26668/businessreview/2023.v8i5.1571
15
Miami| v.11, n. 8| pages: 01-16| e01498 |2023. JOURNAL OF LAW AND SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT
Loitongbam, S., Sorokhaibam, R., Singh, S. S. (2023). Social Media as a Marketing Tool
Wilert, P., & Suchart, T. (2021, October 25). UNDERSTANDING DIGITAL SOCIAL
RESPONSIBILITY IN THE SOCIAL MEDIA CONTEXT: EVIDENCE FROM
THAILAND. International Journal of Professional Business Review, 1-14.
doi:https://doi.org/10.26668/businessreview/2023.v8i5.1571
16
Miami| v.11, n. 8| pages: 01-16| e01498 |2023. JOURNAL OF LAW AND SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT