Professional Documents
Culture Documents
OPEN
Received: 19 junio, 2020 ▶ Accepted: 18 August, 2020 ▶ Online first: 22 October, 2020
NARRATIVE REVIEW
doi: https://doi.org/10.5554/22562087.e951
Abstract
What do we know about this Post-dural puncture headache is a frequent complication in neuraxial approaches. It may result
problem? in disability, healthcare dissatisfaction and potentially serious complications. The traditional
initial management includes general and analgesia measures with poor evidence. The treatment
Post-dural puncture headache is the
approach best supported by the literature is the epidural blood patch for which rates of up 70%
most common complication in neuraxial
improvement have been reported. Regional techniques have been recently described that may
anesthesia and analgesia techniques.
The epidural blood patch is considered be helpful because they are less invasive than the epidural blood patch, under certain clinical
the standard of care for the management circumstances. This article suggests an algorithm that uses such techniques for the management
of this complication, but there are still of this complication.
a few controversial areas regarding its
implementation. Keywords
Post-dural puncture headache; epidural blood patch; nerve block; sphenopalatine ganglion;
greater occipital nerve.
What is the contribution by this
article?
Over the past decade, regional techniques
have been described that may offer
other options under specific clinical Resumen
conditions, that may and should be added
La cefalea pospunción dural es una complicación frecuente del abordaje del neuroeje. Puede
to the therapeutic armamentarium but
producir incapacidad, insatisfacción con la atención en salud y complicaciones potencialmente
anesthesiologists are not well aware of
these techniques. graves. Tradicionalmente su manejo inicial incluye medidas generales y de analgesia las cuales
tienen baja evidencia. La medida para su tratamiento, con mejor soporte en la literatura, es la
realización de parche hemático, el cual informa tazas de mejoría hasta del 70 %. Recientemente se
han descrito técnicas regionales, que pueden resultar útiles por ser menos invasivas que el parche
hemático, en ciertos contextos clínicos. En este artículo se propone un algoritmo que permite
incorporar dichas técnicas al manejo de esta complicación.
However, only two clinical controlled trials and helps with migraine-type headache, in small series of cases for injection into
have assessed its effectiveness, showing but there is no evidence about its efficacy the epidural space; however, there are no
benefit only during the first few hours. in PDPH. (7) controlled clinical trials to ascertain their
Additionally, the need to use the epidural safety and therefore their routine use is
blood patch was not avoided in the not recommended. (8) Another approach
obstetric patients treated with caffeine, Epidural blood patch described in the literature is the use of
though the pain scored did improve, at epidural morphine; but although some
least over the first few hours. (5,8) The oral This technique is based on injecting trials report improvement in PDPH, it
or IV dose administered should be of 300 to autologous blood into the epidural space, may increase the incidence of nausea and
500 mg/day, with a maximum of 900 mg in through a needle, in order to create a vomiting. Moreover, a potential increased
24 hours, to avoid adverse reactions, such as mechanical sealant effect on the existing risk of respiratory depression has been
insomnia, anxiety, and even seizures, and dural defect. Most patients experience mentioned, because of the potential of the
preventing crossing into the maternal milk. immediate symptom relief, which leads to opioid crossing into the intrathecal space,
(8) While in Colombia the IV presentation the conclusion that the increased lumbar through the dural defect.
of this drug is not available and the canal volume immediately increases the Some authors have researched the use
available oral presentations are not enough CSF pressure. of the epidural blood patch as prophylaxis;
to complete the recommended daily dose, Many aspects about this technique this means, through the epidural catheter,
taking one cup of coffee – which contains have been controversial in the literature, before its removal and after the occurrence
in average 50 to 100 mg of caffeine with an including the optimal timing, the volume of an accidental dural tear. The studies
availability of almost 100% through this and the substance to be injected, inter alia. to assess this approach exhibit several
route -, represents a treatment option. (5) This therapeutic option, though design flaws and hence the evidence is
Conventional analgesics such as invasive, is the approach with the best not conclusive. The prophylactic use of
non-steroid anti-inflammatory agents evidence in terms of improving pain the epidural blood patch is therefore nor
and acetaminophen, are also routinely and duration over time (2,6); hence, it recommended for the time being. (6)
prescribed as part of the management should always be considered part of The relief of symptoms using the blood
approach, although their level of evidence the management algorithm. When the patch may be explained through several
for the treatment of this complication is conservative approaches fail and severe mechanisms: first, the sealant effect of the
low. (5) Whilst conventional analgesia pain persists, the epidural blood patch blood plug on the dural orifice prevents
does not relieve the etiology of PDPH, if should be considered, since inadequate the ongoing CSF leak and generates
the intensity of the symptoms warrants and delayed PDPH therapy may have an inflammatory reaction that also
the prescription of more potent analgesics serious short and long term consequences, contributes to close the defect. However,
such as opioids, this should be done at least such as venous sinus thrombosis, subdural the improvement of the headache is in
until a definitive control or treatment of the hematoma, hearing loss, paralysis of the most cases immediate and this is not
symptoms is achieved. (8) cranial nerves and chronic headache. (6,11) explained only via this mechanism, since
In contrast to the above-mentioned Just as with any medical procedure the risk the CSF volume reestablishes at a rate of
drugs, steroids and hydrocortisone in and benefits should be clearly explained 0.5 ml/hr. Second, the increased pressure
particular, have shown better results in to the patient, since the success rate is inside the spinal canal when transferred
clinical controlled trials. Their mechanism only around 70 %. (12) Emphasis should into the intracranial space, causes cerebral
of action in this condition is unknown, but be made in the potential need repeat the vasoconstriction, and hence offset the
the effect is attributed to the action on procedure for total symptom relief. mechanisms causing the headache. (6,12)
the hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal axis, Injection of crystalloids into the epidural The perfect timing for an epidural
which includes an increased production of space has been assessed as a prophylactic blood patch has also been controversial.
CSF due to the active transport of sodium, and therapeutic measure for PDPH, either Some retrospective trials have suggested
the expansion of the blood volume and in bolus or as a continuous infusion. The that the efficacy of the patch drops if it is
the release of aldosterone and increased increased spinal canal pressure may done during the first 48 hours following the
production of ß endorphins in the brain. (5) result in transient headache relief, but puncture, and patients should be warned
The regimens suggested in the clinical trials the downside is that these substances are about this. The suggestion is then that
recommend doses of 100 mg every 8 hours rapidly absorbed from the epidural space is the symptoms are not too severe, and
for 48 hours. and fail to result in sustained improvement. there are no alarm signals, conservative
Sumatriptan (a serotonin receptor (8,13) Several colloids such as dextran, management should be administered
agonist) causes cerebral vasoconstriction starch and gelatins have been assessed for a sensible period of time, since the
4 /7 colombian journal of anesthesiology. 2021;49:e951.
conditions tends to improve spontaneously, puncture to be left between 12 to 24 hours The greater occipital nerve originates at
particularly when the PDPH is the result of a after the puncture. Similar to the previous the medial root of the dorsal branch of
spinal puncture. Moreover, if the symptoms discussion, the evidence is controversial. C2. It ascends after emerging through
are severe and may be attributed to a large Some authors have pointed to the lack of the suboccipital triangle, below the
dural defect, the epidural blood patch high quality clinical controlled trials that major oblique muscle of the head and
should be an early therapeutic approach, enable a clear conclusion about this issue. becomes superficial between 2.5 and 5 cm
since the likelihood of improving with In 2010, Bradbury et al said that the existing inferolateral to the occipital protuberance. It
conservative measures is poor and the risk literature was far from proving that this innervates the skin, the muscles and vessels
of serious complications is higher. (12) practice was of any real use. (14) of the scalp, all the way to the vertex where its
Nonetheless, this early approach may A meta-analysis published in 2013 starts sharing territory with the ophthalmic
unfortunately increase the risk of having to suggested a reduction in the need to use branch of the trigeminal nerve. (5,18)
repeat the procedure to achieve complete the epidural blood patch in obstetric Blocking the greater occipital nerve
improvement of symptoms. patients with a spinal catheter; however, in the presence of PDPH helps by a
The puncture site to do the patch should no reduction in the incidence of PDPH was neuromodulation effect and decreased
be the same where the initial puncture was actually shown. (6) While this procedure central sensitivity resulting from the
performed or one level below, since the could impact the mechanisms leading irritation of the meninges and the
injection of contrast medium and the study to PDPH, generating an inflammatory paraspinal muscles, blocking the afferent
of the contrast spread into the epidural reaction around the continuity solution fibers to the dorsal horn of the spinal
space, have shown that the injected fluid and avoiding a new puncture to relocate cord. Additionally, the sensitive neurons
spreads mostly in a cephalic direction. (12) the epidural catheter, the risks and of the upper cervical cord are close to the
trigeminal caudal nucleus, and hence its
In terms of the blood volume injected, benefits should always be balanced. This
afferences may also be blocked with this
the literature suggests that the optimum practice should not be adopted in centers
technique. (18)
amount ranges between 15 and 20 cm3, without an adequate protocol for obstetric
An ultrasound guided block requires
and above this volume the risks may exceed analgesia, since any mistakes in the
a high-frequency lineal transducer,
the benefits. If the patient experiences administration of the dose and the volume
preferably a needle to block the peripheral
lumbar pain during the injection, it must of drugs may lead to serious and potentially nerve, 0.5% bupivacaine with epinephrine
be discontinued. (1,6,12) If despite placing a fatal complications. 1:200.000: 3-5 ml as local anesthetic agent,
second blood patch the headache relapses, and 1 mg of dexamethasone; steroid use
the diagnosis should be reconsidered. (7) is recommended to prolong the duration
Some of the complications of the Regional techniques as an option to of the block. The use of hypodermic
epidural blood patch described in the the epidural blood patch needles is also described in the literature to
literature include back ache, though usually administer the block, since these needles
it is self-limited. Mention has been made There are some clinical scenarios in which can be visualized easily under ultrasound
of the development of facial paralysis, the patient may refuse treatment with and the risk of neurological damage with
permanent spastic paraparesis, cauda an epidural blood patch (for example this block is minimal; moreover, these
equina syndrome and meningitis, though Jehovah’s witnesses), or they may be a needles are less expensive than a block
the latter is usually associated with a poor contraindication for its use. Less invasive needle. The approach of the needle may
aseptic technique or to the dissemination techniques may be offered to the patient be in-plane or out-of-plane, although the
of a systemic infection. when the PDPH is moderate to low latter approach minimizes the distance to
The risk of administering blood to cancer intensity. (5,15). be covered.
patients or patients with a viral infection is With the patient in a prone position or
still a concern. The recommendations in sitting down, a scan is performed with the
Greater occipital nerve block probe in the axial position, starting from
the literature focus on avoiding placing the
the occiput, where a hyperechoic line with
blood patch because of the risk of injecting
The greater occipital nerve block (GONB) acoustic shade is identified, corresponding
infected blood into the central nervous
is a superficial block that can be done to the occipital bone. Sliding the probe
system and only use it in severe cases that caudally, the posterior arch of the C1
under ultrasound guidance at the patient’s
respond poorly to conservative measures. bedside. It has been frequently used for vertebra is identified, and more caudally the
Finally, there has been some managing some specific types of chronic posterior arch of the C2 vertebra. (19) The
controversy around the advisability of headache, but some series of cases have medial aspect of the probe is fixed at this
advancing a spinal catheter through the been recently published showing its benefit point, rotating the lateral side in a cephalic
orifice created after an accidental dural in the management of PDPH. (15-17) direction (for a diagonal orientation), that
colombian journal of anesthesiology. 2021;49:e951. 5 /7
renders the image of a longitudinal axis of Figure 1. Probe placement for greater occipital nerve block.
the obliquus capitis inferior inserting into
the C1 and C2 (Figure 1).
The plane between the obliquus capitis
inferior muscle, which the one running
Tran
deeper in the image, and the immediately sduce
r rota
superficial, the splenium, is where the local tion
anesthetic is deposited. (19)
Another option could be localizing
the occipital artery which is 1-2 cm inferior
and lateral to the occipital protuberance
and administer the injection immediately
medial to the protuberance (18) (Figure 2).
The evidence of this block for treating
PDPH is still poor. One of the largest
case reports has 21 patients, describing
significantly improved pain scores in the
visual analogue scale (VAS) in patients
with initial assessment between 4 and 6.
For patients with a higher initial VAS score, A. Placing the probe at the level of the occipital bone and move downwards to the spinous
the block reduced the pain scores, but the process of C2. B. Cephalic lateral rotation.
symptoms tended to relapse. (16) source: Authors.
A. Starts at the level of the occipital bone indicated by a hyperechogenic line. B. The probe is directed caudally and the spinous process in
C1 is identified (nose-shaped). C. Moving on caudally, the spinous process in C2 is identified, with two prominences. D. The probe is rota-
ted laterally with slight medial orientation to identify the three muscle layers (from superficial to profound): trapezius (MT), semispinous
of the head and the obliquus capitis inferior muscle. The greater occipital nerve (NOM) is in the middle of the last two. E. Doppler color
mode localizing the greater occipital artery (horizontal arrow).
source: Authors.
6 /7 colombian journal of anesthesiology. 2021;49:e951.
The second regional technique that may be This is an easy block and requires There are no clinical controlled trials assessing
used as an option is the sphenopalatine nerve minimal training. With the patient in this block so far. The available evidence is
block. This ganglion contains parasympathetic supine decubitus and the neck slightly based on retrospective case series which have
and somatosensory fibers and is localized in extended, a long swab impregnated shown improvements in the VAS scores and
the pterygopalatine fossa, posterior to the with local anesthetic is inserted through a reduced number of patients requiring an
mid turbinate. (5,19) One of the approached is each of the nasal fossae, until hitting the
through the nose and the benefit of its block epidural blood patch. (20)
nasopharyngeal wall. (20) Some case
in case of PDPH is due to the vasoconstriction Based on the literature review conducted
reports have used 2 or 4 % lidocaine in
resulting from the parasympathetic block. to writhe this article, and based on the
gel or in liquid form, and other use 0.5 %
(20) Moreover, due to its relationship to the bupivacaine. (21) These swabs should be experience of the authors, they suggest the
fifth cranial nerve (trigeminal nerve), there left in place for at least 10-15 minutes. The following therapeutic algorithm (Figure 4).
may be a simultaneous relief of the frontal procedure may be repeated in order to This is just a suggestion and is not based on
headache. ensure an adequate block (Figure 3). a systematic review of the evidence.
Figura 4. Therapeutic algorithm suggested for the management of post-dural puncture headache.
Patient with postpartum headache and a history of duran
puncture (spinal or epidural anesthesia with dural tear)
Conservative measures for 24-48 hours: rest, Change in the Neurological signs, non- positional
characteristics of the headache, intense persistent
hydrocortisone headache headache
Persistance of pain
Mild to Intense or
moderate pain disabling pain
Discharge with
alarm signs Neuroing, specialized
neurological assessment
Yes There is a contraindication,
spehnopalatine angle the patient prefers other
option
No
Blood patch
Continue conservative measures:
rest, hydration, analgesia GONB: Greater occipital nerve block.
No improvment Consider
source: Authors.
colombian journal of anesthesiology. 2021;49:e951. 7 /7
8. Russell R, Laxton C, Lucas DN, Niewiarowski J, 18. Sola C, Dadure C, Choquet O, Capdevila X. New
None declared. Scrutton M, Stocks G. Treatment of obstetric York School of Regional Anesthesia NYSORA. [In-
post-dural puncture headache. Part 1: conser- ternet]. 2020. [citado: 2020 ago. 14]. Disponible
vative and pharmacological management. Int J en: https://www.nysora.com/techniques/head-
Obstet Anesth. 2019;38:93-103. doi: http://doi.or-
Financial support and sponsorship g/10.1016/10.1016/j.ijoa.2018.12.006
and-neck-blocks/nerve-blocks-face/
None declared. 10. Arévalo-Rodríguez I, Ciapponi A, Muñoz L, Ro- 20. Nair AS, Rayani BK. Sphenopalatine ganglion
qué i Figuls M, Bonfill Cosp X. Posture and fluids block for relieving postdural puncture hea-
for preventing post-dural puncture headache. dache: technique and mechanism of action
Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2013;(7):CD009199. of block with a narrative review of efficacy.
Appreciation doi: http://doi.org/10.1016/10.1002/14651858. Korean J Pain. 2017;30(2):93-7. doi: http://doi.
CD009199.pub2 org/10.1016/10.3344/kjp.2017.30.2.93
We express our gratitude to Dr. Antonio 11. Moore AR, Wieczorek PM, Carvalho JCA. Associa- 21. Cardoso JM, Sá M, Graça R, et al. Bloqueio do
Bonilla who participated in the design and tion between post-dural puncture headache after ganglio esfenopalatino para cefaleia pós‐punção
development of the therapeutic algorithm neuraxial anesthesia in childbirth and intracranial dural em contexto de ambulatório [Spheno-
subdural hematoma [published online ahead of palatine ganglion block for postdural punctu-
presented at the workshop “Crisis in regional
print, 2019 Sep 16]. JAMA Neurol. 2019;77(1):65- re headache in ambulatory setting]. Rev Bras
anesthesia”, as part of the XXXIII Colombian 72. doi: http://doi.org/10.1016/10.1001/jamaneu- Anestesiol. 2017;67(3):311-3. doi: http://doi.or-
Congress of Anesthesiology and Resuscitation. rol.2019.2995 g/10.1016/10.1016/j.bjan.2017.02.003